Hours after Kevin Warsh's first Jackson Hole address as Fed chairman, Nobel laureate Paul Krugman gives his read: the speech was hawkish relative to what Warsh had been saying, he stayed firmly with the standard inflation measure after floating alternatives, and he offered nothing to anyone hoping for rate cuts.
Krugman also flags a contradiction he says is sitting in plain sight, between Warsh ruling out unconventional policy at the Fed and what the Treasury is doing with long-term bond purchases. Plus his read on Canada tariffs.
Featuring: Paul Krugman, Nobel Laureate in Economics, author of the Paul Krugman Substack Brooke DiPalma, Yahoo Finance Senior Reporter
Watch the full Warsh speech: [LINK TO THE FULL ASSET]
Timestamps 0:00 What Warsh didn't say was the story 0:40 Why this counted as a hawkish speech 1:10 Nothing here for anyone hoping for cuts 2:16 Stubbornly above target, and what that points to 3:14 Why the task forces are a time-buying move 4:00 The unconventional policy the Fed swore off, and who is doing it 4:52 "We got a generic Fed chairman" 5:53 Why Warsh saying nothing about AI was the right call 7:11 Canada tariffs, and where this stops being ridiculous
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
Paul Krugman analyzes a recent speech by Fed Chair Kevin Warsh, noting that Warsh sounded unexpectedly conventional and hawkish. Krugman highlights the lack of drastic policy shifts, the tension between the Fed's restrictive stance and the Treasury's actions, and the general uncertainty surrounding AI's economic impact and escalating trade tariffs with Canada.
Paul Krugman, thank you so much for being with us this morning.
Really appreciate you taking the time.
As I mentioned just now, we just heard from Fed Chair Kevin Warsh,
and his focus here still seems to be on that high inflation.
What did you make of this comments this morning?
Okay, this is one of those classic,
the important thing is not what he said, but what he didn't say.
You know, in the last couple of months, Warsh has floated,
oh, maybe we need a different measure of inflation, and actually it's okay.
And he didn't.
He was completely firmly on the side of the standard measure,
which is running above target.
So he was not, this was a hawkish speech, at least relative to what he'd been saying before.
He said very little of substance.
I mean, I think for even in the markets,
the difference between forward guidance and reaction function,
and we're watching carefully, is pretty.
I mean, that may affect day-to-day trading, but almost nothing else.
And he did, and there are still five task forces,
which nobody quite knows what the point is, but who cares.
I thought this was, the news here basically was that Warsh sounded utterly conventional.
He did not sound at all like somebody who was going to do something different.
Probably if Trump was hoping he was going to make a case for interest rate cuts,
or even sound slightly more dovish than the rest of the FOMC, he didn't.
So I know, not an exciting speech, but I guess not exciting is good in these circumstances.
Paul, and I think the markets sort of feel the same way.
They're sort of saying, eh, the markets, all three major indices now flat.
We're seeing short-term yields, though, rise because of this fear of higher inflation.
With that being said, though, what do we anticipate?
Was there any sort of read-through of what the Fed's next move was?
Because of the fact that he really emphasized that he's not one to provide forward guidance,
but yet their focus on this higher inflation.
So what does this mean moving forward?
Well, he seemed to be saying, which is kind of what most of the Fed governors,
board members are saying, which is that inflation is stubbornly above target,
which points to continuing restrictive policy to bring it down.
And he actually kind of provided some numbers that suggested that he really does not believe
that this is transitory, that it is underlying, that the majority of items are showing
excessively high price increases.
So this is a kind of a tight money until we see a lot better data of speech.
When you heard what he said about the task force, as you noted, we didn't really hear much.
Maybe we're hoping we would hear more.
He said that they're encouraging, the progress is there, but recommendations will come later.
At what point do you think we're going to hear more about the task force?
And what could those recommendations even be here?
Chris Waller supposedly told him over dinner, what's the point?
Tell me who's on the task forces and I'll tell you what the task forces will say.
I don't think anyone...
Monetary policy has got to be one of the most hashed over policy areas in the world.
It's almost inconceivable that any of these task forces will tell us anything that we
haven't already heard hundreds of times.
So I think that's kind of, he's not giving up on it,
but I think that was basically a time buying move.
And I think he's pretty much given up on that.
So one thing I think is worth saying, though, is that one thing that I think was a little
bit interesting was he said very firmly, the short term interest rate is the tool for monetary
policy, except under exceptional circumstances.
And what is interesting is that if you look at what his counterpart, Scott Besant, is doing,
those long term bond purchases are effectively monetary policy, unconventional monetary policy
being conducted by the Treasury.
So we basically have his, over at the Treasury Department, they're doing what would normally,
effectively, the Treasury is doing quantitative easing.
And so you have Warr saying, we don't do that anymore.
And meanwhile, down the road, that's what they're doing.
Right, right.
And we've seen this sort of tension persist, especially over the last week, as you noted,
with this announcement of the double buyback.
So moving forward, will this tension continue, especially since there's so many unknowns
following this address now?
I mean, I don't, I came away from this basically feeling that, well, it turns out that after
all of the hullabaloo and after all of the fear that Trump was appointing a loyalist or
that Warr was going to do something drastic, I mean, he didn't even say anything about
shrinking the balance sheet.
You know, that was his big thing, was that the Fed needs to back off the consequences
of quantitative easing, you know, years ago.
And he didn't say, unless I missed it, he didn't say a word about that.
So this was basically, we got a generic Fed chairman, which, by the way, I think is fine.
That's what we wanted.
One thing that was also sort of a question mark, Paul, is the impact of AI.
He sort of put into question, OK, will it be significant?
What will lead to productivity?
What do you think we expect here?
Because that also was something that maybe had people a little bit excited that Kevin
Warsh would be more vocal about the impact of artificial intelligence.
But it seems like even he's uncertain about the impact of that on the economy.
Yeah, I mean, he actually, he says something intelligent, which is basically we don't know
what the hell is happening.
So in the past, he's been saying, oh, you know, we don't need to worry about inflation
because AI will produce this wonderful productivity boom, which might happen, might not.
He did say it's boosting investment, which is actually slightly a hawkish statement.
But basically, he said very little.
I mean, he talked about how great it is and how secular stagnation seems to be over.
But he didn't make any confident pronouncements about what AI is going to do, which I have
to say is very much the path of wisdom here.
You know, this stuff is, I mean, I read and I'm sure everybody else does enormous amounts
about AI.
And my basic take on it now is tell me what you want to believe and you can find an expert
who will tell you that.
So his agnosticism on AI was actually encouraging.
Paul, really quickly, there's so much uncertainty within geopolitics right now.
But now the latest is this announcement on tariffs on Canada, Canada putting tariffs
on us.
What is the expectation of the impact that that will have on broader businesses here
in the US?
Well, it really depends on how far this goes.
I mean, so far, the tariffs, although they're nasty and they're disruptive, they're only
applying to a relatively small amount of trade.
Now, if the stuff goes forward, I mean, if you take the full list of what Trump is threatening
and what the Canadians are threatening to retaliate, it basically destroys the US auto
industry.
You know, so this could be very serious.
So far, mostly, I mean, so far, if I can say the ridiculous outweighs the substantive.
You know, if Trump just restricts himself to renaming Lake Ontario, then it's not such
a bad thing.
But who knows how far this goes?
Lots of question marks after that meeting.
Lots of question marks around the Canada tariffs.
Paul Krugman, Nobel laureate in economics and author of the Paul Krugman Substack.
Thank you so much for being with us this morning.
Thank you.