What is the best AR-15 barrel length—and are ultra-short 5.56 rifles actually useless?
James visits the FBI’s Ballistic Research Facility to speak with veteran FBI ballistician Robert about AR-15 barrel length, projectile weight, velocity, twist rate, fragmentation, expansion, and terminal performance.
Robert explains why muzzle energy alone tells you very little, why the FBI prefers expanding projectiles over traditional fragmenting ammunition, and how every bullet has an optimal performance window. Depending on the ammunition and intended distance, a longer barrel can even drive a projectile too fast and produce worse terminal performance at close range.
We also get direct answers on the practical differences between 7.5-, 11.5-, 14.5-, 16-, 18-, and 20-inch AR-15 barrels. For law enforcement and home defense, Robert identifies an 11.5-inch barrel with a 1:7 twist and a properly selected 64- to 75-grain bonded projectile as the practical sweet spot. He also explains why 7.5-inch 5.56 rifles are not necessarily worthless—provided their ammunition and engagement distance are properly matched.
This is not internet theory. It is a detailed discussion of actual projectile testing, terminal-ballistics standards, and the variables that determine whether a 5.56 round performs as designed.
Video Summary
AI Generated
James Reeves interviews an FBI ballistics expert to analyze the science of .223/5.56 projectiles. The discussion focuses on the \"optimal performance window\" of velocity, the importance of projectile design over raw energy metrics, and how barrel length should be selected based on specific engagement ranges and mission requirements to ensure consistent terminal performance.
Everyone James Reeves TFB TV. It is my honor. It is my
privilege to be here with Robert from the Ballistic
Research Facility of the FBI. This is one of the coolest
things I've ever gotten to do in my life beats the ---- out of
Disney when I was nine years old, being here with you guys
and getting to talk to you about guns, and more importantly,
projectiles in the science, the ballistic science right that you
guys do here at the BRF. So Robert, first if you would tell
us about yourself and tell us about the BRF. Sure. So I am one
of the ballisticians here at the BRF. I've been in the bureau
into my 15th year, 13 of those years with the ballistic
research facility. But our main goal, our main workhorse here
day in day out is projectile.
Just really fast moving small chunks of metals that you guys
do here. There is a raging internet debate, which we would
love to squash out today. And that is AR 15 barrel length,
and projectile. So there are a lot of opinions about like, say
20 inch AR 15. That being that's Eugene Stone's original
design, that's what it should be anything less, you're ruining
it. You need fragmentation out of 556 for it to effectively
perform and it needs to be going a certain speed 2500 feet per
second to get reliable fragmentation out of many
green weights, so on so forth. We're going to talk about all
that today. First, talk to me generally about the 223556
projectile. Is it good?
Yes, especially for law enforcement. Absolutely. Not
only. And basically, because of the choices that you have, the
556 around since the 1960s. And obviously, all those years, all
those decades, now into the late 2000 onwards, the selection and
choice for the 556 or 223, whatever we want to call it.
There is such a selection now that it makes it obviously a
popular projectile caliber for law enforcement and for people
at home, right self defense, vomit hunting, right? Hunters
can use it out on the ranch.
How important is velocity from a 2235?
So if we have an expanding projectile, or if we have a
fragmenting projectile, so fragmenting can be M855,
green tip, right, the Winchester white box, you can get it, or a
VMAX type projectile for vomit. So either one of those, at a
certain velocity, it will either do what it's designed to do, or
not do what it's designed to do, right? There's a kind of a
window, we call it like an optimal performance window
there. So there's a low end on the velocity, where that
projectile just is not going fast enough to either expand or
fragment. Now, what drives that? Well, barrel length. And I know
we're going to get more into this, right? So if your muzzle
velocity to begin with is below where that projectile needs to
be to perform, you already have limited itself, right? And
obviously, the second one from that is distance. So the further
out the projectile goes, it loses velocity. And depending on
how far away the subject is that you're trying to hit, that
projectile may not perform. So that works for both fragmenting
or expanding. There's this window, this performance window,
where that projectile will work below, won't expand beyond, may
not expand. And there's somewhere in between is that
sweet spot, right? It's not a perfect set number, as we have
discovered here. So we get obviously, we know most, if not
all, the ammunition manufacturers. Sure. One of
those secrets is we know their performance window, and we need
to know that.
What are the characteristics you're looking for to say like
this is an effective, like people stopper?
Fragmenting is for us, the BRF is not the way to go.
Why is that?
So when that, okay, great. So when that projectile enters the,
the human subject is designed to fragment, you then a how many
fragments are we getting? How large are those fragments? And
what is the path of those fragments? We are looking for
that 12 to 18 inches of penetration, right? And we want
a projectile that has a good retained weight. So if it starts
off at 62 grains, when we pull it out of a subject, we want it
to weigh 62 grains, or as close to it as possible. I understand
if it's gone through some intermediate barrier on the way
we may lose some.
It sounds like we're applying what we know about like terminal
performance from handguns to rifles. And I was always kind of
under the impression that maybe it wasn't exactly an apples to
apples comparison, like, are like hydrostatic shock, and like,
you know, energy dump, as some people say, like, are those a
thing? Because when I think of fragmentation, I just think of
like, wow, this thing's basically going to explode upon
impact with a soft target.
And okay, so let's go to that energy dump. So foot pounds of
energy, right? People will go to Academy Cabela's, wherever it
is, your local favorite sports, outdoor sports store, and they
hunting season comes and they're looking down the line for the
one that has the most. They go down. That's the one I'm taking
without any thought or, or, or even concept of what the
projectile itself is. So energy alone is not is not a way to
judge how effective a projectile is. You have to look at the
design of the projectile, and how that energy will then
perhaps be transferred in. Okay, for example, you can take a 338
wind mag 250 grain going at 2100 feet per second or so. And
that has about 3000 foot pounds of energy, you take a 250 pound
defensive lineman, hitting the quarterback on a Sunday, right
at about 29.3 feet per second, he's got about 20 miles an hour
or so, right? Does that quarterback get killed?
It'd be kind of cool if you like it was like for the Falcons or
something.
Yeah. However, if you do all the math and calculations that
defensive end has the same equivalent pounds of energy, is
that 338 wind mag? And so how come? Right? Well, of course,
right, it's the mass, you have the mass of that defensive end,
hitting the quarterback versus that point of that projectile,
a 250 grain point, where all that energy is, is singled down
to that single point. So energy matters that foot pounds of
energy matters. But it's not a single thing to look at. Right?
It's a perception that people have that this energy matters,
they look at the foot pounds of energy. And that's one piece of
the pie, right? focus your whole selection of ammunition, based
on what it says on the end of the box.
Robert, this is where we pause. And I acknowledge my
appreciation of you as an Englishman for using a
professional American football reference. Alright, let's let's
continue. So fragmentation is old news. fragmentation is old
news, basically, is what you're telling me. Okay, so it still
works, right? Yeah, we go down two paths, where if you're
shooting, vomits coyotes. It's good. It's good, right? Because
what's a coyote maybe seven, eight inches in depth, right?
And is that projectile fragments and all that energy does get
displaced within and fragments out. You just like we've all
seen it, you just put a hole in that coyote. It's effective, but
it's not optimal. Is that safe to say for what we're talking
about? Yes, for law enforcement, it's not the way to go. Now.
Again, having said that, the military, right with m 855, or
m 855. A one, right? That is a fragmenting projectile. But
again, it's a different design of a projectile itself. It's
different design. It isn't that flat, no soft point, expanding
projectile that we use. It is a more spitzer right pointed bow
tail, because they're taking shots at three, four, 500
meters. We're engaging here. I'm here or here just beyond you
just beyond the cameras reach, right? I'm engaging, I need to
turn you off now for the army, they need to get hits, right?
Right. And a soft point, flat nose, expanding projectile, just
won't reach out there. I'm not saying it won't reach, but it
will take them more shots because it's not as accurate.
I see. Oh, we have to write we are again, we're reading this
web. We're not looking at a velocity threshold, like it
needs to be going 2500 feet per second to get reliable
fragmentation. Like, like we are with fragmenting. I imagine
there's maybe a different threshold or like a different
useful range with expanding projectiles.
There is but it's still that optimal window we spoke about
earlier.
And what is that window?
Based on the projectile?
Based on manufacturer based on like the design of the
projectile itself, right? How soft is the leg? How thick is
the jacket? Does it have skies? How have they designed that to
expand? And so there is a window there where that will either
will over expand paddles, paddles will break off, right
lower end, whether it's coming out of a short bow, or we've
gone long range again, where it won't expand, and it just stays,
you can pick it up down, you know, 600 meters down, pick it
up and reload it.
Sure. For purposes of simplicity, let's isolate as
many variables as we reasonably can. Talking about the
projectile, like, let's give me a good standard projectile that,
like anyone might have access to. That's that's an expanding
556.
You can go to without naming a manufacturer.
Yeah, please do.
Okay, you can get a 64 grain bonded bonded 64 grain bullet.
That's good. That's good.
Okay. And what kind of speed am I going to need to get that
performance optimal performance window?
So again, depends on the manufacturer itself, but
probably a low end is somewhere around that 2000 feet per
second for the expansion itself, somewhere around there. So 1112
years ago, in the Bureau, we had almost 13 variants of M4
barrel lengths and twists. How difficult that is?
Right here right now real quick. How important is twist rate?
It's important. Yeah, it's important.
Is it very important?
Yes, why? So because okay, with expanding projectiles, you have
linear velocity, but you also have rotational velocity. And
that rotational velocity helps with the expansion of the
projectile.
So I might want faster twist.
Not always you can spin a bullet too fast.
One in seven, one in seven, seven. As a general rule, let's
just one in seven or one in eight, depending on where you're
at. If you're living in that 14 and a half to 11 and a half, I'm
not gonna go shorter because we're gonna get there.
Yeah, we're gonna get there.
If you're living there, one in seven, if you start going 16,
18, one in eight.
So that optimal window and again, you're what you're saying
is, is, you know, you just want the performance, but to get the
performance that satisfactory to the FBI, roughly got to be
moving faster than 2000 feet per second, but maybe not too fast.
Right. So what's what's what's the high end of that?
So once you get beyond for again, expanding projectiles,
once you get into that 3100 feet per second, you may start
finding problems. So once you get if you're going faster than
3100 feet per second, you may start breaking, right?
It folds back so much like those pedals or the the that soft
point will fall back so much that you're losing that
expansion.
Is it theoretically possible then for me to have a round that
works wonderfully out of 16 inch gun, but I put it in a 20
inch gun. And now it's falling apart. A more extreme example,
an 11 and a half inch gun versus 20 inch gun. As soon as I put
it in a 20 inch gun, it's suboptimal.
It's quite possible. Yes, you may be driving it. Yeah, yeah,
sure. So now at short distance now what it may give you and
gain for you is that distance, right? Oh, true. I start seeing
the performance that may be 300 meters, you're moving that
performance window down range, right? Where it's like you're
hitting that optimal performance window.
We live in this world. Yeah, yeah. So a 20 inch barrel here
with the projectiles.
Probably meaningless. Yeah, yeah, yeah, it's not going to
put a hole in you and cause damage, but you're not going to
get the expansion on the performance side of it. We're
looking for. We're driving it through that.
I don't think I need to say it. But this is complicated ----.
Yeah, it is. I mean, there there are so many variables. So I
think at the outset, I mean, I know, ultimately, I'm going to
try to pin you down to like an ideal caliber weight and barrel
length. I know, I can tell I'm not gonna be able to do it. I'm
gonna try. But what I can see is that there are so many variables
involved, that it's almost foolish to say like, this barrel
length. This is like the ideal barrel length. It's like, okay,
well, what distance are you looking at? What kind of
projectile are you
So for law enforcement, because you brought it up, that's the
world we're living in here today. For law enforcement, 11
and a half inch is probably the ideal world to live in.
Why?
First of all, that with that one in seven twist, there's a
variety of weights there from from 62 up to 75 grain that you
can put through that don't go lighter, right? Don't go lighter.
No 62 to 75 grain that can work well out of that barrel length
and twist. Okay, it's short enough for law enforcement that
they can maneuver. It's not too long that they can't maneuver.
And again, we're working in close proximity. If we're
shooting beyond 100 meters, yards in law enforcement, it is
first of all, it's very rare. And also, beyond that, it then
becomes very hard in a court of law to say, could you identify
that subject? Right. So we're limited by all that in law
enforcement, right? Most of our encounters are right here.
Sure. No, and I understand that. And that makes total sense to
me. So if I wanted to go further out, you're saying inside of
100, really, there's no reason to do anything longer than 11
Okay, wow. Yeah, see, that's that's a revelation here.
Because I mean, no, and it makes sense. Like everything you've
said it, it makes sense. But I mean, just to have it put so
plainly by someone with such authority,
I'll just add on to that. There are many times we interact with
many police departments, right, local sheriffs, local police
departments, right all the way up to the major big cities,
right, where the patrol man will have a 16 inch rifle, and the
SWAT team will have a 10.3 inch rifle. Yeah, are we not shooting
the same bad guy? Why the difference? Right, right. Many
times unbeknownst to them, the patrolman with a 16 inch rifle
has got the up on the guy with a 10.3. Right? Sure. Right. I'm
traveling. I'm going with the patrol guy. He's got the right
barrel length and velocity with the projectile that they've
chosen.
And really, I would think as somebody who's worked a little
in local law enforcement procurement, no one's really
even looking at the projectile. And that's one of the most
important pieces of the puzzle.
Many times they just look at the barrel length.
The SWAT guys all want the shortest thing they can get.
Alright, so 11 and a half inches inside of 100 yards. Now just
for fun. We go beyond 100 yards or 100 meters, whatever. What
like what's a good barrel length? If I want to go beyond
the way you want to go to 200 11 and a half. Okay, 300. Yeah,
300. Now you may have to go to the 14 and a half. Okay. And
then like 16. I mean, it sounds like for most people, you know,
16, of course, is more common, because we don't have to fill
out paperwork. Right. But it sounds like for most people, 16
is just right. And then you nailed it on the head, right?
For manufacturers to be able to sell the most guns that they
can, what is the shortest they can make it available to the
most people available is the 16. And you said anything shorter
than that, right, they've got to start filing paperwork out or
welding flash hiders for the end. Sure. Yeah. Right. So
that's what that 16 inches become so popular. If you're
going down the road, and I know you are, I know where you're
going with this about for a DMR designated a designated
marksmanship rifle. Yeah. 18. Why? 18. Why? Just because to
give you that because I'm assuming as a designated
marksman, you're going to have to take a slightly longer shot
than your average patrol officer SWAT guy maybe you may be
pushing that three 400 meter shot. And you're moving that
optimal performance window further out like we're looking
at a bandwidth and you don't want to if you're a bad guy, you
don't want to be in this zone. And we're moving that further
out. He's not here. Exactly. Right. He's overwatching. Yeah,
he's not here. He's two 300 meters back. But for your
average law enforcement officer, average civilian with a good
projectile, which we'll talk about in just a second. 11 and a
half. Yeah. Okay. Why not 12? 12 and a half. Okay, 12 and a half
if you want, but 11 and a half. So through our testing, we did
I'm going back 10 years now, right? 11 and a half inch gave
us everything that we needed. But the 14 and a half. Okay, but
again, it comes down to the projectile that we're putting
to it. Okay, well, give me give me a good projectile. What's
what is the good don't name any names like don't you don't want
the FBI like endorsing James gets in trouble because the FBI
especially I get my buddies from all the different ammunition
companies calling me if you can get again a 64 or 75 grain, if
you can get a bonded solid base bullet, right a bonded bullet
out of an 11 and a half and 11 and a half will give you
everything you need as a law enforcement officer. And if you
can sign the paperwork as a civilian will give you everything
you need as a civilian for that home. Okay, so I've pinned you
down to 11 and a half inch 64 to 75 grain one and seven twist and
anything else we're wasting our time.
Well, the law enforcement defense. Yeah. Okay.
Robert, when I was at IWA Enforced Attack 2025, lots of
seven and a half inch guns from European manufacturers and a lot
of my viewers are saying those are completely worthless,
because you're not going to get 2500 feet per second, you're not
going to get that fragmentation. Do you agree with that are seven
and a half, seven and a half inch barrel 5.56 is worthless.
Okay, so I'm glad you said 5.56. First of all, because I was
going to ask you what caliber Okay, 5.56. Okay. Um, they have
a place, right? Obviously, there are times there are missions
there are departments that require something smaller, you
have to if you're willing to accept that shorter barrel, you
have to be willing to accept that you have shortened your
range of the effectiveness of your projectile, right? So what
is the requirement? What is true? You would ask him what is
and that's what we do. When we're faced with that when
departments come to us and say, Hey, we're looking at a seven and
a half inch, and they and we say, what's your requirement?
Because they all kind of sense of what is your what range are
you going to be engaging? And they'll say 50 meters, okay,
we'll see what we can do, right. And so obviously, we'll test
their projectile out of that 100 meters out of a seven and a
half, you're probably not going to get what the performance
you're looking for out of your projectile at 100 meters out of
a seven and a half, you'll be lucky perhaps to be somewhere in
that 80 meter, 80 yard 80 meter somewhere in there for the
performance of your projectile, again, depending on like we
talked about, right, depending on the projectile.
Well, let me put it to you this way, then somebody says there
is no way like we it is illegal in our country for law
enforcement to shoot further than 75 meters. There's no way
it's never gonna happen. We're not going to shoot past that
range. And they say we want a seven and a half inch gun, and
we're going to use expanding projectiles. Am I going to be
able to hit that optimal window inside of 75 meters with a seven
and a half inch gun?
Yes, with the right expanding projectile.
Yeah, so there are very limited. So it's not totally useless.
It's just only useless at this small range.
We'll find a projectile for you.
Okay, again, there's many other things.
Well, don't don't make work for yourself, Robert, you know,
you're gonna have a bunch of European agencies that are gonna
be watching this video. They're gonna call you now.
That's fine.
There's something about English accents as an American where
it's like, this guy is you're already a smart guy already way
smarter than I am. But you know, everyone's like, Oh my god,
you know, like, you say it in an English accent, it must be
true. But we know that this is all true based on your extensive
experience here at the FBI. So thank you for sharing that with
me. Thank you for sharing that with our viewers. You didn't
have to do this. But it meant a lot. Guys, thank you so much for
watching. Make sure you stay tuned because we're bringing you
more from the FBI. Take care.