The system that produces the world’s most important discoveries runs on metrics that nobody agrees on, odds that would stop most people, and mentorship that sometimes looks like cruelty in blue ink. Subscribe if you want science with evidence, not speculation.
Lipomi is Professor and Chair of Chemical and Sustainability Engineering at the University of Rochester and the author of Science Nonfiction: Behind the Scenes in University Research. His lab works on organic electronics, materials science, recyclable polymers, and the science of human touch. He trained under George Whitesides at Harvard, one of the most cited chemists who has never won the Nobel Prize.
The conversation covers the H-index, what elite mentorship actually looks like when your advisor writes “This is illiterate” in blue ink on your outline, and what the future of academic research versus industry careers looks like in an era of AI, demographic headwinds, and graduate school debt that can’t be discharged in bankruptcy. We also get into homochirality, OLED displays, and why Lipomi thinks the nanotechnology revolution already happened, we just didn’t call it that.
What you’ll hear: -Whether the academic system is designed to produce scientists or to filter them out -What is Baumol’s cost disease and why it explains rising tuition costs -Why the nanotechnology revolution already happened and nobody called it that -How nanotechnology is used in cancer drug delivery today versus what science fiction promised -What it actually takes to build a PhD career at the intersection of chemistry, mechanics, and neuroscience -Whether engineering students should be reading Plato — and what countries that skip it are getting right
“Find a skill at the intersection of three or more interests that no one else is working on.” — Darren Lipomi
CHAPTERS 00:00 He says don't go to college. He runs the department. 01:10 The H-index: imperfect, irreplaceable 02:04 1 in 20 PhDs gets the job 05:42 The meteorite and the origin of life 08:34 Did life's asymmetry come from space? 12:00 Who is an organic materials chemist at 3am? 13:52 The collaboration that started at a coffee shop 15:22 The nanobot revolution already happened 18:24 Nanotechnology inside your body right now 19:08 The $70 billion invention Kodak gave away 22:12 Kodak, Xerox, Bausch + Lomb: what Rochester built 26:06 Working under Whitesides at Harvard 28:54 What he wrote on the outline in blue ink 30:38 Who you work with matters more than what you work on 31:56 Department chair: hostage negotiator, not boss 34:36 Why the department changed its name after 110 years 36:00 The headwinds have never been stronger 38:44 Should engineers read Plato? 39:38 The debt you can't discharge in bankruptcy 40:06 Do you buy Baumol's cost disease? 43:14 Why he had to write the book 48:16 The Fisher-Price camcorder experiment 51:06 Teaching in one sentence. Research in one. 53:42 Losing Darren to Rochester: the Fernando Tatis analogy
Get the transcript, fascinating bonus content, and my Monday M.A.G.I.C. Message: https://briankeating.com/yt
Support Into the Impossible on Patreon, get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
Darren Liponi, Chair of Chemical and Sustainability Engineering at the University of Rochester, examines the systemic failures of modern academia, the economic instability of higher education, and the practical applications of organic chemistry. He discusses the intersection of material science, haptics, and nanotechnology, while advocating for interdisciplinary research and hands-on craftsmanship.
Perhaps the minority of individuals should be going to a four-year institution because the
debt load is so high. My guest today is my good friend Darren Liponi, Chair of Chemical
and Sustainability Engineering at the University of Rochester, in a school he's actively marketing
to undergraduates. He's one of the best mentors and educators I've ever met. I was devastated when
he left UC San Diego and he just told me that most people shouldn't even be in this program.
I wanted to know if he meant it. Is academia like kind of an irredeemably
clout-chasing, you know, kind of money-grubbing pursuit of attention, maybe significance when
we have importance? What is academia, what does it become, and where do you think it can go?
This is a tough nut to crack because when we have promotion and tenure cases,
we want to be able to look at a metric that is reliable, that's standardized across
fields, which is impossible, but at least sort of within within fields. So we look at h-index,
we look at number of citations, we look at number of grant dollars brought in per square foot of
lab space that the individual has. But at the end of the day, you want to know what did that person
do? What is the accomplishment? How have they made a deep and lasting impact in the field?
And that accomplishment is quite difficult to judge, and oftentimes there's a time component
too. It's a impact as a lagging indicator. What if a paper gets one citation today,
but then it gets a thousand citations ten years from now because it became so important?
And so just like capitalism leverages the human competitive instinct, we're kind of
stuck with these metrics in order to evaluate each other and to give each other raises and
promotions. So it's an imperfect system, but it's what we have. Only one out of every 20 PhDs
becomes a tenure-track professor. The numbers are not very favorable for the median person who
wants to go into the field. And it's just, I don't mean median in a pejorative sense,
I just mean statistically, it's a very difficult path. No one knows that a grad student did the
work, that a grad student who made 35 grand a year and forewent retirement savings for their
entire period of training and probably won't recover it by the time they retire,
that the financial burden is probably more so on them than it is on the taxpayer.
So I was trying to tell the story of the people who had to go to grad school because they couldn't
do anything else. They went into research because they could not do anything else,
like an artist or a musician or a chef. That's what they had to do, knowing that the chances
of getting an independent faculty position are one in 20 or lower. Would I have studied
inorganic chemistry and space groups and oxidation potentials and the Schrodinger equation
if I was not forced to? And I'm a highly motivated, really nerdy, really nerdy individual.
Would I have done that for four years, 11 years after high school, before I got my first job?
I don't think I would have. I was lucky in the sense that I had scholarships and my debt load
was not high. If you look at the net present value of my decision by the time I retire,
was it a good decision? I don't know. I probably would have done okay making $85,000 with a
bachelor's degree. There are people for whom it does not make sense to go to college. I would say
that perhaps the minority of individuals should be going to a four-year institution because the
debt load is so high, because the prevalence of high-paying jobs for individuals who are
willing to tolerate certain types of activities can be quite high. I think that's where we need
to focus on as educators in the area of building physical item. We need to rematerialize work and
encourage people to work with their hands, to encourage the building and craftsmanship and
artisanship that's informed by theory because those jobs are going to be the hardest to replace.
Physical AI is going to require an enormous amount of energy and also material science and
mechanical engineering innovation along with the enormous energy demands in server farms,
for example. That's quite a long way off in my opinion, laundry folding robots notwithstanding.
For the next several decades, there will be room for somebody who will be designing a telescope,
for somebody who's designing a satellite, somebody who's designing and building a reactor
that can strip perfluorinated alkyl substances from drinking water. It's the tolerance,
it's the grit to be doing that with one's hands.
I gave you some materials, some extremely interesting engineering that may or may not
contain life on it. Can I touch it? You can touch it. That is your gift for coming on the podcast.
It's a real live or dead meteorite, depending on how you look at it. You can have it too,
guaranteed. I'll send you one. If you, like Darren and me, have a .edu email address and
you live in the United States, go to briankeating.com. I love to send those out and connect
to my beloved ... I'm not going to get in trouble with TSA. No, they might ask you what you do for
a living, which you describe in the book as well. This material was delivered by Outer Space. It
has some interesting deformations, material science, compositions and stuff, but it does
have organic materials on it because I've touched it and sneezed on it and whatnot.
You originally, it seems like, if I recall correctly, you wanted to study origin of
life or get involved with that. What was the impetus for that? How far have you strayed from
that interest or have you? I've always been a bit of a humanist. I've read a lot of books. My mom
had a lot of lefty novels, all this Huxley and Jane Goodall. Although my parents were quite
conservative, actually, this was from her past. She had this box of dusty books. I read quite a
lot of them. When I got to college at BU, I had a fantastic chemistry professor, John Straub.
I was working with him on an independent concentration. When I started college,
9-11 had just happened the second week of school. The second Tuesday of school was 9-11.
I was originally in biomedical engineering. Then I suddenly said I wanted to
learn how people behaved, how they interact with each other, what their life circumstances led them
to their behavior. I changed my major to anthropology. Then I veered back, regressing
to the mean and said, well, how can I combine my interest in people and psychology with chemistry?
It took 20 years of an independent career to finally arrive at where I am right now.
At the time, John Straub introduced me to Richard Dawkins and Edward O. Wilson,
who were scientific humanists. They wrote about the selfish gene theory and how life
were lumbering robots built on self-replicating genes that would co-opt things in their
environment in order to replicate themselves. Not because they wanted to, but because that's
what they did. That's what they'd always done and what we're going to continue to do.
The first thing I saw when I saw these micrometeorites is, I wonder if there are
any chiral amino acids on them. That is perhaps my favorite theory for the origin of biological
homochirality. Every carbon atom has four bonds that point to the vertices of a tetrahedron.
There are two different ways that you can arrange those bonds, the right-handed version
and the left-handed version. They're non-superimposable mirror images.
This graphite in this pencil has carbon in it, right? But it's not bound to itself. It's not
organic. That graphite is a different allotrope of carbon, so it's planar. It's all sp2 hybridized,
so it has to be saturated. My high school chemistry, coming back. Thank you, professor.
That's why they gave me the chair job. You just got me back to 10th grade.
Thanks, Darren. So the graphite and carbon is not chiral. Some of the carbon and coal is,
some of it is not. I know you have a mixture of hybridization states, but most carbon atoms in
DNA and proteins are going to be chiral. And so all helices of the same type, so all keratin
helices in your hair and fingernails, all DNA helices, they're all made of, they all twist the
same direction because of this. Right-handed, right?
Yes, it depends on. Okay, so I'm going to,
so I have a mnemonic for remembering all these different things, because
in cosmology and particle physics, we only have left-handed neutrinos and right-handed
antineutrons. And I'm always like, how do I remember this? I just remember life
may have originated from outer space, from neutrinos and cosmic rays and stuff,
and those are left-handed, so they would only cause an interaction between something
if that's right-handed, and that's how I remember that DNA. Also, you can remember from Jurassic
Park, life is right, life finds a way. Anyway, that's how I remember it, but again, I got a
four on the AP. So there aren't that many ways that you can create new chiral information
from scratch. Naproxen, so a leave, homochiral, you only get one enantiomer, that's one mirror
image. Ibuprofen is sold as a mixture of both. One of them is useless, one of them is biologically
active. And so how do you create the homochirality to begin with? In the pharmaceutical industry,
you have a chiral catalyst, which is often an enzyme, which is biological in origin,
and it catalyzes some reaction, which then biases the formation of every other bond
to form in the way you want it to. Sometimes you might use tartaric acid, which is an
enantiomerically pure. Louis Pasteur, who discovered an enantiomeric excess, literally
used a polarized microscope and tweezers to pick out the crystals by hand of tartaric acid.
And so one of the ways in which homochirality is theorized to have arisen is because of polarized
radiation in outer space. And so when you have meteorites that we're pretty sure were not
contaminated by a biologically homochiral species, there is often an enantiomeric excess,
an excess of one mirror image over the other. And it's conceivable, and there are people that
know more about this than I do, that one enantiomer degrades more quickly in space
because there is polarization. An alien wakes you up at three in the morning. Who are you?
Are you a scientist? Are you an engineer? Are you an academician? Are you a chair?
In your work life, I assume you're a father, I know, and a husband, and very devoted. But
let's leave that aside. What are you? I'm an organic materials chemist. So
materials that are grass-fed and pesticide-free. Materials that are carbon-based. So polymers,
you know, everything in this room, everything outside is covered in an organic medium or made of,
composed of organic media. Anytime you look at something that's nominally abiotic, like a piece
of glass, a metal fork, it's all covered in adventitiously adsorbed organic media. So all
of our interaction with the everyday world is mediated by structures that are composed of
carbon-carbon bonds. And so what I try to do is to understand and manipulate these materials
so that we can make better products, so that we can understand how our senses gain information
from the world. I think if I were ever elected to the National Academy of Engineering, I would want
my citation to be for contributions in using human subjects to understand the physical world.
And by that, I mean, we study the tactile sense quite often. We're very interested in how
the skin deforms when it touches a textile or a material, how the thermal conductivity draws heat
away from it, how it interacts with the afferent nerve fibers in the skin and creates a sensation
that's perceived in the brain. We didn't have a relationship before our students met at Bird Rock
Coffee. And so one of my students was a one, was a part-time barista, and another one was a
frequent, you know, orderer. How will we pay our students? Come on, throw us under the bus a little
more. Yeah, well, you know, they're unionized, so they're fighting a good fight. And so they got
together and they were talking in line at Bird Rock about what they work on. And one of them
was interested in haptics and the other did biostatistics for psychophysical experiments,
primarily for vision. And so they got together and they started designing experiments on the way
in which we perceived materials to be soft versus hard, sticky versus slimy, moist versus dry.
There's a multifactorial analysis that you can probe if you have access to material synthesis
in a clean room, but also have access to a lab with the expertise of Ramachandran.
And so you can analyze what characteristics of the surface and bulk of primarily organic media
that allow it to be perceived in a certain way by touch. So seven peer-reviewed publications later,
we have a better understanding of that now than I think the field did.
Another thing that our friend, just getting back to my childhood, you know,
mentor from the dead, but I wasn't dead at the time, Isaac Asimov and your BU connections,
were the laws of robotics. And now we hear so much about robotics and we hear less about,
you know, kind of the Eric Drexler nanobot than we did previously. We're now hearing about
macrobots, you know, that are going to fold my laundry and, you know, probably grade papers in
the future. They can never replace professors. I mean, come on, our job security. I mean, if we
survived COVID, AI, the point being these nanobots kind of, they were the hot thing,
as I said, Eric Drexler's thing, you know, the Feynman, you know, one of my heroes, right? There's
plenty of room at the bottom. What's happening in nanoscience right now? Besides the chemistry,
I'm talking about actual mini robots going into your blood and doing stuff or building stuff in
the meat world. What's the latest in that? Sure. So the funny thing about Drexler and the nanobots
and he and Rick Smalley, who was the discoverer of C60 fullerene and various other carbon allotropes,
they had this long standing debate about sticky fingers and how van der Waals forces were going
to prevent nanobots from actually working. But I think they ignored the whole field of chemical
catalysis, which are nanomaterials and molecular materials that are literally forming bonds by the
mole full and metric ton full in the chemical manufacturing industry. So that's been happening
and that is, you know, it's never been called, well, it's rarely called nanotechnology, but that
is nanotechnology's biggest accomplishments. In terms of inner space and the magic school bus
and the fantastic voyage, I have a colleague, Joseph Wong, in the nanoengineering department here
who has been doing work for decades on self-propelled micro and nano motors that can
swim around in the bloodstream. And so that, I think it's going to be a combination of active
control of programmed chemical reactions in these nanobots that are actually able to accomplish
something that looks like intelligent behavior. But the other big impact of nano has been
in cancer therapeutics and drug delivery for vaccines, for evasion of the immune system,
for targeting in tumor cells. And you don't just inject taxol or cisplatin in the bloodstream
anymore, you know, those are all encapsulated in some kind of smart nanomaterial that has a
specifically programmed degradation profile, some kinetics that have been influenced by the
ligands that are on the outside sphere. And who could forget microelectronics, too? Although
usually you try to avoid quantum effects in microprocessors, but they're as nano as anything.
We met in 2018, maybe? It was 2019, I can't remember, for the Kyoto Prize, which was awarded
to a University of Rochester kind of a woman who invented the organic LED. Now, to the extent that
any of the public knows about organic chemistry and organic nanochemistry and nanotechnology,
it's through the LED. What's coming down the pipeline? Excite people about the future of
organic, especially organic chemistry as one of your many fields of expertise. What are some of
the next great breakthroughs? You talked about sustainability, power, batteries. What's coming
down the pipeline? What can we get excited about? What can we invest in through your hedge fund
that you're undoubtedly starting at Rochester right now? The organic LED is a great example. It
was invented by Ching Tong at Kodak Research Labs, about four miles from University of Rochester.
After he invented it, he was hired by my department. His office is down the hall from
mine. There is a good chance... He's a mensch. This guy's an incredible mensch. I love this guy.
There is a good chance that your audience is watching this video through an OLED display.
If you have an iPhone or almost any screen, chances are it's organic components that are
creating the image. It's now a $70 billion a year industry. Kodak got almost none of the value from
that invention. Add it to the list. Watch U of R.
If you look at organics and carbonaceous material, carbon allotropes, they are
ubiquitous and ubiquitously exciting. The intercalation compounds, anodes and batteries,
if you look at the next generation of thin film cheap solar panels, you have electron and hole
blocking layers that are principally organic. The materials in perovskite solar cells, you have
the entire history of microelectronics. We think of it as an inorganic technology as in silicon,
gallium arsenide and other materials. The only way that those have ever been manufactured is
because we have these light sensitive organic polymer films called photoresists that you etch
an image in. You're looking now at materials in drug delivery, in electronics and energy
technologies that really require organic materials engineering. We have another project right now
that I have a proposal under review by the Air Force and Space Force on the use of reconfigurable
polymers to suck up space junk in low Earth orbit. Anti-micrometeorite. Inspired by the space
amoeba in the original Star Trek episode. The sky is the limit because if you can put carbon
atoms together in almost any combination, you can make almost any functionality. We should
acknowledge the mastodon in the room. He used to be my treasured colleague here at UC San Diego and
it was no joke. It was a big blow when he left. I was consolable, but losing a top ranked faculty
member to any university is a rival. You get a grad student or you get a top professor, it means
we're not going to get that student or that professor. We're in a zero sum game. I always say
academia and science are made up are infinite games because you can't win science. You can't
win engineering, but you can get the Nobel Prize. You can get the NASC and you can get all sorts of
cool things. That often means you don't get it from somewhere else. One of the things that I most
associate with Rochester, having a good friend, Charlie Freeman, who's out there as a professor
now at Geneseo and went there, was Kodak. I still have Kodak printed out on film, film photographs
from my childhood. This was this huge success story. It built the town. Bausch & Lomb was there
too. Optical. Three huge companies that all involved optics and imaging and printing. At some
level, at some point, lost ground. Market share from 99% to low. You can actually buy a Kodak
digital camera for 99 bucks. It's not the same quality as maybe it used to be, and it probably
is licensed to somebody else for the name. Talk about the parallel side, the academic,
industrial complex, I call it. What is that like? What is the landscape like that you see right now?
Is it an exciting time? Is it AI just dominating everything? The physical world is no more. You're
in the nanomechanical world. What do you see as the future of academic-industrial partnerships
and trying not to make Rochester too attractive? We still need students here, Darren.
Sure. University of Rochester is the largest private employer in New York State outside of
New York City. How I describe it is a Hogwarts attached to a massive medical services company.
We are in the $5-6 billion a year range. Talking about academic-industrial complex,
the undergraduate population is only 6,000 or 12,000 total students and about 500 million in
research expenditures per year. Most of that is in the medical school. There are a lot of medical
device, medical optics companies in the region. A lot of that, the vein of optics, has still
persisted in Rochester, even though Kodak, Xerox, and Bausch & Lomb have a much smaller presence
than they did in the 70s and 80s and the heyday. We have shifted in the economy from primarily
imaging-based to primarily biomedical and biomedical services. Upstream of these consumer
and patient-facing industries, we do a lot of things that are super important to the economy,
but a lot of people would find boring. For example, making machines that make other machines.
We have 60,000 engineers employed in Monroe County. For example, optimization technologies.
They're a design-build firm that made all of the equipment that made all of the mRNA vaccine vials
during the COVID pandemic. Javelin Process Systems makes all of the equipment or the
vast majority of the equipment that cooks and produces Tostitos, salsa, and Phil's Heinz
ketchup bottles. These are B2B companies. We have a very strong relationship with companies like
that, with L3Harris, Cooper Vision, with Bausch & Lomb, which still manufactures contact lenses
and refractive optics. We send a lot of students there. We have research contracts with them.
There's still a strong industrial connection, but the flavor has changed over time. Indeed,
if you walk around U of R, you've got Bausch & Lomb Hall. You have the Eastman as an Eastman-Kodak
quadrangle, and then the Eastman School of Music. Joseph C. Wilson, the founder of Xerox, is the main
boulevard that runs through campus. So going from BU to then going to study at Harvard with
White Sox, was he interested in origin of life? I mean, he's a thousand, what is it,
400 now? A few hundred. I just want to have the logarithm of his age. So talk about George and
working in the lab of one of the most famous academics in all of history, and how little time
you got, but it does seem like you got enough quality time that he really influenced your
philosophy as a mentor. So talk about George and just the many... I mean, quite frankly,
you had merit, but you had a lot of luck too, and to work with him is part of that. But
not all it's cracked up. When I was an undergraduate, I was lucky enough to get
the Beckman Scholars Program, which is an undergraduate research scholarship. And I
went to the Beckman headquarters in Irvine, and George Whitesides was one of the speakers. And
he talked about multivalency and protein-ligand or protein-drug interactions, and how you got
much more, much stronger binding if you had cooperativity and binding. Sounded really cool
and interesting. And he had such a preso-humanistic, right. And he had such a presence,
has such a presence about him. He speaks with a booming baritone voice. He's 6'1 or 6'2. He looks
a bit like Captain Picard, and he has a very powerful handshake, even though even at the time
he was quite senior. And I asked him, you know, what do you look for in mentees? He said,
I look for somebody who's, I look for somebody who's very strong in thermodynamics and organic
synthesis. And I thought that was very precise. That was very precise. And so I said, I want to
work with George Whitesides. And so I was at BU, and I did a lot of running around the Charles
River, and I would pass by the Harvard chemistry building and look at it in awe. And when I applied
and I got in, which was just out of the question for somebody who came from the beginnings that I
did, and I got in. And what was ironic is that as famous as George is, probably the most famous
chemist who's never won the Nobel Prize or who hasn't yet, and more famous than most chemists
who have won the Nobel Prize, is that once you got into Harvard, it wasn't hard to get into his lab.
And in part, that was because he trusted the system. In part, it was because he didn't have
time to interview all the candidates. And in part, it's because, and I don't want to, I don't mean
this in a pejorative sense, although take it as you will, but he was pretty sure that people who
couldn't cut the mustard would just drop out of the lab. And so there was a lot of attrition in
the lab. Most of the mentoring that I received from George came in the form of written comments
on outlines. So he would write in blue ink on the pilot rollerball blue ink pen. He would say
things that no good human being should ever say to any other good human being, like,
this is a pig's breakfast I saw on someone. He wrote, this is illiterate on mine. He would say
things that maybe even looked meaner than it actually was. Like one time, my colleague and
I were sure that he had written, I know you want to f**k it in blue ink. My colleague and I were
looking at it and we're like, there's nothing else it could say. But obviously it didn't say
that. But there was literally, there was nothing else it could say. He was a doctor after all.
And so the in-person mentoring was sparse, but he had such a presence. He has such a presence
in our lives. Everybody who worked in his lab, that we have internalized his direction, his sense
of scientific strategy and how to choose an important problem. And that has followed me
in my career since then. Yeah. And even at one point comes across as somewhat tender,
you know, as you're graduating, he says, I'm going to be devastated when Darren leaves. I mean,
that, that, you know, could bring tears to a, to a non-organic, an actual organic physicist. That
was a touching thing to read and then to hear. And it must've brought you great pride. You had
a thousand publication from his lab or something like that, right? I was in the lab at the time.
At the time. Okay. When that came about and soon thereafter, you have a, you know,
first author paper with him as your, you know, your coauthor, it's, it's incredible.
But you know, a lot of us don't have that benefit. And a lot of times you hear things,
I often tell students in general, it's more important who you work with than what you work
on. And yet, you know, at the same time, you know, science is a game of credit and attribution and
citation. I mean, literally our currency is citations. Right. And, and that's why we get so
kind of upset when people say things like, Oh, peer review is the scam. And it's kind of
undermined, you know, science isn't about peer review and it's just gatekeeping. And I'm like,
you know, once I gave a podcast here with a couple of podcasters that I won't name because I was a
very disappointed the way that they've kind of turned their podcast into, but they, I said
something like we need gates, right? We need a gate. We have a gate around this campus and
the gate keeps people out and it keeps things in and people they're like, you want to trap people
here? I'm like, well, I've got a very expensive, you know, dilution refrigerator costs about a
half million dollars. I don't want that walking off or, or a cup of liquid helium three is going
to set you back, you know, quarter million dollars. Right. So yeah, I, I quite frankly,
like to have a gate around things in academia. I have a gate around my pool. You used to have
a pool. I don't think you have a pool. Maybe you have an ice rink. Sabers. You have a creek. You
have a creek. Sabers are practicing nearby, but it's, you know, we do need gates around certain
things. So, and I think that's why academics get so upset. You know, the joke is academics fight
so much because the stakes are so low as a chair, you know, you're kind of in this position, my,
my colleague and friend and past guests in a Vishak at UC Davis, you know, said a department
chair is not a boss of a professor, right? It's kind of a negotiator that negotiates with hostage
hostage takers on behalf of the kidnap. Right. So how do you view being, you know, kind of
at a top school and having, you know, a phenomenal reputation there, but you know,
you can't please everybody all the time, or you're not a leader. So walk me through the
navigatory, you know, kind of the shoals of being a chair. It's not a job I really want.
Sure. So my last job at UC San Diego was as associate dean for students in engineering.
I had that role for two years. Prior to that, I was the director of the idea engineering student
center. And in the associate dean role, I was basically playing running interference for the
dean. So I would be doing town halls with students. There is a lot of work that I did that I'm still
very proud of and still working on actually at UCSD and garnering scholarship, you know,
money with former colleagues and, and trying to enhance the student experience. I'd really like
to keep that as a as a legacy that I that I have here, the department chair role is completely
different. Number one, it's, it's an executive role, you're the one who decides who has the
final say on teaching and service assignments, also allocation of lab space, you and the dean,
you know, have to agree on it, but the chair is the is the first responder there. And also
the first person in line for promotion and tenure decisions. And so the number of incoming
emails is lower, not just because U of R is a smaller school than UCSD,
but also because my constituency is is 14 faculty members instead of 10,000 students
and, and the dean's office. My primary constituency being the faculty is I have
to represent them at the dean's leadership meetings. I have to represent their interests
when I'm talking to students who have an issue with grading policy, or I missed a final exam,
and the professor won't give me a break, and whatever, every every situation has to be dealt
with, like, like that, you're kind of giving an answer by way of the description of the duties and,
and not, not necessarily making it something that I'm now more appealing, you know, to me that,
but that's fine, because I need a new, you know, assignment. I think what it allows you to do,
so for, for instance, we changed the name of the department recently, it was chemical engineering
for 110 years. And as of this fall, it became the Department of Chemical and Sustainability
Engineering, the reason being that the faculty portfolios, research portfolios, all had something
to do with battery separation membranes, water purification, environmental remediation,
I do a lot of work in recyclable polymers for e-waste, I do a lot of work in solar cell
manufacturing, and so in this period in which we're facing a demographic cliff, where there
aren't as many high school kids as there used to be, and universities are not quite, or the
American immigration system is not quite as friendly to international students as it was
a few years ago, we need to do something to differentiate the product we're offering.
I wrote the other day, I did a poll on the most important scientific medium of all time, Twitter,
and I did a poll, I said, which is older, Oxford University or the Aztec Empire? And it was like
50-50 split, it's like, obviously Oxford's older, right? But, you know, people have been scratching
on a piece of rock with another piece of rock, you know, for literally a thousand years. So
what, what is sort of the future of academia? Like, again, not, not like, who wants to be
department chair? Like, okay, fine, that's a very select set at the apex predators of academia,
but, but, you know, the kind of the entry to the funnel, what kind of product are we delivering to
our students nowadays? Just generally, not, not in your field, my field, but generally speaking,
academia as a whole, higher education. It is the perfect time to be thinking about that question,
because academia has, the critics have never been louder, the societal, the external societal forces
and economics have, have never been stronger, headwinds have never been stronger. The traditional
reason to get a bachelor's degree is to, is to be an important, to have something to contribute to
civic society, to, to know the great works, to be familiar with the, with music and art and
literature, to know a little bit about, have some skills in numeracy. But then comes the more
vocational, professional certification, professionalization. And I would put the
natural sciences in that category, but certainly engineering. And what kinds of,
do we treat those groups of individuals differently? Should we, should the, should
somebody who is sure they want to work in mechanical engineering, should they be reading Plato in a
freshman or sophomore seminar? I would argue, yes, they, they ought to be.
But to be fair, in other countries, they don't, right? In other countries, you're,
you're going to be a physician, you know, you don't take Plato, you don't read Plato, right?
You go straight from, you know, A-levels in your, in your profession as early as, you know,
the end of your undergraduate, so to speak, right? So other countries doing it worse than us
because they have that model? It may be that academia is not the
right place to instill a love of, of, of wisdom, of wisdom, of past wisdom. It may be that,
that the person in one of the countries of which you speak find that dusty old box of books,
or maybe they're already inclined to go to the, you know, go to the library,
or maybe you need somebody who's probably not an engineer, you know, in the, the ethics department
of the company or someone who has a leadership role who, who is, you know, interested in,
in humanism. That is, that is a tough question. The other issue is what the students and the
parents expect to get out of their tuition dollars and the debt that they're going to be in.
Take on debt, we can't discharge in bankruptcy. It's the only form of debt you can't.
Tuition's rising faster than inflation, you know, in most private institutions like,
like yours, right? So what kind of product are they getting? I mean, do we think of them as
customers? And, and if so, to what level do you cater to the, I mean, Apple, you go down to the
Apple store, the genius bar, you know, and you look at their nanoglass techno. I'm sure that's
what you do when you go to an Apple store. But, but in all reality, they don't say like, you know,
we're going to monitor you. We're going to make sure you're not using certain tools. We're going
to grade you. We're going to judge you. We're going to write these, you know, things that,
that determine your future outcome. And, oh, by the way, we're going to charge you,
as I said, two quarter million dollars or half a million dollars if you're at a private school.
And it's going up faster than inflation by a factor of three or something like that. So,
and you can't discharge a debt in bankruptcy, guys. So, you know, take that on when you go
to the Apple store. You'd never do that, right? You'd never even set foot in there as much as
you might like the product. Do you, do you buy into Ball's cost disease theory of why? I'm not
familiar with it. Yeah. So, in sectors of the economy that don't scale. So, healthcare and
education are the, are the two quintessential examples where we can, if you produce widgets
and you get more efficient, you can produce 10 one year and a million a few years later. Right. But
your class isn't going to go from 10 students to a million students, but you need to survive in that
economy where productivity is increasing elsewhere. And so there is, there was a,
is an economist, Baumol, someone in the comments is going to, you know, correct me exactly, you
know, the specifics of this, but it basically says that that's responsible for the increase in
healthcare and education costs because we don't scale. Just to push back on whoever this scholar
is, in certain sectors of both academia, you know, higher education say, and in healthcare,
costs don't go up. Cosmetic surgery has gone down. LASIK has gone down. You know, the very lasers
that Bausch and Lomb makes, you know, contacts for and part of their profits because people have
LASIK surgery. So they don't need the, all right. So that's all gone down because it's elective
surgery. It's not paid for by health insurance and covered by our, you know, lugubrious health
sciences professional. So how do you, how would this Baumol or, you know, it sounds like a James
Bond, you know, mansion or fortress somewhere, right? So, so how would they, I mean, it's not
your theory, but how do they react to that? And there's private educational institutions too,
that are, you know, providing services or even state, you know, University of Florida is a very
different model than the University of California. So yeah, I mean, how, how, how, how do you react
to that as a purveyor, as the supplier of some of the product and some of it is being commoditized.
Yeah. And I think it is, there are some who would argue that faculty and that one, there are too
many faculty and staff and two, that they get paid too much. I think there's way too few faculty.
I think there's way too many bureaucracies, administrators, departments. No, I'm just
kidding. There aren't too many department chairs. Everyone should be chaired. That's what everybody
thinks they are. That's what everybody thinks they are, right? I watch your show, right? I learn a
lot more about, you know, chemistry than I think I would do if I sat in on, you know, some of your
other, so yeah. So where, where is this going? I mean, when you could go to AI, you can go to
YouTube, you can watch molecular podcasts that you could do, you know, a whole university education
in your pajamas for free with no non-dischargeable student debt, like make the argument. I mean, I'm
kind of like grasping for a lifeline here, Darren, help me out here. I mean, we've got to save our
industry. I think our industry is, I mean, COVID didn't kill us. You know, nothing's going to kill
us. AI is not going to kill us. Well, UCSD is still the second most applied to school in America.
In the country, that's right. Yeah. Yeah. So there's the human capital argument and there's
the sheepskin effect argument that if companies are outsourcing certification to UCSD and University
of Rochester, could they have, could the students have learned the same thing? I would argue that
in physics and engineering, because it would be very difficult to do that. I have a sad obligation.
I have to point out an egregious typo and error in your book, which I missed the first time, and
I'm really ashamed and humiliated, quite frankly. And it's, it's hard for me to do this to someone
who I like, quite frankly, but you got your H index wrong in the book. It's,
it's not 60, it's 63. So Darren, you're going to have to issue, you know, second edition.
We didn't do the patented judging books by their cover segment. So we got to do that now.
So talk us through the title, the subtitle, cover art, such as it is. And what was,
you know, I always say you shouldn't, and I think I told you this, don't write a book unless you
can't not write a book. It's kind of like going to grad school, like you shouldn't go to grad
school. That should be your first default op. Don't go to grad school, you know, but if you
can't not go to grad school, and we have a lot of non-traditional people that, you know, go back to
grad school late and I love it, but that was because they couldn't not go there. Talk about
the book. Why couldn't you not write this book? Science Nonfiction is, the subtitle is Behind
the Scenes in University Research. I can't tell you how often I heard an incorrect definition of
indirect cost recovery. And that's why. Thank God Darren. Oh my God. If you couldn't write about
IDC, who would? Think of the children. Think of the children. That is a microcosm of the
misunderstanding of how science is actually done. And so there are fantastic resources on PBS and
YouTube about the wonderful things that science produces. I'm a big fan of Anthony Bourdain
and his book, his first book that made him famous, Kitchen Confidential. And I thought,
wouldn't it be cool if somebody wrote Kitchen Confidential, but about labs instead of about
kitchens. That was a working title for my first book, which became Losing the Nobel Prize,
but it was going to be Cosmic Confidential. It was filling this lacuna in our kind of
understanding in the public, but also kind of, you know, a Jeremiad, but also a warning, but also
an invitation. Because it is a great job. Look, I say, you know, I joked before, it's the hardest
three-hour-a-week job in the world, but I also say, you know, who's going to be a professor? Like,
who's going to pay me to be a professor? You grew up, you know, working class, maybe lower middle
class. I grew up fairly poor, even though my father, my late father was an academician. He was
a professor. He was the youngest full professor at Cornell in the math department at age 26. He
was a full professor. I mean, you can't do that nowadays, but he was, I didn't think you could
be a professor. I'm like, who's going to pay me to taste ice cream and, you know, like ride the
rollercoaster at SeaWorld all day. No one's going to pay me to do that. Let's take it back to where
you got your start, at least in the scientific world, which is in Boston. And one of my kind
of greatest heroes, in fact, was from Boston. I think he was at Boston College. You were at Boston
University. His name was Isaac Asimov. And he not only wrote some of the greatest works of fiction
ever written, science fiction, but he wrote a lot of nonfiction science. And it actually got me my
deepest interest as a teenager in science, his nonfiction books, particularly about chemistry,
which, you know, is the worst possible, you know, field for me. Biology was bad for me. I took AP
bio and we had to dissect a frog. And I was fine with dissecting it, but it kind of hurt its scream.
Like, I might have brought it back to life just to cause it more. No, I'm just kidding PETA folks out
there. But I love chemistry, but I was horrible. I mean, I couldn't remember all these different
reactions and the memorization and just, you know, it just seemed so formulaic. It was like,
I could just go to law school and memorize a bunch of laws or something. I wanted to be a scientist.
Asimov inspired me. What inspired you? What were some of the influences before you kind of became
who you are, you know, the famous professor that you are now and in your, you know, just phenomenal
career, what influenced you at a curiosity-based level? Asimov was at BU. You were right the first
time. And I have read his brief history of chemistry cover to cover. He has all these
little nuggets of, of science, science, non, nonfiction or nonfiction. I was always of the
belief that science and magic were synonymous. When I would watch three, two, one contact and
nature on PBS, I would just, I just conflated the two science. That was the only legitimate
route to magic. Maybe science even was magic. And when I didn't know what I wanted to do in,
in science, but I had a fantastic high school teacher. This is a very common story. We have
people who inspire us in the classroom. And I had, I, it was no different for me. I had a teacher
in high school. I took the regular 10th grade chemistry and then AP chemistry from him the
following year. And he had a way of imbuing atoms and molecules with human-like characteristics.
And that is where somebody like me who wasn't maybe so great at thinking about equations and
things that were very abstract, but also not somebody who wanted to memorize a biology textbook
because there's a lot of memorization in biology. And so for me, chemistry was the center of the
bullseye, but I can understand how other natural scientists gravitate toward physics or biology.
You had this really cool experience as a kid. I had a cool experience with a telescope as a kid
that got me into the career that we have today, which is, you know, as I often say is the hardest
three-hour-a-week job in the world. You had an experience with a type of observational telescopic
device or televistic device. Talk about your exposure, you know, this kind of chance exposure
that got you into the important career that you have, but the most important thing that,
you know, two white guys with a microphone can do, podcasting. So talk about this Fisher-Brice,
you know, video camera and how, really, what should parents do if they want to create a young
Tell me, what are some of your pieces of advice as a parent who's also a professor?
In the late 80s, Fisher-Brice came out with this PXL 2000 camcorder. It was a black and white
camcorder that would take high-fidelity audio tape, run it really fast, like as fast as a fast
forward to get all of the, you know, to get the data rate high enough, and it would record 10
minutes of black and white video on each side of an audio cassette. The images were terrible,
it sucked up light like nobody's business. You needed, so my dad had an early cartridge video
camera, like film video camera, and we used these halogen lamps that he had just to get enough so
that it wasn't a black screen, right? And so I had my stuffed animals act out scenes from Star Wars,
and that was my earliest exposure to video and audio production. The other ancient piece of
technology that I had was a 1980 desktop computer that a family friend absconded with from Kodak,
so they used to dump their old equipment right in the river, in the Tennessee River,
and so we ended up with this thing, and when you turned it on, it would go
like that. It would sound like the Millennium Falcon taking off. You needed a five and a
quarter disc to boot it up. So, you know, what do I do with my own child? You know, she's seven,
and we are interested in creativity and science, so we have a sewing machine, a 3D printer is on
its way. We watch a lot of builder videos. She wants to make animatronics from Poppy Playtime
and other things that I shouldn't be letting her play, but that's, I don't know if that's the right
answer, but that's what we're doing as scientist parents. One of the last organic chemists that I
talked to was Tom Cech, who won the Nobel Prize for his work on RNA, and his book The Catalyst,
which is a phenomenal book, very much kind of Asimov spirit, but in the conversation we had
on the podcast, he spoke about, you know, kind of his philosophy, at least as a scientist, was,
you know, basically, if you're going to do one thing, do it extremely well. Do it better than
anyone can. What's your one-sentence teaching philosophy? And maybe one sentence on research
too. I'll give you two sentences. In teaching, one wants to get the students to do their own work.
When I was in school, I would go to the lecture. I would not have read the chapter ahead of time,
and 60% of it would just straight over my head. Then when I would go home, or back to my dorm
room, I would do the problems in the back of the book, and I would transfer them to note cards,
and that's when I would do the real learning, right? But I wouldn't have done that if I didn't
care. And maybe so the effective professors were the ones that I wanted to, I wanted to,
I viewed them as a role model. I wanted to please them. I didn't want to get an embarrassing grade
on an exam. I was excited by their passion for the material, and that made me want to do it myself.
I've never been somebody who could just absorb something from a lecture and take a test on it.
Research. Find a skill at the intersection of three or more interests that no one else is
So I am a decent organic chemist. Let's say out of physical scientists, I'm 1 in 10. Let's say
I know something about mechanics, but I'm not as good. Maybe I'm 1 in 5. So now I'm 1 in 50.
But I really am interested in neuroscience, and so I didn't even have to be that good at
neuroscience. I just have to have read a couple textbooks and be willing to talk to neuroscientists.
So maybe I'm 1 in 2. Now I'm 1 in 100 at the intersection of mechanics, organic chemistry,
and neuroscience. The Shohei Otani of this amalgam that you made. Yeah, and that's exactly
what my last four research grants have been on is perception of the mechanical, the organic media as
mediated by mechanical forces. I had a guest here sitting in that chair, Nikolai Kokushkin at NYU.
He said in Russian, carbon has a name or an analog. It's like the aggressor. And then oxygen is like
the devastator. Carbon's the assembler, and oxygen's the devastator. And you put them together
with a little hydrogen, and you get just the mellifluous world that we're just so privileged
to be a part of. And we're so privileged that you came back on the show and came back to San Diego.
And congratulations on all your success. It's just wonderful to watch you develop and grow.
And it's kind of like you recruited Fernando Tatis from the White Sox. And you get to watch
him play for the Padres, as I did last night. He still hasn't gotten a home run. But Darren
Lipome, Professor Chair Lipome, it's so great to have you back. Congrats on all your success. I wish
you continued success. And hopefully you'll come and visit. Maybe I'll come back to Rochester and
get some beef on whack with you. Probably in the winter. I'd really like to go there in the winter.
That's my dream. It's January, ice skating. Exactly. All right. We got to get you on a flight.
Thank you so much for coming out. Welcome back to San Diego and have a great trip back. Thanks, Darren.
Darren just told us that most people shouldn't even go to college while he's running the
department that recruits them. If that changes how you see a degree, subscribe and turn on
notifications. And leave a comment. Would you tell your own kid to skip college? For the flip side,
Nobel Laureate Tom Cech told me why RNA might be more important than your diploma. It's linked
right here. Thanks for watching. See you next time. And please don't forget to like, comment,
and subscribe. It really does help me out with the algorithm that determines YouTube performance.
See you next week on Into the Impossible.