Why We Chose On Demand Nitrogen - Liberty Systems Episode 4

Neo Structure
3 followers
Aug 4, 2026
SendCutSend has run both on demand and storage based nitrogen generation systems, and after using both, we've stuck with on demand.
In this episode, Jim is joined by Matt from Liberty Systems to explain the differences between the two systems, where each one makes sense, and why an
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedJim and Matt from Liberty Systems discuss the critical differences between on-demand and storage-based nitrogen generation systems for laser cutting. They explain why on-demand systems are superior for growing job shops that require flexibility, high peak flow rates, and long-term reliability compared to limited storage systems.
Hey guys, I'm Jim.
Joined today with Matt from Liberty Systems.
Liberty makes our nitrogen generation systems.
So we're doing a little vendor spotlight,
kind of behind the scenes on what it takes
to make SunCutSend work.
Liberty has been a great partner for us
for many, many years.
We use bulk nitrogen, like liquid nitrogen
in our cutting process, as well as generated.
But today we kind of wanted to talk about
why we went with Liberty in an on-demand system
versus like a storage type system for nitrogen.
So what's the difference?
That's actually a really good question.
It's kind of one of the confusing things
in the industry too.
What is on-demand, what is storage?
And a quick explanation is on-demand,
it's your peak flow rate 24-7.
You're always gonna have that peak flow rate.
If you're using a lower flow rate,
it's just less duty cycle in the system.
So just think of always having enough flow.
A storage system, they're gonna look at
what's your average flow rates?
What's your average material you're cutting?
And they're gonna have a smaller nitrogen generator
and then they're gonna have a really high PSI booster
and they're gonna store it into cylinders.
So that's how, like Liberty absorbs peak
by sizing it correctly.
Storage systems try and absorb peak
by having a lot of storage that they could dump
in an emergency kind of thing?
Yeah, but here's where the issue comes in
is if I have a leak or let's say
your steel didn't come in or something happens, right?
Where it changes your norm of what you wanna cut each day.
A rush job comes in, I have to cut thicker.
Those storage systems are telling you
what your future is, right?
So if I had thinner material I'm cutting today
but a job came in and you wanna take it and it's thicker,
you can't do it.
No, and so to just background, we've had both systems.
We've had mostly Liberty at one location.
We did try another like Cube type company.
Because it made sense like the way they sold it to us.
Small footprint.
But you're exactly right.
It had no surge capacity
and if things didn't go exactly perfect,
we could almost never catch up with it.
Once you dump those high pressure storage tanks.
Did they tell you to add more cylinders?
Yes, and then you've run out of storage for cylinders
and then even then, even with all the cylinders,
you still can't catch up
and then it takes longer to fill up the cylinders.
I mean, if you look at it, it's just for ease of numbers.
Let's just say I need 10,000 cubic feet
and I have 10 hours of downtime, right?
I'm gonna build 1,000 cubic feet each hour for 10 hours.
Then I'm gonna have 10,000 cubic feet in these cylinders,
right?
And let's just say your peak flow rate
was 6,000 cubic feet an hour, right?
Yep.
If you deplete that storage or you cut thicker,
you can't because the generator making it
only is 1,000 cubic feet an hour.
Yes, the only way to add, you have to add more horsepower.
You have to add another generator.
Yeah, and the front end, not the back end.
And what I see, the mistake I see in the industry
is when these are undersized,
it's adding more cylinders, more cylinders.
That means you need more time.
I don't have time.
I need, you need it on the front end.
Yeah, so, sorry, we should probably talk
in layman's terms about the different systems.
So an on-demand system, what the air comes in,
gets turned into nitrogen,
goes to my plant in a matter of seconds
and it can do that all day long, 24 hours a day.
Whereas the storage system takes that air,
turns it in nitrogen and then compresses it
to like 4,500 PSI, basically like scuba tanks
or like welding tanks, right?
Exactly, exactly.
So the idea, like where those systems kind of make sense
is if you're a small shop and you're running one shift,
maybe you get electricity really cheap at night
or something, you're like, okay, cool.
I can have this thing charge overnight.
And then when I walk in on Tuesday morning,
I have my nitrogen to run for the day and I'm good to go.
We thought that that would work.
But it turns out once you start running a little harder,
you run a second shift, all of a sudden,
that thing turns into an on-demand system
and they suck at being on-demand systems.
Oh, no, you can't.
Well, it's not designed to do that, right?
So yeah, that's, I mean, we build storage systems, right?
Like you said, if you're a couple hours a day,
maybe one shift, I have 16 hours of downtime, right?
So it may make sense in that standpoint,
but do you plan on only having one laser forever
and staying at your revenue for the year, every year?
Or do you wanna grow?
Yeah, if you were like an OEM where,
actually like knife guys, knife guys who have a laser
and they're gonna cut 100 blanks a day
or something like that, some of those systems make sense.
Cause they're like, dude, I only turn my laser on
from the time I get coffee to lunchtime
and then I'm grinding knives for the rest of the day.
That's totally fine.
However, that's a big challenge
to get your equipment utilization.
You just invested in a really expensive laser
and the whole ecosystem to support it.
And then you're only running it like four hours a day.
It's really tough to get that payback.
So our philosophy has always been,
if we buy good equipment, I want it running 24 hours a day.
And those storage systems just can't keep up.
No, they can't, but they serve a purpose, right?
So that's why we do it.
I would say 95, if not more percent of our sales is lasers,
but we do lead generation, heat treating, food packaging.
There's other applications where storage makes sense.
I truly believe storage makes sense
in heat treating applications
where I have a huge volume real quick
and then I bake for five hours.
So I have downtime, right?
So I have a cycle and the storage system
plays with that cycle.
Whereas if we look at a laser,
it's not really the cycle time of the laser,
the beam on time, it's nanoseconds.
So I don't believe that the storage systems
truly keep up for what you need and I like on demand.
Well, if you do choose to go to a storage type system,
a cube type system, it's great
if you're never gonna change your customer base,
you're never gonna change your mix
and your demand is incredibly predictable
because what will happen, like we're a job shop,
we have no idea what we're gonna be doing that morning
or like in an hour, I have no idea
what we're gonna be cutting
because the order just came in.
Yeah, so all of a sudden one day,
you have to cut 200 sheets of quarter inch thick aluminum,
like you're gonna blow through,
however big your storage system is,
you're gonna be done and it can't recover.
And that's one of my things is I like making sure
when I'm doing my scope questions, right?
I have all the details,
so I make sure that you're making a good investment, right?
And ultimately saving you money.
And when I look in the storage systems,
there's so many variables that you have in your shop.
So it's sometimes I feel risky selling a storage system
because I know things change.
So I always feel more comfortable selling a customer system
that I know is always gonna hit those peak flow rates.
Sound like a salesman, but yeah,
I'm not supposed to, this isn't supposed to be a sales thing.
I will say that going with an on-demand system
is more future-proof.
It allows you to have flexibility.
That storage system is gonna tie you into something
great for like small shop,
maybe just starting out, something like that.
Otherwise on-demand should be something that you consider.
Oh, other thing I wanted to say,
the difference in components is wild.
Like compared to the other vendor that we used,
to you guys, like Kaser compressors,
like really good quality fittings
and chillers and all that stuff.
When you get one of these like one and done things,
you open up the panels and you're like,
I can't read any of the writing on these.
Who knows where the hell that compressor came from?
The chiller is like some off-brand, whatever.
And when things go down,
you can't just like go to the local repair guy and get it.
You're usually.
So like pay me now or pay me later, right?
Yeah.
You were talking about.
Yeah, exactly.
Yeah, I mean, we build quality stuff.
Like I said, it's not the cheapest in the block,
but we wanna be able to provide you
with a long lasting system and help you grow
and we grow with you guys.
Yeah, yeah, it works out great.
So a little behind the scenes with Liberty Systems.
Shout out to Matt,
if you're interested in one of these things.
I think we're splitting commission on this.
We said 60-40.
Anyway, for more information,
we're gonna be doing a few series like this,
not only on Liberty, but other vendors too.
So thanks for watching and love you, bye.
