Padres Forced Into An Impossible Decision ...
Jul 20, 2026
AI Generated·May contain errors
Video Summary
AI GeneratedThis episode of Padres Digest discusses recent pitching updates for the San Diego Padres, focusing on the return of Randy Vasquez and the recovery progress of Joe Musgrove and Nick Pavetta. The host weighs the immediate benefits of these returns against long-term roster health and the financial implications of player contracts.
In the words of Professor Farnsworth, good news everybody, our saviors are coming back.
One of our saviors is back.
We got to talk about injury updates.
We got to talk about people being moved on and off the roster.
We've got to talk about hundreds of millions or 32 million dollars worth of mystery and
intrigue for the Padres about this deadline.
Lots to unpack on this episode of Padres Digest.
What's going on?
Christian Pedersen back with another episode of the show that is thinking back to the content
we did last year.
I was way too negative.
It can always get so much worse.
And so as we're going through that, even though the boys are winning right now,
I'm hearing myself from last year and I'm listening to myself this year.
I'm like, you don't need negative Nancy.
So I'm going to be as much positive Pete as I can get to as always.
Like, subscribe, share, comment, all those other things.
No ad reads for you today.
Just going to be talking about some pitching moves because, you know, that was happening.
Randy Vasquez is back after a brief stint on the aisle following getting his ankle hit
on a comebacker and against the Dodgers.
Ron Macaroni, as I have, I know that it's, I know what his actual last name is.
Marinaccio.
I called him Ron Macaroni once and y'all were like, oh, he's just mispronounced that name.
I call players like Bruce Jorgelson, Bryce Johnson.
To me, Ron Macaroni was very much a Padres Padre.
He's somebody who when you go back and do the looking back on, oh, this team,
you're like, I totally forgot about that guy.
Sorry, brother.
But that's just what that is.
Randy Vasquez.
I'm stoked to have back.
It's kind of interesting.
He is going to go to the bullpen.
Not going to go.
Kevin Acy writing about how there's not because of it being the corresponding
move of taking a reliever does not appear that King, Canning, Marquez,
Sears, or Bueller are going to be moved for Randy.
I love this.
I think that Randy Vasquez is part of the long-term vision for the San Diego Padres,
even if it is as the I think best case scenario.
Randy Vasquez is the four or the five next year around a retooled,
healthy, rebuilt Padres rotation.
Like, optimally, he would be the five.
But I could see a Walker Bueller and him as the veterans hanging around at the four or five.
So I think to leave Randy, who's obviously been struggling this year,
has not been like we see his Randy's best is so damn good.
Randy's bad is so damn bad.
But to leave him in the bullpen where he can just get some work and stay consistent to me
is thinking globally about how to put him in the next position with the best position for next year.
Him and Johnny Brito right now.
Just enjoy the bullpen.
Stay healthy.
Get better.
Get a feel building for the future there.
I don't hate that at all.
It's always when we go through all these moves.
Stoked to hear from you.
But that's right.
That's what I've got.
Then a discussion of Joe Musgrove and Nick Pavetta.
I, in order to be consistent and not be too big of a hypocrite,
have to say I have said that I have long said that we are never going to see Joe Musgrove again.
I don't mean that in a bad way.
But here we go.
We're back to the scenario where we're seeing guys get closer and closer.
They both threw an up-down at the Padres Complex in Peoria, Arizona yesterday.
I don't know why he had to put that in big quotes there.
But 15 to 20 pitches.
15 to 20 pitches.
Simulate a couple innings.
Throwing to guys.
I...
You don't need to see the graphics about where we are in the standings.
Because it's not...
I don't...
I'm not going to make the case for,
oh my gosh, if these guys get back,
we are freaking locked in.
Yes, our pitching is atrocious and needs help.
And hypothetically,
I guess I can be talked into if Nick Pavetta and Joe Musgrove
are going to be back for the last little stretch of the season
and have the chance to help us.
If we could...
If we have that, we could go with this absolute terror.
I still don't think an absolute terror is going to really help us.
We're going to go through the grinder in the next 10 days
against the Marlins and Braves,
and I think we're probably looking at a realistically,
like, we'll go 500 through that at best
and stay plenty back of both of these.
So I would ask the same I said with Vasquez.
What's the long-term look?
And the long-term look would, I guess, hypothetically,
because these guys are both on contract,
have them coming back for next season.
In the best possible shape.
And so I would have to ask,
is working them all the way up
to throw five starts at the end of a season
where we end up 20 games out of the division
and seven games out of the wildcard
worth the risk?
Because those are completely meaningless games.
And I guess a small part of me would be like,
oh, you know,
the quote here was that they came out healthy and rock and rolling,
so they're taking the next steps according to stamina.
Very important steps.
Getting closer to facing live hitters.
That could happen next week,
which would continue to make it at least possible
that they are back in August.
So bring them back for, you know,
call it all of August and September.
If that helps the Padres be in a position
where we can, you know,
it's July 19th of recordings.
If the Padres in two weeks are five games or less
back in the wildcard,
I guess I can be talked into
bringing both of them back.
Ease is one of the trade requirements for A.J. Preller.
And then so he would only really need to go out
and get a bat or two
and maybe some bullpen help.
And those are much more attainable with the assets that we have,
et cetera, et cetera, et cetera.
Okay, sure.
We've already seen though with Musgrove
a whole year of recovery
and then he got a whole offseason into a regular,
or into a spring training
and then it got to real game speed
little pieces and fired.
Given that there is a potential
that this could be an unhealthy elbow,
but if we give him another eight months
to get really healthy
and just keep throwing simulated bullpens
and keep taking little baby steps,
is he the wily veteran?
Is he what Udarvish was supposed to be two years ago?
Next year, maybe.
I think there's a decent chance of that.
I just, to me, the risk reward is
it's not that great on running these guys out there
if we're really on the borderline of it.
I mentioned the millions of dollars worth of interest.
This point here, I think, is also just interesting for Pavetta
that August 22nd,
which would be 130 days from him going on the IL,
is there is a trigger in his clause
that if he has not played enough,
pitched enough, started enough, whatever it is,
by that date,
Padres have the option to void his contract.
When I brought this up,
you guys have been oddly defensive of Nick's personal character
and that he wouldn't rush it back for a paycheck.
First off, 32 million dollars worth of money,
I think anybody would rush it back for
and I think you're freaking lying to yourselves if you say otherwise.
But also, I've never really said that there's like...
I don't know personals on these.
I just know business-wise,
it would not entirely surprise me
if the Padres are not interested in being directly on the hook
for 32 million dollars
for a guy that just missed a whole season
or almost the entirety of a season.
Pavetta's good.
Not great.
I don't think that one injury necessarily
can lead to another, to another, to another,
but it's also something where,
again, if we rush this guy back and we get him back,
but then it's like,
oh, but his elbow's still a little permanently tweaked,
do we want to pay 32 million dollars over the next two years
for another guy like to be just part of this
ever-revolving door of old arms
that we have stuck at the back end of our rotation
weighing us down?
I don't want to be personal and like,
oh, I'm anti-Nick Pavetta,
but I also, if I'm just a Yahoo blabbing on the internet about this,
I don't know if he's our best option.
And we talked about needing to get out from some contracts.
If next year we could be done with Darvish, done with Pavetta,
I don't know what the real deal is with Musgrove's contract,
but I'm assuming we're gonna have to keep paying him
for the rest of it, at least from right now.
But to have some of that moved on from,
and then some internal options of Brito or Vasquez,
maybe a Bueller,
and then to have new ownership and a little bit of money,
Bob's your uncle, I think, on the freedom there
that we can replace Nick Pavetta with.
I just ask out loud,
I get that it feels like good news,
but is it really the best news
that those guys are on their way back?
Curious to know your thoughts.
Drop a comment, like, subscribe, share, all those other things.
Until next time, we'll talk to you soon.

