How a Minor Car Accident Can Become a MAJOR Settlement.

Auto Insurance
2 followers
#CarAccident #MinorCollision #MajorSettlement
You got rear-ended at a stoplight. The damage looks minor. The other driver seems cooperative. So you think, "Do I really need a lawyer for this?"
But a few days later your neck is still stiff, the other driver's story starts to shift, and the insurance company is suddenly dragging its feet.
Chris Blackburn and Chad Romey, Indiana personal injury attorneys, have seen minor crashes turn into serious legal and financial problems when people try to handle them alone. This video walks you through when it makes sense to call a lawyer and when it doesn't.
AI Generated·May contain errors
You got rear-ended at a stoplight. The damage looks minor, and the other driver seems cooperative.
So you think, do I really need a lawyer for this? But a few days later, your neck's still stiff.
The other driver's story starts to shift a little bit, and the insurance company's suddenly
dragging its feet. I'm Chad Romey, and this is Chris Blackburn, and we're Indiana personal
injury attorneys. And we've seen small crashes turn into serious legal headaches when people
try to handle them alone. This video walks you through when it makes sense to call a lawyer
and when it doesn't, so you don't get stuck paying out of pocket, missing deadlines that
can kill your claim, or taking a settlement that doesn't cover your medical bills.
So when we talk about minor accident, when can minor damage still lead to, if you will,
major problems? A lot of cases, we represent a lot of people who have been in what the insurance
company would call a minor damage type case. So minor damage, sometimes it's going to be
even just a scratch on a bumper. Those can be very difficult cases to prosecute on behalf
of your clients because the contention is that, well, if there's no damage to the car,
there's no damage to the person or the occupants in the car. That can lead to a lot of major
problems, especially if instances, if the treatment has been minor in and of itself.
But when you start getting into the treatment, you've got to dissect it. And the biggest advice
we could give you at the beginning is, if you are hurting, go to the doctor, follow up the
doctor's advice, and try not to avoid or prolong gaps between when you saw a doctor or did physical
therapy, some time went by, and then you go back to the doctor. Yeah. So I think when we're saying
minor accidents, we really are talking about what's the visual damage to the vehicle.
I was in an accident a few years back, and I tell you, when that person hit me, it wasn't quite a
T-bone. It felt like the back half of my car got ripped off. And when I got out, I could see the
damage, but it was not nearly what I thought it was going to be. It just ended up being some
scratches. And so it's that minor damage where insurance companies will really start to press
you on it saying, well, gosh, like I said, if the car was barely damaged, then you must not have
been damaged either. So even for small injuries, though, these medical bills can start to add up.
So don't ignore the minor pain complaints you're having just because you think, gosh,
I shouldn't be hurt. I shouldn't be hurt because my car doesn't look that bad. And so you kind
of grin and bear it. With respect to medical bills, it is amazing the amount that some of
the providers will charge. So generally what we see in our area here in Northern Indiana,
an ambulance runs maybe $1,500. When you get to the hospital, depending on which hospital it is,
even though it's what seems at first blush a minor type case, you get the bill or the client
gets the bill and it's $30,000 because they've seen multiple doctors, they've had x-rays to
all parts of their bodies. And that bill can be a tougher aspect of the case, especially if
there isn't a lot of follow-up care. Defenses are going to be, well, they're not that hurt.
There's not a lot of damage to the car. And the majority of their bill is diagnostic in nature.
Yeah. And I think when we talk about finer impact cases, ultimately we're talking about,
how do you go about dealing with the insurance company? And handling these types of minor
claims on your own can be very risky. And the reason that they're risky is these are the claims
that insurance companies are designed to defend. They have come up with very sophisticated defenses
for what are called MIST cases, M-I-S-T, minor impact soft tissue cases. And the reason that
they have, they've come up with such sophisticated defenses for these is because it's the most common
case. Most cases that we handle do not involve missing limbs or broken bones. They involve
rear end collisions that cause somebody's neck or spine to do something that wasn't designed to do.
So it's sore. Sometimes it's sore for a couple of weeks. Sometimes it just never gets better.
And so these are the types of cases where insurance companies really, really dig their
heels in. So you do need to be careful. I think if you're the type of person that
really wants to research it, you can go research Allstate and Colossus, their computer program that
they invented in the early nineties. And then they were really at the forefront of the MIST
cases and the MIST defenses. Yeah. So adjusters are going to be real friendly to you typically,
but remember their goal is to resolve your claim for as little as they can. So just be very,
very careful for when you're looking at some of the common adjuster tactics in these types of
cases, quick settlement offers, right? If usually a quick settlement offer is not going to be a good
one, it's just going to be a quick one. So if it's not life changing money, there's no reason
to jump into settling the claim for the amount. You wait until you're done getting better to
resolve your claim. Another, they're going to ask for recorded statements. They're going to maybe
be looking at you for partially blaming you for the accident to reduce what they owe. Ultimately,
they're just trying to save their company money because it's a bit for-profit business on the
other side. Let's touch on the early settlement offers just a little bit, because it's a tactic
that's been around for a while, but it just seems like it's becoming more prevalent and the lawyers
in our office and Chad and I, we've seen a lot more of them here recently, but there are certainly
times where prospective clients have come to us with their offers and we'll simply tell whoever
it is that, I don't think you need a lawyer in this case. In fact, based on what you're telling
me, and if you're not going to get any additional medical treatment and you're done, then that's,
yeah, I would take that. But what you want to do is before you just take that blind or initial
offer or the quick offer from the insurance company, it never hurts to talk to a lawyer
because generally, I mean, we're going to talk to you for free. Yeah. It doesn't hurt to have
that conversation for sure. One thing that is most common in these minor impact cases,
I think it's more common in these cases than in cases where, gosh, it was a huge impact and
there's all sorts of first responders on the scene and they have to cut people out of the
vehicles with the jaws of life. One thing that folks in minor impact cases have to deal with
is, again, a new strategy and it's not by insurance companies, but it's by some chiropractors. So
in these minor type cases, you might get a call. I mean, I've had clients who have gotten a call
from somebody who was pretending to be an insurance adjuster that says, hey, look, we're
just going to set you up with your treatment plan. And somebody who's never been in an accident before
doesn't know that that's not how it works. And then so sure enough, this is not an insurance
company calling to set you up on a treatment plan. This is a calling service or calling agent or
a chiropractor's office who is funneling you to one particular medical provider. You want to be
very, very careful of calls like that. And it happens more often in these minor impact cases.
I've had clients go to treatment that they had no intention of going to. I've talked to other
lawyers who've had their clients go get treatment that they didn't need and they were never going
to treat at all. And all of a sudden they have $30,000 worth of chiropractic unpaid bills because
they also don't use your health insurance. So that's just something to be really, really careful
about if you've been in a minor impact case. Yeah. It's kind of one of those things that
doesn't happen all that often, but it's something that you've got to be aware of,
especially because it's hidden. You've got no idea. So along with that, the insurance companies
are going to have you sign a lot of paperwork. They're going to be documenting everything.
And so at that point, okay, well, do I need a lawyer to handle this? Is this something that
I'm capable of handling? Those are questions you're going to have to ask yourself along with,
well, one of the concerns too, we hear all the time is, well, are you going to take everything
or am I going to get anything out of this if my bills are taken care of, you've got to get paid
and then there's a cost. And so quite simply speaking, the answer to that is, well, we
wouldn't be in business if we were the ones getting the most out of the case. But those
are things that you as a prospective client should be looking at in terms of, well, what's the cost
to me? What's the cost to the attorney? What are you guys taking? What about the stress? Do I have
the ability to take care of this myself? There's cases we'll take that are very small in nature,
simply because they don't want to deal with it. It's worth it to them to say, Chris, Chad,
I think I could do this, but I don't have the time and I don't want the stress in my life.
Just you take care of it. Call me if you get a settlement and then we'll go from there.
And there are some law firms, every law firm has different parameters of the types of cases they're
going to take in. Some law firms look, hey, if your case isn't over a certain value, our law
firm is just not interested in it. We operate a little bit differently. We do want to help
everybody out, even if you have a small case. It might not make sense for some law firms to
take it, but ours is built in order to handle those. When you should, after a minor impact,
there are instances in which you absolutely should consider calling a lawyer. If you have injuries
at all, even if you don't have injuries at the scene, but gosh, you wake up the next day
and you're sure. It doesn't mean just because you call a lawyer that you're going to be suing
somebody, but it's all about getting questions answered upfront. Or that you're even going to
hire the lawyer. Really what you're doing is you're just getting a little bit more information
so that you can protect yourself. Or if the insurance company is disputing who is at fault,
if you're getting offers that you don't know if they're fair or not, if you're getting those calls
from random insurance companies or people pretending to be insurance companies who are
trying to direct your medical care. Or the insurance company is not calling you at all.
Yeah. Or if insurance company is calling and asking for things, like they want you to sign
some documents or they want to take a record a statement. And if the accident involves,
even if it's a minor accident, if it involves a ride share, like an Uber or a Lyft, those can be
very complicated. So you might want to call a lawyer just to have discussions about that or
a commercial vehicle. Touch on the Uber, the ride share. So Uber, DoorDash, Lyft, Uber Eats,
those types of things. Pretty severely injured clients and we were trying to preserve the
vehicle. There was an allegation that she was driving for Uber. And this is one that a lawyer
was definitely needed from the onset because what we were trying to do is send out letters
of preservation to preserve that vehicle. And so Uber was there in the background, but the insurance,
the personal insurance was not ignoring our phone calls. And it's been probably about 45, 60 days
here. And we just received communication from an actual defense lawyer. The vehicle was preserved,
but we put a lot, we put a tremendous amount of work sending out letters and making phone calls
to two or three different insurance companies, a personal attorney and multiple tow yards,
Indian auto auction, trying to track down this particular vehicle.
Yeah. So there's a lot of work that can go on even in minor car actions. That one didn't sound
like it was a minor. That one was not minor. So I don't know if that fit in here at all.
Well, it does because the question, do you need a lawyer?
Yeah. So when you might not need lawyers, if there are absolutely no injuries,
you can still call a lawyer to see if there's anything that needs to happen. But if you don't
have any injuries, typically a lawyer is just not going to add a tremendous amount of value to the
claim. There's really small property damage. If you're not getting a dispute over the value of
repairs, meaning, hey, your bumper's busted up a little bit and they're willing to put on a new
bumper for you. You probably don't need a lawyer for that if there's no injuries and they're
replacing the damage and they're not saying you're at fault for the accident.
I touched on the injuries too. So we're talking about would be physical injuries. So I've got
neck pain, I've got back pain, or I've cut myself. If there are no injuries, you haven't
been checked out, you still probably have a case, but you probably don't need a lawyer at that
point. If you have mental or emotional type injuries, those tend to get a little bit more
complicated. Not always, but that's probably something that you should definitely talk to
a lawyer about. How does a physical injury compare to a mental injury? What's the difference there?
Do I need your help with that type of case? Yeah. If you don't have a mental or emotional,
I guess, injuries or trauma from it, you don't have physical injuries,
one thing you probably don't need a lawyer for is, well, what if I would have got injured? Gosh,
that could have been really bad. Absolutely. I have clients say that to me all the time.
This is funny because I had a client who kept telling me, well, what if I would have died?
What if I would have died? Well, sir, and he's a great client. You didn't die, but I want them
to pay for my funeral. He didn't die. I can't do that. That's not allowed under Indian law,
but I wanted to. I almost died. I want them to pay for my funeral. He wouldn't need a lawyer
for that, but maybe for the rest of his case. Ultimately, if you're just confused as to whether
you need a lawyer or not, you can always call and get a consultation. Most lawyers will handle that
consultation for free. Even though an accident is seemingly small, it can still lead to a lot
of problems. One of my biggest jury results ever was for an auto accident. This case lasted five
years and you could barely see the damage, but she just never got better. Just because it's minor
doesn't mean it's going to be minor forever. Medical bills and lost wages can start to add up.
These are costs you do need to pay attention to if you're going to handle it on your own.
You got to remember insurance companies are not on your side. I don't care how nice they
are to you. Ultimately, there's a profit motive for their business. What they're trying to do is
resolve claims in a way that makes sense on their side, not necessarily on yours. Sometimes if you
have a minor claim and the attorney agrees it's minor, but the attorney is willing to handle it
for you, it might still make sense to let the attorney do it just because it's peace of mind
for you. You know it's going to be done right and you don't have to worry about it. It takes
some of the stress out of it. Most lawyers will offer you a free consultation and they're going
work on a contingency fee, which means they get paid out of a settlement. Most lawyers do not get
paid, at least the ones I'm aware of, are not getting paid if they help you resolve your
property damage. Some lawyers aren't going to help you at all with your property damage, but
most will at least make some calls or send some letters, but usually those parts of the claims
will resolve themselves in clear cut cases. Here in Indiana, property damages, I don't want to say
it's clear or clear cut, but there are other states where property damages is actually a
bigger deal, it's a bigger issue, and lawyers generally don't get involved in that aspect and
they'll make money off of it. Here at our firm, if we handle your property damage, it's just
something that we will do and help with, but we're not taking a fee off of it.
Yeah. If you're still on the fence, here's what I recommend. Take 15 minutes, talk to a lawyer,
see if it makes sense for you to hire them, see if it makes sense for them to take the case.
It could save you a world of stress, time, and money down the line. If you want to be
really prepared, here's your next step. Check out our next video, which is five questions
that insurance adjusters don't want you to ask. In that video, we show you the exact questions
that can shake up your case, stop the insurance company from taking advantage of you,
and make sure you get every dollar that you're entitled to. Don't miss it. Your rights could
depend on it. We will see you there and I'll probably be wearing the same blue sweater.
