Don't believe history books! This is the real life of concubines

History & Culture of East
10 followers
16 Video Views·Sep 23, 2026
This video explores the tragic fate of concubines in the imperial harem after the emperor's death, particularly comparing the history of China and Vietnam.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video explores the tragic fates of imperial concubines in China and Vietnam after the death of an emperor. It highlights how these women, once symbols of power and favor, became disposable burdens to the new regime. While China employed brutal practices like sacrificial burial, Vietnam's approach was generally less violent but still characterized by isolation and loss of agency.
The whole imperial palace was cloaked in silent white. People talked endlessly about power,
the fallen throne, and a new dynasty turning the page. But one thing was almost never mentioned,
the fate of the women who had lived their whole lives in the inner court.
When the emperor was alive, the inner court was a place of favor, jealousy, power,
and political intrigue. But when the emperor died, the inner court suddenly became a problem
to be dealt with. Hundreds, even thousands, of women once called concubines, consorts,
beauties, and attendants. Suddenly became people with no clear place in the new order.
Seen through our eyes today, it is easy to mistake this and think
that all concubines were the emperor's wives, and that every wife was the same.
But in feudal times, that was not true. Concubines were not family, much less loved
ones in the emotional sense. They were part of power itself, selected, ranked, controlled,
and discarded when needed. A concubine's greatest value was not love, but the ability to bear
children, especially sons. When the emperor was alive, a woman could rise from low status
to the top just by winning his favor. But that was exactly why, once the emperor died,
all her support collapsed before her eyes. At that point, the court cared only about
one brutal question. Were these women still needed? And if not, how should they be handled
so order could be kept? And imperial authority could still save face? Of all the endings,
sacrificial burial was the most brutal. Sacrificial burial was not a symbolic ritual.
It was the literal burial of the living. And in many Chinese dynasties, it was once seen as normal.
Under Qin Shi Huang, the practice became extreme. According to ancient records,
after Qin Shi Huang died, all concubines who had not born children were buried with him.
No one dares say for sure how many there were. But what archaeology has found is enough to send
a chill down anyone's spine. In the tomb complex, many skeletons were found curled up
with twisted arms and legs, not straight at all. That shows they did not die peacefully.
But in panic, gasping for air and struggling in despair as the tomb was sealed,
those women did not follow the emperor into the underworld as legend and paintings suggest.
They were literally buried alive. One might think later dynasties were more humane,
but that was not really the case. Even in the Ming dynasty, sacrificial burial still existed.
It was simply called by another name. Some emperors even planned their own funerals while
still alive. Clearly stating who had to follow them and who was allowed to live.
Concubines who had born no son were forced to follow him. Before the sacrificial burial,
the concubines had to dress beautifully and be fully made up. So that even in the underworld,
they could still please the emperor. They were allowed to choose how to die,
poison, rope, or mercury. This may have seemed like a choice. Before they were stripped of every
right. It was not until Kangxi's reign that sacrificial burial was officially abolished.
But by then, centuries had already passed. And countless lives had been buried under imperial
authority. Not every dynasty used sacrificial burial. And many emperors chose another path,
one that sounded gentler. Forcing concubines to enter a monastery.
After the emperor died, low-ranking concubines who had born no son,
or, if they no longer had political value, were told to shave their heads,
put on brown monastic robes, leave the imperial palace, and enter a monastery.
On paper, they took vows to pray for the late emperor, preserve the court's honor,
and show its virtue. But in reality, this was not a voluntary choice. It was a quiet form of removal.
Once they entered the monastery, they were completely cut off from secular life,
from youth, and from feeling. And from any chance to start over.
They kept living, but only as shadows, in silence and oblivion.
Another fate, less often mentioned but no less haunting, was guarding the mausoleum.
This custom appeared in the Western Han, tied to Luho's decision.
After Emperor Gaozu of Han died, under it, some concubines were forced to live in the
emperor's mausoleum grounds. Day after day preparing bedding, utensils, and incense.
Treating the dead man as if he were still alive. They were not allowed to leave,
not allowed to step into the outside world. Guards watched them closely.
Escape meant death, and even their families could be implicated.
Living in such a place of death, alone and under constant fear, many broke down mentally.
They did not die at once, but were worn down day by day until youth and strength were gone.
Of course, not everyone met such a brutal end. Some concubines were allowed to remain in the
palace. Moving to secluded palaces after the emperor died. They were given titles, servants,
and stipends, and lacked neither food nor clothing. But it was a life with no future,
no power, no role, and no one left to truly care. They lived quietly, forgotten by history,
and died alone, even while still bearing the title of royal concubine.
The most humane, but also the rarest, outcome was for a concubine to have a son.
If that son did not inherit the throne but was granted a prince-dom,
his mother could leave the imperial palace and live at his estate.
There, they had relative freedom, family, care, and a life that was less cold.
But this privilege was not for the many. It depended entirely on the son's fate,
not on the mother's own. That was the story in China.
What about Vietnam? When people talk about the tragic fate of Chinese concubines,
they often ask, what about Vietnamese rulers?
Were Vietnamese concubines made to die with the emperor, or treated as cruelly as in China?
It was not exactly the same, and this difference reflects Vietnamese thought,
culture, and feudal society very clearly.
The biggest and most important difference is that feudal Vietnam did not have the
practice of burying concubines alive with the emperor, as in China.
Under the Lai, Tran, Lu, and Nguyen dynasties,
there are no official records showing that Vietnamese rulers took concubines with them in
death. Even rulers with absolute power and a strong court did not adopt this custom.
That was not because Vietnamese kings were kinder, but because of Vietnamese society.
To treat people that way at a funeral was seen as cruel and immoral,
and it clashed with Vietnamese ideas of yin and yang and the afterlife.
But not burying them alive did not mean Vietnamese concubines
had an easy life after the emperor died.
When the emperor died, the Vietnamese inner court also fell into instant silence.
All favor ended, and every chance of advancement disappeared.
From then on, each woman's fate depended on one thing alone,
whether she had a child, and who that child was.
For concubines who bore princes, especially grown princes, life was relatively safe.
When a prince was granted a title and moved to his own residence,
his mother was often allowed to follow him.
By contrast, women who had no children or whose children died young,
usually lived much quieter lives.
Some were kept in the palace and moved to secluded palaces.
They were still supported by the court, with servants and enough food and clothing.
But they lived unseen and in sadness.
Another path many Vietnamese concubines chose or were arranged to take
was to leave and become nuns.
This was more common under the Nguyen, especially in Hue.
One very notable point is that the Vietnamese inner court was much smaller than China's.
There were no scenes of thousands of concubines all living together in a vast imperial palace.
A smaller inner court meant fewer life or death struggles, fewer tragedies,
but also fewer chances to change one's fate.
Vietnamese concubines lived in a less splendid place,
but in return, there was less conflict.
The history of the inner court reveals a blunt truth.
Concubines did not live for themselves, they lived at the emperor's mercy.
When the emperor was alive, they had everything.
When he died, they lost almost everything.
Wars may end, dynasties may change.
But the tragedy of the inner court has lasted for thousands of years.
Behind the dragon robe and the throne were the lives of women
who faded away in silence.
Thank you for following this story.
If you found it interesting, please subscribe,
turn on notifications, and share it.
For now, goodbye.
