You Shouldn’t Be Friends With Your Kids (Katharine Birbalsingh)

Journey of loving children
22 followers
3 Video Views·Jul 28, 2026
In the second speech to our 2025 Annual Conference, Katharine Birbalsingh, the Headteacher of the Michaela School, a free secondary school in Wembley which she founded in 2014, talks about the dangers of being ‘friends’ with children, whether as parents, teachers, or as a society, and how a ‘child-led’ approach in parenting, teaching, or social discourse and cultural mores leads to harmful outcomes for young people.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Hello, good morning.
So I thought we'd start with a very lovely,
all my pictures and videos I've taken off the net.
And here's just a lovely little video of, well,
some children talking about their mother
and imitating her, the sorts of things she says.
Can you hold on one second?
What is going on?
No more snacks.
Elliot and Aubrey, get down here.
I want you to try it.
Can I just have five minutes?
Are you bleeding?
Then you don't need a Band-Aid.
Keep the water in the tub.
I'm getting rid of all these twists
and sending them to Goodwill.
Who did this?
When are you going to be home?
Elliot, can I have coffee?
No.
I hear Mommy one more time.
Mommy's going to lose it.
Are you almost done yet?
I don't think I'm going to make it.
Don't knock over the laundry.
Has anybody seen my keys?
Has anyone seen my phone?
I didn't.
I'm just going to let them walk away.
First one to find my phone gets a piece of candy.
Why do I bother cleaning?
That's enough for me for just five minutes.
Why is Aubrey so quiet?
Anyone seen Aubrey?
Now say, I'm sorry.
They'll give each other a hug.
No more changing into outfits.
I have an idea.
Let's play the silent game.
Go to sleep.
Do what you get and you don't throw a fit.
There's nothing you can say and there's nothing you can do.
So keep me from loving you.
Because we will always love you.
I love you.
No, you can't watch a show.
OK, fine, you can watch a show.
Doesn't it just make your heart sing?
Because children are just the most wonderful things.
All of us are smiling and laughing when we see them.
And of course, you know, that mum,
when they're imitating their mother,
it's because they're so difficult, aren't they?
You know, that's what makes them so lovely,
is that they're so challenging.
They always keep you on your toes.
And mums and dads and teachers and all of us adults
are made so much better for having children in the world.
My next slide here is a lovely quote
that I'm always showing my families at school.
You can be friends with your children when they are children
or when they are adults.
You cannot be both, OK?
And that is so important.
You have a lovely photo that I took off the net here
with a mum and her three boys
and then much later when they are adults.
Now, we do have to choose, you know.
If we are friends with our children,
then we are not doing our duty for our children.
We're not doing what's right by them.
And in the end, when they are adults,
they'll be people who you might not like very much.
And that is why you're not going to be friends with them
when they're adults.
You've got to choose.
We're not meant to be friends,
whether you are parents or teachers or adults.
You could be an auntie, an uncle, doesn't matter.
You are not meant to be friends.
You're not meant to indulge them.
You're not meant to give them what they want.
You're meant to do what's right by them,
and that is hard,
which is why that mum in the first video is saying,
what are you coming home to her husband?
Because it's so hard to do the right thing by your children.
Now, how are new parents friends with their children?
So I'm about to read out some stories.
This is just from one of my teachers.
Every single one of my teachers has stories like this
from all of their various friends who have young children.
So, sleeping babies.
I have one friend who said her baby didn't sleep.
But what she meant was that she wouldn't put the baby down to sleep
because when she did, he would cry.
So to get her baby to sleep, she would put him in a carrier.
As a tiny newborn, it was just about doable.
But by the time he was a two-year-old and weighed 15 kilos,
he would still only sleep when attached to her.
So you can imagine these poor mums.
They think that they can't put their children down
because otherwise they are bad mothers.
Here's another one.
The same teacher is telling me these stories.
I have another friend who slept with her first baby.
She's now had a second baby, so her first baby is nearly five.
And I sort of naively thought that at least it was something
that the baby would eventually grow out of.
But no, she sleeps with their newborn baby
and her husband sleeps in another bed with the five-year-old.
So as a married couple,
they don't go to bed at the same time in the same room
because they're both co-sleeping with their children
who would go absolutely bananas if they were left by either parent.
Now, just think about what that does to a married couple,
what that does to a family.
It breaks the family.
I mean, it's mad that a five-year-old...
Think about what it does to the children
who are then so attached to their parents,
they're unable to sleep on their own.
Now, what about the traditional parents?
So what my teachers will tell me,
those people dare not admit that they've sleep-trained,
even though it gives babies a really, really happy life
because people say it's extreme.
I have another friend who said she did some sleep-training
to her friend who is a psychologist,
and the response was,
as a child psychologist, I cannot believe
that you would ever do something like sleep-training.
People who sleep-train are terrified to tell anyone that they sleep-train
because it helps babies grow and mature,
it helps their emotional development,
it helps the parents too.
These people can't speak out
because they're so worried about judgment.
So just think about it.
Now, I know everyone in the room here,
lots of your friends and so on will all be conservatives,
so you might look at this and think, who on earth are these people?
But I can tell you that, I mean, they're all over the place.
This is what young people are going through all of the time
when having their children.
Then I have another friend who again said the baby wouldn't sleep.
She just wouldn't leave him to cry or to make sounds,
so the baby would make a funny noise, as babies do,
and she would go, oh, he just won't settle,
and she'd grab him and pick him up again.
She went to bed every night at 6pm with her baby
so her baby could sleep in her bed on top of her
so she wouldn't have any semblance of a normal life at all.
This was until baby was 6 months old.
She was worried, obviously, about babies in beds being a little bit dangerous,
so the remedy to this was to take the duvet off the bed.
They live in the northwest of England.
It's blooming cold up there.
Having got rid of the duvet,
she had to put loads of clothes on before going to bed.
Eventually, it became a bit too much,
so she paid a sleep consultant to come and tell her what to do.
The sleep consultant arrived at 4pm and said,
OK, this starts tonight.
Here's what you're going to do.
You're going to put the baby in bed at 7pm,
then you're going to walk out and shut the door.
That'll be £500, please.
This is what is happening.
This is happening all over the place.
These are not exceptional stories.
This is the norm.
This is how children are starting out in life.
These are the pressures.
Culture matters.
So my school, Michaela,
we wrote a book with lots of the teachers.
We put all these essays together about what we do.
It's called The Power of Culture
because culture is everything.
So while we can all know the stats and so on,
the reason why I'm talking about popular culture
and the general media culture
and the culture that my teachers and young people are under at the moment
is because you can quote as many stats as you like to them.
It will make no difference if we do not change the culture.
Now, how are teachers in our schools friends with their pupils?
I just talked about being friends with babies.
How are we friends with our pupils?
So teachers let the children lead the teaching and the learning
and the culture and the expectations.
It's child-centered learning, not teacher-led learning.
Now, obviously, the teacher isn't sitting at the desk in that picture I've got there,
but that might as well be the case
because the children may be at the desks,
but they're the ones making the decisions.
This little girl who's on the net,
I just wish we could actually learn from her
because, I tell you, what I always say to my teachers when they join,
I say, forget about what you've learned in your teacher training.
Forget about what everyone's told you to do.
I want you to think back to when you were young
and you put your stuffed animals in front of you
and you taught them because you thought one day you might be a teacher.
And then I want you to go back to doing exactly what was just,
you know, it was just natural to you.
You just thought, well, how do I teach?
Well, this is how you teach, like this little girl.
Hi, everyone. Welcome to my class.
Today we're going to be learning about numbers.
Now repeat after me.
One.
Two.
Three.
Four.
Now, that, you might think, is what's happening in our classrooms across the country.
I can tell you it most certainly is not.
What is she doing that's odd?
She's getting them all to repeat after her.
She is leading the learning.
The stuffed animals are not.
Now, in our classrooms, it is not the teachers who are leading the learning.
She's even using a stick.
I mean, even at my very conservative school, we do not use sticks.
And yet she is because she's doing what comes natural to her and is the right way to teach.
The natural ideas that come to us are all beaten out of us with teacher training.
Is it any surprise that Bridget Philipson at the moment is pushing through the school's bill,
which will force everyone to be trained to make sure that they're nothing like this girl.
Now, how are our cultural institutions, because it's not just our schools,
it's not just the parents with the parents who are under the influence of other parents.
Our cultural institutions are trying to be friends with our children.
Now, look, for instance, this is the RSC putting on some, as you know, I'm a great fan of Shakespeare,
some lovely Shakespeare plays.
How do they advertise the schools to say, come and watch us?
Well, because if you're if you're daring enough to teach Shakespeare in your school,
well, you can go and watch Othello and the anti-bias and anti-racist methods which acknowledge
the racist history of this play to approach contemporary study of the text staging of the play.
So not to worry. I know he's dead white and male, but we will be talking all about the anti-racism
just to make you feel better about your white guilt now.
Or you can watch The Merchant of Venice approaching the play with an anti-racist lens
to address and combat anti-Semitism, anti-black racism and other forms of prejudice.
Exercises that invite critical thinking. I underline that because I love how they're
always talking about critical thinking when they're the last people on Earth who have any idea how to
how to think critically because they all think in exactly the same manner.
Then we've got the Tempest over here, critical discussions about the racism and sexism in the play
and how to approach these topics in contemporary classrooms.
Resources thinking about environmental issues and current affairs linked to the themes in the play.
Now, look, I mean, obviously, I don't I don't have a problem with talking about these issues.
But when that's the thing, I mean, that's the thing that you're going to watch and talk about.
That's your main point. You can include it. But why is it the thing?
Right. Why is it all we think Shakespeare is worthy of seeing?
And the problem is the RSC itself is under pressure.
Everyone's under pressure to to follow this this this new trend, which I have to say, it's since George Floyd,
you know, that I mean, it was always it's always been the case for some time, you know, in my career.
But it really has just multiplied exponentially since George Floyd.
So how are more experienced parents friends with their children?
Now, the worst of it is the social media. So from when they're little, those little girls at the beginning,
you know, even younger than that, now children are being given smartphones and it's because the parents are exhausted.
They're having to co-sleep with their children. They're doing all the wrong things.
So they're so tired, they're unable to do the right sorts of things.
And then they say, just have the smartphone because I just need a break.
I can't do it. Right. And so they're given these smartphones and then the children have access to social media.
When we first opened Michaela in 2014, you know, in those first few years.
So I still do a welcome event for our parents before the child, the children start in year seven.
And that is because in 10 years ago, it was the case that I could catch them before having given.
It was always that summer before they started secondary school that the parents would give them a phone before they started secondary school.
So I would meet with them in May and I would say that I know the plan.
Don't give them the phone when they come in September. Not only should they not be bringing a phone into school,
you should not have given them a phone at all. And then I explain my reasons why.
Nowadays, I find that huge numbers have had phones for years before they start secondary school.
Some of them have had those phones practically from birth. OK, and the damage that it does to the brain.
We all know anyway, all of us in here will think, oh, you know, we're on our phones a lot.
Oh, my goodness. Actually, ourselves, that we as adults are affected in terms of our concentration span.
Well, think about what that does to the young children growing up.
And anecdotally, I can tell you that at my school, all of the children, the top set.
Well, vast majority of the children in the top set do not have a smartphone.
They don't own a smartphone and they don't own a smartphone because of the strong encouragement.
And that that strong is somewhat an understatement that that we give to families to make sure that they don't get them phones.
And I can tell you for nothing that the entire bottom set all have phones.
That is not a coincidence. And that's every year. I've never known it to be any different, you know, for the last 10 years.
Now, now I want to show you. I mean, and this is just on a on a level of, you know, I mean, I showed this the other night.
I showed this and many others. So this is when I say strong encouragement.
I had a year nine parents evening. The parents evening is not them talking to the teachers.
It's them hearing from me and they sit like you and I talk to them. And most of the evening, I'm not talking about homework diaries.
I'm talking about the Internet because I know how destructive it is.
We I actually sell brick phones to the families for twelve pounds.
We buy them for 19 pounds. And I explain this to the families that I'm making a loss on those phones because that's what I want them to give their children,
because they put their children in such danger by giving them a smartphone.
This is a little experiment that was done by two by these women who create an image of an 11 year old and they put it online and they create a social media account for the 11 year old.
And then they press the timer on their phone to see how quickly it takes for the pedophiles to come.
A parent might assume Bailey would be insulated from any sort of predatory attack.
We launched our 11 year old persona online for 44 and go from a guy whose profile photo is a penis.
One one minute and seven seconds.
We have a message request, although this sorry, two more requests just came in.
How much time? A minute and 40 seconds. Yeah.
How old are you? You go to the profile. You know that that is a child.
It also says in the profile that the child is in sixth grade.
Another one. It's just lighting up like the inbox is just boom, boom, boom, boom.
An incoming video call in less than five minutes.
I can't see you. Don't be shy.
They all say don't be shy.
Few parents know just how dangerous these platforms are for so many kids.
So we brought some on sites they could see for themselves.
Eleven year old Bailey's persona was approached with an even more disturbing level of manipulation and requests.
While the majority of the abuse happened from a distance, our child profiles also received requests to meet up in person, especially our 15 year old persona.
I don't think parents have any idea.
You know, I showed this to my families.
I also showed them there's a woman called Ellen Room, who I know, who is an extraordinarily brave woman who's sadly her 14 year old died.
She believes because she was he was trying to do one of these tick tock challenges and blackout challenge.
And I had her leave me a voice note warning my families about what could happen to their children.
I played that for them.
And then I played a video of her of her website where she's explaining about the day when she found her son dead in his room.
And, you know, I felt I'd achieved something because a number of my moms were crying when I finished my meeting and that I do this.
And that's why I have an entire my top sets without phones, you know, and that's all I managed to achieve.
You know, now, obviously, there are no phones in my school, you know, but we're at the next level of trying to make sure that our children don't have phones at all.
And I could I could spend five hours talking to you about the ins and outs about phones.
I mean, what these women have just shown you here.
And we've written that just to make sure our parents pedophiles so that they understand.
So our parents don't speak English like we do.
It's just it's it's so people don't we just don't understand what's going on on the ground.
Right. What young parents are up against what?
Imagine if you have, you know, my my teachers, because they're quite young and and and Western, I have to say, you know, they they tend to their friends only have one or two children and they're struggling.
What if you have four or five children?
You know, how are you meant to cope with all of this?
Will you give them smartphones?
You know, our families say to us, well, what else are we meant to do with them?
And then because culturally everything's changed.
So in the day 20 years ago, I used to say, you know, get them off the TV.
We don't want them on the TV. We want them reading.
Now I'm begging them to go on the TV.
And I'm saying, please, because at least you watch Coronation Street.
There's a narrative that they can follow.
Right. And they're not on social media because social media, they're in genuine danger.
And then I mean, and I haven't even gotten I don't have time to get into the broken brain scenario and how they're not able their brains literally like people talk about Gen Z.
Yes. And how it's a problem. Right.
I'm telling you that Gen Z are the way they are because they were brought up on social media and they literally are not they're not able to own something and strategize and own their own development because of the way in which social media behaves.
Bing, bing, bing. And they can't see things through.
People complain about Gen Z. I am telling you, it is because of the world of social media.
Jonathan Haidt is very good on this.
All of his stuff in Anxious Generation, I would suggest reading.
Abigail Schreier is really good on this.
I mean, Andrew Huberman, the neuroscientist is really good on this.
I mean, there's so much you can read.
But the thing is, because there is such the parents are exhausted.
They don't know what else to do.
And plus there they then say, well, the child says, but my my friends are online, so I have to be online.
And then what are they meant to do?
Which is why the government needs to intervene.
And what I would say to this audience, because I know many of you because you're right leaning.
There are too many people on the right saying, but we need freedom.
We need freedom. Look, freedom only works in a socially conservative society.
Right. Freedom. I'm all for freedom.
But that's when there's a sense of shame in us so that we behave in such a way because we care about our duty.
There is honor and strength in the way that we behave and we care about that.
And that's what keeps us in line.
If, on the other hand, we say, oh, all that matters are individuals and that individual freedom is all that matters.
Then then this is what happens.
Well, the other video, that is what happens.
Eleven year old and they're vulnerable.
They don't know. It's what I say to my families.
I say, you think it's not going to happen to your child.
And constantly I have families coming in to see me and they say, well, it's my child.
He's a good boy. He's in the top set.
And I say, yes, yes, you should have listened to me.
Well, now let's get him off the phone.
And then when we do get the children off the phone, all of the families say, oh, my goodness, I've got my boy back.
Oh, my goodness. He was so horrible and nasty.
And now he's turned back into a sweet, lovely self.
They change because of that social media.
So how parents and our general culture undermine schools.
This is an advertisement.
OK, yeah, I can see you've got one.
So what I'm going to do is.
He's done what?
Bloody hell.
Absolutely.
We'll be having words now.
Thank you.
Right, come on.
Robinson's real love in every job.
So this is an advertisement, right?
The boy has been so badly behaved that he's been sent home from school.
Now, once upon a time, there would have been some sense of, oh, my goodness, my parents know.
But when the teachers cannot turn to the parents because that is how the parents behave.
And I don't think that this is unusual.
I mean, this happens all over the place.
But then this is just being encouraged by Robinson's.
I mean, this is part of our popular culture.
Right. This is just normal that an undiversity and everybody watches it and goes, oh, isn't it funny?
Isn't it lovely? Oh, look at her, you know, connecting with her boy when he has just been.
I mean, he'll have beaten up another child.
He'll have done something terrible to send a child home.
It requires some really bad behavior.
Right. And that is her reaction as parents.
Now, everyone talks about leaving a better planet for our children.
Why doesn't anyone try to leave better children for our planet?
Well, I don't understand this.
There's no point in campaigning for the environment if our children are in a complete mess.
And one of the things that I keep saying to everybody is that children are the future.
Whitney Houston got this right.
She got lots of things wrong, but she got that bit right.
Children are the future.
OK, and I don't understand.
And I have to say it's not just the left.
I think that this is the case on the right as well.
I don't think people seem to understand just how important.
I think the right are very good when it comes to families.
They understand the impact of families and they care about them.
And that's really good.
Where I think the right goes wrong is that they don't understand the impact of schools.
People, everyone ignores schools everywhere.
And unless we get our schools to understand what's right for children,
I am telling you, we're all done.
Right. The family cannot compete against the school.
It just can't.
The family cannot compete against the peers and the teachers and the culture that the school creates.
It cannot do it.
So, yes, of course, talk about the importance of families.
100 percent, you know, everything James is saying about the family, 100 percent agree.
But we also need to be talking about schools.
And I realize, you know, James, what we're talking about schools.
He's not an expert at schools.
But and unfortunately, there aren't enough teachers who will be able to speak about schools in the way that I would.
But the fact is that we need we just need to be talking about it more and looking, you know,
if I was telling you about Panty Bliss, this will be news to you.
You know, this is happening all the time.
And when Jordan Peterson talks about the universities and how awful it is, what's going on in universities,
listen, they've already been brainwashed at school.
OK, that's why they they fall so easily at university.
That's why that poor girl is being harassed for carrying a book by Helen Joyce,
because they've already been brainwashed at school.
Now, how can you be in authority over your child?
When you talk about being in authority as opposed to the children leading,
you recognize that being in authority does not mean you're being an authoritarian.
We get the two confused all the time.
You embrace being the leader and therefore happily carry the responsibility that comes with being a leader.
Now, because I do think lots of this is people don't want the responsibility of being a leader.
They'd rather share it out.
And the number of teachers who say, well, I learn just as much from my children as the children learn from me.
And I always think, well, you must be a pretty rubbish teacher then.
I mean, it's just ridiculous.
You recognize this is your duty as a parent or as a teacher or frankly, as any adult.
Right. It takes a village to raise a child.
OK, you try to move from being now this quote here.
Try to move from being in authority to an authority.
Really shows me how things have changed.
So when I first started teaching and I was a PGC student and I was in my placement school and the deputy head,
all the children were terrified of.
And they were it was a crazy school.
There was loads of nonsense going on everywhere.
When they turn up at his store, they always made sure they had their pens and they were always perfect.
And he was giving us some training as new teachers.
And he said, you need to move from being in authority to an authority.
And what's interesting now is that we're not even in authority.
Being an authority went out the window a long time ago.
We don't even want to be in authority at all anymore.
You enjoy teaching the child, take pride in their accomplishments, knowing that their success is your success.
You know, I've always said for 25 years, however long I've been teaching, you know, I've always said to the children,
if you fail, I failed and I don't like to fail.
And that that is what all parents and all teachers should understand.
Now, what does authority in action look like?
Well, you tell your child what to do.
I don't understand what the problem is.
You tell children what to do.
I don't understand why we're asking them what they want.
We tell them what to do.
We're the adults. We know better.
Don't feel bad about telling them what to do.
Remember that as an adult, that's your role to teach and instill good habits.
OK, it's by instilling those good habits that eventually they'll be able to tell their own children what to do.
Use praise and punishment to support you and the child.
And that doesn't mean being mean to the child.
Love the child.
Narrate your love.
You've got to tell them how much you love them, but also tell them, look at what I've done for you.
I've marked all these books for you because I love you so much or I care about you.
I care about your exams.
Or as a parent, look at this.
I've made your favorite tonight for dinner.
That's how much I love you.
And then you're going to get on that homework later.
That that is what needs to happen.
Hold the line.
OK, I mean, I have actually in my office, my my my staff gave me a big cut out of Russell Crowe in Gladiator of Maximus with a thing sticking out of his mouth saying hold the line.
And that is because I'm constantly quoting.
They're about to go to battle, the Romans.
And he gets his generals, whatever, together on the horses.
And he says to them, hold the line.
Stay with me.
What we do in life echoes in eternity.
And that is, you know, and in those days, you know, there was no Christianity.
I mean, there was just a real sense of you don't have to be a Christian to understand this point, which is that what we do in life echoes in eternity.
You know, that's why you you you you celebrate in the children's achievements, knowing that you are partly responsible for that because you've got them there now here.
So this boy, I mean, I'm just taking him off the Internet, but my deputy gave a talk to the staff the other day in our training, one of our training sessions.
And he was talking about his own little boy.
And so things Michael would like to have control over is what he said, said Michael would like to have control over because in some households where Michael would be leading the learning or leading everything.
So if we want to let children lead, well, then he could lead on all of that.
Now, fact is that in that in my deputy's household, the things that Michael actually has control over, none of those.
But he does have control over which of his carefully selected books he wants to read first and which piece of broccoli he is going to eat first.
OK, so little Michael feels as if he has control over something.
Now, I haven't even got into and I know that I'm not going to, you know, the discipline issues in school, right?
I mean, again, I could talk to you for five hours about the discipline issues in schools.
No one has any idea. People don't realize just how bad it is. Teachers know. They all know.
They know what I'm talking about. Everyone else says, oh, you must be lying. You obviously want to be a politician.
I'm always like, well, obviously, if I want to be a politician, I'd be a politician, wouldn't I? I mean, I would certainly be it by now.
I love my school. I love teaching. I love children. It's what I do.
They have got no unity to the school. They have they're teaching them all the wrong things.
They're not giving them a sense of British history, a sense of belonging to to to their country.
They're not instilling authority in their teachers so that they can stand at the front of the classroom and lead and then give demerits and detentions where necessary.
I have to defend these days giving detentions. It's mad.
OK, obviously, a school should be giving detentions. Now, as I said, you can be friends with your children when they are children or when they are adults.
You can't be both. And when you're holding that line, I just want to show you a video where there are alternatives to smartphones.
Here is one.
Right. So when you're holding the line, there's always a glass of wine at the end of the night.
Thank you.
