In this lecture from Sam Altman's How to Start a Startup series, Facebook's VP of Growth, Alex Schultz, provides an expert overview of growth strategies for startups. Schultz emphasizes that user retention is the absolute foundation of sustainable growth, explaining how to analyze retention curves and identify product-market fit. He outlines the importance of defining a singular North Star metric for a company and driving users toward their magic moment—the precise instant they realize the core value of a product. Additionally, Schultz dives into tactical growth levers, including internationalization, virality mechanics, search engine optimization (SEO), and deliverability across communication channels like email, SMS, and push notifications.#StartupGrowth#GrowthMarketing#GrowthHacking#AlexSchultz#StartupClass#SamAltman#UserRetention#ProductMarketFit#MarketingStrategy#BusinessGrowth
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI Generated
This presentation outlines a strategic framework for business growth, arguing that retention is the most critical metric for success. The speaker emphasizes that scaling a product without product-market fit is futile. By focusing on \"North Star\" metrics, identifying the \"magic moment\" of user value, and utilizing data-driven virality and SEO, companies can achieve sustainable exponential growth.
Thank you for having me.
Oversold.
Thank you.
Cool.
So you guys, this is awesome.
I've been watching the lectures in this course.
Isn't it absolutely amazing, the content?
And now you're stuck with me today.
We'll see how that goes.
So unlike Paul when he was talking in the Q&A
and you guys asked him what he'd do if he was at college today
and he said physics, I actually indulged myself.
I went and did physics, did physics at Cambridge.
And I think physics is an amazing class
to give you transferable skills that
are really useful in other areas,
but I guess that's not why you're listening to me today.
Physics isn't the class.
So I paid for college doing online marketing,
direct sales marketing.
I started with SEO in the 1990s.
I created a paper airplane site.
I had a monopoly in the small niche market of paper airplanes
globally, which when you want to start a startup,
also see how big the market could be in the long term.
It wasn't great.
But what that taught me was how to do SEO.
And back in those days, it was AltaVista.
And the way to do SEO was to have
white text on a white background,
five pages below the fold.
And you would rank top of AltaVista
if you just said paper airplanes 20 or 30 times in that text.
And that was how you won at SEO in the 1990s.
It was a really easy, easy skill to learn.
When I went to college, being a physicist,
I thought paper airplanes would make me cool.
And I was actually the most nerdy person
in the physics class.
So I created a cocktail site, which
was how I learned to program.
And that grew to be the largest cocktail site in the UK.
And that really got me into SEO properly when Google launched.
So with Google, you had to worry about page rank.
And you had to worry about getting links back
to your site, which basically, at that stage,
meant one link from the Yahoo directory
got you to the top listing in Google
if you had white text on a white background below the fold
as well.
When Google launched AdWords, that's
when I really started to learn how to do online marketing.
And that was buying paid clicks from Google
and reselling them to eBay for a small margin of like 20%
using their affiliate program.
And that was what really kicked me into overdrive
into doing what everyone nowadays
talks about as growth, or growth hacking, or growth marketing.
And in my mind, it's just internet marketing,
using whatever channel you can to get
whatever output you want.
And that's how I paid for college
and how I ended up going from being a physicist to a marketer
and transitioning to the dark side of the force.
So what do you think matters most for growth?
You've had loads of lectures, and people
have said it over and over.
So what do you guys think matters most for growth?
Someone give me an answer.
Great product.
I agree, great product.
What does great product lead to?
Customers.
And what do you need those customers to do?
Spread the word.
Someone said stay on your site.
Someone said that.
That's it, retention.
Retention is the single most important thing for growth.
Now, we have an awesome growth team at Facebook.
And I'm super proud to work on it.
But the truth of the matter is, we have a fantastic product.
But getting to work on growth at Facebook
is a massive privilege, because we're
promoting something that everyone in the world
really wants to use, which is absolutely incredible.
If we can get people on and get them ramped up,
they stick on Facebook.
So many times, I've advised multiple startups.
My favorite was working with Airbnb.
But I've worked with Coursera.
I've worked with other ones that haven't
done as well as those guys.
But the one thing that is true over and over and over again
is, if you look at this curve, percent monthly active
versus number of days from acquisition,
if you end up with a retention curve that asymptotes
to a line parallel to the x-axis,
you have a viable business.
And you have product market fit for some subset of market.
But most of the companies that you see fly up,
we talk about growth hacking and virality
and all of this other stuff.
I'm going to try so hard not to swear, but it'll happen.
Their retention curve slopes down towards the x-axis
and, in the end, intercepts the x-axis.
Now, when I show this chart to most people,
they say, that's all well and good.
You had a million people a day in terms of growth
when you started the growth team at Facebook.
Or you were at 50 million users.
You had a lot of people joining the site.
So you had a ton of data to do this.
We used the same methodology for our B2B growth,
getting people to sign up as self-service advertisers.
We used this analysis to understand
how much growth we were going to have in that market as well.
And in that place, when I joined Facebook,
the product was three days old.
And within 90 days of the product launching,
we were able to use this technique
to be able to figure out what the one-year value
of an advertiser was.
And we predicted it for the first year
to 97% of what the number turned out to be.
So I think it's very important to look at your attention curve.
And this is how we did it.
If you see here, this red line is
number of users who have been on your product
for a certain number of days.
So a bunch of people, that should say zero,
but a bunch of people will have been on the product.
All of your users will have been on it at least one day.
But if your product's been around a year or whatever,
you will have zero users who've been on it 366 days.
Make sense?
The curve's sensible?
Cool.
So what you then do is look for all
of your users who have been on your product one day.
What percentage of them are monthly active?
100% for the first 30 days, obviously,
because monthly active, they all signed up on one day.
But then you look at 31.
Every single user on their 31st day after registration,
what percentage of them were monthly active?
32nd day, 33rd day, 34th day.
And that allows you with only something like 10,000 customers
or whatever to get a real idea of what this curve
is gonna look like for your product.
And you're gonna be able to tell, does it asymptote?
And it'll get noisy out towards the right-hand side,
like I'm not using real data.
It'll get noisy out towards the right-hand side,
but you'll be able to get a handle on,
does this curve flatten out or does it not?
If it doesn't flatten out, don't go and do growth tactics.
Don't go and do virality.
Don't hire a growth hacker.
Focus on getting product market fit.
Because in the end, as Sam said
at the beginning of this course,
idea, product, team, execution.
If you don't have a great product,
there's no point executing well on growing it
because it won't grow.
Number one problem I've seen inside Facebook
for new products, number one problem I've seen
for a startup I've advised has been,
they don't actually have product market fit
when they think they do.
So the next obvious question that people ask
over and over and over again is,
okay, what does good retention look like?
Sure, I can have 5% retention,
but I'm guessing that Facebook had better than that,
so that's not gonna be a successful business.
And I get really pissed off
when people ask me that question.
Because I think you can figure it out.
And I love this story, and this is like
my one gratuitous story that I love
that I'm throwing in here,
so the rest of it may not be as gratuitous.
But this is a picture that was published
in Life Magazine in 1950
of one of the Trinity nuclear bomb tests.
And there's a guy, Geoffrey Taylor.
Who's heard of Geoffrey Taylor?
Awesome, yes, someone's heard of him.
Geoffrey Taylor was a British physicist
who ended up actually winning the Nobel Prize.
And he was able to figure out
from looking at this picture
what the power of the atomic bomb was,
the US atomic bomb,
and Russians were publishing similar pictures
just using dimensional reasoning.
And dimensional reasoning is, I think,
one of the best skills that I learned
during my time studying physics back in the UK.
And what dimensional reasoning is
is you look at the dimensions
that are involved in a problem.
So you wanna figure out energy,
newtons, meters,
newtons are kilograms, meters, seconds to minus two,
so you've got kilograms, meters squared,
seconds to minus two.
And then you try and figure out
how you can get each of those numbers
from what data you have.
So the mass is the volume of this sphere.
So that's a meter cubed you throw in there.
So you've got meters to the five
over seconds to the minus two.
And he was able to use that
to just figure out what the power
of this atomic bomb was,
what the ratios of the power were
between the Russian and US atomic bomb,
and essentially reveal one of the top secrets
that existed in the world at that time.
That's a hard problem.
Figuring out what Facebook's retention rate is
is not a hard problem.
How many people are there on the internet?
Give or take, someone throw something out.
2.4 billion, 2.3 billion, something like that, right?
Okay, Facebook's banned in China.
So what now?
About two billion?
Two billion.
So two billion people on the internet.
Facebook in our last earnings call
said something around 1.3 billion
in terms of number of active users.
You can divide those numbers by each other.
And yeah, that won't give you the right answer.
Of course it's not gonna give you the right answer,
but it's gonna give you close enough
to a ballpark figure of what the retention rate
looks like for Facebook if we've signed everyone
on the internet up, and then you will know
it's higher than that.
Similarly, if you look at WhatsApp,
they've announced 600 million active users.
How many people have smartphones?
You can figure out that number.
That number's out and knocking around.
It can give you an idea of how many users there are.
Amazon has had a pop at signing up
almost everyone in the United States.
You know how many people are online in the US,
and you've got a good idea of how many customers
Amazon are from the numbers they throw out.
Different verticals need different terminal retention rates
for them to have successful businesses.
If you're in e-commerce and you're retaining
on a monthly active basis, like 20, 30% of your users,
you're probably gonna do pretty well.
If you're in social media and your first batch
of people signing up to your product
are not like 80% retained, you're not gonna have
a massive social media site.
And so it really depends on the vertical you're in,
what the retention rates are.
What you need to do is have the tools
to think about who out there is comparable
and how you can look at it and say,
am I anywhere close to what real success
looks like in this vertical?
So retention is the single most important thing for growth,
and retention comes from having a great idea
and a great product to back up that idea
and great product market fit.
The way we look at whether a product
has great retention or not is whether or not
the users who install it actually stay on it long term
when you normalize on a cohort basis.
And I think that's a really good methodology
for looking at your product and saying,
okay, the first hundred, the first thousand,
the first 10,000 people I get on this,
will they be retained in the long run?
So now how do you attack operating for growth?
Let's say you have awesome product market fit.
You have built an e-commerce site
and you have 60% of people coming back every single month
and making a purchase from you,
which would be absolutely fantastic.
How do you then take that and say,
now it's time to scale?
Now it's time to execute,
was the last thing in your thought, right?
And that's where I think growth teams come in.
Like my contrarian viewpoint or whatever is,
if you're a startup, you shouldn't have a *******,
you shouldn't have a growth team.
Damn it!
So close!
Halfway through and I failed.
You shouldn't have a growth team.
Startups should not have growth teams.
The whole company should be the growth team.
The CEO should be the head of growth.
You need someone to set a north star for you.
Gratuitous shot of the NASA page.
You need someone to set a north star for you
about where the company wants to go.
And that person needs to be the person leading the company,
in my opinion, from what I've seen.
And Mark is a fantastic example of that.
Back when Facebook started,
lots of people were putting out
their registered user numbers, right?
You'd see registered user numbers for MySpace,
you'd see registered user numbers for Kontakta,
you'd see registered user numbers.
Mark put out monthly active users
as the number both internally he held everyone to
and said, we need everyone on Facebook,
but that means everyone active on Facebook,
not everyone signed up to Facebook.
So monthly active people was the number internally
and it was also the number he published externally.
It was the number he made the whole world hold Facebook to
as the number that we cared about.
If you look at what Jan has done with WhatsApp,
I think it's another great example.
He always published send numbers.
If you're a messaging application,
sends is probably the single most important number.
If people use you once a day, maybe that's great,
but they send one message,
you're not really their primary messaging mechanism.
So Jan published the sends number, right?
Inside Airbnb, they talk about nights booked
and they also publish that
in all of the infographics that you see inside TechCrunch.
They always benchmark themselves
against how many nights booked they have
compared to the largest hotel chains in the world.
They have each of these companies a different North Star.
The North Star doesn't have to be monthly active users
for every different vertical.
For eBay when I was there, it was gross merchandise volume.
How much stuff did people actually buy through eBay?
Everyone externally tends to judge eBay based on revenue.
Actually, Benedict Evans has done this amazing breakdown
of Amazon's business, which is really interesting
to look at their marketplace business
versus their direct business.
eBay is all marketplace business, right?
So eBay's being judged by its revenue
when it actually has 10 times or whatever more
gross merchandise volume going through the site.
And that was the number that eBay looked at
when I was inside there and optimized for.
So every different company when it thinks about growth
needs a different North Star.
But when you are operating for growth,
it is critical that you have that North Star
and you define it as a leader.
The reason this matters is the second you have
more than one person working on anything,
you cannot control what everyone else is doing, right?
I promise you, having now hit 100 people I'm managing,
I have no control.
It's all influence.
Yes, I can say to one person, do this one thing,
but then the other 99 are gonna do
whatever the hell they want.
And the thing is, it's not clear to everybody
what the most important thing is for a company.
It would be very easy inside eBay for people to say,
you know what, we should focus on revenue.
Or you know what, we should focus on the number
of people buying from us.
Or you know what, we should focus on
how many people list items on eBay.
And Pierre and Meg and John, those guys as various leaders
always said no, it's the amount of gross merchandise volume
that goes through our site, it's the percentage
of e-commerce that goes through our site.
That is what really matters for this company.
Which means when people are having a conversation
you're not in the room, or when they're sitting
in front of their computer screen and thinking about
how they build this particular product
or this particular feature, in their head
it's gonna be clear to them that it's not about revenue,
it's about gross merchandise volume,
or it's not about getting more registrations.
Registrations don't matter unless they become
long-term active users.
A great example of this was when I was at eBay in 2004,
we changed the way we paid our affiliates for new users.
And affiliate programs are a bit out of fashion these days,
but the idea of an affiliate program is essentially
you pay anyone on the internet a referral
for sending traffic to your site,
but it's mostly about getting access to big marketers
who do it on their own, like separately,
and there's some really good stories from this.
We were paying for confirmed registered users.
So all of our affiliates were aligned
about getting confirmed registered users to the eBay site.
We changed our payment model to pay
for activated confirmed registered users.
So you had to confirm your account and then bid on an item
or buy an item or list an item
to become someone that we paid for.
Overnight when we made that change,
we lost something like 20% of confirmed registered users
that were being driven by the affiliates.
But the ACRUs only dropped by about 5%.
The ratio of CRU to ACRU went up,
and then the growth of ACRUs massively accelerated.
The cause of this was if you want to drive CRUs,
if someone searches for a trampoline,
you land them on the registration page
because they think they have to register
and confirm before they get that trampoline.
If you want to drive ACRUs,
you land them on the search results page
within eBay for trampolines
so they can see the thing they want to buy,
get excited about it, and register when they want to buy it.
And if you drive just CRUs,
people don't have an amazing magic moment on eBay
when they visit the site.
And that's the next most important thing to think about
is how do you drive towards the magic moment
that gets people hooked on your service?
So in the lecture notes for this course,
I've stuck in a bunch of links
to people I think are brilliant at all of this stuff.
That retention curve I showed earlier,
there's a link to this guy Danny Ferrante
who's incredible talking about retention curves.
The magic moment, there are two videos linked.
One is Chamath talking about growth,
who was the guy who set up the growth team at Facebook.
And one is my friend Naomi and I talking at F8 four years ago
about how we were thinking about growth back then.
And in both of those videos,
we talk about the magic moment.
So what do you guys think the magic moment is
for when you're signing up to Facebook?
You hit that big green button.
What is the moment when users are like, aha.
Mark even talked about it
at the startup school a few years back.
See your friends.
Simple as that.
And usually it is very simple.
I talk to so many companies
and they try and get incredibly complicated
about what they're doing,
but it is as simple as just when you see
that first picture of one of your friends on Facebook,
you go, oh my God, this is what the site is about.
And Zuck's talked at Y Combinator
about getting people to 10 friends in 14 days.
That is why we focus on that metric.
The number one most important thing
in a social media site is connecting to your friends
because without that,
you have a completely empty newsfeed
and clearly you're not gonna come back.
You'll never get any notifications.
You'll never have any friends telling you
about things they're missing on the site.
So for Facebook,
the magic moment is that moment
when you see your friend's face
and everything we do on growth.
And if you look at the LinkedIn registration flow
or you look at the Twitter registration flow
or you look at what WhatsApp does when you sign up,
the number one thing all these services look to do
is to show you the people you want to follow,
connect to, send messages to as quickly as possible
because in this vertical, that's what matters.
When you think about Airbnb or you think about eBay,
it's finding on eBay that unique item,
that Pez dispenser or broken laser pointer
that you really, really cared about
and wanted to get hold of.
Like when you see that collectible thing
that you were missing,
that is the real magic moment on eBay.
When you look on Airbnb and you find that first,
you find that first listing
that's like a cool house that you can stay in
and when you go through the door,
that's a magic moment.
And similarly on the other side,
when you're listing your house,
the first time you get paid is an amazing moment.
When you're listing an item on eBay,
the first time you get paid is a magic moment.
You should ask Brian what he thinks
because they've done these amazing storyboards
which I think has been shared
of like the journey through a user's life on Airbnb
and how exciting it is
and he's talking in like three lectures time.
The guy's awesome at talking about the magic moment
and getting his users to feel love and joy
and all this stuff.
So think about what the magic moment is for your product
and get people connected to it as fast as possible
because then you can move up
where that blue line has asymptoted.
Then you can go from 50% retention
to 60% retention to 70% retention easily
if you can connect people with the thing
that makes them stick on your site.
The second thing to think about
is everyone in the valley gets wrong
that we optimize when we think about growth for ourselves.
So my favorite example is notifications.
Again, talk to lots of companies,
advise lots of companies.
Every single company when they talk about notifications
goes, oh, I'm getting too many notifications.
I think that's what we need
to optimize for on notifications.
Okay, are your power users leaving your site
because they're getting too many notifications?
No.
Then why would you optimize that?
They're probably grownups and they can use filters.
What you need to focus on is the marginal user,
the one person who doesn't get a notification
in a given day or month or year.
Our experience of our products,
and by the way, like building an awesome product
is all about thinking about the power user, right?
Building an incredible product
is definitely optimizing for the people
who use your product the most.
But driving growth,
people who are already using your product all the time
are not the ones you have to worry about.
So in this Danny Ferrante video,
there's also, that's linked from the lecture page,
there's also talk about our growth accounting framework
that we use to think about for growth.
And we looked at new users, resurrected users,
people who weren't on Facebook for 30 days and came back,
and churned users.
And the resurrected and churned numbers
for pretty much every product I've ever seen
dominate the new user count
once you reach a sensible point of growth,
a couple of years in, whatever.
And all those users who are churning and resurrecting
had low friend counts and didn't find their friends
and so weren't connected to the great stuff
that was going on on Facebook.
And so the number one thing we needed to focus on
was getting them to those 10 friends,
getting them to whatever number of friends they needed.
So think about the user on the margin.
Don't think about yourself
when you're thinking about growth.
So operating for growth,
what you really need to think about
is what is the North Star of your company?
What is the one metric where if everyone in the company
is thinking about it and driving their product
towards that metric and their actions
towards moving that metric up,
you know in the long run your company will be successful.
And by the way, they're probably all correlated
to each other, so it's fine to pick almost any metric.
Whichever one is the deepest,
that you feel the best about,
that aligns with your mission and your values,
probably go for that one.
But realistically, daily active users,
fairly correlated to monthly active users.
We could have gone with either one.
Amount of content shared,
also very correlated to how many users there are
because guess what?
You add a user, they share content.
So lots of things end up being correlated.
Pick the one that fits with you
and that you know you're gonna be able to stick with
for a long time, but have a North Star.
Have a North Star and know the magic moment
that when a user experiences that,
they will deliver on that metric for you on the North Star.
And then think about the marginal user,
don't think about yourself.
Those are, I think, the really important points
when you're operating for growth.
Everything has to come from the top.
So the last area here is tactics.
And my hope was that I could hit a few of these
and then I've got a list of tactics I wanna go through
that I'm better talking with a whiteboard and whatever on.
But you can ask me questions as I'm going through on those
about how they work and what goes better.
But the important tactics that you need to think about are,
this is a great guy, by the way, Tom Fishburne.
He lives in the Bay Area
and he does these really cynical cartoons that I love.
So let's say you've found your niche market
that you're gonna have a monopoly on
inside the mousetrap market.
It's a silenced mousetrap for sitting under beds
so that if the mice come to your bed overnight,
they can be killed without waking you up.
So that's your niche market.
And your mousetrap is better than anybody else
for that market.
What typically happens in Silicon Valley
is everyone thinks marketers are useless.
Like, I thought marketers were useless
when I was a physics student,
so I'm sure as engineering students,
you must think we're awful, awful people
who aren't useful to have around.
Like, build it and they will come.
That is something that is very much the mantra in the Valley
and I don't believe it's true.
I believe you actually have to work.
There's a good article, again, in the lecture page
from interviewing Ben Silverman
where he talks about how the growth of Pinterest
was driven by marketing.
That's a really good article to read into.
I'm biased, of course.
So the first tactic I want to talk about
is internationalization.
Facebook internationalized too late.
Cheryl said it broadly in public
and I definitely agree with that.
One of the biggest barriers to our long-term growth
and one of the biggest things we had to deal with
was all the countries where there were clones.
Famously, Studiefeldt said had fakebook.css
in their HTML.
And there were a ton of sites like that out there,
whether it was Studiefeldt said as a clear clone,
Contactia, Mixi, Cyworld, Orkut.
There were all these different social networks
around the world that grew up
while Facebook was focused on the US.
And so internationalizing was an important barrier
we needed to knock down.
And knocking down barriers is often very important
to think about for growth.
Facebook started off as college only.
So every college that it was launched in
was knocking down a barrier.
When Facebook expanded beyond colleges to high schools,
I wasn't at the company,
but that was a company shaking moment
where people questioned whether or not
Facebook could actually survive,
the culture of the site could survive.
Then expanding from high schools to everyone,
that was like just before I joined
and that was a shocking moment
and that spurred the growth onto 50 million
and then we hit a brick wall.
And when we hit that brick wall,
that was the point when a lot of existential questions
were being asked inside Facebook
about whether any social network
could ever get to more than 100 million users,
which sounds stupid now,
but at the time, no one had ever achieved it.
Everyone had kind of tapped out
between 50 and 100 million users
and we were worried that it wasn't possible.
And that was the point at which the growth team got set up.
Chamath brought a bunch of us together.
It was, he said very publicly
that he wanted to fire me on multiple occasions
and he probably should have done,
but without Chamath,
I think none of us would have stayed at the company.
We were a really weird bunch of people,
but it worked out.
And the two things we did, I think,
that really, really drove growth initially
was number one, we focused on that 10 friends in 14 days
and getting users to the magic moment.
And that was something Zuck drove
because we were all stuck in analysis paralysis
saying, is it causation?
Is it correlation?
Zuck was like, you really think if no one gets a friend
that they'll be active on Facebook?
Are you crazy?
The second thing was internationalization.
It was knocking down another barrier.
And when we launched it,
I think there were two things that we did really well.
Number one was, even though we were late
and we were stressed about being late,
we took the time to build it in a scalable way.
We moved slow to move fast.
And you can actually hear the full story from Naomi
in one of the videos linked from the lecture page.
But what we did was we wrapped all the strings in the site
in FBT, which is our translation script,
and then, or translation extraction script,
and then we created the community translation platform
so that we didn't just have professional translators
translating the site,
we could have all of our users translating the site.
And we got French translated in 12 hours.
But we managed to get, to this day,
we're now at 104 languages translated by Facebook,
for Facebook, 70 of those are translated by the community.
And we took the time to build something
that would enable us to scale.
The other thing is we prioritized the right languages.
So back then, the right languages,
the big four languages were French, Italian,
German, and Spanish, Figs, and Chinese,
but we were blocked in China.
So we focused on French, Italian, German, and Spanish.
Now look at that list,
that's today's distribution of languages.
Italian isn't on the list anymore.
French and German are about to fall off.
In the last year, we quadrupled the number of people
on Facebook in Hindi, quadrupled.
And so building for where the world is today
is an easy mistake to make,
and it's what a lot of the other social networks did.
We built a scalable translation infrastructure
that actually enabled us to attack all of the languages
so we could be ready for where the future is going to be.
And you'll probably be able to see some stuff
from our internet.org summit in India
about where we want to go with language translations
later today,
because I think they're talking about that stuff there.
So these are the tactics I want to go through now,
and I'll stick with the whiteboard for that stuff.
But I'd really encourage you guys, as I go through these,
if you've got any questions about them, let me know.
I think this should be a more free-form time anyway,
but I think some of these tactics are quite interesting.
So virality.
Yes.
I think there are two ways to look at virality.
There's a great book.
Whoops.
The book on the right here by Adam Penenberg, Viral Loop,
goes through a bunch of case studies of companies
that have grown through viral marketing.
And I strongly encourage you,
if you're interested in viral marketing, to get that book.
I think Ogilvy in advertising's great as well,
because chapter seven,
he's like, if you can't think of anything else,
stick a car to a billboard with superglue,
and people will buy your superglue.
And he's got some really good creative tips in there.
The guy's been dead 20 years, and I think he's still,
I buy, everyone on my team gets both of these books
when they start on my team.
So virality.
So Sean Park has this model that he taught,
or he told us about when I joined Facebook,
which is to think about virality for a product
in terms of three things.
First is payload.
So how many people can you hit with any given viral blast?
Second, he had cooler words for these,
I'm not quite as cool.
Second is conversion rate, and third is frequency.
Payload, frequency, and conversion rate, whatever.
That order.
So how many people can you hit at once is payload.
How many times can you hit them per blast is frequency,
and what are they gonna convert at?
And that gives you a fundamental idea
of how viral a product is.
So Hotmail is the canonical example
of brilliant viral marketing, right?
Back when Hotmail launched, there were a bunch
of mail companies that had been funded,
and they were throwing huge amounts of money
at traditional advertising.
How many people know the Hotmail story about virality?
Awesome, great, new audience, sorry.
There's two or three people who'll be bored.
But Hotmail, back at that time,
people couldn't get free email clients.
They had to be tied to their ISP.
And Hotmail and a few other companies launched,
and their clients were available wherever you went.
You could log in via library internet or whatever,
school internet, and be able to get access to that,
which was a really big value proposition
for everyone who wanted to access it.
Most of the companies went out there
and did big TV campaigns and billboard campaigns
and newspaper campaigns and things like that,
bought a lot of advertising off Yahoo, all of those things.
But the Hotmail team didn't have as much funding,
and so they had to scrabble around
to figure out how to do it.
So what they did was add that little link
at the bottom of every email that said,
sent from Hotmail, get your free email here.
Now the interesting thing is,
that meant the payload was low, right?
You email one person at a time,
not necessarily gonna have a huge payload.
Maybe you send around some of those viral spam emails,
but then I'm not sure I'll click on your link.
The frequency is high, though,
because you're emailing the same people
over and over and over,
which means you're gonna hit them once, twice,
three times a day with that same link
and really move up the impressions.
And the conversion rate was also very high
because people didn't like being tied to their ISP email.
And so Hotmail ended up being extremely viral
because it had high frequency and high conversion rates.
Another example is PayPal.
PayPal, PayPal is interesting
because PayPal has two sides to it.
PayPal has the buyer and the seller side.
The other thing that's interesting about PayPal
is its mechanism for viral growth was eBay.
And so you can use all kinds of things for virality
that may not look necessarily obviously viral.
So PayPal, if you sent money,
if you said to a seller, I am going to send you money,
like, I can't think of a higher conversion rate.
Frequency was low, payload was low.
But PayPal did this thing
where they gave away money
when you got your friends to sign up for PayPal.
And so that's how they went viral on the consumer side.
They didn't have to do that for sellers
because if I said, I am gonna send you money via this,
you will take that.
And even on the consumer side, they went viral
because someone said, sign up for this thing
and you'll get 10 bucks.
Why wouldn't you?
So they were able to go viral,
but in both cases, it was because their conversion rate
was incredibly high on the buyer and the seller side,
not because their payload and frequency was high.
Make sense?
So this is a really good way to look at virality
if you wanna say, is this product viral?
Facebook was not viral via email sharing
or anything like that.
Facebook was purely viral by a word of mouth
because the interesting thing about PayPal and Hotmail
is to use them, the first person had to send an email
to someone who wasn't on the service.
With Facebook, there's no native way
to contact people who aren't on the service.
And everyone thinks of Facebook
as like viral marketing success,
and that's actually not how it grew.
It was word of mouth virality
because it was an awesome product
you wanted to tell your friends about.
How's everyone doing?
Is this interesting?
Great question, yes.
When you're talking about this low payload
in both those examples,
in the later rounds as this sort of campaign
or whatever you wanna call it gets going,
are you gonna have a much higher payload
as more and more people are sending Hotmail
to more and more folks,
and that way your payload grows and grows and grows?
So the question is, in the first round,
it makes sense that it has a low payload,
but in later rounds, aren't you gonna have higher payloads
as people send more and more and more emails?
I guess in my head, well, first and foremost,
I think you actually only send emails
to a small number of people.
So compared to the massive viral engines that exist today
where you import someone's entire contact book
and send them all an email,
or where you post to everyone's friends on Facebook,
the actual payloads are still very small
even if it's everyone that you email
on a frequent basis you hit.
And I'm also thinking really per email sent out,
how many people are on it?
But it's a fair point.
Like, yeah, as more people get on Hotmail,
they'll send more emails,
as more people use email,
the product actually grows more and more successfully.
So that's a fair point.
Go for it.
Doesn't point of conversion also matter?
So like when Hotmail, you just click and you sign up,
but if you see a billboard ad,
it's more than more users just signing up.
Completely agree, that's why, oh, sorry.
Doesn't point of conversion matter as well?
So on Hotmail, you click to sign up,
but on a billboard, you have to remember the URL,
go to the website, type it in,
find the registration button, click register and sign up.
Yes, yes, anything you can do
to move friction out of the flow
and going from an offline ad to an online ad
removes huge amounts of friction from the flow.
Obviously, totally agree with that.
One more at the back.
Aren't frequency and conversion related?
Absolutely.
If you hit someone with the same promotion,
I repeat to that,
aren't frequency and conversion related?
If you hit someone with the same email
over and over and over again,
or the same banner ad,
this is one of the things that's fundamental
about online marketing.
The same rules apply to every channel.
If you hit someone with the same Facebook ad
over and over and over,
the more times you hit them with the same ad,
the less they'll click.
That's why we have creative exhaustion,
you have to rotate creatives on Facebook.
Same with banner ads.
Same with newsfeed stories.
The 50th time you see that IQ story in your newsfeed,
you are not gonna click on it.
If you haven't clicked on the 49 before,
you're not gonna click on the 50th.
The same is absolutely true with these emails.
So if you send the same email
over and over and over to people for an invite,
then, or if you send the same little link at the bottom
over and over and over to people for Hotmail,
or, I mean, the PayPal one's different
because people just signed up.
But yes, you will get lower conversion rate,
and the more you hit someone with the same message,
the less they convert,
is fundamental across every online marketing channel.
Every online marketing channel.
Cool.
Second way to look at virality,
which I think is awesome,
is by this guy, Ed.
And Ed runs the growth team at Uber now.
He was at the growth team at Facebook,
and he was a Stanford MBA student
and did a class similar to this
where they talked about virality,
and they all went and built viral products,
and there was a bunch of press about that, actually.
And he's brilliant at this stuff.
The interesting thing about Uber
is if you look at their growth team,
they're incredibly focused on drivers
because as a two-sided marketplace, they need drivers.
That's a huge, huge chunk of their focus as a team,
even though they've got, like,
probably the best viral guy in the world at the company.
So with virality, you send out,
you get someone to contact import, let's say.
Then the question is how many of those people
do you get to send imports?
Then the question is to how many people?
Then how many click?
And you can put extra steps in this.
You can put how many open, how many click, whatever.
How many click?
How many sign up?
And then how many of those import?
So essentially, you want people who sign up to your site
to import their contacts.
You want to then get them to send an invite
to all of those contacts.
You want to get it to all of those contacts,
not just one of them.
Then you want to get a percentage of those to click
and a percentage of those to sign up.
If you multiply out the percents at every point in this,
this is essentially where,
well, this isn't a percent, this is a number.
If you multiply those out,
that's essentially the point where you get
to the question of what is the K factor?
So if you have, when someone imports,
if on average they send invites to 100 people,
sorry, doing that wrong.
Let's say 100 people get an invite per person who imports.
And then of those 10% click, that gets you to 10.
And then of those, let's say 50% sign up,
that gets you to five.
And then of those, only 10 to 20%
actually subsequently import.
You're gonna be at a point where you're at 0.5 to one
as your K factor, and you're gonna not be viral.
So a lot of things like Viddy are very good at pumping,
or were very good at pumping out stories
that got the K factor over one.
And it's perfectly doable to get the K factor over one.
But if you have something that doesn't have high retention
on the backend, it doesn't really matter.
So you should look at your invite flow and say,
okay, what is my equivalent of import?
How many people per import are invites sent to?
How many of those receive clicks?
How many of those convert to my site?
How many of those then import?
To get an idea of your K factor.
But the really important thing is still to think
about retention and not to think about virality
and only do this after you have a large number of people
retained on your product per person who signs up.
So a couple more things we were gonna touch on.
SEO, email, SMS, and push notifications.
So on SEO, there are three things you need to think about.
First one is keyword research.
People do this badly all the time.
So I launched this cocktail site that I talked to you about.
I spent a year optimizing it to rank
for the word cocktail making.
Turns out in the UK, no one searches for cocktail making.
About 500 people a month.
I dominated that search term, it was awesome.
400 visitors a month, it was amazing.
Everyone searches for cocktail recipes in the UK.
And in the US, which is the biggest market,
everyone searches for drink recipes.
So I optimized for the wrong word.
So you've gotta do your research first
about what you're gonna go after.
So research consists of what do people search for
that's related to your site, how many people search for it,
how many other people are ranking for it,
and how valuable is it for you.
Supply, demand, and value.
Simple economics, I guess.
So you do your keyword research,
you figure out which keywords you want to rank for.
There are great tools out there to enable you to do that.
Honestly, the best is quite often the Google AdWords
keyword planner tool, really.
Once you've done that,
the next most important thing is links.
So PageRank is how all of SEO essentially is driven
and Google is based on authority.
Now there's a lot of other things in Google's algorithm now
like do people search for your website,
there's a lot of stuff about the distribution
of what the anchor text is that's sent to your site
so that if you abuse it and spam it,
they can pop up with spam.
White on a white background,
five pages below the fold doesn't work anymore.
But the single most important thing
is to get valuable links from high authority websites
for you to rank in Google.
Most important thing.
Then you need to distribute that love inside your site
by internally linking effectively.
And when I joined Facebook,
we'd launched SEO in September 2007,
which was before I joined.
I joined November 2007.
And we'd launched it and we were getting no traffic
from the pages we'd launched, public user profiles.
So when I went in and looked at it,
the only way you could get to any public user profile
was to click on the footer of the page for the about link,
then click on one of the blog articles,
then click on one of the authors,
and then spider out through their friends
to get to all their friends.
Turns out that Google was like,
they buried these pages, they're not very valuable,
I'm not gonna rank them.
We made one change, we added a directory
so that Google could quickly get to every page on the site
and we 100X'd SEO traffic.
Very, very simple change, drove a lot of upside
about distributing the link club internally.
And then the last thing is there's a bunch
of table stake stuff, XML site maps,
making sure you have the right headers.
It's all covered really well online for what you wanna do.
I'm gonna stop now and make sure,
because we had a few questions,
but what other questions are there?
Go for it.
Can we go into email?
Let's go into email, okay, great.
Email.
Email is dead for people under 25, in my opinion.
Young people don't use email.
They use WhatsApp, they use SMS,
they use Snapchat, they use Facebook.
They don't use email.
If you are targeting an older audience,
email is pretty successful.
Email still works for distribution,
but realistically, email is not that great
for teenagers especially, and even people at university.
You know how much you use instant messaging apps
and how little you use email,
and you guys are probably on the high end
of the scale for email, because you're in Silicon Valley.
That being said, on email, the things to think about.
Email, SMS, and push notifications all behave the same way.
They all have questions of deliverability.
So to finish first, first you have to finish.
Your email has to get to someone's inbox.
So if you send a lot of spam and you end up
with dirty IPs, or you send spam from shared servers
where other people are, or you send email notifications
from shared servers where other people
are sending spam from, you are gonna end up
being put in the spam folder consistently,
and your email will fail completely.
You may end up being blocked and have your email bounce.
There's a lot of stuff around email where you have to look.
When you receive feedback from the servers
you are sending email to, 500 series errors
versus 400 series errors, you have to be respectful
of how those are handled.
If someone gives you a hard bounce, retry once or twice,
and then stop trying, because if you are someone
who abuses people's inboxes, the email companies
spam folder you and it's very hard to get out.
If you get caught on a spam house link
or anything like that, it's very hard to get out.
It's really important with email
that you are a high class citizen,
that you do good work with email,
because you want to have deliverability for the long run.
That counts for push notifications and SMS too.
With SMS, you can go and buy SMS traffic
via Grey Roots with people where they're having
phones strung up, attached to a computer
and pumping out SMSs.
That works for a time, but it always gets shut down.
I've seen so many companies make these mistakes
where they think they're gonna grow
by using these kind of tactics.
If you can't get your email, your SMS,
or your push delivered, you will never
get any success from these.
Push, you spam your power users.
I know that's slightly different to what I said earlier,
but you actually spam your power users
and give them notifications they don't care about
and make it really hard for them to opt out,
so there's no settings where they can opt out
and they start blocking you.
You can never push them once they've opted out
of your push notifications.
And it's very hard actually to prompt them
to turn them on once they've turned them off.
So number one thing to think about
about email, SMS, and push notifications
is you have to get them delivered.
Beyond that, it's a question of open rate,
click through rate.
So what is the compelling subject line you can put there
so that people are gonna open your email
and how can you get them to click when they visit?
Everyone focuses towards doing marketing emails
that are just spam, in my opinion.
Newsletters are stupid.
Don't do newsletters because you'll send the same message
to everyone on your site, someone who signed up
to your site yesterday versus someone
who's been using your product for three years.
Do they need the same message?
No.
The most effective email you can do is notifications.
So what are you sending?
What should you be notifying people of?
And this is a great place where we're in the wrong mindset.
As a Facebook user, I don't want Facebook
to email me about every like I receive
because I receive a lot of likes
because I've got a bunch of Facebook friends.
But as a new Facebook user,
that first like you receive is a magic moment.
Turning on that notification across all of our channels
increased the click through rate
on our emails, SMS, and push notifications,
but we only turned it on for low-engaged users
who weren't coming back to the site
so it wouldn't be spamming them.
So it was a great experience.
So think about that.
What notifications should you be sending
is the first thing that you need to think about
on email, SMS, and push.
And then the second thing you need to be thinking about
is how can you create great triggered marketing campaigns?
So when someone created
their first cross-border trade transaction
was one of the best email campaigns
I was ever part of at eBay in terms of click through rates.
It was awesome because it was really timely,
really in context, the right thing to do for the user.
So I'd say make sure you have deliverability,
most important thing.
Focus on notifications and trigger-based email,
SMS, and push notifications beyond that.
So I think we're out of time.
There's one thing I wanted to finish with,
which is, and if you guys have any questions,
I guess you can reach me and if I get spammed,
I just won't reply.
We have great spam filters, no.
One of my favorite quotes is from General Patton,
and it's so cliched, it's crazy, but it's awesome.
A good plan violently executed today
is better than a perfect plan tomorrow.
And one of the things Chamath instilled in us,
and Javi still instills in us,
and Mark instills across the whole of Facebook
is this move fast and don't be afraid to break stuff ethos.
If you can run more experiments than the next guy,
if you can be hungry for growth,
if you fight and die for every extra user
and you stay up late at night to get those extra users
to run those experiments, to get the data
and do it over and over and over again,
you will grow faster.
Mark has said he thinks we won because we wanted it more,
and I really believe that.
We just worked really hard.
It's not like we're crazy smart
or we've all done these crazy things before.
We just worked really, really hard and we executed fast.
And I strongly encourage you to do that.
Growth is optional.
Thank you.