My name is Amir, Im a 27 year old video editor and animator. I'm a student of philosophy & psychology and I create these videos with the hope of helping other people overcome their biggest hardships and obstacles in life through philosophy.
There's a certain friction,
I actually call this limbic friction,
where let's say you don't wanna get out of bed
in the morning, you just don't.
Maybe you're tired, but maybe you're just not motivated
and you force yourself to get up.
What you're doing is you're using top-down control
to say, oh, the fatigue I feel,
I'm gonna override that fatigue.
And much of what's online is how do you override
that fatigue, that lack of motivation?
And some people say, well, you gotta do it out of love,
and then other people say you do it out of anger,
and it doesn't matter.
These top-down mechanisms are very subjective.
If you are gonna do it because you really care
about the person that you're gonna pick up at the airport
and you gotta get up early, well, that's one mechanism.
If you're gonna do it because you're a person of your word
and you said you were gonna be there, you do it.
The just do it mantra is top-down control, okay?
Now, the top-down control is also involved
in controlling reflexes.
The desire to consume something that isn't good for you,
you can resist that desire through top-down control.
The more rested you are, generally,
the easier it is to engage top-down control.
So when I look at people, like, I don't know Rhonda Rousey.
I don't know too much of her story, but I do know David.
He's been to my lab, and I endorsed his book,
and I'm obviously super impressive.
David Guidance needs no introduction.
Super impressive, and I think one of the many important
things that David stands for is the ability
to override limbic friction,
to talk to, to convince himself to do it anyway.
And there are others that do this,
I've talked about this as well.
That is top-down control, and what they've,
what he's done, if I may, I don't, I've never,
I've never actually figured this out conclusively,
but I have a strong sense that what he's done
is he's somehow gotten very familiar
with the narrative of friction,
or the experience of friction,
and the narrative of overriding friction,
and he knows that a win is coming later.
And so, what happens is if you know
that overriding limbic friction
is gonna create a win down the line,
that win could be a sense of accomplishment,
that you conquered something in this limbic friction.
So you need to know what that accomplishment looks like.
You need to experience, it helps to know
what the win feels like, yes,
and what you can do is you can start to
thread back that dopamine from the future
to the idea, by getting out of bed,
I'm already starting to experience the win.
You can anticipate the win.
Now, there's actually a paper that was just published
on this, this is good timing for this question,
which is that really points to the fact
that delayed gratification is controlled by dopamine.
And it's a somewhat complex paper,
so I don't wanna get into the details,
but what it shows is that if you know
that by delaying gratification, you are going to,
it's worthwhile, you start to achieve
that dopamine increase earlier.
So delayed gratification is, as it sounds,
is resisting the urge, resisting the chocolate bar,
or resisting the staying in bed,
or whatever it happens to be.
But that itself can start to evoke dopamine release.
Now, I'm not David Goggins, obviously, I never will be,
but the way he describes his process
is a little bit different, I think,
than just pure like, oh, I feel great doing it.
He talks a lot of times about how
it's very, very challenging for him.
But when you talk to people who are very good
at overriding limbic friction,
you start to get the sense that,
even if it's very challenging for them to do,
that they understand the great reward
that's gonna come later.
And I think for a lot of people,
the challenge is they haven't experienced,
or they can't see the win, and experience the win,
and so it's very hard for them to override limbic friction.
And I'm not talking about limbic friction
as this mild little thing.
Limbic friction, it's like a booming voice
throughout your brain and body,
of stay in bed, sleep is important.
I heard on the podcast, sleep is important, stay in bed.
And to override that requires an immense amount
of what we call willpower,
but willpower is top-down control.
It kind of is also going against
what was required of us as a species,
like instant gratification in many ways
is a survival mechanism, right?
Yeah, I mean, if you could get all your sustenance
without having to venture out too far,
why would you go any further?
Now, the evolution, the forward evolution
of culture in our species and individuals
has been created by people that were willing
to push out further and further.
I mean, right now, we talk a lot about Elon, right?
He's the one that's sort of like,
well, why limit yourself to Earth?
You know, which is a cool concept.
But this exists in every domain, as you know.
Rich Roll, our good friend.
Anytime we overcome doubt, challenge,
internal doubt and challenge,
we're engaging these mechanisms.
It's a vital part of our individual development.
Would you say it's a skill?
Absolutely.
It's a skill and there's neuroplasticity in this circuit.
That's the thing that's often not discussed
is that the ability to focus is enhanced
by forcing yourself to focus.
The ability to sleep is enhanced
by getting better at relaxing and turning off thoughts.
And the ability to override limbic friction
can only be created one of two ways.
One is to increase your overall levels of alertness
through dopamine and norepinephrine.
That's why people take Adderall and Ritalin,
drink caffeine, smoke nicotine.
In order to get more alert,
they're biologically hacking their way into the system.
I think it's beautiful when people can psychologically,
I would say, I always imagine scruffing myself.
You know, like you'd scruff an animal
or you'd scruff an animal.
Scruffing myself and forcing myself into it
because for me, it helps to third person myself.
It's very hard as the, you know,
the way the brain is and the way we identify as individuals,
I'm not gonna refer to myself in the third person.
I will not do that.
There's a name for that in psychology.
I won't mention it in clinical psychiatry.
It starts-
We had a bit of a joke before.
It starts with an N, yeah.
Starts with an N and ends with an M.
Or yeah, or anyway,
narcissists generally talk about themselves
in the third person.
And it's hilarious, right?
Because they think so much of themselves
that they talk about themselves in the third person,
revealing the micro-squishy inner ego of the narcissist.
But what I'm talking about is third personing oneself
in service to overriding limbic friction.
And sometimes we have this narrative
that's so closely tied to our immediate state
that we have a hard time forcing ourselves
into some other mode of action.
And so it can be very helpful
to take on a view of yourself
that's living in anticipation of the future state
that you're going to be in,
like successfully getting out of bed in the morning.
I did this this morning.
Last night I said, let's...
My partner and I said,
let's go jump in the ocean tomorrow morning.
We got up and it was raining.
It kind of like the smallest matter.
Very misty today.
And I was like, oh God, it's gonna be cold.
And then we're driving down there
and I didn't tell her
because I didn't want her to know what I was thinking.
I hate getting in the ocean when it's cold.
I absolutely hate it.
But then we got there
and actually the water was just a little bit warmer
than the external environment.
It was beautiful.
We had the best ocean dip in the morning
and then a sauna afterwards.
And it was wonderful.
I've been feeling great all day as a consequence.
But it took a little bit of override.
That's a mild recreational example.
But I think that if we can start to see
these reward systems and top-down control
as things that we can modulate in real time
and use it sparingly.
I'm not suggesting people do this for everything, right?
It can be very exhausting to scruff yourself
into the best action all the time.
But look, I mean, people are recovering from addiction.
They have to do this.
It's a process from morning till night.
How important is tying that
to sort of bed down these neural systems,
this rewiring you're talking about?
How important is tying that
to some sense of satisfaction or celebrating?
You mentioned sort of achievement earlier.
Is that sort of critical to closing the loop on all that?
So it's very important to experience a win at some point.
But one thing that a lot of people misperceive
is that we should always celebrate our wins.
The dopamine system is very good at predicting wins.
And when it can predict a win,
if those wins come on a regular basis,
you start reducing the amount of dopamine
that's released in response to those wins.
It seems a little counterintuitive,
but the casino owners understand this.
The pattern of reinforcement that works best
in animals and humans is intermittent random reinforcement.
So one thing that you can do, and I suggest to people,
is that if you are working hard at something
or you're really pushing yourself,
sometimes reward yourself,
but occasionally delete the reward.
Because it sets up,
there's something called dopamine reward prediction error.
Again, we probably don't have time to get into all the,
it's a computational analysis of what keeps things,
people and animals motivated to continue to pursue.
And random intermittent reinforcement
is the optimal schedule.
Have you done an episode on that?
Somewhat, I did an episode on dopamine,
sort of a dopamine masterclass that got into it,
but I haven't really boiled it down to a specific protocol,
but it would look something like this.
You're in your 90 minute learning bout
or work bout of any kind.
You're doing your little gap learning things.
And every once in a while, you look at the clock,
you go, oh, I've made it 30 minutes
without looking at my phone.
You're thinking, okay, that feels pretty good.
Other times, you might say,
okay, I made it to the 45 minute mark.
I'm gonna go get myself a nice cup of coffee.
So you have a little bit of coffee.
Other times you delete the coffee and you keep working.
What you're doing is you're effectively taking that goal
line and you're moving, you're catching little micro wins.
It's sort of like a video game
where you pick up little coins.
I'm an old school guy.
I don't play video games, but the ones I did play,
like you pick up coins, you can give you power.
Like Pac-Man or there's like the Super Mario Brothers.
I'm truly old and out of it in respect to this.
So forgive me.
But what you're doing is you're picking up
additional lives or points,
but occasionally you don't take anything.
It keeps you in pursuit.
Keep it guessing.
Let's see, another way to do this is,
I suggest people avoid layering dopamine.
You know, you have one dopamine system
that fortunately can be activated
by a lot of different things.
So for instance, I love the feeling
of being completely rested, going into the gym,
or going for a run mid-morning after a cup of coffee,
hydrating well, using the bathroom,
listening to my favorite music on a sunny day.
But that's a lot of things layering in for dopamine.
And what happens is that if that becomes
your hope and expectation, fine.
But if that becomes your requirement
for actually having a great run or workout,
you're in trouble because the next time
it's not gonna be that exciting
and you're not gonna be that motivated.
You actually won't perform as well.
So this year what I've been doing
is every third or fourth workout or so,
I think kind of randomly,
I leave my phone in the car,
I don't use any music,
and I don't allow myself any kind of pre-workout stimulant.
So I have to generate all the force and energy
and everything I'm gonna do from internal processes.
And you might say, well, that's kind of masochistic.
Why would you do that?
It's supposed to be fun.
Well, I'll tell you, the next time
when you bring your headphones
and you're listening to music,
you feel like a god in there.
Why?
Because you are secreting so much more dopamine,
so much more noradrenaline,
so much more effective at performance.
But then the next time you have to throttle it back.
And so I'm excited by all the tools that are out there,
all the, you know,
there's all this like cognitive enhancement stuff
and people are plugging into every device
and they're trying to figure out
do I have white noise in the background
or metronomes and all that stuff.
But it's good to not layer in too many things.
There are other examples of this
where are a little more unfortunate.
Pornography is a really good example.
There's a huge issue now, right?
Because pornography is so much more
readily available on the internet.
Now let's just remove the kind of
the moral judgments about it, right?
Because that's not what this is about.
A scientific discussion about this would say
that there's an enormous availability
and range of imagery that's very powerful
that feeds directly into the dopamine system.
And a lot of people,
young people who are growing up
watching a lot of intense pornography
are suffering from a lot of sexual side effects
and struggles of sexual interactions in real life
because those interactions are not as intense
as the things that they're seeing.
The other thing that's happening to just mention
is that I've got colleagues that work on this in psychiatry
that they are wiring their nervous systems
to become aroused viewing other people having sex
as opposed to them having it.
And so they're running into a lot of trouble there.
So what's happening is that dopamine levels
are so high that real life,
it's like eating extremely palatable foods
that are just blitzing your system.
Every taste bud, high salt, high sugar,
high fat to the point where it's just,
and let's assume delicious.
I don't generally like those kinds of foods,
but and then all of a sudden it's like,
here's a bowl of rice or a salad.
It's gonna taste like garbage to you
because you're at first anyway.
Poor night's sleep will almost always create brain fog
if not the first day, then the second day.
Brain fog could be any number of things.
It could be lack of adrenaline.
Some people are just not engaged enough
in what they're doing.
It is amazing how we can be so excited
and engaged in certain things and not in others
and feel so sleepy in certain environments.
And then all of a sudden we're wide awake.
I've lectured to many students that feel this way
about my material.
I know the feeling, there's this,
I won't go into the details,
but there's this office in Sydney.
And whenever I walk into this place,
I literally feel so tired.
And it might just be the types of conversations
that I'm usually having in this setting
and I'm not fully engaged,
but something triggers me in that environment
where I just feel sleepy.
Well, low oxygen turnover will definitely contribute,
slightly elevated temperature, low oxygen turnover,
these kinds of things.
I mean, this is the post-lunch lecture phenomenon.
I don't lecture undergraduates anymore,
but I used to look out and I would teach at night.
I actually preferred to teach at night
when I was teaching undergraduates
because in the evening,
people are a little bit more conversational.
So I do these nighttime lectures,
six to 7.30 p.m.
It was great,
but there were always a couple of people just dozing.
And I was a student that had a hard time
staying awake in class.
I think being stationary,
just listening to the hum of a voice,
the temperature's up a little bit
and next thing I know it's like class is over.
Some of the best sleep I ever got was in classes,
but please don't sleep in classes if you can avoid it.
I think that being actively engaged in material is very key.
You know that I did an episode on ADHD
and one of the things I learned in researching that episode
is that people who have ADHD
actually have a remarkable ability to focus
if they really like the activity,
which tells you that the dopamine system,
which is associated with really liking
and pursuing something,
is really key for attention.
And no surprise,
Ritalin and Adderall mainly work
to increase attention and focus
by increasing dopamine and adrenaline.
So, you know, I think if we like a place
and we like a topic and we care about it,
we tend to be alert for it.
And when we're not, we just kind of drift off,
which is sort of a, of course, answer.
Yeah, right?
Like it's common sense,
but it sounds like the most important part
of hacking focus and attention
is finding something that you enjoy doing.
That's right.
And I would say,
find something that you really enjoy doing
and have a tool so that when you have to engage
in things that you don't want to do,
you know how to go forward center of mass anyway.
Because I'm not saying that people
should pursue things in life they hate,
but one thing that I did when I was in school,
for instance, there were a couple subjects
that I really didn't like.
And I would try and lie to myself
and tell myself that I liked it.
Then I decided, well, okay,
adrenaline and dopamine are these alertness molecules.
And I'm just going to think about
how much I hate this topic.
And then I'm like, I actively hate this,
not bored by it, but how much I actively hate this topic.
And then all of a sudden
you get this attentional engagement.
And I was like, you know what?
I'm going to defeat this topic just to prove,
like, I'm going to wrestle this topic to the ground.
And so then I was able to do it
because I had to take the course.
And then what you find, which is kind of ironic,
is then if you do well enough on a particular subject,
you're like, I kind of like that topic.
You know, it's because you've conquered something.
So I think it's good to be,
to engage in things and find things that you really enjoy,
leverage these dopamine systems.
But look, there comes a time and place
where you have to lean into effort
that you simply did not choose.
And that's part of becoming a functional adult, I think.
And it's also something that Anna Lembke,
when she came on my podcast, discussed.
You know, a lot of younger people these days
are really focused on finding their passion
and they're waiting for something
that engages them so completely
that everything seems very facile
and they're just able to be forward,
center of mass all the time.
Sometimes you have to enter things through the back door.
And in order to feel really excited about something,
you have to feel as if you worked through that friction.
That's an accomplishment in and of itself.
If you're on social media and you're scrolling
and you don't even know why you're scrolling,
like you don't even know what you're looking for,
your dopamine system has been tapped out
and you need to take a break from it.
Maybe a couple hours, maybe a couple of days.
I think social media is great.
I teach science on social media.
I see you all the time on social media.
You know, there's a lot of great social interaction.
There's a lot of opportunity to learn and see things.
Some are funny, some are interesting, some are disturbing.
But when you're at the point
where you're engaging in something
and you don't even know what the win is,
but you find yourself reflexively engaging in it,
your dopamine system is now plummeting.
And that's a serious issue.
So the other thing is that a picture is worth 1,000 words
and a movie is worth 1,000 pictures.
Our visual system is so tuned to watch motion
and to see movies.
So you're seeing movie after movie,
after movie, after movie.
What's happening is the context is switching constantly.
The human brain has never been confronted
with context switching at this rate.
You know, a television went from six channels
to 12 to 200, but this is the first time
that you can walk around with your television.
You can have it in your car.
You can have it on the phone, excuse me, on the plane.
So I use social media and the internet a lot.
Unlike email or reading an article online,
social media is, you know, you can scroll
through a thousand different
or a hundred different contexts within five minutes.
And that's a big override for the brain.
And then the rest of the world seems kind of boring.
Like, you know, you see people at dinner
scrolling their phone.
It's because actually the brain wants novelty.
It's seeking novelty all the time.
These days I'm turning off my phone in the evenings.
I'm sort of, I'm on there a little bit,
but I'm finding I'm kind of sick of the phone.
I think a lot of people are kind of hitting this point
where they're like, ah, I'll get on social media
for an hour or two a day,
but this is getting a little pointless.
Yeah, but you're right, it has its place,
but it's nice to be able to connect
how you're engaging with it, using it,
and your feelings with science.
Because then all of a sudden it's, you're in control.
Yeah, and I use the phone.
I try and not look at my phone
for the first hour that I'm up.
Usually I only make it about 30 minutes
while I go do my walk.
I want to download whatever processing I did in sleep
and write a few things down.
The phone isn't sinister.
It's our overuse of it that's sinister.
It's like calories aren't bad.
It's overindulgence in calories is bad.
It's not complicated, but I think that knowing
that the dopamine system is what got you started
with the phone, but the reason you scroll
is not for more dopamine.
It's because you're seeking that big dopamine peak.
It's subconscious, but the amount of dopamine
that you're getting from any individual post
is tiny, tiny, tiny, tiny, and then it's more
about just trying to get back to baseline.
So I say, so when you, at first, any activity that's fun,
you get this huge peak, and then a trough,
and then it comes back to baseline.
But if you engage in that activity too often,
the way that the dopamine system is arranged
is eventually you're just engaging
in that activity to just be okay.
You're just fighting for normal,
fighting for neutral, as I call it,
and that's addiction.
That's compulsive use of something
in order to just feel okay.
That's not pleasure.
The most important thing to understand
is that for most adults, so that is people
about age 18 to 20 and older,
daily caffeine consumption is not going
to be a problem provided it does not induce anxiety,
and certainly provided that it not induce anxiety
or panic attacks, and provided that it does not disrupt
your nighttime sleep.
This is why I always recommend
that if you are going to consume caffeine
in any form, coffee, tea, soda, or otherwise,
that you try not to ingest caffeine within the eight,
and ideally within the 10 or even 12 hours
prior to bedtime.
That's because the half-life of caffeine is such
that even if you are able to, for instance,
have a cup of coffee around 3 p.m. or 4 p.m.,
and then fall asleep around midnight,
the architecture of the sleep that you get
is going to be disrupted.
For instance, it is very important
that you get sufficient amounts
of both slow-wave deep sleep
as well as rapid-eye movement sleep each night.
And if you consume caffeine too close to bedtime,
and here I'm defining too close
as anywhere from eight to 12 hours before going to sleep,
chances are you're not going to get
as much rapid-eye movement sleep
or slow-wave sleep that you would otherwise.
And it is the amount of rapid-eye movement sleep
and slow-wave sleep that together lead
to whether or not you feel you had a good night's sleep
in terms of your next-day alertness and cognitive abilities.
Now again, some people may find
that they can drink caffeine in the late afternoon,
maybe even at night, and still fall asleep,
but I promise you, even if you're in that category,
you will sleep far better,
meaning the architecture of your sleep will be better,
and you will feel far more rested the next day
if you abstain from caffeine
within the eight to 12 hours prior to bedtime.
And I should also say that none of us are perfect,
myself included.
I will sometimes have a cup of coffee in the late afternoon,
and sometimes that will cause me
to stay up a little bit later, sometimes it won't.
I don't think you want to obsess or worry too much
about having some caffeine every once in a while
in the late afternoon if you are still able to fall asleep,
but don't make it a regular habit.
Now, as far as we know,
there is no drawback to consuming caffeine
on a daily basis, again,
provided it does not disrupt your nighttime sleep,
and provided that it does not induce anxiety.
In fact, most of the world
consumes caffeine every single day.
The current estimates are that 90%, that's right, nine zero,
90% of adults throughout the world
consume a caffeinated beverage every single day.
That's a staggeringly high number,
making caffeine the most popular drug on the planet.
In fact, because of the way that caffeine works,
and just to remind you how it works,
it effectively blocks adenosine receptors.
Adenosine is a molecule that builds up
in your brain and body more and more.
According to how long you've been awake,
it makes you feel sleepy.
Caffeine blocks the adenosine receptor,
and then when it is dislodged from that receptor,
whatever adenosine has built up and is around
can then bind to the adenosine receptor
and makes you feel very sleepy.
That's the caffeine crash.
So if 90% of the adult population of the planet Earth
is consuming caffeine every day,
that means 90% of the adult population of planet Earth
is blocking their adenosine receptors
for some portion of their daily life,
and then their adenosine is binding to the vacant receptor
once the caffeine has dislodged.
And why are 90% of adult humans consuming caffeine every day?
Well, to feel more energized, more focused,
to have more both cognitive energy and physical energy.
Now, of course, most people are not walking around
thinking, oh, caffeine gives me more energy,
more focus, et cetera.
Most people are consuming caffeine every single day
and are consuming caffeine every single day
in order to feel quote-unquote normal,
to be at their baseline level of cognitive ability
and physical energy and so on.
In fact, if you look at the data on caffeine consumption,
what you'll find is that caffeine
actually is a cognitive enhancer.
It can improve learning and memory.
It can increase physical energy.
It can increase mental and physical stamina.
But a feature of those studies that's not often discussed,
but that was, however, discussed
in the full episode on caffeine,
is that studies of caffeine typically are done
by taking chronic caffeine users
and then having them abstain from caffeine
for some period of time, usually four days to two weeks,
in which time they undergo caffeine withdrawal.
They do not feel well.
They get foggy-headed.
They have less energy.
There's some malaise, sometimes even some mild depression.
And then what they do is they have people take caffeine
and take a cognitive exam or do some physical activity
and compare their performance to what it was
when they were in the withdrawal state.
Another typical form of study on caffeine
is to take people who are naive to caffeine
or who never take caffeine
and then have them ingest caffeine
and then measure their cognitive
and or physical performance.
And in both cases, you see improvements.
What I'm saying here is that daily caffeine consumption
is not going to lead to improvements in cognitive ability
or improvements in physical ability above one's baseline
unless you either abstain from caffeine
for some period of time,
typically four days to two weeks prior,
or you are not somebody who typically ingests caffeine.
In other words, 90% of the world's population
is drinking caffeine on a daily basis
to be at their normal level
of mental and physical functioning.
And I would say that if you are going to drink your caffeine
drink it in the early part of the day,
as I mentioned earlier,
I am a big proponent of delaying your first caffeine intake
until at least 90 minutes after waking
in order to avoid the afternoon crash.
I've talked a lot about this on the podcast.
There are a lot of clips on the internet
explaining the rationale behind that.
And if you do experience an afternoon crash in energy,
I do recommend delaying your morning caffeine intake
to 90 to 120 minutes after waking.
Now, for people that want to get more
of a true cognitive enhancing
and performance enhancing effect from caffeine,
again, you're going to have to abstain from caffeine
for about four days.
Regular caffeine drinkers, that's going to be difficult.
That is going to lead to headaches.
That's going to lead to brain fog.
That's going to lead to feelings of malaise.
In fact, the last time I took four days off
or even a week off from caffeine consumption
was when I was sick.
I don't get sick very often, but when I am sick,
I generally abstain from caffeine.
And sometimes I wonder whether or not the malaise I feel
from whatever viral or bacterial thing
I might be dealing with when I'm sick
is in part the malaise of caffeine withdrawal.
I certainly notice I feel much better
when I return to drinking caffeine,
but that tends to coincide with feeling relief
from whatever sinus symptoms and other symptoms
I might have been experiencing from the illness.
So it's not a good experiment.
I can't tease apart those variables.
So the short answer is for most adults,
there does not seem to be any major downside
to consuming caffeine.
And there have been scattered reports here and there
in humans showing that ingesting caffeine
can increase dopamine receptors,
which will effectively allow you to get more
out of the dopamine that you produce.
This is why caffeine has a mood elevating
as well as energy elevating effect.
I should point out that some people
just cannot tolerate caffeine.
It makes them too jittery, too anxious.
They start sweating, they get heart palpitations.
It's very hard for these people to build up a tolerance
to caffeine that allows them to enjoy it.
These are the people that can even feel
a fluttering of the heart and a lot of energy lift
from decaf coffee, something that to me
is just a foreign concept,
but some people are just that sensitive to caffeine
that even the small amounts of caffeine in chocolate
or decaf coffee make them feel too alert
and they should abstain from caffeine.
I don't think they are in any way harming their health
by abstaining from caffeine.
Getting back to the original question
about daily caffeine consumption,
this person goes on to say that for them,
okay, this is their personal experience,
after a few weeks of consumption of daily caffeine,
the negatives start to outweigh the positive ones.
They're getting poor quality sleep,
lack of appetite, anxiety, et cetera.
And when they don't consume caffeine,
they find it a lot easier to be mindful
and their meditation practice is much better,
but they're lethargic and less motivated.
Okay, so what they're describing
are all the classic symptoms of caffeine overuse,
probably not abuse in this case,
although caffeine can be truly abused.
People taking caffeine pills, et cetera, in large quantities.
We're not talking about that,
but this person is describing the classic pattern
of overuse of caffeine and the classic pattern
of withdrawal from caffeine when they stop taking it.
So what should somebody like this do?
And I think that's an important question to answer
because I think a lot of people fall into this category.
They drink caffeine every day,
they're no longer getting the performance enhancing effect
of caffeine, so they're taking it just to be normal
or feel like they can focus normally
and have normal amounts of energy.
But then if they try and come off, they feel worse.
Okay, there are a couple of ways to do this.
You can taper your caffeine intake off
over the course of four to seven days,
but most people don't have the discipline
or don't wanna spend the time doing that.
But if you want to, the way you would do that
is you would cut it by about 10 or 15% per day.
You could do that by volume
or you could do that by concentration of coffee,
that sort of thing.
A simpler way to go about all this
that still will allow you to get some
of the performance enhancing effects of caffeine
and yet experience far less withdrawal
would be two things.
First of all, just have your amount of caffeine intake
for two or three days.
So again, that could be by volume
or it could be by concentration,
probably easiest to do by volume.
And so instead of drinking an eight ounce coffee
in the morning, maybe you do four ounces
of regular coffee, four ounces of decaf,
or you just have the four ounces of coffee.
You do that for three or four days
and then you take perhaps one full day off
from caffeine, maybe another full day off.
You're going to feel a lot less bad on those two days
having cut your caffeine intake in half
in the previous four days than you would
if you just went cold turkey.
And then you go back to ingesting caffeine,
but you go back to ingesting caffeine at that 50% dose
or what used to represent that 50% dose of caffeine for you.
And you just continue that way on a daily basis.
And then every once in a while
when you want the performance enhancing effects of caffeine,
you go back to what was your original dose,
which is now double what you're taking on a daily basis.
So what we're really talking about here
is not going cold turkey.
We're not talking about quitting caffeine indefinitely.
What we're talking about is cutting the amount of caffeine
that you drink in half for about four days,
okay, plus or minus a day,
and then taking two days off from caffeine completely
and then going back on that half dose of caffeine
indefinitely, that's your new baseline of caffeine intake.
And then every once in a while,
if you need a bit more of a lift,
you ingest twice as much caffeine
or a coffee that's twice as concentrated.
We should acknowledge that most people
aren't going to be really precise
about the amount of ounces and the amount of caffeine.
Nonetheless, it's pretty straightforward
to know that you're reducing your caffeine intake.
Certainly it's clear to know
if you're ingesting no caffeine for a couple of days.
And it's pretty clear
when you're doubling the amount of caffeine,
but you don't have to worry so much
that you're exactly doubling the amount of caffeine.
You could drink one and a half times
as much as you happen to drink on the day before,
or you could drink three times as much.
You would definitely feel it
if you drink three times as much.
One very important thing to recognize
is that on any day where you really spike
your caffeine intake above baseline,
no matter where that baseline is,
when you start, could be zero,
could be 400 milligrams, could be 200 milligrams.
When you double that intake,
you will get a big boost of energy.
And the next day, you're going to feel the crash from that.
You're going to feel more lethargic.
You're going to feel not so good.
This has to do with dopamine receptor modulation.
This has to do with adenosine receptor modulation.
The important thing to do is not continue
to consume that elevated level of caffeine,
which is what most people do.
And then they set a new higher baseline just to feel normal.
The key thing is to just manage to get through
that crash day.
Manage to get through that one day
where you feel a little less good,
or maybe even down a bit.
Get outside a bit, get some more sunshine.
We know that spikes your cortisol in a good way, right?
It can increase the catecholamines, dopamine, et cetera.
Get a little bit more sunlight,
get a little bit more movement.
Get outside, do something to offset
those feelings of malaise,
and then get right back to your original goal
level of caffeine each day.
There's no use in getting so quantitative
that you make your life miserable,
you know, measuring things out like a laboratory chemist.
If you're that type and you want to do that, be my guest.
But unless you're taking caffeine in pill form,
it's very, very hard to get extremely exact
about the amounts of caffeine that you're ingesting.
So it is okay to eyeball it,
but understand the contour of how caffeine works
and what the caffeine performance enhancing effect
comes from.
It comes from a caffeine intake above baseline.
Understand that anytime you go above baseline
with your caffeine intake,
there's the potential of some anxiety.
Understand that there's going to be a slight withdrawal
effect that lasts about 24 to 48 hours.
Battle through that short period,
and you'll be right back where you started
and where you need to be so that you can enjoy caffeine
on a daily basis and derive the benefits,
because there are many benefits to drinking caffeine
and avoiding some of the potential hazards.
Learning is a two-stage process.
And the learning I'm referring to
is specifically deliberate learning.
You know, children are learning passively all the time.
They're taking in new information.
Their brain is, it's not a complete tabula rasa.
It's not a complete blank slate.
There's some hardwired functions they show up with,
thank goodness, like breathing, like heart rate,
heart, controlling heart rate.
But that helps.
I mean, you know, offload as much as you can
to the genetic program to hardwire the nervous system
so they can learn how to walk.
And walking is a good example.
A kid learns how to walk and then walks reflexively.
But of course, at any stage,
you can think about how you're walking.
You can do hopscotch,
and you have to change your cadence
of jumping and walking, right?
So that's this flexible transition
between voluntary and involuntary movement,
but you have to learn how to walk.
So, but what we're talking about now
is generally deliberate learning,
language learning, skill learning,
learning knowledge of any kind,
learning how to, you know,
navigate the emotional dynamics of a relationship,
anything.
Two phases.
One is active engagement and focus.
Much of the trigger for neuroplasticity as a process
is engaged by dopamine and norepinephrine
and a molecule called acetylcholine,
which is liberated from multiple sources.
We always talked about how acetylcholine
controls the contraction of muscles,
but in the brain,
acetylcholine mainly comes from two sets of neurons,
one in the brainstem and another in the basal forebrain.
And it serves as a kind of a highlighter,
marking particular connections or neurons
that later stand a chance to become stronger.
So let me give an example.
I don't speak a second language,
but let's say I decided
I was gonna learn conversational French.
I would learn some nouns or some verbs.
I would focus on this.
And the greater degree of focus that I bring,
the greater amount of acetylcholine is released
at that time.
And at the particular locations in the brain,
they're involved in enunciating the words
and writing the comprehension,
multiple spots within the brain.
That kind of marks those or flags those areas
as potentially changing later.
But the actual rewiring of the nervous system
happens during states of deep sleep or sleep-like states.
And so when we say neuroplasticity,
the brain's ability to change in response to experience,
that's a two-part process.
It's a process.
It's not an event.
We always think about things as events,
but in biology, almost everything is a process.
So the takeaway from this is in order to learn at any age,
the most critical thing is that you bring as much focus
and active engagement to the learning,
the encoding of the information,
bringing in the information,
and then that you get into a state of deep rest
as quickly as possible.
Typically, that would be the night after you learn,
after you have this trigger.
But there are some beautiful studies
published in Cell Reports last year and the year before
showing that people who take a 20-minute nap
within the four hours after these triggering learning,
or people that do a non-sleep-deep-rest-type protocol,
even just sitting there quietly and not doing anything,
they learn much faster.
In other words, the brain rewires much faster.
That interesting.
It's very interesting.
And what's happening is very interesting.
We've long known that during sleep,
there's a replay of the neurons in the same sequence
that they were played during the activity
earlier in that day, sometimes even backwards.
For some reason, it's like the songs
played backwards at night.
Who knows why?
I don't think we should focus too much on that right now.
But that replay is the consolidation of the information.
You learn.
This is why you try something physically,
try it physically.
You can't do it, you can't do it,
and then you come back a week later and voila,
you can do it.
You had the opportunity to change the neural circuits
so that now you can do it.
These non-sleep-deep-rests,
or these shallow naps of 20 to 30 minutes
also create a replay or a firing of the neurons.
But there's an additional tool.
So what, sorry, I should say there's a tool
which is get as focused as you can,
but then relax as deeply as you can.
People think that the expectation
is that you're going to be like a beam of focus
for 90 minutes.
That's not the case.
You can flicker in and out.
You're going to get distracted.
You bring yourself back.
I mean, focus is an active process
of bringing that spotlight of attention back.
It's always like-
Much easier without the phone.
Much easier using a program called Freedom.
Free program online where you can just
turn off the internet.
It's, I'll tell, it's very painful as you know,
and yet there's something deeply satisfying
about completing one of these 90 minute bouts.
You really feel good in your brain and body
because we were actually designed to do this.
I said design-
It definitely feels like a grind at some stage.
Oh yeah, and that friction and that anxiety
sometimes that we feel is adrenaline.
It's supposed to be stressful to learn.
This idea that we just sit back and learn
or that, you know, movies have really destroyed
the notion of learning.
The idea that you're going to pick up the sword
and suddenly have the skills.
You know, forget it.
It's like, this doesn't work that way.
I mean, it's friction, friction, friction,
friction, friction, and some days are good
and some days are worse.
If you slept better, generally it's better.
People are always trying to optimize
how much caffeine, background noise,
yes noise, yes music, no music.
You have to tweak things according to your circumstances.
But you, after about 90 minutes,
should really take a break
and let your mind go idle somewhat.
Ideally, you would take a 20 minute nap
or a 30 minute nap or do a non-sleep deep rest protocol
within the first hour to four hours after that.
But a lot of us have a lot of demands.
You go straight from a 90 minute bout to commuting.
Sleep that you get that night is going to be
the most powerful tool for wiring the nervous system.
Right, that's when it really happens.
And so we can talk about tools to get into deep sleep
and stay asleep more if you like.
But there's another thing that you can do,
which is that there's a beautiful literature
on what's called gap learning effects,
where let's say, and this has been looked at
for physical skill learning,
for music learning, math, et cetera,
where if every couple of minutes, just randomly,
during your intense learning or focus,
you pause and you just take 10 seconds and do nothing.
Just let your brain idle.
Eyes open or eyes closed, doesn't matter.
What happens is your rates of learning actually increase.
And the reason is, now they've done neuroimaging on this,
really excellent studies published in great journals,
show that during those little gaps that you're taking,
there's a replay of the neurons very fast
at something like 10 or 20X the speed
that normally they would be rehearsing.
So you're getting more repetitions
by stopping every once in a while.
Now, you actually have to do the work
and how many of these to insert, and it should be random.
So there are some free apps out there
where you can set like a random buzzer
or just every once in a while while you're writing
or trying to do something, you just pause and do nothing.
Where was that tool when I was going through school?
Yeah, exactly.
And I think that the science on this dates back
about 20 years, but it's only now that there's enough
of what I call a kind of center of mass around these studies
that really point to the fact
that gap learning effects are really strong.
They're very beneficial, you learn faster.
So it's focus, rest, focus, rest, focus, rest.
And that can be done on the micro level,
like within that 90 minute block.
Let's just make up a number for fun
so people have something to anchor to.
If you're gonna sit down and do an hour of work,
let's say for every 60 minutes of focus
or learning that you try and do,
introduce 30 gaps of 10 seconds at random
and truly at random, not on a regular interval.
And then sometime later that day,
if you can do an NSDR, non-sleep deep rest.
And if you can't, okay, no big deal.
You won't learn as fast, but you'll still learn
provided that you get into deep sleep that night
and you, let's say you have a lousy night's sleep.
You'll still learn, but you won't learn as well.
And maybe the next night you stand a chance
of encoding that information.
So neuroplasticity involves a very strong trigger
and then deep relaxation is when the actual rewiring occurs.
And there are exceptions to this,
but I should just mention,
because it brings us back to an earlier point,
that when you think about the tools
that people use to enhance focus,
Ritalin, Adderall, L-tyrosine,
excessive amounts of caffeine, nicotine,
those all help with the trigger part,
but they don't help with the relaxation part.
And so a lot of people don't learn.
They just get really good at doing,
but they don't actually learn.
So very effective people in,
regardless of workplace or activity,
sport or cognitive work or otherwise,
perform very well because they're very good
at regulating the seesaw of focus, relax.
Focus, relax.
And in the longterm, it also is very health enhancing
as opposed to health depleting.
I mean, I know a dozen or more people
who have done very, very well in business or academia
who are a mess.
They, I mean, they're physically a mess.
They're emotionally a mess.
They're mentally a mess.
Their relationships are a mess.
People that I consider successful
are people that are very successful
in multiple domains of life.
And that almost always correlates
with an ability to engage and disengage,
deliberately engage and deliberately disengage.
And thank you, Matthew Walker and others
who have emphasized the importance of sleep.
You know, I mean, Matthew was really kind of first man in
on trying to convince the world
that this whole idea of you'll sleep when you're dead
is really foolish.
And listen, I think it's a fact
that in order to get good at anything,
unless you're just an absolute talent,
you need to apply yourself and work hard
and sometimes work longer and harder
than you feel like working or is healthy for yourself.
I mean, that's a reality.
But Matt, I think really pointed out
that sleep is important for learning
and a number of other aspects of health.
I think that the ability to toggle back and forth
between engaged and disengaged states
and to see that whole process,
engage and disengage in the dynamic control of that
and deliberate self-control of that,
that is a superpower.
And we tend to only look at one side of the equation,
the leaning in.
I always think, the way I like to think of it
isn't so much as a seesaw
is you can either be back on your heels,
flat-footed or forward center of mass.
I stole this from Pat Doss, the founder of Made For,
did nine years in the SEAL teams.
And so I like that, that forward center of mass is great,
but it's energetically demanding
and you need to learn how to come up to just,
flat-footed every once in a while.
Now, when you're back on your heels,
that's a sign that likely you were doing
too much time forward center of mass.
No one wants to talk about this,
but people who grind, grind, grind rarely succeed
and then just take off and do something else.
I think people, humans have mastered this process
of engaging and disengaging on a longer timescale,
work hard, play hard, or they'll take a long vacation.
But what I'm talking about doing this is across the day.
I'm talking about regulating your nervous system
within the unit of the day,
or even within the unit of the morning,
or within the unit of the afternoon.
And I think that that's a much more useful,
at least to me, a much more useful time bin
to conceptualize this.
Because the idea that you're gonna sell the company
or launch the thing and then you'll rest,
okay, but you can be so much more effective
if you know how to dynamically control
your nervous system in real time.
And great athletes know how to do this.
Great musicians know how to do this.
Even within the playing of a piece of music
or within a race, they know how to reserve energy
so that then they can kick at the end.
Or in academics, you learn,
I was always on the quarter system,
which is a 10-week system.
You learn how to pace yourself through the quarter
because otherwise you're coming in screeching at the end
and you then get two weeks off and it's really stressful.
You're just trying to recover your health
and then you're back into another cycle.
So I think one of the reasons that,
I'm not superb at this, but one of the reasons
I've been at least partially successful
in maintaining a laboratory and doing a podcast
and I like to think, you can ask the people in my life,
decently effective in my personal life
is that I think all the time, am I pushing too hard?
Yes or no.
And there are times to lean, go forward center of mass.
Don't get me wrong.
But this can be done with,
forward center of mass can be done
if you want it through drinking caffeine,
in the supplements that we talked about earlier
or pharmacology we talked about earlier.
The main way to do it is to get in that kind of inspired
and motivated pursuit.
But then physiological size, non-sleep deep rest,
reverie, all of that is very useful.
But the foundation of that whole process,
there's a third layer, which is sleep.
When you're well-rested,
you're able to engage this forward center of mass
flat-footed thing at will much more easily.
When sleep suffers, everything suffers.
And so I always say, when people come to me
and they say, listen, I think I have attention deficit
or I've got anxiety.
I would just say, how's your sleep?
You want to always start with sleep.
Great sleep makes everything better.
And then once that's in place,
then you can start thinking about
some of the other processes.
Great sleep to me is you fall asleep relatively easily.
You wake up no more than once.
It's actually pretty normal to wake up
once in the middle of the night
and go use the restroom and go back to sleep.
Because a lot of people freak out when they wake up
and they're like, oh, my sleep's messed up
or their whoop score, their aura score is off.
And, you know, I don't think it's that big of a deal.
I mean, ideally you don't, but you know,
a lot of people have what's called nocturia,
which is nighttime need to urinate.
So it happens.
A couple of things that the path
to a really great night's sleep starts in the morning.
Talked about this a lot, but I'll say it again.
Wake up, if you want to be alert,
get as much bright light in your eyes as you can.
Never look at any light that's so bright
that it's painful to look at
because it can damage the eyes, but ideally sunlight.
So if you wake up at 4 a.m. and the sun isn't out,
turn on bright lights if you want to be awake.
But if the sun is out and once the sun is out,
go outside without sunglasses.
And yes, you have to go outside.
You can't do this through a window
or through a car windshield.
And get some bright light in your eyes.
It doesn't have to be beaming directly at you,
but indirectly or in the general direction
of the sun is good.
Wearing corrective lenses or contacts is fine,
even if they have UV filters.
That light can get to the neurons in the eye
that trigger a whole set of processes.
It sets in motion a big increase in cortisol,
but it's a healthy increase that leads to alertness.
Triggers an increase in body temperature,
which is important for waking up.
There's a whole set of processes there.
And it sets a timer on melatonin release
so that about 16 hours later,
your melatonin levels are gonna go up.
How long to view light?
Well, anywhere from 10 to 30 minutes,
depending on how bright it is.
If you wake up and you go outside and it's 9 a.m.
and it's beaming bright light and you're on a snow field,
it'll probably take 30 seconds.
If you're in the depths of the UK winter
and you go outside and there's a lot of cloud cover,
maybe 20 minutes.
You can check your phone out there.
You can do things out.
You can take your coffee out there.
But you have to get outside.
The window filtration is a serious issue.
Do you do that every day?
I do it every day.
And I don't get enough sun off my porch behind us.
So I will walk up the street.
My neighbor's all there.
And I walk up there with my coffee.
I often bring my journal and just kind of write down
whatever comes to mind.
Get some sun in my eyes.
My partner and I will walk up there and we'll just chat.
And then we would come back.
And you do that most days.
If you miss a day, no big deal.
If you miss two days, you're starting to drift.
And when I say drift,
I mean that these neurochemical systems
are gonna start to get out of sync with the daylight cycle.
Shift workers is a whole other business.
We don't have time.
I did an episode on shift work.
People can find that on our website
because it's very particular to shift work and jet lag.
But that morning light pulse is,
I say light pulse, light viewing is immensely important.
A drift in cortisol peak toward the later day
is a signature of depression
and waking up at three, four in the morning
and not being able to fall back asleep.
Signature of depression.
Drift in cortisol peak.
So you'll get that drift
if you don't get that light exposure early in the morning.
That's right.
And so you're gonna get a pulse
and a big increase in cortisol
at some point every 24 hours.
You want that to be early in the day
and when you want to be alert.
Now, some people wake up at 10 a.m., right?
I've got a friend who's, I consider,
you know, he's kind of a mentee of mine
and he likes to sleep in and he's a teenager.
He sleeps in.
So he's gonna wake up at 10,
but then he goes outside and he gets his sunlight.
If you wake up at five,
again, if the sun isn't out,
turn on as many bright lights as possible
and then go outside once the sun is out.
Why?
Because early in the day,
you need a lot of bright light
in order to trigger this mechanism.
Now, the second tool is that later in the day,
as the sun is heading down,
it doesn't have to just be crossing the horizon,
you also want to get light into your eyes
for the following reason.
It adjusts the sensitivity
of what we call the retinal photoreceptors,
the cells in the eye that detect light
and makes it such that nighttime light
that you're gonna get at eight or 9 p.m.
won't have as severe an effect on reducing melatonin.
So I consider it kind of your Netflix inoculation
because when you're viewing screens at night
or you're, unless you have built your house
so that all the lights are red lights
and they're really dim,
most people use artificial lighting at night
and that can mess up sleep.
So if you're really extreme about it,
you, you know, you make your house a cave at night.
I don't do that, okay?
I tend to dim the lights,
I don't like bright lights after about seven or 8 p.m.
But getting that afternoon light is great
because it sends two signals to your brain and body
about where you are in time,
meaning time is the rotation of the earth.
So you get your cortisol pulse early,
melatonin comes on,
people who start waking up late or super early
and they spend all their time on their phone,
it's not enough light to trigger
these mechanisms early in the day.
But at night, retinal sensitivity is such
that if you are looking at your phone
on full screen brightness,
or you have a lot of artificial lights on,
you're going to suppress melatonin
and you start disrupting these mechanisms.
So bright light early, bright light in the afternoon,
minimize bright light exposure in the evening,
all colors and flavors of light.
It's not just blue light.
This is gonna be responsible for a lot of sleep issues.
A ton of sleep issues.
A lot of people have written to me,
I would say thousands of people have written to me
and said, I get morning sunlight every morning
as best I can, 10 to 30 minutes,
and my sleep issues are resolved.
Now, some people do that
and their sleep issues are not still resolved.
I would say, then you look to how late in the day
are they ingesting caffeine?
Do they have a kind of rumination issue?
Are they eating enough?
I mean, one thing that is not commonly discussed
is that in order to sleep well, you have to eat enough.
Not necessarily right before sleep.
And nowadays there's a big movement
towards don't eat within two hours of sleep.
And I think it's generally a good idea.
Sometimes I obey that, sometimes I don't.
But if you don't have enough starch in your system,
sorry, low carb keto people,
but you're gonna have sleep issues
unless you do other things to offset that.
Because starches and the whole association
with the tryptophan system and the serotonin system
are part of the calming system.
There's a reason why we reach for certain
so-called comfort foods when we're stressed
is because they increase the release of serotonin
and they blunt cortisol.
So if you're just a bag of cortisol and adrenaline
and you're fasting a long period of time,
it's very hard to get quality sleep.
And I think intermittent fasting is terrific.
Sachin Panda, who really is the one
that kind of popularized this
at the scientific level anyway,
is a friend and colleague of mine, does beautiful work.
But you need to figure out how much to eat
and when to eat and what to eat
in a way that still allows you to transition to sleep.
So I'd say the light viewing early,
the light viewing in the afternoon,
avoid bright lights of all colors.
Blue blockers are fine if you like them,
but it's not just blue light
that can mess up these circadian clock systems.
Any bright light, any bright light will do that
because of the spectrum of wavelengths of light
that the neurons that are responsible for this respond.