On August 26, a massive mudslide and flash flood struck near the border between Tibet, China, and Nepal. On both sides of the Gyirong Port, buildings including the joint inspection facility, commercial warehouses, and nearby villages were almost completely destroyed. Later aerial footage showed the five-story port building, nearly 66 feet tall, collapsing within seconds and leaving only a pit-like foundation. Steel reinforcement bars were all bent in the same direction. If reinforced concrete structures could disappear in an instant, the fate of human lives can only be imagined.
Nepalese rescuers pulled Chinese national worker Liu Haitao out of the rubble
after he had been trapped inside a tunnel for 11 days.
He was one of the few survivors among more than 900 workers trapped inside the tunnels.
However, the story never became a trending topic on Chinese social media
despite making headlines around the world.
The Nepalese military said that at around 1pm on September 5,
Rescuers entered the Trishuli 1 tunnel and about 738 feet inside,
their flashlight spotted a curled up figure.
Liu Haitao, aged 49, is from Anyang, Henan province.
After being trapped for 11 days without food or water,
he was visibly thinner when he was rescued.
Liu recalled that while waiting for rescue,
he saw lights from search teams in the distance several times and kept shouting for help.
But because of the distance, rescuers apparently did not hear him
and he eventually lost hope.
It was not until rescuers approached him on September 5
and the light shone directly on him that he still struggled to believe that he'd actually been found.
Liu has now been airlifted to the Nepal Army's Central Hospital in Kathmandu for treatment.
One thing many people online agreed on was that he was lucky he was trapped inside Nepal.
After confirming that her brother had been rescued,
Liu Haitao's older sister said she was extremely excited.
The siblings worked as farmers in their hometown
and only went to construction sites for temporary work during the farming off-season,
earning just enough to cover basic living expenses.
His wife had health problems and cannot do heavy labor,
so the family has been struggling financially.
Earlier this year, Liu went to Nepal with another villager to take temporary work,
and that was when the disaster happened.
Fortunately, he was rescued safely.
The disaster destroyed an entire village near the Nepal-Tibet border
and severely damaged 12 hydropower plants along the Trishuli River basin.
The Nepalese government estimated that about 900 workers
were trapped inside tunnels at multiple hydropower projects.
Over the years, many roads, bridges, tunnels and hydropower plants built in Nepal
have involved Chinese funding, Chinese companies and Chinese workers.
Casualties and economic losses caused by this disaster are likely to be significant,
but the Chinese side has remained largely silent about the full extent of the damage.
According to a statement released by Nepal Water and Energy Development Company,
the developer of the Trishuli-1 hydropower project,
385 workers from the main civil engineering contractor Power China remains missing.
They include Chinese technicians, engineers and management staff,
as well as many locally hired construction workers, drivers and temporary laborers in Nepal.
Ten days after the disaster, Nepal mobilized rescue efforts
and continued releasing updates on the operation.
More than 12,000 people have been rescued, including Chinese workers pulled out from tunnels.
Meanwhile, on the Chinese side,
the Chinese Communist Party has mobilized nationwide efforts to suppress information
while detaining Tibetans and preventing discussion on the landslide.
On September 5, a video uploaded by a user showed Chinese Communist Party police in Tibet
detaining a Tibetan man wearing traditional clothing.
Police ordered bystanders not to record the scene.
The person filming said,
I'm not the one breaking the law.
Police officer angrily shouted,
Don't film, don't film.
The officer then attempted to seize the phone and the video was cut off.
After the disaster, Tibetan internet police and public security authorities quickly intervened.
By the end of August, at least 12 people in Tibet's Shan'an region
and other areas had received administrative punishments
or educational punishments for discussing the disaster.
What exactly did they do that was considered illegal?
Some people posted,
More than 3,000 people have already died on the Chinese side.
Another person wrote,
Thousands of people at the Girong Port in Shigaze lost their lives in an instant.
Another said,
Today, the mudslide buried more than 1,000 people.
On August 26, a massive mudslide and flash flood struck near the border between Tibet,
China and Nepal.
On both sides of the Girong Port,
buildings inside the joint inspection facility,
commercial warehouses and nearby villages were almost completely destroyed.
Later aerial footage showed the five-story port building,
nearly 66 feet tall,
collapsing within seconds and leaving only a pit-like foundation.
Steel reinforcement bars were all bent in the same direction.
It can only imagine what happened to human lives.
How many people were buried at Girong?
How many were injured?
How much property was lost?
And how badly Chinese companies were affected
remained difficult for the public to learn.
Recently, investigative journalist Wu Zhucheng wrote on X
that Girong Port had a permanent population of over 3,000 people,
with temporary residents making up about one-third of the total.
At the time, hundreds of vehicles lined up waiting for inspections and border clearance.
Their drivers and passengers likely had little chance of escaping.
Even more alarming, he said,
dozens of miles of roads along the route run besides rivers,
leaving vehicles on those roads with little chance of escape.
Wu Zhucheng said previous reports indicated
that seasonal visitors and temporary residents
had at one point reached three times the size of the permanent population.
Reports said that Girong Port normally hosted large numbers of cross-border traders,
logistics and warehouse workers,
construction personnel involved in China-Nepal railway and hydropower projects,
as well as thousands of foreign tourists and pilgrims traveling each year to Mount Kailash.
The surveillance footage showing Girong Port
being hit head-on by the mudslide was seen around the world.
Inside China, however, it was almost impossible to find.
What is the Chinese Communist Party trying to hide?
Wu Zhucheng pointed out that the Girong Port disaster was
30 percent a natural disaster and 70 percent a man-made one.
He said the government must take responsibility in these three areas.
First, was the warning issued in time?
Were four minutes enough for people to evacuate?
Second, was the evacuation effective?
In the face of heavy rain, flash floods and mudslides,
were there any advanced plans to organize evacuations?
Third, did man-made barriers around the port
and road designs block possible escape paths?
Warning systems, evacuation plants and emergency facilities are all human responsibilities.
Meanwhile, overseas Tibetan rights groups confirmed
that information from the border area on the Tibetan side
remains under strict government control.
Foreign media have so far been unable
to enter the disaster zone for independent reporting.
The Foreign Correspondence Club of China, FCCC,
confirmed in a statement on September 4
that more than 10 foreign journalists had applied to the Chinese government
for permission to report in Tibet, but all requests were rejected.
BBC China correspondent Lauren Bicker said the CCP
had imposed extremely tight control over information about the Nepal flood disaster,
with the order coming from Xi Jinping himself.
According to data from Nepal's National Disaster Management Authority,
as of 12pm local time on September 5,
the mudslide had killed 1,344 people in Nepal, with about 5,000 still missing.
In comparison, according to Xinhua News Agency,
as of 6pm on September 4,
the Girong mudslide in Tibet had caused 31 deaths and left 531 people missing.
There was almost no public list of missing people,
and no open access to footage from the scene.
Eleven days after the disaster, no survivors had been found on the Chinese side.
A public WeChat account called DocYouth
published an article by an author using the name Bian Cheng.
The article featured surveillance footage of the mudslide crashing into Girong Port.
Within hours, both the article and video disappeared.
China Digital Times, which tracks online censorship in China,
found that the footage had been systematically blocked on WeChat
and could not even be sent through private one-on-one chats.
One user posted a video publicly questioning,
why have domestic Chinese media not reported the mudslide disaster?
However, an informed source said that after the video was posted,
the man was criminally detained by police on charges of picking corals and provoking trouble.
I have been following the Girong Port mudslide disaster these past few days.
I believe most Chinese people have also been deeply concerned about what happened.
After so many days of efforts by rescue teams,
we still haven't heard any particularly good news.
But there is one thing I cannot understand, and I have to make this video to ask.
After all these days, where have China's mainstream media gone?
The mainstream media in China have mainly been reporting two things every day.
The first is that they keep releasing videos of the flash floods in Nepal,
both before and during the disaster.
Some of these videos came from local surveillance cameras,
while others were filmed by local residents on their phones.
But these same mainstream media outlets have never released any videos
or surveillance footage from our side showing what happened when the mudslide struck here.
According to normal logic, if you can obtain videos from overseas,
why can't you get videos from inside China?
You have been extensively reporting on the devastating scenes when the mudslide happened
abroad. But as Chinese people, we are obviously more concerned about our own people.
What exactly happened when the mudslide hit?
Nepal has videos and surveillance footage and reports say more than 1,000 people died there.
So what exactly is the basis for the casualty numbers on our side?
Why am I posting this video today?
Because yesterday I came across a video showing the normal daily operations at Jirong Port.
It showed a very large number of people moving through the area.
That is why I became extremely worried about what the situation at Jirong Port
was like when the mudslide struck.
After the disaster, an official media directive circulated online,
allegedly instructing media outlets to follow a unified reporting line.
The document said media could only repost official central government reports
and had to begin coverage by emphasizing a mudslide occurred on the Nepal side,
highlighting casualties in Nepal while downplaying the disaster inside China.
Because communications remain disrupted in parts of the disaster area in Tibet,
outside observers have suggested that the actual number of casualties and
missing people on the Chinese side may be far higher than the official figures suggest.
In response, the CCP's state-run media outlet Tibet Daily quoted rescue experts
as saying that this was not an ordinary mudslide,
but a disaster chain involving an ice collapse, debris flow, and mudslide.
They said the flow speed may have reached 164 feet per second,
with debris averaging about 13 feet deep and reaching a maximum depth of 52 feet.
Life detection equipment could effectively search only to a depth of less than 7 feet.
Experts described the rescue operation as searching for a needle in mud.
This explanation has also drawn questions from outside observers.
If authorities acknowledged that the disaster had such extreme destructive power and deadly speed,
why were downstream areas not warned in time before the disaster struck?
Meanwhile, Nepal's side was hit by the same type of ice collapse and mudslide disaster,
yet rescuers there continued finding and saving more than 10,000 survivors.
More controversially, families of several missing Chinese workers told the Epoch Times
that they traveled from places including Lhasa and Sichuan to the disaster area,
but were told that Girong County had been sealed off and they could not enter the port area.
Some families said they waited near checkpoints but were not able to get
clear information about whether their relatives were alive or dead.
The disaster in Nepal has completely exposed the true nature of the Communist Party.
In every disaster where information is covered up,
what is revealed is the system's disregard for human life.
One commenter said with deep sorrow that beneath the ruins were not only fellow citizens,
but also a conscience of a system that had already died.
It is easy to imagine how much pain the families of the thousands missing in China must be suffering.
Yet in hidden corners of the internet, a heartbreaking accusation has emerged,
one that many say is more chilling than the disaster itself.
The wife of a missing police officer posted online,
My husband, there hasn't been a single word from you.
Our three children are waiting for you to come home.
The government said they will take full responsibility.
The compensation is only 2,000 yuan a month.
Back then, I paid 2 million yuan just to get you into the system,
and they promised a total income of 500,000 yuan a year.
You had only been in the job for one year, and the money to buy the position was borrowed.
I'm raising three children. How are we supposed to survive?
More than 10 days after the disaster, Nepal mobilized the entire country to save lives,
while China mobilized the entire country to put on a show.
On the third day after the disaster,
Chinese military forces only started to enter the disaster area.
After September 1st, authorities stopped updating rescue figures,
suggesting that rescue operations had already been halted.
In other words, those missing people trapped underground,
even if they were still alive, could be only treated as dead.
CCP disaster propaganda videos have triggered widespread anger online.
Another staged propaganda video was exposed,
showing rescue workers swinging shovels through empty air without actually digging.
Even the staged scenes appear to be poorly done.
Another CCTV report showed a grand entrance by Chinese rescue forces,
red flags waving, troops marching in perfect formation,
uniforms spotless, and slogans shouted loudly.
The lines had to remain perfectly straight,
as if the mission was to complete a patriotic education display.
As for the people still buried underneath?
They appeared to be secondary.
So far, apart from reports about finding a mud-covered rabbit toy,
arresting more than a dozen people online for allegedly spreading rumors,
and placing red flags everywhere,
Chinese rescue coverage has largely focused on showcasing life in Tibet,
including cooking meals at the disaster site,
demonstrating knife skills,
displaying fresh ingredients,
and showing steaming bowls of rice.
Some users questioned why,
at a disaster site where every second counts,
rescuers were spending significant time chopping vegetables and tossing food in pans.
Earlier, Chinese state media, including Xinhua,
specifically highlighted that the five large characters reading
I love you China on a cliff above the port
remained visible after being hit by the mudslide.
For years, China has promoted its drones,
satellite remote sensing,
artificial intelligence,
live detection technology,
and engineering equipment,
repeatedly claiming it is world-leading and far ahead.
One commenter asked,
when thousands of lives were hanging in the balance,
where exactly were these leading technologies?
When disaster strikes,
the key question is whether a government puts human life first,
or whether it prioritizes controlling information,
restoring order,
and protecting its own image.
The contrast between the Chinese Communist Party and its neighbor is clear.
On September 4th,
Canadian writer Sheng Xue wrote on X
that the ruins left by the disaster
are the harshest test of humanity and political systems.
She said that for people living under Chinese Communist Party rule,
when disaster strikes,
they may not only become victims of destructive engineering projects,
but may also be abandoned by bureaucratic systems,
trapped behind censorship and control,
and deprived of timely warnings and rescue.
Even after being buried alive,
their names and deaths could be erased by authorities.
Australia-based legal scholar Yuan Hongbin told the Epoch Times
that during major disasters,
the CCP's first priority is protecting political interests.
He said,
during any major disaster or major incident,
what the CCP dictatorship wants to do first
is to create a national lie to cover up the reality
and hide its wrongdoing.
Yuan Hongbin also said
that the CCP has long exploited Tibet's natural resources
through destructive development.
After disasters occur,
it again prioritizes maintaining political control
while hiding casualties and property losses.