Why did Jonathan Sacerdoti’s Oxford Union debate go viral — and what happened behind the scenes? In this episode of The Brief, host Shabbos Kestenbaum sits down with Jonathan Sacerdoti — British broadcaster, journalist, and public intellectual — for a conversation about the Oxford Union debate that went viral around the world, the BBC's Gaza documentary scandal, and what the UK's two-tier approach to law and media actually looks like from the inside. The debate — on the motion "The West Should Be Suspicious of Islam" — took place in June but was held back by the Oxford Union for weeks. When selective clips started leaking to Middle East Eye, Jonathan and his team released their own footage. Within hours, the Oxford Union found the upload button. The result: 13 million views and a global conversation.
Jonathan and Shabbos also cover: The BBC's Gaza documentary narrated by the son of a Hamas junior minister — and why the BBC claimed not to know Why the BBC, funded by a mandatory license fee, is more culpable than commercial media for spreading misleading content about Israel and Jews Two-tier policing in the UK: are politicians and law enforcement treating people differently based on religion, ethnicity, and politics — and why? The multiculturalism mistake of the 1990s: how Britain moved from a shared national identity to a society of parallel enclaves that don't communicate Why Jonathan — as a Jew — believes Israel's model of integrating vastly different communities around a shared national identity is exactly what Britain needs Mohammed topping the UK baby name charts for three years: what the demographic shift means, what it doesn't mean, and why second-generation integration data is the real story Why the UK still hasn't banned the Muslim Brotherhood — and what Germany's intermediate approach to monitoring non-violent extremism could teach Britain Jonathan Sacerdoti is a British broadcaster, journalist, and public intellectual.
00:00:49 The Oxford Union Debate — Why Was It Suppressed for 6 Weeks? 00:01:34 The Motion: Should the West Be Suspicious of Islam? 00:02:28 The Viral "You'd Be Cooked" Clip — Played & Reacted To 00:03:15 Who Was Aisha — And What Her Argument Actually Proved 00:04:26 Islamic Extremism & Radicalization on UK Campuses 00:06:20 Tommy Robinson, Two-Tier Policing & the BBC's Role 00:07:00 Why the BBC Is More Culpable Than Commercial Media 00:08:23 The BBC Gaza Documentary Narrated by a Hamas Minister's Son 00:09:25 Are UK Politicians Treating People Differently by Religion? 00:10:23 Why Politicians Fear Muslim Voter Blocs — And Call It a Ceasefire 00:11:14 What Equal Treatment Under the Law Actually Looks Like 00:12:14 The Oxford Union Thesis: Why the West Has the Right to Be Suspicious 00:13:07 Jonathan's Argument: As a Jew, As a Briton, As a Non-Muslim 00:14:20 From the Rushdie Fatwa to 7/7 to Manchester to October 7th 00:15:15 The Polling on British Muslim Attitudes — Sharia, Schools, Press 00:15:53 Can These Cultural Attitudes Be Reformed? 00:16:41 The 1990s Multiculturalism Mistake That Changed Britain Forever 00:17:08 Israel as a Model for Integration — Why Zionism Matters 00:18:42 Mohammed Tops the UK Baby Name Charts — What It Really Means 00:19:40 Second-Generation Muslims & the Radicalization Data 00:21:16 Brexit, Immigration & Taking Back Control — What Actually Happened 00:22:01 Why Hasn't the UK Banned the Muslim Brotherhood?
Why did it take so long for the Oxford Union to even release the footage publicly?
The media and the BBC are absolutely culpable.
It should be telling the truth, but the BBC chooses not to do that.
They said Islam is in fact a religion of peace, and if you disagree, we will literally cook you.
She thought she was being funny. I think she meant what she said,
and I think she didn't quite understand how it really disproved her point.
That same mob outside had actually blocked the entrances.
Why is the West right to be suspicious of Islam?
The attitude towards non-Muslims is extremely problematic.
They carry those attacks in the name of Islam.
Why hasn't the UK government banned the Muslim Brotherhood?
And welcome back to The Brief. We have a great show for you.
But just before we begin, make sure you like, comment, subscribe
to ensure that we can reach as large of an audience as possible.
And with that, we're joined today by Jonathan Sachidoti.
He is a British broadcaster, journalist, public intellectual.
Jonathan, appreciate you making the time.
Great to be with you, Shabbos.
So I want to get straight into it.
Oxford Union debate, which has since blown up, gone super viral.
The Oxford Union itself is often known as the last bastion of free speech.
But the debate that you took part in recently
was actually not a debate you took part in recently.
It took place many months ago.
So can you just educate myself and educator viewers,
why did it take so long for us to find out about this debate?
Why did it take so long for the Oxford Union to even release the footage publicly?
Right. Well, I've done a couple of debates at the Oxford Union in the last two years, actually.
So one was about Israel.
And that was about a year and a half ago.
And I got massively abused in that by the handpicked audience.
Order. The member is abusing the forms of the house.
That went hugely viral.
13 million people watched the abuse.
And so I was surprised that they did invite me back about a year and a half later.
And that was to talk about Islam.
And the motion for debate was whether the West should be suspicious of Islam.
We actually did the debate back in June.
They said that the video would be out within a couple of weeks.
And it wasn't after six weeks when they started to leak clips of it to Middle East Eye,
who started to edit it rather selectively.
And at that point, we decided that the videos that we had taken
in the debate really ought to be released so that people could see the whole thing properly.
And what do you know?
Within a few hours of doing that, the Oxford Union managed to find the upload button.
So that burst into the world.
And as a result, yes, it's gone massively viral.
It's being retweeted and shared and clipped and commented on all around the world,
which, if I'm honest, is the real reason one goes to the Oxford Union to do a debate,
because it can be quite arduous sitting there and quite stuffy.
So what you really go there for is in the hope that the debate
will get a worldwide audience who will then discuss the topic properly.
And in that sense, of course, mission accomplished.
I do want to get to your thesis, which is that the West should be suspicious of Islam.
But just before I get into it,
I want to play perhaps the most viral clip from that debate and then get your reaction to it.
Stephen Yaxley Lennon, known to his hooligans as Tommy Robinson.
Stephen, there is a crowd outside rioting against you tonight.
And without the protection and generosity of a Muslim Palestinian president
and a mostly South Asian executive committee,
you would be quite literally cooked.
So, Jonathan, that was your ideological opposition,
essentially arguing that Islam is, in fact, a religion of peace.
And if you disagree, we will literally cook you.
Your reaction to her claim?
Well, I mean, that's why that clip has gone, you know,
quite so viral, because that girl there, Aisha, was saying effectively,
you know, that if it weren't for the generosity and protection
of the mostly Muslim committee who have hosted you here,
these rioters outside would be attacking you.
And it's true, there were rioters outside.
There were people who didn't want this debate to go on,
partly because it was about Islam,
and partly because one of the other speakers was Tommy Robinson,
who is a controversial figure,
who has been an activist against Islam for many, many years.
And so I think that she thought she was being funny.
And I do feel a little bit sorry for Aisha there,
because of all of them, actually, in chatting before and after the event to all of them,
she was actually quite a sweet girl.
She, you know, her parents actually hadn't been able
to get into the debate to see her speak,
because that same mob outside had actually blocked the entrances.
And so the audience was much smaller than it would normally have been
for a debate like that.
It probably would have been rammed full most of the time,
like the last time I was there for the Israel debate.
And so I did feel a bit sorry for her.
But then on the other hand, I think she meant what she said.
And I think she didn't quite understand
how it really disproved her point rather than made it.
So then let's zoom out from Oxford and talk about campuses in the UK, broadly speaking.
So you've had several high profile extremists and like actual terrorists.
You have Omar Saeed Sheikh from the London School of Economics,
Umar Farooq Abdul Muttalib.
He was the attempted Christmas Day hijacker here in the US.
He went to the University College London.
And in fact, the UK government actually introduced the prevent strategy,
which essentially required universities and colleges
to actively spot signs of radicalization
and stop students, particularly from the Muslim community,
from moving toward violent extremism.
So can you just describe to myself
and to our audience here in the United States,
what is it like as it pertains to Islamic extremism
and radicalization on UK campuses?
I think it's a really tough question because, well, firstly,
it's been a few years since I was a student on campus
and things have changed a bit since then.
But because of my work, I do visit campuses
and I do speak to students and others
constantly about the things that they're going through.
So it's always hard to know how bad the problem is,
because when we see these encampments or the protests,
they look terrible and they are terrible.
But you do then think about it,
how many people in the college or the university
are actually taking part in that?
And when there is enormous social pressure to do so,
you then have to ask yourself,
actually, isn't it true that most of the people,
most of the student body,
actually don't want to get involved in this?
The problem is they're not necessarily speaking out.
And as you say, there are some quite severe cases
of extremism within college campuses.
And there are people who are what they call radicalized,
though I don't like the term,
it sounds far too passive on campus.
And there are problems within certain student bodies
and student societies
where people literally get to hear extremist
or illegal speakers spreading extreme ideologies
and problematic ideas,
which can then indeed lead them
into a life of even terrorism.
So I do think that that is something
which is common to the UK as to the US
as to many other parts of the world.
So you mentioned Tommy Robinson,
and full disclosure, Tommy's been on the show.
He's a friend of PragerU.
And one of the things that he often argues
is the culpability of the mainstream media
when it comes to the normalization of Islamism.
And to me, that's kind of personified
by the attack last week, the BBC reported.
I'm going to quote directly
to make sure I get this right.
They said, quote,
one dead, 16 injured at Berlin Pride event
after vehicle driven into crowd.
Now, of course, vehicles don't commit crimes,
but Islamists do.
Can you talk about the degree of culpability,
if any, of the mainstream media in the UK
when it comes to sort of this normalization of Islamism
and almost giving radical Islamic terrorists
kind of like this free pass?
Look, to my mind, the media
and the BBC in particular are absolutely culpable.
The BBC, why do I pick on the BBC specifically?
Because the BBC is paid for by the license fee.
So if you own a television
or if you watch live TV or streaming services
on the BBC's iPlayer,
you have to pay this tax effectively.
It's not a tax, but it may as well be.
You have to pay over £100 per person.
And that's how they're funded.
And the reason for that is
it's meant to be public service broadcasting.
So if you ask me what a public service broadcaster should do
in terms of how it covers, say, Israel or the Middle East
or what's happening to Jews,
it should be telling the truth
despite it being non-fashionable,
despite it bucking a trend,
because that's exactly the point of a license fee.
If you're not subject to commercial pressures,
if you can't be boycotted by advertisers or pressure groups,
but instead you have the ability to know
that your funding is secure
and you can actually dig through
kind of derangement of mobs
or any kind of pressure campaign
that might be funded externally by Qatar or anywhere else,
then you could literally tell the truth.
But the BBC chooses not to do that.
The BBC instead, for example,
put out a documentary over the last three years
during, you know, since October the 7th,
put out a documentary supposedly telling the story
of children in the Gaza Strip.
And it turned out within 24 hours
of them releasing the documentary
that a friend and amazing activist, David Collier,
revealed that the child narrator of the documentary
was the son of a Hamas junior minister.
I mean, you couldn't make this stuff up.
The BBC claiming that they didn't know
despite having made this high budget
landmark documentary with the kid
and having paid his family.
So effectively money from the ordinary TV viewer
and licensed fee payer
that went into the hands of a family
who are connected to Hamas.
That is just one example.
There are so many examples.
And because they continue to spread this stuff,
they have on the other hand,
a reputation of reliability and that you can trust them.
So people see this on the news,
whether it's about Israel
or whether it's just about Jews in general,
and it's so warped and twisted,
but people believe it and trust it
because it came from the BBC,
one of the most trusted news brands in the world.
So I think it's very much culpable
and I think it's very much behind
a lot of the spreading of this sort of stuff.
You know, this might be tangential,
but I sort of seem that you're alluding
to what Tommy Robinson would call this two-tier policing,
which to me is sort of people in the UK
are treated qualitatively different
based on these immutable external characteristics.
So the Jewish community versus the Muslim community,
conservatives versus liberals.
Do you think that the UK government
is treating people differently based on their politics,
based on their religion, based on their ethnicities?
So there's a lot of discussion
over why some of these fashionable positions,
which aren't true,
get repeated and also get obeyed
or sort of followed along by politicians.
And one of the concerns
is that there are sections of the country
where the voter base is particularly
allied to one idea or ideology
and that specifically in areas
of high Muslim concentration population,
politicians feel that they need to
at least say the right things
that their constituents, their voters will find attractive.
And so what that means is,
even if they know, for example,
that the genocide slur is outrageous
against the state of Israel,
if they don't say it
or if they don't call for a ceasefire
during an existential war
in which there are still hostages being kept
by the Palestinians in the Gaza Strip,
but if they don't call for a ceasefire,
even if it's not really a wise idea,
even if it perpetuates the hostage taking
and keeps people imprisoned in tunnels,
well, then they will lose votes.
And if they lose votes,
they can't do anything in the national interest,
nevermind about Jews or Israel or anything else.
But I would say that that's a cop-out
and politicians, like anyone else,
really ought to do what is right.
They ought to act with conviction.
They ought to act according to reality.
And I think that, as I said,
with the BBC, the same applies with politicians.
These things are self-perpetuating
because the more people go along with the lies,
the more people go along
with the twisting and the calumnies,
the more these things basically are believed
and they sort of become true,
even though they're not.
So I think that all it needs is for people to say,
we're not going to do this
according to the colour of your skin
or according to your ethnic background
or according to the country
that you or your parents
or their parents emigrated from.
We're actually going to treat everyone the same.
We're going to apply our laws the same.
We're not going to tolerate things
which go against our laws or our culture.
And we're going to treat people
as we all should treat each other in this country.
But at the moment, that really isn't happening.
Jonathan, if I may,
let's kind of get into the meat and potatoes
and that is your actual debate itself.
Your thesis was that the West does in fact
have a right to be suspicious of Islam.
So in the most rudimentary and elementary way
I can ask the question,
why is the West right to be suspicious of Islam
in your eyes?
Well, listen,
I do think everyone should go and watch the speech,
not just because it's my speech,
but I was very proud of what I managed to say
in that 12 or 13 minutes
because I think it's an extremely sensitive topic.
I don't shy away from the fact
that I'm talking about other people's religion,
other people's faith and a minority faith at that.
And I'm a Jew.
I recognise that often people criticising your beliefs
or your ideology can feel very scary.
It can feel wrong.
It can feel unfair.
And yet the reason that I will speak about Islam
in such a context is actually because I'm a Jew,
because I'm a Briton,
because I'm a non-Muslim.
And I do think that there is a problem
within the entirety of Islam
that the attitude of many or some who are Muslim
or who are adherents to Islam,
the attitude towards non-Muslims
is extremely problematic.
That is not to say that's for all Muslims.
And there is a debate over whether or not
it is in line with the correct teachings of Islam or not.
But that is what the debate was about.
And so what I tried to explain in my speech
was that I was going to look at this
not as a true or deep analysis of what is
and isn't correct Quranic interpretation.
That's not my job.
My job is to say, actually, as a Westerner,
as a non-Muslim, as a Jewish person,
here's how Islam has entered my life.
Here's how Islam has entered our lives.
And more often than not,
that has been in a negative or traumatic or fatal way.
So I would say that most people's first memory of Islam
who aren't Muslim, say here in Britain,
is not a very positive one.
Where Islam has entered their lives,
it's often been through things like the Salman Rushdie affair,
where Salman Rushdie wrote the Satanic Verses,
a novel for which there was a fatwa issued
calling for his death by Ayatollah Khomeini in Iran.
And indeed, over decades,
he had to have close protection all the time
until eventually something like 20 years later,
he was indeed stabbed in New York at a public event
and lost the use of one of his eyes.
The point is that that is part of Islam.
It may not be part of everyone's Islam.
There are many Muslims who are disgusted by that as well.
But the people who carry out those acts
and numerous others from 7-7 tube bombings
to the Ariana Grande concert bombing in Manchester Arena,
to the 7th of October in Southern Israel,
to the Twin Towers and 9-11, et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
All of those people, when they carried out those attacks,
did so in the name of Islam.
They said it.
It doesn't matter whether I said it.
It doesn't matter whether the opposition in that debate
said that they're wrong.
There is an enormous amount of extremism
and terrorism and violence,
which is inspired by Islamic texts,
Islamic teaching and Islamic belief.
And so I think that the debate is very important
for non-Muslims and very important for Muslims
if we're to try to find a way through that
so that it isn't something that's scary to the rest of us.
And of course, the biggest group of victims
of Islamic terrorist attacks are Muslims themselves.
You mentioned the attitudes of Muslims.
I just want to quote what your co-debater,
your colleague Lawrence Fox mentioned at this debate,
which is 43% of British Muslims
want Sharia law imposed in the United Kingdom.
53% of British Muslims want schools
to instill, quote, Muslim values.
78% of British Muslims say no publication
should ever publish a picture of Muhammad.
So my question to you, Jonathan,
is these are cultural attitudes
that objectively are incompatible
with Western civilization.
You know, we believe in a free press and free speech.
How can this be reformed, if at all?
I don't necessarily know the answer to that question,
but what I would suggest is that
for countries like my own here in Great Britain,
and I feel very British.
You know, I grew up here
and it is very much a part of my identity.
I think that the main thing that we're lacking
is a strong sense of our own identity.
I think that for most of my life,
there's been this transformation of British identity
from something which was very clear
and rooted in our history and our traditions,
and maybe even in Christianity,
which was the religion of the state at one point,
at any rate, if it isn't anymore.
I think that that slid a bit.
And during the 90s, when I was a teenager,
there was this move towards multiculturalism,
which said that different cultures can coexist
within our society without adapting and assimilating.
I think for me, that was probably the biggest mistake,
because what it said was that
we could all live in our own little enclaves.
We could even not learn the same language.
We could exist in our own bubble
and that doesn't create a cohesive society.
Whereas a varied society
with people from all around the world in it,
that's absolutely fine, even desirable,
because that variety can enrich our culture and identity.
Countries like Israel are just a good example of that.
It is a country with vast amounts of immigration
from around the world.
Yes, Jewish immigration,
but people from such different backgrounds and cultures.
And yet there is a strong Jewish and Israeli identity
which has helped people to create a strong state
with a strong sense of identity.
And yet there are differences in traditions and foods
and ideas and thoughts and even politics,
which do draw on people's ethnic origins
or people's backgrounds or what have you.
I think that we're missing that in the UK.
And that's why, to me, it's actually a great shame
that Zionism and Israel have become such dirty words to Brits
and also across much of the West.
Because actually, I think that Zionism represents
a particularly successful integration
of different peoples from around the world
in a way that they could have a common and shared identity
without losing their connection to, let's say,
the variety that they have from one another.
And so I think that in answer to what we could do,
say, here in Britain,
I think that we could try to instill a bit more pride
in our British history,
a bit more pride in what it means to be British
beyond this kind of modern wishy-washy idea
that what it means to be British is variety and diversity.
Because while those things, as I said, can be important
and can contribute to something great,
on their own, they don't do that.
On their own, what they do is just mean that we are,
in a way, like an island of strangers or a sort of airport
where lots of different people have flown in
but aren't really doing something together.
I think you've already answered this question,
but Muhammad has topped the baby name charts
in England and Wales.
That's for the last three years now.
Can you just talk a little bit about the demographic shifts
that you have seen anecdotally
and what the overall sentiments are of the British people
as it pertains to cultural assimilation or lack thereof?
Sure. Well, the baby name thing is always quoted and referred to
and there's a degree of shock about it.
I will say that it is important
and it does point towards something.
But on the other hand, you've got to remember
that many, many Muslim people use the name Muhammad for boys,
whereas other faith groups or other ethnicities
don't necessarily stick to one name
that they give to all their boys.
So that skews the results to some degree.
But what it does point to, regardless,
is the fact that there is a growing Muslim population
in the UK and people will bristle sometimes
when they hear me or others say that,
because I say, well, what's wrong with that?
How can you as a Jew be critical of a minority religious group
growing in numbers in the country?
Doesn't that show that we're welcoming and compassionate
and that we are accepting and tolerant and et cetera?
But I will say again, those things could be true
if we were sure that the communities we're speaking of
or the groups we're speaking of
are committed to that common sense of Britishness
and they are as committed to getting along
with their non-Muslim neighbours
as maybe their non-Muslim neighbours
are committed to getting on with them.
And then we see polling,
like the polling you referred to earlier,
which gives us a clue as to what some opinions are like.
And we also see in many of those polls
that worryingly and disturbingly,
it's often the British born children of immigrants
or grandchildren of immigrants
who are actually developing more extreme views
or views which are more committed to an interpretation of Sharia
and Islam that is incompatible with the West.
And if that's happening, that's obviously a big problem.
So I think that's what people are worried about
when they think about the demographic shift.
And at the same time,
many people in Britain are generally very concerned
about migration into the country as in America.
Here we have the issue of whether or not
we had control over our own immigration before Brexit,
a few years ago when the British public were given a referendum
of whether or not we would like to stay in the European Union or not.
And the majority of voters chose that we should leave.
One of the big reasons that people quoted for wanting to leave
was that we wanted to take back control
over who was allowed in the country and who wasn't.
We now have the ability to do that theoretically,
but it just hasn't happened.
There has still been massive waves of immigration
and massive waves of immigration from countries
which many people feel are incompatible,
cultures that are incompatible, and plenty of illegal migration.
Every single day, boats are arriving,
crossing the English Channel,
full of people who come from countries
where normal Brits are concerned they don't share our values
and our ethics and our morals,
and that those people are just sowing the seeds
for further problems in this country.
Jonathan, really last question very quickly,
and then I will shut up.
We spoke about cultural reforms,
which I agree are harder to define or articulate,
but why hasn't the UK government
banned the Muslim Brotherhood, for example?
That seems like an easy win, no?
It's a very good question.
And you know, the US is starting to make moves
in that direction as well.
I think one of the problems that we're struggling with
here in the United Kingdom
is the idea of what constitutes valid speech or political thought
under the principle of freedom of speech.
And some people say that the line for extremism
is drawn when it becomes violent,
and when it becomes terrorist.
Others say that there is an earlier line
that we need to draw,
because you shouldn't necessarily wait
for the terror attack.
You should be able to try to nip it in the bud
to prevent the extremism that leads to that.
And Germany, for example,
as a result of Nazism and its history,
has a sort of intermediate stage, as I understand it,
where they have a body which is there
to monitor extremism that is non-violent.
And I think that Britain is struggling
with that very discussion
in terms of which organisations and groups
it will prescribe as terrorist or not terrorist,
and how it deals with people
that it has suspicions towards about their extremism
or any similar problematic or dangerous views.
And I think that's a debate
that really we're actually spending too long having.
It's not that we're not having it.
We're spending too long having it.
We're not making the decisions.
And in the meantime,
groups like the Muslim Brotherhood
have very much set down roots in the UK,
found that they can raise money
through our charity system,
found that they can operate fairly unimpeded here,
when in parts of the Middle East,
they actually can't operate as freely.
Unfortunately, we got to end it there,
but this has been a really illuminating conversation.
Jonathan Sachidode,
he's a British broadcaster, journalist, public intellectual.
Very much appreciate you making the time.
And we are going to ensure that your Oxford Union debate
is clipped in the video description below.
My audience, please make sure you go watch
his brilliant masterclass
on why the West should in fact be suspicious of Islam.
Take care.
Thanks a lot, Travis.
Thanks for watching this week's episode.
Let us know your thoughts in the comments below
and also tell us what topics you want to see covered,
whether it's immigration, tariffs.
We have great episodes coming up
and we'll see you next week on The Brief.