Drink Wine To This: I Put France vs. Spain In A Wine FIGHT — Bordeaux Wine vs. Priorat Wine Region

World of Grape Wine
21 followers
1 Video View·Jul 24, 2026
I poured a full bottle of Bordeaux wine and a full bottle of Priorat from the Priorat wine region— then drank both. Here's what happened to my palate. 🍷
Grab a glass. This is Drink Wine To — the whole bottle wine review format whereyou pour something you love and watch while you drink it. Tonight:
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedA sommelier conducts a comparative tasting of a 2018 Château Smith Haut Lafitte (Bordeaux) and a 2021 Clos Mogador (Priorat). By utilizing a philosophy of contrast and a structured five-step evaluation process, the reviewer analyzes the aromatic profiles, regional typicity, and the evolution of both wines from the first sip to the final glass of the bottle.
You know that feeling you get when you sit down
with a great bottle of well-made wine
and the rest of the world just slows down?
That's what this is.
Tonight, I'm not rushing.
I'm not scoring these wines in the first 30 seconds
and moving on.
I'm drinking them.
The whole bottle of each.
One tonight, one next week,
and I'm inviting you to join me
with whatever you have in your glass right now.
This is Drink Wine 2.
And if you've never seen this before, it's simple.
Pour yourself a glass of wine, your glass,
whatever you've got,
because this wine video is designed to be experienced
while you drink excellent wine.
Go pour yourself a glass right now.
Oh, wait, seriously, pause this video,
go get it, come back.
The next 30 minutes or so is gonna be a lot better
with something in your hand.
Tonight, we have two wines that, on paper,
have absolutely nothing in common.
And that's exactly why I've put them
right next to each other.
This is a 2018 Chateau au Lafite
from Passac-Le-Hague in Bordeaux.
It's a classified Cru Classé de Graves,
Cabernet Sauvignon Dominant, French to the bone.
It cost me around 160 bucks.
I'm not hiding that.
You deserve to know what we're dealing with tonight.
And this is a 2021 Clos Mogador
from Priorat in Catalonia, Spain.
It's made by René Barbier,
one of the five founding winemakers
who essentially recreated Priorat
as a world-class wine region in the 1980s.
A lot of great things happened in the 80s.
Grenache and Keurignan,
grown in these two famous black Licorella slate soils
that you cannot replicate anywhere else on the world.
This one sent me back about 120 bucks.
Different countries, different grapes,
different soils, different philosophies.
One elegant, structured Bordeaux.
One wild, volcanic, Spanish mountain wine.
Why would anyone drink these side by side?
Because drinking them together
is going to change how you taste both of them.
And that, honestly,
is the most interesting thing about wine.
And we're going to get into that all through this video.
Here's the thing about your palate.
It works by contrast.
The more different flavor experiences
you give it in the same session,
the more capable it becomes
of detecting and enjoying nuance.
This is not pseudoscience.
This is how your olfactory and taste memory
actually develops, and you can train them.
So drinking a Priorat next to a Bordeaux
doesn't muddy your experience.
It sharpens it.
Each wine makes the other one more vivid.
Here's how this works.
I use a framework I call
the five steps to a magical wine experience.
Steps one through three, sight, nose, palate.
We go through those first,
and I give you my initial sip and swallow score
where all the snort, taste, and spit reviewers stop.
Then step four, tying it all together,
where I give you my Nostradamus wine prediction.
What I think is going to happen to each wine
is I go through the bottle.
And then at the end, step five,
my proprietary whole bottle review,
where we find out if I was right, and I declare a winner.
The difference between a sip and swallow score
and a whole bottle score, it's enormous.
Wine is a living thing.
It changes in the glass.
It changes as it breathes,
and it changes inside you as you drink it.
It changes you.
The score you give a wine on the first sip
is sometimes completely different from the score
you give it at the end of the bottle.
Tonight, you'll see exactly why.
One more thing before we get into these bottles.
I want to know what wine you're drinking tonight.
Bordeaux, Burgundy, California,
Barolo, Brunello di Montalcino,
Northern or Southern Rome, whatever it is,
drop it in the comments right now.
I read every single comment myself,
and there's nothing I enjoy more
than seeing what you're drinking while I make these videos.
Tell me what you're drinking tonight.
Drop it below.
Passac le Hagen sits just south of the city of Bordeaux.
It's the only appellation in Bordeaux
classified in 1959 for both red and white wines,
a distinction that matters,
because this part of Bordeaux,
well, they're doing something slightly different.
The soils here are gravelly,
which is actually where the name Gravis comes from.
Gravel drains quickly, stresses the vine,
and forces it to work hard.
Hardworking vines make concentrated wine,
and gravel is perfect for Cabernet Sauvignon.
Smith O'Lefitte has a story I genuinely love.
In 1990, a couple, Daniel and Florence Cathiard,
bought this property.
Daniel was a former Olympic skier.
Florence ran a chain of sporting goods stores.
They had zero background in wine, zero,
and they turned this estate
into one of the most sought-after wines in Bordeaux
within a decade.
It's a legitimately great underdog story.
The 2018 vintage in Bordeaux was exceptional.
Some critics called it the vintage of the decade.
Hot and roaring season, low yields,
concentration without heaviness.
If you've been waiting to try a recent Bordeaux vintage,
2018 is a pretty good one to try right now.
Smith O'Lefitte is Cabernet Sauvignon dominant,
around 55 to 60% with Merlot, Cobb-Franc,
and a small amount of Petit Verdot.
That Cabernet Sauvignon backbone
is what gives Bordeaux its structure,
its tannins, and its famous ability to age for decades.
One last thing, this wine is still relatively young.
It was released in 2021, and it's drinking well now,
but most serious critics say it won't hit its peak
for another five to 10 years,
although you know what I think
of the snort, taste, and spitters.
What you're experiencing tonight is a portrait of a wine
that is still becoming what it's going to be.
Maybe.
2018 was a warm vintage,
so we should get a lot of gorgeous fruit.
And I'm not a fan of aging wine right up
until the moment of your death before you drink it.
I say this wine will be fantastic right now.
Prerat is one of only two regions of Spain
with DOCA status,
the highest classification in Spanish wine law.
The other is Rioja.
That tells you something
about how seriously the world takes this region.
And here's the thing about Prerat
that really blows my mind every single time.
In 1979, the entire region produced fewer bottles
than a single mid-sized Bordeaux Chateau.
The vineyards had been largely abandoned
since the phylorexia epidemic of the 1890s
wiped out most of Europe's vines.
There were something like four or five active producers
in the entire region.
Then five winemakers, René Barbier among them,
moved into the village of Guatalas in the 1980s
with basically no money, enormous ambition,
and the conviction that those terraced slate vineyards
were hiding something extraordinary.
They were right.
By the mid-1990s, Prerat wine was on the list
of the greatest red wines in the world.
René Barbier and his family still run Clomogador.
The estate is farmed biodynamically.
The vines, some of them, are over 100 years old.
And these old vines planted in the Licorella,
this shattered black slate
that the locals call the skin of the earth,
they produced tiny quantities
of extraordinarily concentrated fruit
with exceptional intensity.
I call it the Repo Man of wines
because Repo Man's always intense.
The 2021 vintage in Prerat was cooler than recent years,
which gave the wines more freshness and elegance
than the big extracted style Prerat was once famous for.
This 2021 Clomogador is going as far as you and me.
It's not what most people expect
when they think Spanish red.
Let's cut to you for a second.
Take a sip of whatever you're drinking right now.
Seriously, do it.
Now, I want you to notice just one thing,
the texture in your mouth.
Is it silky?
Is it sandy?
Is it powdery?
Is it grippy?
Is there somewhere in between?
Just notice it.
We're going to come back to that sensation.
Write down what you're getting in the comments.
I love mouthfeel.
Let's start this wine fight.
I've Coravined a two and a half ounce
tasting pour of each wine.
They've both had time to breathe,
which with wines this structured,
it's not optional, it's mandatory.
Now, Coravined, I got mine right here,
is a fine wine lover's best friend.
I use it to practice blind tasting
to pass the certified sommelier exam.
We are using it here to evaluate both wines side by side
before we get into the whole bottle.
Whenever I'm drinking a whole bottle,
I always start with a two ounce pour from that bottle
and a two ounce pour of Coravined
from a vastly different bottle.
When I taste, I notice the similarities
and the differences,
and that dramatically enhances the experience
of the whole bottle I'm drinking.
You might say it's a jumpstart to your palate,
but as you go through the bottle,
you will start to notice aromas,
flavors, and sensations,
and mouthfeel you otherwise would have missed.
It also builds up my mental processing power,
so I'll be able to notice flavors and aromas
in future wines I otherwise would have missed.
I am literally expanding my brain's ability
to deliver experience from wine each and every time I drink,
something virtually no one else does.
I've been doing this myself for the last two months,
and the results have been extraordinary.
The Coravined will be your best friend for this.
I recommend you do this with every bottle you drink.
Hey, plus you get to drink two more ounces of wine.
What could be better?
Hey, a note on temperature right quick.
Surface temperature for the Smith Olafite
is around 55 to 60 degrees Fahrenheit.
Club Mogador, same.
These wines want a little coolness
to reserve their aromatics.
If your reds are sitting in a room that's 75 degrees,
I can't stand that,
try putting the bottle in the freezer
20 minutes before you open it.
There's nothing worse than a fantastic,
full-bodied red wine served at the wrong temperature.
That's one of my real pet peeves here in Texas.
All right, let's start with step one of five.
Psych!
And what I'm gonna do is I'm gonna hold up both glasses
against a white piece of paper,
and I want you to look at the color.
Not just this red.
Look at the gradient.
Well, look at the red.
I'm gonna get my white paper here.
All right, got my white paper
with some good wine stains on it.
And so color tells you about concentration of the wine.
It tells you about age,
about the grape varieties in the blend.
And it's not just aesthetics,
it's a preview of everything you're going to smell and taste.
I actually like looking at the color quite a bit.
So this is what I mean
when I talk about building your mental database.
Right now, your brain is sorting a pattern.
Dense, opaque color in the core
often means concentration and extraction.
That information doesn't disappear when this video ends.
The next time you're at a restaurant or a wine shop
and you hold up a glass to the light,
the moment you're about to experience
is gonna be in your memory.
And yeah, you're gonna be that guy
that looks at your wine through the white napkin
and everybody else thinks you're crazy.
I'm that guy, and that guy's a good guy to be.
And look, you're gonna see a lot more
in the glass that you did before.
So let's have a look at the Smith Ola Feet first
and see what we see.
Oh yeah, I can tell it's a warm vintage.
A lot of extraction.
I can see it staining the side of the glass.
Just a beautiful, deep, dark ruby core.
Starting to get some, you know, a gradient around there.
Some thin orange rings kind of fading
just a little bit into pink.
I mean, this is not like a 40-year-old wine or anything.
You can tell that.
But you can tell that it's, while it's still youthful,
it is beginning to get a little bit of age on it.
It's just a gorgeous looking wine.
Look at that extraction.
Look at that staining and concentration on it.
There's gonna be a lot of fruit in this wine.
I can tell you that much.
All right, let's have a look at the Clos Mogador,
and then we're gonna look at them side by side.
The Clos Mogador is lighter in the glass.
A little bit of orange right around the rim,
but then it fades into pink pretty quick.
You can look and tell that this is a youthful wine.
I can look around, not nearly as much extraction
as the Bordeaux, but still a very nice looking ruby wine.
Now let's have a look at them side by side,
and we're gonna see what we're gonna get here.
Oh yeah, well, you can tell how much more extraction
and how darker that Cabernet Sauvignon is.
I mean, it's really opaque,
whereas I can't actually see the paper
in the Priorat wine.
And both of them are gorgeous looking wines,
but you can look at this by sight very clearly,
and you can tell that, hey, this was a warm vintage.
Even though this came from a hot climate,
this extraction has been minimal, cooler vintage there.
This extraction, it's been pretty big.
All right, well, enough of looking at it.
Let's do step two of five, the nose.
Usually Cabernet Sauvignon is not a particularly
aromatic wine, but you do get some wonderful aromatics
when you get your nose in there.
Oh yeah, I get a lot of vanilla, gorgeous blackberries,
black plum, maybe a little bit of tobacco.
You know, sometimes you get a little bit of graphite,
a lot of gravel and gravis,
but this is just a beautiful, you know, Bordeaux nose.
I do not get a jammy or overripe fruit character,
but I do get a nice ripe fruit character from this.
Oh yeah, and then that oak kind of jumps out at me too.
It's not over oak, it's nicely well-integrated,
but I always love it when the blueberry,
vanilla, bacon spices are kind of in harmony
with each other, and this one's beautiful.
Well, let's have a nose of the Priorat,
see what we get here.
Oh yeah, immediately, immediately, strawberry.
You could say wild strawberry.
I always call it strawberry seed.
That's what Grenache is known for, intense strawberry.
Right there, that's what I get.
But I also get a little bit of what's called greek.
It's kind of a fancy name.
It's like Mediterranean scrub bush,
it's Mediterranean herbs and scrub from scrub brush.
You know, a little thyme, a little rosemary in there,
but it gives a little bit of a wild Mediterranean character
behind it and balances out very nicely.
Yeah, and what I like is that the strawberry
is right there, it's forward.
The herbs are, the greek is behind it.
And this is, I mean, it's intense,
but it's not just overwhelmingly kind of blow me away.
It's intense and subtle at the same time.
This is a beautiful nose on this.
Now, what I'm gonna do real quick
is we're gonna build our mental database
on my nose, one, then the other,
and see what comes up that I didn't get before.
Hmm, wow.
So I get a little strawberry out of this one first.
I actually get a little savory in this one coming up now.
And that was just by going one to the other
and kind of jumpstarting it a little bit.
That's a really cool thing to do.
You guys have got to start doing this.
I mean, you just jumpstart your palate and your mind
so much when you go through these great wines like this.
But you know what?
Look, we didn't come here to nose wine.
We came here to drink wine.
So let's cut to the chase.
Let's start up and let's have a taste
of the Smith Olafite, see where we're at.
Hmm, that's such a gorgeous layered Bordeaux.
Wonderful, ripe, juicy fruits,
a tinge of sweetness running into it.
Fruitiness, it's not sweet wine.
Under that, you get the oak, baking spices, vanilla.
Under that, a little bit of tobacco and mineral.
It's so layered as we go through.
Long, lingering finish.
I mean, wow, this is just a really gorgeous wine.
But yeah, there's a little what's called apparent sweetness
because this wine is very fruity.
I really like that in there.
It's not just super dry, suckier.
I'm kind of in the mood for a little one like that today.
I've had really dry Bordeaux.
I love them, but I have to be in the mood for both.
So I'm in the mood for this style right now.
So let's try the Pereira, see what we get.
Gorgeous strawberry, ripe, definitely not overripe.
Very balanced out with the Greek as I tasted it.
But here's something very interesting.
I get a little bit of the sweetness in here
that I get in there, the fruitiness.
And that's a little bit interesting to me.
I noticed both.
Now, what I also noticed in this,
that I noticed the absence of oak.
There's no vanilla, there's no baking spices,
anything like that.
So this is fruit, herbs, Greek, very nicely balanced,
lighter body than this one,
which is a little bit surprising for Pereira.
But this is kind of cool.
This was a warm vintage in Bordeaux.
This was a cool vintage in Pereira.
And they show up in the glass.
Very interesting transposition on that.
But yeah, I get that little sweetness
is going through both of them.
It's a very nice sweetness.
Yeah, I'm really liking that.
Hey, since you watched this far, I have a gift for you.
My magical wines guide, a list of wines
that have been magical for me and others,
constantly updated.
All you have to do to claim your copy
is to go to wholebottlereviews.com forward slash email.
The link is in the description and in a pinned comment.
Back to the show.
Now it's time for my sip and swallow score.
No spit, we don't do any spitting here.
These wines are too good.
Plus, if you're spitting your wine,
you're gonna miss the finish,
the length, the integration, the warmth.
A very, very important part of the wine experience.
And look, you can't feel a finish since you didn't swallow.
I don't know how these snort tasting spitters do it.
You know, they miss out on arguably the most important,
of course, enjoyable part.
Let me give you the initial sip and swallow score
of the Smith Hill Lafitte.
Before I give a score, let me explain.
It's just an entry point.
That's it.
My scores tend to be a little more higher and exuberant
than a lot of the other snort tasting spitters.
But to me, it's an entry point.
I always like to have the floor of 96
of any good wine that I'm gonna drink.
And I've seen two wines that should score that.
But what I wanna see is movement.
Does it move up by a point with a whole bottle review?
A point and a half, that's really good.
Two points, that has a blow you away,
magical wine experience.
With the Smith Hill Lafitte, I'm gonna give it a 96.5
initial sip and swallow score.
I just love that gorgeous fruit integrated with the oak.
The Club Mogador, I'm gonna give it a 96.
I'm not nearly as familiar with the Prerats
as I am with the Bordeaux.
I love the strawberry structure.
I love the Greek.
It's gonna be very interesting to see where it goes.
So let's have a quick taste of them together, right quick.
See if anything else has come up.
And hey, if you got something interesting
starting to show up in your glass,
even going through this video,
write it down in the comments.
Tell me where you're at, tell me what you're getting.
Oh, juiciness in this one just showed up.
It's in that one too.
I get some great earth in this one.
I get some great herbs in this one.
And they kind of both really go together.
I didn't notice the earth quite that much
the first time I tasted it.
Now it's kind of boom, come up.
The Greek and the strawberry are really kind of balanced.
That was very interesting
because both of them have a juiciness to them.
That kind of a freshness, a juiciness,
even though this was a warm vintage.
That's a similarity that I get.
A freshness, a juiciness in both of them.
These are both gonna be very, very excellent wines.
Let's go into step four.
So where are we?
Two wines, two kind of completely different worlds.
One is a little bit restrained, architectural, patient,
generous, aromatic, expressive.
You've seen what I've had to say from each one.
One's a young Bordeaux from a legendary vintage
that I think is coming together really nicely.
The other is Prieurat from one of the founding fathers
of the modern Spanish wine revolution.
And honestly, it's from a cool vintage,
so it's definitely gonna be a surprising one.
But both of them share,
you see the commonalities that I talked about,
but both of them share some ambition.
These are both wines made by people who believe
that the land they farm is genuinely exceptional.
And when you taste it, you're gonna believe it too.
Here's what I've noticed in the glass
in the last few minutes while I'm talking to you.
Let me give you a quick recap.
I noticed the freshness has started to show up.
One thing that just popped into my mind
was I noticed that both of them
began developing notes of cherry.
Little red cherry in here, little black cherry.
We're gonna get that in both.
The balance in the Prieurat
between the Greek and the strawberry is fantastic.
The freshness in both is wonderful.
And there's a balance between oak and blackberry in here.
Balance, balance.
And so when you start comparing these two
before you get into a full bottle,
all of these things start coming into your mind.
So these are just gonna be two absolutely fantastic wines.
And look, this is the whole bottle effect
at a glass level.
Wine is not a static object.
It breathes, it changes.
And if you're drinking yours along with me tonight,
I'd love to know,
is your glass tasting different now
than it did at the beginning of this video?
Has the mouthfeel and texture changed?
Hey, drop a comment and let me know.
Hey, if you're having fun
and you like the idea of my no BS whole bottle reviews
where I give you the truth
about what you're actually drinking,
where I put these wines to a real test,
then subscribe to my channel right now.
Hit that button because I have a lot more brutal truths
coming, a lot more sommelier secrets
to share, a lot more Bordeaux and some Prieurat secrets.
And hey, if you know how to use high points,
send a few my way.
Here's where I make my Nostradamus wine prediction
based on where both wines are right now.
Before I finish,
I actually even started out of the bottle.
I'm gonna tell you what I think is gonna happen
with each of them over the next few hours of my drinking.
The Smith of Lafitte,
I think we're going to get substantial evolution.
I think the fruit is going to lengthen and heighten.
But I think like what happened with the earth that came up,
I think the fruit is gonna feature the fruit,
but you're gonna get earth on top.
Then you're gonna get some oak.
Then you're gonna get some mineral.
Then you're gonna get some tobacco.
And I think it's really, really gonna evolve.
So I think this one, give it a 96.5.
I think you can get up to as high as a 98.
So you're really excited to drink this wine,
particularly right now because of its reputation.
So I think this thing could jump up by 0.5 to 98.
Club Mogador 2021.
This one's a little bit harder for me to do
because I haven't drank as much Prieurat,
particularly a cooler vintage Prieurat.
I gave it a 96 to start with.
I think you could get up to 97.5.
I think we may see a slower evolution with this one.
I think the herbs are gonna feature quite a bit,
but I think we're gonna get some unusual flavors
that are gonna pop up.
And I think I'm gonna make this prediction.
Always got that wonderful strawberry going through it.
I think the cherry's gonna kind of balance out with it too.
I love cherry in my wine.
I love black cherry, I love red cherry.
So I think we may get a real cherry component
kind of start to come up.
But hey, that's just my guess.
You never know with these Nostradamus wine predictions.
Will my Nostradamus wine prediction be right on
or will the wines tell me something different yet again?
The great thing about a whole bottle review
is the wine reviews itself and it often startles you.
I'm gonna drink the Club Mogador tonight,
the Smithola Fete next week.
Maybe I could do a twofer.
And when I recover from my wine hangover,
I will give you my proprietary whole bottle review
and declare the winner in this wine fight.
I'm just gonna do the Club Mogador
because if I drank both,
I couldn't give you a proper whole bottle review
in one night.
And we take our whole bottle reviews seriously here.
Now is a great time to pause the video,
pour yourself a second glass of whatever you're drinking,
settle in, see what happened
with the experience of each bottle.
And we're gonna get into my whole bottle review
starting right now.
I have returned, fully recovered from my wine hangover
and ready to give you my final whole bottle review
of both the 2021 Club Mogador from Priorat in Spain
and the 2018 Smithola Fete from Pesac Leogne in Bordeaux.
As you can see, both bottles have been fully
and happily consumed and are ready for review.
And as always, I have, of course,
taken a full page of notes about each one,
glass by glass, drop by drop, glass one through five.
So let us start with the 2021 Club Mogador
because this was one that was a little bit surprising to me.
Most of the times you get a Priorat, and I love Priorat,
you get something that's very full body,
it's very alcoholic, it's very intense.
This one, cooler vintage, so it was a little leaner,
a little more subtle, but it had some surprises in store.
So let me get my glasses out,
and we are going to get right into this,
starting with glass number one of the 2021 Club Mogador.
So the first thing that I saw out of it immediately was,
just like the first sip that you saw,
a lot of great strawberry seed, intense strawberry,
but not as intense as Priorats that I've had before.
There were some subtleties and some nuances to it.
We got a lot of red and black cherry in it.
That was one thing that was consistent
throughout this whole bottle.
Red cherry, black cherry, and I do love cherry in my wine.
We also got a decent amount of Greek,
herbal, Mediterranean scrub brush, thyme, rosemary,
a little bit of lavender,
and that was very well balanced with the strawberry.
So the first glass of this wine was exactly as advertised.
We started getting into glass two,
started getting a little bit of slow evolution.
I'm just going to tell you,
this was not a fast-moving wine at all,
even though it's a little leaner than most Priorats,
but we did get slow, noticeable evolution.
We got some ripe strawberry,
and what I thought was pretty neat about the strawberry was
it started out as like one note, just one strawberry,
and then it became like ripe strawberry, fresh strawberry,
maybe a little under-ripe strawberry.
You could see it kind of separate
into these different categories and layers of strawberry,
and I really liked that.
Everything was still lean and elegant.
Nothing was intense or jammy or even overripe,
but you could see the fruit begin to separate.
That was pretty neat.
Same thing happened with the cherry,
and what it would do was
it would kind of alternate with the Greek.
You would get the fruit,
which would start to come apart in a good way
and rotate a little bit.
You get the Greek, got a little bit of earth in there,
got a little bit of mineral in there as well,
and it started to evolve into a very, very nice wine,
but nothing that really kind of overwhelmed me
or just kind of blew out my senses
like some of those Priorats can do.
That can be a good thing and that can be a bad thing.
So as we got into glass three,
oh, some savory notes started to appear.
Not quite cured meat,
so I would say that would be savory.
That went really well with herbs,
like maybe a little bit of savory pork roast,
and that was pretty neat,
but we still got those wonderful layers of strawberry,
wonderful layers of dark cherry,
maybe a little bit of black fruits,
maybe a little bit of blackberry,
but this wine really was all about the strawberry.
Still, a little bit of slow evolution.
As we go into glass three and glass four,
that's where I'm starting to look
and see if this wine triggered any emotion, any feeling,
if it brought up any memories.
And no, I didn't get any of that in this wine.
I felt happy, I felt pleased, I felt mellowed,
I felt relaxed.
I was very happy that I was drinking a Priorat,
but it didn't really trigger anything
off the way some of these crazy magical wines can do.
As we got into glass four,
it's really a slow-moving evolution.
Little bit more strawberry came out.
The fruit began to lengthen, heighten a little bit.
It would show up, the Greek would show up,
the savory would show up,
and it began to come together real slowly,
almost sort of like a molasses.
It didn't have that character of molasses,
but that's how it kind of moved,
it was a slow pace like a molasses.
It was very mellow, it was very relaxing,
it was quite enjoyable.
And then as we got into glass five,
the evolution really began to slow down a little bit,
which I thought was perfectly fine.
It got to where it got to, it slowed down,
it took us up and deposited us on the shore
after this nice, slow river ride,
kind of down a river of slowly flowing molasses,
and said, okay, that's it, that's what you get.
You get all your strawberry, you get all your cherry,
you get your Greek, you get your herbs,
you get a little bonus savory,
you get a little bit of earth, you get a little mineral,
and that's it.
And so I didn't think that this had extraordinary evolution.
It didn't trigger any memories or feelings.
It was a very nice bottle, but I will say this about that.
I like regional topicity,
and one thing that is sort of happening
in the wine world right now
because the wine world moves in fads
is that everyone is moving toward this elegant, minimalist,
low extraction, because they don't want to be
the big steakhouse wines to the Robert Parker era.
And that, if it's a return to form, I think it's good.
But if it's a reaction to something,
I'm not that happy about that.
Prior rats are supposed to be intensely concentrated,
juicy, intense, and I thought this wine,
even though it's from a cold vintage,
was a bit too elegant for the type.
Now, as it is, I thoroughly enjoyed this wine,
but if I'm going to drink prior rat,
give me the juiciness, give me the concentration,
give me the power, give me the intensity.
And this was just a little bit elegant.
So maybe a minor, minor criticism before cold vintage,
certainly a very good bottle of wine.
So my final whole bottle score for the 2021 Claude Mogador,
I'm going to upgrade this a point to a 97.
I thought it was a solid 97 whole bottle review,
but not getting anywhere close.
All right, let's get over to the Bordeaux.
And you guys know that I love Bordeaux.
Warm vintage, 2018 Smith O'Leafete.
So let's talk about how it's evolved from glass one.
As you remember, the first sip that I took of this,
very interesting, was immediate apparent sweetness,
fruitiness, I was like, wow,
there's a lot of fruit in this wine,
even a little bit of strawberry.
So when I went to drink the whole bottle,
which I gave this a nice two-hour decant,
I expected strawberry.
I mean, I expected not strawberry, I expected fruit.
I expected intense, apparent sweetness.
And you know what I got?
The opposite, surprise, very dry wine.
In fact, I tasted it, I got earth, I got tobacco,
I got graphite, I got mineral,
I got a little bit of cedar, baking spices from Oaken.
Oh, by the way, behind that, a little bit of fruit.
So I was like, wow,
this wasn't anything like I was expecting.
What happened to the fruit?
Is it going to be there?
Well, the fruit told a pretty interesting story.
And so that was really kind of a unique surprise
when we went into it because I tasted it and I said, nope,
this is Bordeaux, this is Saint-Saëns,
this is Graves, this is where you are.
We have no idea where that apparent sweetness came from.
This is a dry wine, baby.
So as I got through it, as I went through it,
I was like, wow, this is, I am squirrelly in Bordeaux.
What's going to happen next?
Well, as we got into glass two, the fruit began to appear,
but it didn't jump out.
It didn't overpower.
It kind of peaked its head up
and integrated very well with all the tertiary flavors.
So the wine started out
with the tertiary flavors first and foremost
in these wonderful stratified layers.
But the fruit was a bottom layer.
However, as I went through the bottle,
starting in glass two, the fruit began to climb the ladder.
And that's what I really liked about this wine.
At first, it integrated with the earth, fruit and earth.
Then it integrated with the tobacco, tobacco and fruit.
Then it began to integrate with the oak,
then the tannin, then everything.
So it was really, really remarkable
as I went through glass two and then glass three
to see how the fruit began to slowly come to life
and reveal itself at every level.
And so we got into glass four,
something happened that I just love to see.
You don't see it very often,
but I've seen it happen a few times.
I call it a rotation.
And so what happens is,
is the fruit and all the tertiary flavors,
they kind of start to rotate like a spinning cylinder.
And so you'll get some blackberry here,
some earth here, some tobacco,
but it all kind of spins around
and it all begins to sort of start mixing together.
And that's what happened in glass four.
And so it wasn't like a fast rotation,
but every time you had a sip,
it would turn another revolution
and then another revolution.
And so it showed all sides of itself
with this really slow spin.
That was just really, really remarkable, totally unexpected.
This was a surprise wine
because every preconception I had about it going in,
it blew them away.
And so at the end of glass four,
I started thinking, wow, this was a warm vintage.
The fruits there it's representing is climbing the ladder,
but it's not really at the forefront.
Huh, that's interesting.
Then all of a sudden we got into glass five and boom.
It's as soon as I took the first sip, it turned rich.
That fruit jumped all the way up on top and said,
no baby, we're going to finish with me on top
and push everything else.
I really was quite extraordinary
because I was like, whoa, there's the fruit.
There's the apparent sweetness.
There's the thing I tasted on the first sip.
And glass five was all about the fruit.
The rest of the tertiary flavors were there,
but they're kind of rotating under the fruit
where the fruit sat on top and said,
no, we've got some blackberry for you.
We've got some black plow.
We've got some cassis.
We've got a tiny hint of strawberry for you.
We're saving the best for last.
And so that's how glass five went.
I thought it was absolutely fantastic.
Now, did it bring up any memories or feelings
or anything like that?
No, it really didn't.
I was very happy.
I was drinking a Bordeaux.
I felt mellow.
I felt relaxed.
I felt very happy.
And I felt surprised and a little bit entranced
by what was going on with the cylindrical spinning
and then boom, that rich fruit suddenly showing up
in glass five when I least expected it.
So what I loved about this wine
was it was full of surprises and it did the unexpected.
That's it.
It really caught me by surprise.
It did things that were totally unexpected
that I've never seen of any Bordeaux
or really any other wine.
Now, the only thing that was lacking from this wine for me
was the emotional component.
I started wondering if it was gonna show up,
but it never really did.
It never really grabbed a hold of my mind in that area,
in that way.
If it had, I would have put this up
in some of the best wines I drank, but it didn't.
So this thing was all about the flavor, aroma, body, mouth,
feel, change, evolution, and texture experience
without really touching the emotion.
So I gave this one a 96.5 on the first sip,
which then on the first glass completely surprised me
because it went the opposite direction.
But because of the really neat evolution of this one,
I am going to upgrade it to a 97.5.
Solid 97.5, not touching a 98
because there's no emotional component,
but in this wine fight today,
I am going to give the 2018 Smith of Lafitte
the crown by half a point in its surprising evolution.
Highly recommended.
So what's better than one wine fight?
Another one with my final whole bottle review.
Tap and click to watch the next one coming up right now.
