Fishing On A Secretive Military Island ¦ River Monsters.

Nature Pulse 🏞️
4 followers
1 Video View·Aug 13, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThe narrator explores the waters around a remote, military-controlled island in the mid-Atlantic to identify a \"silvery predator\" described by survivors of the 1942 sinking of the *Laconia*. Through shore fishing, trolling, and scent-baiting, he examines local marine life to determine which species could have attacked people in the open ocean.
No one lives here permanently.
The vast majority of the 800 or so personnel are on military contracts.
What they do is not public knowledge.
And some areas of the island are strictly off limits.
But it's the vast expanse of water around this speck of land
that interests me.
Very few people get to fish here, either recreationally
or commercially, which means that the species that are here now
are going to be the same ones that were here in 1942.
I now want to see what's in the water around the island.
I'm heading to a remote spot which isn't often fished.
Beneath the surface here, the land shelves off very quickly.
So even with a cast from the shore, I should be on the edge of deep water.
Lovely looking clear water.
There are a few beaches here and there on the island,
but mostly it's rock and fairly treacherous underfoot.
But I just thought while I was trying to get a boat sorted out,
I'd come along and get some lures in the water.
See, start to get a feel for what's living around here.
That's something on. That's a fish on already.
First cast. That's a good sign.
All right, just going to swing it.
It's a grouper. Very impressive size mouth.
Even on a fish this size.
So there's certainly predators in these waters.
I waste no time getting my lure back into the water,
and it's not long before something else hits it.
Oh, I can see something out there.
It's been followed by several fish.
Lovely fish. A blackjack.
That is definitely a predatory fish.
Some sharp teeth.
The way it hammered that lure on the surface.
The thing about the lure I'm using at the moment is that it makes a lot of
disturbance. It's visual.
It's also sound as well.
And fish, they're all opportunists, particularly predators.
They come in and have a look.
And even when this one was on the line, there's other fish chasing this.
It's just a very good
beginning to my education about this particular part of the ocean.
Right, this is an oceanic trigger fish,
so-called because of that that spine on the back,
a bit like a trigger on a gun.
And what they do is they they jam that in the open position like that.
To hold themselves in coral.
They often go to sleep like that at night.
And look at the teeth on that.
Those are sort of coral munching teeth.
But it actually went for a lure.
The thing that's quickly becoming apparent to me is
how rich these waters are.
Also, how competitive the fish are.
You get one fish on the end of the line or one fish showing interest.
And it's it sort of calls in the other fish.
And I think in terms of
my investigation,
I think this could be pretty significant.
The seas here are teeming.
There's little doubt about that, even from just a few hours fishing.
But I don't think that the fish that hit my lures today
would have been present or of any significance that night
when the Laconia sank.
But they do give me a vital behavioral clue.
A struggling fish on the line attracts the interest of other predators.
What I saw here today was how quickly that happens.
Undoubtedly, the Laconia sinking was an event in the ocean,
not just for the people involved, but also for the animals that live there.
There would have been no shortage of distress signals in the water that night
with over a thousand people floundering at the surface.
The question is, would those signals have been enough
to start a feeding frenzy in the open ocean?
The accounts of eyewitnesses suggest that they would have been.
One thing I'm coming across again and again is that a lot of the people
in the water that night speak of being attacked by
schools of large, aggressive silvery fish.
Take this from Ian Peel, who was one of the many people
who was in the water who hadn't been able to get a place in a lifeboat.
Immediately, I heard cries of shark.
But it wasn't shark I saw, but huge numbers of large silvery fish
slicing and attacking at will.
Even more formidable than a shark.
The obvious culprit is the Barracuda, a fish I've encountered before.
But I can eliminate them from the suspect list because ferocious as they are,
they tend to school and hunt around coastal reefs, not in deep open ocean.
So what exactly was Ian Peel describing?
The mid-Atlantic is new territory for me, and I'm working with limited information.
But somewhere out there, there's the silvery predator
that was first on the Laconia scene, and I've got to work out a way to find it.
The best way to cover a large search area is to use a technique called trolling.
Whenever you're fishing,
the biggest question is, where are you going to put your bait?
And in this immensity of water, that's a very big question.
But with the island here, there's a plateau where it gradually gets deeper,
out to a couple of hundred feet.
And then in a very short space, it plunges down to a couple of thousand
and then keeps on going.
And what we're going to do is going to fish on the move
and just go along the drop off with lures out the back.
The survivor's accounts describe the fish that drew first blood
as being medium sized and fast.
So that's what I'm going for.
On the big rod, we're going to put this.
This is you can see that mimics a fish in the water.
This is quite significant because what happens, the water catches
that as we're moving and it pushes it down.
It makes it dive and it gets a good wiggle on.
Serious hooks on here.
Thick wire, because quite likely if anything hits this,
it's going to have teeth.
In fact, you can see it's been hit a few times by some toothy creatures.
So off we go.
We work our way along the drop off
to increase my chances of a take in the vast mid-Atlantic.
I have two different lures working at the surface and two deeper down.
The lures have definitely got the attention of the birds,
so they got to look fairly convincing.
The fact is, it's something happening on the surface here,
which just gets triggers the attention.
And we're hoping the same will happen beneath the surface as well.
Getting fish to come up and investigate.
As first on the Laconia scene, my silvery suspect was clearly curious and quick.
One of the reels is emptying.
Something has taken the lure.
Screaming take.
Is that off or is it just coming towards me?
Yeah, that was hooked up for 20 seconds or so, but it came off.
Sometimes happens.
It's interesting.
You're just covering water, covering water.
Nothing's happening. Nothing's happening.
And then just out of nowhere, suddenly the reel is screaming.
But in this case, just as quickly, it's gone.
Dolphins beside the boat.
This is a really good sign.
The rod tip's really banging away there.
And that's indicative of the lure down there really pushing out some vibrations.
It's like the dinner gone going off.
And I've got a good feeling about that.
Out here in the middle of the ocean,
there's no significant landmass to stop the huge Atlantic swells.
Then another take on the same rod.
This time, I'm hoping it will stay hooked.
This is steaming away, steaming away.
I haven't seen it yet at all.
It's quite a rapid kick.
Whatever it is, I think I've got a bit of color.
I can see something down there.
Oh, there it is, there it is.
Yeah, there we go.
I've landed a silvery fish and an energetic one.
But is this the fish that drew first blood?
Skipjack, it's almost like a bit of metal, isn't it?
Amazing the energy it's got.
It's actually very mirror-like and actually in open water.
That's very effective camouflage.
If you're about the same kind of depth as that,
it's just going to bounce the light off
and it's almost going to disappear into the background.
But then if you're looking down on it, it's dark.
So it's perfect countershading.
I don't think this skipjack is the silvery predator
that the eyewitnesses talk about.
These fish just don't have the hardware to inflict the sort of wounds described.
I'm going to try a different approach by using to my advantage
the strong currents that swirl around the island.
Maybe it was scent rather than sight that brought in the predators that night.
There's a whole sardine on the end here and the boat is drifting.
So we're just going to slowly drift.
We'll keep some chum going in the water
just to bring the small stuff in and get some activity going
and hopefully bring in the bigger predators.
Oils from these pieces of fish leave scent trails in the water
and the predators here quickly find my bait.
Something fast almost empties my reel.
Fish right next to the boat.
Look at that thing go. Leaping in the air.
The fish is desperately trying to throw the hook.
Then my line goes slack.
Oh, it's still there, it's just running towards me.
And he's out about these waters being rich.
A bit of a confirmation there.
This is a good sized Dorado on.
This clearly isn't a silvery assailant,
but it is a powerful predator in its own right and worth a closer look.
Beautiful fish. Look at that.
Dorado means gold, but look at all the blue on there.
Also known as Mahi Mahi dolphin fish.
Those acrobatic leaps are totally in character
for a hunter that takes out flying fish.
It's still got a lot of strength, actually, I can feel it flexing.
But despite their obvious strength and agility,
Dorados have never been known to pose a threat to humans.
Off he goes. Oh, strong fish.
