Buying a Used Tesla: Advice From a 7-Year Owner

Ex Used Car
15 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis guide offers a comprehensive strategy for purchasing a used Tesla, blending traditional vehicle inspection techniques with EV-specific priorities. It emphasizes battery health verification, the importance of home charging, and the risks of rental history, while clarifying that Tesla's minimal maintenance needs differ from traditional internal combustion engine vehicles.
If you're considering buying a used Tesla, I'm going to guide you through the process that I
would follow based on seven years of owning these cars. We're going to cover what's the
same as buying any other used car, what's different with a Tesla, how to think about
battery health, what to avoid, and a few things that people worry about that they probably don't
need to. I've noticed a lot of my videos are watched by people who are considering buying
a used Tesla and I'm often asked that question of what should I be looking for. So today that's
what I want to go through. I'm not trying to convince you one way or the other, not trying
to sell you anything. I'm just trying to give you the information that I would want if I were in
your shoes. I've been driving Teslas now for seven years. I bought my Model 3 here in 2019 and
obviously still have it, still driving it. And then about a year ago we added the refreshed Model Y.
And what I want to do is give you the kind of advice that I would give a family member
before they made the decision. Now to understand what's different about buying a used Tesla,
I want to first talk about what's the same. Because I don't want to mystify the process.
Most of buying a used Tesla is going to be the same as buying any other used car.
You've decided on what model you want, you figured out your budget, narrowed it down to specific
cars. The car fax report is still going to matter. You're looking for that accident history,
ownership history, especially if it's been in a rental fleet. That would be a big red flag to
me with these cars, even more so than a combustion car. I'll talk about that more in a moment.
And you're still looking at the overall condition of the car, taking it for a test drive,
any strange noises or vibration, warning lights. If you've never driven one, it might take a drive
or two to understand what normal feels like, but still any clunking, thumping, anything that feels
off. The sorts of things that you look for in any other car. You're looking at the exterior,
the interior. I think it's pretty common used car wisdom that if someone didn't take care of what
you can see, there's a good chance that they didn't take care of what you can't see either.
But that might play a little bit smaller role on an EV, and I'll go into that too in a moment.
But up to this point, the process is basically the same as buying any other used car.
So what's different about buying a Tesla? One thing you're going to notice is on that car fax
report, you're not going to see very much service history. You're used to looking for oil changes
and brake jobs and things like that, that kind of basic maintenance. But with the Tesla, there's
just not really all that much to maintain. There's no oil change, no transmission fluid, very little
brake wear, because most of the braking is regenerative. On my Model 3 here, this car has
90,000 miles on it, and I'm on the original brakes, and they still look new. They hardly
ever get used. It's really just one pedal driving with the regenerative braking. Another thing is
that a traditional combustion drivetrain has well over a thousand moving parts, while a Tesla
drivetrain has fewer than 20. Or even figure 40 in a dual motor setup. There's no fuel system,
there's no exhaust system, there's no alternator or starter to fail, there's no belt spark plugs,
there's no emission sensors, so there's just far fewer things that can go bad. So you're not going
to see a long maintenance trail, and that's perfectly normal. What I said earlier, if
somebody didn't take care of what you can see, they probably didn't take care of what you can't.
That still applies, but with a Tesla, I think it matters a little bit less, because there's just
fewer hidden mechanical systems that can get neglected. For instance, you're not going to
have to wonder how often they change the wheel. Battery health. This is what people tend to worry
about the most with these cars, and there's a lot of exaggeration, a lot of clickbait around this
topic. There are two completely different things that people mix together here on the topic of
batteries. The first is a catastrophic battery failure, where the thing just all of a sudden
stops working. And the second is battery degradation, which would be the slow loss of
capacity over time. So I want to talk about those separately. So the first piece of that is the
battery failure, where it just suddenly dies or loses a massive amount of capacity all at once.
Not something that's always predictable. So when it comes to buying one of these used, there's not
a lot you can really research or screen for ahead of time when shopping outside of an alert being
on the screen. But you really just don't see that happening very often in real world ownership,
despite what all of the fear-mongering clickbait out there might insinuate. The batteries are
designed to last a lifetime in the vehicle, or at least hundreds of thousands of miles.
And it's interesting because the battery is probably the thing that people worry about the
most, and yet it's actually one of the most durable parts of the car. And then Tesla backs
these things with an eight-year warranty, 120,000 mile warranty, at least on the premium version,
and the non-premium version I think it's like 100,000 miles. So Tesla itself is pretty confident
that the batteries are going to last. Now I will say that warranties have changed over the years,
so you would have to check into what the warranty is on the car that you're buying.
When you hear stories about full battery replacements, keep in mind that Tesla does
not repair these things at a service center. If there's an issue under warranty, they just replace
the pack and then it gets refurbished later. So when you read something or see something on YouTube
where it sounds like a major failure, it's not always as dramatic as it seems. A big myth buster
here is that people assume you have to replace an entire battery if there's a problem. But these
battery packs are made up of multiple modules and there are independent companies now that
specialize in repairing these things. And they can often replace individual modules or components
if they need to. So there's really, if there's a problem, it can a lot of times be repaired
and it doesn't necessarily mean a full battery replacement. But most owners are never going to
see a battery failure of any kind anyway, or it'll happen so late in the car's life that it'll be
similar to an engine or transmission failure at 350,000 miles or whatever, where at some point you
just have to say, hey, I got my use out of it and it's at the end of its life. Now the second piece
of this is battery degradation. And it's such a big topic that I actually have an entire video
on my channel on how to think about degradation, what to expect, how to measure it. So if you really
want to dig into that, you can watch that video. But the gist of it is this. Number one, the biggest
problem with the conversation around battery degradation is that people don't measure it the
same way. You could have the exact same car and one person says the battery is at 92 percent,
while somebody else says it's at 87, because they just measure it differently. Some people look at
the range estimate on the screen, but that number moves around and really is not a reliable indicator
of battery health. Others use third-party apps, but those calculate things differently and can
give different results. And some people try to measure it by draining the battery and seeing how
much charge goes back in, but that's not something you can realistically do if you're shopping for a
car and it's not a controlled test anyway. So the problem is that all of these methods are
inconsistent. So what can you rely on? The one consistent number we can look at is the battery
health test built into the car. In the service menu, you can go to battery health and run the test
and that will give you a number. Either the number is there or it tells you how to run the test to
get it. If I were buying a used Tesla, I wouldn't buy one without seeing that number. If the test
hasn't been run, the seller can run it and if they don't want to take the time to do that or they make
excuses why they can't do it, I would probably just go and look at another car. Because this
is the one number we can all look at and it's run the same way on each car, so then we can go back
and compare numbers in a scientific way. If somebody says, my battery is still at such and
such percent, you know, 95% of original capacity, let's say, pretty much means nothing to me unless
I knew that they got the number from the test built into the car. Because of all the different
methodologies, they just vary too much and we're not speaking the same language.
Okay, number two, what should I be expecting that number to be? What am I actually looking for?
Well, here's the deal. Short version again. If you want the long version, I have the other video for
that. But these cars have a break-in period in the first 30,000 miles or so where capacity drops
pretty quick as it breaks in and calibrates. But by about 50,000 miles, the battery doesn't really
lose much after that. And my rule of thumb is this, these batteries live their life in the 80s.
They'll reach that 89% mark early on, but a car with 50,000 miles may be at 89% and a car with
250,000 miles may still be above the 80% mark of original capacity. Even if two batteries degrade
a little differently early on, the long-term outcomes converge. Higher 80s early on, lower 80s
later, but generally not moving much past that. And of course, there's always going to be outliers.
The example I've used is the guy who lives on the edge of Death Valley, keeps his car charged 100%,
parks it out in the sun all summer. Those are the reasons that we check the battery health number.
And then the other exception, LFP batteries. Those were used in some of the newer standard
range cars. Different chemistry, different conversation. So if you check that battery
health score in the car, roughly speaking, you might see something around 90% by 30,000 miles.
And by the time it has 100,000 miles on it, I might expect to be like lower 80s. I wouldn't
expect it though to drop much more past that in most cases. And then the one example I had in my
other video that I wanted to share here is, if you've narrowed it down to a couple of cars that
you're interested in, and one has a battery health score that's maybe two to four points higher or
lower, don't put much of your decision into that. Because like I said, these batteries tend to
converge in that mid to low 80s area at some point, even if one does it a little quicker than
another. You might think you're getting a healthier battery comparing those numbers at one point in
time, but the higher scoring car is going to reach that lower number at some point anyway.
And the car with the lower number may very well, may just still kind of be hanging out there where
it was. And realize too that a couple percent may only be about 10 to 12 miles of range anyway,
in real life. And a 100 mile round trip uses only about a third of the battery's capacity when it's
new. So unless you're on a much longer trip, none of this is going to matter much anyway from
practical standpoint. Now another thing people worry about when buying a used Tesla is how quickly
these cars have evolved. They're concerned that something's going to be too outdated.
And I think you can break it into two categories, the car itself and then the computer hardware.
So first the cars themselves. You know Tesla didn't start producing cars in large numbers
until 2018 with the Model 3. And since then they have continuously improved. Tesla has a tendency
to make improvements mid-production, not strictly by model year. You can't always use that model
year alone to understand exactly what improvements a car has. Generally speaking though, newer cars
are going to have more refinement. Things like ride quality, suspension, tuning, noise reduction,
some small interior improvements. And then you have the refreshes on the Model 3 and Y,
which were big improvement periods. But of course the used market prices are going to reflect the
age of the car. Now computer hardware is the second piece of this. First of all, if you don't
care about the full self-driving, the hardware version really doesn't matter all that much.
My 7-year-old Model 3 has hardware 2.5 and outside of full self-driving it behaves really very
similarly to my 2026 Model Y. I still get most of the same updates, car still feels new, everything
works great. Is the screen interface a little sluggish? I hear people say that but I don't
really see it that much. Where the cars really do diverge though is full self-driving. That's where
the hardware really matters. My 2019 Model 3 here has version 2.5 hardware. It will not run any
version of full self-driving. Hardware 3 is, right now anyway, locked into an older version and you
need hardware 4 to run the current version of full self-driving. And with the evolution, as fast as
things are moving, I'm sure the software is going to continue to evolve and the hardware on these
cars is eventually going to restrict you. Not that they would take anything away, but restrict you
from taking advantage of all the latest and greatest FSD stuff that is still yet to come.
I think that's just a logical thought that that's probably what's going to happen. So, bottom line
is, if full self-driving matters to you, make sure you understand what hardware the car has
because the version of software the car is going to be able to run depends on the hardware that's
But if you're just driving, if you're just buying it to drive the car normal and you don't care
about full self-driving, honestly I wouldn't worry about the hardware, the computers or anything like
that at all. And you can validate the hardware version on any of these cars by going to software
under the main menu and scrolling to additional vehicle information and it will show the computer
version as 2.5 or 3.0 or 4.0 or whatever else comes along in the future. Now one thing I alluded to
earlier when we were talking about Carfax reports is rental history, rental car history. I think if
you talk to auto mechanics, this is one of the key things that they're going to tell you, that all
things equal, a car that was used as a rental probably was not taken care of as well as one
that was personally owned. People just don't have the vested interest in it. But rental Teslas are
an even bigger red flag to me. First of all, these things were heavily supercharged as rentals. People
renting a car don't have access to home charging so they're relying on superchargers. And second,
they were often charged to these very high states of charge because the rental car companies wanted
them returned like a gasoline car with a full tank. Charging to 100% regularly and especially
letting the car sit there at a high state of charge in the heat, that's one of the absolute
worst things you can do to the battery. So if the car is frequently fast charged and then left
sitting at a high state of charge, and especially if it's left out in the heat, that's a really
rough life. And the other issue is simply how rental cars are driven. When it's not your car,
people just tend to drive them harder and they care less about how they're treated. And I think
with Teslas being as quick as they are, people take advantage of that. They go out there and
they hot rod around with them. So between more aggressive driving and less care overall, there's
a lot more opportunity for wear and tear. All rental cars have a harder life, but I would say
rental Teslas probably have an even harder life. Another thing I'm asked a lot about is insurance
and repair costs on these cars. So first, the insurance. We all know that insurance varies
drastically from person to person. Your age, your driving history, marital status, where you live,
how much you drive, credit scores get factored in there. There's a lot that gets factored into it.
For me, when I switched from my Infiniti G37 to a Model 3, my insurance stayed pretty similar.
There was a small bump because it was a brand new car, but it wasn't anything that shocked me. It
didn't go up drastically. And when I see averages in the media, I honestly, I just don't relate to
them. I insure both of my Teslas and my van for less than what some of those averages per one car
suggest. So those numbers don't necessarily reflect what you're actually going to pay when
you see those out there in the media. But I have two pieces of advice here. First of all, when
you're comparing insurance costs, you have to compare it to a similar kind of car. The Model
3 is generally considered a compact luxury sedan, comparable to things like a BMW 3 Series or an
Audi A4, Mercedes C-Class. It is not in the same category as something like a Toyota Corolla.
If you compare it to a Toyota Corolla, it's going to look expensive because you're comparing two
completely different classes of vehicles. The second piece of advice that I have is that there's
really no need to guess on insurance. Instead of relying on articles or comments, just call your
insurance agent and get a quote. Just give them a VIN number and ask, what would it cost me to
insure this car? They can get you a very accurate answer very, very quickly. And honestly, that's
going to be the fastest way to figure out what it's actually going to cost you. If you're curious,
just call them. Now on repair costs, I really haven't had much done to my car. On my Model 3,
I had a 12-volt battery replaced for about $114. Tesla actually came out and changed it in five
minutes in my driveway. There was a recall on a wiring harness in the trunk that they needed to
fix. I changed the cabin air filter, put tires on it once, and I added windshield washer fluid to it.
And that's basically it. So I'm really not the best example of major repair costs, just because
I haven't had any. And I think that that really goes back to the mechanical simplicity of these
cars. There's just so far fewer things that can go wrong. But like insurance, there's lots of
shocking headlines out there and clickbait that are going to try to shape your thinking for you,
so watch out. Another thing I want to talk about here is home charging, because one of the biggest
day-to-day advantages of having an EV is being able to charge it at home. You come home, you plug it
in, and you walk away. You don't have to think about it anymore. You're not watching a fuel gauge.
You're not wondering when you're going to need to fill up next. You're never leaving the house with
a quarter tank or just barely in the red. You leave every morning with a full charge. And unless
you're going on a trip, call it, you know, 250, 300 miles or more, you just don't have to think about it.
So all of that time that you used to spend thinking about fuel levels and actually going to
the gas station, all of that's just gone. But it only works if you can charge at home. So I recommend
a level 2 charger. That would be something in the 32 to 48 amp range on 240 volts.
Level 1 charging, which would just be plugging it into a standard 120 outlet,
that's so slow, and it's really electrically very inefficient. It works, but I think most people
would get tired of it pretty quickly. And relying entirely on supercharging, same thing. You're going
to get tired of making that extra trip. So if you don't have a good home charging setup, that would
be probably my biggest hesitation in recommending one of these cars. You might be able to make it
work, but you're going to give up what, in my opinion, is the biggest day-to-day advantage of
having an EV. And so to answer the question directly, would I buy a used Tesla? Yeah, I absolutely
would under the right circumstances. If the battery health is in the normal range, the hardware
matches what I want, if it hasn't lived a hard rental car life, and if my charging situation
makes sense, then yeah, I would definitely consider it. And I'll leave you with this. The best
Tesla advice that I can give you, I say it all the time, avoid the clickbait. There's a lot of
shock-driven, outrage-based content out there about these cars. If it has a shocking headline, it would
have written that way on purpose, so don't let it shape your thinking. If I listened to every negative
thing I heard about Teslas before I bought one, I never would have, and I would have really missed
out. So do your research, look at the averages and not the outliers, make your decision based on
facts and not fear, and I'd be really interested to hear your thoughts on it in the comments, and
I'll see you down the road.
