In this engaging TEDx talk, educator Bart Millar explores the fundamental importance of critical thinking in modern society and whether it truly matters in our daily lives. Millar analyzes why people frequently fall prey to bad logic, misinformation, and deceptive schemes despite formal education levels. Through a series of compelling historical and contemporary examples, including Charles Ponzi's investment fraud, perpetual motion myths, the Dunning-Kruger effect, and touch therapy skepticism, he highlights how cognitive biases cloud human judgment. The presentation provides accessible tools like Occam's razor and psychological insights to demonstrate that objective evaluation is a crucial shield against becoming a victim of flawed ideas.#criticalthinking#tedxtalks#bartmillar#logicandreasoning#cognitivebias#dunningkrugereffect#occamsrazor#problemsolving#mentaltargets#skepticism
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The speaker argues that while people aren't necessarily stupid, they often \"think badly\" due to psychological biases and a lack of critical thinking. By examining historical scams, pseudosciences, and cognitive failures, the talk emphasizes that critical thinking is a lifelong, essential struggle to avoid dangerous delusions and exploitation.
Hello.
So I'm here tonight to talk to you about critical thinking
and whether or not it matters.
This talk used to have a different title,
but my friends convinced me that that was sort of harsh.
And so I needed to develop a new thesis, which was not
that people are stupid, but rather that people think badly.
But then that left me with a new problem, which
was, why do people think badly?
Well, my first thought was, maybe they
don't have a lot of formal education.
But personal experience has shown me
that formal education is no shield against shoddy thinking.
Next, I thought, maybe they just don't have good information.
And then my final thought was, maybe those people
are just gullible.
I was surprised to find out that that's
a word that doesn't appear in any dictionary.
Let me talk about some historical examples
of bad thinking.
This is Charles Ponzi.
He was a charming Italian immigrant to the United States
in the 1920s.
And he had an amazing new investment idea.
Word got around about this idea, and investors
poured their money in.
What Ponzi would do for you is, if you parked your money
with him for 30 days, he would return it
with up to a 50% increase just one month later.
So again, that became a very popular idea.
Well, people at the time didn't realize
that Ponzi was the inventor of what's
now known as a pyramid scheme, also known as a Ponzi game.
But until they realized that, a lot of people
made a lot of money, right up until they didn't
when the scheme collapsed.
Ponzi went to jail for a brief time
and then was deported back to his native country.
Perpetual motion machines have held a real fascination
for inventors for the last several hundred,
if not thousand, years.
The idea of extracting free energy somehow
is a very, very lucrative and seductive one.
Now, to do that, you have to play
with the laws of thermodynamics.
Everybody know the laws of thermodynamics, right?
You can't win, you can't break even,
you can't get out of the game, right?
So that said, perpetual motion machines
tried to defy that through clever systems
using magnets and waterfalls and siphons
and gravity and counterweights.
They purport to extract free energy
from the universe somehow.
The patent office of the United States government
was so besieged by applications for these things
that finally they said, no more, stop bothering us
unless you can bring us a working model
that you can park out in our outer office
where it will run for one year with no intervention.
And since then, applications have been way down.
This is a rendition of snake oil.
Snake oil is kind of a catch-all term
from the last hundred years or so ago.
Pre-FDA, Food and Drug Administration,
anybody could put anything in foods or drugs,
and they frequently did.
A real popular ingredient in cough medicines
at that time was laudanum.
Now, laudanum, we now know as morphine,
which is an extremely effective cough suppressant.
In FDA, pre-FDA, non-regulated dosage days,
it's also an exceptionally effective breathing suppressant,
which is one way to cure your cough.
This is Ellen White.
Ellen White was a prophetess.
She told people around her
that she was getting visions from heaven,
and people started to believe her.
They were listening when she told them
that the world was going to end in 1841,
and again in 1843, and yet again in 1845.
Well, you'd think by then that nobody really
would have been listening,
but thousands of people flocked to her side.
They doubled down on these failed predictions.
When she predicted it, yet again,
the end of the world in 1851,
people were not really disturbed that time.
Maybe they were a little relieved
that the world wasn't ending,
but the important thing is she kept getting visions,
and eventually she had a vision of a school on a hill,
and she found a partner,
and they built Loma Linda University.
Rhinos.
Rhinos came up in a talk earlier tonight,
and I want to talk about rhino horn.
An earlier speaker talked about a horn on a rhino
that was worth $2 million,
and the reason it's worth a lot of money
is because of really shabby, critical thinking.
The idea of using powdered rhino horn
as a cure for fever or impotence
has been around for thousands of years,
and because people are too dumb or too lazy
to go out and buy aspirin or Viagra,
we have this beautiful creature
that's being driven right to the edges of extinction.
Okay, well, so I've shown you
that historically people think badly.
Well, why do they think badly is our next question,
and I have some renditions here.
This is an example of what's known
by psychologists as groupthink.
Groupthink means when you're a part of a group
that wears uniforms or has a secret password
or what psychologists call an in-group,
it's really hard literally to step out of line
with the decisions of that group.
A member of the National Security Council
of the United States government blamed groupthink
for the unanimous decision to go to war against Iraq.
The Ash Experiment.
Ash Experiment basically was, again,
the Ash Experiment was put together
by a psychologist of that name,
and he discovered that if you have people
look at the line on the left
and then ask them which of these three lines,
A, B, or C, is the line on the left most like,
if nine people say A, the 10th person,
not knowing that the other nine people
are collaborating in advance with the experimenter,
that 10th person will almost invariably fall in line
and say A as well,
showing the power of social uniformity.
This is my favorite.
This is Dunning-Kruger effect.
Dunning and Kruger are two psychologists
at Cornell University,
and they became fascinated with the idea of incompetence
after reading a story about a bank robber
who successfully robbed two banks
but was unsuccessful at evading capture.
Now, the reason for that was that the bank robber knew
that lemon juice can be used for invisible ink writing,
and he made the jump in reasoning
that if he coated his face with lemon juice
prior to robbing the bank,
it would render him invisible
to the bank's security cameras.
Now, that didn't work out so well.
His friends identified him on the evening news,
and Dunning and Kruger came away with their big takeaway,
which was this.
Truly incompetent people are too incompetent
to even recognize their own incompetence.
Okay, so I've shown you historically people think badly.
There may be some hardwired reasons
we need to overcome with regards to thinking badly.
There's a couple of tools.
There's a lot of tools out there,
but there's just a couple
that I'm gonna put out in front of you today.
This is William of Ockham.
He was a priest about 1,000 years ago
who came up with what I think is a really great idea.
It's now known as Ockham's Razor.
And Ockham's Razor is this.
All things being the same in any given situation,
the simplest solution is usually the correct one.
Seem good?
So that means when you lose your keys,
you don't need to invoke the CIA or alien abduction.
Basically, you just laid your keys down,
you're retired, and they're probably somewhere in your house.
If you read a news story
about an announced military exercise in Texas,
you don't need to put together a conspiracy
with secret prisons in the basements of abandoned Walmarts
because it's probably what it is on its face,
a military exercise
that's been previously announced in Texas.
This is my favorite example.
This is one I hope you'll take away tonight.
This is Emily Rosa.
Emily Rosa is the youngest person
to have her name on a peer-reviewed professional paper
in a medical journal and at nine years old.
Now, the thing about Emily was she became fascinated
with an idea that was making the rounds
in the 1970s in the United States,
a pseudomedicine called touch therapy.
Touch therapy practitioners
claimed that they could see an aura around people
that they could not only see this aura,
but they could touch it,
they could manipulate it to diagnose and treat disease.
It's hard to refute that.
How do you know that I can't see your auras?
It's hard to prove.
But Emily Rosa asked for some practitioners
to help her in an experiment.
They willingly did so.
I think they truly believed
that they were able to see those auras and feel them,
which was the critical part of her experiment.
She had a large piece of cardboard, taller than her,
and then cut a hole in it
large enough to put your hand through.
She then invited practitioners
to put their hand through the cardboard hole
with her standing on the other side
where they couldn't see her,
and then tell her whether or not they could feel her aura
as she suspended it above their hands.
Well, when they added up the results,
the practitioners didn't even do as well
as the law of averages would dictate.
So that was a multi-million dollar industry
brought down by a little girl with a big piece of cardboard.
It means you don't need a lot of formal education
or fancy equipment to be able to think critically.
What about this?
Does any of this matter?
People say to me,
Bart, why don't you just leave those people alone?
Everybody can think what they want.
I'm going, no, they can't.
There's a reason for that.
Let me show you why.
And I want to say,
not everybody is on board with this program.
A major political party in a major state,
I won't name either, it was the Republicans in Texas,
passed a resolution in their legislature
banning critical thinking in public schools,
which gives everybody here at SAS a big advantage
because you're a private school, right?
Okay, this is why it matters.
About 15 years ago in New York City,
this man began to offer this fantastic return to investors
if they brought money to him a year later,
he'd return it with huge gains, no questions asked.
And people didn't ask questions.
Everybody recognize Bernie Madoff?
This time, thousands of people lost millions of dollars
and lives including that of the Madoff family were ruined.
This is Jim Jones.
He was a charismatic preacher
in Southern California in the 1970s.
He convinced his followers
that they were going to be persecuted
and imprisoned by the US government
for their religious beliefs.
He invited them into a colony in South America,
which he had founded.
They did that.
There, he grew increasingly isolated and more paranoid
and then finally told followers
that now the US government was coming for them
and they would be imprisoned for their religious beliefs.
And the only escape was to follow him directly to heaven,
which 900 of them did drinking cyanide
out of vats filled with grape Kool-Aid.
Well, what about this?
People say to me,
well, maybe I could just do some research on the internet
and then make up my own mind, decide for myself.
I'll tell you, that's a really bad idea.
This is what you get out of that.
The anti-vaccine advocates over the last two decades
have led the way in the resurgence of childhood diseases
that were nearly extinct just a few years ago.
Disneyland last year had an outbreak of measles.
How 1950s is that?
Some people, when they look up in the sky
and see chemtrails is what they see
when they see jet contrails going overhead.
And they say, oh, the government must be spraying us
with nefarious chemicals for some reason.
If you ask them, what about that?
Where's your evidence?
They'll say, sorry, you're either part of the problem,
you're part of the conspiracy
or you're a dupe of the mainstream media.
Homeopathy is a pseudomedicine based on the idea
that the smaller the dosage of a medication,
the more effective it is.
You heard that, right?
And that means that these sugar pills I'm showing you
should be perfect for curing the headache
you're probably getting from this talk
because they contain 0% aspirin.
They should be 100% effective.
Okay, P.T. Barnum said,
there's a sucker born every minute.
Actually, P.T. Barnum didn't even say that.
One of his competitors did.
But what it comes down to is there's always gonna be a crop
of new people coming along that need to be educated.
You know somebody is gonna walk out of here
and go to their dictionary, right?
And be looking under G for gullible.
Let me close with this story.
This is where this is all is that it's not a process
that's ever going to end.
In Bali, in Indonesia, they tell a charming story
of a creature called the rangda.
And the rangda periodically comes out of the forest
and clouds men's minds and makes them think badly
and do evil things.
And when that happens,
the barong needs to come out of the forest
and that's a power for good.
And it battles the rangda.
And it drives it back into the forest after diminishing it.
But it can never kill it.
It represents the struggle,
the eternal cyclical struggle between good and evil.
And I think with critical thinking, it's the same thing.
Essentially, this is a process that's never ending.
And it's one that we can't ever really hope to win,
but it's one that we can't afford to lose.
Thanks very much.
Thank you.