Ptolemy's Almagest dominated astronomical thought from when it was written in the 2nd century CE, until the 16th century. Yet, as historically important as this work is, its nearly impossible to find out anything beyond a surface level understanding of what it contained.
This video will cover Books I and II. In this, Ptolemy introduces his philosophical assumptions, develops several handy tables that he will rely on to make calculations easier, discusses his place on the terrestrial sphere, and explains how location influences our view of the cosmos.
Written in the 2nd century CE, Claudius Ptolemy's Mathematicae Syntaxis,
better known as the Almagest, became the most important text in mathematical astronomy for the
next 1500 years. But despite the historical significance of this text, it's nearly impossible
to find detailed information on how its models were derived and functioned. So much so that when
I began studying historical astronomy, I decided it was best to sit down and work through it myself.
So in this series, I'll share what I've learned about one of the most important
astronomical texts of all time. I'll begin by addressing things conceptually so viewers that
aren't interested in the detailed mathematical workings can get an appreciation for Ptolemy's
work. With that out of the way, I'll then explore select mathematical topics, taking the understanding
from conceptual to functional, allowing viewers to understand how the models were practically
applied. In this video, I'll be exploring books 1 and 2 of the 13 books that compose the Almagest.
In these, Ptolemy lays out his philosophical assumptions, develops several handy tables that
he will rely on to make calculations easier, discusses his place on the terrestrial sphere,
and explains how location influences our view of the cosmos. So join me as we learn how Ptolemy
defined astronomy before the telescope. Ptolemy opens the Almagest addressing Cyrus, to whom a
number of Ptolemy's works are addressed. However, historians have no idea who this individual was,
and if he existed at all, as the name is rather generic. Ptolemy then launches into a brief
discussion on philosophy. It begins with moral philosophy, which, Ptolemy tells us,
individuals can possess some of the moral virtues, even without having been taught. He contrasts this
with natural philosophy, in which it is impossible to achieve a theoretical understanding of the
universe without instruction. He then discusses how Aristotle breaks theoretical philosophy into
three subcategories – physics, mathematics, and theology. Ptolemy sees astronomy as touching on
all three of these. Specifically, the cosmos has various motions associated with it. One may ask
what the first motion was, which Ptolemy immediately states can be viewed as caused by
an invisible and motionless deity. Thus, astronomy is theology, which is completely
separated from perceptible reality. Second, we could ask about the nature of the various
things in the classical Greek sense. Ptolemy labels this as physics. Lastly, the investigation
of number, size, place, time, and such like, he describes as mathematics, which he takes as the
only true knowledge, since the other two are not directly observed, but rather approached
through logic and intuition. Only mathematics provides proof through indisputable methods,
namely arithmetic and geometry. Mathematics, he says, provides a means for investigation
of theology and physics, allowing men to see clearly from the constancy, order, symmetry,
and calm which are associated with the divine. Next, Ptolemy lays out an overarching vision
for the text. He tells us that we'll begin by discussing the position of the ecliptic.
Although he doesn't explain it here, this is the fundamental plane for Ptolemy as the
largely interested in the motions of the sun, moon, and planets, which all remain close to
the ecliptic. In short, the Almagest will use the ecliptic coordinate system instead of the
equatorial coordinate system. Next, he says he will discuss the regions of our part of the
inhabited world and the features differentiating each from the others due to the varying latitudes
at each horizon. In short, Ptolemy will first present many fundamental relationships along the
where things are simple, and then discuss how changing your latitude complicates the view of
the sky and the various circles within it. Then, Ptolemy will discuss the sun and moon,
followed by the phenomena accompanying these motions, by which he means eclipses.
From there, Ptolemy will discuss the fixed stars before discussing the five planets.
But, before doing that, he tells us that we'll need to make some underlying assumptions and
observations about the nature of the cosmos. The first is that the heavens appear to move
like a sphere around us. This is essentially introducing the concept of the celestial
sphere. Ptolemy justifies this by noting that the stars all seem to rotate around a pole,
exactly in the manner we should expect if we were at the center of a sphere being rotated around an
axis in which those stars which were closest to the pole revolved on a smaller circle, while those
that were further away described circles ever greater in proportion to their distance.
Of course, from any point on Earth, we can only see half of this sphere at a time. So,
how do we know it's not just a dome? This would really be best addressed by noting that the
horizon is an illusion, and that the Earth is a sphere, so domes for every horizon amount to a
sphere. But Ptolemy hasn't established a spherical Earth yet, so he doesn't take this approach.
Rather, he states that if the sky were only a dome, this would mean that the eastern portion
of it would have to generate the stars, while the west side extinguished them. Ptolemy calls this a
completely absurd hypothesis, as it would necessitate the generating process recreate the
stars in perfectly the same positions, night after night, and he assumes that any generative process
would be too chaotic for this. Furthermore, there are some stars which never set, known as
circumpolar stars, and those individuals who would claim that the stars are generated and
extinguished fail to address these. He hints at the sphericity of the Earth, noting that the
number of stars which are circumpolar differ for different observers at different latitudes.
In the next chapter, Ptolemy does address the fact that the Earth is a sphere. As evidence for this,
he states that the sun, moon, and other stars do not rise and set simultaneously for everyone on
the Earth, but do so earlier for those more towards the east and later for those in the west.
This is a rather interesting thing to tease out without reliable clocks that can be compared
against local time as determined by the sun. But, it is easily demonstrated by observing the timing
of celestial events, like eclipses, from different longitudes, which is precisely what Ptolemy uses
as proof. He notes that eclipses are not recorded as occurring at the same hour by all observers.
Rather, the hour recorded by the more easterly observers is always later than that recorded by
the more westerly, and that the differences in the hour are proportional to the distances between
the places of observation. As further proof, Ptolemy also notes that when one sails towards
mountains, they seem to rise out of the ocean, beginning with their peaks, due to the curvature
of the Earth. Ptolemy next discusses the location of the Earth in the cosmos. Here, he adopts a
geocentric position that the Earth is the center of the cosmos, and presents arguments for this.
The first is that, if the Earth were displaced, it would cause the timing of equinoxes and solstices
to be different. Additionally, if the Earth were closer to one side of the celestial sphere than
another, we wouldn't see precisely half of the celestial sphere at a time, as the side we were
closer to would dominate our local sky. There's a few hidden assumptions here that are where Ptolemy
goes wrong. In particular, Ptolemy's argument regarding the equinoxes and solstices assumes that
the motion of the other objects is more or less centered in the cosmos. Furthermore, he,
understandably, fails to appreciate the size of the cosmos. Our solar system is so small in
comparison that, even though the Earth does move, its motion was impossible to observe until the
19th century. In chapter 6, Ptolemy argues that the size of the Earth is insignificant with respect
to the size of the heavens. In other words, no matter where you are on Earth, you're effectively
at the center of the cosmos. You don't have to worry about your position on the Earth
bringing you closer or further to one side of the celestial sphere. This may sound rather
unimportant, but it actually becomes relevant for some of the math later on. However, there's also
a notable exception for this as the Moon displays a notable parallax due to how close it is.
Ptolemy then argues that the Earth does not move. Essentially, Ptolemy is stating that the Earth
cannot orbit the Sun. And the reasoning he gives here is the same arguments as the preceding ones
regarding the centrality of the Earth. However, he also provides a further argument based on the
observation that anywhere on Earth, objects seem to fall down. He assumes that downness is an
essential property of the cosmos, drawing everything towards its center, and that the
Earth has settled with its center coincident with this cosmic center. He states that light and
rarefied bodies drift outwards, towards the circumference, but seem to move in the direction
which is up for each observer since the overhead direction for all of us, which is also called up,
points towards the surrounding surface. Heavy and dense bodies, on the other hand,
are carried towards the middle and the center, but seem to fall downwards because, again,
the direction which is for all of us towards our feet, called down, also points towards the center
of the Earth. A further consideration in this chapter is whether the Earth rotates as had
been suggested by Heraclitus of Pontus in the late 4th century BCE. Ptolemy rejects this,
noting that the clouds do not get left behind as the Earth rotates. Again, Ptolemy had no concept
of inertia and assumed that they would tend towards rest without a force sustaining their
motion. With the previous assumptions in place, Ptolemy is essentially done with the starting
assumptions. The rest of the book will be based on observations and mathematical reasoning.
And the first observation that Ptolemy gives is that there appears to be two primary motions
of the heavens. The first is what we might describe as the bulk motion of the night sky,
in which things rotate about us from east to west every day. In modern astronomy,
we recognize this as being caused by the rotation of the Earth. However, since Ptolemy assumes that
the Earth does not rotate, he takes this motion to be produced by the rotation of the sphere of
the stars about the Earth and refers to it as a forward motion. This rotation takes place about
the poles, which naturally produces a great circle, known as the celestial equator. Ptolemy
informs us that it is called the equator because this celestial great circle is always bisected in
two equal portions by our local horizon. The second motion is the motion of the Sun, Moon,
and planets. While they generally get carried across the sky every day, if we pay careful
attention, we can find that they tend to move west to east amongst the background stars.
This is generally easy to observe for the planets and the Moon if you watch for a few nights.
Unfortunately, the Sun blocks us from seeing the motion against the stars for it,
but we can observe that the same stars rise about 4 minutes earlier each day,
which is another way of stating that the Sun rises 4 minutes later each day due to its west
to east motion. In truth, a 360 degree revolution is actually occurring in about 23 hours and 56
minutes, but since we reckon time by the Sun, we add those 4 minutes to bring a day to 24 hours.
Ptolemy considers whether this second motion is truly independent and concludes that it is,
given that it is not simply that these objects tend to move a bit more slowly.
Rather, their motion is along an entirely separate path, the ecliptic, which is also a great circle
with its own poles. The intersection of these two great circles, the celestial equator and
the ecliptic, produces two points in which they intersect, which are the equinoctial points,
where the Sun appears on the equinoxes. Furthermore, if we draw another great circle
through the two poles, it will cut these two circles at right angles, at the points at which
the two circles are furthest apart from each other, known as the solstices. So, this chapter
serves as a bit of a primer on the motions of the various objects as well as the great circles of
the celestial sphere. Chapter 9 is extremely short and is simply Ptolemy stating that his first
demonstration will be to determine the size of the arc between the aforementioned poles along
the great circle drawn through them. Today, we call this the obliquity of the ecliptic.
Before addressing that topic, Ptolemy takes a detour to teach us some math. Much of the math
that we take for granted today hadn't been developed in Ptolemy's time. Ptolemy isn't able
to solve right triangles with sine and cosine. Instead, he uses a geometrical solution in which
a similar unit triangle is inscribed in a unit circle and then uses a relationship between the
angles and chords to solve for the unknown portions. He can then relate this similar
triangle to the one in question to determine the unknown parts. But to do any of that,
he'll need to know what the relationship between the chords and central angles are
in his unit circle. To do that, Ptolemy lays out a table of these angles and associated chords
in half-degree increments from 0 to 180 degrees. However, Ptolemy is going to do this from first
principles. So, he's going to show us exactly how these relationships were determined,
which is the subject of Chapter 10. I won't go through them in depth here, but since this is
the first time we've encountered any math, it's worth noting that Ptolemy doesn't work in decimal.
Rather, he uses a base 60 system known as sexagesimal. This may sound scary,
but you're actually more familiar with it than you think as there's 60 seconds per minute and
60 minutes per hour. That pattern doesn't continue as there's 24 hours in a day. But
if we continued that pattern in both directions, that's all sexagesimal really is. Again,
I'll cover this more in a future video on the mathematical techniques of the Almagest.
But for now, I'll only go so far as to state that he begins with some central angles that are
easy to calculate, 36, 60, 72, 90, 108, 120, and 144 degrees. But beyond these relatively easy
cases, calculating the chords of the angles begins to get trickier, and Ptolemy can't calculate them
directly with the same ease. So, he introduces a theorem, now referred to as Ptolemy's theorem,
as the Almagest is the oldest reference to it, although it's unclear if Ptolemy actually
invented it. This allows Ptolemy to derive a formula for the chord of difference. For example,
since we know the chords of 72 degrees and 60 degrees, this formula allows him to work out
the chord of 12 degrees, which is 72 minus 60. No, it's not simply the difference of the chords.
Similarly, he derives formulas to determine the chord of half an angle he already knows
as well as what happens when you have the sum of angles. And with a little help from a theorem from
Aristarchus, he's able to determine the length of any chord for each half-degree interval from 0
to 180 degrees. And that is laid out in chapter 11, the entirety of which is the presentation
of that table. Returning to the question of the angle between the two great circles,
Ptolemy determines this observationally and introduces two instruments which
both serve the same function, to measure the angle of the sun above the horizon.
The first is a ring divided into 360 degrees with an inner ring that can rotate. The inner
ring has a raised piece on either side placed diametrically opposite from one another.
When the one towards the sun casts a shadow on the rear one, it is directly aligned with the sun
and the angle can be read off the outer ring. A second instrument is even simpler, a quadrant
drawn on a vertical surface with a nail at the center point from which the quadrant is taken.
To use these instruments to determine the obliquity of the ecliptic, the observer would
measure the angle of the sun above the horizon at local noon, i.e. when it's directly south,
on the equinoxes and then compare that to the same angle on the solstices. The difference
between the two is the obliquity of the ecliptic. Ptolemy gives his value as 23 degrees, 51 minutes,
and 20 seconds, or 23.85 degrees, which is a bit high. The value changes over time,
but in Ptolemy's era it was around 23.7 degrees. With this in hand, Ptolemy is nearly ready to
start working out some things on the celestial sphere. In particular, he tells us that he
intends to determine what the length of the arc between the ecliptic and celestial equator is
at different points around these two circles. The value Ptolemy just derived is the extreme.
It decreases on either side of this, reaching zero when the circles intersect,
and then increasing again until it reaches the same value in the opposite direction,
at the other pole. However, all the math you've learned in high school is designed to work on
flat surfaces, and the surface of a sphere is anything but. As such, Ptolemy is going to have
teach us some basics of solving problems when they're on a sphere. With a few preliminary proofs,
Ptolemy derives his one tool he uses to solve these types of problems, Menelaus' theorem,
named after Menelaus of Alexandria. If you're furiously googling this theorem, be warned,
the version of this theorem that you find most frequently is actually meant for flat surfaces.
The version Ptolemy gives is tailored for spheres. Ultimately, Ptolemy works out two
versions of the theorem, both of which function fairly similarly as they both involve segments of
four intersecting great circles on the celestial sphere, the arcs they make as they intersect,
and the chords of those arcs. You may be wondering where we're going to find so many
great circles as we've really only talked about two so far, the celestial equator and the ecliptic.
We find out how Ptolemy intends to address this in chapter 14, and it involves making use of some
great circles that aren't cool enough to get special names. One of them will be the great
circle that's perpendicular to the celestial equator and passes through the point in question
along the ecliptic, and he also makes use of a great circle drawn through the two solstices.
Ptolemy then walks us through an example calculation for the arc between the celestial
equator and the ecliptic 30 degrees along the ecliptic from the vernal equinox. Behind the
scenes, Ptolemy then repeats this calculation for one degree increments along the ecliptic
from 0 to 90 degrees, which is all he needs to do since it's symmetrical about the solstices.
The results of these calculations are laid out in a table, which is the entirety of chapter 15.
So, what use is knowing all of this? Well, it's something we'll be using quite a bit as this just
gave us a new segment of a great circle we now know things about for future use in other
applications of Menelaus' theorem. And the first application Ptolemy gives us is to find the
amount of time it takes for segments of the ecliptic to cross the horizon at sphera recta,
which is a term that even if you like astronomy, I bet you haven't heard before. I know I sure
hadn't. It literally translates as the upright sphere and essentially refers to the view from
the terrestrial equator in which the celestial equator is perpendicular to the horizon.
Returning to the topic for this chapter, because the ecliptic is at an angle with respect to the
celestial equator, equal arcs of it don't rise in equal intervals of time. Ptolemy wants to know
how long it takes a given 10-degree arc to rise. This, he calculates in time degrees. In other
words, he gives the answer in degrees instead of hours, minutes, and seconds. However, one can
convert to hours, minutes, and seconds by taking the same proportion of 24 hours as the value given
is of a full circle, or 360 degrees. What Ptolemy demonstrates is that the segments of the ecliptic
nearest the solstices take longer to rise than the ones nearer to the equinoxes. And that's all for
Book 1. As discussed in Book 1, Chapter 2, Ptolemy now needs to inquire about the effect that varying
the latitude of the observer will have on their view of the night sky. Changing their longitude
just changes what we refer to as the time zone. But increasing or decreasing the latitude rotates
the whole sky. The more north you go, the higher the northern constellations appear in your night
sky. Similarly, the more southern constellations sink below the southern horizon. To get us ready,
Ptolemy starts Book 2 off with a bit of geography. He states that if the whole of the world were
divided into quarters by the equator and a great circle drawn through the terrestrial poles,
then we would be in the northwestern section. As evidence that we're in the northern hemisphere,
he notes that the shadow of a gnomon of a sundial, the part that casts the shadow,
always points north, meaning that the sun is to the south. The statement on longitude is a bit
more of a cheat, since Ptolemy could have imagined this in any orientation and declared himself
either to be in the east or the west. But keep in mind that in the second century,
his knowledge of geography would have been of Europe, Africa, and Asia. Africa was simply
south, so he was really asking which was more western between Europe and Asia.
And based on the previously mentioned fact that eclipses appear to happen later in the same day
when the observer is more towards Asia than Europe, he can confidently state that he's
further west. Turning back towards astronomy, Ptolemy proposes seven points which might be
most appropriate to study. The first will be how far the celestial poles are from the horizons at
various locations, which is effectively asking the same question as the distance of the zenith,
the point straight up in the sky from your location, is from the celestial equator,
as measured along the meridian. Second, he asks, for what regions is the sun able to
pass through the zenith as well as when and how often this occurs? Third, what is the ratio of
shadows of the sun on the equinox versus the solstice? Fourth, the difference in the lengths
of the longest and shortest days? Fifth, how quickly the length of the day and night changes,
day to day? Sixth, what arc of the celestial equator rises or sets with a certain arc of
the ecliptic? And lastly, he says that we will explore particulars and quantities of angles
between the more important great circles. However, instead of addressing any of the questions Ptolemy
just told us he was interested in, he goes off in another direction, asking how to find the arc of
the horizon between the celestial equator and a given point of the ecliptic for various latitudes.
As is often the case, Ptolemy provides an example problem. He works it for an observer in Rhodes,
Greece, which Ptolemy believed to be at 36°N latitude, and takes the point of the winter
solstice of the ecliptic to be just rising on the horizon. Essentially, what Ptolemy is asking
is how far that point, the winter solstice, on the ecliptic is away from the celestial equator
along our horizon. This is a bit of a funny way to phrase the question because the celestial
equator always crosses the horizon due east and due west. So, what Ptolemy is really asking
is how to find how far away from due east the ecliptic crosses the horizon at various latitudes
at different times. As a more general case, asking how far away from east something rises
is known as the ortive amplitude. I'm not going to walk through Ptolemy's example problem,
but this is one of those spherical geometry problems that makes use of Menelaus' theorem.
The four great circles involved are the celestial equator, the horizon, the observer's meridian,
and a great circle drawn in through the celestial pole and the winter solstice,
which is on the horizon. It gives a Menelaus configuration looking something like this.
In the next chapter, Ptolemy discusses how to use the information on the length of the
longest day, the summer solstice, to be able to calculate the altitude of the north celestial
pole above the horizon. This problem is not particularly different from the previous one
and uses an almost identical application of Menelaus' theorem. Next, Ptolemy looks at how
often the sun reaches the zenith at various latitudes. This isn't really a calculation
so much as a visual understanding of the celestial sphere. Discussing this in modern astronomy,
as the Earth rotates beneath the celestial sphere, the zenith point will trace out a small circle
about the celestial sphere. As a quick statement, the small circle that the zenith traces out
is going to be as far away from the celestial equator as is the latitude for the observer.
So, if you're on the terrestrial equator, then your zenith will be zero degrees from the celestial
equator, essentially tracing it. If you're at 10 degrees north latitude, your zenith will trace out
a small circle 10 degrees above the celestial equator. In short, your zenith will trace your
line of latitude onto the celestial sphere each day. Understanding this, it means that the most
northerly point at which the sun can pass through the zenith is the latitude equal to the obliquity
which, again, Ptolemy previously gave as 23.85 degrees. At that latitude, on and only on the
solstice, the sun will touch the zenith. At all lower latitudes, it will pass through the zenith
on two days, once as it moves northward and once as it returns southward. At higher latitudes,
the sun cannot cross through the zenith. But when does this happen? Ptolemy tells us that
we can actually use the table of inclinations that he created in Book 1, Chapter 15 to figure
this out by looking up the latitude in question. We then take the corresponding value as a fraction
of 360 degrees and determine what proportion of a year that is. Add and subtract that from the
date of the summer solstice to figure out the dates that the sun passes through the zenith.
Ptolemy doesn't stop to explain why this works, it's simply left as a neat trick.
Next, Ptolemy asks how we can derive the ratio of the length of a sundial's nomen on the solstice
versus the equinox. This is a pretty straightforward high school trig problem,
only complicated by the fact that Ptolemy didn't have high school trig.
So, he has to apply his best method of solving right triangles to solve it.
Ptolemy has laid out these last few chapters because, in Chapter 6, he goes through the
various terrestrial latitudes and talks about how the sky would look in each of them.
He begins with the terrestrial equator and works his way northwards,
defining a total of 39 zones. For each, he describes the length of the longest day,
which direction the shadows of the nomens point, and how long the days are on the equinox and
solstice. At many latitudes, he also lists a major city. This chapter feels very out of place in the
Almagest as a whole, and the translator, G.J. Toomer, makes it clear in the footnotes that
this is something of a fossil from an earlier astronomical tradition, in which this information
had some uses. But, as far as the Almagest goes, we'd never actually use this information again.
Ptolemy then returns to the question of how long various arcs of the ecliptic take to rise with
various parts of the celestial equator, but now for the more complicated case in which the observer
isn't on the terrestrial equator. The math gets a bit more complicated, but Ptolemy is still able
to exploit some symmetries about the solstices and equinoxes to save himself some work. He first
proves these symmetries, and then works through another example problem for us. Having shown us
how to do the math, Ptolemy again does the rest of it behind the scenes and gives us the results
in a handy table which has several columns, calculated for the various latitudes, but not
all 39 he went through back in chapter 6. Instead, he picks 11 that he finds especially important.
This has been a lot of work, so Ptolemy spends a chapter illustrating some of the handy things we
can determine from this table. The first thing that he tells us we can do is to determine the
length of a day at various times throughout the year. Second, we can convert to what are known as
seasonal hours, which I should pause to explain. In modern timekeeping, we divide the day into 24
hours of equal length, referred to as equal hours. However, this wasn't how it was always done.
For much of the medieval period and the era prior, it was quite common to simply divide the day and
night each into 12 hours. On the equinoxes, this would be the same as the equal hours. However,
during the summer, when the days are longer, the daytime hours would have to be stretched and are
longer than the equal hours. Conversely, at night during the summer, the seasonal hours are shorter
than an equal hour. This is an annoying system, but will actually be important later on when
Ptolemy needs more ancient records which were recorded in the unequal hours system.
Thus, he needs to understand what it means in terms of the equal hours so that he can work
with these observations. Next, Ptolemy gives the most significant nod to astrology in the
entire Almagest by telling us that these rising timetables are helpful for determining what zodiac
sign was on the horizon at a given time. Ptolemy doesn't explicitly call this out as astrological,
but at the end of the day, this is known as the ascendant sign. Another application with potential
uses in astrology is finding what point of the zodiac is on the observer's meridian at a given
time. Again, Ptolemy doesn't explicitly tie this to astrology, but this is the culminating sign,
as culminating means on the meridian, and is divided into an upper culmination, when something
crosses the portion of the meridian above the horizon, and a lower one, when it crosses the
meridian below the horizon. We're also told that we can go backwards, and if we know how high above
the horizon something culminated, we can determine where along the horizon it would have risen.
The next several chapters are Ptolemy showing how to work out various other angles on the celestial
sphere. In chapter 10, he demonstrates how to find the angle between a point on the ecliptic
and the observer's meridian. In chapter 11, he demonstrates how to find the angle the ecliptic
makes with the horizon. In chapter 12, Ptolemy explores two topics. The first is the angle made
between the ecliptic and an altitude circle. An altitude circle is simply another great circle
that goes through the observer's zenith, which is the pole of the horizon, and some other point.
The meridian, which we've discussed previously, is simply a special case of an altitude circle
where the second point is the points due north or due south. Ptolemy picks his points that the
circle will be going through as the various points along the ecliptic, but the manner in which he
chooses the points along the ecliptic is initially rather odd. He chooses them based on how long it
will be until that point reaches the observer's meridian in hourly increments. This means that
the calculation will make use of the rising timetables to determine some of the arcs
involved in the calculation, so we're starting to see how the Almagest builds upon itself.
In addition, Ptolemy also demonstrates how to calculate the distance of these points from the
observer's zenith. Before beginning chapter 13, I'll pause briefly to say that the calculations
we've introduced have seemed pretty random and arbitrary. However, they will be coming into play
well down the road. Specifically, we'll be coming back to this information in book 5 and book 6,
where we deal with the moon, because the moon is close enough to exhibit parallax,
and this information will be needed to determine just how much.
However, there's a lot that goes into determining the lunar parallax.
This includes what point on the ecliptic we're referring to, how long before that point culminates,
the angle that the ecliptic is inclined with respect to the altitude circle at a given point
in time, and the observer's latitude. These are all things we've just discussed.
Like many of the calculations on the celestial sphere, this one gets annoyingly complicated.
So, Ptolemy does as he's done before and summarizes the results in a table.
But because there's so many factors, this table is by far the largest we've encountered so far.
He goes through the same 11 latitudes he used in the table of rising times from chapter 8 in this
book. For each one, he takes the first point of each zodiac sign and calculates the angles and
zenith distances when it is culminating and for an integer hours before and after noon.
This means that we have 11 latitudes, each with 12 signs, each with an average of 6 hours before
or after noon, resulting in about 800 entries in this table. I'm quite glad that Ptolemy did
the math for us and instead only gives us an example calculation.
And that's the end of book 2. To recap, books 1 and 2 were mostly set up for what will come later.
Ptolemy has derived from first principles the tools that he'll need to be able to solve right
triangles, taught us how to do math on the celestial sphere, introduced several important
great circles, and provided us with some nifty tables that will become important as we go.
In the next video, I'll explore book 3 in which Ptolemy introduces the eccentric and
epicyclic models to explain the complicated motion of the wandering bodies, and then he
will adopt the former to develop his model for the sun. So, join me next time as we continue
exploring how Ptolemy defined astronomy before the telescope.