This Engine Is Replacing Diesels, And It Only Exhausts Steam

Machine Engine
3 followers
JCB has been working hard over the last few years to develop their hydrogen combustion technology, which is to be a direct replacement for their diesel engines. I check it how the engines work and how they are constructed in-house.
#machine #Equipment #Engine
AI Generated·May contain errors
This engine, despite having a set of spark plugs, is designed to directly replace a diesel engine.
This could be a game changer.
For decades, diesel engines have powered everything from construction machines to boats,
trains and your mate's Stage 2 330B.
Diesels are reliable, hard-working, always known for their chunky torque output.
They are still the most popular solution for the hardest working vehicles across the globe.
But there's another technology being rolled out that is vying for the same utilitarian crown.
I am at JCB in Derbyshire, specifically the power systems plant.
They pump out nearly a thousand engines a week in this building,
with an engine coming off the production line here every three minutes.
The vast majority of them are four-cylinder and six-cylinder diesels,
but integrated into this exact same production line is a brand new, very exciting engine on the block.
This is JCB's bread and butter, the 448 diesel.
It's built to run thousands of hours every year, in some situations continuously.
It's a bulletproof engine and is a genuine piece of engineering pride for the company.
It can be found in everything from backhoe loaders to telehandlers to compactors.
JCB has done some very cool stuff with their diesel engines.
They created the Performance Fast Track 2 tractor,
a version of which hit a peak speed of over 150 miles an hour
on its way to recording an average of 135.
They took a diesel land speed record with the JCB Diesel Max,
clocking a casual 350 miles an hour.
Someone has even swapped one into an old Landy.
This is a gold standard diesel engine, but in this world that's looking for
lower carbon power solutions, JCB has been working on a direct replacement.
This is what they're shouting about these days,
the 448 H2, JCB's four-cylinder hydrogen combustion engine.
When I thought of hydrogen previously,
I thought of the car that James May used to own, the Toyota Mirai.
That thing had a hydrogen fuel cell.
Now they work through an electrochemical process that mixes hydrogen with oxygen
over a catalyst to generate electricity that then powers an electric motor.
So the Mirai was essentially a hydrogen-powered EV.
This JCB hydrogen engine does things very differently.
It is an internal combustion engine, not as we know it,
but there are explosions going on in there.
JCB has created the H2 to directly replace the 448 diesel,
and here are the figures of each.
Yes, that's right.
They've mapped the H2 to exactly match the figures of the 448 diesel.
No mucking about.
JCB has now done something pretty damn epic with its new hydrogen engines.
Remember earlier in the video, I mentioned Diesel Max, the world's fastest diesel car.
Well, welcome to the Bonneville Salt Flats,
and that thing through there is the JCB Hydro Max.
JCB has brought this machine to this legendary high-speed location
to break the 400-mile-an-hour barrier using two JCB H2 engines,
one of them in front of the cockpit and one of them behind it.
They have been bored out to five litres,
and with a bunch of motorsport internals and turbos,
they're putting out 800 horsepower each.
That's 10 times the original factory output from these H2 engines.
And wing commander Andy Green has done it.
He's taken this car to an average speed of 406.32 miles an hour,
making this thing the fastest hydrogen-powered car ever made.
A car that I would love to bring here to Bonneville in Utah
in search of its top speed would be my V8 Daily, my Jaguar XJ Supersport.
Something I made sure to do before I bought that car
was enter its VIN into today's video sponsor, CarVertical,
to make sure I was buying a car without a dodgy past.
Punch in your reg or VIN number to CarVertical,
and you'll end up with a report that looks like this.
First up, immediately, it's one of the best CarVertical scores I've ever seen.
82 out of 100.
That's a solid A for where I'm from.
Very nice.
And you can dive right into the car's history.
It has had five owners.
It hasn't been stolen, suffered any big damage,
hasn't been clocked, or has any outstanding finance.
All great stuff.
It hasn't been involved in a natural disaster as well.
It does have an amber warning in emissions though,
although that's because it has a 500 horsepower supercharged V8.
I'm okay with that.
The report shows pictures from back in 2022,
when it was back on 44,000 miles,
probably from when it was sold two owners ago.
And its MOT history is really solid,
only really failing for tyre and brake wear.
Interestingly, CarVertical says that the estimated annual running cost
will be around £2,900.
We'll see about that.
Make sure to use CarVertical to check a car's history before you buy it,
and use my discount code FERNIE to get 20% off,
or up to 50% off if you batch buy reports for cars further down the line.
Hopefully you end up with reports as good as this one right here.
I reckon, with a pulley and a tune,
my Jag would be good for 200 miles an hour down here.
Half what that thing is capable of.
Well done, JCB.
The way to look at this engine is essentially an amalgamation
of both a petrol engine and a diesel engine.
Working up from the bottom, right up to the pistons,
everything is very diesel-based,
chunky and engineered to deal with low-down,
high-compression, diesel-esque torque outputs.
The cylinder head then takes us into the petrol side of things.
So in place of the diesel injector,
there is now a spark plug,
and then the hydrogen injectors are plumbed in here to the inlet manifold.
It uses port injection.
Those injectors spray hydrogen into the inlet ports.
That then makes its way into the combustion chamber with air.
The spark plugs then ignite that air and hydrogen mixture,
just like a petrol engine.
So JCB are using an amalgamation of technology
to go down this new strand of internal combustion engine.
Why has JCB gone for hydrogen combustion?
Well, they already have the legacy engine architecture
to convert over to hydrogen,
rather than starting fresh with a hydrogen fuel cell solution.
Battery electric doesn't work for heavy industrial applications either.
Were the vehicles running for a full eight-hour shift,
sometimes even a 16-hour double shift,
the battery would constantly need charging
due to the weight it is moving all day,
and the battery would degrade quickly.
Petrol engines don't have the sheer torquey grunt
and efficiency to top diesel.
But if any restrictions came along
surrounding decarbonizing the industry,
diesel will always be the first to die.
Hence why JCB is designing these hydrogen engines
to be essentially copycats of their diesels.
The tricky thing with hydrogen
is the efficient production and transportation of it.
JCB are working backwards from their engines
to come up with solutions.
They currently use the high-kit hydrogen refueling system.
That is a mobile system that makes sure
there's enough hydrogen on site for its machines.
The hydrogen gets to the work site
via long tubular trucks that get their hydrogen
from the hydrogen production sites.
Those production sites are popping up at a growing rate
and take water and extract the hydrogen
from the water using electrolyzers.
To dive even deeper into the innards of this peculiar engine,
I grabbed Ryan, Engineering Director of JCB's
state-of-the-art Research and Development Centre
to take me through the nerdy bits.
Ryan, hydrogen combustion is supposedly,
it works a lot like a petrol engine.
How, if you compare, say, an air-fuel ratio
of a petrol engine versus this hydrogen engine,
how do they compare?
Is it quite close or is the combustion quite different?
It's a great question.
It's probably actually one of the
biggest fundamental differences.
It's got similarities in that it's spark ignited,
but to be honest, that's where it sort of ends.
Hydrogen, when it's at lambda one,
burns really hot and burns really fast.
It's a volatile fuel.
It's one of its great properties.
It burns easily.
Because of that, we need to control the combustion.
And one of the kind of principal risks
associated with hydrogen combustion is knock,
you know, cylinder knock or pre-ignition.
And the two, slightly different to one another,
but both can manifest on a hydrogen engine.
Really easily.
And if you run a hydrogen engine at lambda one,
it'll knock away and pre-ignite like crazy.
And as we know, that's pretty much game over for an engine.
So the way we mitigate that, the way we prevent that,
is we do run very lean.
After questioning Ryan further about the air-fuel ratio,
these things are running between five and eight times leaner
than what we're used to in petrol engines.
Hydrogen is such a combustible molecule,
you only need a tiny amount compared to petrol.
So it's quite interesting.
Most of what goes through this is air.
It's mainly air with a tiny amount of hydrogen added.
And it's got such a high calorific value, hydrogen.
You know, it's three times that of diesel or petrol.
You only really do need a tiny amount
to create the power that you need for the engine.
And by running it very, very lean,
that actually reduces the combustion temperature.
It slows down the speed of combustion inside
and it helps mitigate that knock or pre-ignition.
Obviously, there's a huge amount of focus then
on getting the combustion right.
Because if you get the combustion right,
that is the nucleus of the engine.
That's where you get and derive that power from.
And we recognised really early on,
there's lots of academic research to tell you
you need to run very lean to mitigate knock.
We recognised instantly,
we want the biggest displacement engine we can.
So we started with our 4.8 litre engine.
We've made a million plus of our diesel engines now.
You know, we've been in production
more than 20 years, in fact.
22 years this year,
and we've made well over a million of them.
They must be very good then.
Well, exactly.
Well, we like to think so.
So, you know, they're robust, they're dependable,
they last for a long time.
You know, they're perfect for our customers' needs.
So we didn't want to throw all of that away.
So when we look at the architecture of the engine,
we're stuck with the kind of cast iron block,
It's a very robust bottom end
because we're very confident of that,
and we want to try to maintain that.
It is a different block.
There's some different materials in there.
We've gone to a different grade of cast iron.
We've got some different breathing in there
because, you know, one of the by-products,
well, the only real by-product
of hydrogen combustion is steam.
But of course, that means we need to manage
how we deal with the excess water in the engine.
So we've got a different breathing system in there.
So it's a different geometry block,
but fundamentally, it's diesel-esque in its DNA.
Right. Okay.
Well, going through the anatomy of the engine,
that this looks very diesel to me.
So how much of this engine is actually diesel parts,
or is everything being tweaked slightly
for the hydrogen OP?
I would say it's probably sort of a 50-50 mix, really,
in terms of there are some definite components
that are absolutely just carry over.
And some of the, you know, we look at the,
for instance, the crankshaft we've talked about,
you know, things like the primary drive gear.
There's really no need to change things like that.
You know, a gear on the end of the crank,
does it really know whether it's diesel or hydrogen?
It just does its job.
So where we can carry over components,
we always like to, because they're proven technology.
They're proven they're robust.
You know, they do what they need to do.
You know, push rods, tappets, et cetera,
they're all carry over.
When we get onto things like pistons,
although they're diesel-esque in their appearance,
if you actually kind of look at the bowl here,
you can see it's quite different to a diesel piston.
So a diesel piston would normally have
a sort of a pronounced peak in the middle,
sort of a, and we call that
a twin vortex combustion system on diesel.
It's got a nice name.
This is a much more of a sort of,
it's not quite a flat bowl,
but it's almost just a flat bowl.
And that's just, again, it's many hundreds
and it is literally hundreds of analysis runs
we've done with CFD to get the right in cylinder mixing
and get the gas dynamics right.
So although the piston is, you know,
not dissimilar to a diesel engine,
you know, it's an aluminium piston.
It's got a steel ring carrier, et cetera.
It is absolutely completely different.
With the tech of the engine now whirring around my head,
I couldn't resist walking through the production line next door
for the engines are built component by component.
The raw materials are sourced from a global supply chain
where it all ends up in here, which is the machine shop.
We've got a line down this side that is for the engine blocks
and another line down this side is for the cylinder heads.
The machining that happens in here
is making sure everything is to JCB standards
and how they want it.
For example, the pattern within the cylinder base.
A certain amount of engine blocks and cylinder heads
are randomly chosen per shift to come into this room
and be measured even more accurately.
Some of the machines in this room are taking measurements
that are sub-micron to add that extra level of accuracy
over the usual gauges and visual inspection.
All of those freshly measured parts make their way through
from the machine shop to the assembly line.
And what's really cool is that internally,
every different line is classed as a customer
to allow for maximum accountability
and zero excuses internally.
Jimbo, over on crankcase assembly,
isn't just some other bloke working on a line.
He is a customer that everyone upstream has to perform for
so that he can do his job as effectively as possible.
Just like we saw in my video at Horse Power Trains,
this production line has photo boosts throughout it
to make sure that everything is as it should be
before it moves on to the next station.
The engine spends two minutes, 45 seconds per station,
any more and the target for the day will be missed.
Let me show you exactly how a JCB engine
goes from its component parts
right through to a fully built engine, step by step.
First up, the engine block is split.
The bearing shells are installed.
There's a quick photo shoot before the crank is installed.
Gasket material is then applied by a robot
to form the perfect sealing pattern
for sealing the crankcase.
The bed plate is torqued down,
followed by a test to make sure that the crank shaft
is spinning as it should.
The gear case has the fuel pump already fitted
and is then sealed up robotically and installed.
Then the single camshaft goes in
and is timed up robotically.
Then comes the bell housing.
The pistons are pre-assembled in-house
with the conrods attached and the rings installed.
They are then inserted in the engine block from this side.
On this side, the end caps are installed
and then everything is torqued down.
The sump is then sealed up and then bolted on.
A piston protrusion test is then undertaken
to make sure that the pistons are reaching the right height
when at top dead centre.
Once that has passed, the head gasket goes on.
At this head station,
the valves and collets are installed again using a robot.
The cylinder head is then lifted onto the engine block
and then it moves down the trackway here
to then be automatically torqued down.
Then in go the rocker arms
before the valve blast is nailed through automation.
In go the injectors followed by the rocker cover.
The front and rear crank seals are then installed
followed by the inlet manifold.
Then goes the turbo and exhaust manifold.
The engine is then tested for any leaks
through a vacuum test for the seals
and then a pressure test for the fuel system.
After that quick blasting, on goes the flywheel.
We're nearly there.
On goes the crank pulley
and we're ending with the starting motor.
One and a half hours after the base engine components
enter the assembly line,
we have our fully built finished engine
that then goes straight into the in-house engine test bed
to be run in.
Most of them are diesels.
The odd one now is hydrogen.
I will never tire of walking up and down
an engine production line,
seeing an engine being assembled
so quickly and yet so accurately
hundreds of times over every day.
Something I didn't realise before I came here
was that out of all the engines
produced here every week,
a percentage of them are for other OEMs
outside of JCB.
For those engines,
the cooling and emissions after treatment tech
are installed in-house
so that it's one neat package
that can slot straight in to another OEM's machines.
The biggest question for most of you guys watching this
will be,
can this hydrogen combustion technology
be usable in cars?
I asked Ryan about this point
to get the full professional answer.
Feasibly, if optimised for it,
could one of these hydrogen combustion engines
sit in a car and perform
like any other diesel or petrol engine?
We see no reason why it couldn't.
You know, the fundamentals of a combustion engine,
you could make a smaller version of that.
You know, you could make a two litre version.
Plenty of businesses have demonstrated the technology
so it's absolutely applicable in an on-highway world.
We naturally look,
given the size and the output of the engines,
we tend to draw parallels more
with the heavy sort of truck industry.
You know, if you were to look at a truck engine stripped down,
a lot of the parts look pretty similar to our engines
and there we think it's got some real potential.
If you're trying to move 40 tonnes of something
a very long distance,
you know, hydrogen combustion could be a great way to do it.
And we know that people who make those kinds of engines
are doing that research, they're working on it.
So it's going to be an interesting few years
to see how it works out, really.
Well, you guys seem to be ahead of the curve.
Do you have automotive companies knocking on the door saying,
can we have a peek at what you guys are doing?
We've certainly spoken to a few.
I think for the automotive guys,
they've got some real difficult decisions to make.
You've got the, you know,
a sort of a rapidly approaching internal combustion engine,
you know, I'm going to say ban, you know, on highway,
you know, push towards something else.
So if you're sat in a car company and you're going,
well, what do I invest in?
Do I do EVs and do I do hydrogen combustion?
Do I, you know, do I do hybrids?
Do I probably need to do it all, frankly?
So it's a real difficult set of decisions
for those guys at the moment.
What we were keen to do,
and one of the things we've succeeded with this engine
is to demonstrate to our sector
and the sort of the, let's say,
the governments of the world who are busy
sort of writing decarbonisation policies for off highway
that there are multiple ways
to achieve that decarbonisation.
And what we were keen to avoid
is that on highway scenario
where legislators have dictated technology
rather than the outcome.
You know, if you dictate the outcome,
which is we don't want any carbon, fine.
There's multiple ways to achieve that.
We know our customers, we know our customers' needs
and we think hydrogen combustion, you know,
ticks all those boxes for our customers.
Which we were really concerned at, you know,
five years ago that they were potentially
just going to say CVs, you know.
If you were on an electric machine,
A, you might have to recharge it,
even if you recharge it once a day or twice a day.
Where do you recharge it from?
Because there's no grid connection.
No, yeah.
So then you end up in the perverse situation
of having to rent in a diesel generator
to recharge your electric machine.
And you go, well, we've definitely failed
in our ambition of net zero if we're going to do that.
So our concept's dead simple.
You have your machines on site.
They're working all day.
And we have a regular, I mean, we call it a milk round,
but a regular kind of round.
You know, you come around with your refueller.
You can refuel up to 16 backhoe loaders
on one of these refuelling trailers.
And then that, because that's towed
behind a truck or a van or whatever,
that can then go and do the 20 mile journey
or so to the refuelling station.
And then be pumped up there.
It's really cool how far you've taken it
and you're showing right guys, industry, this works.
Because I imagine it's a very chicken and egg situation
because everyone says, you know,
the issue with hydrogen is the production of it.
But I guess if you can get this engine out there
and show people it can directly replace diesel,
does that then mean that the people
building the infrastructure will then start to accelerate
because there'll be more demand for it?
Is it that kind of tough battle, chicken and egg?
It's chicken and egg.
I think I definitely agree with you there.
In order to justify the rollout of infrastructure,
you need the demand.
In order to accommodate the demand,
you need the infrastructure.
And this is really where governments
and legislators can help and play their part.
Because some of these big decisions on infrastructure,
they are society-wide decisions
and strategic decisions that governments really have to take.
You need to have a strategy for such things.
What's interesting is when we look across the globe,
India's a great example.
We've got a really strong presence in India as a manufacturer.
We've been there for many, many decades.
Now, India at the moment, well,
India doesn't have any domestic reserves of fossil fuels.
It's got some coal, but in terms of oil and gas,
it has to import all of that energy.
So not just for construction equipment,
for trucks and lorries and cars and everything.
It has to import all of that.
And obviously, from a geopolitical standpoint,
that's quite a tricky situation at the moment.
These days, yeah.
These days, and pretty tough.
But what India as a nation are really enthusiastic about
is the possibility of hydrogen.
Because what India does have,
it doesn't have natural reserves of oil and gas,
but it does have a huge abundance of solar energy.
It's got a massive coastline,
so it's got plenty of water or access to water.
And therefore, you can make your own fuel.
You can make hydrogen.
Really, you know, relatively straightforward.
You know, you use solar energy in terms of solar panels,
electrolysis to make your hydrogen.
And of course, the difference between that
and going down a fully electrified route is
it's quite hard to transport electrons,
but you can create hydrogen, pressurize it,
and move it around the country.
You know, and you can do that via pipelines if you want to,
or you can do it via tankers, fundamentally,
like you would do with petrol or gas.
So we're seeing some really bold moves in places like India,
strategic government moves to say,
we need hydrogen because it's going to help us
in terms of energy security in the future.
You can't make your own oil.
You've either got it or you haven't.
And you can dig it out the ground if you've got it,
but if you haven't got it, you can't make it.
Okay.
But you can make hydrogen.
Ryan, you have this huge line of test cells,
and this one is running a hydrogen engine.
What are you testing for right now?
We use these test cells to test all sorts of things, frankly.
I tend to refer to them as a sort of torture chamber
for an engine, if you like.
One of the party tricks we've got with our dynamometers here
is that they're transient dynamometers.
So they can mimic the load that you might see
on a dynamic application.
So in a car example, that might be going around a street
or a racetrack or something like that.
We can play that back into the dyno
and the dyno will impose that exact load onto the engine.
In our application, we tend to data log a machine
doing re-handling cycles or roading applications.
And again, we can play that into the engine.
So as far as the engine is concerned,
it could be in a machine.
It really sort of doesn't know the difference.
And I'm guessing with these engines,
you don't need any form of emissions package
compared to the diesel engine,
where I imagine that's quite a serious amount of testing
going into that.
Steam, steam.
So in terms of what comes out of the engine,
it's all about what you put into the engine.
So we put hydrogen in and it combusts with the oxygen
and creates H2O, steam, water.
One of the early kind of negative connotations
with hydrogen combustion,
and certainly when we started our development journey
five years ago,
was people talk about oxides of nitrogen.
And really what they're talking about there
is the air that goes into the engine
that we all breathe is approximately 80% nitrogen,
which is most of the time just a harmless inert gas.
But if you get it very, very hot,
it can oxidize with the oxygen and it creates NOx,
which is problematic.
It's an emissionized,
it's a controlled pollutant from petrol engines,
diesel engines, anything in fact.
And it has problems to human health
and all the rest of it.
So it's a bad thing and we don't want to create it.
And so we were concerned about that at the beginning,
but one of the best ways to eradicate NOx
in the combustion chamber
is don't get the nitrogen hot.
So if you don't get it hot enough,
it doesn't oxidize.
And you were saying the leaner you make the mixture,
the cooler it gets.
Exactly.
So that's the sort of secret sauce recipe really,
is by running very, very lean,
you control the combustion from a point of view
of not creating any damage to the engine,
you know, detonation, pinking, pre-ignition.
We also reduce that combustion temperature
below the point where the nitrogen
has got the time to oxidize.
Like any chemical reaction,
it's kind of time at temperature.
So the amount of time it spends in the combustion chamber
is quite short because it's running at 2000 RPM.
And so if you don't get it hot enough,
you don't create the NOx.
By keeping the H2 engine running so lean,
the emissions from it actually end up
containing less NOx than the air we breathe,
less than the background NOx level here in the UK.
Well, I'm very curious about sound.
So right now,
we'll cut to what a diesel JCB engine sounds like.
And then now what a hydrogen JCB engine sounds like.
Ryan, why do those sound different?
It is the fundamental difference
in terms of the combustion system.
So a diesel engine, it's a compression ignition.
Most people understand the diesel cycle.
You take air, draw it into the engine,
compress that air,
and then it's almost right at the top dead centre
when the air is fully compressed,
you then introduce some diesel.
That introduction of diesel
into that hot compressed air,
that initiates combustion in the diesel.
So you get quite an aggressive pressure rise
through the combustion chamber.
That creates that rattle.
And that characteristic knocky sound
that you get from a diesel engine,
particularly an old mechanical diesel engine,
where you can't really control that combustion,
that's the diesel sound,
which we all know.
When you move to a spark ignited engine like hydrogen,
it's quite different.
You compress the air,
but you pre-mix.
So you introduce the hydrogen into that compressed air,
and then you introduce a spark into that
to initiate that combustion.
And you get this progressive flame front, we call it,
that moves across the combustion chamber.
And that allows a much sort of softer pressure rise.
So it's not as aggressive
in terms of the sound that it gives.
And that's the fundamental difference.
And when you listen to a backhoe loader,
a diesel backhoe loader and a hydrogen one
and compare them,
the hydrogen one sounds much more like
a big refined petrol engine.
It's got that characteristic to it,
but of course it's got none of the carbon emissions.
Can we rag this now if we do 6,000 RPM?
You could try.
Could there be a future pathway
for fossil fuelled power engines?
In the not too distant future, probably not.
But solutions like hydrogen combustion
or synthetic fuels could lead a pathway
for internal combustion to stay around.
JCB is throwing the kitchen sink at this solution.
We'll find out in future how it all works out.
With renewable energy costs decreasing,
and therefore the production of hydrogen
coming down with it,
this form of internal combustion
could be about to kick off.
We'll see.
If you like this video, give it a thumbs up,
subscribe for more content just like this.
What's for you won't go by you.
I'll see you in the next one.
