Think getting a written Out-the-Door price is the finish line? Think again. In my previous video, I showed you how to get dealerships to give you a written Out-the-Door (OTD) quote without stepping foot inside the dealership. Now it's time to use that quote to your advantage.
In this video, I walk you through the exact strategy I use to analyze a dealership's offer, determine a realistic target price, build a professional counteroffer, and negotiate like someone who's done hundreds of deals.
You'll learn: ✅ Why you should NEVER negotiate the Out-the-Door number first ✅ How to work backward from the selling price ✅ Why professional negotiators rarely ask for the number they actually want ✅ How to make a counteroffer dealers will take seriously ✅ Why leaving negotiating room often saves thousands ✅ What to say when a dealer claims you're "not even in the ballpark"
This is the same negotiation strategy we teach our Homework Guy Car Buying Service clients across the United States and Canada.
If you haven't watched Part 1 yet ("STOP Asking for an Out-the-Door Price... DO THIS Instead!"), go watch it first. The strategy in this video builds directly on that one.
🚗 WANT A PROFESSIONAL TO NEGOTIATE YOUR NEXT VEHICLE?
Our Homework Guy Car Buying Service negotiates directly with dealerships on your behalf so you don't have to.
✔ Written Out-the-Door pricing ✔ Professional negotiations ✔ Dealer comparisons ✔ Trade-in guidance ✔ Financing review ✔ Nationwide service
Stop negotiating alone.
If you enjoyed this video, please LIKE, SUBSCRIBE, and leave a comment telling me what vehicle you're shopping for. I read as many comments as I can!
— Kevin Hunter The Homework Guy America's Consumer Watchdog for Car Buyers
👉 Learn more at thehomeworkguy.com 👉 Homework Guy Car Buying Service available
Do you happen to be on Facebook? If so, would you do us a big favor? Go to our facebook page and click on "Follow." We would greatly appreciate it! https://www.facebook.com/thehomeworkguy/followers
This guide explains how to strategically negotiate a vehicle purchase once you have received a written out-the-door (OTD) price. Instead of reacting emotionally to the final total, the author advocates for a professional, data-driven approach that involves rebuilding the price from the ground up and leaving room for counter-offers to secure the best possible deal.
How to turn a written out-the-door price into a winning negotiation.
In my last video, I showed you how to get the dealership to give you a written out-the-door
price by leading the conversation. If you missed it, go back and see it. That's a must,
or you'll never get your hands on the information I'm about to help you analyze next.
If you haven't watched that previous video yet, it's titled,
Stop Asking for Out-the-Door Price, Do This Instead.
Stop this video, go watch it first, because today's strategy
doesn't work without you following those directions first.
Once you've got that written out-the-door quote, now the real negotiation action begins.
Today, I'm going to show you exactly how I analyze that offer,
how I decide what number to counter with, and why I almost never counter with the price
I actually want, and how even one simple back and forth can save you thousands of dollars.
Well, let's jump in.
Why I don't respond immediately
The first thing I do, actually, is absolutely nothing, but not forever,
for the amount of time I told the salesperson I needed. If I told them,
I'll review everything tonight and get back to you tomorrow morning, that's exactly what I do.
Keeping your word matters. Most dealerships deal with buyers who are fickle and disappear.
They change their minds or never respond at all. When you consistently do exactly what you said
you would do, you immediately separate yourself from the average customer. They know you're
different and they treat you differently. Professional people like working with other
professional people. Don't negotiate the out-the-door number first.
Now, I start analyzing the offer. Let's use an example. Suppose the dealership sends me
this vehicle's selling price, $64,595, and then, after taxes, dealer fees, title, license,
everything, the out-the-door price comes to $69,400. Most buyers immediately look at that
$69,400 number and start throwing out random offers. That's not what I do,
and that's not what our coaches do. Never. I work backwards, and so do my coaches,
because if the selling price isn't right, nothing else is going to be right.
Step one, fix the selling price. The dealer selling price was $64,595.
Now, let's say the homework target price is $62,525. The first question I ask myself is,
what do I honestly believe this vehicle should sell for? Based on market conditions,
plenty of research, inventory, current incentives, competing dealers, and everything else I know,
let's say that I believe the fair selling price is $62,525. So, I adjust that $64,595 number
down first. Everything else gets rebuilt from there.
Step two, add back the required cost. Selling price of $62,525. Now, I add back the legitimate
cost. Sales tax of $3,750. Title and license fees, $500. The new out-the-door price is $66,775.
The government fees aren't negotiation items. They're simply part of buying a vehicle. When
I add everything back together, my revised out-the-door price becomes $66,775. Now,
here's where the strategy starts. Step three, don't ask for what you really want. The real
goal is to buy this truck for about $66,500 out the door. Do I offer $66,500? Absolutely not,
because then there's nowhere left to negotiate. Instead, I intentionally go lower, usually by
around $1,000 on a deal this size. That means my written counter offer becomes $66,775 out the
door. Notice something. I'm not making a ridiculous offer. I'm making a serious offer, one that tells
the dealership I'm ready to buy, but I'm expecting you to negotiate. Now, here's why this works.
Over the years, I've learned something. Being about $1,000 apart on a $65,000 to $70,000 vehicle
isn't that much. It's close enough that most dealerships will keep talking. But if I throw
something ridiculous like $64,000 out the door, I'm way too low. There's a good chance they won't
even bother responding. The goal isn't to shock them. The goal is to push back, but to keep them
engaged. So here's what I'm actually hoping for. The dealership comes back and says, we can't do
$65,775, but we can do $66,500. That's perfect. That's where I wanted to be all along. One back
and forth, and I just reduced the deal by roughly $2,900. That's strategic negotiating, not emotional
negotiating. If I have other comparable out the door prices from other dealers, and you always
should, you might not be done here. If you have a significantly lower OTD from another outside the
area dealer you negotiated with, here's where you say to the local dealer, match this offer, or I
will take a trip and purchase the other car. Never counter with your final number. This is one of the
mistakes buyers make. They counter with the exact number they want. Never do that. Always leave
yourself some negotiating room. If you don't, you've already used up your last move before the
negotiation even starts. Well, Kevin, what if they say you aren't even in the ballpark? Sometimes
you'll get this response. You aren't even in the ballpark. Great. Now make them help you. Simply
respond. Then tell me where your ballpark is. They give you a number, and you say, I'll think about
it, and I'll get back to you. Notice what just happened. Instead of arguing, you paused and
gathered information. If their ballpark is still ridiculously high, you probably don't have the
possibility of a deal. It could be time to move on to another dealer. But if it's reasonably close,
counter again, because I can promise you something. The first number they throw back at
you will never be their best number. Never. There is almost always another move left for you.
The big picture. Notice something. None of this happened inside the dealership. No pressure. No
manager walking over. Nobody breathing down my neck. No waiting three hours. No sitting in a
finance office because everything happened because you controlled the negotiation on the phone from
the comfort of home. You got the written out the door price first. Then you analyzed it. You rebuilt
the numbers. You made a strategic counter offer, and you negotiated from a position of strength.
That's exactly how professionals negotiate. If you skipped my previous video, go back and watch
it because that's where this entire strategy starts. You cannot negotiate effectively until
you've gotten that written out the door price, and you'll only get it by controlling the conversation
up front. Get that conversation well rehearsed and down to a science, and you'll get somewhere.
Once you've done that, use the negotiation process I showed you today, and you'll negotiate like
someone who's done this hundreds of times. If this video helped you, give it a thumbs up.
Subscribe if you haven't already, and leave a comment and tell me what vehicle you're negotiating
right now. As always, I'm Kevin Hunter, the Homework Guy, America's consumer watchdog for
car buyers. I'll see you on the next video, and I'll get some fly swatted.
Hi, Kevin Hunter here. Now listen, some of you actually enjoy the dealer process. Some of you
enjoy navigating all the dealer stuff we teach our audience about. If you're a do-it-yourselfer,
we have plenty of free tools for you, and that's always been totally cool with us.
But some of you others definitely don't like it at all. In fact, you hate going through the dealer
sales process. If you'd rather not manage this process alone, our car coaching team handles new
and used car deals nationwide for our viewers. New vehicles, used vehicles, leases, factory orders,
and trade-ins. We get you written out-the-door prices for everything. We do all the negotiations
so you don't have to battle dealers by yourself. There's always documentation oversight,
and you do have a quarterback to consult with when you go into finance, because we never
leave anyone on their own. Either your coach stands by for you, or I do. Bottom line, we do
all the work so you don't have to. And honestly, most people who use the service tell us the same
thing. They wish they had done it sooner. And yes, the intake call for the service is done directly by
yours truly, me. If that sounds like the kind of car buying you'd prefer, consider using our
hassle-free car buying service. Just find the big red button on the homepage at thehomeworkguy.com
and read all about it. All right, let's get back to the show.