No More Debate!! Dry Aged Vs Wet Aged Steak Experiment

Happy Grill Time
30 followers
PitmasterX skill full explains the difference between dry aging and wet aging a steak. Which is better for your wallet and which is best overall. In a extended experiment he will take you on a journy to discover the differences.
#cooking #food #grillfood
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video compares dry-aged and wet-aged beef using cuts from the same animal to ensure a fair test. After five weeks of aging, the creator evaluates the differences in effort, cost, tenderness, and flavor to determine if the complex process of dry aging is truly worth the investment.
This is the same cow, this is the same cat and it's both been aging for five weeks.
But one of them was vacuum packed and put in the fridge.
And the other one I hung in my butcher's dry-aged cabinet.
Today we're going to find out what's better dry-aged steak or wet-aged steak.
Dry-aged beef is expensive.
It takes time, it takes space, it loses weight and if you do it wrong it can go very very raw.
Wet-aged beef is much easier.
It stays in vacuum bags, it almost loses no weight and you can even find it in the supermarket.
But does easier also mean worse?
Or is dry-aged beef really worth all the money, effort, risk and meat loss?
Today we are going to find out.
Five weeks ago we slaughtered our neighbor's cow
and that gives me a unique opportunity to do an honest experiment.
Because most of the time these experiments are done with store-bought cuts
and not actually of the same animal.
Because the slightest detail is going to make a steak taste different.
It could be age, it could be feeding, it can be DNA, it can be anything.
My neighbor's cow has been raised up to 18 months old
and it's a crossbreed between Black Angus and Holsteiner dairy calves.
And I might have said this before but I actually love the way
that the dairy farmers work with this product.
Because they need their dairy cows to get calves so that they can actually get milk.
And so you kind of get the best of both worlds.
On one hand you get your dairy and on the other hand you get the meat.
It's the ultimate form of efficiency and sustainability.
So once the cow was slaughtered I went to my butcher Gert-Jan van der Horst
and we cut it up together so that I can get specifically these two cuts.
One for the dry-ager and one for the vacuum bag so we can do this comparison.
I already have a lot of knowledge on dry aging and wet aging
and I actually expect the dry-aged steak to be nutty flavor and tender
and kind of like developed umami.
And from the wet-aged steak I'm expecting a little less moisture loss.
I'm expecting tenderness but overall the same flavor profile.
And maybe a little bit more acidic flavor because we kept it in the bag.
And that's where my expectations stop.
Because I want to know if the dry-aged steak became more tender than the wet-aged steak.
And which one of these is actually better and which one of these I prefer the most.
What is dry aging?
Well dry aging is when you take a piece of beef, put it in a dry aging cabinet.
Which is a conditioned environment, means cooling, antibacterial.
That also means it has a ventilator and a UV light to kill the actual bacteria.
And also very important it controls the humidity.
Then we are talking about dry aging conditions.
And that piece of beef over time will decay without starting to rot.
And without starting to rot is maybe the most important part.
Because nobody likes a rotten steak.
I know it all sounds very complicated and that's why we have wet aging.
Wet aging is the opposite of dry aging.
And not only because it's dry versus wet.
Because it's also easy versus hard.
Because with wet aging all you have to do is put the beef in a bag, put it in the fridge.
And then just wait.
All the magic is going to happen by itself without you having to do anything.
And without the risk of failure.
Now of course as long as you keep the temperatures way down.
Not freezing but just above freezing.
And I think the idea behind this is so brilliant that I actually made a short
film content video about it.
Telling you to buy the oldest beef in the store as long as it's well packed.
And kept at the right conditions.
And that means just low temperatures.
You can even go as far as to buy the oldest meat in the store.
And have better results than the freshest meat.
So be on the lookout for that expiration sticker that gives you a nice big discount.
So now that we actually know how dry aging and wet aging works.
We kind of also get an understanding of the amount of effort that we put in with dry aging.
It's not just UV light.
It's also the antibacterial activities.
And it's also moisture control.
Whereas with the wet aging it's a lot simpler.
All you have to do is pack the steak or the roast in a proper way.
And the amount of effort that that takes is so much lower.
That it kind of makes sense that a dry aged steak costs a lot more money than a wet aged steak.
Another thing that is going to add up on the cost side is the risk.
If you are dry aging and the dry aging goes bad.
Which means you're getting mold, moisture spots.
It can happen every now and then.
And it also means you're going to have to throw away those pieces of meat.
Or cut them off.
Which means a lot more waste and therefore higher cost.
And we cannot forget about the humidity loss.
Just think about keeping meat in a bag like this.
Where does the humidity go?
Nowhere.
It stays in the bag.
But with a roast like this, well you can control the humidity in the cabinet.
But in the end you're going to lose moisture.
So it's inevitable that you're going to lose some of the weight.
And if we factor all that in.
Then can the dry aged steak still beat the wet aged steak?
Because you're going to need a lot better flavor to make up for those extra costs.
Of course you can dry it for a lot longer.
And the flavor will keep developing.
And the steak will become even more tender.
But is it then still worth it?
Or are we just losing too much moisture?
Hopefully for me I hit the sweet spot.
And this steak is going to be the best it can be.
I think it's time to take a look at this wet aged steak.
And experience what it's actually like opening one of these bags.
The first impression is that the meat definitely changed some color.
From a dark red meat we went to a lighter almost pink color.
And some trimming is definitely in order.
Because the fat's almost falling off.
Let's make a cross cut to take a look inside.
And there we see the beautiful trusted steak color.
Which gives me the indication that I need to trim off some of the outside meat.
To expose this diamond in the rough.
This does mean that I will be creating more waste than I've expected on forehand.
But in the end I want to do everything to ensure that I'm going to get the perfect steak.
When I've got everything trimmed down the portion is quite small.
Definitely smaller than I expected.
Time for the dry aged beef.
The trimming is definitely a little bit more challenging.
But there's a lot less waste than I expected.
35 days dry aged is definitely not doing anything great.
However I do want to get rid of all the fat on the outside of this steak.
Because the flavors of the fat are really intense.
It will give you an extreme dry aged taste going towards the rancid.
And that will not make my steak taste better.
And again the sizes of the steaks are kind of small.
So I'll just leave them a little thicker.
That way I will still end up with a decent cut of meat.
I'm gonna leave one steak with a little bit of fat on.
So that I can taste it afterwards.
To see if I'm right on how rancid the fat actually got.
I'm gonna tidy this up with butcher's twine.
Season them with salt.
Then the steaks go into the fridge for about four hours.
So they can soak up the flavor of the salt.
For my grill I will be using the Napoleon professional charcoal.
It's a grill that will let you lift the charcoal bed up and down.
To increase or decrease the temperatures underneath your steak.
And with its cast iron grill grates it's absolutely perfect for this job.
The charcoal grill is up to temperature.
The steaks are ready to go.
All I need to do now is stick in a wireless thermometer and put it on the grill.
This is a wet aged steak.
I think we got a beautiful Maillard effect with a nice crust.
And it looks really good.
But the real question is what does it look like on the inside?
And does it taste good?
I'm really not surprised.
But this steak looks freaking amazing.
You just have to think about it.
It's wet aged.
And when we started out with it the steak looked already really really good.
Something out of a fairy tale.
But now that it's cooked it looks even better.
I'm already super happy with this experiment.
And the question is now what does it taste like?
I can't start to explain how tender this is.
It is super super tender.
Insane tender.
I'm not talking about regular tenderness.
I'm talking about next level tenderness.
So I must say that I was a little bit worried about the fat and how it would turn out.
You know it's a ribeye.
You got the fat running through.
And I am glad that I cut off so much to get that perfect steak.
Because now it's absolutely perfect.
Now for the dry aged steak.
How good is it in comparison?
Is it worth all the extra effort?
Let's find out.
And again perfect results.
Look at that steak.
It is a thing of beauty.
Literally.
This is what dreams are made of.
We can look at it all day.
I mean the crust is fantastic.
The steak looks really really good.
But what does it taste like?
Dry aged.
There we go.
It is so good.
So the first thing you need to get out of the way is that
what these steaks have in common is that they're both great.
But I also had a steak well almost after we butchered it.
Like seven days after.
And the steak was amazing.
But it wasn't great like this.
This is next level.
I mean the tenderness is insane.
The flavor profile is really good.
It's not like exaggerating dry aged flavor profile.
But the tenderness and a little bit of the umami nuttiness is really really good.
So overall this is a fantastic steak.
I mean you can buy Wagyu steak any day of the week these days.
Even in supermarkets.
And I mean seriously nothing special about Wagyu anymore.
But this like dry aged and effort and love and
and like going the extra mile.
It just makes a steak so much better.
It's so good.
It's really good.
But now we really have to ask ourselves which one is better?
The dry aged or the wet aged?
And if the dry aged is better then is it worth all the extra effort?
So one more taste test right?
Wet aged.
Real good.
Dry aged.
The outcome is not what I expected.
I expected the dry aged steak to win by miles and be so much better.
I'm a visual guy.
You get that right?
So let's put it this way.
The steak seven days after butchering.
It was really really good like this.
Then we wet aged it.
And it became like this.
Significantly better.
And the dry aging effort is just a little bit better.
Like a little bit.
Like maybe five percent in the overall goodness of the steak.
And if you think about that.
Is it then worth it?
Dry aging a steak.
That basically means we're unlocking something here.
If we're just going to the supermarket and we're buying the oldest steak that we can find.
And preferably for a discount.
We're golden.
Don't worry about dry aging.
Forget about it.
Oh my god.
I'm gonna find the dog.
And I'm gonna see if we can have her do a taste test.
And which one she prefers.
Wet aged.
Dry aged.
Okay there we go.
Wet aged.
Dry aged.
Which one?
