Just when you though it couldn't get any better...

Panthers Digest
1 follower
1 Video View·Aug 3, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of Panther's Digest analyzes the NHL's top center duos, arguing that the Florida Panthers' pairing of Alexander Barkov and Sam Bennett is superior to the Edmonton Oilers' duo. While the Oilers boast higher offensive output, the Panthers provide a more balanced combination of elite two-way play, defensive stability, and physicality essential for championship success.
Just when you thought it couldn't get any better, The Athletic writes an awesome article
about the top two centers for each team and where they rank compared to the other teams in the NHL.
The hierarchy, if you will, of line one centers, line two centers for each team.
On this episode of Panther's Digest, we are going to talk about where
is Alexander Barkov and Sam Bennett on that list? Why are they there? How do they stack
up against guys that are above them? And I'm going to ask you guys a question now.
Do you think that is where they should be? I'm going to give you an argument as to why I agree
with The Athletic in saying where they are is right smack dab where they should be. I'm going
to support it. And I do want you guys to comment down below. Let me know where you think they
should be. I'll even throw in the top three guys that we have, include Lundell, maybe even four
and say Lars Eller in this too, because I think we have combination wise. I'm not saying each line,
we have the top guy for that line. I'm going to say we have probably arguably the best four
combination of centers in the league because our third line center Anton Lundell is the best third
line center in the league. Lars Eller, I'm not going to say he's the best fourth line center
in the league. Is he a good one? Yes. Very defensive forward guy. I'm happy we got them,
but I arguably think that like our combination of centers, we probably have the best four in the
league if we combine them there and letting them do what they're supposed to do on those lines.
Awesome. But let's focus really more on Alexander Barkov and Sam Bennett. So like I said,
this is Panther's Digest. I'm Greg Andrews. Don't forget to subscribe guys. Those of you
who are watching and not subscribed hit the button down below. It takes two seconds to do
support the channel. Help me blow up here and let's make this channel bigger. I appreciate
all of you guys. So let's get into this right now. Every NHL's top six center duos ranked from best
to worst. Well, where do we place on that list? We were not generational. That spot, I would say,
yes, they're right. It does. That spot deserves to be taken by McDavid and Draisaitl. No doubt about
it. In the elite level that was just below, it was McKinnon, Nelson, and then Barkov and Bennett.
So it's not 1A or number one, then 2A and 2B. It's like they're both tied for second in that
elite level. Now what I'm going to tell you is this. I'm going to give you my argument as to
why Barkov and Bennett deserve to be at that spot. Let's talk about Alexander Barkov first.
This is not about sexy stats and offense because in every single sport that is out there guys,
the sexy thing is offense. We all know that. I'll give you a very good example. In the NFL,
do you know how many defensive players have won the MVP? Two. Two guys since they started giving
the MVP award in 1957. One belonged to Lawrence Taylor. The other was Alan Page. The only two
defensive players. The only two in almost 70 years of NFL football guys. That's it. That's it.
So when you're looking at the MVP in the NHL as well, it all has to really do with offensive
statistics pretty much. They're not going to look at your giveaways, your face-off win percentage,
your hits, your blocks, your takeaways, your course percentage, all of that. It literally
just has to do with goals and assist points plus minus. And yes, what are you doing for your team?
Yeah, it's, it's pretty cut and dry. We all get it, but Alexander Barkov is a top five center
in the league. I'm going to show you his numbers right now. Since he came to the league in 2013,
2014 played that first season and where he has been since not last year, but the following the
previous season, because obviously he didn't play last year, but notice since 2019, 2020,
I know there was the lockout year. Um, sorry, the COVID year and all that stuff. So he hasn't
played a full season of 82 games since 2018, 2019 is full big. Most full season was that 73
game season in 2324 when we won our first Stanley cup, but he's been averaging around since let's
do the last four years. He's averaging around 69 to 70 games a season. There's nothing wrong
with that. There's 84 games this year. I think he's going to be ready to go, but the thing for
Barkov is his defense. Three times Silky award winner. He's the best two way player on the
planet. He's the best defensive forward on the planet. You cannot argue it period. So when you
look at this, let's do this. He are, he averages 1.15 points per game since the 2122 season. Yeah,
pretty, pretty impressive. That's 95 points per every 82 games. It's seventh best among
first line centers. I already said the Silky awards that he has won, and he only is on the
ice for 1.64 goals against in every 60 minutes of five on five since the 2324 season. And he also,
by the way, who I'm going to compare our top two guys to these two limited Connor McDavid
to eight points on five on fives in the two, the two years that they met in the Stanley cup finals.
That's pretty damn impressive. It is again. I'm going to say, when we start talking about
Connor McDavid and these guys, we'll get into that in a moment, but I'm going to tell you
at the end of this. So, so if you want to scroll forward, be my guest, but you're not going to
want to miss what I'm gonna have to say about the comparison of where Barkov is versus McDavid
Bennett versus dry cycle, because the numbers are going to be crazy.
So here are his playoff numbers. The three years we went to the Stanley cup finals. I mean,
he's got, he got better every single year. One thing I can say, if you want to compare
McDavid and Barkov is obviously McDavid doesn't have to put up 40 goals in a season. He's not
that guy he can. Yeah, but he's more of the assist guys, the setup guy. He's a transition
player. Not very good on defense. Really not, really not. And I've already said, if you want
to kind of put one side to the other and say, okay, well Barkov side, his, his bad side is
playing offense. It's not really bad. Not like you can say to Connor McDavid, like his, his
defensive side is not good at all. It's really not, but Barkov is balanced defensively and
offense. He doesn't need to do a hundred points in a season because guess what?
He plays great defense. It leads to offense. Connor McDavid coughs the puck up all the time.
I'll get into his numbers in a minute, but Barkov's numbers are spectacular. By the way,
his giveaways, he averages 43 a season for the last four years from 21, 22, he had 51 giveaways,
38, 31, and 52, his face-off win percentage. He averages 56.4% in the face-off circle.
Since 21, 22, all these numbers are since 21, 22, 56.9%, 54.9, 57.3, 56.5. By the way,
if you're going to talk about McDavid or even dry sidle in the face-off circle, but more so
McDavid, McDavid's numbers are not that great. And I'll tell you, but he's also done fewer
face-offs compared to Barkov and he's played more games in a given season.
In 23, 24, Alexander Barkov had 1,026 face-offs the following season, 1,100.
And he didn't even play full season. So imagine had he played a full season,
he probably would have been 13 or 14, maybe even 1500 face-offs in total. I wouldn't say
1500, probably like 1300 face-offs in total with the extra 12 games or so. So let's talk about
hits. It's almost a push in a way, but I would say Connor McDavid's numbers are just about two
hits per game lower on average in the last four seasons, because he had a year, we had like 118
hits, I believe. But Barkov has been consistently going up for the most part, 50, 52, 103 and 87
since the 20, 21, 22 season. Barkov sacrifices his body, averages almost 50 blocks a year,
42, 48, 50 and 54. Takeaways 52 and a half in a season, 59, 56, 61 and 34.
Numbers are very good defensively. Offensively, you already saw,
he is solid across the board. Alexander Barkov does it all offensively and defensively. He's,
I think, the most balanced player in the league. Best two-way player,
best defensive forward in the world. Yes, he's a top five center. Tell me I'm wrong.
And don't just give me offensive stats for other players. You've got to tell me,
how are they on defense? It's not just about, if you're a one-way player and all you do is
play offense and you can't play defense, sorry, you're way below Alexander Barkov. I don't care
if you score 80 goals in a given season. If you can't play defense, you're not contributing
completely to your team. And that's a big hit against you. You got to play defense.
So now for Sam Bennett, his number's not the greatest, but one of the things that he
is hands down, well above all three of the guys, Barkov, McDavid and Darius Sidelis,
he's so physical. So physical. He averages 145, almost 146 hits in a given season every single
year in the last four years. 150, 173, 145, 115 since the 23-24 season. Very physical.
You guys could say everything about him is controversial. He's dirty.
He always gets away with certain calls, but his antics and his gamesmanship, you've got to say,
are effective, especially in critical moments of a game. That is part of this game, guys.
That is part of this. The intangibles that are there and that is what he brings are the
intangibles. So again, his numbers are not off the charts for the regular season. He
turns it up in the playoffs. That's why he won the Conn Smythe. 15 goals in the playoffs was awesome,
was great in the finals. He deserved it. His contract, still kind of questionable when we
signed him and that $8 million a year. We'll see how he does this season. I think he's going to
really have a great year now that things are hopefully normalized on the team and everybody's
healthy. Let's take a look at his playoff stats. You already know, 15 goals in the 24-25 season,
seven assists, great numbers. They've been going up every year that he has made the playoffs. He
has been very good. His giveaways, 49.25 in the regular season average. Base-off win percentage
isn't the greatest, just below 47%, but I said his hits. He puts his body out there and he will
block shots at 38.75 blocks per game the last four seasons. Takeaways, 32.5 average per season
the last four years. By the way, in the last three playoff runs, he has 51 points in 62 games.
Again, it's those intangibles. It's the physical nature that he has on the ice,
that assertive, I'm going to hit you. I'm going to be physical. I'm going to get under your skin.
There's a reason why he was brought in here is because of that physical prowess.
There's a reason why Eller was brought in. There's a reason why Hathaway was brought in.
There's a reason why both Kachuk brothers are on this team. Marchand is on this team.
And Gudis, Gajovic, I think everybody gets the point that we are going to be physical.
That's how we win. Barkovs, I told you, his physical numbers, his hits went up when Matthew
Kachuk got here. That's the style of play, the wear them down, grind it out style of play that
the other team doesn't want to touch the puck because they don't want to get hit anymore.
Because they're getting bruised, they're getting beaten, they're getting battered,
they're getting worn down. That's what we do. Let's take a look at Connor McDavid now, guys.
He is no doubt. I'm going to say this. Yes. I know people have already made the argument. He's
not the best player in the world. I'm going to say he is the best player in the world,
but he's not the best two way player in the world. He can score. He could set up his guys.
He's got great hands, but so does Barkov. Both are very good skaters,
but there are risks that he takes where I say, I don't really want to say that he is hands down
the best player in the world, but he is the best player in the world guys. Look at his numbers
season in and season out. He averages over a hundred points per season. He has been relatively
healthy throughout his career. His numbers are good. Look at the assist numbers. They're
incredible, but I've said this before. He doesn't need to score 40 goals every single season.
He's great at setting up his teammates. He's a transition player. That is what he is. And that
is one of the reasons why he has a lot of giveaways in the last four seasons. He's
averaged 92 and a quarter giveaways per year. He had 134 of them this past season. That's
ridiculous. Face-off win percentage. It's better than 50% just above it. He's at 50.05%,
but in 2024, 25, he had 776 face-offs the year before 865. That's why I was saying you would
compare him to Alexander Barkov. Barkov is much better in the circle and he's in it more frequently
than Conor McDavid is as for hits. Like I said, the 20, 20, 24 season kind of skews his numbers
a bit because he had 118 hits, but the last two seasons, he only had 40 hits per season in the
last two seasons. They've gone tremendously down. Barkov has gone up, took a little bit of hit
in 24, 25, but that's okay. So McDavid averages 71, almost 72 hits per season, but it's because
of that 118 he had in the 23, 24 year. So I'm going to say a little skewed. I'm not going to
say, yeah, that's what he averages. He doesn't, he's not that physical of a player. He's not as
physical as Barkov. He's definitely not as physical as Sam Bennett. His takeaways 53 and a
half on a yearly basis for the last four years, since 20, 25, 26, he had 32 of the previous season,
32, then 68, then 82. He has gone down. His numbers have suffered a little bit. I think his style of
play has changed a little bit more, especially as he's getting older. I don't think he wants to be
as physical. I don't think he wants to be in those scraps along the boards, trying to really fight
for the puck. I told you his game is more about the transitional aspect, letting the other guys
work the boards, have the puck come free, let him take it up the ice, find the guys that are going
to be open and create plays transitional player. That is one of the reasons why he has a lot of
giveaways. He takes a lot of chances offensively, trying to find guys in the slot, somewhere near
the net, find the open player that can get a good look. And sometimes those passes don't hit the
mark. And that's where the giveaways come in. Sometimes it happens even in neutral ice.
Sometimes, I mean, guys, again, there's so many different scenarios I could bring up here,
but let's keep going. Let's talk about Leon Dreisaitl. He on the defensive side is definitely
porous. He is purely, I might say purely, but swings a lot more to the offensive side of things
than the defensive side. Here are his numbers for his entire career. Very good. Like I said,
he has gotten better over the years. Obviously, first four years in the league was still solid,
but man, did he pick things up in 2018, 2019. He's been great. Connor McDavid definitely helps
with that, obviously. Good numbers offensively. Solid across the board. The shooting percentage
is phenomenal, by the way, if you really look at that. Look at his power play goals.
He always goes on that, looks for the cross ice passes, wide open net. That's why he usually has
such high power play goals per season. He also has good assists. I mean, he's great offensively.
He and McDavid are the best two, one, two punches for centers in the league offensively. Defensively,
not so much. By the way, in 2025, 26, he only played 25 games, as you can see there. Let's
take a look at his playoff numbers. By the way, regular season numbers. I want to go over this
really quick. Giveaways, 97 in a given season on average for the last four years. Since this past
season, he had 106, then 88, then 92, then 102. That's a lot of giving away the puck, a lot.
Here's his playoff numbers. I'm going to still go through some of the regular season stuff.
Face-off win percentage, pretty good, 55.75%. Since 2023, 54.9, then 56.9, 54.3, 56.9. He's
very good in the face-off circle, but he's not there nearly as much, once again, as Alexander
Barkov. He's not. Barkov's in there all the time, guys. Hits, he's not a physical player.
27 a season for the last four seasons. He had 40 in that 23 season, then 26, 27, and 15 last year.
Blocks doesn't really do a lot defensively with blocks. Excuse me, that was blocks. That was 27
a season. His hits, 45.25 hits per season for the last four years. I'm going to redo this again.
His hits, 45.25, 66, then 58, 23, and 34. That's leading up to this last season. Blocks, like I
said, 2023 season, 40, then 26, 27, 15, 27 per season. Takeaways, 77, 82, 35, and 26. He averages
55 a year. It's gone down. His numbers have gone down defensively. They really have.
What I really want to put out there is this. Bennett is incredibly physical. Those intangibles,
getting under the skin of the opposing team, the way that he plays, like I said, his gamesmanship
and his antics play a lot into this. The physical nature of hockey that he brings to the table
is a game changer for the Florida Panthers, especially in big moments. That's why he's here.
I think winning the Conn Smythe put the Florida Panthers in this position with him and Barkov.
I think the duo, yes, what they do is right up there with the top three. I think right where
they are is perfect. I wouldn't say they're above McKinnon and Nelson. I still think McKinnon and
Nelson, yes, they're both in elite levels, but I think they are better than Barkov and Bennett
because Bennett still needs to prove himself a little bit more. He needs to do a little bit
more offensively. I think he's got to be better in the face-off circle, but I still believe they
need to be there because Barkov is elite. He's a superstar, best two-way forward in the world,
top five center in the league. Absolutely. Do not tell me he doesn't belong to be there.
If you're just giving me offensive stats, you can shove that. Don't give me a player who doesn't
play defense, but can give me 150 points in a given season. I don't give a damn that they do
that. Show me defense and show me offense. Conor McDavid, he is the best player in the world,
but his defense is subpar. There's a reason why he's never been uttered in the sentence
with the word selkie award in it, ever in his entire career. He turns the puck over too much.
Drysaddle turns the puck over too much. They're both not that physical. Their game has changed,
but Florida Panthers, both of those guys, their offensive numbers might not be adding up to what
McDavid and Drysaddle are or McKinnon and Nelson's numbers are, but they're damn good defensively.
They are more physical. There's a reason why we bested the Oilers in two straight Stanley Cup
finals and shut down their top two players. And when I say shut down, yeah, they're going to have
their moments, but Drysaddle was non-existent. I think it was in the 23, 24 season. McDavid ended
up stealing the show and winning the con Smythe ridiculous though. I said that he won it. He had
great numbers, but I still think it should have gone to a Panther and the following season.
Again, we have covered them up. We blanketed them, the two best centers in the tube, the two,
the top center duo in the league. We shut them down. They had their moments, but look at the
previous match-ups that they had in the playoffs in both of those years, how well they did.
And then they met the Florida Panthers and it was like, Nope, we're cutting you down.
So anyways, guys, let me know what you think. Comment down below. I appreciate all you guys
tuning in. Really interesting article. Go check it out on The Athletic about top center pairings
in the league. It's a great article to read. Don't miss it. Anyways, guys, until next time, go cats.
