In this video, we uncover why a massive region of the United States remains remarkably sparsely populated. From Montana and Wyoming to the Dakotas, Idaho, and Nebraska, discover how the Rocky Mountains, limited water, brutal winters, migration routes, mechanized farming, and transportation shaped America’s “Empty Zone.” We also explore why resource booms and remote work haven’t transformed the region—and why established cities elsewhere continue to pull people, businesses, and investment away.
This video is for educational and informational purposes only and is based on publicly available scientific data and expert analysis through August 2026.
This video analyzes why the northern interior of the United States remains sparsely populated. It explains how a combination of harsh geography, historical migration patterns, and the economic principle of agglomeration created a cycle of low density that persists despite the region's vast natural resources.
There's a massive part of the United States where something unusual happens.
Cities become smaller, highways become emptier,
towns grow farther apart, and eventually
huge stretches of the map contain almost no major population centers at all.
Montana, Wyoming, North Dakota,
South Dakota, and parts of Idaho and Nebraska
form one of the most sparsely populated regions
But this isn't empty land. There are enormous rivers,
mountain ranges, grasslands, forests,
mineral deposits, oil fields, and millions of acres of farmland.
So why didn't Americans build major cities here? Why did millions of
settlers continue west toward California and Oregon
while enormous sections of the northern interior remain sparsely populated?
The answer begins with geography, but geography alone
isn't enough. Climate, water, agriculture,
transportation, migration, and more than 150 years of settlement patterns
all reinforced one another, and scientists studying how populations
develop
have revealed something important. Once a region falls behind,
catching up can become extraordinarily difficult.
This is America's empty zone, and its story began long before the modern
United States existed.
A land that looks easier than it is.
Look at the Great Plains on a map, and they seem almost perfect for settlement.
There are no giant oceans separating communities.
Much of the terrain is relatively flat. Enormous
areas can be farmed, and some of America's longest rivers cross the region.
But zoom out, and something becomes obvious. Much of the northern interior
sits between two very different geographic environments.
To the west, rise the Rocky Mountains. To the east,
stretch the Great Plains. And together, they create difficult conditions for
large concentrations of people.
The Rockies are the first obstacle. Mountainous terrain
limits where large cities can expand. Roads become more expensive.
Railways require carefully selected routes.
Agriculture becomes harder as elevation increases.
But the mountains create another problem hundreds of kilometers away.
Water. Moist air moving across western North America
can be forced upward as it encounters mountain ranges.
As that air rises, it cools, and moisture can fall as rain or snow.
By the time air descends on the opposite side, conditions can become considerably
drier.
This rain shadow effect contributes to the semi-arid environments
found across parts of the interior west. And that matters because many successful
early American settlements depended heavily on reliable agriculture.
But limited rainfall wasn't the only challenge. The rainfall that does arrive
can be highly variable.
One year can be productive. Another can bring severe drought.
For a modern farmer with irrigation, crop insurance,
machinery, weather forecasts, and national transportation networks,
those risks can sometimes be managed. For a 19th century settler,
a failed harvest could destroy everything.
And then winter arrived. Winter changed everything.
Northern Great Plains winters can be brutal.
Cold Arctic air can move deep into the United States.
Temperatures can fall far below freezing. Snowstorms can isolate communities.
Strong winds can create dangerous wind chills
and drifting snow. Today, people have insulated houses,
natural gas, electricity, snow plows,
interstate highways, weather satellites, and modern
emergency services. Early settlers
had none of that. A severe winter wasn't simply
uncomfortable. It could become a survival problem.
Livestock could die. Transportation could stop.
Food supplies could run low. And isolated homesteads
might be separated from the nearest settlement by enormous distances.
Yet cold alone cannot explain America's population map.
Chicago is cold. Minneapolis
is cold. Boston experiences severe winters.
And north of the United States, Canadian cities such as Calgary
and Edmonton grew into major metropolitan centers.
Clearly, humans can build enormous cities in cold climates.
Something else was happening. And to understand it,
we need to follow the people who actually crossed
this landscape. Millions went west, but many
kept going. During the 19th century,
the United States experienced one of the largest territorial expansions
in its history. The Louisiana Purchase of 1803
dramatically expanded American territory. The Oregon Treaty of 1846
helped establish the northwestern boundary with British North America.
Then came migration. Thousands and eventually
millions of people moved west. But they didn't spread
evenly across the continent. They followed opportunity.
Some followed fertile farmland. Others followed rivers.
Then came the Oregon Trail. California's gold rush
created another enormous attraction after 1848.
People crossed plains and mountains
because they believed something better waited on the other side.
That distinction is important. For many migrants,
the northern interior wasn't necessarily the destination.
It was part of the journey. If you were willing to endure months of dangerous
travel, you needed a compelling reason to stop.
Was there exceptionally fertile farmland? A major port?
A huge manufacturing center? A gold rush?
An established city? For enormous areas,
the answer was no. So people continued moving.
And every person who continued west strengthened cities
somewhere else. California gained settlers.
Oregon gained settlers. Existing towns gained businesses. Businesses attracted
more workers. Workers created larger markets.
Larger markets attracted even more businesses.
Population growth began feeding itself.
Meanwhile, places that missed those early migration waves
faced the opposite problem. And then the U.S. government
tried to change that. America tried to fill the plains.
In 1862, President Abraham Lincoln signed the Homestead Act.
The idea was powerful. Encourage people to settle western lands
by offering opportunities to claim property if they lived on
and improved it under federal requirements. Settlement
accelerated. Railroad companies promoted western lands.
Advertisements promised opportunity. Immigrants arrived from Europe.
New towns appeared. For a while, it looked as though America's northern
interior might eventually fill with people. But
there was a problem hidden in the climate. Some farming
systems settlers brought west had developed in wetter environments.
As settlement moved onto the semi-arid plains,
rainfall became increasingly important and increasingly
unreliable. During favorable years, crops could succeed. That encouraged more
settlement. Then drought arrived. Harvests failed.
Families abandoned farms. Communities shrank. Scientists today
understand the Great Plains as an environment capable of enormous
climatic variability. Drought isn't an unusual accident here.
It is part of the system. And history eventually demonstrated
just how destructive that system could become.
The Great Plains could turn hostile. During the 1930s,
drought combined with land management practices to help produce one of
America's most famous environmental disasters.
The Dust Bowl. Large areas of the Great Plains
experienced severe drought. Vegetation disappeared from some heavily cultivated
landscapes. Exposed soil became vulnerable to wind
erosion. Then enormous dust storms developed.
Skies darkened. Topsoil traveled hundreds of kilometers.
Farms failed. Families migrated. The worst
Dust Bowl impacts were concentrated farther south,
especially across parts of Oklahoma, Texas,
Kansas, Colorado and New Mexico. But the disaster revealed something much
larger about the Great Plains. This landscape could support massive
agricultural production. But it could also change dramatically
when rainfall disappeared. Water would always determine what was
possible. And the farther west settlement pushed
across the plains, the more obvious that limitation became.
Then there was another problem. Successful farming
didn't necessarily mean successful cities.
Agriculture needed fewer people. This is one of the strangest parts of
America's empty zone. Much of the land isn't economically
worthless. Quite the opposite. The northern Great
Plains became enormously important for agriculture.
Wheat, cattle, corn in suitable areas, soybeans, other grains and livestock.
Modern machinery allows enormous amounts of land to be managed by relatively few
people. A single combine can harvest areas that
once required large teams of workers. Tractors became
larger. Forming became more efficient.
Transportation improved. Agricultural productivity
increased while the number of workers required on many farms
decreased. That meant the countryside could produce
more food without producing large population growth.
This is completely different from an industry that employs hundreds of
thousands of workers inside one metropolitan area.
A productive farm may require land. A major technology industry requires
people. And cities grow around people. As American agriculture mechanized, many
rural communities lost one of their biggest historical reasons for existing.
Young people increasingly moved toward larger cities.
Schools consolidated. Businesses closed. Services became concentrated in regional
centers. Population became even more spread out.
But couldn't railroads and highways solve the problem?
They helped, but they also reinforced an existing pattern.
Transportation connected the region without filling it.
Railroads transformed the American West. Before rail transportation, moving large
quantities of goods across thousands of kilometers
was slow and expensive. Railways changed that. Towns developed along important
routes. Cheyenne became a major railroad center.
Billings developed into an important regional transportation and commercial
hub. Fargo grew around transportation,
agriculture, education, and trade. Other communities expanded near river
crossings, rail junctions, mining districts, or
government centers. But notice the pattern. Development
concentrated in specific locations. Huge areas between those locations
remained lightly populated. Then automobiles and interstate highways
changed transportation again. You could now cross enormous distances
without needing a major town every few kilometers.
That actually made sparse settlement easier.
A farmer could transport goods farther. Residents could drive to regional
centers. Trucks could move products hundreds of
miles. Instead of forcing new cities to appear
everywhere, modern transportation allowed a small
number of cities to serve enormous territories. And
aviation pushed this even further. A city didn't need
to be connected to every neighboring community.
It needed access to the national network. The empty zone became more connected, but
not necessarily more populated. Then America discovered enormous resources.
If agriculture couldn't create giant cities,
perhaps natural resources could. And this region contains plenty. Montana
has coal, copper, gold, and other mineral resources.
Wyoming became America's dominant coal producing state for decades.
North Dakota contains the Bakken Formation,
one of North America's most important oil producing regions.
Oil development transformed western North Dakota
during the 21st century shale boom. Towns such as Williston expanded rapidly.
Workers arrived. Housing demand exploded. Roads became crowded.
Businesses appeared. For a moment, it demonstrated exactly what could bring
large numbers of people into the empty zone. Jobs.
But resource booms have a weakness. They depend on the resource,
and they often depend on price. When energy prices fall
or extraction slows, growth can reverse. Automation can also reduce the number of
workers required. A giant mine may generate enormous
economic value without requiring a giant city. An oil
field can stretch across thousands of square miles without
producing a metropolitan area of several million people.
Natural resources created regional centers.
They did not fundamentally rewrite the population map.
And this brings us to Canada, because just across the border
something seems to contradict the entire story.
If climate is the problem, explain Calgary.
Travel north from Montana and eventually you reach Alberta.
The geography remains familiar. Great plains,
rocky mountains, cold winters, long distances.
Yet Alberta contains two enormous metropolitan centers,
Calgary and Edmonton. So why did cities grow there while Montana and Wyoming
remained sparsely populated? Part of the answer is economic
concentration. Alberta became the center of Canada's
enormous petroleum industry. Edmonton developed as an important
industrial and administrative center. Calgary became deeply connected to the
corporate side of Canada's energy economy.
Instead of energy activity being distributed among many competing
American states and metropolitan regions,
a major portion of Canada's petroleum industry
became concentrated around a small number of Alberta cities.
Those cities then developed something even more powerful.
Momentum. Once a city becomes large enough,
it doesn't need the original industry to explain
every new resident. Universities expand. Hospitals grow. Financial services
develop. Technology companies arrive. Construction
increases. Restaurants open. Corporate headquarters attract
professionals. Immigration adds population. The city
itself becomes an economic engine. That is one
of the biggest differences between Calgary
and much of the American northern interior. Calgary
crossed a threshold. Most cities in America's empty zone
never did. Cities have gravity. Economists sometimes describe this
through agglomeration. Businesses benefit from being near other businesses.
Workers benefit from living where there are many employers.
Employers benefit from locating where there are many workers.
Universities produce skilled graduates. Airports become larger
because more people use them. Large airports
then make the city more attractive to companies.
Infrastructure attracts population. Population
justifies more infrastructure. The system
reinforces itself. That's why America's biggest cities
often continue growing even when living there becomes expensive.
People aren't choosing land alone. They're choosing networks,
jobs, education, health care, transportation, entertainment, family
connections, professional opportunities. And this
creates a major disadvantage for sparsely populated states.
Imagine two locations. One already has three million people,
a major international airport, multiple universities,
thousands of companies, specialized hospitals,
and enormous labor markets. The other has cheaper land
but only 100,000 people. Which location is more attractive to a company
employing 10,000 highly specialized workers?
Usually, the first. Cheap land isn't enough.
Empty space isn't enough. A city needs an ecosystem
and building one from scratch is incredibly difficult.
Why not build a new city? The United States
certainly has enough land. In theory, a completely new metropolitan area
could be constructed somewhere in Montana, Wyoming,
or the Dakotas. But who would move there first?
Companies need workers. Workers need jobs.
Developers need buyers. Airlines need passengers.
Universities need students. Hospitals need patients.
Retailers need customers. Everyone is waiting for everyone else.
Meanwhile, existing cities already provide those things.
This is why historical settlement patterns matter hundreds of years later.
Decisions made during the railroad era can indirectly influence
where people live in the internet era. Once population concentrates somewhere,
enormous amounts of infrastructure accumulate around it.
Moving that system becomes extremely expensive.
But there is one modern development that was supposed to change everything.
Remote work. Remote work should have changed the map.
For the first time in American history,
millions of workers discovered they didn't necessarily need to live near
their employers. In theory, that should benefit places
with cheap housing, open land, and small communities.
And some smaller cities did attract remote workers.
But remote work didn't eliminate geography. People still want airports,
restaurants, health care, schools, entertainment,
outdoor recreation, reliable internet, social networks,
and many still want access to larger cities.
That's why places such as Denver and Boise have attracted substantial growth.
They provide access to western landscapes while still offering
significant urban infrastructure. The empty zone faces the same problem again.
People may be free to live anywhere, but anywhere doesn't mean every location
is equally attractive. And another enormous change is coming.
Climate. Could a warmer climate fill the empty zone?
At first, the idea seems logical. If harsh winters discouraged settlement,
warming temperatures should make northern states more attractive.
Growing seasons could lengthen in some places. Winter temperatures could become
less severe on average. Meanwhile, parts of the American south
face increasing heat. Some coastal regions face rising sea levels.
Water shortages threaten parts of the southwest.
Could population eventually migrate north? Possibly.
But climate change creates problems for the northern interior too.
Higher temperatures can increase evaporation. Drought risk can intensify in some areas.
Wildfire conditions can worsen. Water systems can become more unpredictable.
Agriculture may face new stresses. And warmer weather alone doesn't create an economy.
People need jobs, infrastructure, housing, universities, health care, transportation.
A warmer Montana doesn't automatically become another California.
The forces keeping this region sparsely populated are much deeper than temperature.
The empty zone isn't actually empty.
There is also something important about the word empty.
This region isn't empty. Millions of people live here.
Indigenous nations have deep histories across these landscapes stretching back thousands of
years. Farmers manage enormous agricultural areas. Energy workers operate some of America's
most important resource systems. National parks attract millions of visitors.
Communities continue to grow and change.
The mystery isn't why nobody lives here. The mystery is why population density
remains so low compared with other parts of the United States.
And the answer isn't one thing. It's a chain reaction.
Mountains restricted settlement in some areas. Semi-arid conditions limited agriculture in others.
Drought increased risk. Cold winters made isolation more dangerous.
Migration routes pulled settlers toward competing destinations.
Railroads concentrated development into narrow corridors.
Agricultural mechanization reduced the number of workers needed.
Resource industries created booms without necessarily creating enormous permanent cities.
Then America's largest metropolitan regions accumulated infrastructure,
jobs, universities, airports, and investment. Each stage reinforced the next.
Why the region may stay sparsely populated.
And that's what makes the future so interesting.
There is no physical law preventing Montana from someday containing a city of 3 million people.
There is no rule saying Wyoming must remain the least populated state.
Population patterns can change. Oil transformed parts of Texas.
Technology transformed Silicon Valley. Air conditioning helped accelerate
growth across the Sun Belt. Las Vegas grew in the Mojave Desert.
Phoenix became one of America's largest cities despite extreme heat and limited local water.
Human technology can overcome extraordinary geographic obstacles,
but there has to be a reason. Jobs, resources, transportation, technology,
government investment, or some combination powerful enough to attract hundreds of thousands of people.
So far, America's northern interior hasn't experienced a transformation
large enough to completely change its settlement pattern.
And without one, existing population centers have an enormous advantage.
Dallas already exists. Seattle already exists.
Denver already exists. Minneapolis already exists.
Phoenix already exists. Every year these metropolitan areas attract
new companies, workers, infrastructure, and investment.
Starting another major city hundreds of miles away
means competing against systems that have been accumulating advantages for generations.
That's incredibly difficult.
So why is such an enormous part of America still sparsely populated?
Not because Americans simply dislike cold weather. And not because the land is useless.
The explanation is much bigger. The Rocky Mountains shaped transportation
and rainfall. The Great Plains created enormous
agricultural opportunities, but also exposed settlers to drought and extreme weather.
Early migration routes carried millions toward more attractive destinations.
Railroads created isolated population centers rather than one continuous urban corridor.
Mechanized agriculture allowed huge areas to remain productive with relatively few workers.
Mining and energy created powerful economies without necessarily producing
giant metropolitan populations. And once America's major cities were
established elsewhere, they began attracting even more people,
businesses, infrastructure, and investment. Geography started the pattern.
History reinforced it. Economics locked much of it in place.
And that may be the real reason America's empty zone remains so sparsely populated today.
Because once cities reach a certain size, they attract more growth.
And once a region spends generations without those cities,
reversing the pattern becomes enormously difficult.
The question isn't whether humans could build another major city here. They absolutely could.
The question is what would ever give millions of Americans a reason to do it.
And until that answer appears, one of the largest regions of the United States
may continue looking exactly as it does today. Enormous.
Productive. Beautiful.
And remarkably empty.
If you enjoyed this documentary, subscribe to Discover Tube for more
explorations of the hidden geography, geology, and science shaping America.
And tell us in the comments, would you live in America's empty zone?