Tibet-Nepal 20-Story Mudslide: Thousands Dead, China Says 16, Truth Harder To Find Than North Korea

China Observer
822粉絲
On August 30, a CCTV reporter at the disaster site in Gyirong, Tibet, saw that the rocks left behind by the flooding appeared to be about 60 meters high, roughly the height of a 20-story building. The river channel remains severely damaged.
Join this channel to get access to perks:
https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCT2kPBcD6tXn8TP_aV7BmgA/join
#chinaobserver
All rights reserved.
⭐You can support us at: https://donorbox.org/china-observer-supporting-independent-news
⭐For business cooperation, please contact us: [email protected]
On August 30th, a CCTV reporter at the disaster site in Girong, Tibet, saw that the rocks left
behind by the flooding appeared to be about 60 meters high, roughly the height of a 20-story
building. The river channel remained severely damaged. Several days after the disaster,
as of 10pm on August 30th, the Chinese Communist Party reported 16 deaths and 546 missing people,
including about 261 foreign nationals. Many people online questioned the accuracy of the
official casualty figures. In July 2026, a woman from Shandong filmed her journey crossing through
Girong port into Nepal for a motorcycle trip. Her video showed that the area around the port
was filled with supermarkets, souvenir shops, restaurants and hotels. The mudslide this time
destroyed buildings on both sides of the border. After seeing the footage, many people asked,
how many people actually died?
There are rows of shops on this side of the port. You can exchange Nepalese rupees here.
The supermarket offers a very good exchange rate. There are hotels ahead too. Can I exchange
Nepalese currency here? Yes. How much would you like to exchange? This is Nepalese money.
Exchanged 300 yuan for 7,000 Nepalese rupees. Some commenters wrote, I'm the person who helped
with the customs clearance. I haven't been able to reach him. Can you contact him? Another person
wrote, don't delete this. The supermarket owner in the video is my best friend. After the mudslide
destroyed Girong port in Tibet on August 26th, families and friends of missing people have been
using every possible way online to search for information about their loved ones. So far,
Chinese authorities still have not released a list of missing people. Videos and discussions
related to the disaster have also faced strict censorship. While Nepal was able to rescue
thousands of affected residents within days, Chinese rescue teams reportedly failed to reach
the core disaster area at Girong port for several days. The dispatched rescuers were seen staging
footage while walking through the dangerous terrain and crossing rivers with ropes. The
operation was both unsafe and inefficient. No helicopters or rescue robots were seen.
After several days of staged scenes, they finally reached Girong port, missing the 72-hour golden
rescue window. Chinese state media reported that at 11am on August 30th, firefighters collapsed
from exhaustion at the rescue site. State media coverage focused heavily on rescue scenes,
but did not explain what happened afterward or who was rescued. Some commenters sarcastically asked,
what exactly did they rescue to become this exhausted? Many people criticized what they
called increasingly careless staged footage by state media. They questioned how firefighters who
had supposedly spent days without sleep could have clean uniforms, clean shoes without mud,
no sweat on their faces, and clean hands. At dawn on August 29th, Chinese rescue teams
continued searching through the ruins of Girong port. In the core area, surrounded by thick layers
of debris and mud, rescuers were seen using their bare hands to clear away broken concrete,
rubble, and steel bars, while repeatedly shouting in hoarse voices,
is anyone there? Chinese rescuers at the scene called out toward a mudslide pile that was tens
of meters thick, as if survivors buried underneath could still respond. Port Girong was flattened,
while state media crews lined up and shouted pointlessly. The footage triggered widespread
public anger. Some people online said that after two or three days buried under the rubble,
a person might still be able to make sounds, but whether anyone could actually be rescued did not
seem to matter. The procedure was to look right, first film, second take photos, and third shout
slogans. Other commenters angrily said the staged scenes were extremely hypocritical, cruel, and
cold-blooded. They said that after being buried for two days, anyone trapped beneath would already
be in critical condition. Even if someone responded, could they really be dug out by hand?
They criticized the rescue teams for bringing no detection equipment or search dogs. They said that
while they could not actually save anyone, they were shamelessly staging scenes for the cameras.
Some people sarcastically asked, where are the high-tech thermal imaging cameras,
the life detectors, the infrared sensors, robots, remote sensing equipment, and drones?
Where did they all go? They can only rely on shouting with their voices? Over the years,
state television has promoted so many advanced rescue technologies. Why are they nowhere to
be seen now? Chinese state media later released another set of images showing armed police carrying
out rescue operations at the mudslide site. The footage showed them lightly moving dirt and rocks
with shovels and pickaxes. Their movements were small and slow, making it appear as if they were
just posing for the cameras. Some commenters said the armed police were not even trying to make the
performance look real anymore. The fake digging is so lazy, one person wrote. Others pointed out
that some people were simply walking around holding flags, asking who is this kind of staged
video even made for? Another commenter wrote a sharp criticism. Real rescue efforts should be
judged by results, not by slow motion footage and red vests used to create a dramatic image.
A recent report by NetEase News stated that the Girong Port building in Tibet had been
completely flattened. At the rescue site, a rabbit toy covered in mud was seen sticking
out from the debris. One highly liked comment responded, can you just treat people like human
beings? Why are you trying to create an emotional moment with this? How many of our fellow citizens
have you found in the past few days? Were any of them alive? This is what you should be reporting.
This is what everyone cares about. On August 27th, Chinese Communist Party Premier Li Cheng
visited the disaster area for inspection. Photos from the scene showed that the shoes of the
accompanying officials were extremely clean, with no visible mud stains. This raised questions
over whether he had truly entered the front line of the disaster to understand the situation,
or whether he was simply following a pre-arranged inspection route as part of a formal procedure.
The same glacial mudslide disaster unfolded across two countries. Nepal's response stood out,
with frequent helicopter operations equipped with cameras, ground teams conducting manual
excavation, and medical teams on standby. The rescue scenes involving the Nepalese military
showed what a life-or-death operation truly looked like. Soldiers rolling through mud,
rushing through water, carrying massive rocks by hand, running with injured people on their
shoulders, and continuing intensive operations despite the risk of secondary landslides.
Their movements were direct, their coordination was tight, and there was no sense of performing
for the cameras. The urgency and professionalism on display stood in sharp contrast to the half-hearted
mud-digging performance seen in CCP propaganda videos. The difference was especially clear in the
release of information. Nepal updated the public three or four times a day and allowed interviews
with international media. It also allowed independent online reports, allowing news
updates to continue flowing. Dozens of reports were released every day. A list of foreign nationals
involved was also compiled. Nepal even rescued a horse that was found alive. International sympathy
and assistance soon followed. Based on public information, Nepal deployed more than 30 helicopters
for the rescue operation, while China deployed four helicopters. The contrast is difficult to
ignore. The speed of Nepal's disaster response outperformed that of a much larger country.
As of 10 p.m. on August 30, Nepal's latest official update said the flooding had killed 734 people,
left 2,498 people missing, and that 7,514 people had been rescued. The casualty figures had been
updated at least 11 times. On the Tibet side of Girong, Chinese authorities had updated their
figures only three times. On Nepal's southern side, helicopters and drones filled the sky,
while large numbers of rescue workers searched on the ground, with updates continuously shared
with the world. On the northern slope, the rescue operation appeared to have fallen silent,
leaving only what critics described as staged performances. Information disclosure remained
extremely limited. Families of missing people do not need silence or vague numbers.
This stark contrast has caused many outside of China to view the country as an unreliable partner.
As long as censorship and media controls remain in place, critics argue that China will never
become a truly respected nation. The mainland Chinese WeChat account City's Geography wrote
that Nepal is a small country, but in its disaster response, it had reached international
standards. The article described Nepal as a country worthy of respect. Meanwhile,
information restrictions, censorship, and suppression by the CCP have hidden the true
situation in Tibet. According to BBC Chinese, foreign journalists were not allowed to enter
Tibet without approval. During major incidents, there is often only a brief window to obtain
firsthand information before images are removed and public discussion falls silent. Human rights
groups say Tibetans who speak to reporters or post content online that contradicts official
narratives may face detention or arrest. As a result, Tibetans living overseas have still been
unable to confirm whether their relatives are alive. A BBC reporter noted a striking comparison.
She had previously reported from North Korea. And at times, it was actually easier to contact
sources in Pyongyang than to reach people in Lhasa. Ryan Fioressi, Executive Director of the
International Campaign for Tibet, said the result is that only the Chinese government controls the
flow of information. During disasters, this means local residents may avoid sharing information
about trapped people or the hardest-hit areas because they fear punishment. Meanwhile, Chinese
internet police punished two people online for allegedly fabricating and exaggerating casualty
figures and distorting the causes of the disaster. They were subjected to administrative
penalties, ordered to receive criticism and education, or required to sign written commitments
controlling their speech. A Lhasa tour bus driver named Suo, using a pseudonym, told the Epoch Times
that 15 tour bus drivers from his company were near Girongpor at the time of the disaster,
and all of them remain missing. My friends are mostly over there. There were 15 people at the
all from our company, Lhasa Transportation Industry Group, but now all of them are missing.
He said the vehicles driven by the 15 drivers were all 29-seat tour buses. At the time,
these vehicles were stationed around Girongpor. Some were there to pick up tourists, while others
were transporting tourists. Suo said he operated tourism routes around Girong last year, but did
not go there this year, allowing him to escape the disaster. He said among the 15 drivers,
seven were Tibetan and eight were Han Chinese. Several of them were from Sichuan. According to
his description, the number of vehicles at the port was far greater than just tour buses. He said
there are many vehicles at the scene, possibly more than 100. There were also trucks and private
cars. This suggests that when the mudslide struck, the area around the port may have been crowded
with workers, drivers, tourists and other travelers. Speaking about the rescue progress,
Suo's voice became noticeably heavier. He said the search and rescue operation has now reached
the central area. Only the Nepalese side has found and rescued some people. On the Chinese
side, not a single person has been found. Suo also described what happened to a fellow villager.
The driver had originally been assigned to go to Girongpor to pick up a tour group,
but he temporarily returned to Lhasa to handle other matters and missed the trip that day. He
said, I don't know what happened, but somehow my fellow villager went back to Lhasa for vehicle
inspection and escaped the disaster. Maybe it was fate. A man from Sichuan named Zheng Hui said
his older brother was an international logistics truck driver who regularly traveled between Lhasa
and Nepal. When the disaster happened, he was waiting near Girongpor for clearance.
Zheng recalled speaking with his brother the day before the disaster. My brother said there were
road collapses in Nepal and he was waiting at the border checkpoint. Then something happened
the next day and I haven't been able to reach him since. That phone call became their final
conversation. Chinese state media reports have focused only on official rescue operations and
leaders' instructions. Reports from independent sources have been deleted. After the border
checkpoint was destroyed, surveillance footage of the disaster could not be shared on platforms
like WeChat. Some analysts say that in China, one of the most heavily monitored countries in
the world, the first response to a disaster is often to suppress information and delay action.
The approach then becomes one of prolonged delay, avoid solving the problem, refusing to
acknowledge the problem, and instead focusing on those who raise questions and the family-seeking
answers. Eventually, after public attention fades, the death toll may quietly be released
This mudslide has exposed the risks created by Beijing's aggressive transformation of the Tibetan
Plateau. For years, the CCP has blasted through mountains, built tunnels, constructed highways,
and developed dams across one of the most fragile landscapes on Earth. The Himalayas are among the
youngest and most geologically active mountain ranges in the world. Tibet is also Asia's water
tower, supplying rivers that support nearly 2 billion people downstream. When Beijing alters
landscapes, builds dams, and changes river systems, the consequences can extend far beyond
China's borders. The mudslide along the Nepal border has sparked criticism that the Chinese
Communist Party has spent years carrying out reckless development, violating natural laws,
and creating man-made disaster. For years, China has been building roads and tunnels through one
of the most fragile mountain ranges on Earth. This involves blasting through rock, cutting into
removing vegetation, and redirecting drainage systems. If these activities are not properly
managed, they are known to increase the risk of landslides. Therefore, when a massive mixture of
ice, rocks, and mud suddenly collapse near a heavily developed border corridor, it is only
responsible to ask whether the construction contributed to the tragedy. The glacier collapse
may have been the immediate trigger, but the CCP can't blame nature every time a mountain collapses.
Nepal deserves an independent investigation into China's blasting activities,
slope modifications, disrupted drainage systems, and environmental oversight. China has exported
its infrastructure model across the Himalayas, and it has also exported the deadly consequences
to neighboring countries like Nepal. Taiwan Artificial Intelligence Lab's founder Du Yijin
recently reviewed aerial footage of the Guirong port before the disaster. In a Facebook post,
the greatest sin of all beings is turning man-made disasters into natural disasters.
If the mouth of a river were built like this in Taiwan, it would not be called a natural disaster.
He said Guirong port was essentially a massive illegal structure built on a river channel,
narrowing the flood passage and encroaching on the river's space.
He said when nature strikes back, disaster is inevitable.
As early as 2018, Tibetan writer Sangye Gyatso, living in exile overseas, warned in an article
that the CCP's large-scale construction of reservoirs, hydropower stations, and intensive
mining operations in Tibet had become a ticking time bomb hanging above the heads of Tibetans.
Lin Tinghui, Deputy Secretary General of the Taiwan Society of International Law,
told media that the Chinese Communist Party has long pushed major construction projects in Tibet
while also building large numbers of military facilities along the China-India border.
The projects involve blasting mountains and carving tunnels,
including hiding aircraft inside mountain caves. Once slopes become unstable,
heavy rain or melting ice could trigger more disasters.
Lin said that since the 7th and 8th centuries, Guirong port had been an important route for
Tang Dynasty envoys and Buddhist monks traveling to India, as well as a key path for Tibetan Buddhism.
For more than a thousand years, the area has never experienced a disaster of this scale.
Yet in recent years, repeated flooding has occurred there.
He said the CCP's atheistic ideology has led it to believe that humans can conquer nature,
but people must respect the forces of nature, or nature will strike back.
The destruction of Guirong port was not an accident. It was a warning,
a preview of what can happen when authoritarian ambition, the exploitation of nature,
and the manipulation of science ultimately collide with the power of nature and the judgment of
history.
