Boston 25's Bob Ward reports outside of Plymouth County court after the defense asks for an emergency stay following a move for mistrial in the Lindsay Clancy murder trial.
Defense attorney Kevin Reddington is attempting a last-minute legal maneuver to avoid a mistrial in the Lindsey Clancy case. After the jury failed to reach a verdict, the judge granted Reddington a narrow 60-minute window to seek a stay from the Supreme Judicial Court (SJC) before dismissing the jury.
situation. Elise, hold on. I'm told that Bob Ward is now available outside of the courthouse.
You were in that courtroom, Bob. Walk us through. We could see some of the exasperation it looked
like there on Kevin Reddington's face, that we're right back where he had hoped to avoid.
Absolutely, Cal. When we were let into the courtroom, it was about an hour after the
jury began its final push and deliberations, and they sent back there one more time. And
it was almost exactly an hour later, and there was a feeling that this might be it, that
either that lone holdout juror has dug in his heels and they can't reach a verdict,
or maybe that lone holdout juror has changed their mind and there is a verdict. We really
weren't sure. Then we heard those arguments that were being made. Actually, before the
judge even got into the courtroom, the clerk came out and had a sheet of paper that, of
course, you can't read, but it was shown to both the prosecutor and Kevin Reddington at
the podium, not at the bench, but at a podium. The judge was not in the courtroom yet. Both
sides were reviewing it, and Kevin walked away. Kevin Reddington, the defense attorney,
walked away, and we could see his face, and he was very, very frustrated. So I started
getting a sense that this was not going to go his way, that this mistrial might be taking
place. But then, you know, we heard what happened. You saw what happened. And then, just out
of the blue, Kevin Reddington came up with this last chance to try to stay everything
and get that appeal out to that single justice at the SJC. A lot of people were surprised
by it in the courtroom. The courtroom, you know, when we started this six, seven weeks
ago, there were only two benches filled with the press. There are now seven benches filled
with the press and only two available for spectators. So there weren't as many spectators
in there as there has been because more press is showing up. But when Kevin asked for that
and was able to get that 60-minute window, there was actually an audible gasp behind
me from some of the spectators, because, clearly, none of us saw this one coming.
And this is a trial filled with surprises like this, just not — you know, a lot of
things that are taking place that we just have not seen before. And it's still continuing
right up here into the 11th hour.
Well, and, Bob, I'm just — simple math here. That order from the judge was given
here just about 10 minutes ago. So we are now down to about 50 minutes left in that
one-hour window for Kevin Reddington to throw what essentially sounds like a Hail Mary here
to see if he can delay a decision in this trial.
You talked about the gasp behind you there in the courtroom. We're in uncharted territory,
Bob.
Yeah, we are. People who are here, the spectators who are here, were hoping that Lindsey Clancy
today would be acquitted, either through straight not guilty or not guilty insanity. So they
are disappointed that this has happened. They wanted a verdict, just like Kevin Reddington
wanted a verdict, just like Lindsey Clancy and her family wanted a verdict. That's
why that gasp was there.
I don't think and I haven't seen anyone from the other side of this issue showing
up every day in court to witness what is going on. But I think you're right when you call
this a Hail Mary pass. The judge clearly did not want to do this. You probably heard him
arguing a bit with Kevin Reddington, saying, what, you're going to make this jury come
back tomorrow, Saturday? You know, incredulous, thinking that's not a serious request, because
you can't open up this building. You can't get these court officers here on a Saturday.
And as you mentioned, it's Labor Day weekend. You're really talking about Tuesday. This
jury, I could tell they look tired. They look worn. They're probably tired of just being
here every single day. And then on top of it, being confronted with the evidence in
this case. And then on top of that, being frustrated over not being able to reach a
verdict after all this time. It looked to me like the jury was tired and probably at
this point on a long holiday weekend, probably just wants to go home. And I think that Judge
Sullivan is keeping that very is paying close attention to that. And he probably wants to
send them home as well. So I think everybody was was very surprised in the courtroom when
Kevin Reddington said, I need an hour or actually, he said he wanted a couple of days. He wanted
more than an hour. But the judge said, I'll give you an hour. And then if you don't have
it, then I'm sending this jury home. So the judge and Kevin Reddington definitely not
on the same page here. Yeah, you could definitely pick up on the exasperation there in court
between both Reddington and the exasperation we saw in the judge. But Elise, I want to
ask you, the judge does have the discretion here in terms of what to do next. He is trying
to accommodate all sides.