The American Revolution produced a lasting republic, now in its 250th year. But is it still the country the founders envisioned? Claremont Review of Books editor Charles Kesler joins associate editor Spencer Klavan to review the CRB’s summer 2026 edition, including Kesler's own essay on the principles and lasting success of our revolution as distinguished from its English and French counterparts. Other essays in the issue include Christopher Flannery on Benjamin Franklin's advice for the common man, Andrew Roberts on the clashes between Churchill and de Gaulle, and much more!
Chapters 00:00 Introductions 01:33 Three Declarations, Three Revolutions 11:15 Benjamin Franklin's Advice for the Common Man 20:51 Comments on Ken Burns's The American Revolution 30:30 Retrospective on Summer Blockbusters - The Odyssey, Obsession, and More 33:43 On Wine, Rudolf Steiner, and Astrology 36:03 Closing Remarks
This episode of *The Close Read* podcast previews the summer 2026 issue of the *Claremont Review of Books*, themed \"America at 250.\" Host Spencer Clavin and editor Charles Kessler explore the American tradition, comparing the American Revolution to the English and French experiences, analyzing the pragmatic legacy of Benjamin Franklin, and reviewing various cultural and scholarly contributions.
Hello, and welcome back to The Close Read, the official Claremont Review of Books podcast.
I'm your host, Spencer Clavin, Associate Editor of the Claremont Review of Books,
and we're here to inaugurate a new issue, volume 26, number 3. This is our summer
2026 issue, and it's the America at 250 issue. The time has come when the issue should already
be in your mailbox if you're a subscriber. If you're not, of course, you can always become
one by going to claremontreviewofbooks.com. But if you're not yet persuaded, hopefully you will
be by the ensuing conversation with our fearless leader and editor, Charles Kessler. Charles,
always nice to see you. Yes, thank you, Spencer. Great to be here. And we should mention you can
buy a copy of the Claremont Review of Books at many bookstores and newsstands if there happen
to be any still existing near you. True. Yes. Well, exactly. As I understand it, bookstores
are making a small, modest comeback as people get less and less excited about the digital world. So
you may well be able to find a physical copy in your local bookstore, and you can write by them
individually, issue by issue. You don't have to be a subscriber or go online. Although,
of course, we'd welcome your subscription. So this is, as I mentioned at the top, our
semi-quincentennial commemorative CRB. You could call it our first quarter millennium,
if you're being optimistic, like our friend Jeff Anderson. But we've got five, no fewer than five
pieces up at the top on the front of this one to approach and discuss a variety of... approach the
American tradition, let's say, from a variety of different angles. First and foremost, we should
talk about the lead essay written by none other than one Charles R. Kessler. And it just so happens
we have him here in the room. So Charles, The Declaration and American Exceptionalism is an
essay which previously was published in a slightly modified form. Here, we've given it the title
Three Declarations, Three Revolutions. And so you're talking about the English, American,
and French revolutions and discussing the differences among them in a way that I think
is very clarifying for the uniqueness of the American Revolution and perhaps also its
durability. But I'm sure you can speak much more eloquently to your own essay than I can.
And I'm wondering if you want to say a little bit about what occasions this essay... when it was
first... when you first wrote it, and then how you think it's held up in the intervening time.
Well, it was written during the bicentennial season. That's at the end of the last century,
you know, in 1976 until 19, I guess you could say, 89. If you're talking about the bicentennial,
not just of the Declaration of Independence, but also of the Constitution. And that in 1989
would bring you also to the bicentennial of the French Revolution, which was 1789,
and also at least an anniversary for the English Revolution and the English Declaration of Rights
in the 17th century. So the essay was originally in an academic volume from Peter Lang Publishers,
with a bunch of essays by a very interesting and stimulating set of historians and political
theorists about those three great beginning points of modern politics, the English Revolution,
both in 1640, both the first installment, you might say, of it, and then the second installment
in 1688, the famous Glorious Revolution, or the Bloodless Revolution, as it's sometimes
called, which has a more direct connection, you might say, to America. And then, of course,
the American Revolution, centering on the Declaration of Independence, 1776. And then
the last great modern, well, the last great 18th century modern revolution, the French Revolution,
1789. Each one of them, very different, but each one, beginning, interestingly, with a declaration,
a declaration of rights, a declaration of independence, and in the French case,
a declaration of the rights of man and citizen. So each one of these great revolutions,
which contributes to some, you know, in different ways to modern politics,
modern Republican politics, one could say, with a small r, began, however, by
announcing a set of principles. And the sets overlap to some extent, but really head in
different directions. And my essay, in its revised version, slightly shortened,
and perhaps made a little bit pithier for our CRB readers, who are, after all, paying customers,
and deserve the pithiest product we can give them. The three revolutions coincide with three
tendencies in modern politics, which we could still point to and talk about. And the English
Revolution makes no mention of natural rights. The only kind of rights in the English Declaration of
Rights are the ancient rights of the kingdom, the ancient contracts that underlies their form of
government. Ours is emphatically a declaration of natural rights. All men are created equal,
endowed by their creator with certain unalienable rights, as our declaration says. And then we have
the tough case of the French Revolution, which is also emphatically a revolution of natural rights.
Of philosophy, you might say. But which, you know, goes in a very different trajectory from ours.
It basically radicalizes, it turns into, it spills an ocean of blood again and again and again in
waves. It finds no stability, so to speak, until Napoleon comes on the scene and the revolution
is effectively over. So it's, the French have had to number their revolutions,
America has not. We like to think at least we've had one revolution and it was very successful,
and we're still living in the republic that it created. That's, I mean, I think that's true
for the most part, but it's not uncontroversial. A lot has changed in American politics,
and so the extent to which we are still the same republic is disputable these days.
But anyway, my piece on the three revolutions is designed to figure out what's unique to the
American experience and to the American principles. And one of the things I argue
is that even though we share a certain kind of natural rights orientation with the French,
mostly the principles, even the high principles, you might say, of America and France
are different. And theirs are more Rousseauian, more like the French Enlightenment.
Ours are more Lockean and pre-Lockean, more like the English Revolution, a little bit at least,
more like America. A peaceful experiment that fell apart only once in the Civil War,
and that was a spectacular failure, of course, but we managed to put the Union together and
come out the other side of it in a way that the French never quite did.
And again, although there might be some who would dispute this, we typically say that
our Civil War ended up maintaining or reinstating the existing Constitution
rather than amounting to an actual change in the government.
Yes, we like to think we came out with a more perfect Union just as we went in.
Exactly so. Yeah, you could almost put these three polities and declarations on a spectrum,
since those are very popular these days. You could have kind of a sliding scale,
beginning with the English on the one side and the French on the other side, where the English are
sort of rooted and locked into this very historicized idea of their rights and their
traditions, and the French have just blasted off into the stratosphere with this highly abstracted
and universalized, and as you point out, depersonalized idea of rights, so all written
in the third person. And then the balancing act, as you put it, of the American experiment is kind
of to sit prudentially in the middle of those two things, which ironically, since that sounds more
like a precarious position, has actually proven a more durable and pacific way to go about things.
Yes, as you put it, I hadn't really registered that we could technically be celebrating this
whole 250th episode until, what, 2039, if we wanted to. Why not?
So if you feel like the 250th has let you down, don't worry, you have another
episode, another chapter of it coming pretty soon, so just hang on.
Yeah, it's like people who celebrate their birthdays for weeks on end because they have so
many different events. We can do that too, I think, for America. And we've certainly,
in this issue, we've got a number of pieces, not just yours, but there's Christopher Flannery
on Benjamin Franklin, which I've enjoyed hugely. The title we gave to this one is
Our Happiest Founding Father. As you point out, there's perhaps less nude sunbathing in this
than one might have expected, but lots of other great stuff, including this wonderful evaluation
of Franklin by Mark Twain, who just detested the moralism of his precepts, like early to bed and
early to rise. Flannery writes, "...had brought the young Twain sorrow beyond reckoning and was
primarily responsible for his present state of general debility, indigence, and mental aberration."
But Flannery gives us a slightly more favorable view of Franklin throughout this piece.
There's something just immensely charming about the character of Franklin, and I think it's
interesting that he's appeared for us in this 250th moment. You, of course, are interested a
great deal in your essay on Jefferson, and I was thinking about this sort of disputes among
Jefferson, Adams, and Hamilton, and even Madison, when it came to these questions of natural law.
Would you say that Franklin had a theory of these questions, or was he more interested
in slightly other concerns? What's your understanding of how Franklin views the
political philosophy of the Revolution? Well, Franklin speaks very occasionally of natural
rights, mostly in the context of slavery and the denial of natural rights. And, of course,
one of the first great anti-slavery advocates in America. But you're correct to put your finger on
a difference between him and the others. He doesn't really talk about natural rights very much
in a sort of philosophical way, not nearly as much as Madison or Jefferson, or for that matter,
I would say, even Adams and Hamilton. Franklin is an empiricist. He's very interested in history.
He's very interested in what has happened and why it has happened. And although they're all
like that, they're all interested in the past, of course. He is not, despite spending a long
time in France and being a diplomat in England and in France for the United States, he's not
that interested in high philosophy, high Enlightenment philosophy. He's interested in
science, but as an experimentalist more than a theorist, you might say, or as a man whose
theories have to be confirmed and invite confirmation by, you know, experiments.
So in that sense, he is a little different. I mean, each one of those founders has a style
intellectually and personally. And what Flannery talks about, Flannery, who is, of course, our
great expert on Mark Twain as well as on Ben Franklin, is the personality, you might say,
of Benjamin Franklin and how he not only lived his life, but how he described his life,
how he, you know, the autobiography, which is what a lot of this piece, Flannery's piece on
Benjamin Franklin, is about. Franklin's autobiography is a kind of story of his
self-creation. And it's, you know, it's, there's a kind of the public Franklin described in the
autobiography. And then there is the other Franklin who is on the edges of the autobiography,
but is not the subject of it. That's the Franklin who's the scientist, who is the
experimenter, who is the printer, publisher, entrepreneur, and who is the who is a great man
in many ways. But the story he wants to tell in the autobiography, which Flannery has great fun
with, is the story of how Franklin is an ordinary man and can give advice to ordinary men to be
happier, to be wiser, wealthier, and, you know, to live longer and better lives. And it doesn't,
you don't have to be Franklin. You don't have to be a genius to achieve any of those things.
You just have to follow the advice he gives you in the autobiography.
Yes. If you were being flippant, you could call him the first lifestyle influencer in America.
It's a self-help book, but written by someone who is not your normal self-help book writer.
Right. No, it's, I found particularly interesting, you know, you mentioned that each of the founders
has a style, which of course is true, and they each also represent a slightly different strain
of 18th century thought, European thought. With Franklin, I think you're, as you say,
you're getting this delight in empirical science. You're getting the kind of rationalist
tradition, but also the sturdy kind of daily virtues that became a big part of the American
ethos. And we get in this essay, some wonderful kind of comparisons and quotations from D.H.
Lawrence, who, like Twain, was kind of appalled at Franklin's aphorisms and his moral advice.
He said they were for the poor and vulgar to profit by. And as you say, that's precisely
the point. Flannery writes, Franklin's autobiography did pave the way for respect
for the working man and acknowledgement of the dignity of working for a living enterprise
industry frugality, making it, taking the main chance and getting ahead were made
respectable by Franklin's example. Yeah, no, I think that's right. Flannery is right about that.
You know, Franklin, for Franklin, you could say the rights of man are true, but not that
interesting. I mean, what what he finds interesting is what ordinary people with
rights can do with those rights, how they can how they pursue their interests, how they pursue
happiness. And they need a lot of advice, as it turns out, on how to use these rights wisely,
prudently and and even part, you know, enjoyably. And so, you know, Franklin is one of the great
joke tellers among the founders. He had a sense of humor which everyone acknowledged and which,
you know, Flannery lauds and describes, even though neither Twain nor D.H. Lawrence found it
in their in their portraits of of Franklin. But, you know, if you if if you were to ask yourself
which founding father could tell a joke the best, you know, it's not going to be Washington.
It's probably not going to be, you know, Hamilton, nor is it going to be. I mean,
Adams actually has a great sense of humor. Not I would imagine he is witty rather than a
jokester, though, you know, but Franklin is a little bit more like a guy who can get up
in a room and tell a bunch of jokes and, you know, crack the whole room up
and and suddenly maybe even leave a lesson from the jokes for the for the audience.
No, it's just a part of why I think he was so beloved in France is he was not only this
learned man and a great compiler of of data, but right. A great at parties,
basically, and incredibly popular in high society. Yeah, this is important.
Well, we should mention as well these there's so much in here about the 250th.
The great Alan Gelso has a very subtle and interesting review of Aquila Mars latest book
on the Constitution. Aquila Mars, somebody who was teaching it at Yale while I was there,
and writes a great deal of kind of public facing books on mostly constitutional law.
I think this is part of a series Born Equal Remaking America's Constitution from 1840 to 1920.
Yes, that's right. That's right. Did you take any courses from him when you were at Yale?
I sat in on a few lectures. I didn't. It's because constitutional law wasn't my
specialty. I didn't I didn't want to get a grade in it, but I did. I did. I did sit in and I had
some friends who were great devotees of his and really thought he was the bee's knees.
So Gelso is respectful here in this review, but also takes issue with some of his
reading of the Constitution, which I found very interesting. And
Gelso is just always so learned on these on these topics.
Yes, and both Gelso and Aquila Mars notice a lot of details, which, you know, add up to quite a bit
when you connect them up, connect all those dots. And I think, you know, Aquila Mars is a liberal
originalist, which is not as that's not as rare a species as you might think. But he's proud of
being an originalist of a sort, not the Scalia kind of originalist or the, you know, Clarence
Thomas kind, to be sure. But but a consistent sort of progressive originalist, which if you're
going to be a progressive, it's a better kind of progressive to be, I'd say. Yes, absolutely.
We are all originalists now. I think probably when Amar began writing, that was a more unusual
thing to be than it is perhaps now. Yes. But yeah, I think you're right. I think that's right.
And we also have Martha Bayless in this issue writing on Ken Burns's recent
massive documentary on the American Revolution. Yes, I'm surprised how much she liked it actually.
You can see somewhere right now streaming or if it's not on PBS live, it's on PBS streaming,
I'd say. Yes, it's streamable. And I was encouraged and interested to see how much
Martha liked this documentary. I had heard it being sort of attacked for basically adopting
the 1619 view of history or at least featuring it prominently. But apparently I don't know if you
have you seen this huge? I have not. I have not seen the Ken Burns documentary. I will eventually,
but I have not yet. You know, I have to leave room for the Odyssey.
That's important. Yes. Well, I believe Martha Bayless will be writing for us about the Odyssey
in the next issue and as will I a little bit. So there's lots to be said on that.
Something to look forward to. Yes. There you go. Right. Good reason to subscribe for
two essays or treatments of the of the Odyssey coming up in the is that the fall issue, I guess,
of this Claremont Review. And we have one other we should mention the fifth of the five essays
on America at 250, which is Justin Dyer's review of Matt Spaulding's new book, a sort of historical,
cultural treatment of the Declaration of Independence called The Making
of the American Mind. And I've read I've read this book by my old friend and student,
Matt Spaulding, and it's very good, very well written and wonderfully researched there.
I learned all sorts of things. Stories from Tocqueville's letters about attending a 4th of
July, you know, ceremony in Albany, New York. I mean, I had I'd never seen that letter before,
but it's very it's very moving as a tribute to sort of what Americans thought about
the 4th of July, even in 1831 or so, 1829, whenever he was in Albany, but he was there.
And the few last veterans of the Revolutionary Army are paraded through town at this 4th of
July parade and received great, you know, passionate tributes from the speakers and the
audience. The last living connection to the Revolution or the Revolutionary War, at least.
But anyway, this is a great piece as well. Now, overall, as you say, let me ask you as a
classicist, so semi-quincentennial, what we're calling this party, is that really a Latin word?
Okay, well, actually, I've been joking that you only call it the first quarter millennium if
you're an optimist. Yes. But in fact, there's optimism built into the etymology of the word
semi-quincentennial as well, because it really means half of 500 years. And that implies, at
least, that we're only halfway to our most glorious anniversary yet, which none of us,
of course, will live to see unless they succeed in uploading our brains into robots or something.
I think this is what you would call an instance of neoteric diction that is making up words,
basically. I don't know of any loci or places where you can find the word semi-quincentennial
in Latin texts, but maybe I'm wrong. We'd have to search some of the databases.
You're right. It is an optimistic term because, you know, not many republics make it to 500.
And here we are celebrating ourselves for having made it halfway to 500. I mean,
the Roman Republic more or less made it to 500. But of course, it was falling apart and becoming
an empire in that last century. So it's not a solid case for the 500-year republic.
But as you say, our friend Jeff Anderson prefers the term quarter millennial, which means we're a
quarter of the way to the thousand-year republic. And that, I mean, while that may be true in some
sense, it certainly leaves a long way to go. That's right. That's right. Well, the Christians
might call that a pious hope that we could see the thousandth anniversary of America.
Yes. I think if you overlay our history onto Roman history and imagine that we are,
you know, due for a 500-year trajectory, then where we are in the progression is a little bit
unsettling. Like we're due, I think, for a Punic war or something, some giant international global
conflagration. But let's hope that that's not how history works. We should also say that there are
pieces in here besides the 250th pieces. Lots of them, in fact. There's a lovely essay on Melville,
which I read aloud for our listeners. If you're interested in that, you can find that on your feed.
We've got this great piece, Parallel Lives, by Andrew Roberts, which is about a book on
Winston Churchill and Charles de Gaulle. I had not, I don't know if you were familiar with all
of these anecdotes that he trots out about the passionate and sometimes intense sort of rivalry
between these two men and their disagreements. I knew some of them, but not all of them.
It's a very Plutarchian book, apparently, and a very Plutarchian review. So there's a lot of
amusing anecdotes in it, eye-opening anecdotes as well. And there's a new French book on de Gaulle,
which I commissioned a review of from a friend a few weeks ago, and we won't see that for an issue
or two, but there is a big new French book on a biography of Charles de Gaulle.
So we can look forward to that. And a two-part biopic, I think, also. Yes, and not just books,
new media. Yes, radical innovation. Yes, exactly. Well, we've got Odysseus on screen,
we've got de Gaulle on screen. It's been a very, actually, a genuinely interesting
summer for movies, as it turns out. I haven't heard anything about the Mandalorian movie.
Have you seen that? Yes, I think people are keeping a tender silence.
I mean, Baby Yoda was a big thing. But where did Baby Yoda go?
I know Grogu, the adorable Grogu, who does feature in this movie. But, well, you know,
this was a movie that was supposed to be a season of the show before that plan got scuttled,
and it feels like it. It's a jumble of various episodes, some fun, some less fun.
And it was kind of an intriguing — you won't find this discussed in the CRB issue, so that's why
you have to come to the podcast to hear the extras — but it was an intriguing moment. This was
supposed to be one of the big tentpole blockbusters of the summer, the Mandalorian, the He-Man,
Masters of the Universe movie, and then The Odyssey. And of those, only The Odyssey has
actually succeeded financially. The Mandalorian flopped badly, as did He-Man, whereas these sort
of younger YouTube filmmakers who made two big horror movies, Backrooms and Obsession,
sort of surged ahead. Oh, and Disclosure Day. Steven Spielberg's Disclosure Day also did not do
very well and was not well-received. Oh, I saw that one at least.
Okay, and did you enjoy it? Yes, I thought — you know, I think he is a crowd-pleaser
as a moviemaker, and this is a crowd-pleasing picture. I mean, all the themes will be
familiar to anyone who's seen E.T., the Extra-Terrestrial, or the other one
from his earlier days. But still, you know, it's moving in certain ways and
interesting throughout, I thought. Yeah, I definitely enjoyed being in the theater and then
enjoyed it less and less as I left the theater. The more time elapsed and I looked back,
I thought, that movie didn't really make any sense at all. But that's perhaps not the point.
Yeah, I certainly didn't regret going to see it. But yeah, it was part of this trend that
Mandalorian and He-Man and Avengers Doomsday is coming out, and that will either be part of this
trend or buck the trend if it succeeds. In any case, perhaps that's a retrospective on the summer
movies as a piece we should commission. Come for the book reviews, stay for the movies.
That's right. Come for the movie chat. Before we have to close out, I just want to mention
this piece, Wine Lunacy, by Sam Schneider, who is our new Backpage Wine columnist.
And he deals — somehow in this short essay, Schneider manages to touch upon about five of my
personal weird niche obsessions. He starts with Hesiod, the Greek poet Hesiod, makes his way
through Rudolf Steiner, the occultist and cult figure who inspired one of my favorite writers,
Owen Barfield. On the way, we get wine, grapes buried in the soil, and fertilizer in bull horns.
I mean, this is really a tour de force. Plus, you get some wine recommendations out of it.
No, that's right. I mean, Sam is, of course, he works for the Encounter Books, which is a
noble book press, book publisher in New York, and publisher of many conservative and historical
books of one kind or another, several large ones you have yourself reviewed recently in the Claremont,
in earlier issues of the Claremont Review. But I must say, Schneider, Sam Schneider,
has the amazing ability not to write a typical wine review column. I mean, you do learn about
some wines and how they're made and if they're good or not and why, but you also learn a lot
many other strange things, which are delightful. And he's a very unusual and, I think,
brilliant wine columnist in his own right. He writes a different kind of wine column
than you'll see anywhere else. Yes. No, absolutely. And worth, I think, the price of the issue to get
to the back page and find this gem of an essay. It also touches on astrology and astronomy,
another of my favorite weird obsessions. Yes, that's right. That's right. So there you go.
And whole foods as well. Well, we should, since that's the back page and since we're out of time,
we should wrap this up. Charles, it's been a delight as ever. And I will mention just once
more, first of all, that you can go to ClaremontReviewOfBooks.com if you are not already
a subscriber, but you've listened to us. If you've listened to us all the way through and
you're not itching to subscribe, I don't know what to tell you. That's a problem with your own taste.
You can become a subscriber and you can also join at ClaremontInstitute.substack.com. You
can sign up for Claremont Digital Plus, which is where you get not just our typical online
offerings, but also extra episodes of this podcast and our other podcasts, the Roundtable
of the American Minds podcast. You can comment on our articles, which means that if you're mad at me
about my opinions about the Odyssey movie, you can actually write in and tell me how mad you are. So
if you want to pay for that privilege and many others, go to ClaremontInstitute.substack.com.
That's it for us this time around, and we will talk to you next time.
Thank you.