Steven Spielberg's latest film returns to one of his favorite subject matters, aliens. Does this original summer movie have the signature Spielberg magic?
Become a channel member to get access to custom badges, emoji, and early access on videos! / @danmurrellmovies
Dan Merl reviews Steven Spielberg's new UFO film, *Disclosure Day*. The movie explores the chaotic potential of revealing alien existence to the public. While the reviewer finds the screenplay somewhat average with some plot contrivances, he praises the strong acting, striking visuals, and the legendary collaboration between Spielberg and composer John Williams.
Steven Spielberg's UFO film Disclosure Day hits theaters this weekend, so let's see them aliens.
Hello everybody, I'm Dan Merl here with my review of Disclosure Day. The review embargo was just
lifted and I have a chance to share my thoughts on the movie. This is Spielberg's first film since
The Fablemans back in 2022. He also wrote the story for the film with the screenplay
coming from David Koepp. It's Koepp's fifth time writing a Steven Spielberg film and his first
since Indiana Jones and the Kingdom of the Crystal Skull. The plot for Disclosure Day has been a
guarded secret almost as much as the secret of alien existence itself, so I'm going to give you
a very basic overview of the film. This is all stuff from trailers or that you find out in the
first 10 or 15 minutes of the movie. Disclosure Day finds the world on the brink of war, but behind
that a secret government agency is fighting to keep proof of alien existence from the public.
Josh O'Connor plays Daniel Kellner, a computer genius in possession of said proof. Emily Blunt
plays Margaret Fairchild, an airy local weather reporter who suddenly develops fantastic abilities.
Side note, Margaret works at a local Kansas City news station, which coincidentally was where I
saw my critic screening of this film. The audience that I was in was probably the only one in the
world that's going to clap at the on-screen location identifiers in Disclosure Day. Colin
Firth plays the head of the secret government agency, Wardex, who is using every tool in his
arsenal to keep the public from finding out the truth about aliens. And Colman Domingo plays Hugo
Wakefield, the head of the Truth Movement, who's directing his sleeper agents from the shadows
while preparing the endgame. All of this intrigue will result, if the truthers have their way,
in Disclosure Day, the day that humanity is presented with absolute proof that we are not
alone in the universe. This is the fourth time that Steven Spielberg has dealt directly with
aliens after Close Encounters, E.T. the Extraterrestrial, and War of the Worlds,
and it's a subject matter that he's obviously very fascinated with. This is not necessarily
a big picture story, a rumination on the existence of aliens, but a moment by moment journey through
the potential revelation of the existence of aliens. However, inside of that journey,
we do get discussions about the ramifications of alien existence on things like government
and religion, and whether humanity can even handle such a disclosure. You can tell that
these are questions that Spielberg himself has pondered over the years, and this feels like an
extension of the first feature that he ever wrote, Close Encounters of the Third Kind, back in 1977.
If that movie was about the wonder of discovering aliens exist,
this one is about the potential complications that would come with it.
As a huge fan of Steven Spielberg, he is the director that got me into movies in the first
place, I think that his career can be divided into a few different eras, but this film feels
like a combination of a lot of the work that he's done over the years. It has a lot of elements of
the dark futurism of Minority Report, which actually now kind of closely matches our real
world, along with the more awestruck filmmaking that we saw in his early movies. Given that the
story is literally about the clash of those two things, I think the combination works really well,
and I liked the look of the film, which is done through the lens of Spielberg's long-time
cinematographer, Janusz Kaminski. We also get another collaboration between Steven Spielberg
and composer John Williams, one of the greatest cinematic combinations of all time, and given
that it's John Williams, it's probably not a shock that the music in this movie is really good.
There's one track in particular that plays under a crucial scene that has a piano part that I think
is very reminiscent of another piece of score that John Williams wrote for E.T., which is my
favorite movie score of all time, so John Williams, genius, breaking news. The acting in this movie is
also very strong, especially from Emily Blunt. This is one of the best performances of her career,
if not the best. She's asked to play a lot of notes in this movie, from broad comedy to sheer
panic, and she nails every single one of those notes, along with Indy Navaretti from Obsession.
This is one of the clear frontrunners for me for performance of the year so far. Josh O'Connor I
think is also good in the movie, but I felt like his character was more a function of the plot.
The story kind of flows through him, but I didn't feel like his character got as much
depth to play with. Colin Firth plays a suitably threatening antagonist who can wield terrifying
power to get what he wants, and Colman Domingo I think provides kind of a warm heart at the
center of the film, though I think he too could have used a little bit more character depth.
And in service of the saying that there are no small parts, Courtney Grace, who's a former TV
anchor, plays the same role in a critical sequence of the film, and I think absolutely
crushes it. It's a role that might seem inconsequential, but it kind of grounds the
impact of what we're seeing on screen at the time. And Wyatt Russell also does a great job,
as Margaret's boyfriend, scoring several laughs of his own. He's a standout in the film until the
script just kind of runs out of things to do with him. If the movie has a main weakness, I think it
is the screenplay from David Kapp. I have a very up and down relationship with David Kapp. He has
written some great movies, and he's also written some terrible ones. And I think when you look at
this film, what it has are a lot of great scenes that are placed into a somewhat average story,
and I don't think that that is conflicting. I think you can have great scenes in a good
screenplay. It basically meant for me that the connective tissue between those great scenes
could have been a lot stronger, so that they all flowed together, flowed into and out of each other,
and made the overall screenplay great instead of just parts of it. However, the scenes that are
great are great in a lot of different ways, whether it's heavier dialogue scenes or action
sequences. Disclosure Day offers a lot of different things, including frequent and effective humor,
creative action set pieces, genuine insights into the nature of humanity, and a suspenseful ending.
The script does at times, though, dip into what I think are some of Kapp's weaknesses,
including some plot contrivances, and some things that I thought were just a little too
unbelievable, even in a movie that's nominally about aliens. But those things don't kill the
movie. I just think that those few things, along with the overall average nature of how the story
itself flows together, holds the movie back from being truly great, even though it does achieve
greatness in some individual moments. Steven Spielberg has a gift, not just for depicting
amazing things on screen, but also for making the audience feel the awesomeness of these things,
just as much as the characters in the movie feel the awesomeness. And he was able to do that for
me, again, with a lot of stuff in Disclosure Day. It may not have been awe at the scale of some of
his greatest works, but it's still awe. And I think that he is one of the greatest visual directors
of all time. There are shots in this movie that prove that he has not lost his touch,
and I particularly liked how he and Kaminsky used reflections in the movie, often combining
two separate elements in one frame, in really interesting ways. Disclosure Day is an incredibly
dynamic film, and it's over two hours long, but still flew by for me, even at times when the story
took a little bit of a stumble. Directing a movie, a really good movie, is kind of like conducting a
symphony, and there are very few people, I think in the history of movie making, that do it better
than Steven Spielberg. Any frustrations that I might feel about Disclosure Day really come from
the fact that I think it could have been an absolute masterpiece, something that would have
been an even more effective bookend to Spielberg's career, and it's not over, but I just mean a movie
at the beginning and a movie at the end, along with 1977's Close Encounters of the Third Kind.
The elements are all there, but they just don't all come together at the same time,
which by the way shouldn't be necessarily an expectation for any movie, because there are
very few movies where all of the elements come together in that kind of beautiful symphony that
I was talking about of a truly great film. But I think that the possibility was there with Disclosure
Day, and I'm actually anxious to watch the film a second time, now that I kind of know where the
story's going and what the character connections all are, to see just how effective it is once you
get past that sort of first blush of seeing the movie without having seen really anything other
than trailers. But what I can say after my first viewing, as I sit here in the middle of the night
recording this review, is that it features some fantastic acting, some deep questions,
striking imagery, and a curiosity about humanity's place in the universe that can only come from a
filmmaker who's genuinely passionate about the subject matter. So on my personal scale,
I'm putting Disclosure Day very healthfully into the It's Good category, inching up toward the See
It Now category, and I think that this may go down as the signature film of Spielberg's late career,
unless of course he cooks up something even better than this movie in the next several years,
which would absolutely delight me. So those are my thoughts on Disclosure Day, what do you think?
Are you heading out to theaters to see it this weekend? Let me know down in the comments below,
and as always, stay tuned right here for the latest in movie news, reviews,
box office, and more. Until next time, stay safe, watch the skies, and I'll see you then.