Understanding Science’s Great Mysteries | BBC Earth Science

Truth exists
11 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis video examines pivotal discoveries in space science, ranging from the Moon's formation and solar weather monitoring to the accelerating expansion of the universe. It explores the search for antimatter via the AMS, the chemical origins of life on Mars, and the use of forensic science to identify extraterrestrial materials in ancient artifacts.
Discovering exactly how the moon formed is key to finding out why it has two such distinct sides.
And as a young astronomer, Bill and his colleagues thought the answer could lie
in what they saw on the moon's surface.
We discovered this big impact basin on one side of the moon,
which really seemed to solidify the idea that these crater-like features are not volcanic,
these are formed by big impacts.
So you have lots of interplanetary debris hitting the moon all the time.
These impacts gave Bill the idea that the history of the moon is tied to that of our own planet.
He suggested that as the earth was forming,
another smaller planet might have formed in a similar orbit around the sun.
As the planet circled our star,
their paths inevitably crossed with catastrophic consequences.
The resulting collision caused an enormous explosion,
throwing up a vast cloud of gas and dust around our planet.
This superheated debris then combined,
forming a new molten body,
one that slowly cooled to form our moon.
In the early 1980s, a conference was proposed
to see if scientists could agree on a story for the moon's origins.
It was decided, let's have that conference in Hawaii.
Sure enough, everybody wanted to come to the conference all of a sudden.
Everybody's wearing their Hawaiian flower.
It's amazing how many people were wearing beards in those days.
Having worked out the details with his colleague Don Davis,
it was time for Bill's theory to face some tough scrutiny.
That meeting has been sometimes described as one of the most
significant meetings in planetary science.
We went through lots of different theories,
and the giant impact theory was the one that got the A+.
The giant impact hypothesis still reigns supreme
as the go-to theory of how our moon was formed.
It seems to fit so many criteria of what we know about the solar system
that I think it's still a major part of planetary science.
Bill and Don's theory explains a lot about our unusual moon.
The sheer amount of debris thrown up by such a vast collision
would lead to its unusual size.
But the theory offers no explanation
why the radioactive elements found in the Apollo samples
are more common on the near side today.
And it doesn't explain the far side's much thicker crust.
Or even the surprising differences in appearance
revealed by the Lunar 3 probe.
Today, in the race to explain the mystery,
three competing theories stand out.
All three begin with the giant impact hypothesis.
But it's what happened next to cause the moon's two-sided nature
where they all disagree.
Like Jess Barnes, geologist Katie Joy
is fascinated by the far side mystery.
Because people hadn't seen the far side of the moon,
we just made the assumption that the far side was the same as the near side.
So Lunar 3 turned our ideas on its head,
and those ideas are still being turned on their head.
Katie is one of NASA's lead investigators.
Studying the precious Apollo samples
to better understand the moon's mysterious past.
Because the moon's surface is very old,
it can tell us a lot about history of the solar system's past.
It can tell us about Mars, Mercury, Venus and the Earth.
Every time there's new technology,
we can ask these rocks new questions.
And that's why they're sort of the gift that keeps on giving
because they're always going to be available
for us to look at with new ideas.
The Apollo samples continue to teach us about the moon,
the Earth and the rest of the solar system.
But when it comes to solving the far side mystery,
there's a problem.
With the lunar missions that have been to the surface and collected samples,
we've only visited a very geologically restricted area
on the near side of the moon.
So in order to fully understand the moon and the far side composition,
we really need to go back and collect samples
from a more diverse region.
And with NASA's Artemis mission,
aiming to return humans to the lunar surface in the coming years,
Jess is preparing for a new batch of evidence.
We want to preserve that DNA, fingerprints, rocks
as precisely as possible so that we don't lose any of that evidence.
So before we go back to the moon,
we really need to understand
what's the best way to curate and keep samples safe
and preserve them for future generations.
To get ready for these upcoming missions,
NASA is releasing some crucial, untouched evidence from its vaults.
After Apollo 17, people soon realized that
it would be beneficial to future generations
to lock some of the Apollo samples away in special storage for 50 years.
And now we're at the point in time when NASA has decided
things have improved so much that we're now in a position
to open those samples, use new technologies on them
to answer past and new questions.
Now, armed with techniques impossible 50 years ago,
Jess is one of the handful of people
chosen by NASA to analyse these precious samples.
One of the things that we've been doing
is using a particle accelerator
to measure the oxidation state of sulphur in our samples.
We're really looking at these samples forensically
and this is a really new technique
that's been applied to lunar samples only in the last few years.
Yeah, bring it up a little bit and we can just slow scan.
This tool allows Jess to piece together the sample's history
and establish how new evidence might be better preserved in the future.
We find that samples that were prepared 50 years ago
contain a lot more sulphur than we see in samples
that were actually stored frozen for 50 years.
We're not quite sure why that is,
but this is one of the things that we want to find out.
Do we need to do something differently
for samples coming back from the Moon in the future?
It's a problem that must be addressed
before we return for more evidence.
Something Jess knows is critical
if we're ever to finally solve the mystery of the Moon's far side.
Tucked away on the outskirts of Washington DC,
an anonymous building is home to a small team of solar weather watchers.
We can be hit by the next solar storm any time soon
because they happen fairly frequently.
Yari Collado-Vega is a director at NASA's Space Weather Analysis Office.
Good morning, everybody. Is there any activity today?
Everything looks quiet so far today.
Her team's job is to keep satellites and astronauts
safe from the ever-present threat of space weather.
Space weather is the activity in space that is mostly dominated by the Sun.
We have the solar wind, which is the expansion of the solar corona,
and it's always there.
The solar wind is a stream of electrically charged particles
that flood from the Sun and continually bathe the Earth.
We see its effect through the glowing gas it creates
at the top of our atmosphere, the aurora.
This solar wind is a constant presence,
but sometimes activity on the Sun's surface increases dramatically.
The Sun can also have big, strong solar storms that come in different types.
We have the solar flare, which are big, bright eruptions of radiation,
and we also have coronal mass ejections,
which are big explosions of particles that travel through space.
Coronal mass ejections, or CMEs,
are enormous bubbles of electrically charged particles
that explode from the Sun's surface at millions of miles per hour.
And not only can they destroy infrastructure here on Earth,
they can fry the electronic circuits of satellites in a flash,
and are even a potential threat to humans.
Coronal mass ejections can actually cause damages
to the instrumentation of the satellites that we have in space,
which is the satellites that we use for technology every day on Earth.
You know, communication problems, GPS signal loss,
and in the scenario of astronauts,
it could cause a radiation-hazardous environment for them.
We send astronauts to the Moon, and then in the future years to Mars,
they're not going to be protected.
We have to make sure that we send those astronauts to space safely.
So we need to make sure that we can predict those events.
Yari and her team keep a constant eye out for solar superstorms,
and when they spot them, assess their severity.
Our job is to do the predictions when you have a coronal mass ejection.
And when we do that, we actually can see how the CME explodes
and how it actually travels through space.
And then we inject the CME into a simulation, which is what we have here.
You can see here the Sun, the Earth,
and you can see the planets and the missions across the solar system.
And this is like looking at the Sun from the top.
And you can see here a very small CME being ejected.
And we use the images here so we can actually predict
where they're going and when they're going to hit.
Sabani Basu heads up a team working on a revolutionary technique
to detect sunspots.
Well before they're seen from Earth.
Unlike the Moon, which shows us just one of its faces, the Sun rotates.
So if there's a strong sunspot on the far side of the Sun,
it could be a problem because in a week or two it would face us
and there's a potential for a big solar storm.
It takes about 27 days for the Sun to rotate once.
So if a potentially dangerous sunspot appeared on the far side,
scientists wouldn't know.
But Sabani overcomes this by listening for them.
You see the ripples that are produced when I threw the rock into the water.
These are waves and some of the waves are going fairly far,
but a lot of the energy is going inside, deep inside.
That's what happens on Earth when there's an earthquake.
An earthquake happens say here, the energy as sound waves go deep inside
and they can be detected at different places on Earth.
Now exactly the same thing happens in the Sun.
The Sun quakes all the time.
The outer layers of the plasma on the Sun, they are a boiling, churning mass.
They keep the Sun shaking, ringing like a bell.
These sound waves travel throughout the entire structure of the Sun
and remarkably they can be detected by Earth-based observatories.
So assume this is the cutout of the Sun.
So we're seeing inside the Sun and that's the centre.
So the waves, just like the waves caused by earthquakes on Earth,
they sort of travel around.
Now let us assume the Earth is somewhere here
and we are looking at the Sun in this direction.
So if there's a sunspot here,
there is absolutely no way we would know looking from here that there's a sunspot there.
Now the sunspots have strong magnetic fields which changes the speed of these waves.
So if you have waves that go through the sunspot,
they become faster than waves that do not go through sunspots.
Which means they arrive at this point where we're observing them at slightly different times.
And the time difference between them actually allows us to detect
that there's a strong sunspot on the far side.
Using the technique, Sabani can accurately detect
where sunspots are hidden on the far side of the Sun.
And she can also predict how many and how big they are.
But most importantly, how long until they have Earth in their sights?
Since the Sun rotates, the sunspot will be visible to us maybe in a week or two.
And since strong sunspots can cause strong solar storms,
this allows us to prepare for the event.
If for the eventuality that there's going to be a big storm, we get a warning.
This is a groundbreaking technique.
It means researchers can do what was previously thought impossible.
Predicting the arrival of a sunspot weeks before it faces Earth.
Adam was part of a team researching exploding stars called supernova.
Some of the brightest objects in the sky.
Our team had been experts in looking and studying nearby supernovae
to measure essentially how fast the universe was expanding now.
And so we wanted to be able to look out and see how fast it was expanding in the past.
To look back into the past, Adam and his team
searched for supernovae in the far reaches of the universe.
And what they found there was barely believable.
Edwin Hubble had thought that the expansion was actually slowing down,
like dust settling after an explosion.
And for almost a century, everyone else had thought he'd been right.
Decades of work really going all the way back to Hubble
had shown that the universe was expanding,
that the gravity of all the matter in the universe
would tend to slow or pull back on the expansion after the Big Bang.
But Adam's research told a different story.
I was analyzing the first large tranche of data
and looking at the supernovae to tell us how much the expansion was slowing down.
And when I began looking at the results, they were really shocking.
It wasn't slowing down a lot and it wasn't slowing down a little.
It was actually speeding up.
It was as though the universe was currently accelerating,
which was not on the menu of options at the time.
When what you find is the opposite of what you expect, it's pretty shocking.
I mean, mathematically, it's just a change in sign,
but in terms of physics, it changes everything.
Adam believed that the expansion of the universe was, perplexingly, speeding up.
And this was the discovery he'd emailed colleagues just days before getting married.
By the day after, they'd responded.
Adam showed me fantastic plots before he left for his wedding.
Who knows? This might be the right answer.
I'm worried.
We all know that it is far too early to be reaching firm conclusions.
Seriously, you probably never will have another scientific result
more exciting come your way in your lifetime.
So there was a great deal of energy, excitement and fear
because, you know, nobody wants to get something wrong.
But Adam wasn't wrong.
The expansion of the universe isn't slowing down, as Edwin Hubble thought.
It is accelerating.
It's getting faster.
This was an astounding discovery.
And knowing how fast it was expanding
meant Adam thought he could calculate when it all began.
So with new measurements, we found the universe that was about 13,
plus or minus, maybe 0.3 billion years old.
Scotland's Astronomer Royal Catherine Haymans
believes observations of the universe don't agree on its age
because the mathematical models aren't quite right.
She suspects our understanding of the dark universe may be an illusion.
Our best information about the universe tells us
what the universe looked like right after the Big Bang.
And from that data, we can come up with a model
of what the universe should look like today.
But what we're finding is that the universe that we observe
isn't quite what we expected,
and we can't fully explain the universe that we're observing today.
It means that we can't trust it when it tells us how old our universe is.
It just doesn't add up.
Catherine thinks that although researchers have calculated
how much of the dark universe is out there,
they've little real idea of its impact.
We know that the stuff we're made up of, the Earth, the Moon, the Sun,
everything we can see in the universe,
that accounts for less than 5% of it.
The rest is dark.
Two components, dark matter and dark energy.
Dark matter, that's the kind of the big gravitational stuff
that keeps everything bound in our universe together.
And then, ha, it's evil twin, dark energy,
which appears to be causing the expansion of our universe to accelerate.
Those are our three main ingredients, and we only understand 5% of it.
So, you could picture this as an epic fail for science.
We don't understand 95% of our universe,
but I like to think of this as a big challenge,
because if we can understand that,
then hopefully that will really revolutionise
our understanding of everything around us.
To try and work out just how dark matter impacts the universe,
Catherine investigates how it has evolved over time, since the Big Bang.
So, this is a map of dark matter spanning across the sky.
Where you can see bright spots,
that's where there's lots and lots of dark matter.
And as the colour gets darker, that's where there's emptier voids,
where there's much less dark matter in our universe.
And what we're finding is not what we were expecting.
We can see clumps, we can see voids,
we can see that cosmic web-like structure,
but it's not exactly what we expected.
It's a lot smoother than predicted for what we should see today.
That's a bit of a problem,
because it takes time for these dark matter structures to form.
Catherine has spent decades fine-tuning and finessing her dark matter map.
So, for about the last 20 years,
I've been working to map out the invisible dark matter in our universe.
This is our map of the north.
We've got another map of the south.
And whilst this is one of the largest dark matter maps
that we've ever been able to make,
it's still quite a small patch of the sky.
So, we might have been unlucky.
This might have been just a weird patch of the universe that we've looked at,
but it's not exactly what we expected.
And the fact that this is a lot smoother
suggests that the universe is slightly younger than we first thought.
As yet, Catherine is unsure just how much younger.
But her work continues.
The bulge is where we keep some of our most precious samples.
Meteorites have a particular scientific story to tell.
I love all the meteorites,
but I guess my super favourites are ones that formed
right at the beginning of the solar system
that can really tell us how the planets formed,
because I think these are the most scientifically useful.
There are two main types of meteorite that land on Earth,
and they're made of different materials.
Most of them come from asteroids,
although some come from the Moon, some come from Mars.
But we have all asteroidal ones here.
And among the asteroid ones, most of them are made of rock.
They've got rounded blobs in them called chondrules.
They formed right at the beginning of our solar system.
And a few meteorites are made mostly of iron.
So, this is an example of an iron meteorite that's really super heavy.
Too heavy to pick up.
Around one in 20 are made mostly of iron.
So, they're among a rare type.
But where have these meteorites journeyed from?
Most meteorites are debris,
leftovers from the birth of the solar system,
four and a half billion years ago.
And most of them orbit the Sun between Jupiter and Mars
in the asteroid belt.
Things in the asteroid belt can be quite chaotic.
Often they crash into each other
or they can be affected by the gravity of Jupiter,
which is the biggest planet in our solar system.
And these things can make them career into the inner solar system
and possibly crash down on Earth.
One February day in 2013,
the sky above the Russian city of Chelyabinsk lit up.
Thousands of people saw this massive fireball,
which exploded in the sky.
Over a thousand people were injured,
mostly by the shockwave of the blast when the bolide exploded.
This was actually the biggest impact that we know of on Earth
in the last hundred years.
It was a really, really unusual event
and it resulted in about a ton of material
ending up on the surface of the Earth.
Italian physicist Daniela Comelli
is a world leader in analysing the metals of ancient objects.
She's been working on a new method
that could confirm whether the iron of the dagger
came from a meteorite or from Earth,
without harming it in any way.
With the development of portable X-ray fluorescence spectrometer,
there was this huge technological advance.
The device now are very small and very lightweight
so that they can be easily transported on site
to analyse different types of artworks and findings.
This technology was a breakthrough in investigating ancient objects
and was about to be turned onto Tutankhamun's dagger.
It uses X-rays to excite the atoms that make up an object.
The atoms then emit radiation that allows researchers
to confirm exactly which chemical element is present
and the different proportions of each.
There is a difference between terrestrial
and extraterrestrial iron in terms of chemical composition
because they are obviously both made of iron
but in extraterrestrial iron
there is a higher amount of nickel and cobalt.
This is a clear clue that the piece of iron is meteoritic iron.
Daniela travelled to the Cairo Museum in Egypt
with her X-ray spectroscope
and teamed up with Abdel Razek
as part of a joint Egyptian-Italian group.
We were really keen to unlock the mystery of this blade
and we were not really sure about if the blade will be made of meteorite or not
because we don't have any kind of accurate investigation conducted before.
It was really exciting to analyse such an ancient
and precious archaeological finding.
Really, really fascinating.
Using the state-of-the-art X-ray fluorescence
with high energy resolution detector
we started to collect the data.
If the iron blade contained less than 5% nickel
it would mean it was from Earth
and the Iron Age began centuries earlier than historians assumed.
More than 5% nickel and if the element cobalt was also found
then the dagger had to be from outer space.
Either result would be astonishing.
My heart, personally, I was really willing to find the meteorite's origin
but as a researcher I have to follow the scientific criteria.
The beam of the X-ray spectroscope was aimed at the dagger.
Almost immediately we realised that beside iron there was some nickel
but also that there were traces of cobalt.
So it was very exciting.
But there was still more analysis to be done.
Everyone was watching.
We have some diplomatic people with us.
Even the audience visiting the museum were around us.
The analysis revealed the blade had over 10% nickel.
Way more than the 5% cut-off point.
Trace amounts of cobalt confirmed what everyone suspected.
Tutankhamun's dagger had come from outer space.
In 1996, scientists announced they'd found evidence of possible Martian life.
But Mars is a frozen desert planet.
Its surface is completely uninhabitable.
So could these strange shapes really be ancient alien fossils?
And liftoff!
And why do scientists think they might be able to find more of them?
I've always loved space.
There's all kinds of things moving around and we have no idea what's out there.
Planetary scientist Nina Lanza knows it can be difficult to interpret images from space.
This is Percival Lowell who was an astronomer in the 1880s who was obsessed with Mars.
He made many observations of the surface of Mars using telescopes on the ground on Earth.
Lowell's maps of Mars led to an idea that has enthralled us ever since.
What he thought he saw were these canal features.
He thought he could see signs of a civilization on the surface of Mars.
And these ideas had a huge impact not just on science fiction but also actual science.
So in 1964, when NASA's pioneering Mariner 4 probe reached the red planet,
the public eagerly awaited their first look at the alien world.
Mariner 4 was the very first time we had close-up images of Mars from a spacecraft.
People, when they first saw them, were incredibly disappointed
because they looked nothing like the Mars of our imagination.
There were no alien civilizations.
There was no water.
There were just a bunch of craters and it really looked like the moon.
But just seven years later, Mariner 9 made scientists think again.
Its more powerful camera revealed something remarkable etched on the Martian surface.
This is an image from Mariner 9 and it's a really important image because it was the first time
scientists saw evidence that there might be something more on the surface than just craters.
This is a very sinuous channel that looks like it was carved by flowing water.
Each mission that followed has unearthed more evidence
that Mars was not always a dry, frozen planet.
The Viking orbiter sent back some incredibly beautiful images.
Things like these flowing channels and teardrop islands,
both of which suggest that water was once abundant on the surface
and flowing and making these features.
Mars Global Surveyor sent back this one
which shows a feature that looks like a beautiful river delta.
The twin rovers Spirit and Opportunity found dramatic evidence.
These are hematite spheres and they form in water.
This is a vein of a mineral called gypsum.
So gypsum is a mineral that not only forms in water,
but actually contains water in its structure.
It's now known that in the first one or two billion years of its life,
Mars was much more like Earth.
It had a thick atmosphere and was covered in rivers, lakes and seas.
There is overwhelming evidence just looking at the surface
that there was a lot of liquid water on Mars's surface in the past.
However, this discovery, while extraordinary,
did not prove Mars also had life.
Life needs water, but that's only one thing that it needs.
It also needs certain chemical ingredients
and also environmental conditions before it can actually develop and thrive.
So this is sodium cyanide, highly toxic,
but we use this material for our research, origin of life.
Cyanide is deadly.
As little as a tenth of a gram can be fatal.
John's colleague, Jianfeng Xu, has been working with it for over a decade.
Just keep gloves on, don't eat it.
That's for sure.
Mixing the cyanide isn't enough.
It then has to be exposed to the conditions of early Earth.
I'm going to put this in the solar simulator.
This machine just simulates the early Earth's conditions.
Levels of UV light were much higher back then.
UV light is the energy to drive the reaction.
And it's free energy from the sun.
And we're going to use it.
Inside the machine, the cyanide combines and recombines,
creating the building blocks of life.
After a few hours, we can detect amino acid,
nucleoside precursor, lipid precursor.
They're all very important biomolecules in life.
Cyanide may be the raw material needed to kickstart life.
So finding an abundant supply is vital for John and Jianfeng's theory.
And one type of location is more promising than any other.
Impact craters.
As a meteorite strikes, its energy superheats the atmosphere,
generating huge amounts of cyanide.
And it also melts the planet's crust, creating hydrothermal systems.
The meteorite impact is really important for life to start.
John and Jianfeng's idea is that rainwater flowed down the crater walls,
absorbing cyanide, and then was heated in hydrothermal pools at the bottom.
And reaction taking place then.
So simple.
To prove their theory, John and Jianfeng need evidence.
Chemical traces from one of these craters.
On Earth, it's simply not possible to find evidence of these environments
because all of the impact craters of that period have been erased by plate tectonics.
Scientists still don't understand how life began on Earth.
But they do have three theories about how and where it might have happened.
Hydrothermal vents with chemical energy for early life.
Volcanic pools could have assembled cells.
And impact craters could have provided the raw material for life.
But here on Earth, essential clues to solve the mystery have long been erased.
To find them, scientists need to return to Mars.
30 years ago, Sam's expertise was in fundamental particles found on Earth.
I have a group who collaborate with me.
None of us has done a thing about space.
We start with a totally clear head.
Zero.
We didn't know anything.
The novice group's bold idea was to build a detector
equipped with a highly specialized magnet
designed to discover antimatter in space.
I was quite worried how we're going to do this.
Nobody has ever put a magnet in space.
Known as Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer, or AMS,
it was built over 15 years by hundreds of scientists from 16 different countries.
Took us an enormous amount of effort.
Endeavour will deliver the Alpha Magnetic Spectrometer,
a particle physics detector designed to search for various types of unusual matter
by measuring cosmic rays.
In May 2011, the $2 billion, 7.5-ton antimatter detector was ready to launch.
Now we bring back all the memories.
The detector was loaded aboard the Endeavour space shuttle.
Its destination, the International Space Station.
I was quite nervous.
So many people spent so much time
who had done something nobody thought was possible.
OK, Mark, looks like a great day to launch Endeavour.
Good luck, Godspeed, and we'll see you back here June 1st.
Zero and liftoff for the final launch of Endeavour.
Expanding our knowledge, expanding our lives in space.
250 miles above Earth, in a feat of precision engineering,
the detector was attached to the space station.
Within a short time, you can see signals coming down,
and we know everything's working.
I was relieved.
Since that moment, the detector has been hunting for antimatter in space.
This is a space station.
It goes every 93 minutes around the Earth once.
As the antimatter detector orbits the Earth,
billions of cosmic rays pass through it.
The red line is the cosmic rays.
Since May 19, 2011.
So it's 191 billion.
So day and night, you have to collect them.
There's no such a thing as Christmas,
no such a thing as Halloween.
The cosmic rays' path through the magnetic detector
determines their charge,
and therefore whether or not they are antimatter.
Searching for traces of antimatter in the enormity of the cosmos
is unimaginably difficult.
But a little over seven years into the experiment,
an intriguing signal was picked up.
An anti-atom.
We found one, very clean, anti-helium.
The mass is exactly like helium,
except the charge is just the opposite.
Discovering anti-helium amongst billions of other particles
could have been an error.
And then, after a few months, a second one occurred.
There's no other signals nearby.
Looks perfect.
Finding an anti-atom in space is baffling.
It cannot be produced from ordinary cosmic calculations.
It has to be from something unexpected.
More evidence is needed.
But finding anti-helium in space suggests a startling possibility.
There could be other complex antimatter structures in our universe.
There could even be antimatter stars waiting to be discovered.
And if they are out there,
there should also be other types of anti-atoms.
Anti-carbon, anti-oxygen.
And then we will have more confidence.
Indeed, there's something totally different out there.
