Rome: Power and Glory 5of6 Cult of Order
Sep 9, 2026
This video does not yet have a content description.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe video examines the decline of the Roman Empire, tracing its transition from a peak of stability under Marcus Aurelius to a state of cultural and moral decay. It analyzes how systemic inequality, the erratic leadership of emperors like Commodus, and the rise of Christianity challenged the empire's rigid social hierarchy and traditional values, ultimately leading to a crisis of imperial identity.
Romans thought they'd united the world, but after centuries of conquest and glory,
resentment festered within. Repression and chaos replaced tolerance and order,
and cults of dissent emerged that threatened to divide the empire. In 203 AD,
in a Roman arena in Carthage, North Africa, members of an Eastern cult were rounded up,
publicly tortured for the amusement of the crowd.
Their crime was religious conviction. Their name, Christians.
It was a theater of terror that would haunt Rome forever. One of the victims that day
was Perpetua, a woman who redefined the meaning of defiance. Perpetua is a young mother,
a beautiful young girl, and she is determined to stand by her faith. And even when the government
wants to attack Christians, she remains steadfast. Her father begs her to renounce her faith. She
says, I can't. I must be true to my cause. She's separated from her baby. She's imprisoned.
She's never been in such a place before. She's a woman from a respectable family.
In prison, she kept a diary, a tragic testament to the power of faith.
One night, she dreamed her time in the arena had come. I saw a beautiful bronze ladder
extending all the way to heaven. People were climbing the ladder, but under it was a demonic
serpent. The serpent was attacking the climbers, hoping to frighten them from making the ascent.
And I said, in the name of Jesus Christ, the serpent will not harm me. Then I awoke,
knowing that it wasn't beasts that I'd fight in the arena. It was the devil. And I knew
I would be victorious. The next day, Perpetua was sent into the arena. The lions were released,
but they refused to touch her. So a gladiator was sent in to finish her off. When he too hesitated,
Perpetua grabbed his sword and slit her own throat in defiance. Perpetua's martyrdom stunned
the crowd. She chose death over allegiance to Rome. Why? Rome's century of doubt had begun.
For hundreds of years, the benefits of Roman rule seemed clear. Her army created the most
stable empire the world had ever known. From Scotland to the Sahara, from the Atlantic to
the Euphrates, everyone enjoyed the blessings of Rome's peace. Her government gave the Mediterranean
centuries of community, stability, and prosperity. For hundreds of years, it was good to be Roman.
But that wouldn't last. Our history now descends from a kingdom of gold
to one of iron and rust, Cassius Dio. Emperor Marcus Aurelius presided over the first signs
of decline in the Roman world. Born in 121 AD, he was groomed from an early age to be Rome's next
emperor. Aurelius had 20 years to dream about the kind of ruler he wanted to be
and the kind of empire he wanted to rule. As a Roman, he believed there was a divine order to
things. As emperor, he hoped to recreate that order in the Roman world, which is what Romans
had done for centuries with astounding success everywhere. They pacified the entire Mediterranean
with one set of laws, regulated trade with one currency, replaced diversity with conformity.
Rome's empire stretched for two million square miles, but whether you were in Egypt or England,
you could always travel a straight Roman road to a familiar Roman city.
Roman roads reflect a tremendous centralized organization. All roads led to Rome, of course,
and you could come to the city of Rome and go to the forum, and there was a golden milestone which
told you how far it was to every other city in the empire. Romans liked to know where they stood.
They planned their cities like they planned their lives in a methodical, orderly fashion.
If nature was unpredictable, they tamed it. Romans channeled water to their cities in massive
aqueducts, arguably their greatest logistical triumph. Rome had been a symbol of order and
stability for centuries, and Marcus Aurelius expected to continue that tradition. In 161 AD,
Aurelius finally became emperor. For 23 years, he'd been planning a peaceful rule.
He was in for a brutal awakening. Later that year, war broke out in the east.
Barbarians crossed the frontier and attacked a Roman province. A deadly plague ravaged the
empire, killing a quarter of Rome's population. Germanic invaders then exploited the disaster and
attacked from the north. Rome was suddenly confronted with military threats on two fronts.
Marcus Aurelius spent eight years on the frontiers fighting for Rome's survival.
Like many, he feared it was the beginning of the end, that the great Roman empire was about to fall
to an invading army. But his fears were misplaced, for Rome's greatest problems lay within,
as did the emperor's. Marcus Aurelius had cancer. He took daily doses of a drug he hoped would
alleviate his suffering. It didn't, and in 180 AD, the disease finally won. Aurelius' painful death
foreshadowed the fate of the empire he left behind. Rome too was suffering from a fatal disease,
cultural decay. It was an erosion of traditional Roman values that would force many
to turn to foreign cults for their salvation and, like Perpetua, question their allegiance to Rome.
The Roman empire is as famous for its vices as it is for its virtues. Corrupted by wealth and power,
Rome's legacy was tainted by images of indulgence and imperial excess. The emperor Commodus epitomized
the decay. His arrogance would force everyone to question their allegiance to Rome. Commodus
succeeded his father Marcus Aurelius in 180 AD. Traumatized by an early attempt on his life,
Commodus shunned all public appearances and left Rome in the hands of his closest advisors.
As they terrorized Rome, Commodus amused himself in the palace. He maintained a harem of hundreds
of young boys and girls and abused them at his whim. He kept amongst his minions certain men
named after the private parts of both sexes and on these he liked to bestow kisses.
Herodian. It was a lifestyle funded by corruption and extortion. Resentment festered throughout the
In 190 AD, the poor rioted. They thought Commodus had deliberately hoarded grain to
inflate its price and increase his profits. After nine years as a recluse, the emperor was forced
to play a more public role. The results were disastrous. He demanded he be made a living god.
He took the title Hercules and appeared in a lion's skin, wielding a club on all public
occasions. When a huge fire consumed Rome in 191 AD, Commodus outdid himself. He proposed the rest
of the city be destroyed and an entirely new one rebuilt in his honor. But first, Commodus chose
Rome's most famous landmark for his ultimate act of indulgence. On November 17, 192 AD,
people flocked to the Colosseum. Something truly shocking was on the program. That afternoon,
the slaves and criminals who normally fought in the arena were joined by someone very special.
For the first time in Roman history, an emperor was appearing in public as a gladiator.
Commodus may have won that day, but his victory was short-lived. Commodus was assassinated on
December 31, on New Year's Eve, because next day he planned to be inaugurated as consul,
dressed up as a gladiator. And that was such an affront. It was as though the American president
attended inauguration dressed in American football kit. It was a complete insult to
the total political way of life. The assassination of Commodus wasn't the answer,
for Rome's problems lay deeper still in the very foundation of Roman society.
On August 24, 79 AD, a volcano in southern Italy erupted. Smoldering ash from Mount Vesuvius
buried the nearby town of Pompeii and froze a haunting and revealing portrait of Roman society
for all time. Suffocated by ash, the victims that day seemed united in death. Yet the ruins of
Pompeii showed just how divided they were. The rich lived lives of gaudy luxury. Their houses
were spacious and ornate, their gardens lush, their lifestyles lavish. But the most notorious
element of their decadence is a fiction. Paintings of imagined Roman orgies were commissioned by
19th century politicians to promote their own message of sexual intolerance. The most famous
of these showed a group of disapproving philosophers frowning at a debauched banquet.
There was a serious proposal to put that painting in every classroom in the United States of
because it was seen as an image of morality, of what the Romans were really about were those
philosophical types. And if you get involved in the orgy, in decadence,
then your civilization will fall as surely as the Romans. For most Romans, a lifestyle of luxury and
decadence was a very distant dream. The gap between wealthy and poor was ten times worse
than today. Ninety-five percent of the population struggled beneath the poverty line. They lived in
dark fire-trapped tenements, entire families packed into a single room. The child mortality
rate was 50 percent. Typhoid and diphtheria were constant threats. Equally claustrophobic was a
woman's place in Roman society. Women were considered biologically and morally inferior
to men. They couldn't vote, buy property, or choose who they married. Their fathers and husbands
had legal and financial control over them most of their lives. Rome was built on a rigid social
hierarchy. At the height of her power, one in every three people in Italy was a slave.
And it was their sweat and their labor that gave Roman cities their fabled wealth and splendor.
Astoundingly, the burden of discrimination was lifted once each year. Every December at the
winter solstice, Romans would celebrate the Saturnalia, when everything in Rome turned
upside down. For one week, masters served their slaves dinner. Children of the poor ate with the
rich. It was a surreal disruption of the status quo. For those who wanted more frequent release
from Rome's rigid class system, there was another option. The cult of Dionysus was Greek in origin.
Its controversial rituals, or bacchanalia, arrived in Italy in the second century BC.
With wine and dance, devotees entered a kind of collective trance,
a communal ecstasy that offered escape from the oppressive divisions of Roman society.
People are getting together, they're making cells, they're making little clubs,
and they're assembling in an uncontrollable way at night time in groups that are mixed,
men and women, and they're making, they're not quite sure what sort of conspiracy together.
And it is dealt with in an extremely bloody way. I mean, not only is the cult of Dionysus
completely banned, but the consuls go up and down the country, there are many executions.
At the heart of Roman culture lay a tragic flaw, a social order that tolerated excess for the few
and oppression for the many. That injustice would soon fuel the rise of Rome's most subversive cult
of descent. There was one ideal that made everyone proud to be Roman, an ideal as old as Rome itself,
a commitment to cultural diversity.
Roman society was always enormously open. There's a wonderful story about Romulus who,
when he goes to found Rome, calls upon people to come and live in the city. And the passage
sounds just like the Statue of Liberty, you know, everyone come,
let me take your outsiders and your poor.
One thousand years later, Rome's open door policy was still going strong.
Her fabled wealth and splendor had attracted people from every corner of the world.
You could be in the city of Rome and you could see people who were obviously African,
obviously Indian, obviously Italian, Gauls, Germans.
All of these people were in fact Roman citizens. And so somehow the Romans seem to have been able
to find a way to achieve the American motto, e pluribus unum. They all, they got along,
there doesn't seem to be have been any racial or ethnic tension within the Roman Empire.
By the third century AD, Rome's immigrant spirit applied to everyone, even emperors.
Septimius Severus succeeded Commodus as emperor in 193 AD. He was African, a native of Lepkes
Magna in modern-day Libya. During his 18-year rule, he adorned his hometown with lavish buildings
and brought some of its magic back to Rome. Severus and his wife, Julia Domna,
were both deeply superstitious. He was devoted to an Egyptian mystery cult.
She worshipped a Syrian sun god. Romans had no problem with the couple's exotic beliefs.
The vast Roman Empire had a long history of religious tolerance.
They lived in a pagan world that welcomed virtually everyone's gods.
There's something in the pluralism of Roman religion that makes it possible
to acquire new gods. In their very earliest stories about themselves,
conquests of little towns around Rome involve, one of their myths is that of
evocation. When you go and you pronounce a series of prayers to beg the god of the local town to
come to Rome with you, and it becomes your god, and you add to the strength of the team at Rome.
All that was asked of foreign religions was that they respect the cult of Rome
by making annual sacrifices to the emperor. It was a policy intended to secure some control
in a world of extreme religious diversity. There were as many cults in Rome as there
were provinces in the empire. Bull worshippers from Iran, fertility sects from Egypt,
rain gods from Germany. In the city of Rome, you could experiment with almost anything.
And in that way, I suspect that the religious menu, the huge a la carte menu of choice,
not as large as it would be in Los Angeles or in New York, but still very wide.
But by the third century AD, religious diversity was leading to chaos. People were overwhelmed by
the choices that surrounded them. Severus's solution was sun worship. He hoped it would
prove a unifying force in a very fragmented world. Rome's wealthy decided to follow the sun
in a different way. They traveled east to Greece, Egypt, even as far as India in search of
themselves. But if Romans were confused, their leaders were completely out of control. In 211 AD,
Severus was succeeded on the imperial throne by his son Caracalla, whose most memorable act as
emperor was to murder his own brother, Gaeta. He was sick in body and mind. He often thought he was
being pursued by his father and his brother, armed with swords. At first, Caracalla's insanity was
kept in check. In 212 AD, he awarded Roman citizenship to every free man in the empire,
a dramatic reaffirmation of Rome's commitment to tolerance and diversity. The emperor then set off
on a grand tour of the empire. In December 215 AD, he reached Egypt. In the city of Alexandria,
he was given a splendid reception by its proud new Roman citizens. The affection didn't last long.
Enraged by local criticism of his brother's murder, the emperor invited 5,000 citizens
into a local theater and butchered them in cold blood. In one afternoon, Caracalla destroyed the
fabled value of Roman citizenship. Never had Romans felt so confused or so conflicted about
their place in the world. They're looking for something in the same way that we Americans
are looking for something. I think we can use that same explanation to explain things like
Heaven's Gate and the Jonestown Massacre and any of the cults that have arisen over the past few
years. When they lose their identity, you find that they begin to turn to cults. In the 3rd
century AD, Romans turned to one cult in particular, a cult whose message was destined
to change the empire and the world forever. Christianity's dramatic rise to power in the
Roman world would change everything. A cult based on the suffering of one man was set to challenge
the integrity of an entire empire. Christianity's message spread west from Judea in the 1st century
AD, carried by a small band of apostles. In Rome, it struggled for identity, one of many obscure
cults in a crowded city. One blatant act of brutality would set it apart. In 64 AD, the
emperor Nero publicly massacred hundreds of Christians in Rome, blaming them for a fire
they didn't start. It was the first time most Romans had even heard of Christianity.
But the cult was a perfect scapegoat, its values radically un-Roman.
Blessed are the meek, for they shall inherit the earth. Matthew, woe to you who are rich,
for you have already received your comfort. Luke. Christianity is a protest movement in
one real sense. We mustn't think of early Christians as people who went on demonstrations
through the streets of Rome, or picketed the senate house, or threw eggs at emperors. They're
not that kind of group. They're very quiet, introverted, keeping themselves to themselves.
So anti-Roman in their beliefs, but not a protest movement in the sense of marching on Rome.
Christianity's most revolutionary ideal was spiritual equality. It was a direct threat
to Rome's belief in hierarchy and social division. Women in particular were attracted to the new cult.
It granted them the independence they'd been denied by Roman society.
The only public position of power and prestige open to a Roman woman was as a Vestal Virgin.
Rome's six Vestal Virgins attended all important state events, but their principal duty was to
look after the sacred fire of Vesta, the Roman goddess of the hearth. This fire was the symbol
of Rome's longevity, and it was their job to ensure it never went out. Vestal Virgins were
highly respected and lived well, yet their public honors had a price. Vestal Virgins took a vow of
chastity when they entered the order at an early age. If one of them broke that vow, the punishment
was fierce and final. She was locked in an underground room. The windows were covered,
and she was slowly buried alive. Ironically, early Christians chose to be underground.
They felt safer meeting in the labyrinth of burial chambers beneath the city
known as the catacombs. Here, women participated in the ritual of communion on an equal footing
with men. This shocked pagan Rome and gave rise to scandalous rumors. They recognize each other
by secret signs, and they have sex even before they've become friends. They call each other
brother and sister, and thus their common fornication becomes a kind of incest.
They worship the private parts of their priest, and I've even heard that they kill children
and drink their blood. Minutius Felix. Precisely the same accusations would be used by Christians
to condemn witches in later centuries. But Rome persecuted Christians for another reason.
They refused to respect anyone else's gods. For there is only one God and one mediator between
God and men, the man Jesus Christ, first Timothy. They couldn't absorb Christianity because it will
not allow you to sacrifice to other gods. In particular, Christianity involves the rejection
of the cult of the emperor. And because the cult of the emperor is virtually the only way
in which the whole empire can express its unity, this is very disruptive.
At first, the Roman state tried hard to ignore the conflict. A letter from the emperor Trajan
to a provincial governor in 113 AD shows how lenient he wanted to be.
These people must not be hunted out. If they are brought before you and the charge against them is
proved, they must be punished. But if anyone denies he is a Christian and makes it clear he is
not by offering prayers to our gods, he is to be pardoned, however suspect his past may have been.
Trajan. Trajan was wise in his restraint. Rome's previous attempts at social repression had
backfired. In 19 BC, the emperor Augustus embarked on a program of brutal moral reform.
He feared that the Roman aristocracy, decimated by recent civil wars, was dying out.
His solution was to persuade Roman families to produce pure Roman babies quickly. Adultery was
made a capital crime, punishable by exile or death. Romans openly mocked his moral crusade.
Ovid, the most popular poet of the day, provoked the emperor's wrath by publishing a book called
The Art of Love, celebrating sex and secret liaisons.
Augustus panicked and banished Ovid to a bleak outpost on the Black Sea.
Though others have been exiled for weightier causes, a more remote land has been assigned
to no one. Nothing is farther away than this land, except only the cold and the enemy and
the sea whose waters congeal with the frost. Ovid. Ovid died there 10 years later, still dreaming
of Rome. The emperor's repressive reforms were extremely unpopular and futile. They fathered
more informers than children. Now the country suffered from its laws as it had done from its
vices. Tacitus. But by the second century AD, most Romans had forgotten the lessons of the past.
Christianity's ideals were attracting upper-class women to the faith. Their refusal to perform
public sacrifices to the emperor threatened the male elite. Their response was highly controversial.
Its severity still debated today. In the first three centuries after Christ, most Romans
neither cared nor noticed Christians. They certainly didn't see them as an endless supply
of lion food. More criminals were eaten by lions in the Roman world than Christians.
This is an image which has been created by later Christian sources, keen then to present themselves
as an active movement of protest against Rome. And yet accounts of public persecution have survived.
Rituals of repression that backfired. For persecution produced victims. Victims willing
to become martyrs. One of these was Blandina, a young slave girl. The crowd subjected her to every
horror and punishment. Yet she was by now indifferent to suffering and kept faith in Christ.
To the crowd's amazement, Blandina endured three days of horrific torture in the arena.
In the end, she too was killed. Though the pagans admitted they had never seen a woman suffer so much
for so long. Eusebius. The more you persecute, the more you raise the stakes.
It's a terrible gamble because in throwing people to the lions, you do it in an enormously public
fashion. And if the martyrs play the game well, if they not survive their martyrdom but
maintain their dignity, keep the crowd on their side through the martyrdom,
then it's a wonderful recruiting ground. And the effect of great persecution is
that everyone knows you've got to go this way or that. The big choice is Christian or not.
A protest movement was quickly gaining momentum.
Its very popularity posed a fundamental threat to the Roman way of life.
By the middle of the 3rd century AD, Rome was consumed by doubt.
As chaos and confusion wracked the empire, everyone began questioning the benefits of
Roman rule. Between 235 and 270 AD, more than 30 Roman generals proclaimed themselves emperor.
As Roman legion fought Roman legion, innocent citizens were caught in the crossfire of civil
war. Barbarians seized the opportunity and streamed across the frontiers. Germans in the
west and Parthians in the east disrupted the provinces. Inflation soared and livelihoods
were destroyed. The promise of salvation in the next life was becoming very appealing.
Christianity's tradition of charity attracted many converts in Rome's century of chaos and doubt.
The size of the catacombs in Rome, the cult's secret meeting place, shows just how popular
Christianity had become. By the middle of the 3rd century, there were an estimated 5 million
Christians in the empire. It's an indication of the strength of the church at the end of
the 1st century and particularly of the level of church organization. We've got a church now
that's got a growing membership and that has got a hierarchy of clergy and bishops
throughout the Mediterranean. In 284 AD, Diocletian was crowned emperor. He had risen through the ranks
of the army to seize power in Rome. As befitted a military man, his vision for the future was
brutal. Diocletian felt the key to unity lay in division. He split the Roman world in two
and agreed to share power with three other generals. Their coordinated efforts did bring
peace, only for a time. Diocletian ruled for over 20 years, but spent only two months in Rome.
He was forced to spend most of his time in cities like Trier, Germany, to be closer to
the wars on the frontiers. Rome, a beacon of strength for over a thousand years, felt increasingly
vulnerable, as did the emperor. In a desperate bid for respect, Diocletian proclaimed himself
the son of Jupiter and insisted that everyone kneel in his presence and kiss the hem of his robe.
To many, it was empty spectacle, and they began looking elsewhere for reassurance.
Now, even members of the imperial court were secretly converting to Christianity.
Diocletian said that the unity of the empire is not just a military matter, but it's a religious
matter, and if we can stamp out Christianity, then we will all be worshipping the same gods,
so we will all be the same empire. And when that gamble fails to come off, you fail to stamp out
Christianity, the martyrs produce more Christians. On February 24, 303 AD, Diocletian initiated the
most sweeping persecution Christianity has ever faced. Churches were burned, scriptures destroyed,
Christians sent to work in state mines, or imprisoned and tortured for their beliefs.
If they still refused to sacrifice to Rome's gods, they were publicly tortured.
Rome, once a proud culture of tolerance, had become a repressive cult of order.
What we see in Diocletian's persecution of the Christians are the only two Mediterranean-wide
organizations, the Roman state and the Christian church, battling it out for supremacy.
In 305 AD, Diocletian retired to his summer palace, confident that Rome had won.
He was wrong. In the blood of the martyrs lie the seeds of the church. Tertullian.
There's an irony about Roman history in that one of the great accomplishments of Rome
were the roads. And I think it's fascinating that those roads are what did Rome in.
Because over those roads came the cults, came ideas that would undo the Roman identity
and Roman sense of self. For centuries, Rome's power and confidence had been unshakable.
She had basked in the achievements of her empire, convinced of the glory of her rule.
But a cult from Judea confronted Rome's arrogance, challenged her inequality,
and exposed her brutality. Rome, once a symbol of order and control,
was crumbling into chaos and confusion.

