What really happened at the Battle of Thermopylae? Were there really just 300 Spartans against the whole Persian Empire? Why was this battle important? Join ancient warfare expert Dr Roel Konijnendijk from the University of Oxford, as he breaks down and reacts to the depiction of this iconic event in Assassin’s Creed Odyssey. From the Oracle at Delphi to King Leonidas' battle speech, how accurate is it? We’ll soon find out!
About Assassin's Creed - Echoes of History: Echoes of History is a Ubisoft series brought to you by History Hit. Listen to the full episodes here: https://lnkfi.re/1YFL0t
Hosted by: Dr Roel Konijnendijk Edited by: Merlin Roberts Produced by: Robin McConnell Executive Producers: Etienne Bouvier, Julien Fabre, Steve Lanham, Jen Bennett
Tell us your favourite Assassin's Creed game or podcast episode at [email protected]
00:00 - Introduction 01:03 - Leonidas & Dienekes 02:43 - Spartan hoplite weapons & armour 05:50 - Persian weapons & armour 06:50 - Ancient battle tactics 09:27 - Monomachia: heroic combat 11:42 - Battle insults! 14:20 - Spartan spear technique 15:30 - Leonidas talks too much 16:18 - Ancient war crimes? 18:37 - The Oracle of Delphi 22:08 - The Final Stand of the 300
#assassinscreed#history#sparta Roel Konijndijk examines the historical accuracy of equipment, combat techniques, and characters in the battle of Thermopylae sequence from
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Historian Roelke Neuendijk evaluates the historical accuracy of *Assassin's Creed Odyssey*, focusing on the Battle of Thermopylae. While the game's visuals are praised, it frequently sacrifices historical authenticity—particularly regarding weaponry, armor, and social customs—in favor of cinematic action and modern tropes.
Now we see him killing a prisoner.
You're not supposed to do that if he is a suppliant.
Like, if he comes to you because he has surrendered
and is begging for mercy,
it's very bad form to kill people.
I like the idea of Thermopylae as a tutorial campaign,
which is very much what it was for the Spartans.
But yeah, so...
And they lost, they had to reload it.
So welcome to Echoes of History.
My name is Roelke Neuendijk.
I'm an ancient historian
at Lincoln College, University of Oxford.
I specialize in classical Greek warfare and Spartan history,
and I'm here today to take you through the story,
the historical context, and the combat styles
that you find in Assassin's Creed Odyssey.
I haven't played this game myself, I have to admit,
but I'm very keen to see these clips
and to look at the way that this has been reflected
in this game.
If you enjoyed this video and would like to see more,
don't forget to like and subscribe.
We are ready, my king.
Tell me, Venacus,
have you ever gone fishing with your son?
No, never.
A soldier's life is all I've had the honor to know.
I would have liked to have gone fishing with my son.
So the setting here is the Battle of Thermopylae,
where Leonidas, the Spartan king,
is preparing to fight the Persians.
They've introduced these two characters here,
Leonidas the king, and then Deannachis,
who is another Spartan, who's famous for being the one
who said the famous line about fighting in the shade.
So they've sort of elevated him to an officer of some kind.
Historically, we don't know anything about this character
except that he said that line.
I see that they want to make Leonidas
into this nice sort of fatherly figure, almost,
with his son Pleistarchus.
Like, he regrets that he doesn't get to go fishing.
But, I mean, if you want to think of things
that a Spartan father would have liked to do with his son,
there are some real Spartan things
that you might have used here.
You might have said, I would have liked to go hunting
with my son, hunt for hares, teach him to ride,
see him dance for Apollo at the Gymnopedia.
These are the kind of things that a Spartan father
might wish for his son and might aspire to.
So these would be real Spartan things that Spartans might do,
whereas fishing, totally unattested.
This feels very modern to me.
Spartans, every breath that you have taken
has led you to this moment.
Every drop of blood, sweat, and tear,
all of it has led to where you stand.
The spears and helmets actually look pretty good.
It's just that the spears have a lot of parts
attached to them.
I think they thought that a normal wooden shaft
would look a bit boring,
so they added all sorts of bulbs and metal bits to them.
Forget those.
But otherwise, there are some parts
that are clearly very carefully modeled
on actual Greek material culture.
It just leads to a sort of strange mix
where some of these pieces of kit look a bit too early
and some look a bit too late.
So for instance, the Corinthian helmets that they're wearing
that enclose the face,
they were going out of style by this point,
so they would no longer have been very common.
Helmets are starting to become lighter, more open-faced.
At the same time, they're wearing these muscle cuirasses,
which sort of very carefully sculpt the muscles
and the outline of the torso,
which emerge slightly later.
So we're not quite sure if those would have already been
used during the Persian Wars.
Obviously, both of those things are very Greek,
but they're kind of trying to piece together the nicest bits
and then use them as a whole.
Some of the other parts,
the bracelets that they're wearing on their lower arms,
those are not real.
At best, there were some examples of that
from an earlier period in Greek history,
but by this time, they would no longer have been used.
So that's just because it's just a standard part
of the way that we envision ancient kits.
It's very hard to imagine ancient warriors
without some kind of bracelets or fan braces
on their forearms, but that's not historical.
That's not something that they would have actually used.
When you get this super close-up of the shields,
you can see that they're not quite right.
And this is kind of interesting.
Obviously, this game is obviously rendered
at really high level of texture quality and resolution.
And so you can see all of the details.
And unfortunately, that means you can also see
some of the things that they've done
that may not be quite so authentic.
So you have shields that seem very much based on the model
that's provided by 300, again, that are full metal,
very thick, very large, essentially, you know,
sort of kettles.
There would have been a lot of variation between them,
but they are creating this picture
of a uniform Spartan army, which is equipped, you know,
the equipment is a lot more historical
than, for instance, 300,
but it still draws on that for inspiration,
which is unfortunate because it's unnecessary.
In this case, they might have put in
some actual Greek shields.
Of course, the Spartans in this scene
all have the lambda shield.
So they have a big letter L for Lacedaemon,
the polis of Sparta, which is attested for a later period
that the Spartans would have that on their shields.
By the time of the Persian Wars,
we don't know if they already did.
And we also have some other evidence
that Spartans did still have individual blazons
on their shields, that they could still choose
things to put on their shields,
basically based on their own tastes.
So again, with the Persians,
you actually have a bit more historical equipment
than you see in a movie like 300,
but there are some parts of these outfits
that look a lot more based on actual examples,
depictions of Persian warriors
and descriptions that we find in Greek sources.
So they're wearing these fish scale cuirasses,
chest armor that's made out of overlapping scales of metal.
They're wearing these nice trousers,
which the Greeks are always fascinated by.
Barbarians like the Persians, they wear trousers.
That sets them apart from Greeks
who obviously being civilized, don't wear trousers.
And they have these frigid caps on their heads.
So that's fairly typical sort of Greek style dress.
But then the warriors have equipment
that the weapons in particular,
that doesn't suit them at all.
So many of these guys seem to be fighting
with curved swords, which is very strange.
The Persians in this period wear straight swords,
but they fight mainly with spears and with bows and arrows.
So they should have been fighting with spears.
They shouldn't have been carrying these curved swords.
And they definitely, at least in this kind of close combat,
in this direct confrontation,
they should have been carrying these tower shields,
which the Persian infantry was famous for using.
So they would form a shield wall out of tower shields,
which they would set down,
and they would try and fight from that sort of bastion,
from that battle line, using arrows and spears.
And when that shield wall broke down,
was torn down by assaults from the Greeks, for instance,
that's when, only that's when they would actually
switch over to using hand-to-hand weapons.
So this kind of depiction,
this exists both in Hollywood and in this game.
It's not realistic, but it is a way to depict battle
that allows for the greatest influence
given to these individual heroes.
And of course, when you're designing a game
around the player's agency, that's exactly what you want.
Also, one of the first things that Leonidas does
is throw away his shield.
He literally throws it at a guy to take him out,
and then he just fights on without his shield.
For these Greek warriors,
these heavily armed infantry called hoplites,
the shield is absolutely the main part of their equipment.
The spear may break, but their shield is always with them.
Once they throw away their shield, they've become useless.
The only people who would actually do that
would be people running away from combat
and trying to lighten their equipment
so that they might run faster.
If you're throwing away your shield,
you're doing that to save your life.
You're never, ever doing that to continue fighting.
So you need to be seeing a lot more shields
and shield combat.
People trying to deflect blows
or guard themselves against blows using those heavy shields
because that's what they're for.
That is your main protection
in this kind of chaotic and dangerous environment.
So really, the fact that everybody
just seems to think of their shield as optional
is perhaps the least historical thing
that you're seeing here.
And again, these Persians,
I mean, again, for obvious game reasons,
they have different kinds of weapons.
Some of them seem to be carrying giant maces.
Later on, we're gonna see a hero
who seems to have a giant axe or something like a polearm.
These were not actual weapons in this period.
They didn't exist.
The Persians primarily were armed,
as I said, with short spears.
Those were similar to the Greek ones.
They had a point on one side,
a counterweight on the other for balance.
And their sidearms were short swords and short axes.
They had knives as well,
which are very typical for the Persians.
The Achaemenids are always depicted
with these knives stuck in their belts,
and that's like a ceremonial as well as a status symbol.
So these kind of large polearms,
curved swords, axes, maces,
you wouldn't see these on a battlefield in this period.
The idea that there's champion combat
in the middle of this battle,
while it seemed unrealistic to us,
the Persian Wars are actually the last war
in which we hear about moments
in which this kind of thing, monomachia,
this dueling between champions,
does occasionally seem to happen,
or things seem to happen in the narrative
that our sources want to portray
as essentially duels between champions.
This was much more of a feature of earlier warfare
in the Archaic period among the Greeks.
In this period, you still sometimes have people
who will stand out before the lines
and will challenge individual enemies to a fight.
And so the idea that this is something
that could happen in the middle of a battle
is not entirely alien to the Greeks.
And they would have liked to hear these stories, right?
They would have liked to hear about individual warriors
who might overcome enemies in single combat
to prove their prowess.
The only thing is that Leonidas in this scene
has already racked up such a body count
it's completely ridiculous.
What you would actually see, for instance,
the story we hear in the Persian Wars
is of an Athenian hero called Sophanes
who killed three men in individual duels.
I mean, that's the kind of level that we're talking about.
That makes him a hero.
That makes him worthy of record, right?
The actual body counts of these battles
would be much lower than we would expect.
And certainly individual warriors would hardly kill anyone
with the exception of some noted figures
who might kill more than one.
This is kind of something exceptional.
We know that several brothers of Xerxes,
brothers of the king, were involved in this battle
and actually died in the fighting at Thermopylae.
So any of those might have been a useful name
for one of the champions faced by Leonidas in this case.
That would have been a nice sort of nod to history.
The axe head is actually inspired
by some really nice axes from Luristan,
from essentially the regions of the sort of mountainous
north of the Middle East,
which have this very distinct style, this distinct shape.
So you see that in a couple of bronze finds
from the area from Urartu and places like that.
They seem to have inflated the size of it
so that it can become a polearm,
but you can see that they took some inspiration
from real history.
I will bring Xerxes your head, you insolent Spartan fool!
Come and get it!
He said that thing!
Obviously, this is the famous line from Leonidas,
come and get them.
It first appears in the sources in Diodorus.
So this is first century BC,
more than 400 years after it supposedly happened.
The earlier sources don't report this,
so it's very dubious whether it actually happened or not.
But it's such a famous line,
Molo and Labe, come and get them.
You know, this contemptuous line to Xerxes
when he demanded that the Spartans deliver up their weapon.
Unfortunately, for all the various forms
that this line takes in modern pop culture,
according to the source,
it was in a letter that he wrote to Xerxes
when Xerxes wrote him a letter to demand for the weapons.
So this is not actually a line
that he would have shouted at him
in this sort of brave contemptuous gesture.
It actually was sort of an exchange
of formalities between the two.
But, you know, of course they had to give a reference to it.
So it's a feature of these Greek shields,
these big round shields,
that they would have a blazon on the outside,
which was entirely up to the individual to choose.
So they could have any kind of figurative thing
that they wanted,
anything that they thought would be representative of them,
or their family,
or that might scare the enemy,
or bring them good luck.
They could put anything on those shields.
And we know of hundreds of different designs
from vase paintings,
from bronze applique remains
that would have been attached to the shield,
and also from descriptions in the sources.
So a number of different shield blazons are known,
and it's always kind of funny
to see what they do with that in these games.
So we're not actually sure
if all the Spartans would have used the Lambda shields,
but it's become so strongly associated with them
that, of course, in this scene, they all have it.
Other Greeks could have had any design they wanted.
And so I'm trying to see what this Persian warrior,
who has a very Greek-looking shield,
what they put on his shield,
but I can't quite tell in the darkness.
It seems to be a bull's head, maybe.
Animal features are very common.
Maybe it's a minotaur's head.
These mythological references are very common, too.
Gorgonea are very common,
so the gorgon's face, which is meant to ward off evil.
These are the kind of things that you see a lot.
But some of the most common ones
are pictures that we might think a little bit boring,
like tripods, which are a reference to Apollo,
or the back half of a horse or an animal,
something that may be a reference to speed
or to high prestige of owning these animals.
There are all sorts of designs that are known,
some of which do still look very intimidating,
and others are a little bit puzzling.
One really weird thing is the way
that Leonidas uses his spear.
He seems to constantly hold it under his arm and behind him,
and then kind of brings it forward in an underarm thrust.
As far as we can tell from vases,
and obviously this is also reinforced
by experimental archeology,
so reenactments and people's attempts
to try and make this work,
you know, to try and see what works best
when you try to use replica versions of this equipment,
what we see is that mostly these hoplites
would use their spear overarm,
and the art of using it is really not very sophisticated.
You're essentially just sort of prodding like that.
You're throwing the spear without letting it go.
It's a very simple move, it's quite precise,
and it gives you quite a lot of reach
because the spear is very well balanced towards the rear,
so you have quite a lot of projection in front of you.
So using the spear like that,
you can get fairly accurate thrusts with minimal effort,
and you can keep it up for a long time
because of the balancing,
so there's not a lot of weight pushing you down.
And so what you'd like to see in these combat scenes
is somebody like Leonidas holding his shield up
in front of him, obviously to cover him,
and then just sort of prodding over it like that.
That would be the way to show how the ancient,
how Greek hoplites would have actually fought.
Not so tough without your army to protect you!
Then why are you bleeding so much?
No match for a Spartan!
He talks a lot for a Spartan.
It's a specific thing about Spartans
that they're supposed to have
this very particular way of speaking,
which is very, I mean, it's literally where English
derives the word laconic from.
So this is the idea that you're very short
and to the point and quite witty,
that you say as little as possible
and still get your point across.
And that is something that we're told
is actually part of the Spartan upbringing.
They have to learn to speak like that,
and they get corrected if they use too many words.
They get mocked or humiliated,
or they actually get told that what they're saying
is not pithy enough.
Of course, it's difficult to write like that,
but it would be expected of a Spartan.
We are betrayed by King Xerxes,
nose of the bath behind the mountain.
They're coming.
By dawn, you are completely surrounded.
We are Spartans.
When are we not?
Spartans will mean nothing
when Xerxes wipes your bloodline from the face of the earth.
Now we see him killing a prisoner.
You're not supposed to do that.
If he is a suppliant, like if he comes to you
because he has surrendered and is begging for mercy,
it's very bad for him to kill people.
Obviously, it does happen in Greek warfare.
Killing prisoners is much more common
than killing messengers.
But it's not something you're supposed to do.
If somebody comes to you
and essentially begs you for mercy,
the idea is that you should either spare them
or ransom them if you can.
Obviously, this is not something
that's universally followed.
So we're not necessarily sort of trying to censure
Leonidas for war crimes in this case.
There is no such thing in the Greek mind.
But more commonly, if you capture someone in war,
I mean, you would try to ransom them
or alternatively sell them into slavery.
It's really not very common that they would just say,
okay, well, you are a prisoner giving me information.
I'm just going to.
Today was a day the Persians will never forget.
Tomorrow is a day the world will remember.
It's also very funny to hear him say
that this is a day that the Persians will never forget.
To note that there is not a single Persian source
known to us at all.
That refers to any of these events,
including the entire Persian Wars, in fact.
I mean, there's no trace of a Persian memory
of the Persian Wars.
So the idea that the Persians would never forget this day,
I mean, it's quite possible that they told stories about it.
We don't know.
But certainly as far as historians are concerned,
it seems as though they did their best to either forget
or pretend it never happened.
So it becomes a very funny line in that context.
All of this talk of the Pythia,
the Pythia, I do not care what she says.
Enough!
We have grown tired of your insolent tongue.
Sparta will not go.
The Spartans were known for their piety, right?
They really cared about making sure
the gods were on their side.
And this is one of the things that made them stand out
from other Greeks, according to Greek observers.
One of the things they notably did
is before every time they went to war,
they would seek the advice of the Pythia,
specifically the Oracle Adelphi.
So they would go out of their way
to travel out of the Peloponnese to the sanctuary
to ask the Oracle, to ask essentially Apollo,
if they were doing the right thing by committing to war.
And we have a few occasions when we know
sort of the response that they got.
So for instance, for the Peloponnesian War,
we know they invoked or they sought the advice
of the Oracle and the Oracle said
that Apollo would fight on their side.
So they actually got permission essentially.
They cared about this a lot.
So the idea that he just says,
oh, whatever the Pythia says,
I'm just gonna do what I want.
That sounds like the exact opposite
of what a Spartan would say.
And in fact, we know that for the Persian Wars as well,
they consulted the Oracle about whether
that was the right thing to do to resist the Persians.
And what the Oracle told them is that supposedly
that either Sparta would be destroyed
or one of their kings would die.
And this is why supposedly they fought to the death
at Thermopylae is because they knew
that as long as one of their kings died,
Sparta might be saved.
The days of heroes are over.
You think your blood makes you special?
If we opened your veins, it would spill to the ground
and disappear through the cracks.
You are no one.
It's noteworthy here, the bloodline of Leonidas
is very important to the Spartans.
They claim that both of their royal houses
descended from Heracles.
So they had divine heritage.
They invoked this time and again
in order to confirm both the right of these kings to rule
and also their martial prowess and everything else.
It was very important for the Spartans
that this bloodline went right back to the gods.
So for this priest to say like, oh, you're no one,
your blood's just like any other blood,
it's a strong statement.
It rejects a lot of Spartan propaganda about who they are.
It would need to be addressed directly by Leonidas,
I would think.
This prompts a response from him saying,
I think you might wanna take that up
with my great-grandfather Heracles.
He might have other views on the matter.
You are more than welcome to find out.
Your fate is sealed.
Also, it's noted in the ancient sources,
for obvious reasons, that the Pythia was a crone.
She was an old lady chosen
from among the citizens of Delphi, the Polis.
For the exact reason that what we see in pop culture
of these oracles in 300 and also in this,
if you make them beautiful young women,
there is this implication
that the priests have something sinister going on,
that they essentially drug young women
in order to abuse them.
But the Greeks themselves were already aware
of this potential vulnerability,
this potential exploitation of these priestesses
who were supposed to remain sort of pure
and in very high status.
And so what they did instead was ensure
that that wouldn't happen
by giving the position to older women.
So this is specifically sort of,
it goes against what we know about the Pythia.
Xerxes wants Sparta.
You have to go through me.
So the final stand of the 300,
we get told by Herodotus,
and there are a couple of other sources
that try to describe it.
How much we should trust that description
is obviously difficult to know
because famously everybody died.
So we don't know who is telling this story,
who is giving them the details.
But what Herodotus tells us is that
during this fight,
because they knew they were going to die,
because they knew everything was lost,
they marched out of the gorge
and fought in the open, essentially.
So out of the pass,
and they fought the Persians in the open,
which is why it all went pear-shaped.
So in that fight fairly early on,
Leonidas himself was killed,
but the Greeks that remained fought on,
recovered his body against multiple attacks
by the Persians,
withdrew to a hill,
and on that hill,
once they were finally surrounded,
they were shot down to a man.
So this is kind of the story that we get.
Again, we're not really sure
how much we should trust that.
What we do hear from that,
that seems to be reflected here a little bit,
and that is quite nice to see,
is that Herodotus expresses just how desperate
that fight was.
It was really a fight to the end,
which meant that first all the spears broke
and they went on with swords,
and eventually their swords were bent
and chipped and broken,
and so they fought on with their fists
and with their teeth.
The desperation of the Spartans
and the valor in the end,
when they had no weapons left,
but still they kept on fighting,
that is something that Herodotus
really emphasizes to amplify the glory of the Spartans.
And the scene kind of tries to bring that out,
that these men fought to the absolute last.
Of course, alongside them,
there were also the Thespians,
and according to a very late source,
the Mycenaeans,
who sent a very small detachment to Thermopylae,
they also stood with them and fought to the last man.
I like the idea of Thermopylae as a tutorial campaign,
which is very much what it was for the Spartans.
But yeah, so,
and they lost, they had to reload it.
Thanks very much for joining me
as I made my way through Assassin's Creed Odyssey.
If you like this kind of content,
like and subscribe,
you can find more of it here on this channel.