Greek Art, Lecture 07: High Classical Art (Part 1)

Hellenic Artistry
8 followers
4 Video Views·Jul 23, 2026
Mar 24, 2020
This is Part 1 of a two-part video on High Classical Art (Lecture 7). It includes historical information about the period (450 - 400 B.C.) and then focuses on defining classical art, using examples of sculpture, most particularly Polykleitos's Doryphoros. Part 2 will continue with the High Classical art executed on the Acropolis, most notably the Parthenon and its sculptures. There will also be a brief mention of vase painting.
Chapters
View all
Transcript
Follow along using the transcript.
Show transcript
Diamond In-Sights
968 subscribers
Videos
About
AI Generated·May contain errors
Here continues our look at ancient Greek art, a story of naturalism and idealism.
Lecture 7 covers classical art, which begins about 450 or 440 BC and ends with the 5th century,
in 400 BC. If classical art had a defining moment, this is it. As with the first and
second Persian invasions that closed the archaic and opened the early classical period,
there is a specific historical event that offers a convenient date for the change in style,
the peace with Persia that was signed in 449 BC. Before talking about the significance of this,
let's review some essential points about the historical context leading up to this point.
We will remember that, even after the important Greek victories in 480 and 479 BC,
the Greeks still felt vulnerable to another Persian invasion.
Perhaps with a touch of hubris, they also envisioned taking their own vengeance on
the imperial superpower. For this reason, in 477 BC, Athens coordinated the formation of
an alliance of Greek states known as the Delian League. Member states, pictured here in yellow,
except Attica, which is pictured in red, contributed soldiers, ships, supplies, or money,
but some found the cost too exacting, and when they attempted to secede, Athens used military
force to compel them to remain in the league and contribute their resources. In this context,
Pericles came to power. Remember, Athens was a democracy, and there wasn't even an official
president or prime minister, so Pericles was styled first citizen in a rule from 461 to 429 BC.
In 454, he made the decision to move the league's treasury from the sacred island of Delos to
Athens, allegedly to keep it safe from the Persians. The leaguers were still actively
involved in conflicts with Persia, although the theater of war had shifted to Egypt,
which was also seeking liberation from the Persians and called on the Athenians to help.
Although the Greeks came, the rebellion was unsuccessful. Other conflicts continued until
the Greeks and Persians officially signed a peace treaty in 449 or 448 BC. This had a direct
bearing on Greek art, since this peace prompted the building program on the Acropolis, which
ushered in a new style. In fact, these monuments comprised the most important expression of high
classical art, but they also came at a price. Athens arguably misappropriated the league's funds,
and in doing so, traded conflict with Persia for conflict at home.
In some ways, the Persian invasion marked a high point for unity in Greece, which was
characterized in this period by close inter-fighting and constantly shifting military alliances and
territorial borders, but the most catastrophic inter-Greek fighting was probably a direct
outgrowth of Athens' own new imperial ambitions. You may be wondering what was going on with Sparta,
and certainly some of the Delian League's rebels appeared to Sparta for help in their attempts at
secession. Sparta itself did not join the league for a variety of reasons, including perhaps what
might be called a lack of interest in the affairs of the Greeks across the Aegean Sea and Ionia.
The Spartans were also initially preoccupied with the largest helic rebellion or serf-class
rebellion in their history, but they quickly came to view Athens' imperial expansion as a threat,
and Sparta became the leader of a new Peloponnesian League. This map shows the
pseudo-Athenian empire in red and Spartan allies in purple. Neutral states are in green.
Inevitably, what was known as the Peloponnesian War broke out, lasting from 431 to 404 BC.
Sparta was initially victorious, but peace was short-lived, and the conflicts would resume in
Today's lecture will deal mostly with the high classical art executed before the Peloponnesian
War on the Parthenon in particular, but it will also cover later works on the Acropolis.
With the outbreak of the war and the death of Pericles in 429 BC during a plague that added
to the tumult of these times, specialists see another shift in the classical style by the last
quarter of the 5th century. However, I won't dwell on that distinction.
Before we discuss the art, I just want to add that, even if you don't realize it,
the 5th century and also the 4th century are probably the ones you're thinking of when you
refer to Ancient Greece, and this isn't just because the Parthenon dates to this time.
Classical culture of the 5th century includes the great literary masterpieces by the tragedians
Aeschylus, Sophocles, and Euripides, as well as the comedian Aristophanes,
whose play Lysistrata, which I've mentioned, dates to the late 5th century. The most famous
of all great plays, Sophocles' Oedipus the King, most likely premiered the year Pericles died,
in 429 BC. The philosopher Socrates would have been alive in this period as his 70-year life
was put to an end in 399 BC. But now we can turn to the art.
The classical moment in art coincides roughly with the historical Periclean age about 461-429 BC,
and more particularly with the flowering of Athens during the Periclean building program
begun in 448 BC. Accordingly, you might think of the classical moment as the Parthenon moment.
The rigidity of the severe style has ceded to a more relaxed, more sensual, and more lifelike
approach to figurative art, which has more of a timeless stillness than a rigidity,
and an even more pronounced idealism. As we'll see with the Deripheros, pictured at right,
the contrapposto pose has been fully developed by moving the relaxed leg backwards instead of
forwards, as in the Critios Boi or the Riace bronzes, although you might note that artists
continued to use both relaxed back leg and relaxed front leg poses for the remainder of antiquity.
All in all, this gives figures their most natural and lifelike standing posture yet.
Idealism is rendered more concrete, as it is mathematically theorized in a canon of proportions.
Any individuality of the figure cedes to a kind of platonic ideal, a composite of perfect parts.
Facial expressions betray no emotion, and the figures have a restrained feeling throughout.
Instead, they are characterized by an immutable dignity that Winkelmann famously described as
Even so, pathos and tension or struggle are conveyed, mostly through narrative and composition,
as we've seen before. Finally, keywords that describe the classical aesthetic,
the goal of which is a kind of perfect beauty, include harmony, balance, and controlled rhythm.
Before we get to the Parthenon as both a building and a goldmine of classical architectural
sculpture, I want to continue our discussion of the freestanding nude figure and hopefully tie
that to these classical principles. The embodiment of classical ideals may be found in Polykleitos'
statue, the Doryphoros, dating to about 440 BC. Doryphoros means spear-bearer. The modern Greek
word for spear is still dory. Essentially, it is a depiction of a beardless, strong-muscled athlete
or a way to show a young man in his physical prime. The statue is slightly over life-size,
as was common with the coroi we looked at, and was originally rendered in bronze,
which was the material in which Polykleitos worked. It is only known through Roman marble copies,
with the best-known and most intact version coming from the excavations at Pompeii.
It goes without saying that this is a highly idealized rendering of a human figure,
but it also embodies the quintessence of classical naturalism in the high classical contrapposto.
That's to say, not only are the body parts plausible as in the early classical period,
but the contrapposto pose has been slightly modified so that the resting leg falls gently
backward rather than projecting forward, with the result that standing figures have their most
natural, lifelike, and relaxed posture yet. Perhaps more importantly, it's the most
aesthetically pleasing, as the backward leg better provides a springboard into the most
graceful array of S-curves centered on the axis of the body. While you could trace many visual
paths, they all have an incredible sense of balance, harmony, and controlled rhythm.
You should know that this effect was very carefully contrived by the artist.
In fact, we know that Polykleitos designed a sculptural work that demonstrated the principles
outlined in his written treatise entitled The Canon. Although this literary work no longer
exists, a 2nd century CE Greek author named Galen referred to it, and from these references,
scholars have determined that the Doryphoros is most likely the statue meant to demonstrate
Polykleitos' canon. Of course, canon in the artistic sense refers to a code for proportions,
and ancient Egyptians had established canons for their rather repetitive throughout the centuries
depictions of figures, but we'll see in a moment how Polykleitos' canon may have been
contrived to establish a unique set of internal ratios that would, once again, maximize that sense
of overall harmony through a kind of subconscious observation of repetition and balance.
Before we see how, we should note that physical beauty was important to the Greeks.
We've seen this in the way corporeal perfection was showcased in Greek art almost from its
inception. We've also talked about how the kouroi, in particular, were ideal images not
of the populace per se, but of the aristocratic patrons who could afford to commission the statues.
In fact, the ideal aristocratic gentleman was someone both of good character and good looks.
There was an expression for this particular combination,
kallos kagathos. Kagathos means good in the sense of virtuous or upstanding. Kallos,
as we might remember from our base inscriptions, means beautiful, although it can connote more than
just a handsome face. It can also refer to a kind of manly poise, a charming comportment,
someone who takes care of himself physically. In its combined form, as kallos kagathos,
it just means a great man, a true gentleman. So if you're troubled by the fact that these rather
impersonal expressionless classical statues with their idealized cookie-cover faces lack
a sense of character, rest assured that they are great men, and women too, for an ethos of
excellence is implicit in their good looks. The Greeks of this time were preoccupied with the
idea of arete, or excellence, and for males, the physical training we talked about is just one part
of the overall training in excellence that more broadly applied to their accomplishments and
character. Of course, adding narrative elements, even small ones like a spear, which suggests
excellence in athletics or warfare, imparts a better sense of character than their faces.
There are a few other key traits of classical art in general that I haven't mentioned yet.
Simplicity and seemliness go hand in hand, but simplicity means that there's just enough to get
the point across. Complexity can get messy, and classical art hates messiness. Keep things simple,
straightforward, clear. Likewise, seemliness means that all elements are suitable for the purpose,
and more importantly, in good taste. Classical art should not make you uncomfortable by virtue
of something being indecorous, overwrought, or unbefitting. Pathos is subtle, and really,
classical art should elevate you. Formally, you can follow these rules and have trivial subjects as
well as heroic ones, but given what I said about decorum or seemliness, squalid subjects are not
really part of the repertoire. Usually, the work is intended to elevate the viewer morally or spiritually.
Purity of line makes more sense for 2D work, as it refers to the crisp, clear contours that lack
sketchiness, but more importantly, show a command of the skill of drawing or rendering the subject,
typically in concise but graceful ways. While there are no lines in sculpture, your eye does
perceive edges, and it follows visual paths. These should be smooth, clear, crisp, and pure.
Inherent in Polykleitos' canon was the ancient Greek idea of symmetria. This word literally means
measured together, and rather than referring to what we call symmetry, it referred to the
That's to say, parts to one another, and parts to the whole. This comparison of parts forms a ratio.
Some have surmised that Polykleitos' lost canon was based on what we today call the golden ratio.
This ratio is 1 unit of measure to 1.618 units of measure. When you map the Fibonacci sequence
of numbers onto a grid, a golden spiral fits in it. This is a pattern that occurs in nature,
with the arrangement of some leaves and arguably other objects. By extracting two units from the
Fibonacci sequence, you can see that the ratio of one unit to the next largest unit creates a golden
ratio, 1 to 1.68. But is this ratio in the Doryphoros? By one calculation, it is. The unit
from foot to navel has a 1 to 1.618 ratio to the unit from foot to head, that's to say, the whole
body. But how does this ratio compare to others? Let's look at what the human body would look like
if we deviated from the approximate 1 to 1.62 ratio with regard to the navel's placement on the body.
You can see how the proportions start to get wonky. But just one use of the ratio could be accidental.
To see if Polykleitos has applied it elsewhere, let's break down the red line into two parts
measuring 1 and the remaining 0.62. Sure enough, there's another break into separate units at the
knee. We should also note that according to the Fibonacci sequence, the length of the new blue
line automatically equals the length of the shorter piece of the purple line when divided
at a 1 to 1.62 ratio. But then I wondered what would happen if I brought the green line up above
the blue line, or rather, divided our second blue line into a golden ratio? Sure enough, the chin
marked the division of the remaining space there. It's tempting to continue dividing the Fibonacci
sequence and look for more golden ratios, but this is only one possibility for determining Polykleitos'
canon. Departing from the mathematically abstract, we should return to our discussion of naturalism
and idealism. To determine how naturalistic a representation is, we should probably compare it
to an actual image from nature. By putting the statue beside a photograph, even with a slightly
exaggerated slightly leaning contrapposto, we can determine whether the basic proportions in the
representation of anatomy is accurate. It was actually during the classical period that writers
began explicitly referring to the realism of the representations using the word aletheia, or truth,
only during the Hellenistic period was a theory of idealism developed. However, as noted during
our lecture on archaic art, we can give our own meanings to these words. For our purposes, I
propose that naturalism and idealism coexist, rather than displace each other in some way.
To elaborate a bit further on how the two concepts merge, we'll look at an anecdote about the painter
Zeuxis and his painting of Helen of Troy. As is the case with almost all classical panel painting,
none of Zeuxis' works have survived, but ancient texts describe them as notable for their realism,
small scale, novel subject matter, and independent format. Apparently, his technique created
volumetric illusion through manipulating light and shadow, a change from the usual method of
filling in shapes with flat color. We've seen the latter method in such late archaic mural paintings
as the Tomb of the Divers. We will later look at some Hellenistic work where the lessons of
the classical period have resulted in a three-dimensional look based on modeling with
light and shadow. Zeuxis contributed to the composite method of composition and may have
originated a novel approach to the ideal form of the nude. Keep in mind, however, there is no nudity
in female sculpture and only exceptional examples of female nudity in erotic vase painting.
We imagine it's the same in easel painting in that Helen's corporeal beauty was conveyed perhaps with
the same type of clinging drapery that we're about to see in the Parthenon sculptures.
In any case, as the story goes and as a 19th century artist illustrated here, Zeuxis could
not find a woman beautiful enough to pose as Helen, the most beautiful woman in the world,
so he selected the finest features of five different models to create a composite image
of ideal beauty. Incidentally, this is essentially the 18th century neoclassical theory of the beau
ideal, and you can see how it synthesizes the natural and the ideal. As noted, we could talk
about the idealism of archaic representation of the human figure just as easily as we could talk
about the idealism of the classical period, so the more defining factor that separates the two
is the degree of naturalism that they both have. Now, the way all these words can be used
connotatively and quite specifically in certain contexts does make it a bit confusing, and you
have to remain acutely aware of how you're defining the words. I'm defining idealism as the tendency
to represent human figures as a model of physical perfection and absolute beauty. I'm defining
naturalism as the tendency to represent the human figure as consistent with the laws of nature.
I would use the word realistic in the same way, but I avoid it here because although naturalism
can have its own connotations in different periods, realism is often much more highly
connotative of showing nature not just in a plausible representation, but one that also
has the truth of nature's random accidents, the mistakes that may detract from perfection.
Dirtiness, wear and tear, physical idiosyncrasies, and so on. I do think idealism to some degree can
only be achieved when the principle of naturalism applies, since while we conceptually understand
a statue like the New York Kouros is meant to represent the ideal of youthful beauty and
physical fitness for its time, we find it lacking in perfection when we use nature or reality as a
measure. The Kouros no longer looks perfectly beautiful when we imagine it waking up and coming
to life as a human being. The Doryphoros easily passes that test. We could argue about whether
he's too perfect to exist in nature, but there's an inherent subjectivity already in this appraisal.
When Zeuxis chose one woman's eyes, another's lips, another's legs, another's breasts, another's hips,
who but Zeuxis was really the judge of this? To consider what the words idealism and naturalism
mean to you, I'll invite you to contemplate the following array of images where the
contrapposto is still employed for undressed models today. Any thoughts on how to determine
which of these models would be the starting point for your canon? Does one sum it up, or do you need
to extract various parts from different models? You might also consider the question of how natural
they look and how this figures into your estimation of an ideal. Notice how many underwear ads were
aestheticized by the use of black and white photography. Is perfection a precise canon,
or is it a spectrum? How limited would this spectrum be? Throw another image into the mix.
Are both of these men worthy of a Times Square billboard? Men, like women, are challenging body
image in the media, but is there a difference between inclusion and admiration? Do aspiration
and emulation, or attraction and desire, figure into your estimation? Beauty may remain in the eye
of the beholder, but we should be wary of coming to facile conclusions. After all, we live in a time
where body acceptance is touted, but we have an unprecedented number of ways to fix things,
to perfect ourselves. Shifting the conversation a bit, I think we should remember what this statue
embodies. We've been looking at this ubiquitous male nude statuary since the early archaic period,
but the coroi were classified primarily as grave markers, cult statues, or votive statues. We
viewed the transition to more character and narrative-based statuary in the early classical
period. However, we don't really know who the Deriphoros is. Even if he embodies the canon,
he is also a spear-carrier. Is he an athlete? Is he a warrior? Is he Achilles? Where was his
original location? Was it in a gym, as the much later Roman marble copy from Herculaneum was
found? Is it a commemorative statue, like the charioteer of Delphi, perhaps a winner of the
Olympic Games? There may be other implicit themes, as I briefly mentioned when we first
encountered nudity on vases, the Greeks actually considered male nudity to be a sign of sophistication
and refinement. Contrary to many of our preconceptions, to the Greeks, nudity represented
civilization. The barbarians, as they called non-Greek-speaking foreigners, were considered
less cultivated due to their rejection of nudity as a general principle. However, the Greeks
maintained a strong sense of propriety with regard to nudity. Women were covered in public, and they
generally did not see men exercising or competing in the nude. Revealing the glands was also
considered indecent, and the foreskin was often tied to avoid any accidental exposures. In sculpture
and painting, the flaccid penis is generally rendered on the small side, a kind of exaggerated
retraction, I think, to remove overtly sexual connotations. Remember, in art, sexuality is often
visually equated with the uncivilized or non-rational side of humanity. Even so, we've
admitted there's an inherent eroticism to the nude body. We know the unbearded male, in particular,
is still fair game, and how could we forget those writers who spoke of the gymnasium as a place that
incited homosexual desire? Object of emulation, of appreciation, of desire, or all of these at once,
the Doryphoros creates an ideal template for the male body,
a carefully calculated system of proportions that could be applied to all statues.
In fact, we see the same body, the same face, the same canon, in another statue by Polykleitos,
the Diadumenos. This statue depicts a muscled athlete tying a victory ribbon,
for which he is named, around his head. As with the Doryphoros, there are many Roman
marble copies of this bronze original in various states of preservation. You can actually find two
of the 25 known copies here in New York at the Met. The statue on the left actually was partially
restored by using a plaster cast. Only the head, arms, and parts of the leg are original.
The plaster cast torso helps hold it all together. Although the Polykleitos statues
are beautiful, you understand better the problem with an ideal, ultimately a formula,
when you find yourself looking at more or less the exact same figure,
with just a different pose to the arms. In female statuary, there are still no nudes,
but there is a rapid progression in terms of the portrayal of the underlying anatomical forms during
the 5th century. As you can see from this Roman marble copy of a statue of Aphrodite,
originally cast in bronze around 420-410 BC by Callimachus, the drapery clings so closely to
the body so as to almost reveal it. Furthermore, Aphrodite's left breast is exposed, a touch of
immodesty appropriate only for the goddess of love. We'll see more of this clinging drapery
in the Parthenon architectural sculpture, and with that, we'll turn to the Acropolis.
