4 Costly Mistakes to Avoid When Talking to an Insurance Adjuster

Auto Insurance
2 followers
Sep 8, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedTexas personal injury lawyer Shane McGuire advises against speaking directly with insurance adjusters after a car accident. He explains that adjusters are trained to minimize payouts and may use a victim's polite or uncertain responses against them. He strongly recommends hiring a competent lawyer to handle all communications to ensure maximum compensation.
Hey, this is Shane McGuire, personal injury lawyer here in Texas, and today I'm going
to give you four things to not say to an insurance adjuster when they call you after a wreck.
Now, to preface it, you shouldn't say anything to these insurance adjusters after a wreck
because you shouldn't be talking to the insurance adjuster after the wreck.
You should call me or you should call a competent, good personal injury lawyer to help you work
through the wreck and get you the compensation you deserve.
But if you're bullheaded, like a lot of people are, and you're like, I'm going to do this
myself, I'm going to give you four things to not say to the insurance adjuster.
Thing one, I don't really know how the wreck happened.
I didn't see her.
I didn't see the car coming, whatever.
They are looking for any reason not to pay you.
And I have to tell you, very often, the person who causes the wreck, at the scene of the
wreck, apologetic, they're very kind, they hate that this happened, and they're taking
responsibility for it.
And then, when their insurance agent calls, and they're like, man, your rates are going
to go up, you know, you're causing wrecks out there, I hate that your premium's going
to be higher, all of a sudden, responsibility and altruism and love for your fellow man
goes out the window in exchange for the protection of your own pocketbook.
And so that guy who apologized to you at the scene has now called his insurance company
and said, I didn't do it, not my fault, must have been the other guy, there was an emergency,
you see what had happened was, he's making stuff up.
And so when the insurance adjuster calls you, and you, because you're a nice person, you
don't want to guilt deliver, and you're like, yeah, I didn't really see, came out of nowhere,
and you say something like, I didn't see him until the wreck happened, I didn't see exactly
what occurred, they just came out of nowhere, I'm not exactly sure, you are giving that
insurance adjuster cover to just rely on what their insured said.
Now, in the end, do we still get you paid?
Yeah, we could probably still get you paid, but man, you have made it so much trouble
on yourself, it means you're probably gonna have to file a lawsuit, means you're probably
gonna have to give a deposition, all because at the very beginning, you talk to the insurance
adjuster, when you shouldn't have done so, never forget, they are trained on how to ask
you questions to minimize what they pay, and you're not trained on how to answer those
questions to maximize what you're paying.
Okay, number two, the second thing you don't need to tell an insurance adjuster if you're
foolish enough to talk to them is, I'm fine.
How many times in your life do you think you said the phrase, I'm fine?
You know, you go to church on Sunday morning, somebody says, how you doing?
It may be a laugh or the pits of hell, but I'm fine.
You could have just gotten a horrible diagnosis, so you just say, I'm fine.
Everybody just says, I'm fine.
All the time, your wife just left you, I'm fine, I'm fine.
Everybody says it, and why do you say it?
You say it because you're polite, and you say it because you don't want to be like this,
woe is me, you know, object of pity or whatever, and you're a nice person, and so the insurance
adjuster calls, and they are not calling to be your friend.
Do you think they get bonuses based on relationship development?
They get bonuses based on how many claims they close for de minimis amounts of money.
That's what they're looking to do.
They're looking to close a claim for cheap, and you answer the phone, and you talk to
that adjuster, how are you doing?
That's it.
Why are you telling this person you're fine?
You're going to be asking this person for money, and you're like, I'm fine.
No, that's a bad move.
Don't tell them you're fine.
Describe the injuries that you have.
But again, you shouldn't be the one talking to them anyway.
You should have me talk to them for you.
Now, the third thing that you can't tell the insurance adjuster, just don't do it.
If you're going to talk to them, don't do it, and this is like kind of the bank shot
off of I'm fine.
This is, it goes along with that I don't want to seem like I'm too much.
Do you ever have that relative who has what I call chronic chronicness?
Chronic chronicness is, I mean, if you have it, you know what it is.
Like, I've got something wrong.
You wouldn't believe what just happened.
Little Johnny did this at school today, a boy's teacher was mad at him, and I can't
get over this cold, and my boss is da da da.
Some people have chronic chronicness, and you don't want to be that person.
To guard against being that person, if you're like me and you've got that relative, I mean,
they know who they are.
If you're watching, you know who you are.
If you've got that chronic chronicness relative, then you especially guard against it, and
that insurance adjuster might call you and say, what do you want?
And you might say something dumb like, I just want my medical bills covered.
You're saying it to be nice.
You're saying it because you're not greedy.
What you don't know is the insurance company will leap at that chance and say, yeah, we'll
cover your reasonable medical bills up to a certain amount of money, and then if you
agree to it, which you can do just over the phone, you can do oral contracts in Texas.
If you agree to that, that insurance company's then going to see your bill, like if you went
to the chiropractor, you went to an urgent care facility or whatever, and they start
picking that bill and saying, oh, we said we would pay for reasonable pricing for treatment.
We think this is too high.
We'll pay 60% of this bill.
You know, Medicare would only pay 20%, but we'll pay 60% of this bill.
Meanwhile, you ain't got Medicare.
They treated you, and they're waiting to get paid from the F.O.L.
driver's insurance company, and this insurance company who did this ruse of settling with
you for your medical bills because you said, hey, all I want is my medical covered, and
they said fine for reasonable amounts.
And that little word reasonable, the letter they sent you, is doing a whole lot of work
in the deal, work that you don't even know is going on, like a little poison pill they
stick in there.
And then all of a sudden, you're just dealing with an insurance company having one version
of reasonable and your health care provider having another version of reasonable.
And now you, because you were being nice, you are stuck in the middle of a business
model between two groups of people that you don't want to be stuck between, the E.R.
and the auto insurance carrier.
You don't want to be in the middle of that.
Call me.
Call a personal injury lawyer.
Don't say dumb stuff like this to the insurance company.
Don't say I just want my medical bills covered because you don't know what it is the insurance
company is agreeing to on the backside of that.
The fourth thing you can't say to an insurance adjuster.
You're going to think that nobody would say this, and I'm telling you people say it.
I've had this case.
You know, I'd just gotten over the wreck I had a few months ago.
Once you tell that insurance company that you had a prior wreck or you fell off a horse
or you had a fall a few months, whatever it is, they will lock in on that.
The call is recorded.
They log it in their claim notes.
They're going to say, you know, we think that of the eight weeks of physical therapy you
had after this wreck, I bet you two, two and a half of that, probably because of that fall
you had four months ago, you told us about it.
That other wreck you had six months ago that you told us about.
Now, really what you were doing on the phone is you were just having, you were just having
some camaraderie with the adjuster and kind of just commiserating with them and saying,
man, and what you were trying to say is you were fine before the wreck.
What they hear though is, oh, this person had another incident that occurred and we
get to blame that incident.
I'm going to go back to family.
Do you have the person in your family that always blames somebody else for their problems?
That's the insurance company.
They are looking for an opportunity to blame somebody else for the harm caused by their
insurance.
So don't say those four things to the insurance company when they call.
Don't say anything to the insurance company when they call.
Call us.
Call Meguiar Firm.
And for more advice on how to maximize the value of your car wreck claim, follow us at
Meguiar Firm.
