Katharine Birbalsingh: Teach Kids What To Think, Or Woke TikTok Will Instead

Journey of loving children
22 followers
11 Video Views·Aug 17, 2026
Katharine Birbalsingh, Britain’s “Strictest Headmistress,” argues that modern education is failing children by prioritizing creativity and “self-discovery” over knowledge and discipline. She explains why teaching children WHAT to think—building a strong foundation of knowledge—is essential for developing critical thinking, creativity, and independence. Unlike progressive teaching methods, which leave children unprepared for life and vulnerable to manipulative online content, Katharine’s approach emphasizes discipline, habit-building, and high expectations, preparing kids to thrive in the real world.
Subscribe and ring the notification bell so you don’t miss a single video!
AI Generated·May contain errors
We do need to teach children what to think.
Of course, we need to teach children what to think.
Otherwise, they will all kill each other, right?
And what I mean by that is there is such a thing as,
I mean, look, I'm going to get into trouble for saying this,
original sin.
People don't like me saying original sin.
I once got into a huge load of trouble on Twitter
where I happened to be visiting Paris.
I was walking down the Champs-Élysées.
I saw a tweet.
Somebody said something about kids being naughty.
I retweeted it and said, yeah, like original sin.
Who told me to do that?
Next thing you know, I was having to go on TV to defend myself.
I was being attacked.
You're talking to an increasingly orthodox Catholic.
So you have nothing to...
You are in a safe space for talk of the fallenness of man,
the imperfectibility of this world,
both of which are facts, if you have eyes as well.
So you don't need to have a religious tradition
to look at the world and see our brokenness and our fallenness
and the imperfectibility of man.
And what happens when you decide,
let me try to perfect man.
And you just get Maoism.
You just get the killing fields of Cambodia.
It's just every time.
Exactly.
I am not a Christian.
But the point is that anybody...
You see two toddlers sitting next to each other.
They will...
You give them one toy.
They will hit each other.
They don't say,
oh, darling, how about we share?
You have it for five minutes
and then I'll take it for five minutes.
No toddler has ever said that in any country
in any language.
You have to teach the toddler what to think.
You have to teach him.
Hitting is wrong.
Sharing is right.
And if you don't teach them what to think,
they will kill each other.
That is what will happen.
You have to teach children what, not how.
And when you teach them the what,
you teach them lots of content.
You teach them some history and some geography
and some science and some French and some Spanish and so on.
And once you've taught them all this stuff
and they have loads of knowledge,
they can then think independently about it
because you cannot be creative about something
or with something unless you know lots about it,
which is why I've turned education on its head,
which is why I'm controversial,
which is why I get...
I've had over 7,000 visitors come and visit my school
because I know education.
So I am thinking independently about it.
I'm being creative with it.
I'm out of the box.
The only way that you can be out of the box on anything
is if you know lots about it.
So this idea that we need to be teaching kids how to think,
it's just silly.
You need to teach them what to think.
You need to give them loads and loads of knowledge.
And then it's not like they don't do anything
with the knowledge.
So if you come to our school,
you will see children learning at speed.
I mean, the pace is incredible.
They learn so much.
And then if you were to sit with them at lunch
and have chats with them about history or geography
or science and so on,
they will impress you to no ends.
And then they'll be able to give you
differing opinions at the table
about what they think about 1066
or whatever it is,
you know, whatever historical battle you want to discuss,
they will have different opinions about it
because they know it inside out.
And that's because their teacher knew more than they do.
The teacher gave them the knowledge,
allowed them to do some exercises,
which meant that they would remember the knowledge.
And then once you've got that knowledge
in their long-term memories,
they can use that knowledge and develop it
to come up with their own ideas about that knowledge.
That is what creativity is.
And sadly, Elon and everybody
doesn't understand how to get creativity.
He himself did not become creative
because he's obviously very creative
and independently minded.
He's become that way by finding out lots of stuff,
by becoming knowledgeable.
He doesn't get that.
And this is what people do all the time.
They retrieve, they have a traditional education.
Somebody gives them lots of knowledge
or they find the knowledge themselves by reading loads.
They become creative.
And then they say to their own children
or to the children,
often poor children in the inner city,
no, no, no, no, no.
I'm going to do something brilliant for you.
Let's do something creative with you.
We're going to have lessons in your school
where everybody puts a post-it note on each other's head.
And then you wander around the classroom
trying to identify who has a post-it note
that's just like yours.
Okay, you can do that.
And it's fun.
And I've seen similar sorts of exercises
happen a million times
in a million different classrooms
across the Western world.
But I can tell you at the end of the lesson,
while everybody's had a good time,
few children have learned very much.
Few children remember very much.
What they remember is,
wasn't that fun with the post-it note?
But do they know much about the history
that you were meant to be learning that lesson?
No.
And so are they ever going to be
truly creative later in life
about the history that they were learning?
No, because they don't know any.
And then because they haven't been told
what to think, right?
And they don't know anything.
They are ripe for TikTok
because they don't know any history.
The only history that they're then going to learn
is what they're taught on TikTok.
So TikTok, you can't put a video
for more than 30 seconds on there.
Otherwise you lose people's attention.
So via 25 second, 28 second videos
pushing a particular woke agenda,
children are going to learn their history.
So they are then being taught
what to think by TikTok
instead of being taught what to think
by their teachers who should be.
Now, this is the problem.
And Elon is right to pick up on this.
The teacher should be sensibly minded,
small C conservative,
slightly fuddy duddy people
who in 1955, there were loads of them.
Nowadays, all of our teachers are very woke
and believe that the way children should be taught
is to radicalize them
and make them into adults
who are going to reject the establishment.
We believe as teachers that our job
is to get children to be radicals
and overthrow that establishment that's so evil.
Whereas I actually think our job
is to teach them algebra
and to teach them some history
and some geography and some science
and some French.
And if you teach them all of that stuff,
they then have an armor
that they can go out into the world in
and be able to interpret the world
and understand what's happening
and be creative and think for themselves.
But if you haven't really taught them very much,
then the only thing they can learn
is our TikTok
and they are easily manipulated.
They are vulnerable.
Any extremist group out there,
anybody who wants to teach them
whatever they want,
they'll just learn it then
because they haven't got any,
I always call them coat pegs in your head.
Knowledge begets knowledge.
You have some coat pegs
and then you learn some more knowledge
and it sits on those coat pegs
and then you learn more knowledge again
and more on those coat
and the more and more coat pegs
are being developed
and you're just gathering
more and more and more knowledge
and you're becoming more interesting.
That's the goal,
is to be an interesting person.
That is simply not happening
and that's because the progressive selling point,
the progressive schools,
what they say,
go on any website,
you'll see,
we want your child to be creative,
to be unique,
to discover who he really is.
That's what they're gonna say, right?
This is ridiculous.
Everybody needs to learn some algebra.
This business of,
oh, I'm gonna discover who you really are.
No, you need to learn some algebra,
you need to learn some trigonometry,
you need to learn some history,
you need to learn how to write an essay.
Once you've been taught all of that,
then you go to university
and discover who you are.
But at 15,
you need to learn some algebra.
It's when I say things like that,
that people get very upset.
I mean, it all sounds profoundly sensible and obvious
and maybe it's because I am increasingly a pre-modern person.
You have a bunch of actions that...
What is the formula of Aristotle?
That action begets habit,
begets character,
begets who you are as a person.
Yeah.
That seems like the architecture of your school in a lot of ways.
Is that a fair way to put it?
Yes.
So habit building.
So James Clear's book on habits,
Atomic Habits,
and various other habit building books.
We've got tons of them in the library.
I'm constantly doing assemblies on this sort of thing.
We recognize that success comes through habit building.
Jocko Willink, again, is another big hero of mine
because I try and get on my treadmill at 5.15 in the morning.
And I think of Jocko and his tweets
where he tweets his watch and it says 4.03
and he says, let's go.
And I get on my treadmill at 5.15
and I think Jocko was on his treadmill at 4.03.
I'm late.
I've got to keep going now.
And I do assemblies on this.
I do assemblies and I say, be like Jocko.
Do the things that James Clear says.
Habits, you know, Jocko, all of them.
David Goggins, all those guys.
They talk about get started.
Just do something and keep going with it, right?
Because if you get on the treadmill every morning,
it then just becomes who you are.
And we have a pyramid.
And at the top of the pyramid, it says, it's who you are.
And I have my pyramid to show you.
It says, it's who you are.
And at the bottom of the pyramid, you do the right thing
because you want to avoid demerits
and you want to avoid detentions.
Now, that's where the kids start.
They start at the bottom.
Oh, I'm going to get into trouble.
I don't want to get a detention.
I better do my homework.
Oh, I'm going to get in trouble.
I need to be on time.
Oh, I need to be polite.
I need to do whatever because otherwise I get into trouble.
And then they move up the pyramid.
Next step is you want to get a merit.
Step after that, I want to impress my teachers.
So if you know you're in the middle of the pyramid,
it's better that you're doing the right thing,
not just because you want to avoid a detention.
You actually want the respect of your teachers.
That's better.
Then the next step after that, you want a great future.
So then you're connecting.
That's the development bit.
So you know the bit where you were saying about
coddling the American mind, what you and Jonathan Haidt want.
You want kids to go, okay, this is my future.
I could have a bad future.
And be somebody who's always late and never does my homework, et cetera, et cetera.
Or I can have a good future because I develop certain habits
and become that kind of person.
I am owning my own development.
So when you're at the bottom, you're not owning your own development
because you're just doing it because you might get into trouble.
Oh, I don't want a detention.
When you're in the middle, you're doing it because you want to impress somebody.
Okay, that's better.
But when you're on that fourth rung, you understand.
Wait a minute.
What I'm doing now is going to enable me to have a certain kind of future.
I'm going to be a certain kind of person and people will respect
and admire, and I want that for myself.
And I am going to take control of my own life.
So that's where you are in the fourth rung.
That's what you want.
You get there through habit formation, right?
When you get to the top, it's just who you are.
So my thing is, our kids, we'll either have them five years at the end of GCSE
or A-level, that takes us seven years when they go off to university.
And my thing is, lots of them will start at the bottom of the pyramid.
I need, by the time they leave us, they need to be at the top.
I want them to leave us as the kinds of people who naturally, without thought,
can sit on a chair, can look you in the eye, can shake your hand.
We'll always remember to bring a pen.
We'll always go to an interview and walk in and make a good impression,
shake your hand, look at you in the eye.
They're not going to forget their pen.
They'll have done the preparation for the interview beforehand
because they've been doing their homework for seven years without fail.
And they're going to turn up and they're going to impress,
just like they impressed their teachers on that third rung.
And they're going to do that because they understand that this is good for their future.
But it's now who they are.
They're at the top and that's just the person who they are.
And because it's who they are and they can sit up straight
and they can shake the hand and they can look you in the eye
and they can speak articulately, when they're doing all of that in the interview,
their working memory is freed up to be able to think about the content
that they have to provide to the interviewer to say,
I'm the person, the right person for this job.
If on the other hand, you're a typical inner city kid
who hasn't been taught any of those habits,
he's going into that interview thinking,
remember to pull my trousers up.
Remember that I have to sit down.
Oh, I have to shake the hand.
Oh, I didn't look him in the eye.
Oh, did I even know that I was meant to look him in the eye?
Oh gosh.
Oh God, I didn't bring a pen.
And I didn't prepare for the interview either.
And I don't actually know what I'm doing.
And my working memory is completely overloaded
because there's nothing in my long-term memory
because I was never taught what,
I was only ever taught how,
or I was actually just messing around
and pushing people in the corridor and bullying other kids and so on.
And so I'm now turning up to this interview and I've got nothing.
Whereas if the school, on the other hand,
is teaching them what to think,
is building those habits in them over and over and over again
until you get to the top,
you are creating human beings, adults,
who are then able to do it on their own.
And that is what you and Jonathan Haidt want.
You want the kids who are able to be creative,
to be independently minded,
to own their own development and so on.
You only get there by teaching them what to think
and by instilling those good habits over years,
through correction over correction.
You were late again today.
Detention, detention, right.
Merit over here.
Merit over there.
That was brilliant work.
Wow.
Five days straight.
You beat on time.
Well done.
Constant correction.
You're doing that.
Praise and punishment.
At the beginning, I didn't say actually.
So punishment is a dirty word these days.
When I first started my career, punishment was fine.
Then they said,
Oh no, no, children shouldn't be punished.
That's a terrible thing.
We need to turn to sanctions.
And so then we moved to sanctions.
You couldn't ever say punishments.
You had to use sanctions.
Then they said,
Oh my goodness.
Yes.
What is this, the UN?
It was crazy.
So they told us it was all sanctions.
Your sanction was a detention,
but you never talked about detention.
You talked about sanctions.
Then they said,
No, no, no, no, no.
We have to move now to, what was it?
Correction.
So then you started talking about corrections.
Then we moved back to prison.
Okay.
Well, and then we went to consequences.
Okay.
Like we moved from punishment,
sanction, correction, consequence.
We've now got to a point where even consequence,
they say, you know what?
Detentions are just terrible.
What about their mental health?
What about their anxiety?
This is what they say.
And I say, if you don't give children praise and punishment,
that's when you get anxiety.
Okay.
If a child leaves school,
functionally illiterate and functionally innumerate,
that's when they're anxious for the rest of their lives.
So the thing is, is that we've all lost our minds.
We have no idea how to hold standards high anymore for children.
And the children are then going to university.
And then Jordan Peterson comes along.
And Jordan Peterson says,
oh my goodness, look at what's going on in universities.
Oh my goodness, look at what's coming out.
And he's absolutely right.
But where he's wrong is that he doesn't understand
that this already happened at school.
And the reason why all of these guys are wrong
is that none of them care about what's happening in schools.
And I feel like I'm the only person running around
like a salesman with my little suitcase,
going around trying to say to people with my flag,
listen to me, listen to me.
You don't understand.
It's all about what's happening in schools.
But nobody's listening.
