This business case study analyzes the severe financial struggles of Air India under the ownership of the Tata Group. Despite massive investments, a historic 470-aircraft order, and extensive retrofit programs, the airline is facing double the daily losses compared to when it was state-owned. The video explores the four major traps hindering its recovery, including geopolitical issues like airspace closures, fleet hardware delays, production backlogs from major manufacturers, and systemic operational legacy issues. Finally, it outlines the new CEO's strategic roadmap to convert major Indian cities into international hubs to capture global transit traffic and achieve long-term profitability.
We are totally delighted that this process is complete.
Very happy to have Air India back in the Tata group.
Ladies and gentlemen, Air India is failing
and it might just be the worst purchase that Tata has ever made.
Financial year 2026 is one of Air India's toughest years as well.
Airline accounted for more than three-fourths of the combined losses
of Tata's three biggest new businesses.
The loss-making airline facing multiple headwinds in the wake of the Middle East conflict.
In FY21, when Air India was owned by the government of India,
it was losing 19.2 crores every single day.
But shockingly, in FY26, Air India loses 42 crores every single day.
The question is, how is this even possible?
The Tata group built TCS, which makes 52,000 crores in profits today.
They rescued and revived the Jaguar and Land Rover from 2,400 crores in losses
to 27,000 crores in profits.
And they even turned Tata Salt into a 4,000 crore brand.
And it's not that they didn't try.
The Tata and Singapore Airlines have infused 9,558 crores in Air India.
They've announced a 3,300 crore program to fix all their aircrafts.
And they've even placed the largest aircraft order in aviation history
by ordering 470 aircrafts.
It's one of the biggest purchases in aviation history.
But even then, Air India is in its worst state possible.
And to be honest, I just couldn't believe this.
How is it even possible that the Tatas are doing worse than the Sarkari Babus of India?
So I started reading the supply chain reports, Boeing and Airbus order books,
and even Air India's annual filings to understand,
how is it possible that Air India is losing more money under the Tatas
than under the government of India?
What are the biggest threats to Air India's success?
And most importantly, how are they planning to fix it?
And what I found was absolutely mind-blowing.
But before we dive into this case today,
I want to quickly thank Odoo for supporting our content.
People, this September, Odoo is hosting Odoo Experience 2026
for entrepreneurs and tech professionals in India.
It is India's biggest tech and business event with over 45,000 attendees
from 150-plus countries coming together under one roof.
At this event, you will get to attend 200-plus expert talks,
live product demos, 180-plus exhibitor booths, exclusive masterclasses,
and you will even witness the launch of Odoo 20 live on stage.
The best part is, this entire event is absolutely free to attend
because Odoo believes that innovation and education should never be gatekept.
This event is happening on 11th and 12th of September
at the Mahatma Mandir Convention Center in Gandhinagar.
So whether you are an entrepreneur, or a creator, or a techie,
or just someone curious about what India's future looks like, this event is for you.
So register for this event using the link in the description,
and I will see you at Odoo Experience 2026.
People, the first big dent to the Tata Group was due to Operation Sindhur.
In April 2025, after Operation Sindhur, Pakistan closed its airspace only to Indian carriers.
So today, Emirates can fly over Pakistan, Lufthansa can fly over Pakistan, but Air India cannot.
Before the closure, an Air India aircraft leaving Delhi could fly northwest almost immediately.
So it could go from Delhi to Pakistan to Europe to North America.
So Pakistan effectively functioned like an aviation highway between Northern India and the West.
So for Delhi-Chicago, this route roughly covered 12,500 kilometers and took about 14.5 hours.
Now after the Pakistani airspace blocked us, Air India simply cannot move the line slightly north
because we have the Himalayas, restricted airspace and safety requirements.
Instead, many westbound flights from Delhi must initially fly south
away from the destination and then reach North America.
So it has to go from Delhi to Ahmedabad to Arabian Sea to Muscat
and then turn northwest towards Europe, Vienna and then reach North America.
So the Delhi-Chicago flight has to travel 2,500 kilometers extra and the travel time
goes up by 4.5 hours. The worst part is, in just 5 months, this has cost Air India 4,000 crores.
In fact, an internal Air India document reviewed by the journalist estimates this cost to be about
$591 million or almost 5,000 crores over 12 months.
This also makes Mumbai to San Francisco route unviable and Delhi-Washington route also got
suspended. This is the reason why now foreign airlines operate a record 58.4% of India's
international flights and a staggering 95% of India's international cargo.
So every time an Indian flies abroad or an Indian package leaves the country,
the money is most likely going to a foreign airline's pocket.
So do you see that? 95% of the world's fifth largest economy's cargo flies on foreign
carriers. So Air India's biggest competitor isn't an airline, it's geography and geopolitics.
So the question is, Operation Zindur is fine, but what about domestic market and why isn't
Tata Airline not doing as well as IndiGo? Well, they tried. After the Tata Group absorbed
15,300 crores in Air India's debt and paid 2,700 crores in cash to the government,
they launched a vihaan.ai mission where they merged four airlines Air Asia, Vistara, Air
India and Air India Express into Air India and Air India Express and they ordered a record-breaking
470 new aircrafts. On top of that, they also were about to shell out 400 million dollars
to retrofit the old aircrafts and they aim to hit profitability by 2027. So on paper,
it was beautiful and people were rooting for the Tata's to make a historic comeback.
But the question is, what went wrong? Well, I found four traps that they got stuck in.
Trap number one is the product lottery trap. Now after Air India merged Vistara and Air India,
the customer's comfort became a lottery ticket. So if you take an Air India flight,
you don't know whether you'll get an old Air India aircraft with bad seats or a clean new
Vistara aircraft. This uncertainty killed the willingness to pay even amongst the most loyal
Vistara customers. So the question is, if the seats were so bad, why doesn't Air India just
fix them? Well, they tried. Air India began a 400 million dollar retrofit program to fix all
their aircrafts. But this is where they got stuck in the second trap, which was the hardware trap.
As it turns out, an aircraft seat is not an ordinary piece of furniture.
A business class seat is a certified aerospace machine, which has to survive a 16G crash test,
integrate electronics, motors and airbags and get regulatory sign offs so that it can be installed
into an aircraft. And that is the reason why there are only a handful of companies on earth that can
make these seats. So when Air India went shopping, they realized that four out of five seat supplies
are running in chronic delays. And one of its seat suppliers simply exited the program,
saying that they cannot design, certify and produce them at the volume that Air India needs.
This is the reason why Air India is not able to change all its seats. And the retrofit program
is running two years late. So the question is, why don't they just buy new aircrafts?
Well, they tried. In fact, Air India did place an order for 470 aircrafts. But this is where
that third trap came in. As it turns out, as of mid 2026, Airbus and Boeing have a backlog of
10 to 12 years of production. Yes, they have 10 to 12 years of production as their backlog,
and they have 16,683 aircrafts to deliver. And when you place an order for an aircraft,
you don't get the aircraft, you get placed in a queue to get the aircraft. So yeah, Air India
might just have to wait for 10 years to get all their deliveries. But I was like, dude,
why are Airbus and Boeing running so slow? Well, that is where we have two more supply chain risks.
Firstly, Pratt and Whitney, the engine manufacturer discovered contaminated powder
metal inside its GTF engines. The situation got so bad that 648A320neo and other aircrafts had
to be grounded due to this and other engineering problems. Secondly, Russia supplied 65% of
Airbus's titanium and 35% of Boeing's titanium. But after the Russia-Ukraine war, the world does
not have enough titanium. And lastly, Boeing is having such terrible quality issues that
Boeing told Indian carriers that it could only deliver two aircrafts per month to all Indian
airlines combined. So to all Indian airlines combined, Boeing cannot deliver more than 24
aircrafts in a year. And then comes trap number four, which is the operating system trap. Long
story short, Air India was inheriting a 69 year old operating system built by the government of
India. For 69 years, maintenance was deferred, processes were delayed and the best engineers
left. Tata bought the planes, they bought the brand, they bought the routes, but they also
inherited the operating system. And you cannot simply uninstall a 69 year old operating system
in four years. On top that the tragic crash in June 2025 only intensify the pressure and the
costs. In fact, a data presented in the Lok Sabha says that 137 out of Air India's 166 aircrafts
had recurring defects and 54 out of the 101 Air India Express aircrafts had issues. This
is what software engineers call technical debt. And lastly, when the Tata's fused Vistara into
Air India and Air Asia India into Air India Express, for the customers it became a big,
big pain. Vistara was India's most loved premium airline. So when its pilots were moved to Air
India space structure, they revolted, there were mass sick leaves, cancelled flights and a culture
war between Vistara and Air India's Sarkari legacy. These are the traps that Air India
stuck in. So now the question is what exactly are the Tata's doing to fix Air India? Well,
now they've appointed a new CEO and this CEO has such a stellar record that between 2011 and 2022,
he has taken Ethiopian airlines from $1 billion to $4.5 billion in revenue from 33 aircrafts to
130 aircrafts and from 3 to 12 million passengers. Eventually, he turned it into Africa's most
profitable airline group. So the question is what exactly is his plan? Well, firstly,
his mandate is to turn India into a hub. Look at this, an airline earns money in two ways,
it carries people to and from its own country, which is the home market, or it carries people
between two other countries through its own airport. This is called the sixth freedom traffic.
And this is what practically built Emirates into a billion dollar empire. So if you look at
Emirates flights, they don't just contain people going to Dubai, most people halt at Dubai,
and then they fly to all destinations across the world. So right now, passengers from Delhi,
Mumbai and Bangalore come to Dubai, and then they fly to London, New York and Sydney. That is
because Dubai is so strategically located that one third of the entire world's population lives a
four hour flight away from Dubai, and two third of the world's population lives within an eight
hour flight away from Dubai. But Dubai is not the only city with a geographical advantage.
Delhi is well placed at the intersection of major travel corridors, linking Europe
and West Asia with South Asia. From Delhi, Bangkok is about four hours 20 minutes away,
Hong Kong is five hours 40 minutes, Singapore is five hours 45 minutes, Tokyo is eight hours
five minutes and even London is about 11 hours five minutes on nonstop flights. And Delhi is
strategically located that if you look at the London to Singapore route, it's a 462 kilometre
detour via Dubai, but via Delhi, it's only an eight kilometre detour. And this can give Air
India and India three incredible superpowers. Number one, more routes will become economically
viable. For example, if Air India starts Delhi to Rome route, Delhi alone may not provide enough
passengers to fill that aircraft every day. But if Air India feeds Delhi with passengers from
Jaipur, Lucknow, Kathmandu, Bangkok and Colombo, suddenly the Rome flight receives demand from
six different markets. This is called traffic aggregation, which allows the airline to combine
multiple streams into one large aircrafts, increase frequency and open routes that would
otherwise remain unviable. Number two, every route strengthens every other route, a hub creates a
network effect. So adding Delhi Bangkok does not just create one route, it can create Bangkok
And lastly, when an Indian flies through Dubai, the connecting airline earns the ticket revenue
while the foreign hub earns landing charges, shopping revenue, cargo revenue, ground handling
income and even maintenance demand. So an Indian hub keeps more of that economic activity inside
India. And it also gives Air India additional belly cargo capacity, loyal customers and premium
passengers. Air India wants Delhi as its principal global hub, Mumbai as its secondary hub and
Bengaluru as its southern hub. On top of that, Air India intends to build maintenance, repair and
operations vertical and intends to expand its cargo vertical with its hub model. Now the only
hope is that Air India gets its aircrafts on time from Airbus and Boeing and the titanium crisis
must be solved soon. Otherwise, this is going to put Air India into deep, deep trouble. So as a
Tata fan, I'm just rooting for the Tata's to make an epic comeback and turn Air India into one of
the greatest airlines the world has ever seen. This is the story of Air India at the moment and
I just hope you learned something valuable from this case study. That's all from my side for today
guys. If you learned something valuable, please make sure to hit the like button to support our
work. And for more such insightful business and political case studies, please subscribe to our
channel. Thank you so much for watching. I will see you in the next one. Bye bye.