Worse Than Tibet Disaster? 3 Massive Landslides Strike China: $170B Mega Dam In Danger

China Observer
822粉絲
On September 1, several mainland Chinese internet users posted videos showing a landslide at Tiger Leaping Gorge. The footage showed rocks tumbling down the mountainside. The scenic area was nearby, and tourists rushed to avoid the falling debris.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT2kPBcD6tXn8TP_aV7BmgA/join
#chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
⭐You can support us at: https://donorbox.org/china-observer-supporting-independent-news
⭐For business cooperation, please contact us: [email protected]
On September 1st, several mainland Chinese internet users posted a video
showing a landslide at Tiger Leaping Gorge. The footage showed rocks tumbling down the
mountainside. The scenic area was nearby, and tourists rushed to avoid the falling debris.
The users who posted the video said the landslide occurred at around 2.30pm
and lasted for about four minutes. Fortunately, no casualties have been reported so far.
According to online posts, rockfalls had already occurred at the same location on July 30th and
in mid-August. With the latest incident, the area has now experienced three similar events
in the same spot. On the afternoon of September 1st, the staff at the Gorge Scenic Area confirmed
that a collapse had occurred that day, but said it was outside the official scenic area.
They said the site remains open as usual. Officials from Tiger Leaping Gorge Town said
frequent rainfall in recent days may have loosened the soil and rocks,
contributing to the collapse. Online commenters wrote
Public information shows that Tiger Leaping Gorge is a famous canyon along the Jingsha River,
the upper section of the Yangtze. It is located on the border between Lijiang City,
Yunnan Province, and Shangri-La City in Tibet. The canyon has an elevation difference of more
than 9,800 feet from the riverbed to the mountain peaks. At its narrowest point,
it is only about 100 feet wide, making it one of the deepest and most dangerous canyons in the
world. Previously, Chinese media reported that on July 18th, heavy rainfall flooding in the scenic
area. Some buildings collapsed, walkways were flooded, and some tourists were trapped inside
tunnels for nearly two hours. The construction and operation of hydropower projects can alter
conditions, potentially triggering or worsening landslides. Notably, Chinese authorities have
built, are building, or are planning to build numerous large hydropower stations in the area.
In recent years, the entire Jingsha River has been almost filled with hydropower projects.
In 2024, Chinese geologist and environmental scholar Fan Xiao published an article revealing
that 27 Cascade hydropower stations were planned along the main stream of the Jingsha River
from Yibin, Sichuan Province to Qinghai Province. The plan would completely transform the natural
river into a chain of interconnected reservoirs. Currently, 12 hydropower stations along the
middle and lower reaches of the Jingsha have been completed. Of the 13 planned stations on the upper
Jingsha River, the Suolong hydropower station has been completed, while six others are still
under construction. Among them is the Shulong hydropower station on the main stream of the
upstream from Tiger Li Bin Gorge and near the border of Sichuan Province and Yunnan Province.
According to official statements, in August 2025, the project completed construction of the first
inclined shaft of what was described as the steepest water diversion tunnel currently
under construction in China. The main construction phase has now moved from excavation to concrete
pouring. Fan Xiao has long studied and publicly criticized excessive hydropower development and
including cascade hydropower development and large dams along the Dadu River,
Jingsha River and the Three Gorges Project. He cited their potential negative impacts
on geological stability and the ecological environment. The proposed Tiger Li Bin Gorge
hydropower project, located in the upper section of the middle reaches of the Jingsha River,
has attracted strong interest from hydropower developers because of its massive reservoir
regulation capacity. Although its installed capacity is smaller than the Three Gorges Dam,
the project has major advantages in reservoir storage and multi-year water regulation.
Its water storage capability is even greater than that of the Three Gorges Dam. It is considered
multi-year regulating reservoir with a total storage capacity of about 48.5 billion cubic yards.
However, Fan Xiao pointed out four major problems. First, the project is built on an active fault
zone with intense geological activity, creating major risks of earthquakes, landslides and other
geological disasters. Second, it would damage natural landscapes, ecosystems and cultural
heritage sites, including Tiger Li Bin Gorge and the first bend of the Yangtze River at Shigu.
These are part of the Three Parallel Rivers World Natural Heritage Site,
national scenic areas and natural protected areas. Third, it would submerge roughly 33,000 acres of
farmland, villages and rural areas in the Jingsha River Valley between Tongpan and Taocheng,
forcing at least 150,000 people to relocate and endanger their livelihoods. Fourth,
the project harms the environment and sustainable development. Under the leadership of Hu Jintao
and Wen Jiabao, Chinese authorities took a more cautious approach toward major water projects.
Since 2004, the project faced strong opposition from Chinese citizens and international
environmental organizations and was suspended by 2007. Hydropower developers later renamed the
hydropower station as the Longpan Hydropower Station in an attempt to restart the project.
The Associated Press reported at the time that Hu Jintao avoided attending the completion ceremony
of the highly controversial Three Gorges Dam. The report said Hu's decision was very different from
previous CCP leaders, who often sought to associate themselves with major economic achievements.
In September 2007, Chinese state media began reporting that officials had acknowledged
various problems with the Three Gorges Dam. The Guardian reported at the time that then-Chinese
premier Wen Jiabao had intervened to stop plans to build 13 dams and hydropower stations along
the New River, calling the plan unscientific. Wen Jiabao had a background in geology. Earlier in
his career, he spent 18 years working at the grassroots level in geological exploration
and related work at the Gansu Provincial Bureau of Geology. However, after Xi Jinping came to power,
many major water projects that had previously been blocked were restarted openly. In 2022,
China's National Development and Reform Commission and National Energy Administration
officially included the Longpan Hydropower Station, formerly known as the Tiger Leaping
Gorge Hydropower Station, in major projects listed under the country's 14th five-year
renewable energy plan. At the national strategic level, the Longpan project was redefined as a
major project for Yangtze River flood control and energy transition. The project was effectively
revived. In 2024, the Longpan project began preparations for resettlement. At the end of 2025,
Yunnan Huadian Longpan Hydropower Development Company was officially created specifically
to oversee construction of the project. China affairs expert Yang Bo said that this shows
that during the Hu Wen era, authorities still showed some consideration for people's welfare,
while under Xi Jinping, large-scale projects driven by ambition have ignored public interests.
He said Xi reportedly claims people first, life first, but the launch of harmful projects like
this reveals a pattern of making favorable statements while also pursuing damaging policies.
After the 2008 Wenchuan earthquake, Fan Xiao also published research analyzing the potential
impact of water storage and pressure infiltration from the Zipingpu Reservoir on accelerating fault
zone fractures and triggering earthquakes. He listed seven indicators used by Chinese
researchers to assess reservoir-induced earthquakes, including a dam and reservoir
reaching a certain scale, active fault in the reservoir area, significant recent tectonic
movement, abnormal deep gravitational gradients, highly permeable rock formations, and previous
earthquake activity. Fan Xiao said the Zipingpu Reservoir met the first six of these criteria,
indicating a high risk of triggering earthquakes. Fan pointed out that the reservoir has a dam height
of 156 meters and a water depth of more than 330 feet. The enormous weight of the stored water
placed additional pressure on the Longmenshan fault zone. At the same time, water seeping deep
into the ground effectively acted as a lubricant, reducing the fault zone's resistance to shearing
and accelerating the fracturing process. China has seen repeated natural disasters and man-made
disasters, with landslides occurring frequently in recent months. Affected by heavy rainfall brought
by Typhoon Zhaodou, flash floods struck parts of Beihu District in Chengdu, Hunan Province.
On August 21st, more than 10 landslides occurred, while more than 20 road sections were blocked by
collapses. Chinese authorities emphasized rescue operations and claimed that as of September 1st,
there were zero deaths and no missing people. However, some observers questioned whether the
full extent of the disaster had been disclosed. On the early morning of August 23rd, Fengshan Town
in Yunnan Province was hit by prolonged heavy rainfall. A mudslide struck Anshi Village,
while a landslide occurred at Shuiqing Village. As of 5pm that day, the disaster had left two
people dead and four others missing. Videos from the scene showed mudslides carrying large
amounts of trees and rocks into the village. Some roads were destroyed, while mud and debris piled
up around homes. Firefighters carried out search and rescue operations at collapsed mountain areas
and among the ruins. At around 8am on August 15th, a landslide occurred in Pinan County, Guangxi
Province. Large numbers of trees were swept down with the mud and soil. During the incident, an
elderly man carrying an umbrella happened to walk through the area. As trees repeatedly fell toward
him, he quickly dodged the falling debris. Fortunately, he escaped the series of impacts.
On July 20th, a landslide and collapse occurred in Qinglong County, Guizhou Province,
destroying multiple roads and leaving more than half of one roadway missing.
On the morning of July 17th, a major mountain collapse occurred near the Wujiang River in the
Miao and Tujia Autonomous County, Chongqing. The disaster killed 51 people, left 10 missing,
and injured 10 others. On July 13th, continuous rain and wind brought by a typhoon triggered a
landslide near Gua'ao Village near Yueqing, Zhejiang Province. Large rocks fell into the road,
forcing a nearby bus stop to suspend service. Workers used excavators to clear the fallen rocks.
A local villager commented under a CCTV video, saying the road is the only route villagers use
to enter and leave the area every day. The person said small rocks had already been falling from the
Villagers had reported the issue to village and township authorities and repeatedly called the
government hotline. However, the relevant departments only installed a simple protective
barrier and failed to take any substantial reinforcement or hazard removal measures.
The commenter said ordinary barriers could not withstand large-scale rock falls during
heavy rain and typhoon conditions and urged authorities to address the danger at its source.
Shortly afterward, the critical comment was reportedly removed by online censors.
On June 23rd, a section of the Changchao Bridge in Liuzhou, Guangxi Province was hit by flash
floods. The bridge foundation and supports were left exposed after the surrounding soil
was washed away. The most devastating disaster in recent months was the massive flash flood and
mudslide disaster along the China-Nepal border in late August, whose impacts continue to be felt.
The catastrophic mudslide that struck the border on August 26th severely affected areas near Tibet's
Shigatse City and Rasuwa District in Nepal. So far, more than 1,000 people in the two countries
have died, and more than 4,500 people remain missing. Videos from the Nepalese side of the
disaster showed a large section of the mountain slope suddenly collapsing in a canyon. Large
amounts of rock and soil poured down the mountainside, quickly creating a massive cloud
of dust that covered the road and valley below. A person filming from the opposite mountainside
captured the entire process, from the initial collapse to the massive landslide. As the collapse
continued, grayish-yellow dust spread through the valley, almost completely blocking the view
of the entire canyon. Regarding the cause of the mudslide, Chinese experts have generally said
the main trigger was the collapse of a glacier inside Nepal. They said the glacier broke apart,
triggering a rock collapse, and all the broken material combined to form a glacial mudslide.
However, this explanation differs significantly from analysis recently published by international
researchers. Geologist Kristen Cook from the University of Grenoble in the Alps and a member
of the Nepal Mudslide Investigation Team recently published her analysis in National Geographic,
saying that the disaster was caused by the sudden collapse of bedrock beneath the glacier.
The collapse dragged the entire glacier down the mountain slope. The rapidly falling ice melted
quickly and blocked the river, eventually causing a deadly outburst flood from a landslide-dammed
lake. In an interview with Radio France International, Kristen Cook explained that the
glacier itself did not contain nearly enough energy to melt such a large amount of ice.
If only a glacier were involved, it would more likely have resulted in an ice avalanche.
An ice avalanche would move slowly down the valley and would not develop into such a massive flood.
A huge amount of rock was needed to trigger an event of this scale and to generate enough
heat to melt the ice. Glacier collapses are closely linked to glacial activity,
while rock collapses are largely determined by geological conditions and geological history.
The driving forces behind glacier collapses and rock collapses are different.
Independent commentator Tsai Hsien-kun wrote that the disaster along the China-Nepal border
involved not only natural forces, but also human factors. He said the large-scale infrastructure
development in the Himalayas has already damaged glaciers and high-altitude ecosystems,
and this may only be the beginning. Without stopping and reassessing these projects,
larger and more frequent disasters could occur in the future. He wrote that the Himalayan region
is already one of the world's most fragile ecosystems and one of the areas most sensitive
to climate change. Glacier retreat, permafrost melting, and expanding glacial lakes combined
with large-scale construction of roads, hydropower projects, mines, and tourism facilities have placed
additional pressure on unstable mountains and valleys. A single extreme rainfall event,
glacial lake outburst, or landslide could quickly intensify along river valleys and
eventually become a disaster affecting multiple regions or even crossing national borders.
Deputy Secretary-General of the Taiwan Society of International Law Lin Ting-hui
criticized China's construction of dams, roads, and tunnels. Lin said that blasting mountains
has damaged local ecosystems and geological stability. Combined with accelerating glacial
melt, meltwater can seep into weakened slopes, and when heavy rainfall occurs,
the scale and destructive power of mudslides can increase dramatically.
As early as 2018, a Tibetan writer living in exile warned that China's large-scale construction of
reservoirs and hydropower stations in Tibet, along with intensive mining activities,
had become a time bomb for Tibetans. Water resources expert Wang Weiluo, who lives in Germany,
said scientific reports had long warned that similar risks could occur again. He said if
China had shared data earlier, downstream losses could have been reduced. In his view,
the disaster was caused by a combination of ice and rock collapse and human alteration of the
terrain. Wang Weiluo pointed out that at the location where the two plateau rivers meet,
in Kirong, Tibet, construction projects have narrowed the river channel.
This means that when massive amounts of mud and debris rush downstream at high speed,
the floodwaters and debris, the flows that would normally spread outward, are forced into a much
narrower channel. He said, the narrower the river channel, the higher the mudslide can rise,
and the greater the impact on surrounding infrastructure. He also warned that the
massive hydropower project on the Yarlung Sampo River faces similar high-altitude geological
risks. The Yarlung Sampo Megahydropower Project is located in Ningchi City, Tibet. It plans to
build five cascade hydropower stations, with a total investment of about 1.2 trillion yuan,
about 170 billion US dollars. The project is expected to have an installed capacity
of 70 million to 81 million kilowatts, equivalent to about three Three Gorges Dam projects.
The megaproject officially entered the construction phase after a groundbreaking
ceremony was held in July 2025. Wang Weiluo said, the chain disasters involving high-altitude ice
and rock collapses, landslide-dammed lakes, and mudslides are not rare in the Tibetan Plateau.
Climate warming is making glaciers increasingly unstable. He warned that if the Yarlung Sampo
Megahydropower Project were to encounter a similar disaster, the risks and consequences would be far
more severe. He added that the lack of widespread public opposition inside China is itself one of
his biggest concerns.
