California Attorney General Bonta Talks About Meta Settlement

Live News Network
1.4K followers
7 Video Views·Aug 26, 2026
California Attorney General Rob Bonta holds a press conference on Aug. 26 on the proposed settlement with Meta.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Good morning, everyone. We'll just wait a few more seconds for folks to get into the room.
And good morning, everybody. Rob Bonta, California Attorney General. Thank you
for joining me this morning. I am pleased to announce that our multi-state,
bipartisan coalition has reached a proposed settlement with MEDA that, if entered by the
court, resolves the claims of our case and institutes real change, real transparency,
real protections for children and teens across the country that will be implemented
over the coming months. MEDA has agreed to make significant changes that will reduce
the risk of harm that Instagram and Facebook pose to teen users. Daily time limits and blocks on
nighttime use that can only be lifted by a parent, limits on notifications during school hours
and overnight, an end to displaying the number of likes on a teen's post, a ban on plastic
surgery filters, enhanced detection and removal of kids under 13 from these platforms, and more.
A whole suite of protections to reduce the harm that we know children were suffering from over
the last number of years. This is a significant victory for families across the country, for
parents, for children, for those who are suffering in silence and those who are suffering in public.
This is a major breakthrough, a milestone moment, a watershed moment, because when it comes to
protecting our children's mental health, there is no time to lose. Instead of getting tied up in
years of trials and appeals, we have secured the changes we were after. It's also telling that
MEDA settled midway through Instagram president Adam Mosseri's testimony, and before CEO Mark
Zuckerberg could take the stand. I want to double click on the details of this agreement, but
before I do, I'd like to thank the bipartisan coalition of 51 attorneys general who stood
together to hold the social media giant accountable to the law and the harm it's created.
Bipartisan isn't something you hear too often these days. It speaks to the fact that protecting
our children isn't and should not be political. It's a priority. It's our duty. It's a North Star
for us. I also want to express my gratitude to the members of California DOJ's consumer protection
section who have worked tirelessly on this case for years, head down, sleeves rolled up, just
getting the work done from the investigation to filing the complaint to discovery and to a
powerhouse performance at trial starting last week that I couldn't be more proud of. Our team,
I'm biased, I know, but our team did very, very well and made me very, very proud, and the trial
did not go well for MEDA. These extraordinary public servants have dedicated so much to this
case, and it shows. I know some of them are on fumes today, needing a little more sleep,
and I know and hope they'll get it soon, but I couldn't be more proud of the collaborative effort
from my team, from teams across the country, from a bipartisan set of attorneys general
holding MEDA accountable and delivering for our children, our parents, and our families.
To briefly recap, we sued MEDA over claims that it designed and deployed harmful features on
Instagram and Facebook that drive compulsive use and harm young users' mental health,
and that the company knew about these dangers and lied to teens, to parents, and to the public
about them. We believe the proposed settlement filed today addresses some of the concerns at
the core of our lawsuit and that it will force transformative changes necessary to protect
our children. And importantly, these changes will be made within months, no more waiting.
For all users under 18, MEDA has agreed to set a default daily time limit of two hours that will
drop to one hour if other social media platforms agree to similar terms, set a default block
between midnight and 6 a.m. when our children should be sleeping, not scrolling, set a default
block on notifications between 10 p.m. and 7 a.m. and during the school day, again, when our
children should be sleeping and studying, not scrolling. The company will create an enhanced
mechanism for teens to report potentially harmful content and has agreed to respond to 90 percent of
those reports within six hours. MEDA will set a default ban on displaying the number of likes
or reactions to posts and a ban on cosmetic procedure filters,
plastic surgery filters, and it will have an option for users to choose a non-personalized
feed, meaning a feed that doesn't use an algorithm to target them with content aimed to keep them
endlessly scrolling. Those are some of the changes to the platforms. MEDA has also agreed to maintain,
review, and improve existing teen content safety measures and will create enhanced
parent supervision tools. It will institute robust age assurance measures to detect users
under 18, and it will develop ways to identify and remove kids under 13 from their platforms
entirely. MEDA will bring on an independent auditor with expansive access to information
and resources, regular reporting, and the right to communicate with our offices. That's critical
to us to maintain accountability, oversight, and make sure that MEDA delivers on all of these
legal commitments. Finally, MEDA will be subject to an injunction prohibiting it from making further
false, misleading, or deceptive statements around its safety features. In addition to platform and
policy changes, MEDA has agreed to pay the states joining this agreement up to 17 billion dollars
over 10 years. California alone will receive 1.5 billion to 2.1 billion dollars if this settlement
is approved by the court. How the majority of this money will be spent will ultimately be decided by
the legislature and the governor, but it is earmarked in the proposed settlement for purposes
related to the prevention or remediation of mental health or other harms to young Californians
associated with social media use. From the beginning, this case has been about protecting
young people, our children, our future, online. The data is clear. More time on social media tends
to be correlated with depression, anxiety, body image issues, susceptibility to addiction,
and interference with daily life, including learning. If you're a parent like I am, or a
guardian, or a teacher, or a health care provider, sadly you've likely seen some of that play out in
real life. We protect our children from so many daily dangers, but we can't adequately protect
them from harms MEDA hides and lies about, or from designs that are built to suck our children in.
With this settlement, that is changing. In the coming months, our children and teens will be
safer on Instagram and on Facebook. As big as MEDA is, it doesn't stand alone. We're continuing our
fight across social media, including our litigation against TikTok, and we'll continue to demand
better from all parts of this industry through our ongoing work with the legislature, our defense of
SB 976, California's social media algorithmic harms bill, from continuing industry challenges,
and through our enforcement work under California's existing consumer protection and privacy laws.
We'll continue to do all we can to ensure our children are safe online, no matter what platform
they log into. I urge other companies to take note that our door is open. I've said it before,
and I'll say it again. I'm always willing to come to the table for honest, good-faith negotiations.
I'd much rather work with California's business community than have to take them to court.
We want innovative companies to continue to grow in our state, contribute to our economy,
advance our nation, and employ our people. We just expect them to follow the law as they do.
Innovation isn't a free pass to do as you please and hurt our people along the way.
At the end of the day, the mission is simple, protect Californians and uphold California law,
and to stand with California children, teens, and parents when companies put them in harm's way.
If we have to go to trial to do so, we absolutely will. I'm glad that with this proposed settlement,
we were able to find common ground, and if we receive court approval, secure the wins
California sought to protect our children for years to come. Before I open it to questions,
I want to again recognize the individuals on my team who stood up for California families and
children. They aren't here for the glory, and I'm sure I'm about to embarrass them,
but they deserve the accolades, and I want to give them the credit that they deserve.
Megan O'Neill, Josh Olszewski-Jubiler, Neha Arora, Casey Reed, Sam Beckett, Pauline Ryan,
Jordi Hefkart, David Beglin, Jake Fernandez, Robbie Mattson, Michael Kosang, Emily Kalanithi,
Barney Eskandari, Tina Cherenpong, and Nick Akers. An incredible team working overtime to deliver
amazing results for our children, for our families, for our state, our country, and our future. Thank
you to each and every one of them for their incredible work. With that, I am happy to answer
your questions. If you'd like to ask a question, you may do so by hitting the raise hand icon at
the bottom of the screen. You can also submit questions through the Q&A feature. Please state
your publication when we call on you. First question comes from Ethan. You're now unmuted.
Hi, I'm from, it's Ethan Barron from Mercury News. Thanks. So you mentioned this addressed
some of the issues of concern here. What did you compromise on with this deal and what still needs
to be done? I don't think we compromised on anything here, but there's always more to do.
This is a really strong down payment, if you will, on protecting our kids. It is transformative.
It is a watershed moment. It is a milestone mark. Mostly what needs to be done is getting similar
protections across the industry with TikTok, with YouTube, with Snap. Meta is a major player,
and this is an incredible result, but there's others that need to follow suit. And again,
we're happy to talk in the boardroom to get to those results, or we can see folks in the courtroom
as well. But there is a symmetry, if you will, a matching, if you will, between the claims that
we were making in court and the remedies that we could have secured and what we've secured in this
settlement. The night block, the block on notifications during school hours and at night,
the limit on duration, two hours or one hour if other industry players come on board, that
is in perfect symmetry and harmony with what we were seeking in court. So this is an outstanding
constellation of protections. But there's always more to be done, and this is an ongoing effort
that policymakers, AGs, and others will be part of for some time to come. But this is a breakthrough.
This is a milestone. This is transformative, and we're proud of what we've accomplished today.
Thanks. So are we to take it that you didn't give up anything to get to this agreement?
Well, it depends on what you mean by that. We are always measuring our settlement results with our
potential litigation results, not with respect to maybe what you're suggesting, which is
everything possible under the sun. Are there other things possible under the sun? Yes.
Are there things that we could have got better in our litigation? No. This is an amazing result.
So when you say compromise measured against what we could get in litigation, we got the things that
we could have got in litigation, and I'd say more. So the opposite of compromise. We, if you will,
overperformed in our settlement and delivered more results to children and families and
parents across the country than we could have got potentially in our litigation.
But are there more things to do under the sun? Yes. And we'll continue to do those things.
Thank you. Next question comes from Maria. You're now unmuted.
Hi. Can you talk a bit more about the phase two restrictions and contingent payments? I'm very
interested in the other companies, Snap, TikTok, and YouTube. It seems that there are provisions
of the agreement that appear to contemplate them accepting substantially similar restrictions.
So have these companies already committed to those terms, or are there some talks going on with those
other social media companies? So there is a built-in design, as you mentioned, that's really
important to us in this proposed settlement agreement with Meta that we hope the court will
approve, that contemplate industry-wide solutions and their potential, and frankly, the desire and
the intent to have those industry-wide solutions. And so there are some restrictions. One example
is the limit of two hours of use per day. If that applies to just Meta,
then it remains two hours. But if other industry players make commitments similar to what
Meta has made here, then the commitment, the restriction, ratchets up to one hour per day.
And that is the hope, that we will be able to get these heightened protections, these
more significant commitments that they will kick in for Meta if and when we are able to secure
commitments and agreements from other industry players. So I'm not going to comment on any
current potential or even whether there are discussions with other players, but I will say,
because this is public, we have a lawsuit against TikTok. We're going to be putting more time and
attention and focus on that. We've already put everything that's needed and necessary, but
with the momentum that we've built, the success that we've secured here, we will be focusing on
rest of the industry. This is an industry-wide problem. Meta is part of the industry, a major
player in the industry, but there's a bigger ecosystem that we will not be satisfied until
we address all of the problems in the entire industry. So we are going to focus on TikTok.
We are going to focus on Snap. We're already focusing on them to some degree. We're very
concerned about YouTube. So my hope and my belief is that we will see commitments across the industry
and then the sort of phase two, tier two, the ratcheting up of commitments and
conditions that are contemplated in the settlement agreement format, that those will kick in
as others in the industry also make similar commitments.
Thank you. Next question comes from Elizabeth. You're now unmuted.
Thank you so much for doing this. I guess just big picture, do you see this as a big tobacco
moment for tech? We've talked a lot about the stakes here and how much do you look at this
kind of big picture with other litigations still going forward against Meta and other companies
and the fact that there are still lots of outstanding, as you just mentioned,
lawsuits against TikTok and others, even against Meta too, and they're vowing to keep fighting.
Thank you. I know there's quite a bit of interest in drawing this comparison with tobacco. I think
there are some similarities. There are also some limits to those similarities. I do think
just stepping back, regardless of whether it's analogous to tobacco or not, this is a major
moment to clean up an industry that has been hurting our kids. And so in the way that the
impact of the solutions delivered in tobacco were good for health, good for kids,
good for Californians and Americans, this is similar. It's great for children and families
and parents who've been suffering. It's similar in that fact that it's a number of AGs banding
together, asserting ourselves, exerting our authority, demanding better, requiring accountability
and enforcing the law and delivering results. It's similar in that way. It's similar in the way that
Congress hasn't been delivering and has left a vacuum and a gap so that the state AGs stepped
in to deliver. It's similar in that it deals with public health, different issues, but public health
issues broadly. So yeah, there are some similarities, but I think there's probably
also some limits to those similarities. I think the most important thing to focus on here,
whether it's similar to tobacco or not, is this is transformative. This is momentous. This is a
major step forward in the ongoing quest and journey to make sure that our children are safe
everywhere, including online. And, you know, I got to just take a moment to say I
have heard from many parents as we brought this case this morning,
and, you know, with gratitude, but also relief. I think they feel safer today. I think they feel
seen today. I think they feel protected today. I think they feel more confident in the future
of their children. I think a lot of them are worrying and have been concerned about what's
happening to their kid online, what MEDA has been visiting upon them and imposing on them and the
harm that they are suffering from. I've had a number of AGs reach out to me and sort of take
off their AG hat and just say, this is a big deal as a mom, as a dad. And I feel the same way.
You know, I'm the AG of California, honored and grateful for that. But the most important title
I'll ever have is dad to my kids. And I am, as a dad, thankful that our AGs came together to
deliver this. So I want to put it in those terms. It's transformative for moms and dads and for
kids and for families. And, you know, for the mental health of the most precious thing on our
planet, our kids. Next question comes from Chris. You're now unmuted. Hey, can you hear me?
Gotcha. Thank you very much. It's Chris Woodward, the center square.
Congrats on the settlement. Can you tell us what California may be doing with any money it receives
from MEDA? Yeah. And again, high 1 billion plus to 2 point something plus, depending on what other
members of the industry do. And it'll be not surprising what we do with that money. It's
generally going to be used to what we call it, usually abatement and mitigation efforts to
address the problem of social media harms to the mental health of children. So it will help reduce
the harm to children, help address those mental health issues that I've talked about from anxiety
and depression to body image issues to addictive tendencies to learning loss. We will be addressing
the underlying problem here, which has always been with the money, which has always been the focus
of this case, the mental health harms of kids and helping make sure our kids are safe and healthy
and protected. Next question comes from Mike. You are now unmuted. Hi, thanks for taking my
question. It's Mike Swift at Emlex. Could you talk a little bit about the $17 billion figure?
It seems a little arbitrary. How did you get to that number? What was the formula for it? And
secondly, could you talk a little bit about the settlement negotiations? It seems like the trial
has been going really badly for MEDA the last two days to my eyes. And just wondering if that brought
them to the table or if this is something that's been close to resolution for a long time.
Sure. So the $17 billion is, again, a secondary but important component of the settlement. We
have always been focused on, we will always be focused on the injunctive relief, the changes
in business conduct, the reduction in business practices that hurt kids. And we've delivered,
and then some in multiple ways, from the beauty filters to the likes that were ending, to the
night blocks, to the blocks on notifications during school hours and nighttime, the reduction
for daily use. All those are really the heart and the core of the settlement.
And then there's the $17 billion that is going to be spread across the 51 states and the District
of Columbia and territories. And it is an unprecedentedly high number. It is historic.
It is, I think, the highest financial payment of its kind, way higher than opioids,
higher than what the EU secured. So while secondary, it is also very significant. And we
wanted to make sure that there was appropriate funding paid for by MEDA to address the harms
that MEDA created. MEDA created the harms, MEDA should help pay for the mitigation, for the
programs that will address mental health harms to kids. And it will go out to each of the states
through a formula. So it is important that it be significant. And $17 billion is historically high
and very significant. So we're grateful for that component of the settlement agreement,
but it is not the focus. The focus is the injunctive relief, the changes to business
practices going forward that will reduce the mental health harms to kids. And yeah, I think
for anyone who's got eyeballs and is paying attention, the trial is not going well for MEDA.
And that is not dissimilar from how other trials have gone. I think ours went particularly well
for us and particularly bad for them, given the incredible talent of my team and our collaborative
team of AGs from across the country. But having Instagram president, Adam Masseri,
giving testimony as we settled was not random. I think they were dying to have him get off the
stand. It was not going well for him after already devastating and damaging testimony by other
witnesses, including a whistleblower who worked inside of MEDA and knew exactly what they were
doing and also what they didn't do, having knowledge about the harm that their products
created for kids. So settlements take time. And this is obviously multiple states, the District
of Columbia, territories working with MEDA. And we are always happy to explore potential outcomes
through settlement, if they meet our lofty standards, if they get the job done,
if they deliver on what we're looking for, or we can get it through trial. And here we were
sort of on a dual path where we were in trial, as you know, putting major witnesses on the stand,
having Zuckerberg around the corner to be called. But we were also exploring settlement and we were
able to deliver through settlement in an incredible way that it was beyond what we could
have gotten through trial. So we're grateful for how this all turned out with what we're delivering
for kids and families and parents across the country. Thank you. Next question comes from Ian.
Hi, thanks for doing this. Kind of just to follow on from that, you obviously had the
verdicts from the juries in the other cases in the spring, and then you had this ruling from
the judge in New Mexico pretty recently. How much did those outcomes kind of change the dynamics
and open the door to a settlement and just sort of show that it was possible to win that trial
and that maybe there was another door that MEDA might want to take here?
Sure. You have to ask them that question to really get an answer. But from where I sit,
you can't ignore the major defeats that occurred in a short period of time leading up to our major
federal trial involving multiple states across the country. They took a major hit in Los Angeles,
a major hit in New Mexico with my colleague in New Mexico delivering that, and they got a chance to
see what juries thought about their witnesses and their defenses. They got a chance to see
how Instagram president Adam Masseri and CEO Mark Zuckerberg performed on the stand or perhaps
didn't perform so well. So they got a chance to turn theory and hypotheticals into reality and
see how they did in our court of law where justice and accountability are delivered by juries and
judges. And so I don't see how that wasn't in the back of their mind when they started the trial in
our case, but every trial is different. And if we weren't prepared and didn't have our case tight
and didn't have our arguments sharp and weren't ready to hold them accountable in court,
then any case could be different. This case could have been their bounce back where they started
defensing cases and started winning and could have turned things around. But because of the talent
and commitment, preparation, and readiness of my team, I think the trial was heading towards
probably their worst performance that they've seen in a court of law. And settlement is always
informed by the ongoing litigation. And if you're having a bad day or every day is a bad day for you
in trial, that is going to affect settlement. So I think we had a wind at our back. We had a lot
of momentum that we created with our preparation in our case and with our incredible performances
at trial that helped lead to this very important, significant milestone result.
Next question comes from Cecilia. You're now unmuted. You have to unmute yourself as well.
Thank you so much, AG Bonta. So you used the words historic watershed landmark.
Certainly the company, Amedda, began its many lawsuits on social media addiction with
guns a-blazing. They're very confident that when they talked a lot about the defense of Section 230,
this feels like a legal breakthrough as well. Would you characterize it that way in the sense that
the legal arguments were COPPA and consumer protection laws with the states, and then
the tort law on personal injury? So it's kind of like a get-around of this legal shield that's
protected the whole industry. Can you talk a little bit about that and the importance of
how this settlement perhaps breaks through of what has been a pretty impenetrable
shield liability-wise for Amedda and the other companies?
I have another, but let's start with that. Thank you.
Sure. Section 230 and the First Amendment have been sort of defenses that
Amedda has often gone to, and they remain the laws of our country. Section 230 is a federal
statute. The First Amendment obviously is in our U.S. Constitution. It's not going anywhere.
Section 230 and the First Amendment were advanced by Amedda in this case as defenses,
and they had a role to play in this case. I don't want to overstate where the First Amendment
as a defense and Section 230 have gone. They still have ongoing durability, and I think Amedda will
go to those defenses again. But even given those defenses, we have delivered this result.
We overcame them, got to trial, put witnesses on the stand, revealed the dangerousness of the
products, the knowledge of those dangers by Amedda, and they're lying to the public about it.
We made our case despite those defenses, and we put Amedda in a place where
they made the commitments that they made in the settlement. You don't do that if you think you're
going to defense the case on First Amendment grounds or on Section 230 grounds. But this
case is a settlement. I just want to be clear about that. It is not a court order that is
interpreting Section 230 and the First Amendment in some new or different way.
It doesn't have presidential value that will govern how Section 230 and the First Amendment
are seen throughout the country. Those remain ongoing issues and challenges. But I think the
biggest point to be made here is that Section 230 and the First Amendment are not impenetrable
shields to holding Amedda accountable. We demonstrated that today. Our settlement shows
that. They advanced Section 230. They put up that shield and hid behind it and said,
you can't touch us. And we said, we see it differently. We think we can. And we did.
So I think it shows the limits of Section 230 and the First Amendment in delivering
and the ability of the people, children, families who've been harmed by Amedda's conduct
to deliver justice and accountability. But I don't want to overstate it either. Section
230 and the First Amendment remain defenses that are available to Amedda and others in the future.
But we do believe that they are not invincible shields for seeking and securing justice,
and we believe we can continue to build on the momentum that we've started today.
Great. And sorry, just the last thing I wanted to ask you,
AG, is that sort of the setup of the settlement in terms of the different phases and contingency
upon whether other social media companies settle as well, that's interesting to me. Did you set
out with an industry-wide solution in mind? Amedda uses the word in their press release
that they've been partnering with you. Would you agree with that? I guess just trying to get a
sense of how this came to be, this sort of ostensibly unusual settlement in terms of
these contingencies. Thank you. Yeah. I think the terminology is maybe contextual. If we're in court
in this litigation, we're not partnering. We are very much their adversary, the opposing party.
We are the plaintiff suing them to seek justice and to secure a remedy that addresses the harms
that they visited on our children. So that is not partnering when we're in the courtroom,
when we're in trial, when we're taking President Adam Masseri to task and putting on our other
witnesses. That is adversarial by design. Litigation is an adversarial process where
opposing parties come to court and with the help, assistance of a judge and a jury to
arrive at justice. But when you're settling, there is a level of partnership. You have to
talk to each other. You have to be professional. You have to discuss ideas and land on agreed upon
outcomes. And so there is, I suppose, a level of partnership that is inherent in the settlement
negotiation process. And that led to the final settlement. If MEDA was disagreeing and disagreeable
about everything that we wanted, we wouldn't have this settlement. They agreed. And so there is a
set of common ground. I mean, they didn't agree voluntarily out of the goodness of their heart.
We had a trial where we were hammering them. We had a litigation and a trial verdict hanging over
their head, which was not going well for them. So I think agreement or partnering may be in the
eye of the beholder. But to your point about the design, I think MEDA probably has a view
about the industry and an observation about the industry that's true that we have, which is that
MEDA, while they are a major player in the industry and they have visited enormous mental
health harms on kids through their products and their designs, they are not the only player in
the industry doing so. And others rightfully must be held accountable. And so this
proposed settlement agreement that we hope and believe will be approved by the judge
contemplates that, steps back and isn't just wearing blinders as to MEDA's conduct and MEDA's
conduct only. It sees the bigger concerns and dangers lurking in the broader industry and
accounts for it and addresses it and has a plan for it. I think that's appropriate. I think
while we hold MEDA accountable and secure these very important commitments going forward that
will reduce harm to our kids, we need to be aware of the other players that are also visiting harm
on kids and have a plan for that. And this settlement agreement does. Thank you. Next
question comes from Tyler. You're now unmuted. Good morning. Tava Katzenberger here from Politico.
Real quickly, can you just confirm whether or not you've had conversations with representatives
from SNAP, TikTok, and from Google regarding their potential participation in these terms?
On these specific terms that are in this settlement? Yes.
This is hot off the press. So the conversations we've had about the terms in this settlement
are with MEDA. We've been working literally day and night, sleepless nights for my team
to get to where we are today. I think the concepts that are represented are not new to TikTok or
SNAP or YouTube. And we're in a lawsuit with TikTok. So we've definitely had communications
with TikTok around our lawsuit and what we're seeking. We've also been in communication with
other members of the industry. But I don't want to talk about the content, even the weather,
for some of those conversations to the extent that they may involve confidential
components to them. But I think the most important thing is that going forward,
what will happen. And we expect that other members of the industry, including TikTok,
including SNAP, including YouTube, while observing how some of their models are very similar to MEDA
but also maybe different, will adhere to essentially a similar set of remedies and protections for kids
and commitments. And whether we do that through litigation, through conversation and resolution
is really up to the other members of the industry. But we think that this is a really
good blueprint. It's an enforceable blueprint. Once the judge signs off on it, should she do so
for MEDA. But it's also, I think, an appropriate blueprint for what other members of the industry
should do. So to those other members of the industry, if they're following here, they should
take a close look at the settlement agreement and think about how they might want to make
commitments to this blueprint. And very quick follow up. Should this agreement be seen as
in any way precluding other states, including California itself, from taking further action
through the legislature, through their legislatures, for instance, to regulate
social media companies? No, not at all. It's a floor. It is not a ceiling. The above this floor,
these sets of commitments, legislatures, policymakers, our office, should it come to
conduct that we see that we think is violative of the law above and beyond what's contemplated
in this in this settlement, or even if there's violations of this settlement,
that's enforceable by the court. That's why, or hopefully it will be once the court signs off,
should the court in its wisdom decide to sign off here, we can enforce the four corners of this
agreement and the terms of it. But no, this is not sort of what I think you might be suggesting,
that it sort of preempts any other action in this space. Legislators are free. Policymakers are free
to propose other ideas that address the concerns they have with our social media platforms vis-a-vis
the harm they're visiting on our kids. So it is not preemptive in any way. It's a floor,
conceptually, not a ceiling. Thank you. Next question comes from Rachel.
Rachel, you're now unmuted. Hi there, Rachel Miro, KQED News. I was just curious, you know,
what about the other pending lawsuits, the state consumer protection COPPA lawsuits? Does this
agreement, if Judge Gonzales-Rogers approves, does this agreement stop those or do they proceed
apace? Thank you for your question. So let me just back up a little bit here. This is a 51 state
district and territory resolution of claims from across the country. And when there were a number
of different lawsuits brought by different states, the District of Columbia and territories,
and some were part of this federal multi-state, multi-district litigation lawsuit that we were
in trial for in Oakland, that involved 29 states. But other states, including Tennessee, for example,
who's in trial right now, had their own lawsuits in their own states. And so this resolution is
essentially a global resolution, with the exception of two states who didn't sign on,
Texas and Florida. It addresses the claims against META with respect to COPPA and their version of
unfair competition law or false advertising law. It resolves their cases. So it is a global
resolution for all those states, the District of Columbia and the territories who've signed on
of those cases. Thank you. Next question comes from Lisa. You're now unmuted.
Hi, Attorney General Bontas, Lisa Rubin at MS Now. One of the things I wanted to ask you about
is about the injunctive relief in particular, and the fact that it puts a lot of control
into the hands of parent supervisors of teen accounts to either live with default settings
or allow their teens to change them. What level of confidence do you have that META under this
settlement will actually implement the kind of screening methods to A, detect who is and who is
not a teen, and then B, who is and who is not a parent to the extent that teens are trying to
these controls? I'd love to hear you talk about that. Yeah, we're pleased with that part of the
settlement, that there will be more robust age verification tools implemented going forward,
as well as parent verification tools. And what we had up to now, we described in our trial,
I think, very accurately and powerfully as tissue paper defenses. META made much to do about
new approaches or safeguards, I'll put those in air quotes, safeguards that they put in,
many of which they implemented only after we sued them. So they seem to be performative
and superficial and pretextual in response to our litigation. But that as it is, they were
essentially, quote unquote, safeguards that were easily overridden by a child's own swipe of the
finger. That didn't fly, that was unacceptable, and that will not be
allowed going forward. We will have new parent verification, META will implement new parent
verification tools where a parent needs to be authorized and verified as a parent before
there is any overriding of the defaults. So a separate person who's verified and authorized,
not a child who sees a notice and wipes it away with the finger and continues to engage
with the same product and features without any parent actually being involved. So
technology is always a potential limitation. META has shown an incredible ability to accomplish
many things that it wants, many things that it wants when it leads to an increase in their
bottom line. We're confident that they can accomplish these age verification and parent
verification features, and frankly, they're required by the settlement agreement.
Thank you. Next question comes from Jonathan. You are now unmuted.
Great. Thank you for doing this. Jonathan Vanney with CNBC. I'm just curious if META would have
to make any additional changes, pay any other penalties, assuming the case against TikTok
leads to a proposed settlement, just like how this proposed settlement includes some caveats
related to what YouTube and TikTok might agree to. I'm just curious how that plays out.
Yeah. The answer is yes. So there's sort of this level up concept built in across
the settlement agreement where META is required today by this settlement and agreement, and
regardless of what anyone else in the industry does, to do certain things and pay certain amounts.
And if others in the industry make similar commitments, sort of if that trigger,
if that industry trigger is pulled, if you will, where META is not the only industry player making
commitments of this type, then they will do more and pay more. So the answer to your question is
yes. Got it. And then another question, is there any reason why Snap is not involved in the monetary
side of this agreement? I think it might have something to do with the recognition of the
market share that Snap has. But this, I'm not sure what you mean by that. Maybe I'll say that.
This agreement is... That kind of answers my question. Yeah.
Next question comes from Sarah. You're now unmuted. Great. Thank you so much. Sarah
Bloomberg with Agence France-Presse. My question is, assuming that the settlement agreement is
approved by the judge, if META violates the agreement, what types of enforcement actions
are you able to take? Yeah. This will essentially take the form of the settlement agreement,
not just as a sort of, if you will, a private agreement between parties, the AGs on one side
and META on the other. It will be an enforceable agreement by the court. And that was very
important to us. That was a deal point that essentially was non-negotiable for us. We wanted
a judge to oversee the ongoing compliance by META to the terms of this agreement. And so
we will be able to go in court. We'll be able to enforce the agreement. We will be able to hold
them in contempt of court. We'll be able to have a judge with the judicial authority that judges
have make orders and hold META to account. And that is a very important part of the structure
of this agreement. So if, and I hope when the judge signs on, the full weight and authority
of the judge's oversight will kick in to enforce the terms of this agreement.
Thank you. Next question comes from Ethan. You're now unmuted.
Hi, thanks again. And so you mentioned YouTube and you mentioned this agreement being sort of
a blueprint and YouTube is often seen as sort of escaping some of the scrutiny that
companies like META has undergone. And so you mentioned concerns about YouTube and what are
your concerns about YouTube? And to what extent do you think this agreement is more than a blueprint
and is something that gives you leverage, that gives you sort of a stick to use in addressing
the concerns that you have about YouTube? So maybe first I'll say YouTube didn't escape
accountability in the Southern California case. And YouTube I think is appropriately squarely
on the radar of those who are concerned about social media platforms, features and products
that harm the mental health of kids. So YouTube is also not exactly the same in its model as META
and TikTok. We have to recognize that, but there are similar features and products that YouTube
uses that are along the same lines, that are designed to create excessive compulsive use
that lead to mental health harms, and most importantly, that hurt our children
and can and should be changed. So whatever way you want to describe how things may have been
in the past with respect to YouTube, I will respectfully say I think that that's changing,
if it is the way you say, because there is a concern about the whole industry and YouTube is
a major player in the industry, and we want industry-wide solutions so that no matter what
platform you go to, whether it be META or TikTok or Snap or YouTube, our kids are safe and they are
not being preyed on by folks with sophisticated designs, features and products that hurt our
kids, that just shouldn't be. And I'm proud that we've had a bipartisan group of AGs stand up for
that. So is the blueprint something more? I think that's probably in the eye of the beholder. We'll
see how others react to it. But I think this set of, this suite of, this constellation of solutions
in terms of injunctive relief that we've delivered here that apply to META, I really think that
YouTube and Snap and TikTok should be thinking very closely about it, and their commitment to
adopt the same. And it could be done in a really productive way where states talk to other players
in the industry and get to a good place where they're delivering in the same way that META is
through this enforceable settlement agreement for the mental health and well-being of our kids.
Or it could be through trial. But I'll say from my vantage point, my office, we're proud and pleased
about what we've accomplished today. It is momentous and it gives notice to others in the
industry that we're not done. And we expect similar outcomes from them as well. And there's a lot of
ways we can do it. We hope we can do it by working it out with those other industry players and
delivering for our kids as soon as possible. Thank you. And that was the last question.
Super. Thanks, everybody. I appreciate your engagement, your thoughtful questions,
and the opportunity to spend time with you this morning. Take care. See you next time.
