Massachusetts Supreme Court Hears Oral Arguments Over Lindsay Clancy Mistrial

TMZ
10 followers
Sep 4, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
But I will give you the opportunity now to address the specific issue of this particular timeline.
Thank you. I will defer to Attorney Goldblatt on this.
Thank you, Judge. Justice, I would just add that this morning on the 4th,
when before the judge gave the instruction to follow all his instructions,
Attorney Reddington, on behalf of Ms. Clancy, asked that the judge inquire of the jury
individually through voir dire to determine whether this juror was following instructions.
And the judge declined to do that. So that was when this petition was filed.
Based on that, it was filed before the jury sent in their second, I guess their third notice of
deadlock. So there's an intervening, Attorney Reddington requested an individual voir dire
of the jurors. That request was denied. I filed this motion, the petition, with Attorney Reddington.
And then the jury came back, sometime after I filed it, the jury came back saying they were
in fact deadlocked. Just a slight dispute in the timeline. The juror came back with a note
saying they were deadlocked prior to 1230. This was filed at 1230. And at that time,
Judge Sullivan stated that he was going to declare a mistrial after arguments by counsel.
At that time, Attorney Reddington did ask for an individual voir dire. Again, that was denied
based on the Ronke case and that case line. Then Attorney Reddington stated that he was going to
seek review of declaring a mistrial. So that's what I thought this was about. But we did receive
the petition. And we understand now that it's not based on the judge's authority to declare a
mistrial, but rather on the voir dire issue, which I think based on the timeline and the case law,
this is covered under Commonwealth versus Ronke 491 Mass 284 from 2023, where we have nothing in
these notes or anything from the deliberating jurors that indicate a lack of impartiality,
bias, extraneous influence, or inability to deliberate regarding this one juror.
What we seem to have is a dispute amongst the deliberating jurors as to how to apply the law,
but that's their deliberation and which the judge, I think, correctly decided not to inquire
into. By questioning the jurors the prior day about whether they could follow the instructions
and all of them saying yes, and the Judge Sullivan crediting those statements, I think that it's a
judicial discretion issue and Judge Sullivan has discretion to not conduct the voir dire
and to issue a mistrial. Although it was quick papers, it was good papers.
And I understand the distinction that you're making. And at this point, I think I need to
make a decision. So I will leave you make that decision. And
thank you very much for quickly getting on this call.
