Tire Test Goes Wrong: We Break a Land Cruiser

Luxe Auto Hub
7 followers
3 Video Views·Jul 23, 2026
Do you really need to upgrade to all-terrain tires? We compare two similarly-spec'd Land Cruiser 250s to see just how much better all terrains are on challenging trails.
Then it all goes wrong.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Today we are at our mountain test course here in Central Washington State.
And we don't just have one Land Cruiser today. Nope, we've got two of them.
Just a few weeks ago, we added a new and challenging section to our mountain test course.
The first vehicle up was our 2026 Ford Bronco Badlands. And, as expected, it did great. But
the viewers were not satisfied. They spoke out in the comments section and said, hey,
we want to see you bring your Land Cruiser up the same new trail.
So today I didn't just bring my Land Cruiser. I also brought a brand new 2026 Land Cruiser,
which is basically identical, but not in every single way.
Prices you see it here, $70,395 including destination. It includes a premium package,
which adds leather seats, a sunroof, JBL sound, a digital rearview mirror, and some other niceties.
It also has the stabilizer disconnect mechanism and two-tone paint.
This is our 2024 Toyota Land Cruiser First Edition. We bought it for the show a few years ago,
and I put 30,000 miles on it to date. It's been a really good vehicle to drive across the country,
up mountains, and through mud and snow. It's a trim that is no longer available.
The only way now to get the round headlights is to buy the entry level 1958.
Both of these are powered by the same 2.4 liter turbo hybrid system.
They make 326 horsepower and 465 pound-feet of torque.
The four-wheel drive systems are also completely identical.
So functionally, these are the same, but there is one significant difference.
The new Land Cruiser has the stock wheel and tire package featuring 18-inch alloys
wrapped in very mild Michelin LTX trail tires. These are a 265-70 R18 fitment.
If you look at the tread, you can tell this looks more like a street tire than an all-terrain.
Ours has 18-inch TRD alloys wrapped in Falcon Wildpeak AT4W all-terrains.
This is a 265-70 R18 fitment, and it is an e-load, which means it has extra layers for durability.
That also means it's very heavy, which can really impact MPGs.
So that's right, it is time for a shootout, and we're going to answer two questions.
First off, are the factory tires that come with the Land Cruiser as bad as people say?
And can a mild trail tire actually climb our mountain test course?
Let's saddle up, and we're going to start with the new one.
This episode of Driving Sports TV is brought to you by Onyx Off-Road.
Click the link below to save 20% off your new membership using the code DSTV.
We love Onyx Off-Road for planning our off-road adventures.
Which trails to drive? How hard are they? Are they even open?
Onyx Off-Road provides all that information,
in addition to tools to help plan and organize your next adventure.
Have you watched one of our mini road trip videos?
We use Onyx Off-Road to plan and navigate every adventure.
And right now, you can get 20% off your premium or elite membership
to Onyx Off-Road with the code DSTV.
That's, of course, an abbreviation for Driving Sports TV.
It's a little weird having two vehicles that are so similarly specced.
When I got my Land Cruiser in 2024, I immediately changed the tires out
because they really weren't up to spec with what I wanted to do.
However, we never really explored just how capable those tires were.
So today, we're going to see what they can do.
Now, why doesn't Toyota put proper all-terrains on the Land Cruiser?
On our drive out here, we drove both vehicles back-to-back,
the caravan all the way out, basically driving exactly the same.
From Gig Harbor to North Bend, this vehicle did 22.1 MPGs.
My 2024 with all-terrain e-loads, yeah, it did 18.1.
And then when we continued past North Bend, it went all the way to the summit.
Gig Harbor to the summit, that is 16.6 MPGs in my 2024.
And then this one with the Michelin Trail tires did it with 19.9 MPGs.
Now, both of those legs are mostly uphill because we're climbing from
essentially sea level up to the mountains.
And you can see that tires make a huge difference in terms of MPGs.
We're going to start here on Lower Python Pass and try to give it a bit of a climb.
Now, we have cleaned up the trail a little bit.
We've just taken some shrubbery out,
but we haven't actually modified the trail in terms of actual surface at all.
I'm going to go ahead and switch it into 4-low.
That basically opens the toolbox of options here in a Toyota.
Toyota basically makes it so you have to go 4-low to get access to all of your off-road goodies.
So we're in 4-low.
I'm going to lock my center diff, and I'm going to start out here with MTS.
I'm not going to lock the rear yet.
Let's just see what this can do with the computerized traction control
before we turn on that rear locker.
And I'm just going to keep it in auto for MTS.
Now, if you're curious, what's the difference between the older A-Track and new MTS?
MTS is like a scalpel.
A-Track is a sledgehammer.
MTS is basically a more refined A-Track.
I think we're going to have problems with those mud flaps on this vehicle.
See, we're already slipping.
I'm just going to add a little throttle, try to climb up here.
Now, we're testing tires.
We're not testing the ability for momentum to hurl us up a hill, obviously.
So I have to kind of take it easy.
Oh, we got off that first section.
Of course, this is the easiest part of the trail.
Let's not scratch that nose.
This is the easiest part of the trail, so I kind of expected this would not be a huge issue.
Okay, and now we're at the midpoint of the lower section.
Now, one nice thing about not using lockers is we still have the ability to turn pretty
smoothly.
If my locker was on, we would be dragging that rear inside tire.
Let's turn off those parking sensors.
There we go.
Trail camera back on.
Such a nice trail camera in this vehicle.
Up, sharp corner.
Okay, so far it's done well, but the real challenge is the new extension to the trail,
which is right here.
I know this is going to be a challenge for this vehicle, especially because
we don't have rock sliders.
We also have these little plastic pieces in front of the tires that are there for aero.
I took them off on mine.
I probably lost maybe half an mpg because I did that.
But it will affect our approach angle slightly, for the worse.
I'm going to go ahead and disconnect the front stabilizer bar.
I'm going to lock the rear differential.
And let's see how well we climb up this.
I'm going to do the same line that I did with my Bronco, which is taking the trench on the
left here.
Listen for scraping.
I got to keep in mind, this is actually Toyota's vehicle.
I'm just borrowing it.
So we got to be nice to it.
Now with the Bronco, I tried to walk up and it couldn't.
I had to, I had to charge it.
So what?
Wait, wait, wait, what?
What?
Okay, credit where credit is due, the traction control system on this vehicle is crazy good.
Crazy good.
What the heck?
Like, yeah, even the Bronco had problems with that one.
But this one, baby, just walked right up.
Now I'm going to turn on my camera here.
I've got something dragging on the chassis.
I'm not going to go too deep here, but I want to go deep enough to kind of stress the system.
You know, a big pile of dirt here on the side.
I'll also keep in mind, this has running boards.
It does not have rock rails.
So I see a lot of, oh, the mud flaps.
Mud flaps are going to be an issue.
Okay, now we got the drops here.
I don't know how long, this is a longer wheelbase, obviously, than my Bronco.
So I have no idea how we're going to do here.
Thankfully, unlike my Bronco, I have a really nice camera system.
So we're just going to drop down here and see if we drag.
I think we probably are.
Listen, listen.
Dimensions are good.
Now this next one is steeper.
So I'm going to take it at a slight angle, which should help with those
step boards on the side, hopefully.
That way we're putting one wheel down, not both at the same time.
Got a little scrape, but not too bad.
But now we're over on the rocks over here.
Okay, this is a tricky trail.
We made it wider so we have more room to play and we're not forced into a singular track.
No, I need to avoid the bump on the right.
I'll just kiss it.
Because I know with these step boards, that's just not going to happen.
Got a little dip in, dip down.
Oh, yeah, bumped something there, but it was gentle.
Oh, this approach, oof.
Let me check out this approach.
This looks like I'm going to stuff something.
Oh, it's so close.
We are going to start picking up though.
So I'm going to re-jigger this and go in at a slight angle.
By lifting up a corner, it'll improve our approach slightly.
Just enough sometimes.
But of course, now we need to cut around.
Oh, those mud flaps.
Why does Toyota put bad plastic mud flaps on things?
It's like the mud flaps on my first edition are excellent.
I love them.
They protect from rocks and mud, but they never drag, fall off, cause me heartache or problems.
I love it.
Okay, that's pretty tilty.
Now we're coming up to the rock garden.
And honestly, I'm just going to try to get through this without damaging anything, okay?
Let me see what my strategy is going to be.
I think it's zigzag.
That's my strategy.
Now, I'm going to have to put a wheel up on the rock on the left.
But I don't have enough clearance to fully straddle it.
So I'm going to come up to the rock in front of me as much as possible.
And I'm going to hard left it.
And we're going to lift up and try to avoid that rock best we can.
I think we're clear.
But that back driver wheel is going to hit.
There we go.
And now I'm trying to zigzag back, which means my back wheel is now going to
lift up on that rock, probably.
Now, one thing I love about Toyota's camera system,
is you can see both the front and the rear wheels.
That is like almost unheard of.
Make sure that I'm going to clear this one without totally destroying Toyota's lovely wheels.
Actually, truth be told, if I destroy these ones,
I have a full set of them that look exactly like this back at my home garage.
OK, now we're going to go around there.
OK, so that is a proper test of a camera system, if nothing else.
I'll watch my front here.
Now we are going to...
I don't want to cut over too soon because we still need to clear that.
OK, so that is tricky.
It's not the kind of tricky that you might have expected.
You might have thought I was going to crawl over those.
But without rock rails?
No, I'm not going to.
Cool.
Well, it got through the upper Python Pass.
Now we're going to continue on the easy part.
And we're going to try the next climb, which is the Challenging Access Road.
Oh, geez, I forgot how steep this is.
OK, because not only is this steep, it's also not a straight approach.
So we have to come in at an angle, which means we can't just floor it,
because it also kind of tilts in towards the wall.
So if we go too fast here, there's a very strong possibility
that we could shunt into the wall, which I think is mostly rock and clay.
So that means what we need to do here is a very slow crawl approach.
Even if we could go fast, that's kind of dangerous.
And it's because the trail is not like this.
It's like this.
And there's the wall.
OK, let's see what this can do.
Now I'm going to lock the rear again.
I'm going to keep MTS in auto.
Sway bar is disconnected.
And we're going to try to just walk up
with mild trail tires.
Can you do it?
I mean, the traction system on this vehicle are so good.
We're still making some progress.
What? It's still climbing.
OK, is this the is this is this the end of our track?
We're not really making any progress here.
OK, so is this something you're going to do with your Land Cruiser?
Then you might need to upgrade your tires.
But I'm going to say for right now, I'm going to call it on this one.
You'll probably notice that the back of this is starting to pivot in towards the wall.
We don't want that.
So I'm going to go ahead and back out of this.
And we're going to see if we can do it with my Land Cruiser
equipped with proper all-terrain tires.
Let's not scratch that if we can avoid that.
There we go.
Very good.
OK.
I think that did way better, honestly, than I had expected.
Wow, that is going to that is a brutal wall.
Like I got to get repositioned here.
Let's just get.
Yeah, we're going to slide over here.
There we go.
It's the angled entry on this one that really makes it tricky.
And the steepness and the surface and yada, yada, yada.
Yeah, it's just a tricky climb.
So now it's time to go get my Land Cruiser with the all-terrains.
And we're going to see if we can finish that one section.
And then if we can with the all-terrains, then I'm going to go to the upper Python Pass.
And we're going to try to take some harder lines up there.
See what we can do with proper underbody protection.
OK.
Now, it's nice to be able to drive a 2026 right before driving mine,
because it really shows me how this vehicle has worn in in the 30,000 miles that I've driven it.
The seats still look basically like new.
One thing I have noticed, however, is the steering wheel is a lot
smoother after that much driving, obviously from oils in the hands.
But you know what?
It's actually really comfortable now.
I prefer it now to when I bought it.
So it's actually, like, weathered in really nicely.
I mean, these clearly were built to be owned for a while.
Swing around wide and get set up.
Oop, rock.
That beep you heard was my dash cam.
Which, yeah, this thing has so many features, it actually came with a dash cam.
Let's set this up the same way that I just set up the other one.
I'm going to go to multi-terrain select auto.
I'm going to lock my center diff.
I'm going to go into low range.
And I'm going to disconnect my front stabilizer bar.
And I'm going to lock my rear locker.
Now, what I could do to make this climb easier is I could air the tires down.
But for consistency, we try to actually run all of these courses at street pressures.
So waiting for that rear locker to kick in.
Toyotas, you have to have a little differential movement before they lock in their lockers.
So again, I'm just going to try to climb up safe and steady.
We're not going to use momentum.
Climb on up and see what this does.
Big boulder right there.
Okay, already further along, I think.
Nope, this is the spot.
This is the spot where the other tires couldn't get it.
I add a little throttle.
We're making progress.
I think I just blew my front diff.
Okay, let's wheel back and see what we got.
I think I saw oil come out the bottom.
Oh.
Oh, we hit something there.
I did actually break a small piece of plastic off.
Okay.
Well, let's see what we got here, shall we?
Not what I wanted to happen today, that's for sure.
So I don't even know how this got broken.
Did you see this snag at all?
I just heard a clunk when I came down.
It must have snagged a rock.
So this I'm not too worried about.
That's cosmetic.
Let's see what we have for oil.
It definitely sounded like we snapped our front diff.
This is typically a problem for vehicles that are running like 37s.
Those are 33s though.
Oh yeah, oil, oil, diff oil.
Okay, well, that's unfortunate.
Well, let's get this thing parked and figure out what we're going to do next.
Oh, better throw this in.
I'm just going to go real slow.
Turn off that rear locker.
I did not expect that today.
Oh, come on, seatbelt, calm down.
Okay, so I'm probably going to call a tow truck
and we're going to try to get this towed out of here.
I don't know what's going to happen next.
I don't know how long it's going to take.
These vehicles are very capable.
I have driven that Land Cruiser across the entirety of the United States western region,
driven up hills, mountains, through snow, you can imagine it, never had an issue.
So I'm actually kind of glad that if we're going to break it, we're going to break it here because,
hey, we got a second Land Cruiser that we can drive home.
For Driving Sports TV, I'm Ryan Douthit.
Thanks for watching.
Be sure to like, subscribe, definitely subscribe,
and share our videos.
We make them for you.
We break them for you.
And we'll see you right here on the next one.
Even though we had to cut the tire test short,
one thing we did learn is that even in loose and challenging conditions,
the stock tires actually worked pretty well.
Granted, they aren't as durable or versatile as a proper set of all-terrains,
but for most Land Cruiser buyers, the LTX trails provided a nice ride even in the dirt.
And they did it without compromising on fuel economy.
Now, let's talk about our 2024 Land Cruiser.
I did have the dealership fix the arch over the rear wheel.
This was pulled off as I was pulling down, and I was having non-responsive front wheels,
so couldn't quite get out of that corner easily.
But it ended up being about $350 from the dealer,
and that included both the actual plastic piece of the surround,
as well as all fasteners and labor.
As for the loud bang, that wasn't the front differential.
It was the front CV joint, which is connected to the differential.
And even Toyota agreed it shouldn't have snapped,
so it was completely covered under warranty.
This does have a five-year, 60,000-mile powertrain warranty.
So, that's a win.
The mechanic over at the Toyota dealership did say
that he's never seen the CV joint fail quite the way this one did.
So what happens now?
Well, the parts were shipped over to Toyota Corporate.
They will have their engineers take a look at them
and determine if there is a bigger issue to be concerned about.
So for right now, we're just going to consider this a one-off part failure.
Hopefully, it doesn't signal a bigger issue with these Land Cruiser 250s.
But we're going to keep driving this and keep doing adventures,
and we'll definitely learn more in the coming years.
Thanks again for watching, and we'll see you again right here on the next video.
