What is the Best 1911?

Uniform & Arms
3 followers
1 Video View·Aug 14, 2026
Come help me answer this ancient question about John Browning's good old 1911 design.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe speaker explains that the \"best\" 1911 pistol depends on the user's specific goals. He categorizes these firearms into three main types—basic historical models, upgraded shooters, and high-end competition guns—to help enthusiasts choose based on whether they prioritize historical authenticity, ergonomic comfort, or maximum competitive performance.
Itcock 45 here, and I know you can read. What is the best 1911 for you? Is it this one? It might be.
Might be this very pistol I have in my hand because it is a 1911. Okay, so this might be
the best one. Yeah, I let the cat out of the bag, didn't I? Yeah, it's not really which is the best.
How do you define best, better? We use that word, those words all the time, don't we? Man, you all
ask that question so often of us. What's the best or what's the better? Which one of these is better
and all that kind of thing, and you know the answer, don't you? It's always the same answer
whether you ask that question of your mom and dad 50 years ago or you ask me or anybody else.
They always want to answer it depends, right? And that's kind of what this is about. It depends on
your purpose and what you're going to do with it. So I kind of grouped these 1911s into
two, three, maybe four different categories. If you are one of those sorry individuals who
has spent money on anything that was close to being a luxury and you don't have a 1911,
you should be ashamed of yourself. You really should. So let's talk about fixing that situation.
So if you think you might seriously, you know, entertain the notion of owning a 1911 sometimes,
not because you want to use it for your carry gun, you've seen the light, you're going to throw away
your glocks and sigs and everything else that go to a 1911. That could be the case,
but just the piece of history that it is, right? The piece of machinery that it is.
It might be something you ought to have in your collection, right? So I'm going to thank the
Davidson's Gallery of Guns where you get a guaranteed lifetime replacement on your
firearms purchase. Wonderful place. And then SDI, the Sonoran Desert Institute,
get some of that distance learning, firearms technology, drone technology. We all might
need that, right? And then of course you could get on the road to becoming a gunsmith. Appreciate
their support. Here's what I'm kind of looking at this way. If you're thinking about a
mending the error of your ways, okay. Correcting the error of your ways. And you just, yeah,
I need a 1911. Or you're just kind of new to firearms and you think they're really cool
and you've wanted one. You don't need me to bad mouth you into getting one or to talk you into
it. You're kind of looking at them, right? Well, I kind of think of them in terms of like these
over here are kind of your basic 1911s. I could have brought a Springfield Armory that you've
seen that I won many years ago in a shooting match. It's just plain Jane like these. This
is the way these came out of the box. This was a 1991. This is post-series 70, pre-series 80,
whatever it is. No, it's a pre-series 70, 1969 manufacturer. So it's very much like a series
70, not exactly. But this is the way they came out of the box. No customization. They just came
that way. Okay. Basic 1911. Very much like this one that's a USGI model. This was carried by our
soldiers, World War I, World War II. Not customized, right? Not by any stretch of the imagination.
Just your basic firearm. All right. Pathetic sights and everything. So this might be the
category that would interest you most. It's the category I started with, partly because it was
pretty much all the 1911s back in, when was that? That would have been 1973 or 4 when I bought my
first one. It looked a lot like that. It was a series 70. So you didn't walk into a gun shop
and see all sorts of hotshot 1911s, customized, and $1,500, $2,000, $3,000 competition guns,
and all that kind of thing. It might have existed on some level, but not that I was aware of.
So this is a basic, and to me, it's very appealing. It's very appealing because it is
like what US soldiers carried for so many decades. You don't want to
have to get a second mortgage, perhaps, to get an actual USGI model that was carried by a soldier.
You can get a basic 1911. It can be a Colt. It can be any number of brand names, right?
Springfield Armory, you name it. The Rock Island Armories. All of them are coming out of Turkey,
just anywhere. A lot of them being made, and they aren't very expensive, many of them.
Just a basic 1911 because you're not going to go compete with it. You just would like to have one
to take to the range occasionally and have that same feel that US soldiers felt for a long time,
from around 1911 up through about 1985, 1986. And then some of them carried 1911s,
some units up into what, 2000, 2003, or something like that later.
So just for that experience, what it was like, kind of like the reason you would enjoy a Colt
Single Action Armory or a clone of one, just to shoot it occasionally and know what it was like
to live in 1875 or 1885, and that that would be likely the gun you might be packing.
So that might be the best gun for you, or me. Then the next level I kind of see is right here,
and before I tell you about that, I want to thank Alabama Holster. That's what I got on,
and I'm going to put this one in my Alabama holster. Alabama Holster, they make great little
Kydex concealment holsters, or not necessarily concealment, but outside the waistband,
inside the waistband, pocket, you name it. We love them. And then Rent-A-Gun, where you can
rent one of these fine firearms and try it out. Maybe you're not sure you want a 1911. Maybe you
can rent one and make that decision based on your experience with it for several days. So appreciate
Rent-A-Gun. So yeah, this one is the next level, I would say. It's kind of a basic 1911. It has a
magazine because I'm going to shoot it too, but it has some improvements. Not what I'd call a
hot shot competition gun, but you got an improved beaver tail. This one happens to be a Dan Wesson,
a Guardian, you've seen before probably. I just put some new grips on it. Nice Eagle grips I love.
Great friction, but you got a nice beaver tail. Helps you get your hand up a little higher.
Nice paddle safety there, maybe a little wider than a stock safety. A little bit better sights,
kind of a Novak style. Sights that you can actually see, unlike the very first 1911s.
So a little bit of an upgrade as maybe a carry gun, right? And let's just shoot that one. Feels
a lot better to me. Now I can shoot any of them and they're fine, but when you get to this next
level with that nice beaver tail, it just feels good. Let's come out of the holster and shoot
something. Want to? Uh, I'll say it'll only be two liters. We'll just pop this plate.
And they'll reach out, of course. Yeah, might not do anything, but it'll reach out. Just feels
better and it's at that level where back in the 70s and 80s where people would send these to
or take them to their gunsmith or send them off to some of those old time gunsmiths. Some of them
are not with us any longer and they would do this kind of thing. Put some Novak type sights on it,
a better sight, a high ride or a high rise, what do they call it? High ride, I guess. A beaver tail
like Ed Brown is famous for. And you can get extended mag releases or extended slide releases,
all sorts of things on them, maybe a different finish. So that's kind of the next level. That
might be something that would suit your fancy. And you know, you don't have to spend a lot of
money on these either. It's interesting. We've had a couple of Rock Island armories here that
kind of have that profile. They've got a pretty nice beaver tail and better sights, you know,
and very, very reasonably priced. So I guess it just depends, like I say, on you, right?
You might want both, but this one is not as authentic as you can tell. Now it's shorter,
but that's not what I'm talking about. But you know, you got better sights and all that kind
of thing. You might, again, prefer to have one just like the GIs carried with terrible sights
and nothing fancy, no beaver tail to speak of and all that, you know, regular hammer,
spur and all that. Because again, you want the experience of the U.S. soldiers. It's a piece
of history. And I can understand that a lot. You might want both, but it's kind of like the Colt
Signal Action. I have a real problem with the Colt, what's it called? The New Frontier. I think
they didn't start making those until the 70s, 1970s or 19, yeah, 1970s or 60s. Somewhere along
the line, they started putting adjustable sights on the Colt Signal Action Army. And it kind of
makes me want to gag. Even though they're collectible and they're historical in a sense
too. Don't want it, not at all. Even if I could shoot it better, don't want it. Don't want to
look at it even. Yeah, so it's a little bit the same with these. You know, you might just want
that profile, the configuration that our grandpas carried, or maybe your dad, maybe you,
you know, really. Because again, up until 1985. So that's a level. And then this one is kind of
in the same place, although because it's a Nighthawk, we think of it more as a old
hotshot, almost a competition gun, which it would be. In fact, both of these could be. Because,
you know, in USPSA and different competitions, there's a category for stock, you know,
where it's not compensated. It's, you know, it's maybe even has a round limit and different things
like that. So these could be a competition gun. And they were. A lot of people customized them
for that. Things that were okay, legal, you know, in competition, but yet made them more shootable,
better sights, the beaver tail and everything. So they could be competition, but I kind of just,
they're sort of in between a transition. They're just better 1911s for shooting, right? If you
just want one, you want to shoot a lot and have a lot of fun with it. You don't compete or whatever
you do with it. You know, these are just really desirable because they've got that big beaver
tail, all that kind of thing. Okay. And then you might not be happy with that. What you want
is something like this. There's one reason I wanted to do this since I have this, you know,
borrowed from Davidson's gallery guns is this Kimber 2K11. So this is a, that's not compensated,
but this is kind of a high dollar, a hotshot competition level of firearm. Mint. I say mint
for that. It could be a carry gun too, but it's, it's heavy. It's kind of chunky design. It's a
nine millimeter too. It's a little different, right? Cause it's really considered a shooter.
They've done everything to this thing to make it a sweet shooter with little concern for tradition,
necessarily. They, you know, to look like this or function just like these, not, not that
important. It's got a different guide rod set up and you know, it's got ambi safeties and all the
things we talked about in the main video, optic or fiber optic sites. And you put a optic on it
back here. You know, it's set up for all the flat face trigger, nine millimeter holds a lot of
rounds, nice big fat grip got a rail, but but it's kind of considered a competition level firearm
for sure. So those are the three I'm going to shoot that if you'll let me, but those are kind
of the three categories I think about now I can say four, that's a different category too. But in,
and you might be considering that, you know, if you don't have a 1911 maybe that's your first
choice and you're saving up to, to get, you know, an actual 1911 that was parried and was issued.
Then that's definitely a worthy endeavor to pursue something like that. But other than that,
I kind of group them in about three and there's probably 14 other categories, you know, like
everything else, but anyway, it came by mind. So I thought I'd share it with you, right?
So let's shoot this one. This one's we've been shooting. It's dirty. Let's get it dirtier. Let's
put something on this target though. Make sure it's still accurate and it is,
I should be able to hit the gong if I remember where to hold.
Like that's where I need to hold. Being too fast, not holding my sight picture.
Let's pop that cowboy around the two liter.
This thing, I was going to pop them out fast, but we did that. We've done it before. This thing,
you can shoot, oh man, no recoil, great big grip, and you could literally empty that magazine in
about, I don't know, two, three seconds, almost anybody. So really a great competition firearm.
And of course there's different levels of this one, even for competition.
You know, you have these hotshot pistols like this that are also compensated for
different classes, open class. I don't know if this would qualify for standard,
if you'd have to shoot this thing in open class or not. It's been so long since I did the USPSA
thing. I think this one would probably qualify for maybe production class, whatever, just,
or limited, whatever. But it's a hotshot competition gun. That's the point. And it's
expensive. It's not cheap. Now in terms of hotshot competition guns, I'm not saying
Kimber's more expensive than all the others or anything. Just any of them in this category
are pretty expensive. Because they've taken the 1911 concept and they've taken it to new heights
to make it really shootable, really reliable, fun to shoot, different chamberings and all that.
Okay. Nine millimeter, maybe your favorite chambering. Maybe that's why you'd rather have
a pistol like this one. So anyway, for what it's worth, what's the best 1911? Of course,
the best one for you is what I'm talking about. Those are kind of your categories that I think
about. I mean, if I got all my 1911s out, I think they'd kind of fit into one of these four
categories. So there's probably other categories. Nothing is perfect. But that's the way I think
about it. And if I think about it that way, that means you should think about it that way. Anyway,
let me know if you don't have a 1911. And if you don't have one, maybe you need to write in your
comment, explain what it is in your life that took you down the wrong road that prevented you
from having a 1911. If you're 16, I'm not talking about that. But if you're over 30, and you don't
and you're a gun person, you enjoy shooting, and you don't have a 1911. I kind of think you need
to explain yourself. You owe us all an apology and an explanation. So get at that. Life is good.
Oh yeah, that's better. This is a great gun for defense. Oh hey, didn't see you guys there. While
I've got you here, I want to remind you of our friends over at Talon Grips and Ballistol.
Talon Grips makes grips. Can you believe it? For all different types of firearms,
you can get rough texture or more of a rubberized texture. Just sticks right on there.
Really affordable, really cool option to improve the grip for your handguns or rifles. So please
check them out at talongungrips.com. You'll be glad you did. And also Ballistol. Dad has been
using Ballistol for many years. It's a cleaner and a lubricant, and it's non-toxic. It works
really great, and we're happy to have them on board since it's been a part of our shooting
endeavor for a very long time. So go to ballistol.com, talongungrips.com. And also,
while you're out there, I'm juggling all these things here. Also, while you're on the internet,
please do check out our other social media like Hickok45 on Facebook. There's also Hickok45
on Twitter, TheRealHickok45 on Instagram. There's a John underscore Hickok45 on Instagram
where I do some things. So check out all that stuff, and then watch more videos.
