Toyota Tacoma vs. Chevy Colorado vs. Ford Ranger: What We Learned After a Year of Ownership

Van & Truck Lab
86 followers
AI Generated·May contain errors
We've owned all three of these trucks for a year now,
and we've lived with them every single day,
just like you would.
So that means we've done it all.
Work, play, boring everyday commutes,
long road trips, school pickups,
and tons of fun off-road.
And this has all totaled more than 50,000 miles combined.
So which one's the best?
I'm gonna tell you the good, the bad,
and the broken for all three of these.
And at the end, we'll tell you
which one you should actually buy with your own money.
Let's start with the Colorado,
because it's the one that we've had the longest.
Now, if you want a full breakdown on this truck,
you can check out this very handsome gentleman's video
right here.
Otherwise, here's a quick recap.
It's a Z71, which is the second most expensive trim level.
And then we added on the optional towing package
and some tech goodies.
So when a vehicle enters our one-year road test program,
our team of about 40 people commute, road trip,
and take notes on it.
That way, it's not just my opinion you're hearing.
These trucks have been in a whole bunch
of different scenarios with different perspectives,
giving you the best possible informed opinion.
So if you're looking for something new or used,
be sure to check out what we're testing now
and what we've tested in the past.
And with that, here's what we like.
First off, the upgraded powertrain has been a fan favorite.
None of our midsize trucks have a V6,
and of the three, only the four offers one.
But our Chevy has the high output version
of that 2.7 liter turbo four.
I took a big 2000 mile trip up north,
lots of highway time,
and that engine was happy to hum along in the background.
No complaints.
Another big win for the Colorado is its utility.
We have been loading and unloading this bed constantly.
Now, when I first did the video on this truck,
I pointed out one of my favorite features,
the short king sidestep.
My words, not Chevy's.
Now, I assume that this would be a very popular feature,
especially for people on our staff under six feet tall.
Turns out, I was right.
Yep, I did.
Yes, I used the step in the truck.
It was great.
I'm just under six feet and I used them.
Yep, me too.
The tech in the Colorado is really well done.
Chevy relies heavily on Google,
which makes life great for the driver.
Google Maps is fantastic.
The Google Assistant gives the best voice commands
in the game right now.
And of course, you can download third-party apps
like Spotify.
And Chevy keeps Apple CarPlay and Android Auto,
which is crucial.
I love that CarPlay still exists.
Yeah, you still have all the advantages
of the Google operating system.
This is becoming more and more of a rare case
as GM begins to transition away
from smartphone integration entirely,
which I think is a terrible, terrible decision.
So what don't we like?
Well, the interior is spacious and feels nice,
right up until the moment you step
into the other two trucks.
There's just so much plastic in here
and the materials could be better.
One time I drove this thing
and whatever's going on here on the center console,
borderline gave me a rash on my elbows.
I know, Clint, oh, you're so soft,
but you put sandpaper on your center console
and tell me how tough you are.
Three people left the exact same comment.
We also think the Chevy seats
are the least comfortable of the three,
especially after a long journey.
Another knock we have against the Colorado
is its ride quality.
Of the three trucks we own,
it's the worst over bumps,
even though it has tall, cushy tires.
This is by no means a bad truck.
And if you need any evidence of that,
every time we post a video on the Colorado,
there are tons of people who leave a comment
saying that they bought one and that they love it.
And I believe those people.
But when it comes down to the smaller details,
we think that the Chevy just lacks a little bit
behind the Ford and the Toyota.
There's just room for improvement.
Next up is the Tacoma.
This one's a 2024 TRD Off-Road,
which if you ask me is the sweet spot in the lineup.
Has the right equipment and the right price
without things getting too crazy.
Now, if you want an in-depth overview
with all the features on this thing,
check out this video right here,
my good friend, Emi Hall.
So let's start off with some good news.
Not all of them come in this color.
You have the freedom to choose something
that actually looks good.
Now, in fairness, some people on our staff
do like the color on this Tacoma,
but yeah, everybody has their opinion.
We have a lot of good things to say about this truck.
Now the old Tacoma, the interior wasn't all that nice
and it wasn't all that comfortable either,
but they fixed it, mostly.
I never really fit well in past Tacomas.
They were really all wrong for my body.
That's no longer the case with the new truck.
Toyota increased the headroom
and offers more adjustment for the seat and steering wheel.
I can finally drive a Tacoma without feeling uncomfortable
and awkward and splay-legged.
All the knobs and switch gear in the Tacoma
feel really chunky and satisfying to use.
It goes for the whole truck.
Out of all three, it sort of feels the truckiest.
I just, I like that in a truck.
The first time I drove this Tacoma,
I mistakenly thought that it was a fully loaded TRD Pro.
I hopped in, I saw the giant screen,
I fired up my heated steering wheel
and everything just felt like luxury.
Now, 55 grand is a lot of money for a mid-sized truck.
I totally understand that,
but I don't feel like I'm missing out on anything in here.
This interior is nice
and it's a lot less plasticky than the Chevy.
The tech here isn't quite as slam dunk
as the Colorado's Google-based setup,
but you still have everything you want,
including wireless, Apple CarPlay and Android Auto.
Now, when it comes to the display,
it is absolutely ginormous.
It is by far the biggest of the three trucks.
It makes me feel like an iPad kid sitting at a Chili's.
Yes!
One of the reasons the TRD Off-Road is so great
is because it can do exactly that.
We wheeled all three of these trucks in a different video
and the Toyota won the majority of the test.
Now, just a reminder,
the TRD Off-Road is 20 grand less than a TRD Pro.
This truck is extremely capable.
Speaking of, owning this Tacoma
and driving plenty of others over the year
has taught us one thing that's really important.
You don't need the optional hybrid powertrain.
We like the standard four-cylinder just fine.
The Tacoma's turbocharged four-cylinders
leagues better than the V6 it replaced.
Good riddance to that six-speed automatic too.
The eight-speed is much better
and this whole powertrain is great in general.
It's smoother, shifts better
and just really improves drivability for this truck.
But this is far from a perfect pickup.
We've fallen short of the EPA's fuel economy estimate
over the course of the truck's life.
It's actually been a trend among these three,
but disappointing nonetheless.
And then there's a topic of passenger space.
The Tacoma doesn't have any.
This backseat is straight up punishment
for anybody on a short drive, let alone a long journey.
This is definitely a category
where the Taco lags behind the other two trucks.
But still, a lot of people on our staff love this truck,
myself included.
It's a well-rounded workhorse with very few major flaws.
And now the Ranger.
So the F-150 is our highest rated big truck.
So naturally we wanted to spend some time
with its little sibling to see if it's any good.
And you know what?
There's a lot to like here.
Comfort stands out big time.
The other two can be noisy, almost agricultural,
but not the Ranger.
So I seem to like the last generation Ranger
more than most of my colleagues,
but there's no doubt the current truck
is a big improvement in just about every way.
It's quieter, it's more comfortable.
It just feels a little more grown up and refined,
really distilling what makes the F-150 a winning truck
into a smaller, significantly easier to park package.
The blue truck rides better than its garage mates too.
And as far as driver assist go,
it has a similar feature set to the Colorado and the Tacoma,
but everything is executed just a little bit better here.
And before we get off driving,
we had the chance to get behind the wheel
of the turbo six version of the Ranger earlier this year.
And you know what?
It's only a little bit quicker
than the turbo four version and less efficient.
Save yourself the 2,200 bucks.
If there's a problem with the Ranger, it's fuel economy.
The Ranger missed its EPA estimated mileage
by a little more than the Tacoma did.
In spite of that, it still manages
to have the best fuel economy in the group by just a hair.
Now the Ranger here has the best cabin materials
of the three trucks we have today.
Now we've been talking a lot
about scratchy, hard black plastic,
and there is refreshingly almost nothing going on in here.
This is a nice feeling truck.
And as an added bonus,
you also have marginally more towing and payload capacity.
When it comes to tech, I like what we have going on here.
You also get wireless Apple CarPlay
and wireless Android Auto kind of
in this upright tombstone shape going on.
Almost forgot, this has the best sound system
of the three by far.
But as we know, making trucks is hard
and there are definitely some areas
where Ford can do better.
From a driving perspective,
the Ranger can feel a bit floaty and disconnected
and the transmission takes a little bit of time
to warm up before it smooths itself out.
Something we've learned over time,
if the engine start stop system is on,
you don't want to use the brake hold feature
because everything feels a little bit jerky.
Some people on our team didn't love these seats
and for a few others,
these headrests were a pain in the neck, literally.
But by far, the biggest problem we've had
with this Ranger so far
is something we've never experienced before.
The doors didn't want to close.
Not long after we bought the Ranger,
I realized I kept having to slam the doors
just so they would close all the way.
Why do I have to slam the doors
on a brand new pickup truck?
In a perfect world,
you would not have an opinion on your car's doors.
The Ford Ranger, on the other hand,
happens to exist in this world.
The rear doors would not close consistently
unless you really, really slammed them,
which since, you know, it's not my car,
it's Edmund's car,
something I was all that comfortable with.
So basically anytime you close the back door,
you'd have to kind of guide it all the way in
to into the latch,
which was pretty, pretty irritating.
Now, of course,
nobody wants to buy a truck that's gonna fall apart
or lose a whole bunch of value after a whole year.
Let's discuss.
At least when it comes to maintenance and reliability,
these trucks have been bulletproof,
which is exactly what you want to hear.
Their stories have been straightforward,
starting with the Chevy.
I took the Colorado in Ford's first service
and aside from routine maintenance,
they also fixed a recall
for the fuel injector flow rate control.
The whole process was super smooth
and only took a few hours.
Now, counter to what you might think,
the Tacoma is the only truck of the three
that has given us any real trouble at all.
And it's not the engine or the suspension,
the transmission, anything big like that.
No, it's something much more specific, the seatbelt.
So the day I picked up the Tacoma from work,
I planned to take my wife out to dinner.
We had picked a spot, gotten dressed up, the whole thing.
However, when she went to sit in the passenger seat,
the seatbelt wouldn't move.
It was completely locked up.
We took it into the dealer to find
that there was a problem with the mechanism,
but that the part wouldn't be in for a few days.
During that time, I tested the seatbelt again
and it mysteriously started working.
However, we still wanted to get it fixed properly,
so we took it back to the dealer
where they're able to do so under warranty
at no cost to us.
Things were also business as usual for the Ranger
and its one and only service.
We took the Ranger in for its first service
with around 9,800 miles on the clock.
So this was its 10,000 mile service.
It was pretty simple.
We made an appointment online, got to the dealership,
and it was a pretty basic service too.
An oil change, a filter change,
tire rotation and balancing, easy stuff.
We got there at 7.30 and we're out of there by nine
and it only cost us 200 bucks, so super easy.
As we like to do with all the cars we own,
we got all three trucks appraised after a year
to see if they held their values.
When we did the math, we were in for a surprise.
The Tacoma actually lost more value than the other trucks,
depreciating by 33% in the year that we had it.
And even though it had the most mileage,
the Colorado dropped by about 29%
and the Ranger did best, losing about 27%.
None of the trio has broken our hearts
when it comes to maintenance or repairs,
so we're left with cost to run.
Using the nationwide average of $3.08 per gallon,
here's what it would cost to drive
all three trucks 15,000 miles.
As you can see, it's super close
and this probably shouldn't sway your purchase decision
one way or another.
So after all of that, which one would we buy again?
For me, Colorado.
I think I'm gonna have to go Colorado.
Tacoma, every day.
Tacoma, but I wouldn't have said that
before we got our truck.
I think my money is gonna go towards the Ranger.
It's the Ranger for me, dog.
So let's break that tie.
In our official opinion,
we have to give this one to the Ranger.
It's our Edmunds top rated truck for 2025.
And that's because it's the most well-rounded of the three
and the one that's best to live with every day.
But I'm curious, which trucks do you wanna see us buy next
and review just like these ones?
Let us know in the comments
and as always, thanks for watching.
