Why Emma Stone Won Her First Oscar

Emma Stone
7 followers
Why did Emma Stone win the Best Actress Oscar for La La Land over Isabella Huppert, Natalie Portman, Ruth Negga, and Meryl Streep? In this video, Cody Dericks joins me to break down the main reasons why Stone was victorious at the 89th Academy Awards
#film #entertainment #EmmaStone #actress
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedBrian and Cody Derricks analyze the 2016 Best Actress Oscar race, examining the tension between subtle acting and \"flashy\" roles. They discuss the technical mastery of Natalie Portman and the prestige of Isabelle Huppert, ultimately detailing why Emma Stone's momentum and the emotional core of *La La Land* made her victory inevitable.
Hey, it's Brian. Welcome to The Awards Contender. We are talking Emma Stone's Best Actress Oscar
win for La La Land today, and I'm very excited to welcome Cody Derricks back to the channel
to talk about this very fun race. How are we doing, Cody?
Doing well. I was talking with you about this beforehand, but I'm excited to talk about a race
that is not from the 1930s, but is also not from two months ago. Like, I'm excited to discuss
something that I remember. I was there on the ground. I was there on Twitter, but we've had
some remove and some time to think about it in process, so I feel like I have a really good
firsthand eyewitness account to this specific race.
Before we get to the nominees, Cody, let's talk about some big snubs. I just made a whole video
about Amy Adams' snub for Arrival. She had everything she needed, and she still missed,
and the movie overperforms. It gets in the picture and director, and Amy Adams is an
Academy darling. They nominate her for close to a decade at that point for all of her great work.
What is your take on the Amy Adams snub?
I think it was a case of, well, obviously Amy's going to get in, so I'm going to throw my vote
behind Ruth Naga, who probably needs the help. I'm going to throw my vote behind Meryl Streep
because I loved her speech at the Golden Globes, and I love Meryl. I'm going to throw my support
behind Isabel Huppert because she may not get in. I was really taken by that movie, and it's finally
a chance to recognize this great international actress. I think Natalie and Emma were always
getting in regardless, but I think a lot of people just let Amy go. Then, of course, there's
the factor of it's a pretty understated performance. It is not very emotionally volatile.
Finding an Oscar clip might be difficult. These are things that I don't consider marks of a great
or poor performance, but Academy voters certainly do.
But she gets in everywhere, Cody, from the Globes to BAFTA. She's nominated everywhere.
That's the piece of it. It's not like they gave a rival three technical nominations.
Then I'd be like, well, that makes sense. They didn't go for the movie.
But because the movie's in picture and she gets in everywhere beforehand, that's the piece of it.
Most of us are like, she was right there. Four, as we're going to talk about, four of the best
actress nominees this year are not in Best Picture nominees. That's kind of interesting.
There's also Annette Bening, 20th Century Women. I just watched that film again last night. Such
a lovely movie, and she is fantastic in that. What happened there?
She's amazing. She's amazing. I, at the time, wasn't really super fond of that movie. I was
like, oh yeah, it's well-written and it's clever. Re-watching it, man, she is
unbelievable in that performance. Probably my favorite leading actress performance of this year.
Wow.
And my favorite performance of hers by far. I'm a little divisive on her generally,
but I think she's just phenomenal in this movie. Just really exceptional.
I think the problem with the movie is that it's an ensemble piece. Maybe because she gets kind
of lost in the ensemble of so many characters, it was going to be difficult. It's also a kind
of a subtle performance. I think those were the main two. You could say were snubs or the big
omissions. I would also throw in Taraji P. Henson, Hidden Figures. I mean, she gives a great
performance in that movie. Wasn't much of a factor. She is a part of the ensemble at SAG,
who win Best Cast. She gives the speech there, but she's not even nominated an actress at Golden
Globes and she's got that incredible scene where she goes off on Kevin Costner's character
and she is the lead of that film, you know, wins SAG Ensemble. It's in Best Picture.
I think because she didn't really get any nominations leading up to it by herself.
She's like probably number eight at best, but I mean, she had to get some votes.
I would love to see the number six to 10, like the votes for actress 2016, like who was in six,
probably Amy. Benning is maybe seventh, but maybe she's eighth or ninth. I don't know.
So let's get to the five nominees, Cody. We are going to talk about these nominees in order of
their chances of winning. So I think all of you will know who we are starting with.
Let's begin with Meryl Streep, Florence Foster Jenkins.
This is my favorite place in the whole world. And I'm going to sing here.
So in Florence Foster Jenkins, also starring Hugh Grant, Streep plays a wealthy New York
socialite who pursues her dreams of being an opera singer. This is a real life story.
She's a real life figure. The movie is very flawed,
unforgettable. I had not seen this in a decade. I know how you feel about it.
But here's the thing. You know, I was watching this movie around the time I was making my Amy
Adams snubs video, and I was like, OK, Florence Foster Jenkins is going to be awful. Streep is
going to be very just meh in it. The movie has its issues. Streep is bringing it in the film.
I think it's a big and flashy performance. She's got a physical transformation. She's like heavier
the way she carries herself. And it's not easy, I think, to sing that terrible, considering how
great of a singer Streep is in one scene after another and show confidence to show she's trying.
We have her dying at the end. It's a big performance. And I'm like, oh, this was catnip
for older Academy members. I mean, it kind of makes sense to me now rewatching the films.
Why Streep got it? I find this movie to be evil.
I think there is a dark, insidious energy to this movie's existence.
I think the way it kind of says if you're rich and want to live in a delusional fairyland where
you can perform at Carnegie Hall, you are able to do so. And all that matters is that you're happy.
And the way it talks about critics in the movie, I find deeply unsettling.
I don't like the idea that rich people can just buy their way into talent. And you see this problem
domino effecting to the present day where so many people who are famous now are given the
time and ability to work on their craft because they come from rich family. I'm not saying people
can't be rich and talented, but there's too many people who are rich and not talented but famous
nowadays. I find this movie to be reprehensible in the way that it looks at that as a virtue
because she just wanted to sing. That being said, Meryl's pretty good.
Meryl's pretty good in this movie.
I think my problem with this nomination for Streep is that even though she's doing good work,
it's really tough to listen to a woman sing terribly in scene after scene. It's kind of
fun and comedic at first, but there's a good three or four big scenes where she's singing
and people are snickering in the audience. I can recognize the good acting she's doing,
but it's not the most enjoyable movie.
There's a few reasons why this nomination doesn't sit super well with me. One,
I do think it is kind of a default. It's Meryl type of nomination, which she has,
I would say almost half of her nominations. You could probably count in that department.
I think if this was played by just some actress in her of that age, like name a name.
And also even at the time, everybody was pretty aware that a good reason she got in
or a big reason she got in is that she gave the Firebrand speech when she won her Cecil B. DeMille
Lifetime Achievement Award, which was just not long after Carrie Fisher's funeral,
which she was good friends with her. And she talked about Trump in the speech, but did not
name him by name. So really it was kind of a, if you know, you know, type situation. And it's an
excellent speech. It has nothing to do with her performance, but it did feel like people were
voting for her performance in Best Actress factoring in her nonfiction speech she gave
at the Golden Globes. I had forgotten like street for this movie. She's also in a SAG
and a BAFTA. She was strong. It's not like this nomination at the Oscars came out of nowhere.
I do have to say the one thing I really like about this nomination for Meryl Streep
is that moment at the beginning of the ceremony where Jimmy Kimmel, you know, kind of tongue in
cheek talks about how overrated she is and stuff. And then the whole audience gives her a standing
ovation. I like that part. All right, next up is Ruth Nega, Loving. I think it's all right.
We may lose a small battles, but win the big war. In Loving, also starring Joel Edgerton,
Nega plays Mildred Loving, who was arrested in 1958, Virginia, for being in an interracial
marriage. The case eventually led to the 1967 Supreme Court decision, Loving versus Virginia.
Jeff Nichols directed this film. It premiered at the Cannes Film Festival in 2016. It goes on to
have a pretty good run. And, you know, Golden Globes, Critics Choice, it's in the mix there,
an actor, an actress. On Oscar nominations morning, Loving gets one Oscar nomination,
Best Actress for Ruth Nega. What do we think about this performance?
I think she's pretty incredible in this film. It is a movie that is predicated around the idea that
this couple, who is so huge and looms so large in American history and civil rights history,
and they were not interested in being at the center of anything publicly reckoned with,
as this case obviously was. They just wanted to live their life. They just wanted to live
quietly in their home, at least as portrayed in the film. And to that degree, Ruth Nega's
performance is perfection. She is underplayed, but not anonymous. She feels fully invested into
the character. The emotional high point of the film and her character's journey in general comes
at the very end when she gets the phone call telling her, we don't even hear the audio on
the other side, that the case was settled in their favor. And you just watch her reaction,
and it's totally captivating without being over the top. There's also the fact that she's doing
a perfect accent. Ruth Nega's voice does not sound like that in real life. Yeah, this is a
lovely performance. I was definitely surprised when she got in. This, to me, was the
most surprising of the five nominations on nomination morning. Yeah, I was rooting for
this one. I loved this film. I thought her performance was beautiful, subtle. She often
is acting with her eyes, with her expressions, where she's not saying anything. That haunting
shot of her sitting in the jail cell, that sticks with you. She's not talking. She's not crying.
You feel what she's feeling in that moment. I love her chemistry with Joel Edgerton,
the way she is determined to make this right without having to scream and shout and be on
the phones and stomping into courthouses and stuff. It's just a really great performance
that I was like, it's too subtle. She only gets in at Critics' Choice and Golden Globes,
and in a very crowded field. I think most of us thought she was going to miss.
For Nega to get in over Amy Adams, that's quite something that enough people voted for this film,
for her performance, when it is so subtle, when it's not in Picture Director, it's not in one
technical category. This is kind of an inspired Oscar nomination that year for Best Actress.
Inspired is the word. It's the kind of really exciting, I can't believe the Academy actually
did it. They made the right choice here. To your point, her nomination does kick Amy Adams out. I
do think she's fifth place of the nominees here in terms of likelihood. She was on the least
predictions. I can say that with certainty. I was there. I was not predicting her.
You could argue she's in fifth place, like Nega was never going to win this.
I would put her above Streep though, because it is a more exciting nomination. It's her
nomination, a younger actress who many of us are discovering around that time.
But the Academy, they didn't care for the movie. It's not in any other category. As I said, it's
her first nomination. It's a very competitive category. You can't really put her above fourth
place. Now we have Natalie Portman, Jackie. Inform them that I will work with Jack tomorrow,
alone if necessary. So in this film, Natalie Portman plays former First Lady Jackie Kennedy
navigating the chaotic days following the tragic death of her husband, JFK.
We have moments where she's being interviewed. We see her in the motorcade. We see her during
the assassination. And the movie bounces around back and forth to all kinds of things happening
during mostly that week or two. And this, Cody, is my favorite performance in the category.
I think Portman is extraordinary in this movie. It is a total acting masterclass.
She's the whole thing. I don't think there's a scene she's not in. She's in the whole movie.
It's a very big performance with crying, with frustration, with terror, long monologues,
a physical transformation, a different voice. And I think she nails everything in this movie.
She had just won an Oscar for Black Swan six years prior. Well, not just. I mean,
it had been a few years. But I think this would have made a really great second win for Portman.
Yeah, she's excellent in this film. And it's really exciting to see her do a performance
like this. Totally transformative, to your point. The impersonation is pretty spot on.
While the movie is not a typical biopic, even though she's giving what kind of feels like a
performance in like the standardized, like we grade this on a rubric type way. But the movie
itself is not typical. It is non-linear. It takes place like kind of in her perspective
mentally rather than like, again, linearly. At the time, this was the performance that people,
you know, gay guys on Twitter most wanted to win. This was definitely the fan favorite.
The, you know, that she's not going to win, but she should.
There were still people holding out hope, like way up till Oscar night for some reason.
She was the critics choice, so she wasn't a non-contender. But yeah, I think like
second place at best, but I don't disagree with your third place placement.
Yeah, third place makes sense. I guess you could even argue second. She does win critics choice
best actress. It feels crazy to get rewarded for something that in itself was a rewarding experience.
But that's not enough to win an Oscar. Just critics choice, like ask Paul Giamatti,
the holdovers. He even won Golden Globe comedy musical. He won two. Just critics choice. It
wasn't going to make a difference, but it is kind of fun to see that clip of her winning a
critics choice. It's on YouTube. She's pregnant again. She's always pregnant, Cody, when she's
winning stuff. Uh-huh. It's a good luck charm. And it's like the only time that whole season
Emma Stone is doing this from her seat. Emma Stone wins basically everything else.
And Portman is nominated everywhere. Like she's there at SAG. She's at BAFTA. She's at Golden
Globes. If the awards voters had loved the movie more, if Jackie's in picture, maybe not director,
but it's in picture, it has like five or six nominations, not just three. She could have been
more competitive. I just, I think there wasn't a lot of love for the film itself. And that hurt
Portman in the long run. This nomination had to happen when she lost at SAG, when she's not even
there at the Oscars. I'm like, I don't think she's going to win, but it would have been a worthy
victory for Portman. Now we get to Isabelle Huppert L.
So in this film from director Paul Verhoeven, Huppert plays Michelle, a powerful executive who
is sexually assaulted and then takes it upon herself to track down the man and reveal his
identity. This is a very captivating performance. Also a premiere at Cannes, like loving. Huppert
had been doing incredible work for decades. This was the first performance I was like, okay, this
one might actually get her in at the Oscars. She is sad. She is weird. She's funny. She's
unpredictable. She never plays a victim. She is assured and confident, so full of complexity.
This is our longest film we're talking about today. It's about two hours and 20 minutes. She
is all over this thing. It's definitely one of her finest performances. I am so happy she got
in at the Oscars. To your point, confidence is the word that comes to mind with this performance. It
is such a fully developed character that has no moment of wavering from the truth of her personality
to the point where it almost feels like she's not playing anybody. Like this must just be what
Isabelle Huppert is like. It's so just true. It's a weird performance, but not in the way you
think. Not in a weird performance like Anne-Margaret and Tommy. This is weird in its own way
because she never quite behaves the way you expect her to. She makes so many unexpected decisions,
but none of them are flighty. Even though they're unexpected in the decision-making,
the fact that she made the decision is not unexpected because of what her character is.
I think it's pretty phenomenal work. To your point, it's like finally she gets nominated and
it's good that she is an Oscar nominee in her career. Based on the types of movies she makes,
this is very likely, I think, probably going to be her one-and-done nomination.
But still, she's an Oscar nominee. Yeah. I mean, most every year we get an older veteran
who maybe hasn't even been nominated before. Like Charlotte Rampling gets in for 45 years
a year prior. I like when the Academy does that, especially when it's for a performance that's
maybe not winning everything or getting nominated everywhere. Looking back, I mean, I did have some
problems with the film overall. It's a hard watch. It has its lulls. It's not my favorite
movie we're talking about today. This could have been a film, a performance. The Academy
could have just said, no, we don't have to nominate it for anything. That she got in,
I think, is really exciting. Like she needed to get in for this. And she won the Golden Globe
Award for Best Actress in a Motion Picture Drama. That was a moment. I think I was predicting Natalie
Portman or maybe Amy Adams. When Huppert won that, I went, oh, we have a race. That's a really cool
win. Thank you for making me win in a French film directed by a Dutch director here in America.
Oh, my God. Thank you. Even though on the nights I wasn't really thinking Huppert would win over
Stone, I would still put Huppert in second because she was older, had a richer backlog of movies and
films that people loved. And it was her first nomination, had never won. I think it would have
been Huppert and not Portman. It is tough, though, because her movie does not even get nominated for
what was at the time for a language film. And it was contending. It was a potential nominee.
But the movie is really unfriendly on purpose. That's the point. But I can see a lot of voters
going, no way. But I think Isabelle Huppert's performance and just her as a name, if nothing
else, was able to kind of leapfrog the hesitations that voters might have for even touching this film.
So, like, if it wasn't Stone, Huppert would have been a moment, I think, because the movie's not
even in foreign language film. Like, it's not even in that. It was going to be tough for her to win
being the lone nominee. But this is a really great Oscar nomination for the amazing Isabelle Huppert.
And finally, that brings us to the winner of Best Actress 2016 at the Oscars, Emma Stone,
La La Land. And I can find something else that I'm supposed to do because I left to do that.
And it's been six years and I don't want to do it anymore. In La La Land, directed by Damian
Chazelle, Stone plays Mia, an aspiring actress struggling to grow her career. She falls in love
with a jazz pianist, Sebastian, played by Ryan Gosling. And the movie shows her her ups and downs
in the industry and it allows Emma Stone to play everything. Wow. I mean, talk about an acting
showcase. This is a performance, Cody, filled with so many pleasures, moments of drama, moments of
comedy. She sings, she dances. She's full of wits and charm. This role fits Emma Stone perfectly
and she knocks it out of the park. I think both the performance itself, the type of character
she's playing and what she's asked to do and where she was in her career, she was kind of
guaranteed to win this Oscar. It is like a tailor made with a bow Best Actress nomination. Go voters,
give her the Oscar. And they did. I remember even when it was a bit more of a contest with Natalie
Portman in the mix, Isabelle Huppert wins the globe. To me, it did not even feel like there
was any question that this was going to be anybody but Emma Stone. To your point, she has everything
in this movie. She's playing an actress. She's playing an actress who is struggling at first
and then succeeds. So she's either somebody that actors want to be, or they can relate to her
journey because they once were there. It's just like so many factors in this performance, let
alone the movie is so fricking strong. Otherwise it's just perfect for Oscar voters to give the
award to. And to me, it was no surprise. She was on her second nomination at this point.
She was still young, but experienced that kind of catch 22 that Oscar voters love for their actress
winners. Yeah. This was such an easy, easy call to make. And to me, a pretty dynamic win. I still
love this performance. I love this movie. I think I think I prefer it to her poor, poor things
performance ever so slightly. I didn't think that'd be controversial. Oh man. Yeah. What
an all timer. She's she's good. It's fun performance. All right. So let's talk about
the five main reasons Emma Stone won the Oscar for best actress. Reason number one,
it's one of the year's most beloved films, I think, especially compared to the other four
films that are nominated in best actress. You know, there's no contest. La La Land,
14 Oscar nominations. If not winning best picture, it's in second place. It's right up there.
You know, that was a massive haul, a then record, you know, shared at the time, at least
with all about Eve and Titanic. It wins picture almost everywhere. She's the only nominee whose
co-star is nominated. Ryan Gosling is in best actor. None of the other four nominees and actress
have a co-star nominated even in the supporting category. So because people loved this movie,
especially more than the other four in actress, I think that's the number one reason.
Yeah, it was just the movie of the season. And like, yeah, there was backlash.
It got there when it swept the Golden Globe seven for seven. I think it's still the most
wins of all time or at least has a clean record and it gets the most nominations of all time.
And there was the backlash built, but I know the backlash didn't touch Emma Stone.
Yeah. The only thing I thought might hurt her was her age. She's what, like 27, 28.
But in best actress at the Oscars, they tend to not care. It's hard to win in best actor when
you're under 30, but under 30 for actress like Jennifer Lawrence, Silver Linings Playbook,
it doesn't really matter if they love the film and the performance. That's not going to be
something that prevents you from winning an actress. Reason number two is that Emma Stone
mostly swept the season. She doesn't win critics choice that goes to Natalie Portman for Jackie,
but Stone wins the Golden Globe for best actress in a comedy or musical.
She wins SAG. She wins BAFTA. That is a lethal combination for a beloved movie that's in best
picture might win. Like reason number one, reason number two, you could just end it there.
Those two reasons she was winning 100 percent.
To be an actor, playing an actor and receiving an actor by a guild of actors.
It's pretty exceptional.
Winning the SAG wasn't a surprise. The fact that she also won BAFTA,
it's just undeniable. If she's winning the Brits over, she's winning the Oscar.
Reason number three, her career had been exploding for about a decade after Superbad 2007.
She's very much acclaimed for her performance in Easy A 2010. She's great in Crazy Stupid Love.
She's in the two Spider-Man films with Andrew Garfield. Not the greatest movies,
but her stature in Hollywood is on the rise. And then especially her performance in Birdman,
for which she gets her first Oscar nomination and best supporting actress.
I do think it helps to have one prior nomination.
You know, like if Stone had been on her first nomination for La La Land,
she probably still wins anyway. But having a previous nomination for Birdman, that helped her
too. Reason number four is that Stone had the most appealing showy role in the category.
It's not the only showy role. You have Streep and Florence Foster Jenkins.
You have Natalie Portman and Jackie. Those are also showy performances. But I think the
most appealing one is what Stone is bringing in La La Land. It's not a physical transformation,
but because she gets so much to play in drama, comedy, musical, it's just a giant whirlwind
performance that was like, especially because of its appealing nature,
also was going to get her to a win. I would say the fifth and final big reason Emma Stone won the
Oscar for La La Land is that final audition scene. That is the scene where she pops more than
anything else. If she didn't have that scene, she might still win. But that was the scene that sealed
the deal. What also helps is that it immediately follows what's undoubtedly her most dramatic parts
of the movie, which is the fight she has with Ryan Gosling's character into her failed one-woman show,
into the scene where she's talking to Ryan Gosling and saying, maybe I'm not good enough,
maybe I don't want to embarrass myself anymore, that will kill me. And then it goes right into
the audition. So it's kind of a perfect rollercoaster ratcheting up the hill until you
get the drop of the audition. And same as before, the audition is one big long take. It is just her.
But yeah, as I talked about in the Best Actor video, Ryan Gosling does not have that scene
in the movie. He doesn't have a solo scene quite like her audition scene at the end of the movie,
like Gosling at that pier and he dances with that woman and it's a lovely moment,
but he doesn't have that scene in the film the way Stone does.
No, this ultimately becomes more her story than his. They're definitely co-leads and they have
their own stories that get their happy endings, but she gets the moment. She gets the moment.
Yeah. So because of those main five reasons, Emma Stone won her first Academy Award for Best Actress.
And this guy is a really beautiful symbol to continue on that journey and I am so grateful
for that. So thanks so much for being here, Cody, talking about Best Actress 2016. Is there anything
else you want to mention, talk about this race that we didn't cover? Like I said, I think time
heals all wounds. And after experiencing this race firsthand in all its craziness, in all of its
controversies, earned and unearned, justified and unjustified, I think looking back, we can say
that the way the awards ultimately went, kind of the best case scenario for all people involved.
Emma Stone gets her first Oscar for great performance. Moonlight gets to win Best Picture.
Everybody's happy. Now we just have two great films that we can appreciate. And for purposes of
this video, a great performance that was, you know, the start of a fruitful Oscar journey,
because now she's kind of become like the modern day Meryl Streep where she gets nominated every
time she performs. Yeah. I mean, her performance in Bugonia is fantastic. I adore her performance
and her win, of course, for Poor Things. But I never want to come on here and say, well,
like her Poor Things win is an old timer. That first one for La La Land, it's fine. It's okay.
No, this is a fantastic win. I was so excited to talk about it with you today, Cody.
If you can tell our viewers where they can find you online, now would be the time.
You can find my writing and podcasting at Next Best Picture and Awards Watch,
and I'm on every social media platform at CodyMonster91.
All right. Thanks again, Cody. And I will see you next time at the Awards Contender.
