Here's What Pops This Stock Bubble

Wealth Wizards
9 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines a precarious financial loop where private equity firms use life insurance companies to fund the AI boom. By utilizing \"permanent capital\" from policyholders to finance risky AI infrastructure through private credit, these firms shift the potential cost of an AI bubble collapse from investors to retirement accounts and state taxpayers.
So there's a very credible theory that says
this whole stock market right now
is being propped up by AI.
And AI is being propped up by your insurance.
Which means if it fails,
it'll be our money that disappears.
And here's how this works.
If you have a life insurance policy
or something called an annuity or a pension,
there's a rule you might not have heard of.
It's called the State Guarantee Association.
And the rule basically says,
if and when a life insurance company fails,
every other insurance company in your state
is forced to fund that loss and cover the difference.
Now what's interesting is that in most states,
they get that money back as a credit
against their state premium taxes.
This is a graph that shows how this works.
If an insurance company fails,
the competitors get assessed,
and then they get reimbursed with those state tax credits.
But what this means is,
this bailout is not paid for by the industry.
It's paid by the state,
which means it is paid for by you.
And what's happening is that a huge amount of AI debt
has been stuffed into this specific structure.
In fact, there is now more than a trillion dollars of debt
tied to artificial intelligence.
This is debt that was used for things like data centers,
GPUs, and power contracts.
And it's around 15%
of the whole investment grade bond market,
which turns out is even more than the banking sector.
Now, the laws that are supposed to protect
our retirement money from collapsing from these loans
do not apply to these.
Because about a week ago,
the SEC clarified that these are not classified
as asset-backed securities.
Therefore, the same rules of securitization
that were put in place to protect us after 2008
do not apply to them.
What this means then,
is that we don't really know for sure
who's holding all this debt and how bad it might be.
Now, the truth is someone is holding the debt
and there are some clues to what's happening.
Check this out.
This shows that life insurance companies
now hold roughly $849 billion of private credit debt,
about 42% of that whole market.
And the private companies that are involved
in a lot of cases are the same companies
that own the insurance companies buying the debt,
which means the same companies
that are creating this AI debt
are also selling it to themselves.
And if the debt goes bad,
it's gonna be the public that will cover it.
Now, no one can tell us exactly how much AI debt
is stuffed inside of American life insurance companies.
That data is not public for anyone to see
because a lot of it has actually moved offshore to Bermuda
where there's very little disclosure requirements.
But there's over a trillion dollars worth of risk
somewhere in the system.
And the most likely place is an industry
that if it is allowed to fail,
will get covered by state taxpayers automatically.
So I wanna explain exactly how all of this works,
how this could affect the markets,
and why I think this is a very credible theory
that could affect all of our retirement accounts
and investments.
So with that said, let's get into it.
Hi, my name is Andrei Jikh.
Hope you're doing well.
Come for the finance and stay for the AI bubble again.
Now, this is gonna be a very long and complex video,
but I promise it'll all come together.
And I'm gonna keep referencing this one visual
so that you never lose track of where we are.
But this is the structure.
Again, it's complicated,
but I'm gonna untangle it as we go.
This is the flow of money.
I wanna give credit to Daniel Oliver
from Mermican Capital whose research this is based on.
The link is down below to read more.
But his argument is that the money in your 401k
and your pension and your life insurance
is not just sitting somewhere waiting for you.
It's already been invested.
And this is where it went.
Meta, for example, wanted a data center,
cost about $30 billion.
Meta did not want $30 billion debt on its books.
So Meta put in 20% as equity
and an asset manager called Blue Owl put in the other 80.
But Blue Owl doesn't have $24 billion
sitting around either.
So to fund their share, they sold bonds,
$27 billion worth of bonds that don't come due for 24 years.
So somebody has to buy these bonds.
And the biggest buyer took $18 billion of them.
And that buyer is a company that manages money
on behalf of pension funds, endowments,
and insurance companies.
So now Meta gets its data center.
Blue Owl gets its fee.
And the actual risk,
like whether the building full of computers
is still worth anything in 2050,
that gets transferred to a pension fund
or an insurance company,
which is to basically say it ends up with you.
Essentially, this means if this structure fails,
it will most likely get a bailout
because if it fails,
guess who's gonna be the one to pay the price?
It's gonna be the public,
which means we cannot let it fail
or else there will have to be a bailout.
Now, where have we heard all of this before?
2008.
Hold on, haven't we learned from 2008
by having stricter regulation and more transparency?
Yes, but with some exceptions.
See, after the financial crisis,
regulators looked at what went wrong with securitization,
which is this practice of bundling loans
and then selling them to investors as bonds.
There were two problems with securitization.
The first problem was that nobody knew
what was in these things.
If you bought a mortgage-backed bond,
you had almost no idea what loans were inside of it
or how they were even doing.
So the fix for that is called Regulation AB.
Now, Reg AB is the disclosure rule
for asset-backed securities.
It says if they're gonna sell one of these,
they have to tell investors what's inside of it.
There needs to be asset-level detail and ongoing reporting,
which got significantly tightened in 2014,
specifically because of what happened in 2008.
Now, the second problem with securitization
that led to 08 is that before the crisis,
Wall Street ran a model people call originate-to-distribute.
This is where they write a loan, they package it,
they sell it, and they just walk away.
And once they walked away,
it did not matter to them whether the loan ever went bad
because they already got paid.
Their incentive was not to write good loans.
It was to write a lot of loans.
So the fix for that one is called Regulation RR,
risk retention.
It's part of Dodd-Frank.
And the rule says if you package debt
and sell it to investors,
you have to keep 5% of it yourself, with some exceptions.
But hopefully that way,
it discourages them from selling dog poop to people
if they have to eat 5% of it themselves.
That way they're more aligned.
Okay, so those are the rules that we put in place
after 2008 to make sure 2008 doesn't happen again.
And those rules are still enforced today.
But then, a week ago,
a law firm who works on a lot of these
AI securitization deals,
they wrote to the SEC.
And they were like,
we got a question.
Can you clarify?
Do these rules apply for these AI loans?
And the SEC wrote back and said,
now that you mention it,
no, the securitizations of the type you described
are not asset-backed securities.
Why not?
Their reasoning is because an AI data center
is a building, right?
It's a physical asset.
It's not a financial asset that pays down over time
the way a car loan or a mortgage does.
And if it's not an asset-backed security,
well then, Reg AB does not apply.
Reg RR does not apply.
That is partially why it is really hard to understand
what's actually happening
and who's holding all these loans
and if they're good or bad.
So this theory says that the structure we have today
looks a lot like 2008 with a few more steps.
The only difference though,
right now is the thing that's being packaged
is not a mortgage, it's a data center.
And the companies holding the bag at the end
are not the banks, it's the insurance companies
that we all pay for if they fail.
And here's how that would work.
Okay, so before I explain that,
I wanna talk about something
that has nothing to do with money
and everything to do with money, which is health.
So my back's actually been hurting me for a while now
and I did what I think most people do,
which is absolutely nothing about it, for years.
Which is funny because I'll spend hours
reading central bank policies and checking my portfolio
for details that don't really matter.
And I don't think the appointment is the hard part,
it's all that other stuff.
You have to find someone who's in the network,
you have to call during business hours,
which is when you're usually busy,
you get put on hold,
and then they tell you the next appointment
is in four months.
If there's something you've been meaning to get looked at,
you know exactly what I'm talking about.
And that's where today's sponsor, ZocDoc, comes in.
ZocDoc is a free website
where you search local, in-network doctors,
over 150,000 providers across 200 plus specialties
in all 50 states,
you get real patient reviews and detailed profiles,
so you're the one deciding who fits what you care about.
You see actual openings on the calendar
and you click to book instantly.
And I can vouch for this because I finally used it,
I picked someone myself
and I was in the office the next day
and I didn't have to deal with waiting on the phone
and then weeks to see a doctor.
I walked out with a referral the next day after booking,
it was a smooth experience from booking to see a doctor
all the way to the appointment.
And once I was there, they saw me within 30 minutes.
And most appointments happen within 24 to 72 hours,
and sometimes you can get in the same day.
I know clicking a link seems small,
but it's a real step toward taking your health
as seriously as you take investing and everything else.
You can go to ZocDoc.com forward slash Andre,
the link's the first thing
in the description down below as well,
that's ZocDoc.com forward slash Andre.
Thanks to ZocDoc for sponsoring this video
and for helping us all take better care of our health
and now let's get back to it.
So here's how this AI bubble is using life insurance
through private equity.
It is a very complicated, so a fair warning,
here's the part of the chart that we're in right now.
Everything I'm about to explain
is gonna happen on this bottom line.
So here's how it works.
It starts with life insurance companies.
See, I thought life insurance companies
are companies that pay for your family
if and when you're gone.
But it turns out that's the product,
but that is not how they actually make money.
How they make money is,
we pay them a premium every month,
sometimes for 30 or 40 years.
Now, they don't just hold this money in a vault obviously,
they invest it.
And whatever they make on that money
above what they eventually owe us,
that's their profit.
There's a name for this chunk of money,
it's called the float.
But there's something built into this arrangement
that's not fair.
Because when an insurance company invests your money
and it does good,
you don't get more money.
You get exactly what your insurance contract says
because your return is fixed.
And if they make more money than they owe you,
they keep the difference.
Okay, that's fine, right?
But where it's not fair is that if they make less,
that's their problem until it is so much less
that they can't pay you at all.
Then it becomes your problem.
So your upside is capped,
but your downside is not.
Now again, that's okay
when the insurance company managing your money
has no other business.
But there's a huge conflict of interest
as you're about to see.
The trillion dollar question is,
what do they do with the float
while they're holding our money?
Historically, the answer was,
they would put that money into government bonds,
US treasuries and high grade corporate bonds.
Stuff that pays a small, steady, predictable amount.
But then 2008 happened.
So the Federal Reserve lowered interest rates
to basically zero and they stayed there
for the majority of the coming decade.
So if you're an insurance company, this is really bad
because you sold policies to people for years,
promising that they'd get a certain return.
And those promises got a lot harder to keep
when rates went to zero.
So now those safe, boring bonds
that they were relying on for profit
paid them almost nothing.
There's a phrase for what happened next.
It's called reaching for yield.
It means they had to take on more risk
to get you the money they promised.
That's where private equity came in,
which is this box right here.
Step two is, who manages your money?
Which is private equity.
What is private equity?
Private equity is just a business
that buys companies using borrowed money.
But over the last 15 years, they also got into lending.
They started making loans that the banks used to make.
And the problem with that is, if you're gonna be a lender,
you need a huge pile of money to lend.
Ideally, money that doesn't leave.
But a typical private equity fund has a 10-year life,
meaning they raise money, they invest it,
and at the end of 10 years, they have to give it back,
which means every year, they have to raise money again.
They never stop asking for money.
So imagine you're a private equity company
and you look at the insurance business.
That's an opportunity for you
because you're looking at $100 billion
that doesn't leave for 30 years.
It gets topped up every single month by our premiums.
And by law, that has to be invested into something.
That's the kind of business they would like to own.
The industry actually has a word for this.
They call it permanent capital.
And that is why private equity companies
have been buying insurance companies.
Check this out.
According to Oliver's research, from 2009 to 2024,
private equity ownership of life insurance companies
went from basically zero to more than $700 billion
in assets across 134 insurers.
In total, estimates for the amount of insurance money
that private equity controls right now
is at $1.5 trillion.
Now, that's not the bad part.
The bad part is that conflict of interest
because of what they're doing with this money,
which is this, step three.
Step three is private credit,
which started lending our retirement money to themselves
and that has created a conflict of interest.
See, there's a private equity company called Apollo.
It's one of many.
And Apollo owns a life insurance company called Athene.
Athene holds annuities,
which is retirement money, aka regular people's savings.
Now, Apollo's other business is making loans.
So Apollo makes a loan to some company.
Apollo needs someone to buy that loan.
Who buys it?
Athene, the insurance company Apollo owns.
In fact, $227 billion of Apollo's own deals
are inside of Athene.
Now, I know it sounds confusing
because Apollo, the private equity company,
owns Athene, the life insurance company,
so you'd automatically assume
they have one set of interests,
which is to make money for everyone, but it's not.
Apollo makes money for shareholders by collecting fees.
Athene's insurance policy holders get a fixed return,
no matter what happens.
Those are two different groups of people.
And when money moves from Athene over to Apollo,
one group is making money at the other group's expense.
Now, I know that probably still sounds confusing,
so here's an analogy.
Imagine your bank makes a loan to some business, right?
Normally, your bank holds that loan,
and if the business can't pay, that's the bank's problem.
That's why banks are very careful
about who they lend money to.
But in this case, imagine your bank takes that loan
and stuffs it inside of your 401k.
That's not good because they picked the loan.
They decided if the loan was good or not.
They were incentivized,
not necessarily by the quality of the loan,
but by the amount of loans they give out.
They charged a fee for it,
and another fee for managing the 401k that bought it.
Now, if the business fails and goes under,
that's not the bank's money.
The bank already got paid fees,
so that's your retirement money.
Now, if that was really happening,
you'd probably wanna know about it.
Turns out, right now, if you have an annuity,
there's a very decent chance that this is happening.
And that's because it's not just Apollo.
KKR owns Global Atlantic.
Blackstone has stakes in several insurers.
Brookfield owns American National.
They all have these same structures,
roughly $700 billion of it.
If all of this goes wrong and the market blows up,
it's not their money that will disappear.
It's the policyholders, then the guarantee fund,
then the state, and then you.
So now, let's kind of follow the money
and see where it's all really going and what it's funding.
What they're obviously funding is AI.
Here's step four.
This is where your money is ending up,
because AI is super expensive.
All the major tech companies are now spending more
than they make combined.
They're spending more on AI than their whole cashflow,
which is why they're borrowing.
Google raised over $30 billion in debt,
and they issued a 100-year bond,
which is a bond that comes due in the year 2126.
So that's step one.
You create the debt.
Step two is you hide the debt
because they don't want that debt to be seen.
Why?
Because if Microsoft builds a data center,
that's a huge expense on their financial statements,
and their stock will go down.
So they found a workaround.
Somebody else builds it.
A separate company makes it.
Microsoft just signs a contract
promising to rent it for the next several years.
And that promise is what makes
this whole thing financeable, right?
The other company walks into a bank.
It shows them that Microsoft signed this contract,
and that's what allows them
to borrow billions of dollars against it.
Now, that promise does not show up as debt
on Microsoft's balance sheet.
According to Goldman Sachs,
these companies have about $1.5 trillion
in lease commitments,
but $1 trillion of that does not appear
on their balance sheets at all,
which is why, when you look up Microsoft financials,
you're not gonna see a trillion dollars of obligations.
So that's step two.
You hide the debt.
Step three is somebody actually has to lend that money.
And it's not the banks because the banks are regulated.
They have capital requirements.
This is where private credit comes in.
Blackstone, Apollo, KKR, Brookfield,
along with asset managers like BlackRock,
they're all competing for these huge deals.
There's now roughly $1.2 trillion of debt tied to AI.
Now, hold on.
I have a question.
How do you sell one of these bonds
backed by a building full of these computers
to a conservative insurance company?
You need a rating, right?
Insurance companies want good ratings
because a higher-rated bond has a lower capital charge,
meaning the insurer has to hold
less of its own money against it.
Basically, a good rating is permission to buy more.
And some of the biggest asset managers,
including Blackstone and Apollo,
are now amongst the most frequent users
of ratings companies outside the big three.
But one private equity sponsor is now under investigation
over payments to a ratings company.
Two ex-employees sued,
alleging that they were pressured
to inflate those ratings to win business.
Now, they deny this and it's still ongoing,
so keep that in mind.
But step four, the risk gets moved offshore
using something called reinsurance,
which is a fancy way of saying
it's insurance for insurance companies.
That's why Athene moved almost all of its $200 billion
in retirement obligations to its Bermuda affiliate.
Moving liabilities to your own offshore reinsurer
gives you more flexible capital requirements, right?
It gives them different accounting standards
and fewer disclosures.
And it's not just Athene.
According to the BIS,
the Bank of International Settlements,
U.S. life insurers have moved $2.1 trillion in reserves
to these reinsurers.
The share going to offshore reinsurers
went from 14% to 40% since 2017.
So let me tie all this together.
Here's the whole structure.
Your premiums, those monthly payments you make,
those go into an insurance company.
That insurance company is owned by a private equity company.
That company makes loans to data center projects.
The private equity company then sells those loans
to the insurance company that it owns.
The loans are worth whatever their model says it's worth.
The rating comes from a company that the industry is paying
and the liability has been moved offshore to Bermuda
where we can't see it.
And if those loans go bad,
the insurance company takes the hit.
If the insurance company can't cover it,
the guarantee fund does.
And if the guarantee fund pays out,
the other insurers have to cover it.
And then they get that money back
as a credit against their state taxes,
which means the state ultimately absorbs it.
And the state is, of course, your tax dollars.
Okay, so then the question is, how bad is all of this?
And the truth is we don't know,
but we can kind of check.
We got a preview.
Take a look at this.
This is Japan's four biggest life insurance companies.
And they're sitting on about $96 billion worth
of unrealized losses right now.
It's a lot.
Now it's for a completely different reason, to be fair.
It's because Japan had interest rates at zero
for a really long time.
Their insurers bought a huge amount
of Japanese government bonds.
Their rates started going up.
And when rates go up, bonds you already own go down.
So they're underwater.
But Japan kind of has the good version of this problem.
Japan's insurers own their government bonds,
which are safe, boring, liquid,
and they're priced out every single day on the open market.
Our insurers own private loans that don't trade anywhere.
And they're worth whatever their model says they're worth.
And their number is $96 billion.
It's going up.
That's for Japan.
The U.S. doesn't have a number.
We just have Bermuda.
But that's why Japan is so important to the U.S.
That's why we're helping prop up their currency.
Because Japan holds a huge amount of U.S. treasuries.
Their yen, their money is weakening.
They need to buy more of it to keep it strong.
They could sell U.S. treasuries to do that.
So the U.S. is like, please don't do that, Japan.
We will take our U.S. treasuries from you.
Here, we'll sell our European treasury bonds.
Here's some money.
Because if the U.S. does not come to Japan's rescue,
Japan could start dumping U.S. treasuries,
which would then cause interest rates
to go up here in the U.S.
And so everything in this video that I explained
would get even more expensive.
All the private credit and all that debt,
it gets way more expensive
and potentially blows up our markets
because all of this only works under the assumption
that borrowing money stays cheap.
Now, I don't think anyone can tell you
when any of this matters or maybe it won't matter.
Maybe the AI build-out pays off
and the market just keeps on going for another year or two
and none of this is important.
But it feels like we built a system after 2008 specifically
so we could see this stuff coming.
And it seems like bit by bit, we kind of recreated it
just with different characters
and with a little more extra steps.
So time will tell what happens.
If you wanna learn more about what's happening with Japan,
I made that video specifically.
You can watch somewhere up here.
And if you wanna know how I'm personally thinking about this
from an investment perspective
and what I'm doing with my own money,
you can watch those videos in the premium member section
where I post my extra thoughts and I post the day early.
If that's valuable to you, the link is down below.
Thank you so much for watching this video.
It's very long and very confusing and I know that,
but I hope some of it made a little bit of sense.
I hope you have a wonderful rest of your day.
Smash the like button, subscribe if you haven't already.
I'd love to see you here next time.
Let me know your thoughts.
I'll see you soon.
Bye-bye.
