Appeals court reverses block of controversial Texas election law

Fox - 26 Houston
15 followers
50 Video Views·Aug 17, 2026
The 5th Circuit Court of Appeals just last week cleared the way for Texas' controversial
election law, Senate Bill 1, to take effect before the November midterms.
The law includes provisions requiring Texans to put their ID or Social Security number
on their mail-in ballot applications.
It also requires anyone who helps a voter fill out their ballot to sign an oath swearing
that they did not coerce them in how to vote.
Gary, these changes, the 5th Circuit Court of Appeals overturned the entire ruling by
the federal judge.
All nine points.
Yeah, well, the 5th Circuit, we know, is conservative.
I think it was the right decision.
You know, it's interesting.
I was involved in a lawsuit, Chris, a civil lawsuit, where we did extensive discovery
about cheating on mail-in ballots.
And we had ballot grabbers, which I call them, were going in and getting people to sign paperwork
so they get the ballots.
But then we determined they were actually voting for them.
So these are provisions to try to make sure that there is no cheating with mail-in ballots.
Were they enough to change the election?
Probably not.
But, I mean, I was actually really surprised.
But the other thing I learned about that was it took a long time for us to prove the 20
cases we were after where this happened.
It's a lot of work.
So to get enough to change an election, it takes millions of dollars.
Bill, there really shouldn't be an issue if you're going to help someone fill out their
ballot to sign an oath saying you didn't coerce them and how to do it.
That's probably not the most controversial part of that law.
Yeah, let's step back for a second.
If you go all the way back to the Carter-Baker Commission that looked at voting in the United
States, which I think was way back in the early 2000s, it identified mail-in voting
as probably the most problematic part of our system.
And ironically, the mail-in ballot was really sort of a Republican invention because mostly
older voters like it and mostly older voters were voting for Republican.
The Democrats have gotten a lot better at it and now it's not such a good idea.
So this is a partisan issue, for sure.
But, like, my parents voted by mail forever.
And after my mother started having problems, you know, Dad would help her fill out the
ballot.
Now, do I think he needs to fill out an oath?
No, not really.
But if there's somebody going through a nursing home and helping multiple people fill out,
then yeah, they need to sign some kind of an oath.
And I don't see any problem putting your driver's license number on it.
This is kind of much to about nothing to me.
But at the same time, I understand that it's, you know, the integrity issue, convincing
people that the elections are fair and nobody's cheating or anything, is really more important
than how much actual cheating goes on.
Senate Bill 1 was really an attack at Harris County and what it instituted during COVID
in increasing the number of places you could drop your ballot off and drive in voting.
It took care of everything Harris County had done.
That's what the Fifth Circuit Court of Appeals said.
All of those measures can take effect.
Yeah.
And so, again, I think what's so important for democracy is for people to feel like they're
being governed by people that they had a voice in electing or even if they lost.
But when that is taken away, that's where the problems exist.
And right now, something like 40 percent of Americans have a question about the integrity
of the voting system.
So anything that works to tighten it up is a good thing.
What happened as a result of this new law, the one election that's been had under it,
the rejection rate of mail-in ballots went from 1 percent to 12 percent.
The highest percentage of people whose ballots were rejected were Asian-Americans, of all
things.
Part of the problem is the number that's in the office has to match what's on the ballot.
And so if I thought I put my driver's license number on it and that's the number that I
write on my ballot and send it in, and actually when I registered, I had my PIN number on
there instead, the ballot gets rejected.
And so simplifying it is probably a better thing, which is it must be either the last
four of your social, your driver's license or something.
That would be good.
But right now, that's the step that's probably causing the problem.
My guess is two elections down the road, it won't be as big of an issue.
Charles, we've had many, many cycles where the Republicans have said we've got to have
voter ID, voter ID, voter ID.
What would be wrong with just putting your driver's license photo on your voter registration
card?
I don't really, I mean, I don't see that there is a problem, I think.
And that's why I argue that some of these aren't really controversial because, I mean,
it seems like pretty standard to have something like your, whether it's your social security
number or even driver's license number or something like that on it.
And the oath doesn't seem too prohibitive either.
And so it seems like it should be easy and it might help some of those ballot harvesters
that you often see in some of these communities that go around to nursing homes and other
things like that.
So I don't see it too much of an issue with it.
All right, April, we'll get to you on the next one.
That's all we have for this block.
We'll be right back.
I'm Chris Tritico.
And this is What's Your Point?
