Supergirl Movie Review . The latest DC comic book movie in the James Gunn cinematic universe. I give you my spoiler free review breakdown and reaction. Supergirl Review
This review of the DCU's *Supergirl* describes a mediocre film that fails to fully realize the potential of the *Woman of Tomorrow* comic. While the casting of Millie Alcock and Jason Momoa is highly praised, the movie is criticized for its generic villain, disjointed action, and derivative style, ultimately landing in a \"cursed middle ground\" that may contribute to superhero genre fatigue.
Supergirl is now the second movie in James Gunn's DC Universe.
In this film, we are of course following Supergirl, Kara Zor-El, played by Millie Alcock, who is
celebrating her 23rd birthday.
She's passing the time going to planets with red suns just to get drunk until she comes
across a little girl named Ruthie who begs for her help to get revenge on a man who murdered
her family.
And that's all pretty much it.
I don't have any spoilers for you guys.
This will be a spoiler-free review.
Okay, Supergirl, the second movie into the DCU.
This is of course not the slate I thought or had in mind, and you know, being completely
honest with you, whenever they announced Supergirl as one of the next films in this universe,
I wasn't jumping up and down excited, but whenever James Gunn had announced, you know,
it would be based off the Woman of Tomorrow comic, well, bought it on Amazon or read it
that weekend, and I was like, oh, okay, I see why this would be a great idea for a movie.
It totally is a reinvention of what most people see, the Supergirl character.
It's not just a female mirrored version of Clark Kent, an innocent, happy-go-lucky girl
that also just happens to have Superman's powers.
There is something more deeper, complex, and interesting about her.
In the Woman of Tomorrow comic, she got to be raised on Krypton for a good chunk of her
life, experience her culture, and then see it all die slowly before her eyes.
It makes her a darker and more broken person than Clark Kent, and I think that leads for
an interesting movie to tell.
So when looking at the trailers for the movie, everything seemed right up the alley.
The only qualms I had was it didn't feel as colorful or vibrant as the comic book, but
if anything, that's a complaint we can say about every movie nowadays.
They all just feel like they have a gray filter over them.
In the end, I just wanted another good movie in the DCU so that we can continue getting
excited for the next project.
I sat down, watched it, I'm growing a bit weary of the DCU now.
I really do feel Supergirl has all the right ingredients to make it a great, heck, even
amazing film.
In fact, even with just what it does present, there'll be enough there for I think a decent
amount of people to walk out happy, but man, it did not pack the punch I was hoping for.
I did leave Supergirl slightly underwhelmed.
I mean, in a thumbs up, thumbs down world, I'm still gonna give it like a, oh, it's good
because there's nothing offensively bad about the movie.
This isn't like a disaster or something where it's like, oh, dude, this is over, but it's
that cursed middle ground that I feel sometimes might be even worse than just a straight up
bad movie, where we get a film that I think sometimes is responsible for the fatigue we're
feeling in the superhero genre, where it just comes out feeling average.
So average, there's nothing that exciting to talk about, and also not even nothing that
negative to talk about, and you're just kind of like, it was all right, I was okay, I mean,
I passed the time with it.
I feel like that is almost a bigger death sentence than a movie just being bad.
Is that just me?
Am I exaggerating here?
But I don't want to be all doom and gloom.
I think there are fun things in here and little nuggets that paint a brighter direction for
some characters I'm excited to see in Like Man of Tomorrow.
So starting off with the good before I get into things I'm more mixed on is, yes, I do
think Millie Alcock is great.
I really hadn't seen much of Millie Alcock's acting before this movie because I wasn't
much of a Game of Thrones or House of Dragons person, so I didn't have much to go off of,
but I do like this portrayal of Supergirl.
I think that's such an interesting and unique direction for the character, and honestly,
all those aspects of her backstory and the flashbacks we get, to me, that was some of
the most engaging parts of this movie.
It really had the elements, and like I was saying, ingredients for this to be an emotionally
and impactful film.
Seeing where she came from, what happens to Krypton, why she feels a little bit more broken
and isn't as happy-go-lucky as her cousin, Clark.
I like when those elements of Carl were being explored.
Just like in the Woman of Tomorrow comic, she develops a relationship with this little
girl named Ruthie who just really wants someone to help her get revenge, and their dynamic
is good enough.
I wish it was a little stronger, but there is this great arc where Supergirl just really
warns her about the dangers of fulfilling your revenge and what that could do to your
heart, to your soul, and I also like that because although Supergirl has really no interest
in really being a big superhero or being a symbol of hope, she hasn't completely abandoned
a lot of her morals, and she knows what it's like to be in a dark, sinister place, and
she doesn't want to wish that upon anybody else, and if she can save them from that,
she will do her best to do that.
Aside from Ruthie and Millie Alcock, we also have appearances throughout the movie from
two pretty big characters.
One, David Cornsweat Superman.
You've seen him a bit in the trailers, but he's actually scattered throughout the movie
in flashbacks quite a bit where you actually have a decent enough presence of him, and
man, just the little moments of David Cornsweat, I am still so on board with his interpretation
of Superman.
I think that's one thing the DCU is getting right, whether you feel strongly one way or
another about the movies themselves, the way they're portraying the stories, and even certain
story details, I think casting-wise and what they're trying to emulate from these characters
is coming off in the right way, because although I've walked away feeling slightly underwhelmed
with elements of this movie, and I didn't connect to it as much as I wanted to, I am
excited to see Millie Alcock as Supergirl show up in the next Superman movie, Man of
Tomorrow, which is confirmed, and James Gunn already said he's got a couple of scenes with
her filmed.
I want to see that, and I want to see more of their interactions as cousins.
Heck, even today, a lot of people were buzzing online because James Gunn posted a little
story of Wonder Woman in what appears to be Supergirl, hinting that maybe the Wonder
Woman movie will feature Kara as a supporting character, and I'm like, okay, I definitely
would see that.
And I guess speaking of character portrayals, I think that they're doing a good job with
a big one a lot of people were anticipating is Jason Momoa as Lobo.
Another character that's scattered throughout gets a good amount of screen time for you
to really feel them, and I already like him as Lobo way more than I ever liked him as
Aquaman.
It just fits Jason Momoa's personality so much more, and I think he gave me the biggest
laughs in the movie.
He was definitely somebody I was enjoying every second of.
I'm still not quite sure if I would fully watch a movie of just Jason Momoa as Lobo.
I know they're trying to gear that up, and heck, sometimes elements of this movie feels
like testing the waters of like, okay, do people like Lobo enough to give him a film?
Part of me feels like he works so well in this because of the sparing amount of time
we got with him and him breaking some of that serious tension, because heck, that's another
benefit in this movie.
I feel like this movie does have a better balance in handling the serious dark stuff
and balancing that out with some jokes.
You know, there's this kind of insignificant character voiced by Seth Rogen, it's a little
alien, and that had me laughing a lot in the movie, but a lot of it is handled seriously
and it lets you breathe in those serious moments with Kara and her backstory, and it's just
elements I appreciated, because sometimes it feels like comic book movies don't want
to let you sit in with the sad moments.
And it's going to be that type of stuff that I think for casual viewers of superhero movies
or people who just want to know, like, okay, what's Supergirl about?
This, I think, will have enough in it for them to walk out going, oh, that kind of surprised
me.
I wasn't expecting that.
I didn't know that's how they would do Supergirl, because I will admit, I think if you have
no expectation whatsoever, this movie will come out surprising you, and maybe that's
one of the reasons I felt underwhelmed or disappointed is because I did read The Woman
of Tomorrow comic, and some of the elements and choices and things that they do to adapt
it just felt very off, leading me now to some of the things I'm mixed to negative about.
Okay, I really hate to say it, because I was getting the vibes when watching the trailer,
but I thought, no, it's just marketing.
When watching the movie, I could not help to feel the Guardian of the Galaxy vibes this
film was trying to emulate.
There's just so much iconography that I think if you took scenes out of context and said,
oh, these are deleted scenes from the Guardians of the Galaxy movies, you would totally buy
into it.
And it's not just little things.
I mean, I think Craig Gillespie really thought, oh, James Gunn is hiring me for this movie,
he must want it to be like how he does his superhero movies, because at times it really
does give off Timu Guardians of the Galaxy.
I mean, such visual iconographies that this movie copies is like when Peter Quill is in
space and is getting crystallized to the orange headphones, the needle drops with the music,
which this movie shows you how brilliant sometimes James Gunn is at picking the music to match
the scenes, because the songs here, when they drop with the action, they don't hit the same
way.
I mentioned that this movie had all the right ingredients, and I truly feel that it just
wasn't presented or delivered in a way that I felt packed that punch.
There is an emotional backstory with Kara, and we get elements of it, but those scenes
did not hit the way they should have.
I felt what the movie was trying to go for, but I could just never meet it all the way.
I think a lot of that is because of the biggest downside of this movie, and that's the generic
villain, Kramp.
Looking at the comic book counterpart and what they did for the movies, I have no idea
why we even have to do this visual, exaggerated, grotesque-looking villain.
If you just write a good villain, you don't have to make them look also physically disgusting.
I just felt he was easily the most forgettable and bland part of this.
Part of the movie is wanting to be excited for the villain, and they do things that sometimes
just feel like shock value to show how evil he is, but it was so cartoony, I could never
feel attached to the villain side of the story.
I don't know if it was also just me, but I just felt sometimes the way the movie was
also edited, especially in its action scenes, really just made the film come off so disjointed.
There are moments where the action scenes kind of feel unique or different, like there's
this teleporting thing that happens within a bus and some alien device, and especially
in the final battle, it really tries to showcase what Kara is capable of as Supergirl, but
again, some of that is weighed down by the visual style, which is just a bunch of gray
smoke everywhere and the awful needle drop that does not match the moment well.
It really just made me come out thinking I think Craig Gillespie was the wrong choice
as director here.
He has some great movies under his belt, no doubt, but he's never directed a big blockbuster
action film like this, and I just don't think he had his own unique visual for this.
Instead, he was trying to emulate what he's seen from James Gunn, and I think that hurt
it.
This movie redone, maybe with a different director, I'm surprised it wasn't a female
director, maybe could have actually given this movie a lot more weight, made it feel
more impactful, because like I said, all the elements, emotional beats, backstory, character
arcs is there for this to have been an above average superhero film, but what is currently
presented just made it average, and again, it's that thing where this is not good for
the DCU.
I'm not saying it's all over and we should be panicking after this one when we know,
I'm saying if every movie is this average, this generic, this walk away feeling of, that
was fine, there's not going to be that excitement for more, to want to draw up people going
to the theater and all that.
I still think this movie will definitely find its crowd, and enough people will come out
praising it, because like I said, there's nothing atrocious or wrong about it.
Heck, even like turning the tables a little bit for me, I kind of felt that way with Blue
Beetle, where in the end that was kind of an average superhero film that had a lot of
similar elements we'd seen in other things from like an Iron Man or the early Ant-Man
movie, but overall I was happy with what the movie gave me, and I think this will be that
for some people, unfortunately Supergirl just didn't have that big hit I wanted.
For anyone else also curious, I am going to do a spoiler review, but I don't know how
long of a spoiler review that is, because it's a very standalone story with just minor
little like offhand lines that could be dissected and explored for bigger DCU, there are no
post credit scenes, but they just tagged it on instead as the final scene of the movie
and now the film has no post credit scenes.
So in the end, even though I just came out feeling fine with the movie, I'm still looking
forward to Man of Tomorrow, whatever else they have next in the DCU, I just hope they
can learn from this and also for whenever Supergirl pops up next in the universe.
So I'm looking at Supergirl, I'm going to give action 3.5 stars, I was actually kind
of underwhelmed by the action scenes, a lot of it felt very generic, I wasn't a huge fan
of the way they were edited and shot.
The final action scene is probably the highlight, but again it's taken down by some of the visual
style and the needle drop, but it really did lack that visual flair I was hoping it would
have.
Comedy in the movie, I'm going to give it 2.5 stars, I think a lot of that comes from
Lobo and that Seth Rogen alien, but it's a film that's trying to be more serious than
comedic.
Drama in the film, I'm going to give it 3 stars, it honestly should have been a stronger
story with the material they were working on from Woman of Tomorrow, they did make some
changes from the material that I'm not a huge fan of, and I really do think it's some of
those changes that led to a lesser impact in my feeling towards Supergirl's emotional
hook.
And suspense in the movie, I'm going to give it 2 stars, I think with just a generic villain,
you don't feel that attached to the struggle and threat.
When looking at the 3 C's, honestly this is a film where casuals are going to get the
most enjoyment, where cinephiles are just going to recognize some of the familiar tropes
either from Guardian movies or other superhero films where it just feels very generic and
average.
Critics I think are going to be equally harsh on that, and I'm curious to see what the overall
reception is, because again, the film's not terrible, but I don't know how much word of
mouth is going to be made on this one.
So when it comes to Supergirl, although I had a finite enough time, and I still recommend
you check it out just to get Kara Zor-El because of the future she'll have in the DCU, I think
it's one you can wait to rent at home.
That'll do, Duncan.
That'll do.
Again, just my opinion, I'm happy to hear from you guys if you were someone that ended
up loving it or are really high on the film.
We'll definitely talk spoilers once the movie's released.
But throwing it off to you guys, how are you feeling about Supergirl, are you still excited
for it?
Don't forget to like, subscribe, comment here at 3C Films, or on TikTok at 3C Films, but
as always, I'm Chris, take care.