I tried lace making at 3 difficulty levels

Drawing With Oil Pastel
26 followers
#art
Masterpieces of Irish Crochet Lace (abridged), Thérèse de Dillmont (a few of the motifs from the book with the pattern I followed. I found the full ebook at my local library, be sure to check at yours if you want the full thing!):
AI Generated·May contain errors
Lace making has always been one of those crafts that I really want to try and learn,
but I've just been too intimidated. I'm talking specifically about bobbin lace. I keep seeing
these videos on social media of people with like a hundred little wooden pegs tied to strings,
and they're shuffling them around in ways that I can't comprehend, and they end up with these
beautiful intricate pieces of lace. It's like witchcraft to me. And I love crafts,
so I'm very intrigued. But there are tons of different styles of lace making out there in
the world, many of which were developed as simpler, less expensive ways of mimicking bobbin
lace. So today I'm going to try and wrap my head around the concept of bobbin lace, but I want to
try and ease myself in with some supposedly less complicated techniques, Irish lace crochet and
tatting, and see how the three compare. Okay, so I want to start out with Irish crochet lace
because it's the one out of the three that I actually have some experience with. I've been
crocheting for several years, so I'm really familiar with all the basics, and I have dabbled
with Irish lace crochet specifically in the past. So I think this will be a nice and easy starting
point, and then I can work my way into newer territory. So Irish crochet lace is essentially
just very fine and delicate crochet done in a way that creates very intricate patterns to
form lace. It was developed in Ireland, I believe, during the potato famine as a way to create
less expensive lace. I assume it's because crochet is something that more people knew how to do,
as opposed to, like, bobbin lace or needle lace, so it was just more accessible for more people to make.
So it started out trying to replicate existing styles of lace, but then sort of developed into
its own unique thing. The most recognizable feature to me are the three-dimensional floral motifs.
You'll see a lot of rosettes with, like, raised petals that come off of the work. To me, that's,
like, the most iconic part of this style of lace making. So I want to make, like, a little doily or
some similar piece with a raised floral motif. I checked out an ebook from the library that's a
manual for Irish lace crochet. It covers a lot of the basics. It has patterns for different motifs
that you can kind of combine together to create your own designs, and then it has patterns for
more finished pieces. I found a pattern in there that I really like, so I'm going to give that a
shot. So I'm going to use some number 10 crochet cotton for this and for all the other different
styles of lace making that I'm going to try, just to keep things consistent. And then the hook that
I'm using doesn't have a size on it, but I checked it on my little hook knitting needle gauge
checker tool, and it was slightly smaller than the two millimeter hole, but it's a little bit bigger
than my number 10 steel crochet hook. I think it's probably around a size five or six is my guess.
If you don't know lace crochet hooks, they're also called steel crochet hooks. The sizing goes
backwards, so the bigger the number, the smaller the hook size is going to be. That's pretty much
all I'll need for this, other than scissors and blocking supplies, but I'll need those things for
all the different methods that I'm trying. So I've got everything I need, so let's go ahead and get
started. I think Irish crochet lace is fairly simple to pick up if you already know how to
crochet, since it's literally the same thing. It's at a much smaller scale, obviously, and I find that
counting stitches is much more important than with standard crochet, since you're not just working to
the end of a row. You need to know exactly how many stitches are in each part of every motif.
The other main difference that I noticed is that you're typically not crocheting into stitches the
way you do with standard crochet. You're working over either chains of stitches or over a separate
thicker piece of yarn called padding. For example, to make the petals of the rosette, you start with
a base chain of stitches, then work double crochets around that whole chain instead of putting your
hook through the bars of the stitch. So I've been working on my little rosette motif, and one thing
I've noticed in all of the Irish lace crochet that I've done is that the patterns are so ridiculously
complicated at first glance. Like, if you really break them down, it's just regular crochet stitches,
but when you just get presented with this block of text, like for example, the pattern that I'm
following now, uh, I finished the main rosette, and then now I'm working the ground that surrounds that,
and I'm on round two of that. I really just want to read out these instructions as they are written
so you can see what I'm dealing with. I now present to you a dramatic reading of rosettes
surrounded by square-shaped ground. Second round. One chain. One single between the first and second
picots. Placed behind the picots. One chain. One single between the second and third picots.
Double star. Six chain. Three united picots. Six chain. One plain between the first and second picots.
One chain. One plain between the second and third picots. Eleven chain. One plain between the first
and second picots. Two chain. Turn the work. Make over the eleven chain. Twelve plain. One chain.
turn the work, make 12 plain which are placed on the 2 horizontal loops of the plain stitches
beneath, turn the work, make 3 times, 6 chain and 1 plain on the 4th plain, turn the work,
make over every loop of chain stitches, 1 plain, 1 half treble, 6 treble, 1 half treble and 1
plain, make 4 single descending into the 3 united picots, 1 chain, 1 plain between the 2nd and 3rd
picots, 6 chain, 3 united picots, 6 chain, 1 plain between the 1st and 2nd picots, 1 chain,
1 plain between the 2nd and 3rd picots, repeat 3 times from the double stars,
6 single on the 1st 6th chain. That's step 2. I think part of the issue or even like the main
factor in the issue is that this pattern was written in the early 1900s. The book that I'm
referencing is published in the 80s but it's a reprint of a book from sometime in the early
1900s. They don't give a specific date, I'm not sure why, but it's using different terminology.
Like if you crochet and you were listening to all of that and you're like, what's a plain?
There's a key at the beginning of the book that tells you like this means that and that
means this. I had to write it down. So a modern day slip stitch in American terminology in this
book is called a single stitch, a single crochet is a plain stitch, a double crochet is a treble,
a half double is a half treble, and a double crochet is a double treble. That terminology
is much more similar to modern day UK crochet terminology because they're different,
which is one of the fun things about learning crochet. So we use the same names but for
different things, which is not confusing at all. And the way the pattern is written with just
a block of text makes it kind of difficult to follow as you're just looking at that,
but if you break it down into individual steps it's not too difficult to work out. You just have
to like really sit and pay attention and keep track of where you are and when you're repeating
things and what's going on. So I'm gonna try and make that paragraph into the second round
of my rosette, but I'll check in a little bit later once I have this whole piece finished.
Hello, I have discovered I have made a critical error in the first round of the ground because
in the pattern what they do is they start with a V centered over one of the petals on the rosette
and then the next V goes from like the edge of the first petal to the center of the next one,
and then from the center of that petal to the edge of the next. So that way you end up with
like I think it's 12 V shapes going all the way around. What I did was the first V centered over
a petal and the next one centered over the gap between the first and the next petal,
and then the next one centered over the petal and the next one in the gap. I end up with 16
V's in the first round, so I thought I was almost done with the second round, and then I realized I
had way more space than I should. In order to correct that, I would have to rip back all of my
work up until the start of round one, and I don't want to do that. So what I'm gonna do instead,
instead of making this a square with four corners, I'm gonna make it a pentagon and go
with five, and even then it's not gonna be totally even. All of these little petal shapes have two
V's in between each of them. If I do five corners with the little petal shapes, one of them's gonna
have to have three V's between the two. It's not gonna be a square and it's not gonna be perfectly
perfect, but it'll be done, and I think I'm just gonna skip the third round because I don't want
to do it. I hate to say it, but I really don't. So I guess this is a good reminder to really read
through all the instructions before you just charge ahead and assume the pattern is symmetrical,
because it turns out this one isn't. So I'm gonna leave it as a five-pointed thing, leave it the
size, and then go ahead and block it and see how all that goes. So we're freestyling a little bit,
making some changes, and moving forward. Okay, so now that I've sort of dipped my toes into the
lacemaking realm with the Irish crochet lace, I'm going to move on to tatting. I'm less familiar
with tatting. I've never tried it out before, but I've definitely heard of it and seen some
stuff about it and have been doing some reading in preparation for this video. From what I can
tell, it's basically tying a series of knots into string, sometimes over top of another cord, to
form these lacy patterns. Based on the research I've been doing online, there are a few different
ways to do tatting. There is needle tatting, which uses a blunt sewing needle. I also read
something about crow tatting, which uses a crochet hook. But what I think is the more common style of
tatting, or at least is the kind of tatting that I've always heard about and it's what I'm going
to be trying out today, is shuttle tatting. So for shuttle tatting, you need to have a shuttle,
which is what this little guy here is. It's a little oval-shaped thing. It's got two layers
and then a bobbin in the middle that you wrap the thread around. The ones that I have are plastic.
I think most of the ones you can find today are made of plastic, but historically I've seen that
they made them out of like wood and ivory and metal and all sorts of very fancy pretty things.
But I'm using plastic shuttles. These actually belonged to my great uncle, who did tatting.
My mom recently gave me his tatting stuff that she had, that she'd inherited when he passed away.
So I've got a few of his shuttles and a couple of pieces of tatting work that he had done,
which are just so pretty and so nicely done. I really need to like wash them and block them and
like frame them or something so I can have them displayed. It's really nice to get to see like some
examples of the finished work in person. So I've got four shuttles. They're all plastic.
Two of them are Clover brand, two of them are Boy. And if you crochet, those might be familiar names
to you because both of those companies also make crochet hooks. Based on the research I've been
there are different styles of tatting shuttles. Some of them, like this guy, have a little pick
at the end so that you can kind of pick up the thread when you're tying the knots. And then other
styles have a little crochet hook built into the end. And then some of them also just don't have
anything at all. They're just plain, like the back end of this one. The Boy shuttles have the little
crochet hooks built into the ends. So I was like, okay, that's just different brand names. And then
I looked a little bit more closely and I noticed that the orange Clover shuttle that I have, the
pick end is kind of like warped and like melted almost. So I was like, oh, okay, that's weird.
That got melted somehow. And then I looked a little bit more at the Boy shuttles and I realized
that they're also kind of melted too on the ends of the hooks. And then I got a sneaking suspicion
and I looked up Boy brand tatting shuttles and I was able to find several like eBay listings for
this exact style of shuttle in the same red plastic and none of them have the hook. They
all have a little pick. So I'm pretty sure he melted these a little bit with like a lighter or
something and then bent them to form a hook, which is very in character for my great uncle. So it'll
be fun to try out both and see which one I like better. I guess all the shuttles are already
wound with thread, but I have no idea how old this thread is and how like
stable and sturdy it is. And also all the shuttles are a little bit sticky. So I'm going to unwind
all of these and then give them a quick wash and then rewind them with my number 10 crochet
cotton, actually get started. I was able to get some actual physical library books about tatting.
The one that I'm following today is Aunt Ellen's Tatting Handbook, a treasury of techniques and
projects by the staff of the Work Basket magazine. I think it's from the 1980s. It's got a lot of
diagrams that seem fairly easy to understand. We shall see if I am able to piece all of this
together from still images and written instructions or if I end up needing to find
a video tutorial. I'm gonna get my shuttles all cleaned and set up and then we can start
trying to figure this out. Okay, so I've got my shuttle wound. Hold the flat side of the shuttle
between thumb and forefinger of your working hand in a horizontal position, the thread coming from
the back of the shuttle. Spread the middle ring and little fingers of your helping hand.
First half the double stitch, hold the shuttle in your working hand, bring the shuttle thread
across on the pole. What does that mean? I don't think I can figure this out from a book.
So I was not at all able to understand how to do tatting from a book.
I mean, one of the books that I got literally said in the introduction that people used to
think it was impossible to learn tatting without an in-person teacher, so that should have been
the first red flag. Ultimately, I needed to see the process in action to understand,
so I started looking for video tutorials. I also found that, as with almost every other form of
fiber art, everyone has a slightly different way of working. The way they hold the shuttle,
the way they move their hands to form the stitches. So it took me a while to find a
tutorial that made sense to me. I found Bryce Adams' videos on YouTube to be the most helpful
personally. I'll link them down in the description. I found that she had the clearest instructions
and simplest technique of all the different sources that I looked at. The first thing
that I had to figure out was flipping the stitch, or as one of the older manuals I looked at calls
it, the transfer, which is so sinister sounding for no reason. Basically, tatting is done by
tying half hitch knots. If you've ever made one of those macrame friendship bracelets,
you've tied a half hitch. You have one straight thread and the other loops around it to make
the knot. With tatting, you've got the shuttle thread and the ring thread, though it's actually
one thread that's just wrapped around your non-dominant hand in a specific way, but I digress.
The ring thread is secured at both ends so it can't be wrapped around to make the loop,
while the shuttle thread is free at one end and can form the loop. But the way tatting works,
you need the ring thread to be wrapped around the shuttle thread. So you have to flip the stitch.
You loop the shuttle thread around the ring thread to start tying a half hitch,
but before you tighten the loop down, you release the tension on the ring thread to give it slack
and simultaneously pull on the shuttle thread to make it taut. This flips the loop of the half
hitch, so the ring thread is now going around the shuttle thread, and then you can tighten the loop
down. You do this twice, first so that the loop faces down on the shuttle thread, then again so
that it faces up to make one double stitch, which is the base for all of tatting. I don't know if
I'm explaining that super well, for me at least it was something that I really needed to see
in motion to fully understand. It requires a lot of coordination with both hands, and your
non-dominant hand has to do a good bit of work. It took me a while to pick up the rhythm, but once
I had that down, it wasn't terribly difficult. Okay, I have completed my first piece of tatting
that's actually a finished thing and not just miscellaneous loops. It's a little flower,
like a little snowflake. It's definitely a little wonky, my joins leave something to be desired,
but for a first go at it, I'm pretty happy. I'm definitely starting to get it. I feel like I've
got a decent handle on the basics, so I'm going to attempt to follow a pattern. This is a different
book that I got from the library. This is a Tatting in Lace by Mary Connior. I'm gonna try this
carnation pattern, which might be a little ambitious given I struggled a lot with this,
but I want to give it a go and try and jump in. I'm gonna give it a shot and see how far I get
before I give up, probably. No, no, let's be confident. I'm gonna give it a shot and make
the whole thing. I was gonna say perfectly, that's a bit too much. I'm gonna make the thing.
It'll exist. This pattern, like all tatting patterns from what I can tell, is made up of
rings, which are closed loops of double stitches and chains. Double stitches worked on a separate
thread that joins with the rings to make arcs. The little frilly loops are picots. They are made by
leaving space between double stitches so that you get an extra loop of thread. Picots are also used
as connection points to join rings and chains to create the lace pattern. So it is the next day.
Definitely starting to pick it up and understand the mechanics of it. I think the biggest thing
was figuring out what to call all the motions in my head, because I was following these tutorials
and they're like, you go over, under, around, and through, and da-da-da-da-da, and understanding what
I'm supposed to do, but keeping the rhythm was a big issue, because I would twist,
under, over, flip, pull, over, under, through, around, and then I realized I'm just singing Whipped in
Shape from Legally Blonde the musical, and that isn't helping, shockingly. So I think I finally got it
kind of nailed down in my mind. It's like I go towards you, forward, through the ring, back,
relax the tension, so you flip the stitch, tighten down, and then away from you,
backwards through the ring, flip the stitch, and tighten down, and that's it, and you just keep
doing that. It's definitely a workout for your non-dominant hand, because you're like holding it
in this like weird position, and then trying to like manage the tension with your index finger.
So I'm gonna keep tatting away, and I'll check in whenever something interesting happens, um,
probably whenever I finish this thing, hopefully whenever I finish this thing,
because if something interesting happens before then, something has gone wrong.
I continued following the tatting pattern with no major issues. There were a few small mistakes
where I joined elements together at the wrong points, but nothing that made it impossible to
keep going with the pattern like I had with the crochet lace. Once I had completed the pattern,
I woven my thread tails, which honestly was the most annoying step, and then I blocked it.
Okay, so I have completed my first piece of tatting. It's not perfect, of course, um, there's
some wonkiness with the tension, and I definitely still struggle a bit with the joins. There are a
couple points where I just straight up joined to the wrong section of the pattern, so, so it's a
little bit, a little bit funky, but for a first attempt, I think this is pretty good. And so now
that I feel like I have a pretty good base understanding of tatting, I'm going to move on
to bobbin lace, which is kind of like the final boss of this whole video. As I've said, I find
bobbin lace to be the most intimidating out of all of the different techniques that I want to try,
but I've been doing some research, I've been watching some tutorials, and I think I have
a general idea of how it's supposed to work, and it seems a bit less mystifying than it did
previously. Bryce Adams on YouTube, I think her channel name is just Bryce, she's the one who made
the tatting tutorials that I found the most helpful. She also has some videos on bobbin lace,
so I've been watching through those. I'm going to follow her beginner's tutorial for a basic
braid, half stitch, and cloth stitch first, and then I found a pattern for a sampler. Another
YouTuber on here, Book Hoarding by Bianca, made a video a few years ago about her process of
getting started in bobbin lace. She recommended this pattern from Katharina Wason. They created
a pattern for a sampler that starts out with very basic techniques and then adds new things in to
create a more complex, intricate pattern, so I want to give that a shot as well today. So for bobbin
lace, you do need some supplies. You need bobbins, of course. Bobbins are just little sticks that you
wrap your thread around. Usually they're made out of wood, and you manipulate those to weave the
lace. They can be very intricately carved and painted and decorated, and they can get quite
expensive, but at their core they are just little sticks that you wrap your thread around, so it's
pretty easy to substitute less expensive, easier to find items. You also need a lace pillow. The
way bobbin lace is made, you're weaving small sections and then pinning them down in place as
you go to keep the tension and everything set correctly until you have woven enough to lock it
in, I believe, is the way it works. So you need something to pin into, and that's where the pillow
comes in. There are several different styles that I've seen. There's cookie pillows that are just
flat, round things. There's bolster pillows that are cylindrical and shaped like a bolster pillow,
hence the name. There's mini roller pillows that are like tiny bolster pillows that are set into
bigger flatter pillows, and they move and it's a whole thing. Really you just need something
fairly sturdy and pinnable, so I'm gonna try and use my foam blocking mats that I use for knitting.
They are literally made to have textiles pinned onto them, so I think they will work pretty good
for this. For the pins, I have a pack of sequin pins. They're just little tiny metal ones, and
then I'm going to be using the number 10 crochet cotton for this. I think that might be a little
bit too heavy for the bobbin lace, like in general, but I'm gonna give it a shot and see how well it
just for the sake of consistency between all the different techniques, but we shall see how well
it works. I started out by winding my bobbins. Bobbin laces worked with pairs of bobbins. I wound
each end of long lengths of thread around clothespins and tied them off with a lace maker's
knot, which secures the thread but still allows you to spool more off. Then I hung each pair of
bobbins from a pin stuck into my makeshift pillow. I made a little paper guide with just two vertical
lines to help me maintain an even width while I worked, and that went under the bobbins pinned
flat to the pillow. Then I started weaving some of the basic stitches. Everything is made up of
crosses, passing the left hand bobbin over the right, and twists, passing the right over the left.
First I tried a basic braid using two pairs of bobbins, crossing the middle two, then twisting
each pair. So if you think of the bobbins as being numbered one through four left to right,
it's two over three, then four over two, and three over one. That pattern is the foundation for
everything that I learned about bobbin lace. Next I tried the half stitch using four pairs of bobbins.
It's the same cross-twist repetition as the braid, but now you work across the work by crossing and
twisting two pairs, then dropping the pair on the left, picking up the next two bobbins on the right,
repeating the process all the way down, then putting a pin between the last two pairs of bobbins.
Then you add an extra twist to the last pair, and work back to the beginning, going right to left.
By doing this, you weave the threads over and under each other, creating a fabric. Next I learned the
whole stitch, which is almost the same as the half stitch, but you cross-twist cross your two pairs
of bobbins before moving along. This extra cross makes a much more stable fabric. It makes a plain
weave, whereas the half stitch makes a lattice pattern that is much more liable to stretch and
warp. Once I felt like I had a feel for the basic stitches, I cut my bobbins free and unpinned my
work so I could move on to the sampler. The sampler starts off with just braids, then it introduces
more and more elements to slowly work up to a more complicated pattern. It's a free pattern with
written step-by-step instructions, and I think it was really good practice as it has you work a lot
of the basics over and over again. Okay, so I finished up the bobbin lace sampler that I was
working on, and if I'm being honest, I didn't really enjoy the process much at first. I kind of had a
similar experience with the tatting, where like at first when I wasn't getting it, I was starting to
get kind of frustrated. But with the tatting, it felt more like a challenge that I could overcome,
so it was still overall an enjoyable process, and once I picked up on it, it was like fun to do.
With the bobbin lace, at first, it was just too much. It was kind of overstimulating with like
how many threads and how many pins there are. I think especially working with the number 10
crochet cotton, like I predicted, it's too chunky for this work. I think at least just at the scale,
if I sized the pattern up, I think this could work a bit better, but for what this is, it's
very lumpy bumpy, and so like it's hard to see what you're doing, especially when there's so
many pins covering everything up. So I was not really having a good time with this guy, and I was
kind of bummed out like, oh maybe I just don't like bobbin lace, but I did give it another go.
I made another little sample following the last pattern from the sampler, the most complex one,
and I used a much finer thread. This is a silk hand sewing thread that I got from an estate sale.
It's a little bit heavier than what I would use on my sewing machine, but still very, very fine. I had
a much better time with this. Ironically, it was a lot easier to see what I was doing when I was
working with a thinner thread, and like that's lace. That's, that's lace. I'm still like kind of
blown away that I made this with my hands. That's crazy. I made that, and of course it's not perfect.
It's still like one of my very first attempts at bobbin lace, but like that's lace. I don't know,
I'm just very happy with it. It's so pretty. It makes me feel powerful that I can make something
like this with string, so I have decided I do in fact enjoy making bobbin lace. I also think part
of the issue is the supplies that I was using. The like found materials definitely worked, but I think
they kind of impeded my enjoyment. I wasn't a fan of working with the clothes pins. Like if you want
to give bobbin lace a try, I definitely recommend using clothes pins. They're much cheaper and easier
to find. I already had some on hand, so I didn't even need to buy anything, and then like I can use
them for other stuff afterwards, but I did find that they were just kind of big and clunky to
manipulate, and of course I've never worked with actual bobbin lace bobbins, but they seem to be
a good bit smaller and easier to manipulate around, so I don't think I'm going to go out and
buy a whole set of bobbins right away. They're kind of expensive, and I don't know how much I'm going
to be doing bobbin lace on the regular, so I'll probably try and find just something a bit better
than the clothes pins. I also found that I had some issues using the blocking mat in place of the lace
pillow. It definitely worked. It's super easy to pin into. I did find that it was a bit too small of a work
surface, and these are like tile-able blocking mats, so they kind of link together like puzzle
pieces, so I could expand my work area, but the size increments for the blocking mats just
wasn't quite right for this sort of work. I think I'm going to try and make a bolster pillow, one of
the long cylindrical kind. I think I can make it pretty easily using stuff that I have on hand,
and I feel like that would be really useful for making lengths of trim, because you can
rotate it as you work. But that concludes my little exploration of different styles of lace
making. I had a lot of fun trying all these out. It was really interesting to do them all
in succession and see the ways in which they were similar and different. They all have very
different looks to them, and you can create very different motifs with each one. I think the
difficulty ranking of each of them that I had assumed at the beginning definitely still holds
true. Like, the crochet lace was very simple for me to do. Like I said, I've already been crocheting
for years, and I've already played around with Irish crochet lace, so that wasn't a surprise.
Tadding was definitely somewhere in the middle. It took a while for me to pick up, but once I got it,
I had a lot of fun doing it, and it wasn't too difficult. And bobbin lace was definitely the
hardest out of the three. I think I'm starting to get it and get a grasp on it, but I've only like
just broken the surface on all the different stuff in bobbin lace. Like, there's so many other
techniques that I've read about but not attempted. So I'm very excited to try and dive in a bit more
into bobbin lace and all these other techniques, and I would like to explore other styles of lace
making in the future. There are just so many out in the world, so if there are any other styles of
lace making that you would like to see me try and learn, I'd love to hear about it down in the
comments. Or if there are other forms of fiber art beyond lace making that you think I'd be interested
in, please do let me know down in the comments. I'm always looking to try out new things and see
what I can incorporate into my toolkit. So that is it for today. Thank you so much for watching.
I hope you enjoyed the video. If you did, you could click whatever buttons down below you feel
like clicking on. Thank you to all the patrons over on Patreon for supporting this channel, and
especially those in the Magnanimous Maelstroms tier. Hollis Morel, Froggy in Love, Mary Jane Rue,
Oscar, Obie Knit Kenobi, Evelyn, Bear Hardy, and Perfect Primrose. And that is it. Have a lovely
rest of your day. Goodbye!
