The Senate Judiciary Committee holds an executive business meeting at 10:15 a.m. ET on July 23 to organize committee subcommittees and consider the nominations of Todd Blanche for Attorney General, Daniel D. Domenico for the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 10th Circuit, Matthew R. Byrne for the U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Ohio, and Christopher Nassar for U.S. Attorney for the Northern District of Oklahoma.
Nominees Todd Blanche — Attorney General of the United States Daniel D. Domenico — U.S. Circuit Judge, Tenth Circuit Matthew R. Byrne — U.S. District Judge, Southern District of Ohio Christopher Nassar — U.S. Attorney, Northern District of Oklahoma
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
The Senate Judiciary Committee met to handle administrative duties, vote on judicial nominees, and debate the nomination of Todd Blanche as Attorney General. The session was characterized by intense partisan conflict regarding the independence of the Justice Department, the legality of presidential pardons, and the integrity of the nomination process.
On today's agenda, we'll address an organization issue
because this is our newest colleague,
Senator Graham's first markup.
I'll have a few words on that in a moment.
We'll be making it official that she'll fill
the late Senator Graham's position on the subcommittees.
It's my understanding that we can adopt this measure
by voice vote in terms of committee assignments.
On today's agenda, we also have four nominations
that we'll vote on.
Daniel Donahue to serve as a circuit judge
on the U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals, 10th Circuit.
Matthew Byrne to serve as judge on the U.S. District Court,
Southern District, Ohio.
Christopher Nassar to serve as U.S. Attorney,
the Northern District of Oklahoma.
The remaining nominee, Todd Blanche,
was listed for the first time
and will be held over for future consideration.
All three of the nominees that we're voting on today
are highly qualified.
Want to go on to the point about
our newest committee member, Senator Graham.
I speak for all of the colleagues here,
welcome you as a new member of this committee.
And I hope you know on this committee
that for this senator, sitting beside Senator Graham here
when he was chairman and also when I've been chairman
and then also on the budget committee
where he was chairman, I sat beside him.
We worked together on a lot of things
and I really miss his advice,
but more his humor and everything that went with it,
all good humor.
He was surely a true patriot and a defender of this nation.
And all of us, as you know, are deeply saddened by his passing.
We're honored to have you here
and we're confident that you'll continue to make
Lindsey very proud, serving in his place on this committee
and any other committees you're on.
I want to go on and speak about
the hearing that we had last week
on acting Attorney General Blanche
regarding his nomination for permanent role.
He demonstrated his ongoing commitment
to transparency and rule of law.
Indeed, the Justice Department
has thrived under his leadership.
The nation's murder rate
is the lowest it's been in a century.
The Justice Department has protected Americans
at every turn.
We've seen an increase in violent crime arrests,
the disruption of terrorist activities
and seizure of illegal firearms and controlled substances.
We've also seen an increase in the arrests
of child predators and human traffickers
and a massive recovery of missing children
lost during the Biden years.
Mr. Blanche has also led major successes
in thwarting federal program fraud
and ending racial discrimination
embedded in our government under the Biden administration.
Despite all of Mr. Blanche's successes,
the Democratic members of the committee
and throughout the entire Senate,
like clockwork, sought to defame him.
Yesterday, we saw committee Democrats
hold what one reporter called, quote-unquote,
a shadow forum to lodge their attacks against Mr. Blanche.
That description seems appropriate
because the Democrats has operated in the shadows for years.
Now, they're not hiding it.
Some of yesterday's panelists was a former spokesman
for Special Counsel Jack Smith.
As my and Senator Johnson's oversight
has repeatedly uncovered time and time again,
Jack Smith ushered in a weaponization of government
unparalleled in our nation's history.
So if the people who engaged
in the worst partisan warfare this country has ever seen
have a problem with Todd Blanche,
the American people should take notice
because it means Mr. Blanche is doing something right.
To be clear, I don't agree with how Mr. Blanche
or the Justice Department has handled every matter
and I've demanded answers and will continue to do so,
but I'd like to address a few of the recent attacks
waged by others.
Some has falsely alleged that Mr. Blanche
hadn't met with Epstein victims at the hearing.
Mr. Blanche confirmed that he and other
Justice Department officials
personally met with more than 30 victims.
He also rearranged his schedule
to meet with victims present at the hearing that same day.
It's clear that Mr. Blanche is sincere
when he stated, quote,
everyone at the department, including myself,
remains committed to engaging
with the victims of Jeffrey Epstein, end of quote.
Many have also criticized Mr. Blanche
for President Trump's settlement with the IRS.
That settlement purported to establish
the infamous anti-weaponization fraud.
Mr. Blanche has unequivocally stated
on multiple occasions before Congress
and not just on this committee,
but including sworn testimony before this committee
and in multiple court filings across different courts
that the fraud, that the fund is dead.
Still many of my Democratic colleagues
have challenged the portion of the settlement
that remains intact, specifically a release of claims
against President Trump and his family.
To be clear, their tax information
was stolen and unlawfully disclosed
by a convicted criminal contracting with the IRS
and a mutual release of claims
is as commonplace in a settlement
as the paper it was written on.
But for those criticizing the scope of immunity
afforded to the President and his family
who were victims of that crime,
I ask this, where was the Democratic outcry
when President Biden granted blanket pardons
for his own family and associates?
Those pardons often offer blanket
and prospective immunity for prior crimes.
I'd like to read to you now from Hunter Biden's pardon.
It was, quote, a full and unconditional pardon
for those offenses against the United States
which he has committed or may have committed
or taking part in during the period January 1, 2014
through December 1, 2024, end of quote.
Blanket immunity for any crime whatsoever,
known or non-known, that's a fact.
No future prosecution for conduct covering a decade,
that's a fact.
President Biden issued sweeping,
decade-long prospective immunity
for his entire family,
and he did the same for political allies like Dr. Fauci.
So isn't that self-dealing?
I heard crickets from my Democratic colleagues
when President Biden afforded
this widespread unprecedented immunity.
So spare me the outrage.
I get it, my Democratic colleagues
don't like President Trump.
They get mad about everything he's done
regardless of whatever it is
and whether prior Democratic presidents did the same thing.
But thwarting this nomination won't hurt the president.
It'll hurt the American people who are now safer
thanks to Mr. Blanch's successful leadership.
Senator Durbin.
Thank you, Mr. Chairman.
I wanna welcome Senator Darlene Graham
to the Senate Judiciary Committee.
We all miss your brother and our friend, Lindsey.
I can't tell you how many times we worked together,
but it was always a joy.
I see you bring a little different flavor
to the Graham family participation.
I don't see any cans of Coke Zero in front of you,
and I don't believe your brother would attend any session
that didn't include him.
But thank you so much for being with us,
and we want to work with you as we worked with your brother.
Every meeting of the Senate Judiciary Committee
has a necessary starting point, and today was no exception.
Before we can talk about anything else,
we've gotta talk about Jack Smith.
Jack Smith is the political punching bag
of the Senate Judiciary Committee.
Jack Smith, that special counsel
who was looking for foreign influence
on American elections,
whether there was any wrongdoing with classified documents.
Jack Smith, let's go get him.
Wouldn't it be interesting if we could just call him
before this committee, put him under oath,
demand the answers?
Well, he's offered to come before this committee now,
I think, for six months.
We wrote to the chairman and said, bring him in.
Instead of talking about him, bring him in.
Ask these questions under oath,
and if he perjures himself, he'll be held responsible.
But he apparently thinks that he can handle himself
and would like to come before the committee.
We can't do that because we gotta keep punching him,
and if you gotta punch him
and he's already answered the question, it's tough.
So, for some reason, this majority
of the Senate Judiciary Committee
would rather punch Jack Smith verbally before every session
than actually get direct answers from him under oath.
He's still available,
and he should be called on that situation.
To call this agreement that was signed by Blanche
when it came to the Trump family commonplace,
that was a word the chairman used,
commonplace, commonplace for the federal government
to say to any individual, we will forever discharge you
from any criminal liability involving the tax code,
and more, and to do that and to say that that is commonplace,
it is far from commonplace.
It is so unique that a federal judge in Florida
has spelled out the fact that this was extraordinary
treatment and raises serious ethical questions.
Let me also say about blanket pardons.
The president retired the trophy on blanket pardons,
if you'll remember.
His first day in office, he pardoned everyone
who assaulted the Capitol, the insurrectionists
who came in here with the design to tear up this building,
to assault our police officers,
and to stop the process of counting the votes
in the 2020 election.
They did that.
He had to remove the vice president from the Senate chamber.
The Secret Service thought his future was in doubt
if he stayed there under the circumstances.
So President Trump, first day in office in the second term,
gives a blanket pardon to every one of those insurrectionists
for whatever they did, assaulting police officers,
beating him up, all the things that they did.
I don't think that that is easily explained or dismissed.
Whether Biden was right with his pardons,
I'll leave it to you to make your own judgment.
But to say the president's pardon of these cop-beaters
is somehow excusable because of that is just not the same.
I want to take a moment to respond to the claim
that Todd Blanch's confirmation hearing,
Democrats had never criticized
the Biden Justice Department actions.
This is simply and provably false.
When I was chair of this committee,
we held regular oversight hearings, a rarity now.
The hearings covered the Justice Department,
the FBI, and other DOJ components.
And I frequently criticized the Justice Department
and compelled Department of Justice officials,
my own party, to answer for their actions.
Take a few examples.
I called Biden DOJ officials to testify
on the misuse of FISA Section 702.
I called FBI Director Wray to testify
about the FBI's mistreatment of Olympic gymnasts
who were sexually abused.
We had multiple hearings on the implementation
of the first STEP Act signed into law by President Trump
and successfully pushed Attorney General Garland
to bring new leadership to the Bureau of Prisons.
In fact, before this administration,
it wasn't unusual for senators of both parties
to criticize the Justice Department
and call for the Attorney General
to maintain his independence from the president.
During his confirmation hearing,
Republican members lectured Merrick Garland,
and they said,
what we need from our next Attorney General,
the Republicans said, more than anything else, independence.
And the Attorney General, quote,
must be willing to stand up to the president,
my Republican colleagues said,
and say no when the office demands it.
I agree with them, but I don't hear that tune
when it comes to this administration.
Attorney General Garland bent over backwards
to be apolitical.
He appointed a career prosecutor
as independent special counsel
to oversee the investigations of the former president,
and he delegated charging decisions
and day-to-day supervision to the special counsel
to avoid potential conflicts of interest.
Now we have a president who claims,
and I quote him,
absolute right to do what I want
with the Justice Department, end of quote,
and is seeking, quote,
retribution, his words, against the enemy within.
He tweets out orders to the Department of Justice
to prosecute his political opponents,
and Republicans go radio silent and look at their shoes.
I'm old enough to remember when Republicans claimed
a chance 30-minute meeting on the airport tarmac
between former President Clinton
and Attorney General Lynch
was damning evidence of collusion
between Obama White House and the Justice Department,
30 minutes on the tarmac.
But Republicans expressed no concern
that Vice President Vance's
leading lengthy strategy sessions
with Todd Blanche and Kash Patel
in the White House Situation Room
on how to protect Donald Trump
from the Epstein-Files scandal.
Everything we heard from Todd Blanche
at his hearing last week
in his response to written questions
which my colleague will address
indicates that if confirmed as Attorney General,
Blanche will continue to serve the interests
of Donald Trump, not the American people.
He defended his decision to collude
with Trump's private lawyers
to establish a $2 billion trust slush fund
for January 6th cop eaters
and give Trump his family and his businesses
immunity from criminal tax laws.
He continues to claim that the slush fund is, quote, dead,
but refuses to commit any tangible step
to ensure that it cannot be revived.
As one committee member, Senator Cornyn, pointed out,
the text of the settlement agreement
says only parties to the agreement can modify its terms
and Trump and his family could sue to enforce the agreement.
This is Contracts 101,
as one of the witnesses of the outside panel yesterday said.
Blanche also failed to address the inconsistency
between his claims about IRS immunity
and the deal's actual language.
He claimed the deal applies only to Trump.
That's what Blanche told us,
his sons, and the Trump organization.
But the senator from Texas also noted
the language of the agreement also covers, quote,
related or affiliated individuals, close quote,
including, quote, related companies,
affiliates, and subsidiaries.
It goes way beyond what Blanche told us.
Blanche also claimed at the hearing
that the immunity order binds only the IRS
and by extension, the treasury,
but the language of the order
covers other agencies or departments.
And of course, if corruption is coming up to bat,
the crypto boys are surely in the lineup.
Blanche also failed to explain
why he gutted DOJ's crypto crime enforcement
while he personally held investments in crypto assets
of more than $150,000,
allowing the president to rake in $1.4 billion
in crypto windfall in the last year,
even as Americans reported billions of dollars
in crypto fraud losses.
I will have more to say
about this deeply troubling nomination next week.
I yield.
We don't have a quorum yet,
so I'm gonna call on Senator Whitehouse
while he's on the stage.
Yeah, thanks very much, Chairman.
This is in the nature of a point of personal privilege
because in my exchange with Mr. Blanche last week,
well, let me say what I said
and let me tell the committee what his response was.
Here's what I said.
You've refused to exclude January 6th rioters
from your anti-weaponization fund.
You've refused to put in writing
that the slush fund is dead.
Indeed, you've signaled to allies
that payouts are still on track.
You've vacated seditious conspiracy convictions
against members of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers.
You hired January 6th rioter Jared Wise
who'd urged the mob to kill police officers.
You scrubbed press releases about January 6th prosecutions
and called the releases partisan propaganda.
You denied that Trump encouraged any violence
on January 6th.
You cleaned house of every attorney
who worked on a case related to Trump
and you bragged that bringing justice to violent rioters
meant that, quote, every one of them was either pardoned
or had their sentence commuted, end quote.
So that's what I said.
Here was how Blanche began his response.
Almost everything the senator just said,
and he's protected, he's allowed to lie,
but almost everything he just said was absolutely false.
And he ended by saying,
so the narrative that the senator just suggested
and put on me as something I believe is absolutely not true.
We concluded that exchange by saying,
well, let's look at the QFRs.
When you're under oath, we can go through them one by one.
Well, we have the QFRs back.
As to the question of whether he refused
to exclude January 6th rioters
from the Anti-Weaponization Fund,
here's the question.
Yes or no, when you testified
before the Senate Appropriations Committee on May 19, 2026
in response to the question
whether individuals who assaulted Capitol Hill
police officers are eligible to apply for payments
under the Anti-Weaponization Fund,
did you say, and I quote,
anybody in this country is eligible to apply
if they believe they were a victim of weaponization,
end quote.
Response, yes.
So there's one.
To the allegation that he refused to put in writing
that the slush fund is dead.
Question, yes or no,
when you testified before the House Appropriations Committee
on June 2, 2026 in response to the question
whether you were going to issue a new memo in writing
rescinding that May 18 memo
establishing the Anti-Weaponization Fund,
did you say, I'm not committing
to putting anything in writing
and okay, I'm not committing to doing anything in writing?
Answer again, yes.
Signal to allies that payouts are still on track.
Here's the question.
Yes or no, on June 2, 2026,
after you said the Anti-Weaponization Fund
would not move forward,
did Stanley Woodward, your subordinate
and the DOJ representative
who signed the purported settlement agreement
establishing the quote Anti-Weaponization Fund tweet
were on it in response to a tweet
suggesting that there should be a weaponization fund
that will be available to the victims
of the weaponized Biden Justice Department
who can prove their claims against the federal government
through the Federal Tort Claims Act.
Again, he said, as I testified at my confirmation hearing,
the fund can only operate through action by the department,
namely the appointment of commissioners,
the creation of a claims process
to transfer funds and payments.
At my direction, the department will not take these steps,
but the point was about the Federal Tort Claims Act,
which he again failed to deny,
failed to show any falsehood or lie on my part.
He vacated seditious conspiracy convictions
against members of the Proud Boys and Oath Keepers.
Question, on April 14, 2026,
did DOJ move to vacate the seditious conspiracy convictions
of members of the Proud Boys?
Response, on April 14, 2026,
the U.S. Attorney's Office for the District of Columbia
filed a motion to vacate the convictions
of multiple individuals that I believe
are the subject of this question.
Same question with respect to Oath Keepers,
his answer, please see my response to the previous question.
Hired January 6th rioter Jared Wise
who'd urged the mob to kill police officers.
Question, did Mr. Wise work for DOJ
during your tenure as Deputy Attorney General?
Mr. Wise worked at DOJ during my tenure,
although I did not hire him.
It would otherwise be inappropriate for me
to comment on personnel matters
within the Department of Justice.
The facts, including emails that we have,
show that Wise worked at DOJ
from at least May 2025 through April 2026.
Mr. Blanche was confirmed as the Deputy Attorney General
in March 2025.
The hiring of Mr. Wise happened
under the tenure of Todd Blanche.
It's hard to imagine that you can say,
I did not hire him.
Of course the Deputy Attorney General
doesn't hire people personally,
but that evidently was the point he was trying to make.
Moreover, during that time, did Mr. Wise at any point
have the title of Senior Advisor
in the Office of the Deputy Attorney General?
Response, yes.
During that time, did Mr. Wise at any point
have an email address associated
with the Office of the Deputy Attorney General?
Response, yes.
To the scrubbing of press releases
and calling them partisan propaganda.
Question, did DOJ during your tenure
as Deputy Attorney General or Acting Attorney General
remove from its website press releases
on prosecutions related to the January 6th, 2021
attack on the U.S. Capitol?
Response, during my tenure,
the Department of Justice has worked to reverse
the Biden administration's weaponization of the department.
This includes stripping the department's website
of partisan propaganda, like the press releases mentioned,
confirming the truth of my statement.
Denied that Trump encouraged any violence on January 6th.
On November 15, 2023,
in the case of United States versus Trump,
I asked, did you and other attorneys
representing President Trump submit a filing saying,
not a shred of evidence suggests President Trump
called for any violence or asked anyone
to enter the Capitol unlawfully on January 6th?
Response, yes.
That is one quote from a substantive court filing.
Question whether he cleaned house of every attorney
who worked on a case related to Trump.
QFR, on March 26th, 26th,
CPAC with respect to the prosecutions
against President Trump,
did you say there is not a single man or woman
at the Department of Justice
who had anything to do with those prosecutions?
Yes, that is an excerpt of my remarks.
On the same day in response to the question
of how many of those investigators have been canned,
did you say over 200?
Over 200 either left before we came in
because they knew it was coming
or were fired or took early retirement.
They are no longer employed by this department.
Response, please see my response to the previous question,
which was yes, this is an excerpt of my remarks.
On the same day, did you say,
and when it comes to the FBI,
Director Patel has cleaned house there too?
There isn't a single man or woman with a gun,
federal agents still in that organization
that had anything to do
with the prosecution of federal Trump.
He agrees, he fills in the ellipsis in my QFR adding,
which takes a lot of criticism,
especially because of what happened
over the past several years,
but he agrees with my accurate quotation with the ellipsis.
And lastly, bragged that bringing justice
to violent rioters meant that every one of them
was either pardoned or had their sentence commuted.
My question involved his March 26th, 2026 presentation
at CPAC where he said, and I'm quoting here,
if you look at what happened to the men and women
convicted because of January 6th,
by 5 p.m. on January 20th,
every one of them was either pardoned
or had their sentence commuted.
Response, please see my response to question 11A.
It is inaccurate to say I bragged.
Well, it seems to me that it's a pretty heavy load
to come into this committee under oath
and accuse a senator of absolutely false claims
and lying because I'm protected by the committee.
So I wanted to make a record of the fact
that when we went through the statement
that he said was a lie and all falsehoods,
he agreed to every single element of that statement
one by one in his QFRs except minor details
like filling in an ellipsis or saying that he bragged.
None of that amounts to lying.
None of that makes the statements the least bit false.
I stand by what I said and I wish this committee
held our witnesses to a higher standard of conduct.
Thank you, Chairman.
We either, we need one more person
to ratify the appointment of Senator Graham
to the subcommittees and we can't do the nominations
until we get all of the members on my side of the aisle here.
So does anybody wanna speak while we wait?
And if nobody wants to speak,
I was going to ask Senator Graham
after we approved her appointments to the subcommittees,
did you have anything you wanted to say to the committee?
And if you did, now would be a good time to say it.
Thank you.
Thank you, Chairman Grassley
and thank you to Ranking Member Durbin as well.
First, I just wanna say that many of you
have reached out with your posts.
Can I ask you if you can get a little closer
to the microphone?
Can you hear me?
First, I wanna say that many of you have reached out
with personal stories that you've shared about Lindsey
and just how much that has meant to me.
This has been an incredibly tough week for me
as y'all can imagine.
So the stories and just how he personally touched everyone
has meant so very much to me and I greatly appreciate it.
I've watched my brother over the years
serve on this committee
and I know how important he took his role
as a member, ranking member and chairman.
I can assure you that I will serve with this committee
with the same level of commitment as he did.
For nearly 30 years, I've served people of South Carolina.
So I know how the work of this committee
impacts the lives of South Carolinians
and Americans across the country.
What we do in this room impacts the safety
and prosperity of every American.
I understand the weight of this responsibility
and I intend to meet it with the same seriousness,
integrity and care that I've brought to every day
of my career in South Carolina,
to the people of South Carolina.
I'm honored to be joining the Senate Judiciary Committee
and I look forward to serving alongside each one of you.
We welcome you and thank you.
Mr. Chairman, please go ahead.
If we can't do the business of the committee
because members are in another committee
and it's unpredictable when they'll leave that committee
and come to this one,
can I suggest that we have Senator Graham's issue
raised off the floor after the first vote this morning
when we're all going to be there
and hold over the other business of the committee
until the next meeting?
I can't do that because we will not be able
to have the time with the two weeks left after this week
for the Senate to be in session before the August recess
to get the new nominee confirmed as Attorney General.
So what are we going to do?
Can we have the consent of, I don't know.
It's been 35 minutes into this session.
It's the same way we,
maybe I better talk to our parliamentarian.
I think what we'll do is I'll make this follow up
on your suggestion this way
because it is kind of rude of people
not to be able to be here.
Let's wait 10 minutes and if we don't,
we'll see what we can do off the floor.
So 10 minutes from right now.
We'll stand at ease until 10 minutes so people get here.
It seems it's impossible
because of other committees meeting
and some of them having longer meetings
than what they planned to
that we're going to have to recess
and meet off the floor at the vote
of the United States Senate.
And you know how this place is on Thursday
when everything shuts down around two o'clock.
That means the first vote that we have,
which I guess is about 1145 or noon or something like that.
We're going to recess until that point
off the floor of the Senate.