Multiple Oklahoma homeowners say they faced repeated adjuster changes, lengthy delays and disputed claim payments after filing homeowners insurance claims with State Farm, complaints that mirror allegations now at the center of a lawsuit filed by Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond.
FOX23 Investigative Reporter Janna Clark spoke with several policyholders who said they were assigned multiple adjusters throughout the claims process, forcing them to repeatedly explain their cases and delaying repairs.
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
A Fox 23 investigation reveals numerous complaints against State Farm and Allstate in Oklahoma. Policyholders report systemic claim denials, underpayment for damages, and the frequent switching of adjusters to delay payouts. These allegations have led Oklahoma Attorney General Gentner Drummond to file lawsuits against both companies for unfair practices.
Now to a follow-up Fox 23 investigation. We told you the Oklahoma Attorney General has
recently filed lawsuits against two major home insurance companies, State Farm and Allstate.
Tulsa's investigative reporter Jana Clark has gotten a lot of complaints from our viewers
about what happened after they filed an insurance claim mostly related to State Farm.
Jana noticed a common theme when it came to people's complaints.
Literally top to bottom, this wall is, water is rolling down it, the paint has bubbled.
Cassandra Spears came to check her mom's house and found water had leaked from the dishwasher.
So the dishwasher was here.
Cassandra told me water flooded the floors,
rolled down the walls and mold covered everything.
That's horrible.
Yeah, everything was ruined and wet.
Cassandra's mom had passed away and Cassandra took over paying for
the homeowner's insurance with State Farm.
My mom had the same State Farm insurance policy since August of 1996
and been paying all of her premiums and then this happens and it's awful.
Cassandra says State Farm would pay to fix some of the damage,
but the offer wouldn't cover all of the costs.
That's not even close to realistic.
They didn't include damage that their own engineer reported, like this isn't making
any sense and then again they left off portions of the home that were clearly
damaged and impacted by the water and it just continues to drag out.
She says one reason it dragged on and on is because State Farm gave her new adjusters.
The newest adjuster because they switched adjusters again and then
this adjuster had no idea what was going on.
It was just I'm gonna do it all over again.
I had also been told you know that they will switch adjusters right when you're
about to get somewhere so that way you have to start all over.
This isn't the only time I've heard this.
You can see where the fire started over there.
I talked to Kenny Cox about his home that caught fire.
He also told me State Farm kept giving him different adjusters.
They've changed adjusters six times on that.
About every month we get a new adjuster with something different.
It's just been one thing after another.
You know you spend seven hours with first team and everybody wants something different.
He said it just makes the whole process take longer.
It's just so discouraging.
For Kenny and his wife, they've been out of their home more than a year.
You have a total loss.
You're at their mercy.
Fed up, he put up this sign in his front yard.
All we have gotten is lies, denies and delays.
That's what I put.
True?
True. Absolutely true.
What made you put that up?
You shouldn't have to go through seven months of them trying to put it to you every time they can.
The initial claim was on August 17, 2023.
Craig Ellis says State Farm paid to replace most of the cost of his hail damaged roof,
but they wouldn't pay for the sheathing.
The city inspector put it in writing to Craig that he had to get the new sheathing material
for his roof to be up to code and his warranty on his shingles to be intact.
Craig says he ended up paying almost $6,000 for the sheathing out of his own pocket,
and he argued for weeks with State Farm about it.
A lot of time and a lot of effort.
I couldn't tell you the number of phone calls and number of emails and it was very frustrating.
This shows you how many different adjusters that I had to deal with.
He also pointed to the problem of dealing with multiple adjusters.
I had seven different adjusters that I had to work through. They would change.
I would deal with one, I would answer all his or her questions,
and then he would refer me to another adjuster.
And then I would answer the same questions and then some more.
And so we went through this whole litany of adjusters,
and it was just very frustrating.
And it seemed like it was just trying to push the can down the road,
so I'd get tired of asking the questions.
Craig says he tried to get help from his agent, but that didn't work.
Our agent, you know, she's caught in the middle.
She couldn't do anything about it because it's the people that are making,
it's the adjusters that are really making that final call.
This is not right. I know it's not right.
The agent would not help, and I called them multiple times.
You wanted them to advocate for you.
Yes, like that's what agents are supposed to do for their customers.
They're your agent. You're supposed to be able to count on them.
And this one did not care whatsoever.
People need to know your agent has nothing to do after a disaster.
They send out teams, and these teams don't know you. They don't care.
Oklahoma Attorney General Gettner Drummond told me in December
he got so many complaints about State Farm
that his office started investigating the insurance giant.
What do you think about the Attorney General looking into State Farm?
Oh, I'm for it.
I think it's fantastic.
I think that insurance companies need to be held to account.
They need to be held accountable.
Do what you say. People pay their premiums, you know.
Be there whenever they need you.
Then in June, Drummond filed a lawsuit against State Farm.
What do you think is really going on with State Farm?
I think State Farm has a concerted policy of representing full coverage
and having a policy of claim denial inside its own shop
so that Oklahomans pay for full coverage,
we get no coverage, and State Farm reaps a huge benefit.
I think that really is what they have their adjusters do.
I think that they tell them to look for a way to deny
or to just go ahead and issue the denial and then let them appeal it.
Why would they do that?
They're trying to find a way to deny your claim.
They're trying to drag it out.
They're trying to give you misinformation,
thinking that you're not going to argue it or look into it or anything like that,
and I know there's people that do that.
I asked State Farm about their customers' allegations
that State Farm changes adjusters multiple times
to delay paying out claims.
Here's what State Farm said in a statement.
When our customers experience large catastrophes,
State Farm mobilizes a team that can respond to their needs effectively.
Sometimes this may mean that multiple team members assist with a customer's claim.
This approach is designed to improve responsiveness during catastrophe events
while helping large numbers of customers.
Our claims teams are designed to be flexible
in the face of a single claim or thousands of claims.
How does it make you feel, the whole thing?
It really sucks because, you know, for me,
I was already dealing with so much at the time from the loss of my mother
that they were just, it was wrong.
It's just, it's horrible the way they do people.
What do you think is actually going on?
I think they're greedy and just,
I don't think they've got no conscience as a company,
and I know their adjusters don't because I've talked to them.
They're told what to say and, by golly, that's what they do.
They're going to do everything in their power to not pay your claim
if, in fact, they can do it,
which is why they gave me adjuster after adjuster after adjuster after adjuster,
trying to wear me down so that I just said,
you know what, forget it, I'm not going to pursue this.
You pay your insurance. Yes.
You have a problem. Yeah.
You think it's going to get covered, and it should be, but it's not.
It makes it hard for you to believe that if you're paying for something
in a service and there's an agreement that someone's going to uphold it
and there's anything you can do about it because you really can't.
Covering news that matters, Jana Clark, Fox 23 News.
Oklahoma Attorney General Gettner Drummond filed a lawsuit against State Farm in June,
then not long after that, earlier this month,
he filed a similar lawsuit against another insurance company, Allstate.
He says the insurer has underpaid or denied
valid wind and hail damage claims to inflate corporate profits.
Do you have a tip or issue that you think Jana Clark should investigate?
Let us know.
Email fox23investigates at fox23.com or call 918-388-5354 or search Fox 23 Jana Clark on Facebook.