In June 2025, physicists published the most precise measurement of a subatomic particle ever made. The muon g-2 result still doesn’t match what the standard model predicts. Dr. Brian Keating breaks down what that means and why the real story is more complicated than the headlines suggest.
Subscribe if you want science with evidence, not speculation.
In 2013, physicists loaded a 50-foot superconducting magnet onto a barge in Long Island, sailed it around Florida and up the Mississippi River, and drove it through the suburbs of Chicago at 3 a.m. Three thousand people showed up to watch it arrive. All of it to measure one number: g minus 2, the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon.
The muon is a heavier, unstable cousin of the electron. It lives for about 2.2 microseconds before decaying. But in that brief window, it acts as one of the most sensitive probes of new physics we have. Virtual particles from quantum fields tug on the muon as it spins, shifting its magnetic moment at the sixth decimal place. If there are particles beyond the standard model, they would leave a fingerprint in that number. That’s the hunt.
After 60 years, 6 billion muons, and a Breakthrough Prize shared among 400 scientists, the anomaly is still there at 127 parts per billion precision. But the measurement only matters if the theoretical prediction is reliable. Two competing theoretical calculations are giving different answers. One points to new physics. The other doesn’t.
The experiment isn’t wrong. We just don’t yet know which theory is.
CHAPTERS
00:00 A magnet barged across America. Why? 00:46 What makes a muon special? 01:20 Is g supposed to equal exactly 2? 02:00 What lives and dies in empty space? 02:36 Can a particle leave a clue without being seen? 02:56 How do you catch a wobble at near light speed? 03:56 The first experiment that hinted at something wrong 04:24 3.7 sigma: exciting enough to lose sleep over 05:04 Why move a ring 3,200 miles instead of building a new one? 06:04 127 parts per billion: what that precision actually means 06:38 400 scientists. $3 million. One number. 06:50 The calculation harder than the experiment itself 07:36 Two theories. One has to be wrong. 08:06 Is the standard model actually broken? 08:24 The door is still open
Get the transcript, fascinating bonus content, and my Monday M.A.G.I.C. Message: https://briankeating.com/yt
Support Into the Impossible on Patreon, get my weekly M.A.G.I.C. Message, unfiltered bonus content, and live monthly Office Hours with me: https://www.patreon.com/drbriankeating
This video explores the \"G-2\" experiment, a decades-long effort by physicists to measure the muon's magnetic moment. By comparing this precise measurement to theoretical predictions, scientists aim to detect \"new physics\" beyond the Standard Model, though current discrepancies between different theoretical calculation methods leave the final conclusion open.
In 2013, physicists loaded a 50-foot superconducting magnet onto a barge in Long Island,
my hometown, and sailed it down the Atlantic coast around Florida and then up the Mississippi River
and drove it through the suburbs of Chicago at 3 in the morning. 3,000 people showed up to watch
it arrive. 3,000 people coming out. Three generations of physicists. They did it all to
measure one number. A number that three generations of physicists have been chasing since the 1960s.
After 60 years, 6 billion muons, and the most precise measurement in human history,
that number still doesn't agree with what our best theories predict. And last month,
they won the Breakthrough Prize for it. This is the story of G-2.
Before we get to what went wrong, you need to know what a muon is. You could think of a muon
as basically a heavier version of the electron. Same electric charge, same spin, but about 207
times more massive. And it's also unstable. It shows up when cosmic rays slam into the upper
atmosphere. Or they can be produced when you smash protons together in a particle accelerator.
Muons are unstable. They decay. They last for about 2.2 microseconds on average before decaying
into an electron and two neutrinos. Now, that's not a lot of time to work with. But it turns out
to be just right. Like every charged particle with spin, a muon acts like a tiny bar magnet.
It has a magnetic moment. And the strength of that magnetic moment is described by a number
physicists call g. For a point particle that's fundamental with no interactions,
the Dirac equation tells you that g equals exactly 2. But muons, they aren't exactly lonely. They
exist in a universe full of quantum fields. And those quantum fields can affect the muon's
magnetism in ways that are subtle and extraordinarily minute. With these diminutive
effects, physicists can learn a tremendous amount about the quantum foam that's thought
to pervade our universe. Now, here's where it gets really interesting. Empty space is not empty.
It's a churning sea of virtual particles that pop into and out of existence faster than you can
measure them. Electron-positron pairs, quarks, W and Z bosons, even Higgs bosons. Every one of
these virtual particles tugs on the muon as it spins. They change the magnetic moment of the
muon by a tiny amount. When I say tiny, I mean corrections at the 6th decimal place. But here's
critical point. If there are particles out there that we've never detected, particles not found in
the standard model of particle physics, they too would tug on the muon. And this would cause a
subtle shift in the g value. A shift that's tiny, but it could be measurable. This makes measuring
the muon's magnetic moment, the amount of bar magnetism it has, one of the most sensitive
problems we have of new physics. You don't have to build a new particle detector directly. You
just need to see its fingerprint in the wobble of muons in existing particle experiments.
So why do they wobble? And how do you actually measure this? My clever colleagues in particle
physics have been measuring the wobble of the muon and the electron, its lighter cousin,
for decades. The way they do it is ingenious. They shoot muons into a giant circular magnet.
The muons travel around the ring at nearly the speed of light. And as they go, they precess.
Their axis of spin wobbles just like a gyroscope. If the muons had a g value of exactly 2,
the spin direction and the direction of motion would stay locked together. But because g is
slightly more than 2, the spin gradually gets ahead of the direction of motion. This difference,
the anomalous part, is what the experiment measures. Unlike electrons, muons decay,
and when they do, they spit out positrons. Which of the antimatter positive version of the electron
go in the direction of the muon's spin when they get spit out. So counting high energy positrons
over time, you would see a wave-like pattern. That wave-like oscillation is how fast the spin
is precessing. And from the precessional rate, you can extract the value of g minus 2.
The first serious attempt to measure the muon's g minus 2 factor happened at CERN in the late
1960s and 70s. Those experiments confirmed that the anomalous magnetic moment of the muon was
real, and the value they measured roughly matched the theoretical prediction. But the precision of
the theory and the measurement was not yet good enough to see effects that would lead us to believe
there's physics beyond the standard model that we haven't yet accounted for. Now that would be
tremendously exciting. For better than 50 years, we've been waiting for more and more precise
measurements. Then came Brookhaven on Long Island, my hometown. Starting in the 1990s, an experiment
with a very evocative name, E821 at Brookhaven, built a brand new superconducting magnetic storage
ring. This ring was 50 feet across, with a magnetic field that had to be uniform to a few
parts per million. By 2004, after a decade of running, they had their final answer, and it
disagreed with the standard model prediction by 3.7 sigma. This is a large amount, but it's not
quite enough to hold a place in Stockholm for a Nobel Prize discovery. For that, you need 5 sigma.
But 3.7 sigma is enough to keep every particle physicist on the planet awake at night. It's
that exciting. So physicists decided they could do it again, a little bit better, at Fermilab. But
instead of building a new ring for more than 25 million dollars, they had to move the existing
one for a mere 3 million dollars. That's the midnight highway journey I showed you at the
beginning of the video. The ring could not tilt by more than a few degrees, or the superconducting
coils inside of it would be destroyed. Imagine transporting a 17 ton souffle across the ocean,
and not having it pump. Now, it was so exciting even to laypeople that 3,000 people showed up
when they arrived at Fermilab in July of 2013. And that's when the real work began. They wanted to
go from parts per million to parts per billion, and Fermilab was the only place they could do it.
The Fermilab team spent four years upgrading the detectors, improving the beam quality,
and preparing for the precision that had not been available for decades. In the first year of taking
data alone, they collected more muon decays than in the entire lifetime of the run at Brookhaven
National Laboratory. In 2021, they announced their first result. It confirmed the Brookhaven results.
The anomaly was real. Two years later, in 2023, they released an update. The anomaly was still
there. And in June of 2025, they published their final result, the most precise measurement of the
muon's magnetic moment and the G-2 factor ever made. This result stood at an astounding 127
parts per billion level of precision. To put that in perspective, that's like measuring the
distance from New York to Los Angeles and getting it right to within the width of a human hair.
Three weeks ago, the collaboration won the Breakthrough Prize in Fundamental Physics.
Unlike the Nobel Prize, the $3 million purse was shared by more than 400 scientists for six
decades of work all spent to measure that one number, G-2. But here's where the story gets
complicated, and honestly, it's the part that most science communication leaves out. The
measurement only matters if you have a reliable theoretical prediction to compare it against.
That's the way science works. But the theoretical prediction from muon G-2 depends on one of the
hardest calculations in all of physical science. You need to calculate the contribution from the
strong nuclear force to exquisite precision. In parallel with the experimental team, the muon G-2
theory initiative published a prediction in 2020 using what's called the data-driven approach,
pulling numbers from electron-positron collision experiments. That prediction disagreed with the
Fermilab measurement by about five sigma. Was this new physics? Or was this a sign of a mistake
either by the theory group or the experimental group? But then, a different theoretical group
calculated the same quantity using what's known as lattice QCD, a brute force computational
technique that simulates quarks and gluons on microscopic scales using huge supercomputers.
Their result was higher, and it agreed with the Fermilab experimental result. No new physics.
So where does this leave us? So the experiment isn't wrong, and it's clear why they won the
breakthrough prize. They're not going to take that away. The question is which of the two theoretical
calculations is right? And right now, we just don't know. This is what science looks like.
This isn't a headline worthy of the phrase,
breaking the standard model, or everything we know about physics is wrong. Everything is fine,
but a measurement so precise that the limiting factor is our ability to calculate what the
theory actually predicts is an astounding accomplishment for physics. Now, the door is
still open to a violation of the standard model, but I've been an experimental physicist for over
25 years, and what I find most exciting about this result is not whether or not the anomaly
is real or not. It could be real, it may not. It's that we've built an experiment that can see the
fingerprints of particles we've never been able to create. The muon, this particle that lives for
a two one millionths of a second, is telling us something about the deepest laws and structure
of space and time itself. But we still need to figure out exactly what it's saying. If you want
to see the full deep dive and precision test of the standard model, I did a tour of a conversation
on my podcast with one of the people who worked on this. The link to that discussion is in the
description. I'm Brian Keating, the Chancellor's Distinguished Professor of Physics at UC San
Diego, and I do not believe in dumbing things down. If that's what you're looking for, deep
dives into physics, make sure you subscribe. I also described a fascinating cousin of this
experiment, which involves measuring neutrinos and their wispy or possible negative mass here.
Click here for that video. And you won't want to miss my conversation with Fermilab YouTube
channel's Don Lincoln. He's hilarious and brilliant and also an experimentalist like me.