Ancient Art Lecture 19: Hellenistic Greek Art

Hellenic Artistry
8 followers
1 Video View·Aug 9, 2026
Mar 3, 2021
The one with all the agony
Chapters
View all
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
AI Generated·May contain errors
Welcome back.
So today we are talking about a 50 year span of Greek history.
This is known as the High Classical Period, and specifically we are going to be talking
about the Parthenon, which is part of the Acropolis, and how it fits into the High Classical
Period.
So here is the Acropolis, with the Parthenon, the big rectangular building, and the Erechtheion
and other little buildings.
And in order to discuss why it looks the way it does, we have to talk about the influences,
or what was going through the minds of the builders and the political leaders at the
time.
So first of all, the psychological effect of the victory over the Persians gave the
Athenians very high self-esteem.
This was Athens at the high point of the Delian League, before the Peloponnesian Wars, which
were the wars between the powers in the peninsula.
Pericles ruled Athens, and he was going for a legacy or promotion of Athenian supremacy,
or a glorification of Athens as a political power, and a cultural ideal.
He ruled according to the principles of justice, equality, opportunity, rule of law, intellectualism,
and open society.
And according to the Greek historian Thucydides, he says, quote,
If Sparta were to be laid waste, its remains would give posterity little impression of
its power.
But if the same misfortune were to overtake Athens, the power of the city from its visible
remains would seem to have been twice as great as it is.
And here we are, believing in the enduring legacy of Athens, with no mention of the major
military superpower of the time, Sparta.
So, Acropolis means city on top of a hill.
And this city center was dedicated to the goddess Athena.
And Pericles began the rebuilding of the Acropolis after the Persian troops destroyed it in 480 BCE.
So after the Persians were defeated, they were feeling really good about themselves,
they decided to rebuild on the same spot.
The architect and artist and sculptor, who had a whole workshop, Phidias, supervised
the project, and it required staggering amounts of labor and cost.
And work continued through the 5th century BCE.
In addition to the Parthenon, there was the Temple of Athena Nike, which is the victorious
Athena, and the Erechtheion, which we will also discuss in more detail.
It's called the Parthenon because it was dedicated to the goddess Athena Parthenos,
who was the warrior maiden, in contrast to Athena Polias, which is the agrarian goddess
of the city, who was worshipped in the Erechtheion.
So there's like different versions of Athena.
And this temple is basically dedicated to her as a warrior.
It was built on the foundations of an earlier temple to Athena that was under construction
when the Persians sacked Athens.
So many blocks were quarried and partially carved, and the architects, Callicrates and
Ictinos, were restricted to the proportions of that earlier temple.
They did, however, need to enlarge the base of the temple in the northern part to make
room for the enormous cult statue inside.
This is a replica of the giant bronze figure of Athena that had a sphere tip and a helmet
that reflected the sun up to 10 miles away at the port of Piraeus.
So Phidias and his workshop were responsible for that giant statue of Athena.
And there are some characteristics of art made by Phidias.
First of all, there's this Olympianism, which has this, I don't want to call it stoicism,
but it's like a cool, calm, sort of in control of your emotions.
There's also this idea of platonic forms, or the platonic ideals.
And this refers to the philosopher Plato, who sort of said that there was a perfect
shape, a perfect form, and we weren't ever going to get there, but we had to imagine
that.
I'm doing a bad job of explaining platonic ideal.
Basically, it just means like the perfect thing you can think of in your head.
The work done by Phidias, the program, subject matter, treatment, emphasizes the vision of
Epirocles, where Athens, Greece is this beacon of light.
It has simplicity, balance, rationality, however, Phidias was accused of embezzling materials
and money, so he was exiled from Athens.
His career wasn't really destroyed, as he later completes another kind of giant statue
of Zeus at Olympia.
But that was his last big project, and he never worked in Athens again.
Okay, so let's get into the meat and potatoes of this building, and sort of talk about the
architecture and the art.
So there was kind of like two sets of columns.
There was an inner and outer set of columns, and typically the number of columns on a long
side is double the number of the short side plus one.
So here it's eight in front and 17 on the side, eight in front and back.
And then the inner cella, or the room, would be mostly for ceremonies and not general use.
So I think I had mentioned it in the last, maybe the Oracle of Delphi lecture, where
I said like all of the things would take place in front of the temple.
You didn't really go into it.
So here's my favorite part of the Parthenon.
There were many small adjustments in the Parthenon.
Nothing is exactly vertical or horizontal, and because of this, each stone has only one
place it belongs.
You couldn't mass-produce stones, like the Egyptians would make all these stones the
same size and put them on top of each other.
They needed to be carved as carefully as a jewel.
So this is a lot of work, and the question is, what might explain putting all of this
work into it?
So there's a few theories.
The first one is called the compensation theory, and this is where the stylobate, or that top
step, and other horizontals seem to sag if you don't sort of give a little lift to them.
And then the end columns will look too skinny set against the sky if they're not thickened
slightly.
So they're compensated.
The next one is known as the exaggeration theory, which is where the horizontal lines
seem slightly bowed up when viewed from below, so perhaps the temple exaggerates these effects
to make it seem larger and more substantial than it actually is.
The last one is known as the tension theory, and this is where deviations from absolute
regularity create a tension in the mind of the viewer between what is seen and what the
viewer expects to see.
So instead of absolute regularity and geometry, there are these small changes and curves and
angles, which serves to keep the viewer interested for longer.
This is probably a false choice, and it's just a combination of all three.
The stylobate is curved to compensate for the sag.
The entablature is curved to make it seem bigger.
All effects produce a lively and surprising temple rather than a perfectly exact one.
The south side of the Parthenon suffered damage during the conflict in 1687, that's common
era, between the Ottoman Turks, and they were in control of Greece at the time, and they
were fighting against the Venetians.
The temple was being used for ammunition storage, and during the Venetian bombardment, a cannonball
exploded the excess munitions, and it caused a great deal of structural damage to the building.
So this thing had been standing for thousands of years, and then the Turks didn't care about
it, and they used it as a munitions storage, and then basically destroyed it all.
I have this really great video in the modules that I want you to watch about the Parthenon
and the sculptures and videos, but I'm just going to say a few things about it that might
be repeated or it might not be in the video, but I just want to say there's a few interesting
things about the frieze, which is the long band that runs along the inner wall of the
temple.
First of all, it's about three and a half feet high.
One of my favorite little details is that the relief at the top is actually two inches
deeper than at the bottom.
This aids in visibility, so because it's kind of sticking out of the wall further, it helps
you to make sense of it.
It's just like in TASIS, it's another sort of device that allows you to make better sense
of it.
So the frieze itself has stories and images from the Panathenaic Festival and procession
that would have taken place every year, but then every four years it was more elaborate
and special.
And the frieze progresses just as a person in the procession would have progressed around
the building.
We have seen this before.
Something to notice in this frieze is that emotional detachment and idealism are prominent
throughout.
And this is contrasted by the nervous energy of the animals.
Again there's this theme of order over chaos or civilization over nature.
One of my favorite little details is the four cows and the four sheep that are on the north
end and the ten cows on the south are meant for sacrifice on the Acropolis.
And there's this A-B rhythm of placid and then rested cows.
So some are calm and some are putting up a fight.
So here we are.
We have seen this before.
I'm going to ask you in one of the lecture questions to compare these two processions
and friezes.
I'm going to tell you a little bit about the hydria bearers first and then you can use
that information to help answer the question.
So here's the story with the scene on the right.
Three youths are bearing water jars on their shoulders and they're followed at the right
end by a fourth youth who's reaching down to lift his hydria or water jug.
And then behind him or kind of next to him is a flute player who is heading a group of
musicians.
The first three youths are executed in higher relief than the fourth which means that they're
sticking out a little bit further.
And the fourth one is kind of hidden to create depth.
And they wear long robes that leave one shoulder and part of the chest bare as they move solemnly
towards the left.
The uniformity of this scene is broken up by slight variations in the folds of the garment,
the positions of the heads, and the youth gestures.
So I've just sort of given you a formal analysis and now what I want you to do is tell me all
of the things that you find similar and different about these two.
The outer frieze is made up of metopes and this means these little sort of squares with
images inside these three bars.
And each side has a different story in the metopes.
The east there's the gods versus the titans, on the south there's the Lapiths versus the
centaurs.
The Lapiths were a people.
The west was the Greeks versus the Amazons, and then the north was the Greeks versus the
Trojans.
And, again, the overall theme of this is the triumph of order over chaos, Greeks over barbarians,
west over east, people over monsters, etc.
Just like the east and west pediments of Aegina, there is progress within the metopes of the
Parthenon itself.
So this is two different metopes.
You can see the difference between the earlier and the later ones.
The later one, it kind of fills the space more naturalistically.
There's not the awkward gesture of the earlier one.
And then the more progressive later one shows the counteracting forces of Lapith and Centaur,
and a play of light and shadow, like you get sort of lost in the folds and the shadows
from behind them.
A lot of what we know about the Parthenon is actually from drawings by a French artist
Jacques Carre, who made 55 drawings of the friezes and pediments in 1674, right before
the destruction by the Venetians and the Ottoman Turks.
Within the pediments, or the triangular parts of the roof, are two different stories.
On the east you've got the birth of Athena, and then on the west you've got the Athena
versus Poseidon, and that's important because the Athenians had this sort of struggle with
who would be their patron god, and Poseidon was an easy choice because of their naval
prowess, but Athena was the warrior who, in the end, helped them to defeat the Persians.
So ultimately they chose Athena.
There are some real artistic leaps that happen.
In the statuary of the Parthenon, one is that realism and then love of the specific begins
to take over from abstraction and a sort of embracing of the generic from the archaic period.
Another thing is that there are more artists now working and building temples, and so there's,
like we've already talked about, this sort of competition throughout the peninsula, and
that competition led to innovation in all kinds of things, including art.
And so here we have an example of how do you reveal and conceal simultaneously, and you
get this drapery that is kind of clinging to the body, and it allows for contours and
shapes to come through.
I want to end on the Erechtheion, because it has one of my favorite groups of statues
from this whole complex.
The Erechtheion was this strange composite shrine that had multiple functions and it
was dedicated to multiple gods.
It was really important.
It was one of the oldest temples in Athens.
It had pools, shafts, skylights, crypts.
There was a den for a sacred snake, and these were all incorporated into the building.
But my favorite bit is the Caryatids, and these are the human columns.
And there's a story, or there are stories about the Caryatids and why they were used
as columns, but before we get there, I just want to talk about the hair.
So Phidias, the sculptor, in his workshop, made the braids of the hair really thick so
that they could act as a stronger support system, because the neck would have been too
thin, and the column would have been prone to crumble under the weight, so he devises
the strategy of making the hair really wide.
Okay, so why use statues of people as columns?
So there's two sort of stories.
One is they were Spartan slaves, and this would have been the punishment of the women
from Cariae, a town near Sparta, who were condemned to slavery after betraying Athens
by siding with Persia.
So then they would be forced to forever uphold the temple to the god of Athens.
And the problem with this theory is that there were Caryatids being used in architecture
before the war.
The second is that these were priestesses of the Cariae, and they were maidens who carried
sacred objects used at feasts of the goddesses Athena and Artemis.
And they would perform this sort of ecstatic circular dance, and they would carry on their
heads baskets of live reeds as if they were dancing plants.
Now, of course, this is where I ask you, what do you think?
So in your lecture questions, you'll have a Caryatid question as well.
