Why Mystery Men Was Ahead Of Its Time!

Truth exists
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Before comic book movies were a standard household genre, Ben Stiller and Universal Pictures were
working on a superhero story packed with high-profile casts, a massive studio budget,
and some of the industry's best talent behind the camera. And, oddly enough, it totally bombed.
The movie is, of course, 1999's Mystery Men, and its path from weird indie comic book to
huge studio gamble makes it one of the most interesting stories in superhero cinema.
In today's episode, we look back on 1999's Mystery Men, we'll take a look at the comic
book that inspired it, and of course the troubled production and on-set clashes that took this movie
from being an ambitious idea to a massive box office disappointment, and eventually all the
back around to cult classic home video favorite. Basically, today we're going to talk about
why Mystery Men was just ahead of its time. Let's get into it.
Okay, so for those of you who don't know, Mystery Men follows the story of a group of suburban
friends who moonlight as crime-fighting vigilantes in the fictional setting of Champion City. After
the city's most sinister villain is released from his asylum and plots to destroy the town,
the friends must recruit a team of cheap, dime-store superheroes and band together to
take on this horrific threat. The movie stars Ben Stiller as Mr. Furious, William H. Macy as
the Shoveler, Hank Azaria as the Blue Raja, and names like Kel Mitchell as Invisible Boy, Janine
Garofalo as the Bowler, Paul Rubens as the Spleen, Greg Kinnear as Captain Amazing, and of course,
Jeffrey Rush as the movie's villain, Casanova Frankenstein.
Honestly, there are so many good actors in this movie and faces like Tom Waits and
Eddie Izzard, but we'd be here all day if I sat down and named them all.
The film is loosely based on Bob Burden's wacky Dark Horse comic book called The Flaming Carrot,
which features the Mystery Men as a supporting group of characters that were intentionally
lame and underpowered. And in 1997, when modern superhero movies were mostly still
unknown territory, Dark Horse publisher Mike Richardson pitched a concept to producers Larry
Gordon and Lloyd Levine in 97. They were interested in the idea and found the characters and themes of
persisting against all odds to be quite charming, but they knew that a movie like this would be
a huge risk. I mean, these were characters without any name recognition for the most part,
and they have these weird powers like super farting or just being incredibly mysterious.
That's it? That's his power? He's mysterious?
A little bit mysterious.
But what's important here is the timing of all of this. This movie was being pitched at the same
time that Universal and other big studios were buying and developing movies for other comic book
properties, things that were much more popular than Flaming Carrot at the time. Films like Blade,
The X-Men, and a James Cameron Spider-Man movie that was well on its way into development with
Leonardo DiCaprio. However, Universal optioned to do Mystery Men, and they hired family comedy
screenwriter Neil Kuthbert to draft up the script. The studio knew that in order to make these
lackluster characters more likable, they would need the right blend of comedic talent and dramatic
talent to fill the call sheet. Originally, Danny DeVito was offered nearly 15 million dollars to
star in and direct the movie, and DeVito was hot off the success of Matilda, one of the best,
if not the best, Roald Dahl adaptation ever made, and they knew that he had the comedic
chops to lead the cast. However, despite wanting to do it, DeVito declined the gig,
and apparently all over Universal's refusal to give him control over the movie's soundtrack.
But you know what? Maybe that's a good thing, because contrary to popular belief,
the song All Star by Smash Mouth was originally written for Mystery Men. I know we all think of
Shrek when we hear it, but no, this movie got there first. With DeVito out, Universal pitched
Ben Stiller the idea. They asked him to give the comedy a pass and to punch up the jokes and add
some adult edge. They even courted him to direct the movie himself, which he did turn down doing
after being overwhelmed by the scope of the project. However, he was happy to help rewrite
some of the script and, of course, act in the movie. Eventually, Universal found their director
in Kinka Usher, who you probably have never heard of, because this is his only feature film. At the
time, he was a commercial director and B-movie cinematographer. But I do have to say that the
direction of this movie does not come off as amateur in any way, with the entire production
having a charming grunge that's really well balanced with how polished and bright the visuals
can be. I mean, this movie looks good. What Usher brought to the development of this project was his
sense of style that his past in commercials had given him. Things like Joel Schumacher-inspired
architecture and neo-futuristic set pieces. This movie is not boring to look at. However, Kinka did
find some of the script to be quite boring and encouraged a significant amount of improv from
the actors while filming. The comedy of this movie and the chemistry and dynamics between the
characters is so authentic, organic, and believable. They all have such distinct personalities and they
all interact with each other differently, which creates this sense that every character is the
main character of the movie. I love this about Mystery Men. It's a big praise that the movie
gets now as a cult classic. The ensemble cast was the core of what makes this movie work.
Oh, oh, I get it. So your shovel and his face is my project-
You threw a spoon at the guy, Jeff.
Stiller, Hank Azaria, Paul Rubens, and Janine Garofalo were especially involved when it comes
to reworking dialogue and character beats. Approaching scenes almost like a sketch comedy
workshop inside of a big effects movie. They were also able to get input from Bob Burden himself,
as he spent a lot of time pitching ideas and helping people out on the set of the movie.
We all had a lot of freedom. Kinka gave us a lot of freedom
to experiment with our characters, both before we were shooting and on the day.
These characters are incredibly dorky and lame, but also fascinating because of the
actors that play them. Like, for example, Paul Rubens plays The Spleen, and he's like a
version of Shaggy from Scooby-Doo whose superpower is farting. But somehow, it is awesome.
And like Kel Mitchell, he plays a character that can turn invisible,
but it's completely conditional because he can only become invisible
if nobody is looking at him anyway.
So you can only become invisible when absolutely nobody is watching you?
But having Kel Mitchell play this role straight and earnestly the way he does,
and then having this weird conditional superpower work its way into the story
as a severe moment of importance? That is pure brilliance.
However, the production was not without its issues. With the script constantly being
altered on the day of shooting, and frustrations around the studio beginning to poison everyone's
faith in the movie, the production lasted from October 1998 and ran all the way until April 1999.
This is much longer of a shoot than anybody had expected it to be,
and of course, it caused the movie's budget to increase as it went on.
Ben Stiller said in a 1999 interview that he expected it to be, quote,
quick, and didn't realize how long the movie would take to film.
Much of this is due to the movie's practical sets and locations, which took especially long
to create and build. This movie holds up, for the most part, because of the long hours that
went into building these practical sets and locations. Although I do have to admit,
some of the CGI in this movie was a little bit shoddy.
Janine Garofalo noted during production that many of her effects-heavy shots were essentially
her hitting very specific marks and poses so that CG teams could layer in a physical bowling ball
in post. This emphasizes how disconnected the acting is sometimes from the final result.
But to be honest, all of that stuff in the movie still looks really good. But like the
scene where they accidentally fry Captain Amazing when they're trying to rescue him,
that stuff looks pretty bad.
Something very interesting about this movie that we couldn't have known then but is very apparent
now, is how well this movie parodies like a hundred other superhero movies that didn't even
exist yet. For example, the idea of corporate-sponsored superheroes that we love seeing
in things like The Boys or Superman 2025, well, Captain Amazing did it first. And with Pepsi,
nonetheless. Or like we love when Superman acknowledges that just wearing glasses and
making him look like Clark Kent is kind of a silly idea, and this movie went there way before that.
Did you find it weird when Tony Stark, a grown man,
showed up in the apartment of a 15-year-old Peter Parker to recruit him to the super team?
This movie went there. Or how we adore the X-Men and their interpersonal dynamics that
make them feel more like a super-powered family than superheroes. And this movie was already
doing it. It is fascinating just how ahead of the curve this movie really is. It was
parodying something that we didn't even know we were going to be sick of yet. But
that was kind of the problem. All the things I just mentioned are much more relatable now
than they were to audiences in 1999. These days, we crave something unique and something more than
just CGI concrete sludge with rubbery renditions of our favorite heroes slinging random energy
beams at each other. And this movie knew that we'd be sick of it long before we knew.
Its greatest strength is telling a grounded story about lonely underdogs who learn to lean on each
other to save the city and, really, to save themselves. Also, Marvel would never have the
balls to have a gang of serial killers who call themselves the Disco Boys. But either way, when
the movie was finally released in the summer of 1999, it failed to find success at the box office,
bringing in a humble $33.5 million on a budget of more than double that. Despite receiving mainly
positive reviews, the movie didn't gain the traction that it needed to make a profit,
and it sadly faded into ultimate obscurity. Variety called it heavy on the laughs but
ultimately tiresome over two hours. Newsday compared it to a smart comic review that
exalts weird and mundane. Other critics predicted that, unfortunately accurately,
it would become a cult classic on the level of movies like Brazil or Buckaroo Banzai.
But maybe the cult shelf is really where this movie belongs. I like to watch this when I'm
in the mood for something like The Phantom or The Rocketeer. It's got the charm and colorful
visuals of a 90s superhero movie and performances that make you care about the tender and heartfelt
story at the center of it. Mystery Men is a movie about lovable losers trying to matter
in a world that doesn't accept them. Fittingly, the production itself was an underdog and a little
bit messy. It was a stressful fight for a totally offbeat vision inside of a studio system that
never quite knew how to sell it. So the movie bombed. It hurt the studio's bottom line,
and it caused the director to never make another movie again. And yet, like The Shoveler,
it's a movie that just keeps digging. Mystery Men has kept going, and it kept fighting the good
fight all the way until we accepted it as a cult classic movie that is worthy of an annual rewatch.
It found its people slowly, scene by scene, over late night cable runs and VHS rentals,
until the culture caught up and realized that this strange 1999 misfit movie
had been quietly predicting the future of superhero cinema.
If you're interested in the evolution of superhero movies over time,
this movie is like a chapter that you can't afford to skip. Its risky and chaotic production
ended up making it into the special thing that it is today. All I'm saying is, Mystery Men? It's
worth another look, especially if you're one who's dealing with a little bit of superhero fatigue.
And it just goes to show you that sometimes the superhero movies that are mocked or don't work
at first are the ones that end up sticking around and being talked about the longest.
And folks, that is why 1999's Mystery Men was completely ahead of its time. Have you seen this
movie? Do you like this movie? And if you've seen it any time recently, do you agree with my
assessment? I mean, it's basically a parody or commentary or satire, whatever you want to call
it, on superhero cinema long before any of these trends or tropes or cliches had even been
established. For that reason, I gotta say, this movie totally worth re-watching. I love the cast,
I love the story, and I just think that it's fun to look at. This is definitely a 90's movie,
but not in a bad way. Anyway guys, that's all I got for you today. Make sure you like the video
if you liked it, subscribe if you haven't already, and I will be seeing you in the next one.
Good night, everyone.
