Character Education and Social Emotional Learning
Tian-De's Education Research
2 followers
2 Video Views·Jul 20, 2026
Pt. 1 - Influences in Western philosophy and social sciences
AI Generated·May contain errors
So the topic of character education and social-emotional learning is quite vast, and
this brief presentation is going to focus on the influences and the history and the various
philosophers and researchers and thinkers that contributed to this field over the past several
millennia. Currently in the world, most nations have some consideration of this topic, but
in various countries like Japan, Korea, Canada, China, concepts of moral education or character
education are directly baked into the national curriculum. Now, one thing that many outside
observers note about Japan is that, you know, from a very young age, all the kids are learning
different skills, like how to keep things clean, how to work together, problem-solving,
things like this, and it's a unique aspect of the culture that everyone is participating in
and recognizes as just an aspect of their education. More recently in the United States,
many different states and various districts are incorporating some form of social-emotional
learning in their standards, so that within the curriculum, there's this expectation that
social skills or virtues will be included in the curriculum. There are several debates
and differences that people have in this field, and the more one digs into this topic,
the more it's apparent that these are not new debates. Some of them are over 2,000 years old,
and ultimately, a common disagreement that comes about is whether, you know, virtue is
something that is general, it's just part of character, and it can be cultivated, or if it's
skill-based. And this is not even a disagreement that is unique to Western culture. I'm not getting
into this in this specific presentation, but even digging into Chinese cultivation methods,
there are differences, say, within the Confucian tradition about virtue being innate versus
something that has to be learned and imposed. One common agreement, however, is that both
social-emotional learning and character education are facets of a well-rounded education for all
children. So, in the current conception of SEL and character education, there are some clear
distinctions between the two. So, for instance, with SEL, there's a big focus on skills,
developing pro-social behavior and habits. Think about things like goal-setting or
conflict management. Maurice Ellis, one of the key thinkers in both of these fields, actually,
talks a lot about anxiety and teaching kids how to manage their emotions. Those are the kinds
of practices in SEL, whereas character education, when I first started looking into this, it reminded
me very much of what I remembered from Sunday school about knowing stories of virtue, recognizing
exemplars of virtue, and considering how to act accordingly. Now, both of these could exist within
the same framework. They are not mutually exclusive. You don't necessarily need one
without the other. But a key difference that I see, at least in the common discourse of these
things, is that it at least appears, from what I've observed, that the SEL camp tends to root
its justifications more in modern science and educational research, whereas on the character
education side, there is often more of a reverence about the deep lineage that they're building on.
Now, that doesn't mean that SEL does not have origins in, say, Aristotle. He definitely talked
about specific habits for building positive skills, and Confucius and John Locke talked
about similar things, but they also recognize the existence of character. Whereas both are looking at
how to become an effective, upright member of society, SEL is more concerned with how one can
manage their own emotions and relationships, whereas character education is about understanding
what the right thing is to do, and then following through with that. In all three of these different
conceptual frameworks, there are a range of different programs that educators can draw upon.
CASEL, a consortium that promotes SEL, has their five key skills framework for SEL. There are a
variety of character education programs. One, Knowledge is Power, is one that is publicly
available, and there are others that mix these two, such as the Mosaic program that is found in
New Jersey public schools that works on both social skills and character education. In the
modern whole child teaching movement, CASEL is probably one of the better known organizations.
Their five competencies are widely found in many different school systems and state standards.
They've contributed a great deal of research into this, and probably one of the more better
known ones, but character.org, also known as the Character Education Partnership, has their own
framework for promoting character education and their 11 principles. It's quite advanced. It's
quite robust and maybe more than we can get into in this presentation, but one thing that's
very interesting is that with character.org, they're also acknowledging that their principles
are not to the exclusion of SEL, and we'll even talk about how to incorporate both.
About two decades ago, Lacona and Davidson conducted a study called Smart and Good Schools,
where they were looking at schools that incorporated character at all levels. Their
starting point was the recognition that in society, there's a recognition that character
is needed in all professions. They helped promote this idea that both excellence and ethics are
needed for a fulfilling life. One of their main formats that they provide for educators is that
these four keys, having an ethical learning community, meaning you have a community in the
school dedicated to ethical learning, some form of reflection or self-study where individuals are
reflecting on their own character and actions, other study using exemplars. They have peers
and exemplars and stories to model after, and we'll get into the justifications for that once we get
some of the influences in this field. Then public performance, acting out these things.
One of the thinkers that we'll come back to several times in this performance, Maurice Ellis,
his SECD lab combines both of these and provides a framework for these. The Mosaic program mentioned
before was one offshoot of that, and it is pretty common in neighboring New Jersey.
I'm going to start with looking at some of the influences in the character education movement.
Basically, digging into any of this, there's always this sense that just everything is built
on top of the Greeks. The Greeks are well-renowned for having this notion that education is about
educating the whole person. I've been to Plato's academy, the location there, and one thing that
was kind of shocking is that it's not just a place for talking about philosophy. It was a place where
there was wrestling and all these other arts and things that are going on that a true philosopher,
a lover of wisdom, is a well-rounded person. Both Socrates and Plato built on this with their
concept of the good and forms. They had this notion that there are universal forms throughout
the universe and that they are imbued with their own goodness and beauty. Their idea of virtue was
that one would come to recognize and understand this beauty and embrace it and express it through
their actions. This would in turn create a just society. There's that very famous painting of
Plato and Aristotle at the academy where Plato is pointing to the heavens and Aristotle is pointing
down to the earth. Aristotle, who was Plato's student, really was seen as a break from this
Platonic tradition of looking for these abstract and perfect forms in nature and reality to find
goodness. He was much more concerned with the practical here and now and how people could
develop virtue. A big aspect of that was his concept of habituation, where one is recognizing
the right thing to do, deciding to follow it, aligning that within their community, and then
habituating it, making it part of their character. It's interesting thinking about that as
almost some sort of early SEL origin. Even though he talked a lot about virtue and character,
there is this very much skills-oriented feeling that comes out reading about Aristotle.
In the Western tradition, it's impossible to conceptualize character education
without acknowledging the contribution that Christianity made over the years.
The ancient world was not necessarily a friendly place. One thing that Christianity gave the
world was this belief in the sanctity of human life, that human life is sacred,
it's given by the Creator, and that it is an inherent good. In the past, there were philosophers
that did believe this, but it wasn't institutionalized as a common dogma throughout
society. Even if in the Christian world, not everyone followed that, it was at least
accepted and acknowledged. Additionally, what Christianity did was it created
concrete concepts of right and wrong that were, again, recognized throughout society.
No longer are we having philosophers necessarily debate these, that the commoners are able to learn
these concepts. Moral education is not reserved for someone who's just going to go learn at the
academy because they have those luxuries. Additionally, one thing that I find very
interesting about the Christian tradition is this concept of forgiveness. The divine has
forgiveness for human beings and their faults, but with the acknowledgement that because of that
forgiveness, they can change and become good. It's almost as if this concept of character
cultivation is built into this cognitive framework that the whole society is embracing.
Because of this, Christianity provided a common language that everyone shared around concepts
of virtue and morality. And over time, even before the Renaissance, medieval scholars
were looking back to Aristotle's works and considering that even though he was not a
pagan, how his concepts of virtue could be modified to suit this new Christian framework
that Europe was working under. Now, later on, as we're getting closer to the European Enlightenment,
there was this rationalist and empiricist thought process that emerged that was a radical break from
the medieval Christian world. Descartes, who was critical of Aristotle in some ways,
rejected this concept that tradition alone was a source of wisdom and moral truth.
This was a very important concept for the future of moral development. It no longer
was a moral philosophy necessarily grounded on logical assumptions. It had to be something
that was carried within. This influenced both the rationalists and the constructionists.
John Locke, who's often considered the father of British empiricism,
recognized that there are experiences and relations in people's lives that shape their morality.
This came from his concept of tabula rasa, or the blank slate, that considers that
human beings come into the world knowing nothing and that it's our experiences that shape who we
are. This served as a justification for having moral education throughout society.
Hume, a successor of Locke, just did away with this notion that internal concepts correspond
to external reality, meaning that what's going on inside of us is going to influence how we
express ourselves in the social world. It's very easy to see how this concept provides a justification
for why moral education is needed, and furthermore, what form that might need to take.
In any sort of research course that a master's student or doctoral student goes into,
there's this exposure to positivism and constructionism. Locke and Hume would be
part of that positivist tradition, that empiricist tradition. Now, on the other side is the
structure of philosophy, and recognize that any philosophical structure that is built with
poor material is false, and it leads to poor behavior. Kant's whole concept of moral living
was based on this concept of personal autonomy, that people are developing their own concepts of
morality under a developmental track, and that these internal concepts would influence how they
express themselves in the world. One example of this is he talked about having these internal
moral maxims, that every individual is, knowingly or unknowingly, creating moral laws about the
world around them. He goes into how a moral individual should act with that assumption
understood. With this in mind, an individual should not do anything that they would not want
others to do in the moral world around them, and uses this concept of a kingdom of ends, meaning
all people in the world are a good, similar to Plato, they are an essential good of the universe,
and they are the ends of themselves, as opposed to a means, meaning people are a way for me to get
what I want. In Kant's view, people are like legislators who are enacting the moral laws
and living them out that they've developed in the world, and choosing to treat others
in ways that they would want others to treat them, almost like the golden rule.
Piaget built on Kant's idea of moral autonomy or personal autonomy, and it came to recognize
moral development within children, and that this went within very specific developmental stages.
And Piaget's concept of developmental stages is at the core of the learner-centered education
movement. Dewey or Montessori are also part of this movement, and in the whole framework of
whole child education, you don't really have that in the modern sense without Piaget.
Certainly there are several contemporary influences in character education, but without
understanding those pre-modern and ancient influences, none of the modern stuff actually
makes sense. Some thinkers have expanded upon, say, Aristotle's notion of telos,
the habituation, and packaged it for a modern audience. Kohlberg is famous for articulating
very clearly Piaget's concept of moral development stages, and established different realms in which
these moral education can take place, such as having role models or moral exemplars,
peers to discuss morality with, and just school communities. Character.org we touched on already,
as well as Lacona and Davidson. One unique thing about Lacona and Davidson is they expanded this
concept of virtue, especially as it relates to education, into moral virtues and performance
virtues, meaning that there are these moral virtues that are traditionally understood,
but it's also important to consider the virtues of performance, like, am I doing my best work?
There are specific character education programs. Peterson and Zalegman, they provide a framework
including six core virtues that they found to be universal across cultures and religions.
I mentioned the Knowledge is Power program that provides this concept of a character report card,
where educators can track students' progress over time. My first exposure to character education
in a systematic sense was looking at material put out by Hillsdale College in their classical
education movement, where they go deep into looking at these ancient and pre-modern sources
in their classical education materials with a specific eye for virtue within that. We also
touched on the Mosaic Program already, which is common in New Jersey and well known for combining
SEL and character education. A quick example, these are some of the virtues that are prominent
in the Hillsdale classical education. In all the pictures I've seen of those schools,
these virtues are hung up around the school. They're prominent everywhere. You'll see posters,
they're talked about in class, they're used in conversations between principals and students
when something's going on, whether they're praising a student or talking about things
they could do better. It's very deeply worked into the cultural framework of the school.
Social-emotional learning owes a lot to contemporary social science and psychology.
Social-emotional learning probably wouldn't even have this name without Thorndike's concept of
social intelligence. This conceptualization of skills learning probably would not have the
force it has without B.F. Skinner and his behaviorist concept. Think of your first
psychology class you ever took where you have Pavlov's dog where he's watering. That's a
behavioralist tradition. Skinner did a lot to bring this concept of behavioralism into the
human social sciences. Gardner, who started out in the realm of psychology, got very involved in
education with his concept of multiple intelligences. He brings up eight of them. There
are two that are relevant to SEL, which is intrapersonal or emotional intelligence and
interpersonal social intelligence. Within Gardner's multiple intelligences framework,
he recognizes that all of these intelligences can be developed over time. They're not something
that someone's just born with and it's static. It's something that's ever-evolving and can be
trained. Around the same time, Mayer and Salovey did a lot to establish
standards and methods for measuring emotional intelligence in the field of psychology.
Bandura, a psychologist who's had a disproportionate effect on education,
has his social learning theory, which focuses a lot on the importance of modeling and observation
and mastery experiences. Thinking about social emotional learning, it's very hard to
learn these skills if there are no models in place. This was also a
thinker that has had a large impact on this field. Similarly, cognitive behavioral therapy,
a form of psychological therapy where you're teaching people social skills to
solve problems and deal with difficult things, that's essentially what SEL is built upon.
John Dewey is considered one of the key influencers in education over the past 100
years. In his conception of learner-centered teaching and learning, he recognized that it's
important for children to learn empathy and interpersonal skills and not just academics,
that these are part of their ultimate education. All of this came together when Goldman
identified and formulated SEL skills clusters, which are essentially the foundation for the five
areas of social emotional learning put out by CASEL. These areas, which are widely adopted in
many state and local standards, include self-management, self-awareness, social awareness,
relationship skills, and responsible decision-making. It's understood that these need
to be present not only in the classroom and throughout the school, but also in families
and throughout the community where the school is.
Now, this was certainly a very brief introduction to this topic. Probably a whole slideshow could
be provided on any one of these points, but the key point that I'm trying to bring across here is
that debates and developments in moral education are not limited to modern society. SEL is not
something new, even if the term is new. Character education has been practiced for as long as
education has existed. One disappointing thing I had when putting this together was that there
was so much I came across from other cultures, such as Japanese education, traditional Chinese
education. A lot of the SEL research that's currently being done is out of Indonesia.
There are non-Western religions and thought traditions that are contributing to this field
that are often not recognized in American educational discourse, and there are other
forms of society, other than liberal democracies, that have their own takes on these things.
The key takeaway in all of these areas, though, is that moral education and social-emotional
competencies are important for helping young people live fulfilling lives,
and it enables them to contribute to their societies.
